Online auction has become a very popular e-commerce trans-action type. The immense business opportunities attract a lot of individuals as well as online stores. With more sellers engaged in, the competition between sellers is more intense. For sellers, how to maximize their pro¯t by proper auction setting becomes the critical success factor in online auction market. In this paper, we provide a selling recommendation service which can predict the expected pro¯t before listing and, based on the expected pro¯t, recommend the seller whether to use current auction setting or not. We collect data from ¯ve kinds of digital camera from eBay and ap- ply machine learning algorithm to predict sold probability and end-price. In order to get genuine sold probability and end-price prediction (even for unsold items), we apply probability calibration and sample selection bias correction when building the prediction models. To decide whether to list a commodity or not, we apply cost-sensitive analysis to decide whether to use current auction setting. We compare the pro¯ts using three di®erent approaches: probability-based, end-price based, and our expected-pro¯t based recommendation service. The experiment result shows that our recommendation service based on expected pro¯t gives higher earnings and probability is a key factor that maintains the pro¯t gain when ultra cost incurs for unsold items due to stocking.