This document discusses a new approach to library public relations and marketing focused on generating support and funding. It summarizes key findings from the OCLC report "From Awareness to Funding" which showed that increased library usage does not necessarily translate to support for increased library funding. The report recommends targeting messaging at "probable" and "super supporters" to emphasize how libraries are transformational community assets. The document then discusses how the Douglas County Libraries in Colorado has worked to implement this new approach after two failed ballot measures seeking a tax increase. It outlines four skill areas for library managers to focus on to successfully manage this new marketing trend: managing themselves, leading others, organizational awareness, and community building.
5 charts on South Africa as a source country for international student recrui...
850 Managing&Marketing Library Support Ea Walker
1. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -0-
Running Head: MANAGING $UPPORT: A NEW APPROACH TO LIBRARY PR & MARKETING
Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing
Elizabeth Aspen Walker
Emporia State University, School of Library & Information Science
Professor Chapman
November, 2008
E.A. Walker, 11/08
2. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -0-
Abstract
OCLC’s new report, From Awareness to Funding demonstrates a new trend in library PR and
marketing: U.S. public libraries need to expand their messaging to include and encourage library
support and funding. This piece looks at the marketing implications of the report; applies the
findings to four managerial categories essential to managing this trend (managing ourselves,
leading others and groups, organizational awareness/behavior, and community building and
collaboration); and provides examples of the From Awareness to Funding-inspired approach to
managing PR and marketing that is being developed at Douglas County Libraries (Colorado).
E.A. Walker, 11/08
3. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -1-
Douglas County Libraries: A Case in Point
Library use is booming at Douglas County Libraries, an independent mill-levy funded
public library district serving just under 300,000 residents in Douglas County, Colorado. 80% of
all households in Douglas County have -and regularly use- at least one library card. From 2003-
2007, library visits climbed 65%, circulation jumped 74%, and Douglas County Libraries (the
state’s fourth largest library system) checked out more children’s books than any other public
library system in Colorado (LaRue, 2008). It has become satisfyingly clear that the library
district’s efforts to increase library use by investing in public relations and marketing are paying
off in the form of well-used libraries.
This success is accompanied by a challenge: Douglas County Libraries hasn’t had a
funding increase since 1996. From the early 1990s through the early 2000s, Douglas County
consistently ranked as one of the ten fastest-growing counties in the United States (Johnston,
2005). Now property values are leveling off, new growth taxes have dried up, and revenues are
slowing. All the while, library use continues to soar. The district is not able to build large
enough libraries to meet demand in all of the county’s service areas. Simply put: the library
district’s revenues are not keeping pace with the booming demands on the library system.
In 2007, the library board determined it was time for a mill levy increase campaign.
Phone polls indicated 64% approval for a 1.5 mill increase, and library administration felt
confident that most of the 80% of library card holders in the community would vote for the
modest increase in library funding. But on Election Day, the results were distressing: the ballot
measure lost by 210 votes, or by 51% to 49%. Only 34% of the voting populace bothered to cast
a vote for or against the library initiative. After the election, many library users said they
assumed the measure would win, so they did not bother to hit the polls.
E.A. Walker, 11/08
4. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -2-
In 2008, the library district tried again with high hopes, a new and energized group of
community grassroots supporters, and an even more modest mill levy ballot proposal. Only 47%
of the voters approved, and the measure went down again.
On Election Day ‘08, Douglas County Libraries learned conclusively that library use does
not necessarily equate to a willingness to vote for increased library funding. The library district’s
marketing and public relations efforts hadn’t gone far enough. In mid-2008, a new report from
OCLC called From Awareness to Funding confirmed the lesson and established a trend in the field
of public libraries: it’s time to expand our PR and marketing efforts to include and encourage
library support and funding. So how does a manager prepare to ride this trend, make this kind of
marketing shift and ultimately, effect the public’s perception, so they are more willing to provide
financial support to their local library? This piece looks briefly at the results and
recommendations from the OCLC report that most directly impact the library PR and marketing
trend, and then applies the findings to four skills/managerial categories essential to managing
this trend: managing ourselves, leading others and groups, organizational awareness/behavior,
and community building and collaboration. The discussion will be tied into the From Awareness
to Funding-inspired approach to managing a new era of marketing and PR efforts currently
underway at Douglas County Libraries.
