SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 9
Descargar para leer sin conexión
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                         www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012


               Improving Hospital Profitability through Cost of Quality
           (Case Study: VIP Nursing Care Unit, Stella Maris Hospital, Makassar, Indonesia)
                                                Indrianty Sudirman1* Yos Immanuel2
         1. Department of Management, Faculty of Economics, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia 90245
                2. Department of Hospital Administration, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia 90245
                            * Email of the corresponding author: indrianty_sudirman@yahoo.com
Abstract
The Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, Indonesia has made various efforts in improving the quality of services to maximize
profitability through the increasing of market share and cost containment. The financial cash flow within the year 2008-
2010 indicates that the operating costs increased which is in contrast to the rate of bed utilization that decreased for the same
period, that subsequently give impact to profitability. This paper is intended to analyze the relationship between cost of
quality with profitability. The result indicates that the cost of quality has a significant relationship to the profitability.
Partially, prevention and appraisal cost have a significant relationship to improve profitability, while the external failure
costs have a significant relationship to lower profitability. Internal failure costs, on the other hand, have no significant
relationship to the profitability. In conclusion, improving the allocation of prevention and appraisal costs will subsequently
increase the profitability.
Keywords: cost of quality, prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs, external failure costs, and profitability.

1.   Introduction
Increasing competition in the manufacturing and service industry requires companies to give more attention to the quality of
products and services produced, so as to survive in a dynamics competitive environment. Quality improvement can be done
by improving the quality of processes and products or services as it is one of the key strategic objectives in the Balanced
Scorecard concept (Norton and Kaplan, 2008). Improving the quality of products or services will increase customer
satisfaction and market share and subsequently increasing market share will have implications for revenue growth. Thus,
companies need to implement continuous quality improvement efforts by controlling the cost arisen through measurement
of the cost of quality.
Many companies promote quality as the central customer value and consider it to be a critical success factor for achieving
competitiveness. Any serious attempt to improve quality must take into account the costs associated with achieving quality
since the objective of continuous improvement programs is not only to meet customer requirements, but also to do it at the
lowest cost. This can only happen by reducing the costs needed to achieve quality, and the reduction of these costs is only
possible if they are identified and measured. Therefore, measuring and reporting the cost of quality (COQ) should be
considered an important issue for the companies.
Although the cost of quality (COQ) has been a well known concept for many years, but there is no general agreement on a
single broad definition of quality costs (Machowski and Dale, 1998). The cost of quality is usually understood as the sum of
conformance plus non-conformance costs. Cost of conformance is the price paid for prevention of poor quality (inspection
and quality appraisal). Cost of non-conformance is the cost of poor quality caused by product and service failure (rework
and returns). According to Purgslove and Dale (1995), it is now widely accepted that quality costs are the cost incurred in
the design, implementation, operation and maintenance of a quality management system, the cost of resources committed to
continuous improvement, the cost of system, product and service failures, and all other necessary costs and non-value added
activities required to achieve a quality product or service.
Campanella, Jack, et. al. (1990) and ASQC (1970), recognized four categories of quality costs namely: (1) prevention cost;
(2) appraisal cost; (3) internal failure cost; and (4) external failure cost. The definition of each catagory is describes as
follows;
Prevention costs are “the costs of all activities specifically designed to prevent poor quality in products and services”. This
is a proactive approach to defect prevention rather than defect correction and removes the idea of quality efforts essentially
being reactive in efforts to “put out fires”. Prevention expenses can be recovered many times over through reduced appraisal
and failure costs.
Appraisal costs are “the costs associated with measuring, evaluating, and auditing products or services to assure
conformance to quality standards and performance requirements”. Appraisal techniques are used for the verification and
validation. These techniques help organization to increase the quality with lower cost.
Internal failure costs are “the costs resulting from products or services not conforming to requirements or customer/user
needs (which) occur prior to delivery or shipment to the customer”.

                                                              120
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                         www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012

External failure costs are “the costs resulting from products or services that not conforming to requirements or
customer/user needs which occur after delivery or shipment of the product, and during or after furnishing of a service to the
customer”. External failure can include loss of failure business through customer dissatisfaction.
There are also correlation between the maturity of a quality system and the distribution of quality costs. Some studies have
been conducted to determine the actual effectiveness of COQ systems and the degree of maturity, and total costs model
relates the distribution cos of quality to the maturity of the quality system (Juran, J.M., Gryna, F.M. and Bingham, R.,
1975), as shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Conceptual Model of Relative COQ Expenditures Versus Quality System Maturity Level.

                                                     Maturity Level
                             1                   2                3                   4                  5
     Prevention       Very low           Low               Moderate           High                Very high
     Appraisal        Low                Low-Moderate      Moderate           Low-Moderate        Low
     Int failure      High               Very high         Moderate-high      Low-Moderate        Very low
     Ext failure      High               High              Moderate           Low                 Very low
  Total COQ       High              Very high          Moderate-high          Low-Moderate        Low
 Source: Sower, V.E., Quarles, R., Broussard, E. (2007)

The Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, in particular, has developed VIP treatment unit as one profit center with services
focusing on middle to upper segments of the economy. In fact, the purpose of the VIP treatment unit development is not
only to improve the profitability of the hospital to cover all operational and maintenance costs but also to subsidize poor
patients as the committment and implementation of the hospital missions. In conducting the service, variety quality
improvement programs have been conducted to support the hospital profitability through the improvement of market share
and operational cost efficiency. However, in the year 2008-2010, VIP treatment unit operating costs increased by 15.7%
annually. Conversely, the bed utilization rate decreased by 3.59% each year, so a such contradictory trend has given impact
to the profitability of the VIP treatment unit as one of the profit centers at Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar.
Based on these phenomenon, is important to analyze the quality cost of the profitability of the VIP Care Unit at Stella Maris
Hospital of Makassar. The main purpose of this study is to calculate and analyze the cost of quality (prevention costs,
appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure costs) and the level of profitability to identify the variable costs
that have a significant relationship to the profitability of the VIP treatment unit so that it can provide inputs related to the
allocation and control of the quality costs.


2.         Research Method
The research was carried out at the VIP Nursing Care Unit at Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, between April and May
2011.
The research used in this study was descriptive analytic using retrospective study design and quantitative approach. The
variables in this study consisted of 2 (two) groups, the independent variables and the dependent variable. Independent
variables consist of the cost of prevention (X1), the cost of assessment (X2), internal failure costs (X3), and external failure
costs (X4), while the dependent variable in this study is the profitability (Y).
The data was collected by examining and assessing some documents related to the research topic, namely the operational
cost data, annual reports, and implementation of hospital rates. In addition, the interview method was also used to assist the
identification of the hidden cost to equip the data that was not obtained during documentation process. Interviews were also
conducted to the heads of the related surgery units and heads of inpatient unit within the hospital.
The scope of the data in this study comprised the financial structure of the VIP care unit consisting of actual costs, hidden
costs, and estimated profitability. Sampling technique used was a census technique related to monthly operating costs and
profitability of the VIP care unit of Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar during the period of 2008-2010, where the number of
samples were 36 months (n = 36).



                                                               121
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                         www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012



3.   Results and Discussions
The concept of Balanced Scorecard in the customer's perspective described that service quality will increase customer
satisfaction that subsequently will support the acquisition and retention so that it will also increase the market share that
ultimately will affect the profitablity as illustrated in figure 1 (Norton and Kaplan, 2008). From the perspective of cost, the
concept of quality cost considers that the service quality requires the allocation for cost of control (prevention and appraisal)
and failure costs (internal and external) efficiently, thus increasing profitability (Foord K., 2004).



