SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 8
Descargar para leer sin conexión
FOR YOulZ RECORDS
                                                                   STATE OF MAINE
Location            PORTLAND         DISTRICT           COURT
Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605
                                                                                                     •..•...

LORI M HANDRAHAN                                                                                         ORDER FOR PROTECTION
    V.                                                                                                        FROM ABUSE
                                                                                                         19-A M.R.S.A.          section       4007
IGOR MALENKO

      After     due notice           and ~        opportunity          for full hearing        [] full hearing         on the merits
of the complaint               for Protection                   from Abuse,   the following     parties          being present:
~     Plaintiff            ~     Defendant,


THE COURT FINDS THAT:                          (only checked boxes apply)
~  (1) The parties                 are family or household members;
[] (2) The parties                 are dating partners or plaintiff is a victim                                of defendant's
       sexual assault or stalking.
[] (3) The plaintiff was abused by the defendant;
[] (4) The defendant                     presents        a credible       threat to the physical               safety of the
          plaintiff/minor child(ren);
~     (5) The parties have agreed to the following                                  Order,   which is made without              findings
          of abuse.


THEREFORE,                 it      is hereby                    ORDERED       THAT:
~     (A-1) The defendant is prohibited from threatening, assaulting, molesting, attacking,
          harassing or otherwise abusing the plaintiff and any minor child(ren) residing in
          the household.
~     (A-2) The defendant is prohibited from the use, attemped use or threatened use of
          physical force that would reasonably be expected to cause bodily injury against
          the plaintiff or a minor child residing in the household.
~     (B) The defendant is prohibited from having any contact, direct or indirect with
            p~aintiff
            ~ Except           contact         permitted           in paragraph     I and/or   0 below
            [] Except
                            ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
~     (C) The defendant                  is prohibited             from going upon the premises                of the plaintiff's
            residence.
~     (D)   The defendant is restrained from, repeatedly and without reasonable cause,
            following the plaintiff.
~     (E)   The defendant is restrained from, repeatedly and without reasonable cause, being at
            or in the vicinity of the plaintiff's home, school, business or place of employment.
~     (F)   The defendant is prohibited from possession of a firearm or other dangerous weapon.
~     (G)   The plaintiff is granted possession of and the defendant is excluded forthwith and
            prohibited from entering the residence at 28 FRANKLIN TERRACE, SOUTH PORTLAND ME

[&J   (H)


            ~                                                                                                                                             leclvt.
            and                                                                                 is entered:                '<>7   II   .~~-   ••••.




~     (I) The plaintiff is awarded temporary parental rights and responsibilities                                                 (custody)
          of minor child (ren) , whose names and dates of birth are as follows:                                                                       _
                  !l1dCl. 1'1a.er1ko,                   diD))        JI/;J..q/ow
            The defendant's                  rights



              -5lc..      oc.c.I,...l-
              O~           -per-50/
              .she,-     0. ~o     k
PA-009,       ~v.      08/2007       #..'!ire          o[ re.
                I.....e.Sc1.~f     <!r    7/1.••.rJc    c..y
Location             PORTLAND          DISTRICT      COURT
Docket       No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605
                                                                                                        <,
                                                                                                             -- ~-.--
VIOLATION OF AN ORDER CONTAINED IN PARAGRAPHS (A) THROUGH (I) IS
ALWAYS A CLASS Dr AND SOMETIMES A CLASS C CRIME.
POSSESSION OF A FIREARM OR. AMMuNITION WHILE THIS ORDER IS IN EFFECT
IS PROHIBITED UNDER FEDERAL AND/OR STATE LAW IF ANY ONE OR MORE OF
THE FOLLOWING BOXES HAVE BEEN CHECKED: A-I, A-2, OR F.

It is further ORDERED                                 AS FOLLOWS:           (only checked boxes apply)
[] (J) The defendant                     shall pay child        support   pursuant to the attached child support
             order.
~      (K)




[]     (L)                                                                         per   (week) (month) toward              the support        of


~      (M) The                                                                     with or destroying plaintiff's                   property.
[]     (N) The                                                                     goods are divided as follows:



             and the following                  order for protection       of property     is entered:                                          _



~      (0)


~(P)
             I/)Ih(o,o,:t<...y ,    'tu   ti.J CGUy£L', W~O Sh",,11 n,,€I' 1'I?v'lS1t'1   TftYM   tv   tJ'lf Otic,       . I...t2"....:x1U-ct-,

                                                                            as a direct     result   of the abuse,

[]     (S) The       (defendant)             (plaintiff) pay to
                                                                    --------------------------
         the sum of $             as counsel fees; the sum of $                 as court costs.
         Payment is to be made within              days, execution to issue.
~      (T) No child support order is issued at this time (but will be ±.~.~t""tl AR ,.,eo"" ilk 11,,=·

         =:::e                    O:;:::t:::i:::!~,s::o::tf!~::r~~;tj~~~r"n* 16fflly (h~~+kr,
                        f!!:r: ~~±:d                             :      I
WARNING: VIOLATION OF PARAGRAPHS "J" THROUGH "T" MAY BE CONTEMPT OF
COURT.  THESE PARAGRAPHS ARE ALSO ENFORCEABLE AS A CIVIL JUDGMENT.