The OCLC Report
The entire report is a recommended read for public library managers. This paper focuses on
the parts of the report that most directly impact library marketing and PR.
From Awareness to Funding echoes some of the same themes Douglas County Libraries
encountered: public library visits and circulation are up across the United States, funding is not
keeping pace with the demand on library services, mill levy issues are failing in greater number
across the entire country, and the majority of library PR and marketing efforts have focused on
E.A. Walker, 11/08
5. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -3-
use, but not funding and financial support (DeRosa/OCLC, 2008, p. viii). The study was
conducted with the hypothesis that, “Utilizing marketing and advocacy techniques targeted to
the right community segments with the right messages and community programs, we can
improve the state of public library funding” (DeRosa/OCLC, 2008, p. viii).
The report reveals several key findings that are related to the PR and Marketing trend towards
building support:
• There is a lot people don’t know much about their public library.
• When you advocate library support to your patrons, you may be targeting the wrong
audience. Library funding support is only marginally related to library visitation.
• Targeting marketing messages to the right segments of the voting public is key to driving
increased support for U.S. public libraries. These “right” segments include Probable and
Super Supporters.
• Perceptions of librarians are an important predictor of library funding support.
• Voters who see the library as a 'transformational' force as opposed to an 'informational'
source are more likely to increase taxes in its support. People view the library as a
provider of practical answers and information. In the Google™ era, this is a crowded
space; we must reposition our brand to demonstrate our transformative potential and
remain relevant in today’s information landscape.
• Elected officials are supportive of the library, but not fully committed to increased
funding. We must engage Probable Supporters and Super Supporters to succeed.
(DeRosa/OCLC, 2008)
According to the report, we need to create a public library support brand and marketing
campaign that targets our Probable and Super Supporters, and:
• Makes the library relevant for the 21st century.
• Increases awareness about how libraries are funded, and the financial strain and
shortfalls public libraries are facing.
• Instills a sense of urgency by putting the library in the consideration for local funding
with other public services, like police, parks and fire.
• Activates a conversation about how the library is a vital part of the community’s
infrastructure and future.
• Focuses on equal access and the important truth that U.S. public libraries provide equal
access to valuable information resources for all residents.
• Promotes the shared community values that are unique to the public library structure,
including shared community assets, respect for the community, and self-reliance.
E.A. Walker, 11/08
6. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -4-
• Remembers that Super and Probable Supporters resonate with the idea that libraries
provide a “sacred place” where they can enjoy quiet, order, freedom, safety and social
bonding.
• Points out how a great library can impact the community’s stature.
• Repositions the library so the community sees us as: as a source of transformation (rather
than just information); part of the community infrastructure (rather than a traditional
institution that may not be so relevant today); a necessity (rather than “nice to have”);
about the future (instead of primarily the past); a big Return of Investment/ROI for
individuals, families and the entire community (rather than something vaguely altruistic).
(DeRosa/OCLC, 2008, pp. 1-8; 6-4 – 6-12)
So who are these Probable and Super Supporters? DeRosa and the OCLC crew found that
these key supporters are:
• Involved in the community.
• Recognize the library’s importance to recognize the library’s importance to the community
and to a child’s education.
• Are not always heavy users of the library, but believe the library is a noble place, that’s
important and relevant to the community.
• Recognize the value of a ‘passionate librarian’ as a true advocate for lifelong learning.
