SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 90
Download to read offline
Seminar No. 4
Master Class in English Law
Jeremy Lederman
Julian Mathews
Edward Craft
Wedlake Bell LLP
7 June 2013
#7646576
About Wedlake Bell LLP
• Long-established mid market law firm
• Operating from central London
• Full service
• UK and international work
• Founding member of Telfa
Structure of the morning
Fundamentals of English Law – Jeremy Lederman
How to structure a joint venture agreement in the context of a hotel
joint venture - Julian Mathews
An initial public offering of securities in London – Edward Craft
TELFA CONFERENCE AND GLOBAL LAW
FORUM IN CONJUNCTION WITH USLAW
MOSCOW
7 June 2013 – 9:30am to 12 noon
Jeremy Lederman
Wedlake Bell LLP
London
Fundamentals of English Law
Jeremy is head of commercial litigation at Wedlake Bell.
Jeremy acts and advises on a wide range of international and
UK litigation, arbitration, mediation and alternative dispute
resolution. His work includes acting for creditors and lenders
regarding debt recovery, contractual disputes, disputes arising
from mergers and acquisitions, shareholders and partnership
disputes, professional negligence, fraud, insolvency, IT
disputes, regulatory matters and judicial review, charity
disputes and aviation. Jeremy represents listed multinationals,
national and other businesses of all sizes, religious institutions,
charities and individuals.
Jeremy has substantial experience of litigation involving an
international element. He has recently been acting in
multinational litigation brought by a Russian bank against a
guarantor with a freezing order against assets worldwide.
Jeremy Lederman
jlederman@wedlakebell.com 0044
20 67674 0530
Your speaker
1. Scope of Presentation
2. Sources of English Law and court system
3. Key forms of legal personality
4. Law of Contract
5. Law of Trusts
1. Scope of Presentation
• Large subject in little time
• Necessarily brief summaries
• English law only
• Focus on civil claims and in particular :-
• Sources of English Law and court system
• Key forms of legal personality
• Law of Contract
• Law of Trusts
1. Sources of English law
• Statutes – Specific laws
• European Union
• Regulations
• Directives
• UK statutes and other legislation
2. Sources of English law continued
Case Precedents
• Judge made law "the common law “.
• System of precedent by which Judges follow decisions
in past cases.
• As at 2007 estimated over 1000 volumes of law reports
containing approximately 400,000 cases. Will have
increased significantly since then.
2. Sources of English law continued
• Court of Justice of European Union provides
interpretation of EU treaties and legislation which bind
all courts below (but not itself).
• Supreme Court (formerly the House of Lords -judicial
committee) binds lower courts but not itself.
• Court of Appeal binds lower courts and itself.
• High Court binds lower courts (County and Magistrates
courts) but not itself.
2. Sources of English law continued
• Specialist Courts (for example Chancery, Commercial,
Technology and Construction - 60% of cases in
Commercial Courts have Russian element).
• In certain cases Judges can find ways around
precedents from previous cases but it is not usual to
do so.
• Custom.
• Reports of Law Commission or authoritative articles or
text books may be persuasive.
3. Key forms of legal personality
Natural person - i.e. an individual
Companies
Separate legal personality from shareholders/members or those who control it
and continues to exist regardless of what happens to them.
Main statute Companies Act 2006 largely consolidation but new provisions as
well.
Main types :-
• Companies limited by shares
• Companies limited by guarantee
• Unlimited companies
3. Key forms of legal personality continued
Unincorporated Associations
Partnerships
• Definition - a relationship between two or more persons carrying on
business in common with a view to making a profit.
• No separate legal personality and all partners liable for all debts save as
agreed.
Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs)
• Came into force in 2000. Kind of hybrid of partnerships and limited
companies except much more in common with limited company. No
shareholders, directors or shares, but do have members.
• Separate legal personality.
3. Key forms of legal personality continued
• LLPs very popular with professionals who could not incorporate also as
vehicles for holding real estate. It has been said they offer more
flexibility than limited companies.
• Whilst LLPs have been very popular they not widely understood and we
are experiencing the first few cases on what happens when things go
wrong.
Trusts
• Entities that operate through trustees (see later). No minimum number
but need two to hold real estate.
4. Contract law
Clearest definition :-
"An agreement between two or more parties intended to have legally
enforceable consequences" .
Key requirements for a valid contract :-
a) there is an offer by one party.
b) the offer is accepted by the other(s).
c) the parties intend to create a legal relationship (intention to create legal
relations).
d) there is consideration, i.e. a price is paid for the performance of the
contract.
e) where required, formalities are complied with.
f) the parties have legal capacity to enter into the contract.
g) the wish to enter into the contract is genuine i.e. there has been no
mistake, fraud or duress.
h) the purpose of the contract is legal.
a) Offer
An offer can be verbal, in writing or by conduct.
Example of making offer by conduct would be taking goods from shelf in a
supermarket to a cashier and asking to pay.
An offer ends :-
- when it is not accepted within the time specified or within a reasonable
time (more arguable).
- it is withdrawn before acceptance.
- it is rejected by the person to whom the offer was made ("the offeree").
Rejection can be a simple rejection or by making of a counter offer or setting a
condition.
b) Acceptance
Can be written, oral or by conduct.
If a method of acceptance is stipulated one should follow that.
Must be complete, unqualified and unconditional.
Offer or acceptance "Subject to contract" or Subject to Formal Agreement"
means the parties are not bound until a formal contract is entered into. Such
wording is often used at the beginning of a transaction where the parties want to
put forward an offer but it is intended a fuller agreement is entered into.
Tenders
An invitation to tender is for parties to offer to supply goods or services on
specific terms. A party who submits a tender is making the offer and once
accepted a contract is formed.
c) Intention to create legal relations
Not always easy to ascertain.
Not usually for social or domestic purposes, for example an offer to take
someone out to dinner would not normally be viewed as intending to create a
contract.
In a commercial and business context it will be assumed there is an intention to
create legal relations unless it can be shown otherwise for example by use of the
wording subject to contract or other wording.
d) Consideration
Any benefit or detriment. Money or foregoing an opportunity.
Must be :-
- Real
- Legal
- Possible
It need not be a good bargain.
Usually consideration cannot be in the past, except for bills of exchange and in
some circumstances for services provided in the past.
Another exception to the need for consideration is where a party has in reliance
on the promise of a person acted to their detriment, known as promissory
estoppel.
e) Formalities
Many contracts do not have to be in writing. People put them in writing
because:
i) There are some types of contracts that must be in writing to be valid or
enforceable; or
ii) it is easier to prove the terms rather than rely on parties' memories of
what was said and done.
Culture of English courts is to give greater weight to documents than oral
accounts . Documents do not have memories that can fade or be mistaken.
Contracts with specific formalities :-
Contracts that must be signed and made by deed (a special type of contract) :-
- certain real estate transactions.
- contracts where there is no payment or consideration e.g. a gift.
- transfers of British ships or shares in them.
e) Formalities continued
Certain contracts must be in writing for example :-
- transfer of shares in a UK company
- bills of exchange, cheques and promissory notes
- assignment of copyright
- marine insurance
Certain contracts must have written evidence they have been made (by a note or
otherwise) examples of which are :-
- guarantees (Statute of Frauds 1677)
- contracts for sale of land
- contracts of employment
To avoid any difficulty those contracts are usually made in writing.
f) Capacity to enter into contracts
The parties must have capacity to enter into a contract.
Contracts with those under the age of 18 or insane or drunk/intoxicated might be
unenforceable.
In large contracts with corporate bodies it is worth checking that there is proper
authority to enter into the contracts.
Terms of a Contract
The terms set out the parties rights and obligations
Two types of terms
• Express
• Implied
Terms of a Contract continued
Express terms
Terms that are set out in the contract.
If the terms are not certain the contract will not be enforceable. So generally one
cannot have a contract to enter into another contract ("an agreement to agree").
This is different from at least some US jurisdictions.
The contract must have terms which if not certain, must be capable of being
ascertained without further agreement of the parties. In a number of
agreements there is a mechanism or procedure by which the terms become
definite for example a valuer, expert or arbitrator makes a decision which binds
the parties.
Terms of a Contract continued
Implied terms
Parties are free to agree whatever they wish (save for example illegal matters)
In some cases the court may imply terms into a contract :-
- to give the contract business efficacy (to achieve the purpose of the
contract)
- example - where anticipated that use of port facilities would be
provided but they could not and party making offer had not checked
they could be
- to reflect custom of a particular geographical area or trade
- on grounds of public policy e.g. sale of goods for example that goods
are of satisfactory quality
Terms of a Contract continued
Clauses limiting or excluding liability
Parties free to include such clauses in contracts but this is subject to public policy.
For example clauses excluding or limiting liability for death and personal injury
and as regards consumers are heavily restricted.
Note where dealing on a party's standard terms they might be challenged as not
being "reasonable" (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977).
Must do all that is reasonably necessary to bring such clauses to attention of
other party. If in signed agreement likely to satisfy this test.
Clauses will need to be clear and will be interpreted against the party seeking to
rely on exclusion or limitation of liability.
Terms of a Contract continued
Further distinction between two types of terms - conditions and warranties.
Condition - a term that is so important to the contract that if breached, the other
party can treat the contract as at an end. The innocent party does not then have
to do anything further under the contract.
Example sale of a car - the car does not work at all or is not provided by the
seller - clearly that is a condition and the purchaser is entitled to treat contract
at end.
Warranty - a term that is not central to the to the main purpose of the contract.
Breach of warranty only entitles the other party to damages and he cannot treat
the contract as at an end.
Example the sale of the car - there is a small fault in the paintwork of a car or the
wrong kind of music system is installed. Buyer is entitled to damages only and
the contract continues. The damages would be the difference between what the
