SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 1
Descargar para leer sin conexión
UNDERSTANDING THE NEW
INSTITUTIONAL CRISIS!
August 22nd, 2013

Recently, the Contentious-administrative Chamber admitted claims which seek to
separate the magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice elected in 2009, including the four magistrates of the Constitutional Chamber (instance which has proved
to be independent and has pronounced sentences that permit Salvadorans certain
control over the acts of politicians).
These claims were admitted, although having defects in matters of substance and
form, proving that the motivation of the Contentious-administrative Chamber
could be more political than judicial in this case, falling in the game of manipulating our more independent officials.

What is the Contentiousadministrative Chamber?
Is the court in charge of judging the legality of the acts of the Public Administration.
It does not have any jurisdiction over political or government acts, as the appointment of the magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice in 2009.

ORIGIN OF THE PROBLEM
In the last years, thanks to emblematic sentences (vote by face, prohibition of the “secret account”, cancellation of political parties which did not get enough votes for surviving, nullification of double election of officers and great transparency advances)
the Constitutional Chamber has earned enemies in the Salvadoran political class.
As a reaction to these sentences, we have seen constant attempts to undermine the judicial independence:
In 2011, our congressmen approved the decree 743 which sought to tie the Constitutional Chamber´s hands.
In 2012, with the assistance of a locksmith, illegitimate congressmen and magistrates took over the Supreme Court of Justice.
The creation of a commission which investigates maliciously the appointments of the brave magistrates.
This new attempt, using another Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, seeking to separate the magistrates of their positions and to stop the advances in the POLITICAL POWER CONTROL.

WHY IS THIS SUCH A GRAVE PROBLEM?
Because the citizens are letting our guard down and getting used to these constant attacks to judicial independence.
Because the amount of technical terms makes us believe that only the lawyers lose, when the reality is that we all lose.
Because the institutions which should serve you, are being used like tools for vengeance of the officers who have acted independently.
Because each day passed without judicial independence, is one more day in which your rights and freedoms are at risk.

WHAT SIDE DO YOU WANT TO BE ON?
The side of the Salvadorans who defend the institutions and understand that the state
governed by the rule of law is the key to progress.
The side of those who use the government for their own advantage and think that their
personal interests are more important than the institutions which protect our rights.

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2Ninety Consulting
 
Analisis comparativo leyes
Analisis comparativo leyesAnalisis comparativo leyes
Analisis comparativo leyesfedidenando
 
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your Body
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your BodyWeekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your Body
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your BodyCREO_Org
 
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)Praveen Channe
 
50MoreSitesin61minutes
50MoreSitesin61minutes50MoreSitesin61minutes
50MoreSitesin61minutesjehennes
 
Acero porcelanizado mapa
Acero porcelanizado mapaAcero porcelanizado mapa
Acero porcelanizado mapaLufe55
 
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpes
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpesLa déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpes
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpeslyceesevigne
 

Destacado (14)

The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
The Omnichannel Insurer - Part 1 of 2
 
BWLS_LOGO_V4
BWLS_LOGO_V4BWLS_LOGO_V4
BWLS_LOGO_V4
 
INAUGURACIÓN DE JUEGOS MANANTIAL 2.013
INAUGURACIÓN DE JUEGOS MANANTIAL 2.013INAUGURACIÓN DE JUEGOS MANANTIAL 2.013
INAUGURACIÓN DE JUEGOS MANANTIAL 2.013
 
Shaping Your Pics
Shaping Your PicsShaping Your Pics
Shaping Your Pics
 
intervention2_vicki_becky
intervention2_vicki_beckyintervention2_vicki_becky
intervention2_vicki_becky
 
Analisis comparativo leyes
Analisis comparativo leyesAnalisis comparativo leyes
Analisis comparativo leyes
 
Concordancia Código Procesal Penal y otros textos
Concordancia Código Procesal Penal y otros textosConcordancia Código Procesal Penal y otros textos
Concordancia Código Procesal Penal y otros textos
 
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your Body
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your BodyWeekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your Body
Weekly Newsletter - How Does the State Intervene in Your Body
 
Negocjacje testowe
Negocjacje testoweNegocjacje testowe
Negocjacje testowe
 
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)
CV- Praveen Channe (15NOV 2015)
 
Ramon
RamonRamon
Ramon
 
50MoreSitesin61minutes
50MoreSitesin61minutes50MoreSitesin61minutes
50MoreSitesin61minutes
 
Acero porcelanizado mapa
Acero porcelanizado mapaAcero porcelanizado mapa
Acero porcelanizado mapa
 