• See the library as a vital community resource like public schools, fire and police, and are
willing to increase their taxes to support the library. (DeRosa/OCLC, 2008, p. 7-4)
DeRosa wraps up the report by declaring, “To thrive tomorrow, libraries must translate
belief into awareness, and awareness into action” (DeRosa, 2008, p. 7-5). At Douglas County
Libraries, and public libraries across the U.S., that charge is being incorporated in strategic,
long-range planning, especially when it comes to PR and marketing. The OCLC report came out
shortly before Douglas County Libraries placed their second mill levy increase attempt on the
ballot. While the library district was able to start integrating many of the marketing and PR
messages advocated in DeRosa’s report, the report came too late for creating real change. The
library district has plans to continue their marketing efforts aimed at library use and awareness,
but it won’t end there. A new PR and marketing campaign is in the works; it will focus on
generating library support and funding, using the report’s messaging suggestions. Highlights
include a “library stories” campaign that showcases the transformative benefits of the public
E.A. Walker, 11/08
7. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -5-
library, and the continued effort to find and build an informed, passionate and vocal base of
library supporters who will share their transformative library stories, and promote the importance
of the library and increased funding throughout Douglas County. There’s a big lesson here: library
funding campaigns cannot begin a few short months before Election Day any more. We need to
be campaigning all the time.
How? Library managers can lead change and ride this PR and marketing trend, and begin
to capitalize on the findings of From Awareness to Funding by focusing on four important
managerial skills or categories: managing ourselves, leading others and groups, organizational
awareness/behavior, and community building and collaboration. A resource guide is provided at
the end of this piece; it provides a list of the many titles and resources I have personally found
to be of help. The guide also matches the four managerial categories with a broader list of skills
and concerns related to managing this trend.
Managing Ourselves
The three other management skills rely on the first: our ability to skillfully manage
ourselves. After all, how can we hope to make strides with and lead others, the organizations we
administer, and our community, if we don’t have a handle on the one thing any one individual
can directly manage: ourselves? We must ascertain that we are personally prepared to respond to
the kind of library PR and marketing changes revealed and advocated in From Awareness to
Funding. This will require a good look in the mirror; self inventory, and a dedicated practice of
lifelong, self-directed learning. While we may have completed our formal schooling, the learning
cannot end there. Goleman and Boyatzis’ groundbreaking work in emotional intelligence and
leadership offers a roadmap to this process of lifelong learning (see Appendix I).
Boyatzis reminds us to assess our strengths and weaknesses. Rath’s Strengths Finders 2.0
and Olson and Singer’s work in assessing leadership skills and practices and the SWOT (Strengths,
E.A. Walker, 11/08
8. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -6-
Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats) technique would provide a good starting point. Similarly,
Boyatzis reminds us that we need to develop trusting relationships in order to gain the benefit
of advice, support and feedback. Managers should seek out a support system of trusted
colleagues, opinionated library staff/patrons/supporters, and possibly a mentor.
After assessing our personal strengths and weaknesses, we should make sure we have the
tools we need to manage and lead the change we are trying to achieve with others, throughout
our organization, and in our community. Goleman’s Primal Leadership: Learning to Lead with
Emotional Intelligence provides many tools for the manager who needs to carry forth the vision of
the new marketing plan and make sure all the pieces fall into place. The book also takes a long
look at the personal/self-oriented competencies of emotionally-intelligent leadership (self-
awareness and self-management), and preps managers in the art of coaching employees and
community members throughout the process of rallying support. Likewise, managers should check
out Kotter’s Leading Change; the book provides a clever and concise approach to planning for,
communicating about, and implementing change.
Our focus on lifelong, self-directed learning in regards to the self-management skill and
the support marketing trend requires an in-depth reading regimen. Managers must become
thoroughly acquainted with the OCLC report and the associated “Turning the Page” resources
produced by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. They will also need to take a good look at
the ever-growing body of work about library marketing. Similarly, managers should keep an eye
on other library’s support marketing campaigns, and borrow their successful ideas. Our gaze
should not fall on libraries alone. Managers, in their effort to bolster their strengths and skills,
should research outside of the library literature and look at the marketing field itself, monitor
trend-watching sites, and learn more about the art of formal and grassroots campaigning.