                                                                      Consumer
                                                                      Aquisition
                                                                                                  Market Share
                                         Consumer
                                        Satisfactionn                 Consumer
                                                                       Retention
     Service Quality
                                                                                                   Profitability


                                                    Cost of Quality

                                          Cost of                     Cost of
                                          Control                     Failure


                                 Prevention Cost                 Internal Failure Cost

                                  Appraisal Cost                 External Failure Cost


                                                    Figure 1. Theoritical Framework

The analysis of the profitability of the unit cost of quality care is carried out by measuring the profitability VIP care units
and components of quality cost, which consists of prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure
costs. The conceptual framework of this study is illustrated in figure 2.



                                  Prevention Cost


                                  Appraisal Cost                                   Profitability of the
                                                                                    VIP Nursing Care
                               Internal Failure Cost
                                                                                          Unit

                               External Failure Cost
                                                                                : Independent Variable
                                                                                : Dependent Variable

                                                    Figure 2. Conceptual Framework




                                                                 122
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                                                                                        www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012

3.1. Cost of Quality
Cost of quality is the cost associated with the prevention, identification, improvement of low (bad) quality products or do
not meet customer needs and the opportunity cost of time lost of production and sales. Cost of quality includes 4 (four)
groups of costs, i.e., prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs, and costs of failure external (Campanella, Jack,
et. al. 1990). The cost of quality of Stella Maris Hospital during 2008 – 2010 is presented in figure 3.




                                                                                                                                      1.916.137.155
                2.500.000.000




                                                                                                                               1.620.080.000
                                                                                                 1.414.410.674
                2.000.000.000
                                                                                                                                                      Prevention Cost
                                                           1.200.349.037




                                                                                            1.169.850.000                                             Appraisal Cost
                1.500.000.000
                                                      942.667.000




                                                                                                                                                      Internal Failure Cost

                1.000.000.000
                                                                                                                                                      External Failure Cost (BOD
                                                                                                                                                      80%)
                                                                                                                     126.981.740
                                        131.684.437




                                                                              125.178.068




                                                                                                                    147.474.915
                                       92.862.123




                                                                              92.998.306




                                                                                                                                                      Cost of Quality
                                      33.135.477




                                                                             26.384.300




                                                                                                                   21.600.500



                  500.000.000



                               -
                                           2008                                  2009                                   2010

                                    Figure 3. The cost of quality within the year period of 2008 to 2010

Based on the statistical F test, it was shown that prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure
costs linked to the profitability simultaneously. It can be seen from the value of R Square of 0.914 or in other words, Stella
Maris Hospital profitability of 91.4% determined by the cost of prevention, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and
external failure costs, while the remaining 8.6% is determined by other factors beyond the cost of quality is not examined in
this study.
Partial relationshion between each cost of quality components with profitabilty is illustrated in table 2, and will be further
elaborated in the following sections.
                                                                           Table 2. Paired T-Test of Profitability Correlation

                                                                                                                       Profitability
                                            Variables                                                                                                    Significant Level
                                                                                                                       Correlation
                           Prevention Cost (X1)                                                                              0,521                             0,001
                           Appraisal Cost (X2)                                                                               0,716                             0,000
                           Internal Failure Cost (X3)                                                                        0,063                             0,715
                           External Failure Cost (X4)                                                                       -0,475                             0,003
                         Source: Primary Data

3.2. Prevention costs
Prevention costs are costs incurred as a result of efforts to prevent poor quality of services rendered. It is intended to
maintain and improve the quality of service to consumers (Foord K., 2004). In this study, the costs of prevention include the
cost of quality planning and nursing care, the cost of human resource training, and facility maintenance of care units. As can

                                                                                                                 123
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                          www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012

be seen from Figure 3, the cost of prevention in the periods of 2008-2009 decreased by 4.94% from 131 million IDR to 125
million IDR. In the periods of 2009-2010, on the other hand, the prevention cost increased up to 17.81% from 125 million
IDR to 147 million IDR. The decrease in the prevention cost is also followed by a decrease of 0.27% in failure costs both
internal and external in the periods of 2008-2009, and a further decrease of 34.79% in 2010. This indicated that during the
years of 2008-2010, Stella Maris Hospital has tried to fix the quality of the VIP nursing care unit through the allocation of
quality cost as a part of prevention cost.
As shown in table 2, the analysis results showed that prevention cost has a significant effect on profitability at level of
0.001. Partial correlation coefficients of the cost of prevention with a value of 0.521 have a positive direction. This value
means that the rising costs of prevention will be followed by improved profitability significantly. In this case, the Stella
Maris Hospital still needs to further enhance its prevention cost allocation to maximize the profitability of VIP nursing care
unit as indicated by the regression correlation. This finding is in a good agreement with Hansen & Mowen (2006) stating
that the prevention cost and appraisal cost are part of control costs intended to prevent increasing of bad impact resulted
from poor product/service quality delivered to customers through minimizing the cost occurred from the failure.
Previous research carried out by Rahmat and Amalia (2007), also found that the increase of budget allocation for prevention
and appraisal costs of hospital will reduce the cost occured caused by external and internal failures. Therefore, it is necesary
for the Stella Maris Hospital to increase the allocation of prevention to maximize the profitability of VIP nursing care unit.
Under optimum allocation, the prevention cost could minimize the occurance of failre cost which subsequently increase the
profitability. This is inline with Hansen and Mowen (2006) that stated that cost efficiency will increase profitability.
This thought is also consistent with Balanced Scorecard hierarchical logic (Norton and Kaplan, 2008) stating that the
improvement of growth and learning will increase the quality of internal process that may have impact to consumer
satisfaction and ultimately will influence profitability. The prevention efforts that need to be done by Stella Maris Hospital
includes the improvement the quality of human resources including selection and recruitment process, better qualification
through sustainable education as well as internal and external training. The Stella maris hospital should also periodically
maintain the medical and non medical equipment and facilities as well as establish a electromedical team to supervise the
medical and non medical equipment and facilites. In addition, the Stella Maris Hospoital also need to improve and control
the quality continuously. Such efforts are covered in the perspective learning and growth from Balanced Scorecard concept
(Kaplan and Norton, 2008).
3.3. Appraisal Cost
Appraisal costs are costs ocurred as a result of the evaluation or audit on an ongoing basis to the standard of services to meet
the expectations of consumers (Foord K., 2004). It is intended to evaluate the quality of service to customers. In this study,
appraisal fee covered the folllowing costs as follows; the cost of internal surveys, nursing care evaluation cost, and
callibration cost of medical facilities of the VIP nursing care unit in Stella Maris Hospital.
Based on figure 3, the appraisal cost in the years of 2008-2009 increased by 0.15%, from 92.8 million IDR to 93 million
IDR. Similarly, in the year 2009-2010, the cost valuation increased by 36.54% from 92 million to 127 million IDR. This
indicates that an increase in the cost of the VIP care unit has applied a particular system related to the services provided. In
addition, the allocation of appraisal costs in the VIP nursing care unit has not been maximized, especially in the years 2009-
2010, where the cost of failure has increased by 34.79% (internal and external) even though after the year 2008-2009 it had
ever decreased by 0.27%.
The analysis result as shown in table 2 indicates that appraisal cost have a significant relationship to profitability at level of
0.000. In addition, partial correlation coefficients of the appraisal with a value of 0.716 have a positive direction. This value
means that the rising cost of appraisal will be followed by the improvement of profitability significantly. Therefore, the
Stella Maris Hospital needs to to further enhance the allocation of appraisal cost to maximize the profitability of the VIP
nursing care unit as also shown in the regression correlation.
Based on the findings, the Stella Maris Hospital has to increase the budget allocated for appraisal cost to maximize its
profitability. Several efforts could be improved regarding evaluation process as follows: (1) consistently conducting staff
performance and productivity evaluation based on key performance indicator that has been decided together, (2) conducting
monitoring and evaluation as well as follwing up the impelemtation of nursing care standard, and (3) continuously
improving the accreditation status in which one of the criteria is related to nursing care management.
3.4. Internal and External Failure Costs
Internal failure costs are costs ocurred due to a mismatch of internal processes to produce the services in accordance with
established standards and consumers requirements (Foord K., 2004). In this study, the costs of internal failure include
several components i.e., the cost of repairs and costs due to the resignation of HR in the VIP nursing care unit in the Stella
Maris Hospital during the periods of 2008-2010.