WARNING TO THE DEFENDANT: AS LONG AS THIS ORDER IS IN EFFECT,                                                                          YOU
MUST OBEY IT. NO ONE, INCLUDING THE PLAINTIFF, CAN GIVE YOU
PERMISSION TO VIOLATE THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ORDER.

     This order is effective                                       forthwith        and shall remain in
force and effect until                                              ~w~h~w~/~3~O~lO=_                                   _
unless       earlier       modified           or vacated     by order of court or, with respect              to Child Support
or Parental           Rights          and Responsibilities,         by a Case Management         Officer.     It is ORDERED
that a copy of this Order be served                           in hand on the defendant          by the following            law
enforcement agency:                                                                                                                  _



PA-009,       Rev. 08/2007                                    Page 2 of 3
Location   PORTLAND DISTRICT COURT
Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-0060S
                                                                                     <,        .:
Copies    of this order    shall be furnished     by the clerk to the law enforcement          agency   with
jurisdiction     in the location    of the plaintiff's      residence.


        This Order   is incorporated    into the docket by reference         pursuant   to M.R.Civ.p    79(a).



Date:        &/&/0 g
              / -I
                           ~iatl.:,!:·:~;~t:it~?!2~t0
                                  --.= rDepilty) Clerk
********************************************************************************************




PA-009,   Rev.   08/2007                     Page 3 of 3
STATE OF MAINE
Location      PORTLAND   DISTRICT   COURT
Docket    No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605
                                                                                      ,......   ..   ,   .


LORI M HANDRAHAN                                                 ORDER PROHIBITING
    V.                                                        POSSESSION AND REQUIRING
                                                                 RELINQUISHMENT
IGOR MALENKO                                                  OF FIREARMS AND WEAPONS
                                                              (19-A MRSA Section 4006,4007)

   Based on the complaint      and/or   the Final Order,   the defendant    is prohibited                    from
possessing any firearms and the dangerous weapon(s)           described   below   for the duration                   of
the [] Temporary  [] Final Order in this case.


   Within [] 24 hours []         hours after service of this Order, Defendant is ordered to
relinquish all firearms and any dangerous weapons listed below in the Defendant's
possession to a law enforcement officer or other individual for the duration of the order.
Description of dangerous weapons prohibited and to be relinquished:                      _




   If the firearms and/or weapons are relinquished to an individual other than a law
enforcement officer, the defendant must, within 24 hours after such relinquishment,
                                                                             /,
complete the Notice below and file it with the [] court or [] local law enforcement agency
designated in the order.


Date:        tt/IP/6lC
                         NOTICE      OF RELINQUISHMENT           OF WEAPONS

   The firearm(s) and/or dangerous weapon(s)         listed   above have been relinquished                      to an
individual whose name and address is:




   The firearm(s) and/or dangerous weapon(s) relinquished to the above named individual
are: (List each item relinquished and describe. Attach separate paper if necessary.)




   This notice is being filed with [] the court [] the law enforcement                          agency       designated
in the order, within 24 hours after said relinquishment.



Date:
                                                                          Defendant




PA-016,    Rev. 09/03                       Page 1 of 1
Reset Form


                                                                    STATE OF,MAINE                                       DISTRICT COURT
                                                                                                                         Location Portland
                                                                                                                         Docket No.                                                      _
 Plaintiff: Lori M. Handrahan
 o  individually and on behalf of:

                                                                                       COMPLAINT FOR PROTECTION
 [!I on behalf         of:                                                                     FROM ABUSE
 Mila        Malenko                                                                     (19-A M.R.S.A. §§ 4003 et seq.)