E.A. Walker, 11/08
9. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -7-
The manager should also make sure they are personally knowledgeable about their
library’s growth statistics and financing, or in close cahoots with someone who is. They should
keep tabs on what’s happening at libraries across the country; these numbers can be used in the
messaging. Additionally, the manager should seek out information about the library’s return on
investment (ROI); the Library Research Service provides free access to this kind of information.
Because our new marketing messages and brand need to convey the transformative
qualities of libraries, while engaging community supporters, library managers should draw on
what many librarians already do really well: storytelling, statistical tracking, repackaging
information for specific audiences, education, public speaking and community networking and
building. In addition to the county-wide storytelling campaign and community supporter
development project, Douglas County Libraries is taking note of the OCLC report’s
recommendations to incorporate community ROI in its messaging. In its initial stages, this
project includes a personal ROI calculator on the district’s website that demonstrates how much
you can save by using the library (Douglas County Libraries, 2008)
Leading Others and Groups
The library manager working on this PR and marketing support trend will have ample
opportunity to test their skills in managing and leading others and groups. There’s much work to
do at a group level, including community analysis, developing marketing plans, communication
of the vision and plan, and coaching folks through the sometimes scary challenges of changing
business as we know it. The biggest challenge may well be getting the entire staff on board for
this wide-ranging project. In order for this new approach to marketing to work, the entire staff
will need to be a part of the marketing campaign, not just the department of community
relations/public relations/communications. We must remember that a big part of the OCLC
report’s message revolves around the community seeing our librarians (remember that “librarian”
E.A. Walker, 11/08
10. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -8-
means any library staffer for most folks) as passionate good Samaritans who make a difference in
the community. A few posters or press releases will not cut it, the community needs to see the
staff transforming lives, and hear them discussing the library’s services and challenges. The wise
manager will apply Kotter’s eight stage process of creating major change, as well as Goleman’s
emotionally-intelligent social competencies, so the OCLC findings and new marketing plan can
take root throughout the organization.
In addition to acquiring the personal skills in change management and honing one’s
social competencies as discussed above, the manager should anticipate the need for group
facilitation, team building, and training. The manager will be required to work with groups
throughout this process; skills in facilitating and navigating group conversations will come in
handy. Kotter reminds us of the importance of team-building; the manager will want to make
sure they put together and nourish the right team as they forge ahead with their marketing
campaign. Rath’s Strengths Finder 2.0 may be of use when it comes to putting strong and diverse
teams that encompass many congruous skills and strengths.
Because this trend requires all-staff participation, staff throughout the organization will
require training in some of the same issues the manager addressed when they looked at
managing themselves: an education in the report findings, the library district’s challenges, and
ROI; public speaking and storytelling skills; and networking and community building. If the staff
is well-trained, the entire organization will be better-prepared to address our trend.
Organizational Development
The previous category is intimately tied to our next managerial skill: organizational
development. Just as we learned that all staff will need to be involved in our library marketing
trend and plan, we need to ensure our organizations are ready for, and compatible with, the
change we are trying to create. Is our mission on target? Are things set up so the organization
E.A. Walker, 11/08
11. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing -9-
can accommodate the needed change? Are our libraries poised to demonstrate we are relevant in
the 21st century, and that we truly are a transformative force in our communities that deserves
support and funding? Managers looking to ride the library support marketing trend should make
certain they are well-versed in organizational development and theory. After our second mill levy
loss in as many years, Douglas County Libraries has recognized the need for the “ongoing
campaign” that includes a support-based marketing plan, as well as organizationally-minded
plans to revisit the district’s mission, vision, strategic and long range planning, work plans,
budgeting, services, training, benchmarking, staffing and more. In other words, we’ve learned
that this trend towards building library support needs to happen throughout the organization,
which means it’s time to take a good look at the organization itself.