buyer intended and what was received. Thus hard to calculate for smaller faults.
g) Genuine consent to enter into a contract.
A requirement for a valid contract.
A contract can be attacked on grounds of :-
- Mistake
- Misrepresentation
- Duress
- Undue influence
- Illegality
Mistake
Where nature of contract is not what was intended, including identity of parties,
terms, and subject matter.
One asks the Court to either correct the contract or treat it as unenforceable.
General rule, mistake as to quality does not affect validity of contract. Example
sale of a piece of land by me to you for £1million. If I did not know that land was
in fact worth £20 million because of development potential, the contract is still
binding.
Misrepresentation
A material false statement of fact that induces the other party to enter into the
contract.
Example - on sale of residential land, when the seller was asked whether he had
notice of any applications to develop neighbouring land and he answered “no”
when he did. Buyer relied on that and refused to perform contract when found
out true position.
Misrepresentation must be made by party or his agent.
Innocent party must have relied on the representation.
Statement can be made dishonestly or negligently.
Remedies are damages and/or rescission (cancellation) of the contract.
General rule that silence does not amount to a misrepresentation. A key
exception to that rule is contracts of utmost good faith where failure to disclose
material facts whether asked for them or not, give other party option to treat the
contract as void.
Example - contracts of insurance - although steps started to limit this rule as
regards individual consumers.
Duress
Duress means violence or threatened violence or imprisonment - unusual.
Undue influence
Where influence is applied preventing a party from making an independent
judgment for example where special relationship, for example husband and wife
or lawyer and client or an elderly or otherwise vulnerable person.
Illegality
Where the purpose of the contract is in breach of the civil or criminal law.
Examples
• Bribery and corruption.
• Penalties.
• Contracts in restraint of trade and restrictive covenants following sale of
business or following termination of employment needing to be
reasonable.
Remedies
Refusing to perform the contract.
Damages to restore claimant to position would have been if contract had been
performed.
Claim for quantum meruit ( reasonable fee for work done).
Order for performance of contract (injunction for specific performance).
Privity of contract
General rule has been that only parties to a contract can sue on it.
However since the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 a contract can
impose an obligation on someone who is not party to a contract (a non- party)
and give a benefit to a non-party. In both cases the non-party can sue/be sued.
This is frequently excluded in agreements but could be potentially useful.
Example Collateral Warranties for non parties to contracts in construction still
sought by lenders.
There are other exceptions to the general rule of privity of contract including :-
• Actions by beneficiaries under trusts.
• Certain insurance contracts to confer benefit on non-parties (eg motor
insurance).
• Negotiable instruments e.g. cheques/ bills of exchange.
• Where a contract has been assigned or novated.
Assignments (transfers) and novation
Rights under a contract can normally be assigned unless where personal service
is essential to a performance and then consent of the other party will be
required.
Liabilities under a contract can only be assigned with agreement of the other
party. So this means that will often be a new contract with transferee who takes
over the liabilities – a novation agreement.
Notice of assignment should be given in writing. If not there are risks :-
- that defences relating to the party transferring can be raised;
- of loss of priority over a later transferee who was not aware of the earlier
assignment.
5. Trusts
Extremely brief review
Concepts of trusts and beneficial ownership are in the process of development in
Russian law.
A party ("the trustee") holds assets for the benefit of some other party or parties
("the beneficiaries") or other lawful purpose, so that the benefit of the asset is
for the beneficiaries or object of the trust.
Two kinds of owner. The Trustee is the legal owner and holds the property in
their name. The beneficiary is equitable or beneficial owner.
The settlor is the person providing the assets which are to be held on trust.
Several categories of trusts :-
- Express
- Implied
- Constructive
Express Trusts
Where terms of the trust expressly set out
Can be written or oral
Requirements :-
• Certainty of intention - must be clear there is to be a trust.
• Certainty of subject matter – both assets and how to be held.
• Certainty of object of the trust – i.e. can the beneficiaries be ascertained.
Implied Trusts
The Court will imply a trust in certain situations based on the intention of the
Settlor. For example if the trusts are void or there is a defect the trustees will
hold the assets on (resulting) trust for the settlor.
Constructive Trusts
The Court will impose a trust without taking account of the parties' intentions.
For example if in breach of the trust, the Trustee (T) transfers assets to another
party (X) who is aware of the breach of trust. X holds the assets on constructive
trust for the proper beneficiary (B).
Following on from this a claim could be made for the assets themselves directly
against X. This has advantages in certain insolvency situations so as to claim that
the assets do not form part of X's assets. Further B could also take advantage of
any increase in value of the assets.
© Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved.
This document is for general information only and does not seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of the law. Specific advice should
always be sought for individual cases. This reflects the law as at June 2013.
Thank you for your attention
Any Questions?
How to structure a joint venture agreement in
the context of a hotel joint venture
Julian Mathews – Wedlake Bell LLP
7 June 2013
Your Speaker
Julian is a corporate lawyer who specialises in
private company M&A, private equity and joint
ventures. He has a particular focus on the hotel and
hospitality sector, as well as extensive experience in
acting on corporate real estate transactions.
Julian has acted for both mid-market private equity
institutions and also for management teams. He has
also acted on various cross border joint venture
transactions for real estate institutions and real
estate private equity firms.
Julian leads the hospitality and leisure sector at
Wedlake Bell and has in the past lectured on the
legal process of private equity transactions at the
executive MBA class of London Business School.
.
Julian Mathews
jmathews@wedlakebell.com
0044 20 7395 3174
To Cover
1. Introduction
2. Discussion on nature of the JV entity
3. Touch on tax
4. The operative documents
5. Discussion of the structure of a hotel JV
6. Questions
Introduction
1. Context of presentation
a) Focus is on UK law implications for joint ventures
b) Context of deal is a hotel acquisition
2. Assumptions
a) Assumes a general understanding of JV’s
b) Assumes little understanding of hotel transactions
3. Local or cross border
a) Well, let’s cover both
4. Hotel specific factors
Basic Principles – Why a joint venture?
• Varies, and depends on the circumstances of
the parties and the subject of the business.
But can be due to:
• Sharing costs?
• Pooling of expertise?
• Cross border penetration?
• Main point is to ensure 1 + 1 = 3
Preliminary thoughts on structuring – nature of JV
vehicle
• Likely to be determined by:
• Nature and size of the subject business
• Identity and location of the proposed JV parties
• Commercial and financial objectives of the proposed JV parties
• Tax considerations
• Funding
• Extraction of profits
• Potential structures for the JV vehicle are:
• Limited liability company
• Limited liability partnership (LLP)
• A partnership or limited partnership
• A contractual arrangement with no JV vehicle
Limited liability company
• Generally, for most business joint ventures, a limited liability
company is most appropriate.
• In the UK, that company will be incorporated under the
provisions of the Companies Act 2006.
• As a separate legal entity, a JVCo can:
– Own and deal in its own assets
– Contract in its own right
– Sue and be sued in its own right
• Benefits from a participant’s perspective include:
– Veil of incorporation
– Limitation of liability
Limited liability company
• But note:
• Requirement to file accounts
• Duties of directors, especially conflicts of interest (s.175 of the
Companies Act 2006)
• Accounting issues – is it deemed a subsidiary under:
• The Companies Act 2006 provisions?
• IAS 28 and 31 – significant control?
Limited liability partnership (LLP)
• An LLP formed under Limited Liability Partnerships Act 2000 can
most be applicable for ventures between individuals such as
professional partnerships.
• An LLP is a body corporate with legal personality separate from its
members.
• An LLP:
• Must publish accounts like a limited liability company
• Have at least two members
• Is generally taxed as a partnership despite being a
separate legal entity
• But note:
• No transferable shareholding
• Each member is an agent of the LLP
A partnership or limited partnership
• If a separate legal entity is not chosen, then distinction under
UK law is whether the vehicle is a “legal partnership” or not.
• If a partnership, then the Partnership Act 1890 applies.
• S.1 of Partnership Act 1890 defines a partnership as the
“relationship which subsists between persons carrying on a
business in common with a view of profit” – see s. 2 for rules
of determination.
• Characteristics of a partnership under the Act:
– Each partner deemed to be the agent of the other partners.
– As such, each partner jointly liable without limit for
debts and obligations of the partnership.
– Further, each partner jointly and severally
liable for wrongful acts and omissions of his
co-partners.
A partnership or limited partnership
• Also possible to form a limited partnership under the Limited
Partnerships Act 1907.
• At least one member must be a general partner with
unlimited liability, but the GP can be a company.
• Note that limited partners cannot participate in the
management of the partnership without losing the right to
limited liability.
• Consequently limited partnerships most suitable for a
business where the majority of participants are
passive investors, such as a private equity fund.
A contractual arrangement with no JV vehicle
• Generally where parties agree to operate as independent
contractors in their own right, rather than shareholders or partners.
• The form of the agreement often known as a consortium or co-
operation agreement.
• Note:
• Each party will not have a statutory responsibility for:
• the liabilities and obligations of the venture
• The acts or omissions of the other parties
• But each party has potentially unlimited liability for:
• own actions
• Other parties, if expressly assumed
responsibility or deemed to be vicariously
liable under the agreement.
Tax Considerations
• s
Overview of key documents
• Main documents for a corporate JVCo are:
• joint venture or shareholders agreement
• Articles of association of the joint venture
• Ancillary documents may include:
• An asset or business purchase agreement
• A management agreement
• Loan note instrument
• Service or secondment agreements
• Licence agreements such as for IPR
• For an LLP or LP, then the partnership agreement
will be the main operative document.
Joint venture agreement
• The purpose of the JV agreement is to establish:
• Rights and obligations of the parties
• To establish the corporate entity
• To provide how the JVCo will be operated
• To provide what happens if there are difficulties
• To provide methodology for exit, or termination, once venture aims
achieved.
•
JVCo articles of association
General Structure of a basic Corporate JV for a hotel
venture
JVCo
Party A
(Land/Hotel Owner
Party B
(Operator)
Hotel
(Hotel HoldCo?)
JV Agreement
Loan
Agreement
(Loan
Agreement?)
Sale
Agreement
Management Agreement
Hotel Brand Co?Franchise Agreement
Thank you for your attention
Any Questions?
© Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved.
This document is for general information only and does not seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of the law. Specific advice
should always be sought for individual cases. This reflects the law as at June 2013.
Julian Mathews
jmathews@wedlakebell.com
0044 20 7395 3174
How to structure a joint venture agreement in the
context of a hotel joint venture
Julian Mathews – Wedlake Bell LLP
7 June 2013
An initial public offering of securities in London
Edward Craft – Wedlake Bell LLP
7 June 2013
#7613951
Your Speaker
Edward is a specialist in corporate governance for
both private and public companies. Edward had
advised on many debt and equity capital markets
transactions.
Edward is Chairman of the Corporate Governance
Expert Group of the Quoted Companies Alliance,
the independent membership organisation that
champions the interests of small to mid-size quoted
companies.
Edward has recently been responsible for the new
Corporate Governance Code for Small and Mid-Size
Quoted Companies.
Edward is a member of the corporate governance
group of European Issuers.
Edward Craft
ecraft@wedlakebell.com
0044 20 7395 3099
Outline
1. IPO Options and the London Markets
2. Preparing for IPO
3. Documentation
4. Fundraising
5. Corporate Governance
6. On-going Obligations
1. IPO Options and the London Markets
• Why issue securities to the public at all?
• Decision to IPO is one of the most important a
board can ever make
• Admission to trading distinct from Listing
• Presumption that the securities being offered are
ordinary shares or depositary interests/receipts
– Can also have other securities listed/admitted to
trading, including:
• Non-voting ordinary shares
• Preference shares
• Debt securities
Depositary Interests
• A security in its own right
• Need to have appointed a depositary (and possibly a
custodian)
• Depositary/custodian regulated under UK financial
services legislation
• capable of electronic settlement through CREST
• Additional documentation:
– Trust Deed
– Depositary Agreement
– Legal Opinions
The London markets
Officially Listed Securities (UK Listing
Authority as the EU Authority)
Other traded securities
Growth Market
Premium Listing -
super equivalent
Main Board
Standard Listing –
ESMA compliant
Equity Capital Markets: the global context
The Rules
Rule Responsibility
Listing Rules EU with FCA as UKLA
DTRs under Transparency Directive EU with FCA as UKLA
AIM Rules London Stock Exchange
High Growth Segment Rules London Stock Exchange
ISDX Growth Market Rules ICAP Securities and Derivatives Exchange
Company Law EU and UK parliament
Securities Law EU and UK parliament
UK Corporate Governance Code Financial Reporting Council
Stewardship Code Financial Reporting Council
Corporate Governance Code for Small and Mid-
Size Quoted Companies
Quoted Companies Alliance
Takeover Code Panel on Take-Overs and Mergers/UK
parliament
Prospectus Directive EU
Market Abuse Directive EU
MiFID/MiFID II EU
2. Preparing for IPO
Q: Why move to a public market at all?
liquidity/
extended base
of shareholders
trading/kudos/
staff incentives/
stock for acq.fin.
exit/
valuation
to raise funds for
growth
businesses
Internal Matters
Directors –
executive and
NEDs
Structure
Board
Independence
Independence: directors
• Independence from both the issuer and major shareholders
• Independence criteria set out in provision B.1.1 of the UK Code
• Independence in character and judgement, as well as circumstances or
relationships
• Risk of impairing (or appearing to impair) the judgement of the director
• Where independence likely to be compromised:
– former employee
– material business relationship with the issuer, whether direct or indirect
– receives additional remuneration from the issuer apart from a director’s fee
– participates in the issuer’s share option or a performance-related pay scheme,
or is a member of the issuer’s pension scheme
– close familial ties with any of the issuer’s advisers, directors or senior
employees
– holds cross-directorships or has significant links with other directors
– represents a significant shareholder
– has served on the board for more than nine years
Independence: major shareholders
• Links between directors with major shareholders represents a
significant issue, particularly preparing for IPO
• Issue linked with marketability of issuer’s stock: free float
• There may be an alignment of interests between long term
institutional investors and well managed, significant and
stable family holdings
• Boards should clearly and regularly explain the position to
shareholders
• May be need for relationship agreements
Shares/Depositary Interests
Structure for
listing
Major
shareholders –
founders,
dilution and
relationship
agreements
Shares
Reorganisation
Need to put in place the correct share structure
• Marketability
• Free transfer to comply with listing requirements
• Authority to allot shares/ability to raise new funds
• Is the proposed issuer a vehicle capable of
admission:
– must be able to issue shares to the public in place
of incorporation
– Ltd. to PLC conversion problems
Advisory Team
• Corporate finance advisor:
– sponsor (Listed) – transaction specific
– nominated advisor (AIM)
– ISDX corporate advisor
• Broker
• Depositary (and Custodian if UCITS or AIF)
• Reporting Accountant
• Lawyers
• Registrar
• Financial PR
• Security Printer
retained
3. Documentation: Three Stages
…but before you start
• Will the issuer be suitable for a listing?
• Major board decisions:
– when to IPO
– what to IPO
– which market
– where to fundraise, from and through whom
– price indicators
– where the equity growth will come from
• Risk of markets
– lots of moving pieces
– volatility of markets
– investor appetite may evaporate through the process
– multiple parties
– generally more risky that exiting to private equity
Stage One: commencing the process
Key Message: write your equity growth story
• Strategy
• Board evaluation
• Business Plan
• Engagement terms of advisors
• Market assessment
• Pre-preparation
• Share structure and constitutional matters
• Checking of contractual model etc.
Stage Two: getting you there
Key Message: refine your equity growth story
• Financial DD:
– long form
– short form
– IFRS integration issues
• Legal DD
– Commercial
– tax structuring
– consider where your investors are going to be drawn from
• Corporate Governance:
– Review
– Committee terms of reference
– Audit function (risk controls)
– What will issuer “look and feel” like with a diversified investor base?
– Start to behave like a PLC as soon as is appropriate
• Competent person’s report/valuation report/IP report/specialist reports
Stage Three: Road Show to Impact
Key Message: tell your equity growth story
• Prospectus/Admission Document
• Investor Presentation
• Placing Agreement
• Placing Letter
• Placing List
• Lock-In Agreements
• Irrevocable Undertakings
• Board Minutes
• Regulatory Announcements
• Underwriting Agreements
Timeline
• 9 months from a standing start:
– Stage 1 – 4-5 months
• strategic review
• focus on equity growth story
• largely internal, but with corporate finance advice
• determining points of reference and terms of engagement
– Stage 2 – 3 months
• detailed due diligence and preparation
• significant advisory input
– Stage 3 – Road Show to Impact – 1 month
• “all hands to the pump”
• directors will be busy on road shows with broker
• advisory team will be beavering away on the documents and
funding calls
4. Fundraising
• Key reason for going public
• Key role of the broker
– opening up own book of clients
– role of research
• Consider both the IPO and the medium to long term investor base a n issuer wants
to develop
• Selling shareholders at IPO or shortly thereafter
• Creation of investor and consumer demand for both stock and product
• Balancing interest of long term investment with ensuring there is sufficient
“product” in the market to allow for a healthy level of share trading
• Pricing negotiations between broker and issuer/corporate finance advisor
My advice: buy good advice and follow it!
Financial Promotion
• Issuer must issue a prospectus where:
– issuer is seeking approval to a regulated market
and/or
– an offer is being made to the public
• no prospectus required where seeking admission to AIM/ISDX Growth
Market without public offer
• Need to always consider where funds are being raised and comply with
local law on financial promotion
• A lot of advice revolves around ensuring that a fundraising transaction
does not require a prospectus/is not an offer to the public:
– EU prospectus exemptions now very useful as can offer to up to
200 persons in each EU member state
– UK use of exemptions under Financial Promotion Order 2005
– US use of Securities Act exemptions such as 144A/Regulation S
5. Corporate Governance
• Originally developed by the market
• Coming of age
• Now greater regulatory footing
• EU action plan
The UK Corporate Governance Code: FTSE 350
• The UK Corporate Governance Code is published by the Financial Reporting Council
• Began with the 1992 Cadbury Report on Financial Aspects of Corporate Governance
• It is a Listing rule that all companies within the FTSE 350 apply to the UK Code on a comply or
explain basis
• Five principles around which the detailed provisions are then set out, being:
A – Leadership
B – Effectiveness
C – Accountability
D – Remuneration
E – Relations with Shareholders
• Parallel document: the UK Stewardship Code
– sets out standards of behaviours within the investment chain
– most importantly fund managers
Small and Mid-Size Quoted Companies
• The needs of the SME sector are different
• SMEs are vital in delivering growth post financial crisis
• Governance should not inhibit growth
• Good governance lowers the cost of capital
• One size does not fit all
• The Quoted Companies Alliance Code bridges the gap
between FTSE 350 structures and the rest of the market
• Supporting the ambitions of growth of companies
encouraging:
– proportionate governance
– within an entrepreneurial environment
The Corporate Governance Relationship
6. On-going Obligations
• A requirement of the relevant Listing Rules, DTRs, AIM Rules, ISDX
Rules
• Also need to consider securities laws and compliance with company
law more generally
• Need to keep the market informed “without delay” of all material
developments
• Announcements through a regulatory information service
• Shareholder approval of certain arrangements
– class tests
– related party transactions
– reverse takeover
• Timing for announcement of financial information
• Takeover Code compliance: 30% mandatory bid threshold
• Extended Takeover Code application from 1 September 2013
An initial public offering of securities in London
Edward Craft – Wedlake Bell LLP
ecraft@wedlakebell.com
0044 20 7395 3099
7 June 2013
#7613951
© Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved.
This document is for general information only and does not
seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of
the law. Specific advice should always be sought for
individual cases. This reflects the law as at the date of
publication .
The content of the presentation cannot be applied as legal counselling as this will
always be subject to actual and specific knowledge of the client’s situation.