                                                              124
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                            www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012

In addition, based on figure 3, it can be seen that the cost of internal failure in the periods of 2008-2009 decreased by
20.37% i.e., from 33 million IDR to 26 million IDR. Similarly, in the years of 2009-2010, the internal failure costs
decreased by 18.13% from 26.4 million IDR to 21.6 million IDR. Such decrease can be caused by the improvement of the
quality of internal services in the VIP nursing care unit which then minimizing the cost of internal failure including the cost
of repairs and the resignation of HR. Moreover, this decrease can also be caused by the low allocation of funds to fix the
internal process improvement in VIP nursing care unit of the Stella Maris Hospital.
Based on the trend in external failure costs during the periods of 2008-2010, which increased by 10.52% in the years of
2008-2009 and then increased again by 35.35% in 2010, therefore the low of external failure costs are caused by the low
allocation of funds to fix the improve the internal process of the VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital.
Therefore the hospital needs to pay more attention to improve of the internal processes in the VIP nursing care unit to
improve the service quality and minimize the external failure costs simultaneously.
Based on the statistical analysis result as illustrated in table 2, the external failure cost has a significant level of 0.715,
indicating that there is no significant relationship to the profitability. However, the partial correlation coefficients of the
external failure cost is 0.063 implying that the rising costs of internal failure would be followed by an increase in
profitability, but not significant. Therefore, the Stella Maris Hospital needs to improve the allocation of costs for the
improvement of internal processes to maximize profitability levels as reflected by the regression correlation, but the
utilization must be evaluated and controlled continuously.
In relation to the balanced scorecard concept (Kaplan and Norton, 2008), several efforts could be done by the Stella Maris
Hospital related to surpress the inetrnal failure cost, among others are: (1) standardizing and implementing the hospital
service procedure, (2) impelementing patient safety program consistently, and (3) improving remuneration system.
3.5. Profitability
In this study, profitability is obtained through several stages, which are generally divided into 4 stages:
     •    Calculating the cost of distribution of cost of supporting unit which charged at the hospital for nursing care unit as
          a center of production costs by using Double-Distribution.
     •    Counting the cost of the activity in VIP nursing care unit using the Activity Based Costing (ABC).
     •    Combining the results of the cost of distribution at point (1) the cost of the activity at points (2) to determine the
          unit cost of VIP care class (Super VIP - VIP C).
     •    Calculating the difference in profitability with earnings estimates based on hospital rates and earnings estimates
          based on the calculation of unit cost (Double Distribution and Activity Based Costing).
As can be seen in figure 4, the profitability of VIP nursing care unit withing the year of 2008-2009 decreased by 8.65%, but
then increased by 16.32% in the year of 2009-2010. This situation indicates that the service at the VIP nursing care unit at
the Stella Maris Hospital is productive and profitable. Among the overall cost of quality, there are several types of costs that
can significantly affect the profitability of the VIP nursing care unit including the cost of prevention, appraisal costs, and
external failure costs. Prevention and appraisal costs have a positive correlation coefficient to increase profitability, while
the external failure costs have a negative correlation coefficient, which can reduce the profitability of VIP nursing care unit
significantly. Therefore, it is necessary for the Stella Maris Hospital to minimize the external failure costs through efforts in
an integrated quality control and allocation of cost control (cost of prevention and appraisal costs) optimally. Although there
is no significant relationship to the profitability, the internal failure cost allocation is still required to be optimized since it
still has a positive correlation coefficient that can improve the profitability.




                                                               125
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                                                                 www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012




                                                                                                                         1.916.137.155
                2.500.000.000




                                                                                                                                            1.656.261.512
                                                                1.558.761.626




                                                                                                         1.423.921.850
                                                                                      1.414.410.674
                2.000.000.000




                                             1.200.349.037
                1.500.000.000



                1.000.000.000



                  500.000.000



                               -
                                                         2008                                     2009                               2010

                                                                Cost of Quality                 Profitability

                    Figure 4. Comparison of Profitability and Cost of Quality within the year of 2008-2010

4.   Conclusion
The prevention and appraisal costs have a positive correlation value to the profitability, which means that an increase in
prevention and appraisal costs can increase the profitability of VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital. Thus, the
hospital needs to improve the allocation of prevention and appraisal costs to support quality improvement of the VIP
nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital through well-managed of the budget planning of operational control.
The Stella Maris Hospital needs to to suppress the internal and external failure costs by allocating the cost of control
(prevention and appraisal costs) which can be used for quality control on an ongoing basis so as to increase the profitability
of VIP care unit.
5.   Research Limitations and Future Research
This research is limited by data availability related to revenue and financial statement of the VIP nursing care unit at the
Stella Maris Hospital. Therefore, the revenue was calculated using an estimation approach. Preferably, subsequent research
is required using real data in order to obtain more accurate results.
The calculation of external failure was used bed utilization standards instead of using the standard BOR (Bed Occupancy
Rate). According to the Ministry of Health, Indonesia, the ideal number of BOR is supposed to be equal to 80%, but at a
certain month the bed utilization is above 80%; consequently it will produce some extreme values in the statistical analysis
that could affect the results of analysis of the relationship variables. Therefore, the standard bed untilization using BOR is
the maximum standard of 100%. In the inpatient services, the standards of this magnitude can have an impact to the poor
quality of service provided. Further studies can use the standard BOR by 80% as recommended by the Ministry of Health,
Indonesia.
References
ASQC (1970), “Quality Costs – What and How”, American Society for Quality Control, pp.54
Blocher E., Stout D., and Cokins G., (2010). Cost Management: A Strategic Emphasis, McGraw Hill, Australia.
Born P.H., and Simon C.J., Patients and Profits (2001): The Relationship between HMO Financial Performance and Quality
          of Care, Health Affairs, 20, 2, 2001.