 v.
 Defendant: Igor Malenko
 o  on behalf of:
                             --------------------
    1. Plaintiff information:      Full name: ....:L::.:o:::.!r~i
                                                        ~M:..:;a::::.y.L!..H.!!a:!!n~d:!!rC!::a~h!!:a:!!n.!..._
                                                                                         __      ~                       _
Gender: 0 Female 0 Male            Date of birth: 05/30/1969
Present street address, city and telephone number: (list only your name if address is to be kept confidential and complete
form PA-015, Affidavit for Confidential Address, which can be obtained from the clerk). _~--'--                            _
 28 Franklin             Terrace,   South   Portland,   ME    04106
If different, mailing address: -------:---'-:--c~-:__--------~-------------
     2. Defendant information: Full name: ..!;lq::1.o~r
                                                     .!.!M~a~I~eC!..!n~k~o~              ----,-                                                                             _
Gender: 0 Female BMale             Date of birth: ~0~5!....:/3:::.:0~/..!...1
                                                                   ~97!...:3~           _
Race:      ~ White 0 Black 0 Asian or Pacific Islander 0 American Indian or Alaskan Native 0 Unknown
Present street address, city and telephone number: --.:u=,-,n!..!!.!.kn~o..!.'w~n!...-.         --,                                                                             _

If different, mailing address:.--:--: ~-::-:-:=-_--=-_--,c-----:-_-:-:--:--:--:--
                                  __                                              -:----=---=-
                                                                                            __   ---:-'":--    ~-:-:-         _
     3. Plaintiff's former residence (if different from above), which plaintiff has left to avoid abuse: (street address, city,
state):                                                 -=,-__ --;:::::::;-              ---;::::;:;-                       _
     4. Plaintiff's relationship to the defendant is: [lspouse; 0 former spouse; 0 father/mother of my child(ren);
o  relative; 0 former or present sexual partner; 0 presently living together. 0 dating partner; 0 victim of defendant's sexual
assault; 0 victim of defendant's stalking. If none of the above, describe relationship:

        5.    Plaintiff and defendant are the parents of the following child(ren).
                       Name                                      Date of Birth     Gender                                           Present Address
 Mila        Malenko                                          11/29/06                 _F_          28 Franklin                       Terrace,            S. Portland


     List below where and with whom the child(ren) have lived within the past 5 years.
     Name and present address of                       Dates child(ren) lived                                           Town and State where child(ren)
     person child(ren) lived with                       with that person                                                lived with that person
Plaintiff                                                     Late May 08 - present             ..:;:;:i..:...
                                                                                                           •     ..:...t-'...:;.O..:...n::.:..;la:::..:n..:...a:::2,~IV.:..:I.:::t:'--
                                                                                                                                                                               _
Plaintiff & Defendant                                         Sept 05 - late May 08              S. Portland, ME (2 mo in Budapest)
Plaintiff & Defendant                                         June 05 - Seot 05                 ..:...P-=oc..:..rt..:..:..la=nc..:..d=,~M...:...=:E'__                          _
     6.       The person who has primary physical residence of the above-named child(ren) is _P'--'-"'a
                                                                                                   .•.•
                                                                                                     ;1..Io.llt;ffll...-                                                  _

    7. Plaintiff has not been involved in any way in, and has no information about, another court case in any state
concerning the custody of the child(ren) except as follows: III Divorce or Family Matter Action
o   Protective Custody      0 Other (describe what kind of other case) :---:--                               -:---'-     _
    8. No one other than the parties has physical custody of the child(ren), or claims to have custody or visitation rights
with respect to the child(ren), except as follows:           ~                                                           _
    9. Check all of thefollowing that apply:
              o
             I am in immediate and present danger of abuse by the defendant, and I ask that the court issue a
             temporary order to protect me without prior notice to the defendant.
        Q] My child(ren) are in immediate and present danger of abuse by the defendant, and I ask that the court issue
             a temporary order to protect my minor child(ren) without prior notice to the defendant.
              o
             I am not asking for a temporary order.
PA-OOI, Rev. 08/07
10. Answer the following questions:
               Does defendant have access to a firearm? 0 Yes 0 No            Does defendant possess a firearm? 0 Yes           IIINo
               Has the defendant ever used a firearm in an intimidating, threatening or abusive way? 0 Yes III  No
               If yes, please explain: ~         ~                                  ~                                                -'--_

    11. I base my claim for protection from abuse on the following facts: Describe the abuse. State who committed the
abuse. when it occurred and who was abused. (If additional snace is needed attach another sheet.)




        12. One or both of the parties ate involved in the following related cases:
            III Divorce or Family Matter action      0 Protection from Abuse              0   Criminal Complaint
If there are any court orders awarding custody, visitation, etc. for the children or any court orders against the defendant
or any actions pending against either the plaintiff or the defendant, give details:                                       _

        13.    0       Public assistance
                                 benefits have been or are now being received for the child(ren)
               o The Department of Human Services has been contacted to set up, review, change or enforce a child support
order regarding the child(ren). (If an order has issued, a copy of the order must be attached to this complaint). If either
of the above statements is checked, you must send a copy of this complaint to the Department of Human Services, Support
Enforcement Division, Central Office Supervisor, State House Station 11, Augusta, ME 04333-0011.
     14. 0 To the personal knowledge of the undersigned, Defendant is not in the Military Service of the United States, as
defined in Article I of the "Soldiers' and Sailors' Civil Relief Act of 1940" as amended. This fact is evidenced by the
following facts as to residence, employment, etc.:                                                                          _