More Related Content

What's hot

Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同
Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同
Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同Global Negotiator
 
Contracts q
Contracts qContracts q
Contracts qry_moore
 
Business law PPT Dr.k.Rajeswari
Business law  PPT Dr.k.RajeswariBusiness law  PPT Dr.k.Rajeswari
Business law PPT Dr.k.RajeswariRajeswari Anand
 
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同Global Negotiator
 
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)Contracts (CXC - CSEC)
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)ry_moore
 
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同Global Negotiator
 
Business Communication Legal Aspects
Business Communication Legal AspectsBusiness Communication Legal Aspects
Business Communication Legal Aspectsrehan012
 
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business answer
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business  answerMb0051 “legal aspects of business  answer
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business answerRohit Mishra
 
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit ManagementMark Harley
 
Legal aspects of business.bba 2
Legal aspects of business.bba 2Legal aspects of business.bba 2
Legal aspects of business.bba 2ashfaqueanie
 
Module 1- Legal Documents an Overview
Module 1- Legal Documents an OverviewModule 1- Legal Documents an Overview
Module 1- Legal Documents an Overviewrostrumlegal
 
International contract contents
International contract contentsInternational contract contents
International contract contentsStudsPlanet.com
 
Contract Drafting Under English Law
Contract Drafting Under English LawContract Drafting Under English Law
Contract Drafting Under English LawMarian Dent
 
Business law
Business lawBusiness law
Business lawfancynew
 
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3Ali jili'ow
 

What's hot (20)

International Sales and Services Contracts
International Sales and Services ContractsInternational Sales and Services Contracts
International Sales and Services Contracts
 
Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同
Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同
Contrats pour la Chine en Chinois 中国合同
 
Business law
Business lawBusiness law
Business law
 
Contracts q
Contracts qContracts q
Contracts q
 
Business law PPT Dr.k.Rajeswari
Business law  PPT Dr.k.RajeswariBusiness law  PPT Dr.k.Rajeswari
Business law PPT Dr.k.Rajeswari
 
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同
China Contracts in English-Chinese 中国合同
 
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)Contracts (CXC - CSEC)
Contracts (CXC - CSEC)
 
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同
Verträge China in Chinesisch 中国合同
 
Business Communication Legal Aspects
Business Communication Legal AspectsBusiness Communication Legal Aspects
Business Communication Legal Aspects
 
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business answer
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business  answerMb0051 “legal aspects of business  answer
Mb0051 “legal aspects of business answer
 
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management
2017 AICM Credit Symposium - Australian Institute of Credit Management
 
Legal aspects of business.bba 2
Legal aspects of business.bba 2Legal aspects of business.bba 2
Legal aspects of business.bba 2
 
Module 1- Legal Documents an Overview
Module 1- Legal Documents an OverviewModule 1- Legal Documents an Overview
Module 1- Legal Documents an Overview
 
International contract contents
International contract contentsInternational contract contents
International contract contents
 
Contract Drafting Under English Law
Contract Drafting Under English LawContract Drafting Under English Law
Contract Drafting Under English Law
 
Business law
Business lawBusiness law
Business law
 
Structure cisg
Structure cisg Structure cisg
Structure cisg
 
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3
BUSINESS LAW ASSIGNMENT 2016_3
 
Adl 12-business-law
Adl 12-business-lawAdl 12-business-law
Adl 12-business-law
 
Introduction to Mercantile and Commercial Laws
Introduction to Mercantile and Commercial LawsIntroduction to Mercantile and Commercial Laws
Introduction to Mercantile and Commercial Laws
 

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (7)

Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Check Your Financial Health
Check Your Financial HealthCheck Your Financial Health
Check Your Financial Health
 
Personal branding me, myself and i
Personal branding  me, myself and iPersonal branding  me, myself and i
Personal branding me, myself and i
 
Email and Social Media
Email and Social MediaEmail and Social Media
Email and Social Media
 
Recursos naturales
Recursos naturalesRecursos naturales
Recursos naturales
 
Ind Assignment Tablet Pc
Ind Assignment Tablet PcInd Assignment Tablet Pc
Ind Assignment Tablet Pc
 
Leadership and Continuing Professional Development
Leadership and Continuing Professional DevelopmentLeadership and Continuing Professional Development
Leadership and Continuing Professional Development
 

Similar to Master Class in English Law Seminar No. 4

BUS 115 Chap007 contract law essentials
BUS 115 Chap007   contract law essentialsBUS 115 Chap007   contract law essentials
BUS 115 Chap007 contract law essentialsneogenesis6
 
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United Kingdom
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United KingdomEhsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United Kingdom
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United KingdomEhsan kabir Solicitor
 
Contract Act - Business law
Contract Act - Business lawContract Act - Business law
Contract Act - Business lawKarthik Raj
 
Contract presentation day 1
Contract presentation day 1Contract presentation day 1
Contract presentation day 1Leks&Co
 
Ehsan kabir Solicitor - Four types of property rights
Ehsan kabir Solicitor -  Four types of property rightsEhsan kabir Solicitor -  Four types of property rights
Ehsan kabir Solicitor - Four types of property rightsEhsan kabir Solicitor
 
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-Lawyers
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-LawyersGetting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-Lawyers
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-LawyersCal Stein
 
Presentation (workshop)
Presentation (workshop)Presentation (workshop)
Presentation (workshop)Mukut Deori
 
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptx
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptxLes 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptx
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptxSanjivKumar612376
 
Case Studies-Types of Business Contract
Case Studies-Types of Business ContractCase Studies-Types of Business Contract
Case Studies-Types of Business ContractMuhammad Asif Khan
 
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).ppt
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).pptSummer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).ppt
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).pptMuhammad Asif Khan Awan
 
Contract act ch 1 legal aspect of business law
Contract act ch 1  legal aspect of business law Contract act ch 1  legal aspect of business law
Contract act ch 1 legal aspect of business law Karan Kukreja
 
law (unit-i) (1).pptx
law (unit-i) (1).pptxlaw (unit-i) (1).pptx
law (unit-i) (1).pptxswadhi3
 
Arbitration Presentation2009
Arbitration Presentation2009Arbitration Presentation2009
Arbitration Presentation2009apdh1312
 
Elements of contract CHAPTER 02
Elements of contract  CHAPTER 02 Elements of contract  CHAPTER 02
Elements of contract CHAPTER 02 Arif Arain
 