                                                                                126
European Journal of Business and Management                                                                  www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol 4, No.11, 2012

Campanella, Jack, et. al. (1990). Principles of Quality Costs : Principles, Implementation, and Use. 2nd ed. Milwaukee :
         ASQC Quality Press.
Foord K.(2004), “High Tunnel Marketing and Economics”, Minnesota High Tunnel Production Manual for Commercial
         Growers, 2004.
Hansen D.R., and Mowen M.M., (2006). Managerial Accounting, 8th Edition, Thomson Higher Education, USA.
                                                                               rd
Juran, J.M., Gryna, F.M. and Bingham, R. (1975), Quality Control Textbook, 3 edition, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Machowski, F. And Dale, B.G. (1998), “Quality Costing: An examination of knowledge, attitudes and perceptions”, Quality
        Management Journal, Vol.5, No.3, p.84
Norton, Kaplan. (2008). The Balanced Scorecard : Translating Strategy Into Action. United Kingdom : Harvard Business
         Press
Purgslove, A.B. and Dale, B.G. (1995), “Developing a quality costing system: Key features and outcomes”, Omega, Vol.23,
          p.567
Rahmat, and Amalia., (2007). Perhitungan dan Analisa Biaya Kualitas Pada Rumah Sakit “X”. Universitas Indonesia :
         Jakarta
Randall G and Brown S., (1999). “Prevention is better than Cure”, Crisis, UK
Schiffauerova and Thomson. 2006. A review of research on cost of quality models and best practices, International Journal
          of Quality and Reliability Management, 2006, Vol. 23, No. 4, pp. 1-23
Shah U., (2011). Quality and Cost of Heallthcare: “An Indian Prespective an Assessment of Direct Cost of Quality Across
          Hospitals in India”, International Journal of Business and Management Tomorrow Vol. 1 No. 1
Sower, V.E. and Quarles R., (2003). Cost of Quality: “Why More Organization Do Not Use It Effectively”, American
         Society for Quality, 2003.
Sower, V.E., Quarles, R., Broussard, E., (2007) “Cost of quality usage and its relationship to quality system maturity”,
         International Journal of Quality & Reliability management, Vol. 24, No. 2, (2007), PP. 121-140.


Indrianty Sudirman. A full time lecture in strategic management and the secretary of the doctoral study program of
economics at Faculty of Economics, Hasanuddin University of Makassar, as well as a part time lecturer in marketing at the
University of Indonesia of Jakarta. Since 2000, the author has been actively involved in the development of teaching
hospital of Hasanuddin University, and now assigned as a management consultant of the teaching hospital. The author has
also been heavily involved in research and community services related to strategic management and marketing as author’s
expertise as well as being a consultant in variety healthcare industries. The author is active as a member of several
professional organizations such as Association of Indonesia Economics Scholars (since 1997), Indonesia Marketing
Association (since 2000), Indonesia Management Scientist Association (since 2005), and Communication Forum of
Indonesia Hospital Administration Master Programs.




                                                          127
This academic article was published by The International Institute for Science,
Technology and Education (IISTE). The IISTE is a pioneer in the Open Access
Publishing service based in the U.S. and Europe. The aim of the institute is
Accelerating Global Knowledge Sharing.

More information about the publisher can be found in the IISTE’s homepage:
http://www.iiste.org


The IISTE is currently hosting more than 30 peer-reviewed academic journals and
collaborating with academic institutions around the world. Prospective authors of
IISTE journals can find the submission instruction on the following page:
http://www.iiste.org/Journals/

The IISTE editorial team promises to the review and publish all the qualified
submissions in a fast manner. All the journals articles are available online to the
readers all over the world without financial, legal, or technical barriers other than
those inseparable from gaining access to the internet itself. Printed version of the
journals is also available upon request of readers and authors.

IISTE Knowledge Sharing Partners

EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Open
Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial
Library , NewJour, Google Scholar

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Power point template
Power point templatePower point template
Power point templateradygogo
 
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phone
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phoneCustomer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phone
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phoneIAEME Publication
 
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...Alexander Decker
 
I. Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...
I.	Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...I.	Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...
I. Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...Lena Argosino
 
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...Brown485
 
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...Callahanne
 
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_quality
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_qualityFogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_quality
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_qualityAshenafi Girma
 
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy. a ca...
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy.  a ca...Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy.  a ca...
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy. a ca...Alexander Decker
 
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...kalotogub
 
Product Quality
Product QualityProduct Quality
Product QualitySajith91
 
Healthcare Supply Chain
Healthcare Supply ChainHealthcare Supply Chain
Healthcare Supply Chainssnbarnett
 
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...Aamir Ali
 
Dabholkar servqual
Dabholkar servqualDabholkar servqual
Dabholkar servqualDiah Gembul
 
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...paperpublications3
 
Recoverd ppt file(4)
Recoverd ppt file(4)Recoverd ppt file(4)
Recoverd ppt file(4)asif
 
Tugas dimensi dabholkar
Tugas dimensi dabholkarTugas dimensi dabholkar
Tugas dimensi dabholkarnoe irredenta
 
The international journal of business and management
The international journal of business and managementThe international journal of business and management
The international journal of business and managementPatrick Sweet
 
Customer Service
Customer ServiceCustomer Service
Customer ServiceMonil Sheth
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Power point template
Power point templatePower point template
Power point template
 
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phone
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phoneCustomer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phone
Customer expectations and perceptions of service quality of mobile phone
 
Precise services and supply chain prioritization in manufacturing companies u...
Precise services and supply chain prioritization in manufacturing companies u...Precise services and supply chain prioritization in manufacturing companies u...
Precise services and supply chain prioritization in manufacturing companies u...
 
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...
Impact of service recovery on customer satisfaction in hospitality industry o...
 
I. Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...
I.	Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...I.	Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...
I. Stages of Operational Competitiveness the different levels of customer con...
 
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...
Solutions manual for operations management processes and supply chains 11th e...
 
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains Global 11th Edition Krajews...
 
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_quality
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_qualityFogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_quality
Fogarty catts forlin_measuring_service_quality
 
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy. a ca...
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy.  a ca...Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy.  a ca...
Supply chain cost identification as a means of cost reduction strategy. a ca...
 
I038079084
I038079084I038079084
I038079084
 
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...
Operations Management Processes and Supply Chains 12th Edition Krajewski Test...
 
Product Quality
Product QualityProduct Quality
Product Quality
 
Healthcare Supply Chain
Healthcare Supply ChainHealthcare Supply Chain
Healthcare Supply Chain
 
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...
Solution manual for operations management processes and supply chains 10th ed...
 
Dabholkar servqual
Dabholkar servqualDabholkar servqual
Dabholkar servqual
 
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...
Quality-Driven Logistics: Reverse Logistics Process Reengineering, Improving ...
 
Recoverd ppt file(4)
Recoverd ppt file(4)Recoverd ppt file(4)
Recoverd ppt file(4)
 
Tugas dimensi dabholkar
Tugas dimensi dabholkarTugas dimensi dabholkar
Tugas dimensi dabholkar
 
The international journal of business and management
The international journal of business and managementThe international journal of business and management
The international journal of business and management
 
Customer Service
Customer ServiceCustomer Service
Customer Service
 

Similar a Improving hospital profitability through cost of quality

Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case Study
Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case StudyDevelopment of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case Study
Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case StudyIOSR Journals
 
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...Alexander Decker
 
Total quality-management
Total quality-managementTotal quality-management
Total quality-managementqualityinhealth
 
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS ijmvsc
 
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...Associate Professor in VSB Coimbatore
 
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...Dr. Amarjeet Singh
 
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...OECD Governance
 
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqm
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqmBenefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqm
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqmeSAT Publishing House
 
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...Alexander Decker
 
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industry
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment IndustryImpact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industry
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industryijtsrd
 
Cost effectiveness and cost containment
Cost effectiveness and cost containmentCost effectiveness and cost containment
Cost effectiveness and cost containmentSaumya Srivastava
 
Costofquality
Costofquality Costofquality
Costofquality VarunRao78
 
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...IRJET Journal
 
The Cost of Quality
The Cost of QualityThe Cost of Quality
The Cost of QualityTran Nguyen
 
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docx
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docxRunning Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docx
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docxcharisellington63520
 

Similar a Improving hospital profitability through cost of quality (20)

Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case Study
Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case StudyDevelopment of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case Study
Development of Model for Quality Costing in a Medium Scale Industry-A Case Study
 
Cost of quality
Cost of qualityCost of quality
Cost of quality
 
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...
The impact of applying quality management system and environment standard on ...
 