        THEREFORE,              I ASK THE COURT TO:
!!1     (a)     Order the defendant to stop abusing me and my minor child(ren) living in the household.
o       (b)     Order the defendant to have no contact with me, directly or indirectly E:J or my minor children.
1!1     (c)     Order the defendant not to enter my separate residence.
[!]     (d)     Order the defendant to refrain from repeatedly, and without reasonable cause, following me or being at, or
                in the vicinity of, my home, school, business or place of employment.
El (e)          Order the defendant not to possess or use a firearm or dangerous weapon.
o       (f)     Give me possession of and order the defendant to leave immediately and not again enter my residence
                located at: 28 Franklin Terrace, S. Portland, ME
o       (g)     Give me possession of the following personal and household property:


o     (h)       Award me custody of the following    child(ren)   (names and ages):   Mila Malenko, 1 year old.


III   (i)       Give the defendant the following visitation rights with the child(ren): Supervised visitation with an appropriate
                professional supervisor pending the GAL's investigation and recommendations       in the family matter and thereafter
                such contact as may be agreed upon or ordered in the family matter.
!ZI   (j)       Order the defendant to receive counseling, to pay support for me and/or our child(ren), pay damages for lost

0.    (k)       Other relief requested: Return of daughter's passport to Plaintiff.   V
                wages or injuries, pay court costs and attorney fees, and enter any ot~ecessary      orders.



Date:         6/6/08                   .              .                    -="7~i:.".;~~;·-·---;>,,£/~-____:=--=~::::::====--
                                                                                           ~laintiff
         Personally appeared the above named Plaintiff and                             oath to the truth of the statements   in the above
complaint, before me,

Date:       6/6/08
                                                                                                 _Cl~n
I am seeking an order for protection from abuse against my husband, Igor Malenko, on
behalf of our daughter, Mila, because I am very afraid for her safety based his history of
physically abusing me with Mila in my arms and without regard to her safety, throwing
things at me that could easily have hit her instead, again without regard to her safety,
delusions he has suffered at times that cause me to be concerned about his ability to
safely care for her when he is one of those states, and his even mistaking her for the dog
on one occasion while in a state.

My fear and request for protection are based in part on the following history:

Igor has a long history of violence, not just against me but against others. At the age of
16, he knocked a classmate into a coma and was ordered to obtain psychological
treatment. After that, Igor suffered incredible atrocities that are not his fault, but that
have left him even more dangerous. He was a member of the JNA, the Yugoslav
National Army, and was severely tortured in the Balkan war, which was known for its
~"L.~ ••• ~L.~L~l~LJ'   .'~~ ~.~~~lL,   1.~ ••~~ r'   11(")I(")01(,.l'Il
                                                                 nl«('.nl'l-rl)"A
                                                                                l'Inn «DAnTTlrnAln l'I
psychiatric hospital, and has been diagnosed subsequently with PTSD by True North. I
also believe he suffers from bipolar disorder, although I am not certain whether there has
ever been a formal diagnosis. There has not been one here, but might have been one in
Yugoslavia.

When Igor has been in manic states, he has, among other things, thrown things at me,
even when I have been holding the baby and nursing the baby, slapped me very hard, also
while I was nursing our baby, and thrown a jar at my head. While we were living in
Budapest last year, he also repeatedly threatened to kill me, forcing me to flee the country
where I had a tenure track academic position. At other times, when Igor is not in a manic
state, he can seem quite fine, and I have repeatedly taken him back based on promises he
would seek appropriate help or treatment, was sorry, would not behave that way again,
and also based on my feeling that my daughter needs her father in her life but that her
safety could only be assured by my being there as well.

Igor is once again in a manic state, and I am very fearful what he might do. Just two
weeks ago, he forced open my bedroom door (which I had blocked) while my daughter
and I were asleep, terrifying me, demanding to kiss our sleeping daughter, and making
threats if I do anything to "take his daughrer" fmrn him l-iA t1;t1 n(")t«nA('.;fvmbt hA
would do, but based on the past specific threats to kill me and past violence during manic
attacks, I am extremely concerned by these threats. Also, while the threats were phrased
in a conditional way of "if I" did something, he has a history of misperceiving situations
and could take almost anything as an effort to ''take his daughter," including this
Complaint, especially now that I am seeking protection on our daughter's behalf, which I
was trying to avoid on the advice of counsel in order to avoid triggering him if I could
otherwise provide for her safety.