Similar to Master Class in English Law Seminar No. 4 (20)

Contract law: the basics and practical tips
Contract law: the basics and practical tipsContract law: the basics and practical tips
Contract law: the basics and practical tips
 
BUS 115 Chap007 contract law essentials
BUS 115 Chap007   contract law essentialsBUS 115 Chap007   contract law essentials
BUS 115 Chap007 contract law essentials
 
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United Kingdom
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United KingdomEhsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United Kingdom
Ehsan Kabir Solicitor : How to make a will in United Kingdom
 
Contract Act - Business law
Contract Act - Business lawContract Act - Business law
Contract Act - Business law
 
Contract presentation day 1
Contract presentation day 1Contract presentation day 1
Contract presentation day 1
 
Ehsan kabir Solicitor - Four types of property rights
Ehsan kabir Solicitor -  Four types of property rightsEhsan kabir Solicitor -  Four types of property rights
Ehsan kabir Solicitor - Four types of property rights
 
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-Lawyers
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-LawyersGetting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-Lawyers
Getting Down To The Details: Contract Basics for Non-Lawyers
 
Presentation (workshop)
Presentation (workshop)Presentation (workshop)
Presentation (workshop)
 
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptx
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptxLes 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptx
Les 2 - Basics of Contract Agency and Tort Apr 2020.pptx
 
Case Studies-Types of Business Contract
Case Studies-Types of Business ContractCase Studies-Types of Business Contract
Case Studies-Types of Business Contract
 
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).ppt
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).pptSummer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).ppt
Summer 2016 semester project business & labour laws (71416).ppt
 
Contract act ch 1 legal aspect of business law
Contract act ch 1  legal aspect of business law Contract act ch 1  legal aspect of business law
Contract act ch 1 legal aspect of business law
 
Business Law 1
Business Law 1Business Law 1
Business Law 1
 
Business Contracts & securitization/Monetization
Business Contracts & securitization/MonetizationBusiness Contracts & securitization/Monetization
Business Contracts & securitization/Monetization
 
law (unit-i) (1).pptx
law (unit-i) (1).pptxlaw (unit-i) (1).pptx
law (unit-i) (1).pptx
 
Arbitration Presentation2009
Arbitration Presentation2009Arbitration Presentation2009
Arbitration Presentation2009
 
Elements of contract CHAPTER 02
Elements of contract  CHAPTER 02 Elements of contract  CHAPTER 02
Elements of contract CHAPTER 02
 
Contract law
Contract lawContract law
Contract law
 
WEEK 3 CONTRACTS.ppt
WEEK 3 CONTRACTS.pptWEEK 3 CONTRACTS.ppt
WEEK 3 CONTRACTS.ppt
 
UAE Country Fact Sheet
UAE Country Fact SheetUAE Country Fact Sheet
UAE Country Fact Sheet
 

More from Awara Direct Search

Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.
Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.
Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.Awara Direct Search
 
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 году
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 годуОбзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 году
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 годуAwara Direct Search
 
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубля
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубляЗарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубля
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубляAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в Москве
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в МосквеОбзор заработных плат в сфере HR в Москве
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в МосквеAwara Direct Search
 
Personal Data Processing in Russia
Personal Data Processing in RussiaPersonal Data Processing in Russia
Personal Data Processing in RussiaAwara Direct Search
 
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014Awara Direct Search
 
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta Venäjälle
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta VenäjälleLaki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta Venäjälle
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta VenäjälleAwara Direct Search
 
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?Awara Direct Search
 
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio Venäjällä
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio VenäjälläJohtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio Venäjällä
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio VenäjälläAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 году
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 годуОбзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 году
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 годуAwara Direct Search
 
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014Awara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Казани
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КазаниОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Казани
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КазаниAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-Петербурге
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-ПетербургеОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-Петербурге
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-ПетербургеAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Краснодаре
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КраснодареОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Краснодаре
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КраснодареAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в Астане
Обзор заработных плат в АстанеОбзор заработных плат в Астане
Обзор заработных плат в АстанеAwara Direct Search
 
Обзор заработных плат в Баку
Обзор заработных плат в БакуОбзор заработных плат в Баку
Обзор заработных плат в БакуAwara Direct Search
 
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in Kazan
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in KazanSalary Survey in Construction Sphere in Kazan
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in KazanAwara Direct Search
 

More from Awara Direct Search (20)

Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.
Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.
Обзор заработных плат в сфере фармацевтического производства в Москве.
 
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 году
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 годуОбзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 году
Обзор зарплат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2015 году
 
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубля
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубляЗарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубля
Зарплаты в москве в период санкций и девальвации рубля
 
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в Москве
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в МосквеОбзор заработных плат в сфере HR в Москве
Обзор заработных плат в сфере HR в Москве
 
Personal Data Processing in Russia
Personal Data Processing in RussiaPersonal Data Processing in Russia
Personal Data Processing in Russia
 
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014
Leadership and Employee Engagement 07.12.2014
 
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta Venäjälle
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta VenäjälleLaki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta Venäjälle
Laki henkilötietojen ja asiakastietojen pakollisesta sijoittamisesta Venäjälle
 
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?
Processing of Personal Data. What’s new?
 
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio Venäjällä
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio VenäjälläJohtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio Venäjällä
Johtaminen ja uuden ajan organisaatio Venäjällä
 
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 году
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 годуОбзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 году
Обзор уровня заработных плат в Санкт-Петербурге в 2013 году
 
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014
Исследование Совокупного Налогового Бремени на Оплату Труда – 2014
 
Salary Survey in Perm, 2014
Salary Survey in Perm, 2014Salary Survey in Perm, 2014
Salary Survey in Perm, 2014
 
Salary Survey in Astana, 2014
Salary Survey in Astana, 2014Salary Survey in Astana, 2014
Salary Survey in Astana, 2014
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Казани
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КазаниОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Казани
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Казани
 
Salary Survey Baku 2014
Salary Survey Baku 2014Salary Survey Baku 2014
Salary Survey Baku 2014
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-Петербурге
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-ПетербургеОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-Петербурге
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Санкт-Петербурге
 
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Краснодаре
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в КраснодареОбзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Краснодаре
Обзор заработных плат в области подбора персонала в Краснодаре
 
Обзор заработных плат в Астане
Обзор заработных плат в АстанеОбзор заработных плат в Астане
Обзор заработных плат в Астане
 
Обзор заработных плат в Баку
Обзор заработных плат в БакуОбзор заработных плат в Баку
Обзор заработных плат в Баку
 
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in Kazan
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in KazanSalary Survey in Construction Sphere in Kazan
Salary Survey in Construction Sphere in Kazan
 

Recently uploaded

Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxMarkAnthonyAurellano
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africaictsugar
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy Verified Accounts
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfpollardmorgan
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...lizamodels9
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menzaictsugar
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?Olivia Kresic
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Servicecallgirls2057
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchirictsugar
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis UsageNeil Kimberley
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
 
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information TechnologyCorporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort ServiceCall US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
Call US-88OO1O2216 Call Girls In Mahipalpur Female Escort Service
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Saket Delhi NCR
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
 