Total quality-management
Total quality-managementTotal quality-management
Total quality-management
 
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS
HIDDEN COSTS OF QUALITY: MEASUREMENT & ANALYSIS
 
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...
Assessment of Cost of Quality and its Effects on Manufacturing Performance: A...
 
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...
Impacts of the Cost of Quality Components on Business Execution and the Strat...
 
Quality Custom Essays
Quality Custom EssaysQuality Custom Essays
Quality Custom Essays
 
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
What are the challenges in measuring pulic sector efficiency? - Julian Kelly,...
 
Cost of quality
Cost of qualityCost of quality
Cost of quality
 
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqm
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqmBenefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqm
Benefits derived by sm es through implementation of tqm
 
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...
The degree to which banks are committed to applying the dimensions of total q...
 
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industry
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment IndustryImpact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industry
Impact of Cost of Quality on Total Quality Management in Garment Industry
 
Cost effectiveness and cost containment
Cost effectiveness and cost containmentCost effectiveness and cost containment
Cost effectiveness and cost containment
 
Costofquality
Costofquality Costofquality
Costofquality
 
Efficiency-short.pptx
Efficiency-short.pptxEfficiency-short.pptx
Efficiency-short.pptx
 
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...
IRJET-Analysis of Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) and its Calculation: Steel Indu...
 
The Cost of Quality
The Cost of QualityThe Cost of Quality
The Cost of Quality
 
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docx
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docxRunning Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docx
Running Head FROM THE FRONT LINES1From the Front Lines.docx
 
Cost concept and economic evaluation
Cost concept and economic evaluationCost concept and economic evaluation
Cost concept and economic evaluation
 

Más de Alexander Decker

Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Alexander Decker
 
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inA validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inAlexander Decker
 
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesA usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesAlexander Decker
 
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksAlexander Decker
 
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dA unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dAlexander Decker
 
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceA trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceAlexander Decker
 
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamA transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamAlexander Decker
 
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaA time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaAlexander Decker
 
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenA therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenAlexander Decker
 
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksAlexander Decker
 
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forA systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forAlexander Decker
 
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabA synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabAlexander Decker
 
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...Alexander Decker
 
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalA survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalAlexander Decker
 
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesA survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesAlexander Decker
 
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbA survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbAlexander Decker
 
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudA survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudAlexander Decker
 
A survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedA survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedAlexander Decker
 
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaA survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaAlexander Decker
 
A study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofA study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofAlexander Decker
 

Más de Alexander Decker (20)

Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
 
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inA validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
 
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesA usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
 
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
 
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dA unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
 
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceA trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
 
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamA transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
 
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaA time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
 
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenA therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
 
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
 
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forA systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
 
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabA synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
 
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
 
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalA survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
 
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesA survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
 
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbA survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
 
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudA survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
 
A survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedA survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveraged
 
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaA survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
 
A study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofA study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health of
 

Último

business environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
business environment micro environment macro environment.pptxbusiness environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
business environment micro environment macro environment.pptxShruti Mittal
 
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptx
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptxBAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptx
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptxran17april2001
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersPeter Horsten
 
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdf
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdfDarshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdf
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdfShashank Mehta
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxmbikashkanyari
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfJamesConcepcion7
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfDanny Diep To
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdfShaun Heinrichs
 
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Peter Ward
 
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Anamaria Contreras
 
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationPSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationAnamaria Contreras
 
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesUnveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesDoe Paoro
 
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsIntroducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsKnowledgeSeed
 
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold Jewelry
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold JewelryEffective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold Jewelry
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold JewelryWhittensFineJewelry1
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Americas Got Grants
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxappkodes
 
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamTechnical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamArik Fletcher
 
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebs
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebsSupercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebs
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebsGOKUL JS
 

Último (20)

business environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
business environment micro environment macro environment.pptxbusiness environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
business environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
 
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptx
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptxBAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptx
BAILMENT & PLEDGE business law notes.pptx
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
 
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdf
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdfDarshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdf
Darshan Hiranandani [News About Next CEO].pdf
 
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptxThe-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
The-Ethical-issues-ghhhhhhhhjof-Byjus.pptx
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
 
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
1911 Gold Corporate Presentation Apr 2024.pdf
 
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
Fordham -How effective decision-making is within the IT department - Analysis...
 
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdfWAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
 
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
Traction part 2 - EOS Model JAX Bridges.
 
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement PresentationPSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
PSCC - Capability Statement Presentation
 
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesUnveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
 
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsIntroducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
 
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold Jewelry
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold JewelryEffective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold Jewelry
Effective Strategies for Maximizing Your Profit When Selling Gold Jewelry
 
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
Church Building Grants To Assist With New Construction, Additions, And Restor...
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
 
The Bizz Quiz-E-Summit-E-Cell-IITPatna.pptx
The Bizz Quiz-E-Summit-E-Cell-IITPatna.pptxThe Bizz Quiz-E-Summit-E-Cell-IITPatna.pptx
The Bizz Quiz-E-Summit-E-Cell-IITPatna.pptx
 
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamTechnical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
 
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebs
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebsSupercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebs
Supercharge Your eCommerce Stores-acowebs
 