Without a protection from abuse order, I do not believe that my daughter will be safe or
that anything will keep him from grabbing Our daughter since he has made it clear that he
intends to do exactly that if there is only an order with respect to me that does not
expressly apply to our daughter. Even with a protection from abuse order, I will be very
nervous for Mila's safety because Igor's actions tend not to be premeditated but instead
impulsive. But the order should ensure an ability for supervised contact that will permit
her to be safe while ensuring they are still able to have contact and maintain a
relationship.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Houston county carries concealed
Houston county carries concealedHouston county carries concealed
Houston county carries concealedKelly Burke
 
Originating summons and affidavit
Originating summons  and affidavitOriginating summons  and affidavit
Originating summons and affidavitPerkins Abaje
 
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitPreliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitIntan Muhammad
 
Transcript of pretrial detention hearing
Transcript of pretrial detention hearingTranscript of pretrial detention hearing
Transcript of pretrial detention hearingCocoselul Inaripat
 
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plc
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications PlcStephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plc
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plcproverbs6_31
 

La actualidad más candente (8)

Houston county carries concealed
Houston county carries concealedHouston county carries concealed
Houston county carries concealed
 
Originating summons and affidavit
Originating summons  and affidavitOriginating summons  and affidavit
Originating summons and affidavit
 
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suitPreliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
Preliminary matters to be considered before commencing a civil suit
 
Transcript of pretrial detention hearing
Transcript of pretrial detention hearingTranscript of pretrial detention hearing
Transcript of pretrial detention hearing
 
Doc. 127
Doc. 127Doc. 127
Doc. 127
 
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plc
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications PlcStephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plc
Stephen A. Odeyemi Vs Nigeria Telecommunications Plc
 
Immig reg
Immig regImmig reg
Immig reg
 
Doc. 126 2
Doc. 126 2Doc. 126 2
Doc. 126 2
 

Destacado

Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii ChildabuseMaine
 
Igor malenko emails in 2011
Igor malenko emails in 2011Igor malenko emails in 2011
Igor malenko emails in 2011ChildabuseMaine
 
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3Transcript to disqual waxman part 3
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3ChildabuseMaine
 
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simone
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simoneSteve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simone
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simoneChildabuseMaine
 
Moskowitz february 2011 decision
Moskowitz february 2011 decisionMoskowitz february 2011 decision
Moskowitz february 2011 decisionChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1Transcript to disqual waxman part 1
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1ChildabuseMaine
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ChildabuseMaine
 

Destacado (9)

Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ii
 
Eli newberger harvard
Eli newberger harvardEli newberger harvard
Eli newberger harvard
 
Igor malenko emails in 2011
Igor malenko emails in 2011Igor malenko emails in 2011
Igor malenko emails in 2011
 
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1
Spurwink report of mila's sex abuse report 1
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3Transcript to disqual waxman part 3
Transcript to disqual waxman part 3
 
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simone
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simoneSteve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simone
Steve pickering's record of may 23 2011 dr simone
 
Moskowitz february 2011 decision
Moskowitz february 2011 decisionMoskowitz february 2011 decision
Moskowitz february 2011 decision
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1Transcript to disqual waxman part 1
Transcript to disqual waxman part 1
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i
 

Similar a Igor's nolo contende to domestic abuse 2008

Similar a Igor's nolo contende to domestic abuse 2008 (6)

WATERSHED: Trillion-Dollar Lawsuit Could End Financial Tyranny
WATERSHED: Trillion-Dollar Lawsuit Could End Financial TyrannyWATERSHED: Trillion-Dollar Lawsuit Could End Financial Tyranny
WATERSHED: Trillion-Dollar Lawsuit Could End Financial Tyranny
 
The Dragon Family Lawsuit
The Dragon Family Lawsuit The Dragon Family Lawsuit
The Dragon Family Lawsuit
 
The Dragon Family Lawsuit
The Dragon Family Lawsuit The Dragon Family Lawsuit
The Dragon Family Lawsuit
 
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF AMENDED PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL WITH SANCTIONS
BRIEF  IN SUPPORT OF AMENDED PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL WITH SANCTIONSBRIEF  IN SUPPORT OF AMENDED PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL WITH SANCTIONS
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF AMENDED PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO COMPEL WITH SANCTIONS
 
Ip remedies
Ip remediesIp remedies
Ip remedies
 
Tort - Kacau ganggu (Nuisance)
Tort - Kacau ganggu (Nuisance)Tort - Kacau ganggu (Nuisance)
Tort - Kacau ganggu (Nuisance)
 

Más de ChildabuseMaine

Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001
Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001
Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001ChildabuseMaine
 