Master Class in English Law Seminar No. 4

  • 1. Seminar No. 4 Master Class in English Law Jeremy Lederman Julian Mathews Edward Craft Wedlake Bell LLP 7 June 2013 #7646576
  • 2. About Wedlake Bell LLP • Long-established mid market law firm • Operating from central London • Full service • UK and international work • Founding member of Telfa
  • 3. Structure of the morning Fundamentals of English Law – Jeremy Lederman How to structure a joint venture agreement in the context of a hotel joint venture - Julian Mathews An initial public offering of securities in London – Edward Craft
  • 4. TELFA CONFERENCE AND GLOBAL LAW FORUM IN CONJUNCTION WITH USLAW MOSCOW 7 June 2013 – 9:30am to 12 noon Jeremy Lederman Wedlake Bell LLP London Fundamentals of English Law
  • 5. Jeremy is head of commercial litigation at Wedlake Bell. Jeremy acts and advises on a wide range of international and UK litigation, arbitration, mediation and alternative dispute resolution. His work includes acting for creditors and lenders regarding debt recovery, contractual disputes, disputes arising from mergers and acquisitions, shareholders and partnership disputes, professional negligence, fraud, insolvency, IT disputes, regulatory matters and judicial review, charity disputes and aviation. Jeremy represents listed multinationals, national and other businesses of all sizes, religious institutions, charities and individuals. Jeremy has substantial experience of litigation involving an international element. He has recently been acting in multinational litigation brought by a Russian bank against a guarantor with a freezing order against assets worldwide. Jeremy Lederman jlederman@wedlakebell.com 0044 20 67674 0530 Your speaker
  • 6. 1. Scope of Presentation 2. Sources of English Law and court system 3. Key forms of legal personality 4. Law of Contract 5. Law of Trusts
  • 7. 1. Scope of Presentation • Large subject in little time • Necessarily brief summaries • English law only • Focus on civil claims and in particular :- • Sources of English Law and court system • Key forms of legal personality • Law of Contract • Law of Trusts
  • 8. 1. Sources of English law • Statutes – Specific laws • European Union • Regulations • Directives • UK statutes and other legislation
  • 9. 2. Sources of English law continued Case Precedents • Judge made law "the common law “. • System of precedent by which Judges follow decisions in past cases. • As at 2007 estimated over 1000 volumes of law reports containing approximately 400,000 cases. Will have increased significantly since then.
  • 10. 2. Sources of English law continued • Court of Justice of European Union provides interpretation of EU treaties and legislation which bind all courts below (but not itself). • Supreme Court (formerly the House of Lords -judicial committee) binds lower courts but not itself. • Court of Appeal binds lower courts and itself. • High Court binds lower courts (County and Magistrates courts) but not itself.
  • 11. 2. Sources of English law continued • Specialist Courts (for example Chancery, Commercial, Technology and Construction - 60% of cases in Commercial Courts have Russian element). • In certain cases Judges can find ways around precedents from previous cases but it is not usual to do so. • Custom. • Reports of Law Commission or authoritative articles or text books may be persuasive.
  • 12. 3. Key forms of legal personality Natural person - i.e. an individual Companies Separate legal personality from shareholders/members or those who control it and continues to exist regardless of what happens to them. Main statute Companies Act 2006 largely consolidation but new provisions as well. Main types :- • Companies limited by shares • Companies limited by guarantee • Unlimited companies
  • 13. 3. Key forms of legal personality continued Unincorporated Associations Partnerships • Definition - a relationship between two or more persons carrying on business in common with a view to making a profit. • No separate legal personality and all partners liable for all debts save as agreed. Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs) • Came into force in 2000. Kind of hybrid of partnerships and limited companies except much more in common with limited company. No shareholders, directors or shares, but do have members. • Separate legal personality.
  • 14. 3. Key forms of legal personality continued • LLPs very popular with professionals who could not incorporate also as vehicles for holding real estate. It has been said they offer more flexibility than limited companies. • Whilst LLPs have been very popular they not widely understood and we are experiencing the first few cases on what happens when things go wrong. Trusts • Entities that operate through trustees (see later). No minimum number but need two to hold real estate.
  • 15. 4. Contract law Clearest definition :- "An agreement between two or more parties intended to have legally enforceable consequences" . Key requirements for a valid contract :- a) there is an offer by one party. b) the offer is accepted by the other(s). c) the parties intend to create a legal relationship (intention to create legal relations). d) there is consideration, i.e. a price is paid for the performance of the contract. e) where required, formalities are complied with. f) the parties have legal capacity to enter into the contract. g) the wish to enter into the contract is genuine i.e. there has been no mistake, fraud or duress. h) the purpose of the contract is legal.
  • 16. a) Offer An offer can be verbal, in writing or by conduct. Example of making offer by conduct would be taking goods from shelf in a supermarket to a cashier and asking to pay. An offer ends :- - when it is not accepted within the time specified or within a reasonable time (more arguable). - it is withdrawn before acceptance. - it is rejected by the person to whom the offer was made ("the offeree"). Rejection can be a simple rejection or by making of a counter offer or setting a condition.
  • 17. b) Acceptance Can be written, oral or by conduct. If a method of acceptance is stipulated one should follow that. Must be complete, unqualified and unconditional. Offer or acceptance "Subject to contract" or Subject to Formal Agreement" means the parties are not bound until a formal contract is entered into. Such wording is often used at the beginning of a transaction where the parties want to put forward an offer but it is intended a fuller agreement is entered into. Tenders An invitation to tender is for parties to offer to supply goods or services on specific terms. A party who submits a tender is making the offer and once accepted a contract is formed.
  • 18. c) Intention to create legal relations Not always easy to ascertain. Not usually for social or domestic purposes, for example an offer to take someone out to dinner would not normally be viewed as intending to create a contract. In a commercial and business context it will be assumed there is an intention to create legal relations unless it can be shown otherwise for example by use of the wording subject to contract or other wording.
  • 19. d) Consideration Any benefit or detriment. Money or foregoing an opportunity. Must be :- - Real - Legal - Possible It need not be a good bargain. Usually consideration cannot be in the past, except for bills of exchange and in some circumstances for services provided in the past. Another exception to the need for consideration is where a party has in reliance on the promise of a person acted to their detriment, known as promissory estoppel.
  • 20. e) Formalities Many contracts do not have to be in writing. People put them in writing because: i) There are some types of contracts that must be in writing to be valid or enforceable; or ii) it is easier to prove the terms rather than rely on parties' memories of what was said and done. Culture of English courts is to give greater weight to documents than oral accounts . Documents do not have memories that can fade or be mistaken. Contracts with specific formalities :- Contracts that must be signed and made by deed (a special type of contract) :- - certain real estate transactions. - contracts where there is no payment or consideration e.g. a gift. - transfers of British ships or shares in them.
  • 21. e) Formalities continued Certain contracts must be in writing for example :- - transfer of shares in a UK company - bills of exchange, cheques and promissory notes - assignment of copyright - marine insurance Certain contracts must have written evidence they have been made (by a note or otherwise) examples of which are :- - guarantees (Statute of Frauds 1677) - contracts for sale of land - contracts of employment To avoid any difficulty those contracts are usually made in writing.
  • 22. f) Capacity to enter into contracts The parties must have capacity to enter into a contract. Contracts with those under the age of 18 or insane or drunk/intoxicated might be unenforceable. In large contracts with corporate bodies it is worth checking that there is proper authority to enter into the contracts.
  • 23. Terms of a Contract The terms set out the parties rights and obligations Two types of terms • Express • Implied
  • 24. Terms of a Contract continued Express terms Terms that are set out in the contract. If the terms are not certain the contract will not be enforceable. So generally one cannot have a contract to enter into another contract ("an agreement to agree"). This is different from at least some US jurisdictions. The contract must have terms which if not certain, must be capable of being ascertained without further agreement of the parties. In a number of agreements there is a mechanism or procedure by which the terms become definite for example a valuer, expert or arbitrator makes a decision which binds the parties.
  • 25. Terms of a Contract continued Implied terms Parties are free to agree whatever they wish (save for example illegal matters) In some cases the court may imply terms into a contract :- - to give the contract business efficacy (to achieve the purpose of the contract) - example - where anticipated that use of port facilities would be provided but they could not and party making offer had not checked they could be - to reflect custom of a particular geographical area or trade - on grounds of public policy e.g. sale of goods for example that goods are of satisfactory quality
  • 26. Terms of a Contract continued Clauses limiting or excluding liability Parties free to include such clauses in contracts but this is subject to public policy. For example clauses excluding or limiting liability for death and personal injury and as regards consumers are heavily restricted. Note where dealing on a party's standard terms they might be challenged as not being "reasonable" (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977). Must do all that is reasonably necessary to bring such clauses to attention of other party. If in signed agreement likely to satisfy this test. Clauses will need to be clear and will be interpreted against the party seeking to rely on exclusion or limitation of liability.
  • 27. Terms of a Contract continued Further distinction between two types of terms - conditions and warranties. Condition - a term that is so important to the contract that if breached, the other party can treat the contract as at an end. The innocent party does not then have to do anything further under the contract. Example sale of a car - the car does not work at all or is not provided by the seller - clearly that is a condition and the purchaser is entitled to treat contract at end. Warranty - a term that is not central to the to the main purpose of the contract. Breach of warranty only entitles the other party to damages and he cannot treat the contract as at an end. Example the sale of the car - there is a small fault in the paintwork of a car or the wrong kind of music system is installed. Buyer is entitled to damages only and the contract continues. The damages would be the difference between what the buyer intended and what was received. Thus hard to calculate for smaller faults.