Improving hospital profitability through cost of quality

  • 1. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 Improving Hospital Profitability through Cost of Quality (Case Study: VIP Nursing Care Unit, Stella Maris Hospital, Makassar, Indonesia) Indrianty Sudirman1* Yos Immanuel2 1. Department of Management, Faculty of Economics, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia 90245 2. Department of Hospital Administration, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia 90245 * Email of the corresponding author: indrianty_sudirman@yahoo.com Abstract The Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, Indonesia has made various efforts in improving the quality of services to maximize profitability through the increasing of market share and cost containment. The financial cash flow within the year 2008- 2010 indicates that the operating costs increased which is in contrast to the rate of bed utilization that decreased for the same period, that subsequently give impact to profitability. This paper is intended to analyze the relationship between cost of quality with profitability. The result indicates that the cost of quality has a significant relationship to the profitability. Partially, prevention and appraisal cost have a significant relationship to improve profitability, while the external failure costs have a significant relationship to lower profitability. Internal failure costs, on the other hand, have no significant relationship to the profitability. In conclusion, improving the allocation of prevention and appraisal costs will subsequently increase the profitability. Keywords: cost of quality, prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs, external failure costs, and profitability. 1. Introduction Increasing competition in the manufacturing and service industry requires companies to give more attention to the quality of products and services produced, so as to survive in a dynamics competitive environment. Quality improvement can be done by improving the quality of processes and products or services as it is one of the key strategic objectives in the Balanced Scorecard concept (Norton and Kaplan, 2008). Improving the quality of products or services will increase customer satisfaction and market share and subsequently increasing market share will have implications for revenue growth. Thus, companies need to implement continuous quality improvement efforts by controlling the cost arisen through measurement of the cost of quality. Many companies promote quality as the central customer value and consider it to be a critical success factor for achieving competitiveness. Any serious attempt to improve quality must take into account the costs associated with achieving quality since the objective of continuous improvement programs is not only to meet customer requirements, but also to do it at the lowest cost. This can only happen by reducing the costs needed to achieve quality, and the reduction of these costs is only possible if they are identified and measured. Therefore, measuring and reporting the cost of quality (COQ) should be considered an important issue for the companies. Although the cost of quality (COQ) has been a well known concept for many years, but there is no general agreement on a single broad definition of quality costs (Machowski and Dale, 1998). The cost of quality is usually understood as the sum of conformance plus non-conformance costs. Cost of conformance is the price paid for prevention of poor quality (inspection and quality appraisal). Cost of non-conformance is the cost of poor quality caused by product and service failure (rework and returns). According to Purgslove and Dale (1995), it is now widely accepted that quality costs are the cost incurred in the design, implementation, operation and maintenance of a quality management system, the cost of resources committed to continuous improvement, the cost of system, product and service failures, and all other necessary costs and non-value added activities required to achieve a quality product or service. Campanella, Jack, et. al. (1990) and ASQC (1970), recognized four categories of quality costs namely: (1) prevention cost; (2) appraisal cost; (3) internal failure cost; and (4) external failure cost. The definition of each catagory is describes as follows; Prevention costs are “the costs of all activities specifically designed to prevent poor quality in products and services”. This is a proactive approach to defect prevention rather than defect correction and removes the idea of quality efforts essentially being reactive in efforts to “put out fires”. Prevention expenses can be recovered many times over through reduced appraisal and failure costs. Appraisal costs are “the costs associated with measuring, evaluating, and auditing products or services to assure conformance to quality standards and performance requirements”. Appraisal techniques are used for the verification and validation. These techniques help organization to increase the quality with lower cost. Internal failure costs are “the costs resulting from products or services not conforming to requirements or customer/user needs (which) occur prior to delivery or shipment to the customer”. 120
  • 2. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 External failure costs are “the costs resulting from products or services that not conforming to requirements or customer/user needs which occur after delivery or shipment of the product, and during or after furnishing of a service to the customer”. External failure can include loss of failure business through customer dissatisfaction. There are also correlation between the maturity of a quality system and the distribution of quality costs. Some studies have been conducted to determine the actual effectiveness of COQ systems and the degree of maturity, and total costs model relates the distribution cos of quality to the maturity of the quality system (Juran, J.M., Gryna, F.M. and Bingham, R., 1975), as shown in Table 1. Table 1. Conceptual Model of Relative COQ Expenditures Versus Quality System Maturity Level. Maturity Level 1 2 3 4 5 Prevention Very low Low Moderate High Very high Appraisal Low Low-Moderate Moderate Low-Moderate Low Int failure High Very high Moderate-high Low-Moderate Very low Ext failure High High Moderate Low Very low Total COQ High Very high Moderate-high Low-Moderate Low Source: Sower, V.E., Quarles, R., Broussard, E. (2007) The Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, in particular, has developed VIP treatment unit as one profit center with services focusing on middle to upper segments of the economy. In fact, the purpose of the VIP treatment unit development is not only to improve the profitability of the hospital to cover all operational and maintenance costs but also to subsidize poor patients as the committment and implementation of the hospital missions. In conducting the service, variety quality improvement programs have been conducted to support the hospital profitability through the improvement of market share and operational cost efficiency. However, in the year 2008-2010, VIP treatment unit operating costs increased by 15.7% annually. Conversely, the bed utilization rate decreased by 3.59% each year, so a such contradictory trend has given impact to the profitability of the VIP treatment unit as one of the profit centers at Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar. Based on these phenomenon, is important to analyze the quality cost of the profitability of the VIP Care Unit at Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar. The main purpose of this study is to calculate and analyze the cost of quality (prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure costs) and the level of profitability to identify the variable costs that have a significant relationship to the profitability of the VIP treatment unit so that it can provide inputs related to the allocation and control of the quality costs. 2. Research Method The research was carried out at the VIP Nursing Care Unit at Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar, between April and May 2011. The research used in this study was descriptive analytic using retrospective study design and quantitative approach. The variables in this study consisted of 2 (two) groups, the independent variables and the dependent variable. Independent variables consist of the cost of prevention (X1), the cost of assessment (X2), internal failure costs (X3), and external failure costs (X4), while the dependent variable in this study is the profitability (Y). The data was collected by examining and assessing some documents related to the research topic, namely the operational cost data, annual reports, and implementation of hospital rates. In addition, the interview method was also used to assist the identification of the hidden cost to equip the data that was not obtained during documentation process. Interviews were also conducted to the heads of the related surgery units and heads of inpatient unit within the hospital. The scope of the data in this study comprised the financial structure of the VIP care unit consisting of actual costs, hidden costs, and estimated profitability. Sampling technique used was a census technique related to monthly operating costs and profitability of the VIP care unit of Stella Maris Hospital of Makassar during the period of 2008-2010, where the number of samples were 36 months (n = 36). 121
