SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 2
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Ballistics and Screams Threaten Oscar Pistorius Defense
Oscar Pistorius and his lawyers have several crucial elements of the prosecution's case to overcome
when they begin their defense Friday, particularly the ballistics testimony on the sequence of shots
and neighbors' testimony on hearing a woman scream.
Pistorius will be the star witness -- and possibly the first witness -- in his defense. His testimony
could last days and Pistorius will be a target of prosecutor Gerrie Nel who will try to catch the Blade
Runner in a contradiction or an flash of anger.
Pistorius has been emotional while watching the testimony, sticking his fingers in his ears during
descriptions of how he shot his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp through a locked bathroom door before
dawn on Valentine's Day 2013, and covering his ears with his hands as her injuries were detailed.
Twice he vomited in court when confronted with photos of his slain lover.
Pistorius, who claims he mistook Steenkamp for an intruder, could be sentenced to at least 25 years
in prison if convicted.
The case could come down to Pistorius' testimony, legal expert Emma Sadleir told "Good Morning
America."
"We are only interested in whether in his own mind he thought he was acting unlawfully in that
moment," Saddleir said. "He is the only person who can tell us this."
Pistorius' fate will be decided by a judge acting alone, not a jury.
In convincing the judge that he is innocent, Pistorius will have to also overcome several key points
made by the prosecution.
Attorney Anton Smith cited four elements of the prosecution's case that stand out: the ballistics,
Pistorius' knowledge of South African gun laws, the pathologist's report and five neighbors who all
testified about hearing a woman screaming before the gunshots.
Scenes From the Oscar Pistorius Murder Trial
"According to me, the most important witness for the state was ballistic expert Captain Chris
Mangena who testified about the succession of shots and where those shots hit," Smith told ABC
News. "What is important about this, is that the 'double-tap' theory of the defense was shot down."
Pistorius' legal team have argued that
when he fired four bullets through the
bathroom door, what people heard was
a "double tap," two rounds fired in
quick succession.
Using lasers to track the trajectory of
the bullets, Mangena told the court that
the first shot hit Steenkamp in the hip,
knocking her onto a magazine rack.
One bullet missed Steenkamp, while
one struck her in the right arm above
the elbow and the other to the right
side of her head.
Mangena's testimony appeared to question Pistorius' double tap claim that because "both shots
would have hit her around the waist area, where the first shot was," Smith said.
Smith said Mangena's evidence was supported by Gert Saayman, the pathologist who performed the
autopsy on Steenkamp's body. Both experts were of the opinion that the first wound Steenkamp
sustained was in the hip, followed by the two other wounds.
The sequence of the shots dovetails with testimony from neighbors who insisted they heard a woman
screaming before hearing thuds sounding like gunshots.
"If we Audiologist Pretoria can assume he shot the first shot, there was a pause and scream, he
should have realized that it was Reeva, or considered that it may have been Reeva," Smith said.
Smith said the evidence from Sean Rens, manager of the International Firearm Training Academy, is
also extremely important to the state's case. Rens told the court that Pistorius had ordered several
firearms from him and took a competency test in order to be declared fit to possess those guns.
http://abcnews.go.com/International/ballistics-screams-threaten-oscar-pistorius-defense/story?id=23
066970

Más contenido relacionado

Más de 8hearingpta

"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.
"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile."Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.
"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.8hearingpta
 
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court | Reuters
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court
| ReutersI'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court
| Reuters
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court | Reuters8hearingpta
 
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial 8hearingpta
 
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star SpottingCharlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting8hearingpta
 
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones 8hearingpta
 
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or dieIT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die8hearingpta
 
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.8hearingpta
 
CNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - TranscriptsCNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - Transcripts8hearingpta
 
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case 8hearingpta
 
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?8hearingpta
 
CNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - TranscriptsCNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - Transcripts8hearingpta
 
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed 8hearingpta
 
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...8hearingpta
 
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play onPIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on8hearingpta
 
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds 8hearingpta
 
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...8hearingpta
 
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning 8hearingpta
 
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist 8hearingpta
 

Más de 8hearingpta (20)

"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.
"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile."Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.
"Some alien native land": Arthur Nortje, literary history and the body in exile.
 