  • 28. g) Genuine consent to enter into a contract. A requirement for a valid contract. A contract can be attacked on grounds of :- - Mistake - Misrepresentation - Duress - Undue influence - Illegality
  • 29. Mistake Where nature of contract is not what was intended, including identity of parties, terms, and subject matter. One asks the Court to either correct the contract or treat it as unenforceable. General rule, mistake as to quality does not affect validity of contract. Example sale of a piece of land by me to you for £1million. If I did not know that land was in fact worth £20 million because of development potential, the contract is still binding.
  • 30. Misrepresentation A material false statement of fact that induces the other party to enter into the contract. Example - on sale of residential land, when the seller was asked whether he had notice of any applications to develop neighbouring land and he answered “no” when he did. Buyer relied on that and refused to perform contract when found out true position. Misrepresentation must be made by party or his agent. Innocent party must have relied on the representation. Statement can be made dishonestly or negligently. Remedies are damages and/or rescission (cancellation) of the contract. General rule that silence does not amount to a misrepresentation. A key exception to that rule is contracts of utmost good faith where failure to disclose material facts whether asked for them or not, give other party option to treat the contract as void. Example - contracts of insurance - although steps started to limit this rule as regards individual consumers.
  • 31. Duress Duress means violence or threatened violence or imprisonment - unusual. Undue influence Where influence is applied preventing a party from making an independent judgment for example where special relationship, for example husband and wife or lawyer and client or an elderly or otherwise vulnerable person. Illegality Where the purpose of the contract is in breach of the civil or criminal law. Examples • Bribery and corruption. • Penalties. • Contracts in restraint of trade and restrictive covenants following sale of business or following termination of employment needing to be reasonable.
  • 32. Remedies Refusing to perform the contract. Damages to restore claimant to position would have been if contract had been performed. Claim for quantum meruit ( reasonable fee for work done). Order for performance of contract (injunction for specific performance).
  • 33. Privity of contract General rule has been that only parties to a contract can sue on it. However since the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 a contract can impose an obligation on someone who is not party to a contract (a non- party) and give a benefit to a non-party. In both cases the non-party can sue/be sued. This is frequently excluded in agreements but could be potentially useful. Example Collateral Warranties for non parties to contracts in construction still sought by lenders. There are other exceptions to the general rule of privity of contract including :- • Actions by beneficiaries under trusts. • Certain insurance contracts to confer benefit on non-parties (eg motor insurance). • Negotiable instruments e.g. cheques/ bills of exchange. • Where a contract has been assigned or novated.
  • 34. Assignments (transfers) and novation Rights under a contract can normally be assigned unless where personal service is essential to a performance and then consent of the other party will be required. Liabilities under a contract can only be assigned with agreement of the other party. So this means that will often be a new contract with transferee who takes over the liabilities – a novation agreement. Notice of assignment should be given in writing. If not there are risks :- - that defences relating to the party transferring can be raised; - of loss of priority over a later transferee who was not aware of the earlier assignment.
  • 35. 5. Trusts Extremely brief review Concepts of trusts and beneficial ownership are in the process of development in Russian law. A party ("the trustee") holds assets for the benefit of some other party or parties ("the beneficiaries") or other lawful purpose, so that the benefit of the asset is for the beneficiaries or object of the trust. Two kinds of owner. The Trustee is the legal owner and holds the property in their name. The beneficiary is equitable or beneficial owner. The settlor is the person providing the assets which are to be held on trust. Several categories of trusts :- - Express - Implied - Constructive
  • 36. Express Trusts Where terms of the trust expressly set out Can be written or oral Requirements :- • Certainty of intention - must be clear there is to be a trust. • Certainty of subject matter – both assets and how to be held. • Certainty of object of the trust – i.e. can the beneficiaries be ascertained.
  • 37. Implied Trusts The Court will imply a trust in certain situations based on the intention of the Settlor. For example if the trusts are void or there is a defect the trustees will hold the assets on (resulting) trust for the settlor. Constructive Trusts The Court will impose a trust without taking account of the parties' intentions. For example if in breach of the trust, the Trustee (T) transfers assets to another party (X) who is aware of the breach of trust. X holds the assets on constructive trust for the proper beneficiary (B). Following on from this a claim could be made for the assets themselves directly against X. This has advantages in certain insolvency situations so as to claim that the assets do not form part of X's assets. Further B could also take advantage of any increase in value of the assets. © Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved. This document is for general information only and does not seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of the law. Specific advice should always be sought for individual cases. This reflects the law as at June 2013.
  • 38. Thank you for your attention Any Questions?
  • 39. How to structure a joint venture agreement in the context of a hotel joint venture Julian Mathews – Wedlake Bell LLP 7 June 2013
  • 40. Your Speaker Julian is a corporate lawyer who specialises in private company M&A, private equity and joint ventures. He has a particular focus on the hotel and hospitality sector, as well as extensive experience in acting on corporate real estate transactions. Julian has acted for both mid-market private equity institutions and also for management teams. He has also acted on various cross border joint venture transactions for real estate institutions and real estate private equity firms. Julian leads the hospitality and leisure sector at Wedlake Bell and has in the past lectured on the legal process of private equity transactions at the executive MBA class of London Business School. . Julian Mathews jmathews@wedlakebell.com 0044 20 7395 3174
  • 41. To Cover 1. Introduction 2. Discussion on nature of the JV entity 3. Touch on tax 4. The operative documents 5. Discussion of the structure of a hotel JV 6. Questions
  • 42. Introduction 1. Context of presentation a) Focus is on UK law implications for joint ventures b) Context of deal is a hotel acquisition 2. Assumptions a) Assumes a general understanding of JV’s b) Assumes little understanding of hotel transactions 3. Local or cross border a) Well, let’s cover both 4. Hotel specific factors
  • 43. Basic Principles – Why a joint venture? • Varies, and depends on the circumstances of the parties and the subject of the business. But can be due to: • Sharing costs? • Pooling of expertise? • Cross border penetration? • Main point is to ensure 1 + 1 = 3
  • 44. Preliminary thoughts on structuring – nature of JV vehicle • Likely to be determined by: • Nature and size of the subject business • Identity and location of the proposed JV parties • Commercial and financial objectives of the proposed JV parties • Tax considerations • Funding • Extraction of profits • Potential structures for the JV vehicle are: • Limited liability company • Limited liability partnership (LLP) • A partnership or limited partnership • A contractual arrangement with no JV vehicle
  • 45. Limited liability company • Generally, for most business joint ventures, a limited liability company is most appropriate. • In the UK, that company will be incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act 2006. • As a separate legal entity, a JVCo can: – Own and deal in its own assets – Contract in its own right – Sue and be sued in its own right • Benefits from a participant’s perspective include: – Veil of incorporation – Limitation of liability
  • 46. Limited liability company • But note: • Requirement to file accounts • Duties of directors, especially conflicts of interest (s.175 of the Companies Act 2006) • Accounting issues – is it deemed a subsidiary under: • The Companies Act 2006 provisions? • IAS 28 and 31 – significant control?
  • 47. Limited liability partnership (LLP) • An LLP formed under Limited Liability Partnerships Act 2000 can most be applicable for ventures between individuals such as professional partnerships. • An LLP is a body corporate with legal personality separate from its members. • An LLP: • Must publish accounts like a limited liability company • Have at least two members • Is generally taxed as a partnership despite being a separate legal entity • But note: • No transferable shareholding • Each member is an agent of the LLP
  • 48. A partnership or limited partnership • If a separate legal entity is not chosen, then distinction under UK law is whether the vehicle is a “legal partnership” or not. • If a partnership, then the Partnership Act 1890 applies. • S.1 of Partnership Act 1890 defines a partnership as the “relationship which subsists between persons carrying on a business in common with a view of profit” – see s. 2 for rules of determination. • Characteristics of a partnership under the Act: – Each partner deemed to be the agent of the other partners. – As such, each partner jointly liable without limit for debts and obligations of the partnership. – Further, each partner jointly and severally liable for wrongful acts and omissions of his co-partners.
  • 49. A partnership or limited partnership • Also possible to form a limited partnership under the Limited Partnerships Act 1907. • At least one member must be a general partner with unlimited liability, but the GP can be a company. • Note that limited partners cannot participate in the management of the partnership without losing the right to limited liability. • Consequently limited partnerships most suitable for a business where the majority of participants are passive investors, such as a private equity fund.
  • 50. A contractual arrangement with no JV vehicle • Generally where parties agree to operate as independent contractors in their own right, rather than shareholders or partners. • The form of the agreement often known as a consortium or co- operation agreement. • Note: • Each party will not have a statutory responsibility for: • the liabilities and obligations of the venture • The acts or omissions of the other parties • But each party has potentially unlimited liability for: • own actions • Other parties, if expressly assumed responsibility or deemed to be vicariously liable under the agreement.
  • 52. Overview of key documents • Main documents for a corporate JVCo are: • joint venture or shareholders agreement • Articles of association of the joint venture • Ancillary documents may include: • An asset or business purchase agreement • A management agreement • Loan note instrument • Service or secondment agreements • Licence agreements such as for IPR • For an LLP or LP, then the partnership agreement will be the main operative document.