  • 3. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 3. Results and Discussions The concept of Balanced Scorecard in the customer's perspective described that service quality will increase customer satisfaction that subsequently will support the acquisition and retention so that it will also increase the market share that ultimately will affect the profitablity as illustrated in figure 1 (Norton and Kaplan, 2008). From the perspective of cost, the concept of quality cost considers that the service quality requires the allocation for cost of control (prevention and appraisal) and failure costs (internal and external) efficiently, thus increasing profitability (Foord K., 2004). Consumer Aquisition Market Share Consumer Satisfactionn Consumer Retention Service Quality Profitability Cost of Quality Cost of Cost of Control Failure Prevention Cost Internal Failure Cost Appraisal Cost External Failure Cost Figure 1. Theoritical Framework The analysis of the profitability of the unit cost of quality care is carried out by measuring the profitability VIP care units and components of quality cost, which consists of prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure costs. The conceptual framework of this study is illustrated in figure 2. Prevention Cost Appraisal Cost Profitability of the VIP Nursing Care Internal Failure Cost Unit External Failure Cost : Independent Variable : Dependent Variable Figure 2. Conceptual Framework 122
  • 4. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 3.1. Cost of Quality Cost of quality is the cost associated with the prevention, identification, improvement of low (bad) quality products or do not meet customer needs and the opportunity cost of time lost of production and sales. Cost of quality includes 4 (four) groups of costs, i.e., prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs, and costs of failure external (Campanella, Jack, et. al. 1990). The cost of quality of Stella Maris Hospital during 2008 – 2010 is presented in figure 3. 1.916.137.155 2.500.000.000 1.620.080.000 1.414.410.674 2.000.000.000 Prevention Cost 1.200.349.037 1.169.850.000 Appraisal Cost 1.500.000.000 942.667.000 Internal Failure Cost 1.000.000.000 External Failure Cost (BOD 80%) 126.981.740 131.684.437 125.178.068 147.474.915 92.862.123 92.998.306 Cost of Quality 33.135.477 26.384.300 21.600.500 500.000.000 - 2008 2009 2010 Figure 3. The cost of quality within the year period of 2008 to 2010 Based on the statistical F test, it was shown that prevention costs, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure costs linked to the profitability simultaneously. It can be seen from the value of R Square of 0.914 or in other words, Stella Maris Hospital profitability of 91.4% determined by the cost of prevention, appraisal costs, internal failure costs and external failure costs, while the remaining 8.6% is determined by other factors beyond the cost of quality is not examined in this study. Partial relationshion between each cost of quality components with profitabilty is illustrated in table 2, and will be further elaborated in the following sections. Table 2. Paired T-Test of Profitability Correlation Profitability Variables Significant Level Correlation Prevention Cost (X1) 0,521 0,001 Appraisal Cost (X2) 0,716 0,000 Internal Failure Cost (X3) 0,063 0,715 External Failure Cost (X4) -0,475 0,003 Source: Primary Data 3.2. Prevention costs Prevention costs are costs incurred as a result of efforts to prevent poor quality of services rendered. It is intended to maintain and improve the quality of service to consumers (Foord K., 2004). In this study, the costs of prevention include the cost of quality planning and nursing care, the cost of human resource training, and facility maintenance of care units. As can 123
  • 5. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 be seen from Figure 3, the cost of prevention in the periods of 2008-2009 decreased by 4.94% from 131 million IDR to 125 million IDR. In the periods of 2009-2010, on the other hand, the prevention cost increased up to 17.81% from 125 million IDR to 147 million IDR. The decrease in the prevention cost is also followed by a decrease of 0.27% in failure costs both internal and external in the periods of 2008-2009, and a further decrease of 34.79% in 2010. This indicated that during the years of 2008-2010, Stella Maris Hospital has tried to fix the quality of the VIP nursing care unit through the allocation of quality cost as a part of prevention cost. As shown in table 2, the analysis results showed that prevention cost has a significant effect on profitability at level of 0.001. Partial correlation coefficients of the cost of prevention with a value of 0.521 have a positive direction. This value means that the rising costs of prevention will be followed by improved profitability significantly. In this case, the Stella Maris Hospital still needs to further enhance its prevention cost allocation to maximize the profitability of VIP nursing care unit as indicated by the regression correlation. This finding is in a good agreement with Hansen & Mowen (2006) stating that the prevention cost and appraisal cost are part of control costs intended to prevent increasing of bad impact resulted from poor product/service quality delivered to customers through minimizing the cost occurred from the failure. Previous research carried out by Rahmat and Amalia (2007), also found that the increase of budget allocation for prevention and appraisal costs of hospital will reduce the cost occured caused by external and internal failures. Therefore, it is necesary for the Stella Maris Hospital to increase the allocation of prevention to maximize the profitability of VIP nursing care unit. Under optimum allocation, the prevention cost could minimize the occurance of failre cost which subsequently increase the profitability. This is inline with Hansen and Mowen (2006) that stated that cost efficiency will increase profitability. This thought is also consistent with Balanced Scorecard hierarchical logic (Norton and Kaplan, 2008) stating that the improvement of growth and learning will increase the quality of internal process that may have impact to consumer satisfaction and ultimately will influence profitability. The prevention efforts that need to be done by Stella Maris Hospital includes the improvement the quality of human resources including selection and recruitment process, better qualification through sustainable education as well as internal and external training. The Stella maris hospital should also periodically maintain the medical and non medical equipment and facilities as well as establish a electromedical team to supervise the medical and non medical equipment and facilites. In addition, the Stella Maris Hospoital also need to improve and control the quality continuously. Such efforts are covered in the perspective learning and growth from Balanced Scorecard concept (Kaplan and Norton, 2008). 3.3. Appraisal Cost Appraisal costs are costs ocurred as a result of the evaluation or audit on an ongoing basis to the standard of services to meet the expectations of consumers (Foord K., 2004). It is intended to evaluate the quality of service to customers. In this study, appraisal fee covered the folllowing costs as follows; the cost of internal surveys, nursing care evaluation cost, and callibration cost of medical facilities of the VIP nursing care unit in Stella Maris Hospital. Based on figure 3, the appraisal cost in the years of 2008-2009 increased by 0.15%, from 92.8 million IDR to 93 million IDR. Similarly, in the year 2009-2010, the cost valuation increased by 36.54% from 92 million to 127 million IDR. This indicates that an increase in the cost of the VIP care unit has applied a particular system related to the services provided. In addition, the allocation of appraisal costs in the VIP nursing care unit has not been maximized, especially in the years 2009- 2010, where the cost of failure has increased by 34.79% (internal and external) even though after the year 2008-2009 it had ever decreased by 0.27%. The analysis result as shown in table 2 indicates that appraisal cost have a significant relationship to profitability at level of 0.000. In addition, partial correlation coefficients of the appraisal with a value of 0.716 have a positive direction. This value means that the rising cost of appraisal will be followed by the improvement of profitability significantly. Therefore, the Stella Maris Hospital needs to to further enhance the allocation of appraisal cost to maximize the profitability of the VIP nursing care unit as also shown in the regression correlation. Based on the findings, the Stella Maris Hospital has to increase the budget allocated for appraisal cost to maximize its profitability. Several efforts could be improved regarding evaluation process as follows: (1) consistently conducting staff performance and productivity evaluation based on key performance indicator that has been decided together, (2) conducting monitoring and evaluation as well as follwing up the impelemtation of nursing care standard, and (3) continuously improving the accreditation status in which one of the criteria is related to nursing care management. 3.4. Internal and External Failure Costs Internal failure costs are costs ocurred due to a mismatch of internal processes to produce the services in accordance with established standards and consumers requirements (Foord K., 2004). In this study, the costs of internal failure include several components i.e., the cost of repairs and costs due to the resignation of HR in the VIP nursing care unit in the Stella Maris Hospital during the periods of 2008-2010. 124