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpes
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpesLa déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpes
La déportation des juifs dans les hautes alpes
 

Similar a Weekly Newsletters - Understanding the New Institutional Crisis

Judicial Activism
Judicial ActivismJudicial Activism
Judicial Activismshainks023
 
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'Istanbul
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'IstanbulCommuniqué de presse du barreau d'Istanbul
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'IstanbulJLMB
 
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Raviforjustice Raviforjustice
 
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Raviforjustice Raviforjustice
 
Boss2 ppt ch13
Boss2 ppt ch13Boss2 ppt ch13
Boss2 ppt ch13dborcoman
 
India Legal 20 May 2019
India Legal 20 May 2019India Legal 20 May 2019
India Legal 20 May 2019ENC
 
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkC8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkFatin Nazihah Aziz
 
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docx
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docxTHE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docx
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docxSOMOSCO1
 
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILL
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILLWHAT IS LOKPAL BILL
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILLgandhi_jimi
 
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdf
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdfPOLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdf
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdfmdzikrullahs27081
 
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018MYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An Introduction
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An IntroductionCause Lawyering in Singapore: An Introduction
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An IntroductionM. Ravi
 
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdf
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdfremediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdf
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdfJohnRichCaidic
 

Similar a Weekly Newsletters - Understanding the New Institutional Crisis (20)

Judicial Activism
Judicial ActivismJudicial Activism
Judicial Activism
 
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'Istanbul
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'IstanbulCommuniqué de presse du barreau d'Istanbul
Communiqué de presse du barreau d'Istanbul
 
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
 
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
Judges revolt the last nail on the coffin of judicial credibility-190118
 
Judicial activism
Judicial activismJudicial activism
Judicial activism
 
Boss2 ppt ch13
Boss2 ppt ch13Boss2 ppt ch13
Boss2 ppt ch13
 
Judiciary
JudiciaryJudiciary
Judiciary
 
India Legal 20 May 2019
India Legal 20 May 2019India Legal 20 May 2019
India Legal 20 May 2019
 
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal FrameworkC8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
C8 - Constitutions & Legal Framework
 
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docx
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docxTHE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docx
THE ROLE OF JUDICIARY IN SOCIETY.docx
 
Lokpal bill
Lokpal billLokpal bill
Lokpal bill
 
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILL
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILLWHAT IS LOKPAL BILL
WHAT IS LOKPAL BILL
 
India a democracy or krytocracy-120320
India a democracy or krytocracy-120320India a democracy or krytocracy-120320
India a democracy or krytocracy-120320
 
Suo Motu Rule
Suo Motu RuleSuo Motu Rule
Suo Motu Rule
 
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdf
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdfPOLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdf
POLITICAL SCIENCE JUDICAL REVIEW MDZ 27.pdf
 
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018
RULE OF LAW IN MYANMAR AND CURRENT SITUATION 2018
 
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An Introduction
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An IntroductionCause Lawyering in Singapore: An Introduction
Cause Lawyering in Singapore: An Introduction
 
Judiciary (2).pptx
Judiciary (2).pptxJudiciary (2).pptx
Judiciary (2).pptx
 
Remedies for maladministration
Remedies for maladministrationRemedies for maladministration
Remedies for maladministration
 
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdf
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdfremediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdf
remediesformaladministration-191227035239.pdf
 

Más de CREO_Org

¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes
¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes
¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajesCREO_Org
 
Programa de Academia Libertad
Programa de Academia LibertadPrograma de Academia Libertad
Programa de Academia LibertadCREO_Org
 
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!CREO_Org
 
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!CREO_Org
 
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!CREO_Org
 
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina Rochac
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina RochacCREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina Rochac
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina RochacCREO_Org
 
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!CREO_Org
 
CLIC I - Programa
CLIC I - ProgramaCLIC I - Programa
CLIC I - ProgramaCREO_Org
 
Clic i programa
Clic i   programaClic i   programa
Clic i programaCREO_Org
 
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de Taiwán
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de TaiwánInforme Comisión investigadora de fondos de Taiwán
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de TaiwánCREO_Org
 
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIA
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIAPosición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIA
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIACREO_Org
 
Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - Programa Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - Programa CREO_Org
 
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!CREO_Org
 
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!CREO_Org
 
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the Youth
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the YouthWeekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the Youth
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the YouthCREO_Org
 
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral Code
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral CodeWeekly Newsletter - New Electoral Code
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral CodeCREO_Org
 