Trevor letter about waxman0001
Trevor letter about waxman0001Trevor letter about waxman0001
Trevor letter about waxman0001ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2Transcript to disqual waxman part 2
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 4
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 4Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 4
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 4ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 2
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 2Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 2
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 2ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 1
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 1Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 1
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 1ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 3
Transcript pfh  vol 1   part 3Transcript pfh  vol 1   part 3
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 3ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume v
Transcript divorce hearing volume vTranscript divorce hearing volume v
Transcript divorce hearing volume vChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume iii
Transcript divorce hearing volume iiiTranscript divorce hearing volume iii
Transcript divorce hearing volume iiiChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1ChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume i
Transcript divorce hearing volume iTranscript divorce hearing volume i
Transcript divorce hearing volume iChildabuseMaine
 
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1ChildabuseMaine
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i iaSpurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i iaChildabuseMaine
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume iaSpurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume iaChildabuseMaine
 

Más de ChildabuseMaine (20)

Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001
Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001
Mila's picture of the rock poppa and michael sniff0001
 
Trevor letter about waxman0001
Trevor letter about waxman0001Trevor letter about waxman0001
Trevor letter about waxman0001
 
Trevor letter
Trevor letterTrevor letter
Trevor letter
 
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)
Transcript to moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (1)
 
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)
Transcript to judge moskowitz jan 2011 hearing (2)
 
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2Transcript to disqual waxman part 2
Transcript to disqual waxman part 2
 
Transcript pfh vol ii
Transcript pfh vol iiTranscript pfh vol ii
Transcript pfh vol ii
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 4
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 4Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 4
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 4
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 2
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 2Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 2
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 2
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 1
Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 1Transcript pfh  vol 1 part 1
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 1
 
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 3
Transcript pfh  vol 1   part 3Transcript pfh  vol 1   part 3
Transcript pfh vol 1 part 3
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume v
Transcript divorce hearing volume vTranscript divorce hearing volume v
Transcript divorce hearing volume v
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume iv part 2
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume iii
Transcript divorce hearing volume iiiTranscript divorce hearing volume iii
Transcript divorce hearing volume iii
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 2
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1
Transcript divorce hearing volume ii part 1
 
Transcript divorce hearing volume i
Transcript divorce hearing volume iTranscript divorce hearing volume i
Transcript divorce hearing volume i
 
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1
Transcript dirvoce hearing volume iv part 1
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i iaSpurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume i ia
 
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume iaSpurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ia
Spurwink pfa hearing transcript volume ia
 