  • 6. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 In addition, based on figure 3, it can be seen that the cost of internal failure in the periods of 2008-2009 decreased by 20.37% i.e., from 33 million IDR to 26 million IDR. Similarly, in the years of 2009-2010, the internal failure costs decreased by 18.13% from 26.4 million IDR to 21.6 million IDR. Such decrease can be caused by the improvement of the quality of internal services in the VIP nursing care unit which then minimizing the cost of internal failure including the cost of repairs and the resignation of HR. Moreover, this decrease can also be caused by the low allocation of funds to fix the internal process improvement in VIP nursing care unit of the Stella Maris Hospital. Based on the trend in external failure costs during the periods of 2008-2010, which increased by 10.52% in the years of 2008-2009 and then increased again by 35.35% in 2010, therefore the low of external failure costs are caused by the low allocation of funds to fix the improve the internal process of the VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital. Therefore the hospital needs to pay more attention to improve of the internal processes in the VIP nursing care unit to improve the service quality and minimize the external failure costs simultaneously. Based on the statistical analysis result as illustrated in table 2, the external failure cost has a significant level of 0.715, indicating that there is no significant relationship to the profitability. However, the partial correlation coefficients of the external failure cost is 0.063 implying that the rising costs of internal failure would be followed by an increase in profitability, but not significant. Therefore, the Stella Maris Hospital needs to improve the allocation of costs for the improvement of internal processes to maximize profitability levels as reflected by the regression correlation, but the utilization must be evaluated and controlled continuously. In relation to the balanced scorecard concept (Kaplan and Norton, 2008), several efforts could be done by the Stella Maris Hospital related to surpress the inetrnal failure cost, among others are: (1) standardizing and implementing the hospital service procedure, (2) impelementing patient safety program consistently, and (3) improving remuneration system. 3.5. Profitability In this study, profitability is obtained through several stages, which are generally divided into 4 stages: • Calculating the cost of distribution of cost of supporting unit which charged at the hospital for nursing care unit as a center of production costs by using Double-Distribution. • Counting the cost of the activity in VIP nursing care unit using the Activity Based Costing (ABC). • Combining the results of the cost of distribution at point (1) the cost of the activity at points (2) to determine the unit cost of VIP care class (Super VIP - VIP C). • Calculating the difference in profitability with earnings estimates based on hospital rates and earnings estimates based on the calculation of unit cost (Double Distribution and Activity Based Costing). As can be seen in figure 4, the profitability of VIP nursing care unit withing the year of 2008-2009 decreased by 8.65%, but then increased by 16.32% in the year of 2009-2010. This situation indicates that the service at the VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital is productive and profitable. Among the overall cost of quality, there are several types of costs that can significantly affect the profitability of the VIP nursing care unit including the cost of prevention, appraisal costs, and external failure costs. Prevention and appraisal costs have a positive correlation coefficient to increase profitability, while the external failure costs have a negative correlation coefficient, which can reduce the profitability of VIP nursing care unit significantly. Therefore, it is necessary for the Stella Maris Hospital to minimize the external failure costs through efforts in an integrated quality control and allocation of cost control (cost of prevention and appraisal costs) optimally. Although there is no significant relationship to the profitability, the internal failure cost allocation is still required to be optimized since it still has a positive correlation coefficient that can improve the profitability. 125
  • 7. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 1.916.137.155 2.500.000.000 1.656.261.512 1.558.761.626 1.423.921.850 1.414.410.674 2.000.000.000 1.200.349.037 1.500.000.000 1.000.000.000 500.000.000 - 2008 2009 2010 Cost of Quality Profitability Figure 4. Comparison of Profitability and Cost of Quality within the year of 2008-2010 4. Conclusion The prevention and appraisal costs have a positive correlation value to the profitability, which means that an increase in prevention and appraisal costs can increase the profitability of VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital. Thus, the hospital needs to improve the allocation of prevention and appraisal costs to support quality improvement of the VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital through well-managed of the budget planning of operational control. The Stella Maris Hospital needs to to suppress the internal and external failure costs by allocating the cost of control (prevention and appraisal costs) which can be used for quality control on an ongoing basis so as to increase the profitability of VIP care unit. 5. Research Limitations and Future Research This research is limited by data availability related to revenue and financial statement of the VIP nursing care unit at the Stella Maris Hospital. Therefore, the revenue was calculated using an estimation approach. Preferably, subsequent research is required using real data in order to obtain more accurate results. The calculation of external failure was used bed utilization standards instead of using the standard BOR (Bed Occupancy Rate). According to the Ministry of Health, Indonesia, the ideal number of BOR is supposed to be equal to 80%, but at a certain month the bed utilization is above 80%; consequently it will produce some extreme values in the statistical analysis that could affect the results of analysis of the relationship variables. Therefore, the standard bed untilization using BOR is the maximum standard of 100%. In the inpatient services, the standards of this magnitude can have an impact to the poor quality of service provided. Further studies can use the standard BOR by 80% as recommended by the Ministry of Health, Indonesia. References ASQC (1970), “Quality Costs – What and How”, American Society for Quality Control, pp.54 Blocher E., Stout D., and Cokins G., (2010). Cost Management: A Strategic Emphasis, McGraw Hill, Australia. Born P.H., and Simon C.J., Patients and Profits (2001): The Relationship between HMO Financial Performance and Quality of Care, Health Affairs, 20, 2, 2001. 126
  • 8. European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online) Vol 4, No.11, 2012 Campanella, Jack, et. al. (1990). Principles of Quality Costs : Principles, Implementation, and Use. 2nd ed. Milwaukee : ASQC Quality Press. Foord K.(2004), “High Tunnel Marketing and Economics”, Minnesota High Tunnel Production Manual for Commercial Growers, 2004. Hansen D.R., and Mowen M.M., (2006). Managerial Accounting, 8th Edition, Thomson Higher Education, USA. rd Juran, J.M., Gryna, F.M. and Bingham, R. (1975), Quality Control Textbook, 3 edition, McGraw-Hill, New York. Machowski, F. And Dale, B.G. (1998), “Quality Costing: An examination of knowledge, attitudes and perceptions”, Quality Management Journal, Vol.5, No.3, p.84 Norton, Kaplan. (2008). The Balanced Scorecard : Translating Strategy Into Action. United Kingdom : Harvard Business Press Purgslove, A.B. and Dale, B.G. (1995), “Developing a quality costing system: Key features and outcomes”, Omega, Vol.23, p.567 Rahmat, and Amalia., (2007). Perhitungan dan Analisa Biaya Kualitas Pada Rumah Sakit “X”. Universitas Indonesia : Jakarta Randall G and Brown S., (1999). “Prevention is better than Cure”, Crisis, UK Schiffauerova and Thomson. 2006. A review of research on cost of quality models and best practices, International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management, 2006, Vol. 23, No. 4, pp. 1-23 Shah U., (2011). Quality and Cost of Heallthcare: “An Indian Prespective an Assessment of Direct Cost of Quality Across Hospitals in India”, International Journal of Business and Management Tomorrow Vol. 1 No. 1 Sower, V.E. and Quarles R., (2003). Cost of Quality: “Why More Organization Do Not Use It Effectively”, American Society for Quality, 2003. Sower, V.E., Quarles, R., Broussard, E., (2007) “Cost of quality usage and its relationship to quality system maturity”, International Journal of Quality & Reliability management, Vol. 24, No. 2, (2007), PP. 121-140. Indrianty Sudirman. A full time lecture in strategic management and the secretary of the doctoral study program of economics at Faculty of Economics, Hasanuddin University of Makassar, as well as a part time lecturer in marketing at the University of Indonesia of Jakarta. Since 2000, the author has been actively involved in the development of teaching hospital of Hasanuddin University, and now assigned as a management consultant of the teaching hospital. The author has also been heavily involved in research and community services related to strategic management and marketing as author’s expertise as well as being a consultant in variety healthcare industries. The author is active as a member of several professional organizations such as Association of Indonesia Economics Scholars (since 1997), Indonesia Marketing Association (since 2000), Indonesia Management Scientist Association (since 2005), and Communication Forum of Indonesia Hospital Administration Master Programs. 127
  • 9. This academic article was published by The International Institute for Science, Technology and Education (IISTE). The IISTE is a pioneer in the Open Access Publishing service based in the U.S. and Europe. The aim of the institute is Accelerating Global Knowledge Sharing. More information about the publisher can be found in the IISTE’s homepage: http://www.iiste.org The IISTE is currently hosting more than 30 peer-reviewed academic journals and collaborating with academic institutions around the world. Prospective authors of IISTE journals can find the submission instruction on the following page: http://www.iiste.org/Journals/ The IISTE editorial team promises to the review and publish all the qualified submissions in a fast manner. All the journals articles are available online to the readers all over the world without financial, legal, or technical barriers other than those inseparable from gaining access to the internet itself. Printed version of the journals is also available upon request of readers and authors. IISTE Knowledge Sharing Partners EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Open Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial Library , NewJour, Google Scholar