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!CREO_Org
 
Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - ProgramaAcademia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - ProgramaCREO_Org
 
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREO
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREONueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREO
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREOCREO_Org
 
Creo que deberias saber tse - inglés
Creo que deberias saber   tse - inglésCreo que deberias saber   tse - inglés
Creo que deberias saber tse - inglésCREO_Org
 

Más de CREO_Org (20)

¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes
¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes
¿Cuál es el miedo? - Reacción de CREO ante postura CAPRES por viajes
 
Programa de Academia Libertad
Programa de Academia LibertadPrograma de Academia Libertad
Programa de Academia Libertad
 
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!
Academia Libertad 2014: ¡Retomemos el camino de la prosperidad!
 
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
 
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
Promueve tu País 2014: ¡Construyamos el país que merecemos!
 
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina Rochac
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina RochacCREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina Rochac
CREO agradece a Rodrigo Molina Rochac
 
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!
¡CREO exige la pronta liberación de Rodrigo Diamanti!
 
CLIC I - Programa
CLIC I - ProgramaCLIC I - Programa
CLIC I - Programa
 
Clic i programa
Clic i   programaClic i   programa
Clic i programa
 
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de Taiwán
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de TaiwánInforme Comisión investigadora de fondos de Taiwán
Informe Comisión investigadora de fondos de Taiwán
 
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIA
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIAPosición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIA
Posición Institucional: LOS PELIGROS DE LA POLITIZACIÓN DE LA JUSTICIA
 
Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - Programa Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - Programa
 
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!
¡Inscríbete a CLIC II!
 
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!
Weekly Newsletter - Evaluate Political Promises!
 
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the Youth
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the YouthWeekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the Youth
Weekly Newsletter - Credit Loans for the Youth
 
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral Code
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral CodeWeekly Newsletter - New Electoral Code
Weekly Newsletter - New Electoral Code
 
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!
Weekly Newsletter - Budget Elaboration Process!
 
Academia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - ProgramaAcademia Libertad - Programa
Academia Libertad - Programa
 
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREO
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREONueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREO
Nueva inconstitucionalidad - Posición Institucional CREO
 
Creo que deberias saber tse - inglés
Creo que deberias saber   tse - inglésCreo que deberias saber   tse - inglés
Creo que deberias saber tse - inglés
 

Weekly Newsletters - Understanding the New Institutional Crisis

  • 1. UNDERSTANDING THE NEW INSTITUTIONAL CRISIS! August 22nd, 2013 Recently, the Contentious-administrative Chamber admitted claims which seek to separate the magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice elected in 2009, including the four magistrates of the Constitutional Chamber (instance which has proved to be independent and has pronounced sentences that permit Salvadorans certain control over the acts of politicians). These claims were admitted, although having defects in matters of substance and form, proving that the motivation of the Contentious-administrative Chamber could be more political than judicial in this case, falling in the game of manipulating our more independent officials. What is the Contentiousadministrative Chamber? Is the court in charge of judging the legality of the acts of the Public Administration. It does not have any jurisdiction over political or government acts, as the appointment of the magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice in 2009. ORIGIN OF THE PROBLEM In the last years, thanks to emblematic sentences (vote by face, prohibition of the “secret account”, cancellation of political parties which did not get enough votes for surviving, nullification of double election of officers and great transparency advances) the Constitutional Chamber has earned enemies in the Salvadoran political class. As a reaction to these sentences, we have seen constant attempts to undermine the judicial independence: In 2011, our congressmen approved the decree 743 which sought to tie the Constitutional Chamber´s hands. In 2012, with the assistance of a locksmith, illegitimate congressmen and magistrates took over the Supreme Court of Justice. The creation of a commission which investigates maliciously the appointments of the brave magistrates. This new attempt, using another Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, seeking to separate the magistrates of their positions and to stop the advances in the POLITICAL POWER CONTROL. WHY IS THIS SUCH A GRAVE PROBLEM? Because the citizens are letting our guard down and getting used to these constant attacks to judicial independence. Because the amount of technical terms makes us believe that only the lawyers lose, when the reality is that we all lose. Because the institutions which should serve you, are being used like tools for vengeance of the officers who have acted independently. Because each day passed without judicial independence, is one more day in which your rights and freedoms are at risk. WHAT SIDE DO YOU WANT TO BE ON? The side of the Salvadorans who defend the institutions and understand that the state governed by the rule of law is the key to progress. The side of those who use the government for their own advantage and think that their personal interests are more important than the institutions which protect our rights.