Igor's nolo contende to domestic abuse 2008

  • 1. FOR YOulZ RECORDS STATE OF MAINE Location PORTLAND DISTRICT COURT Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605 •..•... LORI M HANDRAHAN ORDER FOR PROTECTION V. FROM ABUSE 19-A M.R.S.A. section 4007 IGOR MALENKO After due notice and ~ opportunity for full hearing [] full hearing on the merits of the complaint for Protection from Abuse, the following parties being present: ~ Plaintiff ~ Defendant, THE COURT FINDS THAT: (only checked boxes apply) ~ (1) The parties are family or household members; [] (2) The parties are dating partners or plaintiff is a victim of defendant's sexual assault or stalking. [] (3) The plaintiff was abused by the defendant; [] (4) The defendant presents a credible threat to the physical safety of the plaintiff/minor child(ren); ~ (5) The parties have agreed to the following Order, which is made without findings of abuse. THEREFORE, it is hereby ORDERED THAT: ~ (A-1) The defendant is prohibited from threatening, assaulting, molesting, attacking, harassing or otherwise abusing the plaintiff and any minor child(ren) residing in the household. ~ (A-2) The defendant is prohibited from the use, attemped use or threatened use of physical force that would reasonably be expected to cause bodily injury against the plaintiff or a minor child residing in the household. ~ (B) The defendant is prohibited from having any contact, direct or indirect with p~aintiff ~ Except contact permitted in paragraph I and/or 0 below [] Except ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ~ (C) The defendant is prohibited from going upon the premises of the plaintiff's residence. ~ (D) The defendant is restrained from, repeatedly and without reasonable cause, following the plaintiff. ~ (E) The defendant is restrained from, repeatedly and without reasonable cause, being at or in the vicinity of the plaintiff's home, school, business or place of employment. ~ (F) The defendant is prohibited from possession of a firearm or other dangerous weapon. ~ (G) The plaintiff is granted possession of and the defendant is excluded forthwith and prohibited from entering the residence at 28 FRANKLIN TERRACE, SOUTH PORTLAND ME [&J (H) ~ leclvt. and is entered: '<>7 II .~~- ••••. ~ (I) The plaintiff is awarded temporary parental rights and responsibilities (custody) of minor child (ren) , whose names and dates of birth are as follows: _ !l1dCl. 1'1a.er1ko, diD)) JI/;J..q/ow The defendant's rights -5lc.. oc.c.I,...l- O~ -per-50/ .she,- 0. ~o k PA-009, ~v. 08/2007 #..'!ire o[ re. I.....e.Sc1.~f <!r 7/1.••.rJc c..y
  • 2. Location PORTLAND DISTRICT COURT Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605 <, -- ~-.-- VIOLATION OF AN ORDER CONTAINED IN PARAGRAPHS (A) THROUGH (I) IS ALWAYS A CLASS Dr AND SOMETIMES A CLASS C CRIME. POSSESSION OF A FIREARM OR. AMMuNITION WHILE THIS ORDER IS IN EFFECT IS PROHIBITED UNDER FEDERAL AND/OR STATE LAW IF ANY ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING BOXES HAVE BEEN CHECKED: A-I, A-2, OR F. It is further ORDERED AS FOLLOWS: (only checked boxes apply) [] (J) The defendant shall pay child support pursuant to the attached child support order. ~ (K) [] (L) per (week) (month) toward the support of ~ (M) The with or destroying plaintiff's property. [] (N) The goods are divided as follows: and the following order for protection of property is entered: _ ~ (0) ~(P) I/)Ih(o,o,:t<...y , 'tu ti.J CGUy£L', W~O Sh",,11 n,,€I' 1'I?v'lS1t'1 TftYM tv tJ'lf Otic, . I...t2"....:x1U-ct-, as a direct result of the abuse, [] (S) The (defendant) (plaintiff) pay to -------------------------- the sum of $ as counsel fees; the sum of $ as court costs. Payment is to be made within days, execution to issue. ~ (T) No child support order is issued at this time (but will be ±.~.~t""tl AR ,.,eo"" ilk 11,,=· =:::e O:;:::t:::i:::!~,s::o::tf!~::r~~;tj~~~r"n* 16fflly (h~~+kr, f!!:r: ~~±:d : I WARNING: VIOLATION OF PARAGRAPHS "J" THROUGH "T" MAY BE CONTEMPT OF COURT. THESE PARAGRAPHS ARE ALSO ENFORCEABLE AS A CIVIL JUDGMENT. WARNING TO THE DEFENDANT: AS LONG AS THIS ORDER IS IN EFFECT, YOU MUST OBEY IT. NO ONE, INCLUDING THE PLAINTIFF, CAN GIVE YOU PERMISSION TO VIOLATE THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ORDER. This order is effective forthwith and shall remain in force and effect until ~w~h~w~/~3~O~lO=_ _ unless earlier modified or vacated by order of court or, with respect to Child Support or Parental Rights and Responsibilities, by a Case Management Officer. It is ORDERED that a copy of this Order be served in hand on the defendant by the following law enforcement agency: _ PA-009, Rev. 08/2007 Page 2 of 3
  • 3. Location PORTLAND DISTRICT COURT Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-0060S <, .: Copies of this order shall be furnished by the clerk to the law enforcement agency with jurisdiction in the location of the plaintiff's residence. This Order is incorporated into the docket by reference pursuant to M.R.Civ.p 79(a). Date: &/&/0 g / -I ~iatl.:,!:·:~;~t:it~?!2~t0 --.= rDepilty) Clerk ******************************************************************************************** PA-009, Rev. 08/2007 Page 3 of 3