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court | Reuters
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court
| ReutersI'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court
| Reuters
I'm scared to sleep, tearful Pistorius tells court | Reuters
 
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
Mont. Man Released Pending New Homicide Trial
 
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star SpottingCharlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting
Charlize Theron in Fight Against Aids Picture | This Week's Star Spotting
 
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
SA Police Took Pictures Of Pistorius On Cellphones
 
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or dieIT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die
IT party is over. Now's the time to reinvent or die
 
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.
Customer perceptions of south African cellular network operators.
 
CNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - TranscriptsCNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - Transcripts
 
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
Pistorius At Court docket For Bail Listening to In Homicide Case
 
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?
Do these Bible verses really say that God can heal the sick?
 
CNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - TranscriptsCNN.com - Transcripts
CNN.com - Transcripts
 
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
Xstrata, Glencore Listening to In S.Africa Postponed
 
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...
Die vroee kommunikasieontwikkeling van'n groep babas met pediatriese MIV/VIGS...
 
October 2010
October 2010
October 2010
October 2010
 
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play onPIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on
PIAA PLAYOFF PREVIEWS: KC boys and girls, Farrell and WM boys play on
 
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
Jobs For 18 Yr Olds
 
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...
300 Blackout vs. 7.62x39mm: how does this this American cartridge stack up ag...
 
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
The Coronary heart Never Stops Yearning
 
Audiology
Audiology
Audiology
Audiology
 
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
My Journey As A Speech Therapist
 

Ballistics and Screams Threaten Oscar Pistorius Defense

  • 1. Ballistics and Screams Threaten Oscar Pistorius Defense Oscar Pistorius and his lawyers have several crucial elements of the prosecution's case to overcome when they begin their defense Friday, particularly the ballistics testimony on the sequence of shots and neighbors' testimony on hearing a woman scream. Pistorius will be the star witness -- and possibly the first witness -- in his defense. His testimony could last days and Pistorius will be a target of prosecutor Gerrie Nel who will try to catch the Blade Runner in a contradiction or an flash of anger. Pistorius has been emotional while watching the testimony, sticking his fingers in his ears during descriptions of how he shot his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp through a locked bathroom door before dawn on Valentine's Day 2013, and covering his ears with his hands as her injuries were detailed. Twice he vomited in court when confronted with photos of his slain lover. Pistorius, who claims he mistook Steenkamp for an intruder, could be sentenced to at least 25 years in prison if convicted. The case could come down to Pistorius' testimony, legal expert Emma Sadleir told "Good Morning America." "We are only interested in whether in his own mind he thought he was acting unlawfully in that moment," Saddleir said. "He is the only person who can tell us this." Pistorius' fate will be decided by a judge acting alone, not a jury. In convincing the judge that he is innocent, Pistorius will have to also overcome several key points made by the prosecution. Attorney Anton Smith cited four elements of the prosecution's case that stand out: the ballistics, Pistorius' knowledge of South African gun laws, the pathologist's report and five neighbors who all testified about hearing a woman screaming before the gunshots. Scenes From the Oscar Pistorius Murder Trial
  • 2. "According to me, the most important witness for the state was ballistic expert Captain Chris Mangena who testified about the succession of shots and where those shots hit," Smith told ABC News. "What is important about this, is that the 'double-tap' theory of the defense was shot down." Pistorius' legal team have argued that when he fired four bullets through the bathroom door, what people heard was a "double tap," two rounds fired in quick succession. Using lasers to track the trajectory of the bullets, Mangena told the court that the first shot hit Steenkamp in the hip, knocking her onto a magazine rack. One bullet missed Steenkamp, while one struck her in the right arm above the elbow and the other to the right side of her head. Mangena's testimony appeared to question Pistorius' double tap claim that because "both shots would have hit her around the waist area, where the first shot was," Smith said. Smith said Mangena's evidence was supported by Gert Saayman, the pathologist who performed the autopsy on Steenkamp's body. Both experts were of the opinion that the first wound Steenkamp sustained was in the hip, followed by the two other wounds. The sequence of the shots dovetails with testimony from neighbors who insisted they heard a woman screaming before hearing thuds sounding like gunshots. "If we Audiologist Pretoria can assume he shot the first shot, there was a pause and scream, he should have realized that it was Reeva, or considered that it may have been Reeva," Smith said. Smith said the evidence from Sean Rens, manager of the International Firearm Training Academy, is also extremely important to the state's case. Rens told the court that Pistorius had ordered several firearms from him and took a competency test in order to be declared fit to possess those guns. http://abcnews.go.com/International/ballistics-screams-threaten-oscar-pistorius-defense/story?id=23 066970