In terms of marketing and PR, there’s another thing managers can do at the
organizational level: keep track of and use all the tools and locations that can be used for
unified support messaging across your entire organization (see Appendix II). This could include
newsletters and calendars, online mediums, the bottoms of your checkout receipts,
announcements at storytime, posters in the bathroom stalls… your list will be lengthy if you
take the time to think of your entire organization, and ask other staffers about their ideas.
Community Building and Collaboration
Given the community focus in the OCLC report, community building and collaboration is
an important managerial skill to harness. As we prepare to ride this marketing and PR trend
towards support, we must be primed to find Super and Probable Supporters in our community,
and build a community that believes in the necessity of libraries. In addition to the new phase
of marketing, and the organizational improvement, Douglas County Libraries numbers community
building and collaboration in its toolkit of long-term campaign strategy. The district will
continue to make a place for itself at the community table by participating in a county-wide
E.A. Walker, 11/08
12. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing - 10 -
partnership of governments, sending librarians out of the building to answer “the community
reference question” (LaRue, 2007, p. 93) and increase awareness about the library district’s
services and financial struggles, and the ongoing creation of a base of community library
supporters who want to help us increase funding. In this case, relationship management, long of
interest to library Foundations and Friends groups, will be an important aspect of the community
management skill.
Conclusions
S.R. Ranganathan, the famed philosopher of librarianship, famously wrote, “Libraries are
a growing organism” (Ranganathan, 1957). His comparison is apt- libraries and library
management are complex undertakings, requiring our ability to see the big picture, while still
remembering all of the details. Management necessitates the understanding that all aspects of
our organizations are interconnected and ever-changing. Marketing and PR (and our ability to
drum up financial support) are impacted by and thoroughly connected to public finance, HR,
facilities, customer service, policy, and more. Similarly, our identified management skills all
hinge on one other- you’re going to have trouble rallying your community if you can’t make
headway with the staff, the organization, or yourself. The OCLC report and spate of failed library
mill levies and slashed library budgets across the nation should also remind us of the
fundamental fact that our library “organisms” require financial support in order to flourish. In
order ride this trend, we must take a passionate, thoughtful and diligent role in leading
ourselves, others, the organization, and the community through the changes recommended by
the From Awareness to Funding report.
E.A. Walker, 11/08
13. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing - 11 -
References
De Rosa, C., & Johnson, J. (2008). From awareness to funding: A study of library support in
America : a report to the OCLC membership. Dublin, Ohio: OCLC.
Douglas County Libraries (2008). Library Return on Investment Calculator. Retrieved November
13, 2008, from DouglasCountyLibraries.org Web site:
http://www.douglascountylibraries.org/AboutUs/LibraryValue
Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R. E., & McKee, A. (2002). Primal leadership: Realizing the power of
emotional intelligence. Boston, Mass: Harvard Business School Press.
Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change. Boston, Mass: Harvard Business School Press.
Johnston, G. (2005). www.CREDCO.org. Retrieved November 10, 2008, from the Castle Rock
Economic Development Council Web site:
http://www.credco.org/news/RMNewsDouglasGrowing.pdf
LaRue, J. (2007). The new inquisition: Understanding and managing intellectual freedom
challenges. Westport, Conn: Libraries Unlimited.
LaRue, J. (2008). Does Success Justify Funding?. Retrieved November 10, 2008, from Palin.net
Web site: http://pln.palinet.org/wiki/index.php/Does_success_justify_funding%3F
Olson, C., & Singer, P. (2004). Winning with Library Leadership. Chicago: American Library
Association.
Ranganathan, S. R. (1957). The five laws of library science. Madras: library association.
Rath, T., (2007). Strengthsfinder 2.0. New York: Gallup Press.