  • 53. Joint venture agreement • The purpose of the JV agreement is to establish: • Rights and obligations of the parties • To establish the corporate entity • To provide how the JVCo will be operated • To provide what happens if there are difficulties • To provide methodology for exit, or termination, once venture aims achieved. •
  • 54. JVCo articles of association
  • 55. General Structure of a basic Corporate JV for a hotel venture JVCo Party A (Land/Hotel Owner Party B (Operator) Hotel (Hotel HoldCo?) JV Agreement Loan Agreement (Loan Agreement?) Sale Agreement Management Agreement Hotel Brand Co?Franchise Agreement
  • 56.
  • 57. Thank you for your attention Any Questions? © Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved. This document is for general information only and does not seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of the law. Specific advice should always be sought for individual cases. This reflects the law as at June 2013. Julian Mathews jmathews@wedlakebell.com 0044 20 7395 3174
  • 58. How to structure a joint venture agreement in the context of a hotel joint venture Julian Mathews – Wedlake Bell LLP 7 June 2013
  • 59. An initial public offering of securities in London Edward Craft – Wedlake Bell LLP 7 June 2013 #7613951
  • 60. Your Speaker Edward is a specialist in corporate governance for both private and public companies. Edward had advised on many debt and equity capital markets transactions. Edward is Chairman of the Corporate Governance Expert Group of the Quoted Companies Alliance, the independent membership organisation that champions the interests of small to mid-size quoted companies. Edward has recently been responsible for the new Corporate Governance Code for Small and Mid-Size Quoted Companies. Edward is a member of the corporate governance group of European Issuers. Edward Craft ecraft@wedlakebell.com 0044 20 7395 3099
  • 61. Outline 1. IPO Options and the London Markets 2. Preparing for IPO 3. Documentation 4. Fundraising 5. Corporate Governance 6. On-going Obligations
  • 62. 1. IPO Options and the London Markets • Why issue securities to the public at all? • Decision to IPO is one of the most important a board can ever make • Admission to trading distinct from Listing • Presumption that the securities being offered are ordinary shares or depositary interests/receipts – Can also have other securities listed/admitted to trading, including: • Non-voting ordinary shares • Preference shares • Debt securities
  • 63. Depositary Interests • A security in its own right • Need to have appointed a depositary (and possibly a custodian) • Depositary/custodian regulated under UK financial services legislation • capable of electronic settlement through CREST • Additional documentation: – Trust Deed – Depositary Agreement – Legal Opinions
  • 64. The London markets Officially Listed Securities (UK Listing Authority as the EU Authority) Other traded securities Growth Market Premium Listing - super equivalent Main Board Standard Listing – ESMA compliant
  • 65. Equity Capital Markets: the global context
  • 66. The Rules Rule Responsibility Listing Rules EU with FCA as UKLA DTRs under Transparency Directive EU with FCA as UKLA AIM Rules London Stock Exchange High Growth Segment Rules London Stock Exchange ISDX Growth Market Rules ICAP Securities and Derivatives Exchange Company Law EU and UK parliament Securities Law EU and UK parliament UK Corporate Governance Code Financial Reporting Council Stewardship Code Financial Reporting Council Corporate Governance Code for Small and Mid- Size Quoted Companies Quoted Companies Alliance Takeover Code Panel on Take-Overs and Mergers/UK parliament Prospectus Directive EU Market Abuse Directive EU MiFID/MiFID II EU
  • 67. 2. Preparing for IPO Q: Why move to a public market at all? liquidity/ extended base of shareholders trading/kudos/ staff incentives/ stock for acq.fin. exit/ valuation to raise funds for growth businesses
  • 68. Internal Matters Directors – executive and NEDs Structure Board Independence
  • 69. Independence: directors • Independence from both the issuer and major shareholders • Independence criteria set out in provision B.1.1 of the UK Code • Independence in character and judgement, as well as circumstances or relationships • Risk of impairing (or appearing to impair) the judgement of the director • Where independence likely to be compromised: – former employee – material business relationship with the issuer, whether direct or indirect – receives additional remuneration from the issuer apart from a director’s fee – participates in the issuer’s share option or a performance-related pay scheme, or is a member of the issuer’s pension scheme – close familial ties with any of the issuer’s advisers, directors or senior employees – holds cross-directorships or has significant links with other directors – represents a significant shareholder – has served on the board for more than nine years
  • 70. Independence: major shareholders • Links between directors with major shareholders represents a significant issue, particularly preparing for IPO • Issue linked with marketability of issuer’s stock: free float • There may be an alignment of interests between long term institutional investors and well managed, significant and stable family holdings • Boards should clearly and regularly explain the position to shareholders • May be need for relationship agreements
  • 71. Shares/Depositary Interests Structure for listing Major shareholders – founders, dilution and relationship agreements Shares Reorganisation
  • 72. Need to put in place the correct share structure • Marketability • Free transfer to comply with listing requirements • Authority to allot shares/ability to raise new funds • Is the proposed issuer a vehicle capable of admission: – must be able to issue shares to the public in place of incorporation – Ltd. to PLC conversion problems
  • 73. Advisory Team • Corporate finance advisor: – sponsor (Listed) – transaction specific – nominated advisor (AIM) – ISDX corporate advisor • Broker • Depositary (and Custodian if UCITS or AIF) • Reporting Accountant • Lawyers • Registrar • Financial PR • Security Printer retained
  • 74. 3. Documentation: Three Stages …but before you start • Will the issuer be suitable for a listing? • Major board decisions: – when to IPO – what to IPO – which market – where to fundraise, from and through whom – price indicators – where the equity growth will come from • Risk of markets – lots of moving pieces – volatility of markets – investor appetite may evaporate through the process – multiple parties – generally more risky that exiting to private equity
  • 75. Stage One: commencing the process Key Message: write your equity growth story • Strategy • Board evaluation • Business Plan • Engagement terms of advisors • Market assessment • Pre-preparation • Share structure and constitutional matters • Checking of contractual model etc.
  • 76. Stage Two: getting you there Key Message: refine your equity growth story • Financial DD: – long form – short form – IFRS integration issues • Legal DD – Commercial – tax structuring – consider where your investors are going to be drawn from • Corporate Governance: – Review – Committee terms of reference – Audit function (risk controls) – What will issuer “look and feel” like with a diversified investor base? – Start to behave like a PLC as soon as is appropriate • Competent person’s report/valuation report/IP report/specialist reports
  • 77. Stage Three: Road Show to Impact Key Message: tell your equity growth story • Prospectus/Admission Document • Investor Presentation • Placing Agreement • Placing Letter • Placing List • Lock-In Agreements • Irrevocable Undertakings • Board Minutes • Regulatory Announcements • Underwriting Agreements
  • 78. Timeline • 9 months from a standing start: – Stage 1 – 4-5 months • strategic review • focus on equity growth story • largely internal, but with corporate finance advice • determining points of reference and terms of engagement – Stage 2 – 3 months • detailed due diligence and preparation • significant advisory input – Stage 3 – Road Show to Impact – 1 month • “all hands to the pump” • directors will be busy on road shows with broker • advisory team will be beavering away on the documents and funding calls
  • 79. 4. Fundraising • Key reason for going public • Key role of the broker – opening up own book of clients – role of research • Consider both the IPO and the medium to long term investor base a n issuer wants to develop • Selling shareholders at IPO or shortly thereafter • Creation of investor and consumer demand for both stock and product • Balancing interest of long term investment with ensuring there is sufficient “product” in the market to allow for a healthy level of share trading • Pricing negotiations between broker and issuer/corporate finance advisor My advice: buy good advice and follow it!
  • 80. Financial Promotion • Issuer must issue a prospectus where: – issuer is seeking approval to a regulated market and/or – an offer is being made to the public • no prospectus required where seeking admission to AIM/ISDX Growth Market without public offer • Need to always consider where funds are being raised and comply with local law on financial promotion • A lot of advice revolves around ensuring that a fundraising transaction does not require a prospectus/is not an offer to the public: – EU prospectus exemptions now very useful as can offer to up to 200 persons in each EU member state – UK use of exemptions under Financial Promotion Order 2005 – US use of Securities Act exemptions such as 144A/Regulation S
  • 81. 5. Corporate Governance • Originally developed by the market • Coming of age • Now greater regulatory footing • EU action plan
  • 82.
  • 83.
  • 84. The UK Corporate Governance Code: FTSE 350 • The UK Corporate Governance Code is published by the Financial Reporting Council • Began with the 1992 Cadbury Report on Financial Aspects of Corporate Governance • It is a Listing rule that all companies within the FTSE 350 apply to the UK Code on a comply or explain basis • Five principles around which the detailed provisions are then set out, being: A – Leadership B – Effectiveness C – Accountability D – Remuneration E – Relations with Shareholders • Parallel document: the UK Stewardship Code – sets out standards of behaviours within the investment chain – most importantly fund managers
  • 85. Small and Mid-Size Quoted Companies • The needs of the SME sector are different • SMEs are vital in delivering growth post financial crisis • Governance should not inhibit growth • Good governance lowers the cost of capital • One size does not fit all • The Quoted Companies Alliance Code bridges the gap between FTSE 350 structures and the rest of the market • Supporting the ambitions of growth of companies encouraging: – proportionate governance – within an entrepreneurial environment
  • 86.
  • 87.
  • 88. The Corporate Governance Relationship
  • 89. 6. On-going Obligations • A requirement of the relevant Listing Rules, DTRs, AIM Rules, ISDX Rules • Also need to consider securities laws and compliance with company law more generally • Need to keep the market informed “without delay” of all material developments • Announcements through a regulatory information service • Shareholder approval of certain arrangements – class tests – related party transactions – reverse takeover • Timing for announcement of financial information • Takeover Code compliance: 30% mandatory bid threshold • Extended Takeover Code application from 1 September 2013
  • 90. An initial public offering of securities in London Edward Craft – Wedlake Bell LLP ecraft@wedlakebell.com 0044 20 7395 3099 7 June 2013 #7613951 © Wedlake Bell LLP 2013. All rights reserved. This document is for general information only and does not seek to give legal advice or to be an exhaustive statement of the law. Specific advice should always be sought for individual cases. This reflects the law as at the date of publication . The content of the presentation cannot be applied as legal counselling as this will always be subject to actual and specific knowledge of the client’s situation.