E.A. Walker, 11/08
14. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing - 12 -
Appendix I
E.A. Walker, 11/08
15. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing - 13 -
Appendix II
E.A. Walker, 11/08
16. Managing $upport: A New Approach to Library PR & Marketing - 14 -
R E S O U R C E G U IID E ::
RE S O U R C E GU I D E
ESOURCE U DE
A S P E N ’’S A P P R O A C H TTO M A N A G IIN G TTH E $ U P P O R TT M A R K E TTIIN G T R E N D
AS P E N S AP P R O A C H T O MA N A G I N G T H E $U P P O R T MA R K E T I N G TR E N D
SPEN S PPROACH O ANAG NG HE UPPOR ARKE NG REND
Getting to Know From Awareness to Funding ourselves others organization community
The OCLC From Awareness to Funding report, http://www.oclc.org/reports/funding/default.htm
Turning the Page: Building Your Library Community, http://www.SustainingLibraries.org
The PALINET Leadership Network’s From Awareness to Funding wiki,
http://pln.palinet.org/wiki/index.php/From_awareness_to_funding
Management & Leadership ourselves others organization community
Kotter’s Leading Change, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/34658795&referer=brief_results
Goleman’s Primal Leadership, http://www.worldcat.org/search?q=primal+leadership&=Search&qt=owc_search
Rath’s Strengths Finder 2.0, https://www.strengthsfinder.com/
Olson & Singer’s Winning with Library Leadership, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/55019204&referer=brief_results
Mentoring ourselves others
WorldCat results, http://www.worldcat.org/search?qt=worldcat_org_all&q=mentoring
Library Marketing & PR ourselves
Libraries Prosper with Passion, Purpose and Persuasion! A PLA Toolkit for Success,
http://www.alastore.ala.org/SiteSolution.taf?_sn=catalog2&_pn=product_detail&_op=2403
The M Word library marketing blog, http://themwordblog.blogspot.com/
First Impressions Last: Simple Branding & PR Tips for Libraries blog, http://firstimpressionslast.blogspot.com/
New Jersey State’s Library Story Marketing campaign, http://www.solvinglifesproblems.org/
Marketing ourselves
Seth Godin’s blog, http://sethgodin.typepad.com/
American Marketing Association/Journal of Marketing,
http://www.marketingpower.com/AboutAMA/Pages/AMA%20Publications/AMA%20Journals/Journal%20of%20Marketing
/JournalofMarketing.aspx
Trendwatching ourselves
http://trendwatching.com/
Williams Inference Anomaly Tracking, http://www.williamsinference.com/
World Futurist Society, http://www.wfs.org/
Campaign Strategy ourselves
Larry Tramutola’s Sidewalk Strategies, http://www.tramutola.com/
Return on Investment ourselves others organization community
Library Research Service, Return on Investment for Public Libraries, http://www.lrs.org/public/roi/
Storytelling & Public Speaking ourselves others community
Annette Simmons’ The Story Factor, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/45669330&referer=brief_results
Ron Hoff’s Say it in Six, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/33281636&referer=brief_results
Public Speaking Study and Strategy Guide, http://www.studygs.net/speaking.htm
Meeting Facilitation others
Schwarz’s The Skilled Facilitator: Practical Wisdom For Developing Effective Groups, http://www.schwarzassociates.com/
Organizational Awareness and Development organization
Hatch’s Organization Theory, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/36585836&referer=brief_results
Senge’s The Fifth Discipline, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/21226996&referer=brief_results
Organization Development in Libraries, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/200869043&referer=brief_results
Community Building community
Robert Putnam’s Bowling Alone and Better Together: Restoring the American Community,
http://www.worldcat.org/search?q=au%3ARobert+D+Putnam&qt=hot_author
Kathleen de la Peña McCook’s A Place at the Table : Participating in Community Building,
http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/43884461&referer=brief_results
ICMA’s Libraries: Partners in Sustaining Community,
http://icma.org/pm/9002/public/feature2.cfm?author=Beth%20Pollard&title=Libraries%3A%20Partners%20in%20Sustai
ning%20Communities
ICMA’s Local Government Managers and Public Libraries: Partners for A Better Community,
http://icma.org/documents/Final_Mgmt_Prsptv_Libraries_(gates).pdf
Relationship Management community
Baran’s Relationship Management, http://www.worldcat.org/oclc/126862776&referer=brief_results
E.A. Walker, 11/08