  • 4. STATE OF MAINE Location PORTLAND DISTRICT COURT Docket No. PORDC-PA-2008-00605 ,...... .. , . LORI M HANDRAHAN ORDER PROHIBITING V. POSSESSION AND REQUIRING RELINQUISHMENT IGOR MALENKO OF FIREARMS AND WEAPONS (19-A MRSA Section 4006,4007) Based on the complaint and/or the Final Order, the defendant is prohibited from possessing any firearms and the dangerous weapon(s) described below for the duration of the [] Temporary [] Final Order in this case. Within [] 24 hours [] hours after service of this Order, Defendant is ordered to relinquish all firearms and any dangerous weapons listed below in the Defendant's possession to a law enforcement officer or other individual for the duration of the order. Description of dangerous weapons prohibited and to be relinquished: _ If the firearms and/or weapons are relinquished to an individual other than a law enforcement officer, the defendant must, within 24 hours after such relinquishment, /, complete the Notice below and file it with the [] court or [] local law enforcement agency designated in the order. Date: tt/IP/6lC NOTICE OF RELINQUISHMENT OF WEAPONS The firearm(s) and/or dangerous weapon(s) listed above have been relinquished to an individual whose name and address is: The firearm(s) and/or dangerous weapon(s) relinquished to the above named individual are: (List each item relinquished and describe. Attach separate paper if necessary.) This notice is being filed with [] the court [] the law enforcement agency designated in the order, within 24 hours after said relinquishment. Date: Defendant PA-016, Rev. 09/03 Page 1 of 1
  • 5. Reset Form STATE OF,MAINE DISTRICT COURT Location Portland Docket No. _ Plaintiff: Lori M. Handrahan o individually and on behalf of: COMPLAINT FOR PROTECTION [!I on behalf of: FROM ABUSE Mila Malenko (19-A M.R.S.A. §§ 4003 et seq.) v. Defendant: Igor Malenko o on behalf of: -------------------- 1. Plaintiff information: Full name: ....:L::.:o:::.!r~i ~M:..:;a::::.y.L!..H.!!a:!!n~d:!!rC!::a~h!!:a:!!n.!..._ __ ~ _ Gender: 0 Female 0 Male Date of birth: 05/30/1969 Present street address, city and telephone number: (list only your name if address is to be kept confidential and complete form PA-015, Affidavit for Confidential Address, which can be obtained from the clerk). _~--'-- _ 28 Franklin Terrace, South Portland, ME 04106 If different, mailing address: -------:---'-:--c~-:__--------~------------- 2. Defendant information: Full name: ..!;lq::1.o~r .!.!M~a~I~eC!..!n~k~o~ ----,- _ Gender: 0 Female BMale Date of birth: ~0~5!....:/3:::.:0~/..!...1 ~97!...:3~ _ Race: ~ White 0 Black 0 Asian or Pacific Islander 0 American Indian or Alaskan Native 0 Unknown Present street address, city and telephone number: --.:u=,-,n!..!!.!.kn~o..!.'w~n!...-. --, _ If different, mailing address:.--:--: ~-::-:-:=-_--=-_--,c-----:-_-:-:--:--:--:-- __ -:----=---=- __ ---:-'":-- ~-:-:- _ 3. Plaintiff's former residence (if different from above), which plaintiff has left to avoid abuse: (street address, city, state): -=,-__ --;:::::::;- ---;::::;:;- _ 4. Plaintiff's relationship to the defendant is: [lspouse; 0 former spouse; 0 father/mother of my child(ren); o relative; 0 former or present sexual partner; 0 presently living together. 0 dating partner; 0 victim of defendant's sexual assault; 0 victim of defendant's stalking. If none of the above, describe relationship: 5. Plaintiff and defendant are the parents of the following child(ren). Name Date of Birth Gender Present Address Mila Malenko 11/29/06 _F_ 28 Franklin Terrace, S. Portland List below where and with whom the child(ren) have lived within the past 5 years. Name and present address of Dates child(ren) lived Town and State where child(ren) person child(ren) lived with with that person lived with that person Plaintiff Late May 08 - present ..:;:;:i..:... • ..:...t-'...:;.O..:...n::.:..;la:::..:n..:...a:::2,~IV.:..:I.:::t:'-- _ Plaintiff & Defendant Sept 05 - late May 08 S. Portland, ME (2 mo in Budapest) Plaintiff & Defendant June 05 - Seot 05 ..:...P-=oc..:..rt..:..:..la=nc..:..d=,~M...:...=:E'__ _ 6. The person who has primary physical residence of the above-named child(ren) is _P'--'-"'a .•.• ;1..Io.llt;ffll...- _ 7. Plaintiff has not been involved in any way in, and has no information about, another court case in any state concerning the custody of the child(ren) except as follows: III Divorce or Family Matter Action o Protective Custody 0 Other (describe what kind of other case) :---:-- -:---'- _ 8. No one other than the parties has physical custody of the child(ren), or claims to have custody or visitation rights with respect to the child(ren), except as follows: ~ _ 9. Check all of thefollowing that apply: o I am in immediate and present danger of abuse by the defendant, and I ask that the court issue a temporary order to protect me without prior notice to the defendant. Q] My child(ren) are in immediate and present danger of abuse by the defendant, and I ask that the court issue a temporary order to protect my minor child(ren) without prior notice to the defendant. o I am not asking for a temporary order. PA-OOI, Rev. 08/07
  • 6. 10. Answer the following questions: Does defendant have access to a firearm? 0 Yes 0 No Does defendant possess a firearm? 0 Yes IIINo Has the defendant ever used a firearm in an intimidating, threatening or abusive way? 0 Yes III No If yes, please explain: ~ ~ ~ -'--_ 11. I base my claim for protection from abuse on the following facts: Describe the abuse. State who committed the abuse. when it occurred and who was abused. (If additional snace is needed attach another sheet.) 12. One or both of the parties ate involved in the following related cases: III Divorce or Family Matter action 0 Protection from Abuse 0 Criminal Complaint If there are any court orders awarding custody, visitation, etc. for the children or any court orders against the defendant or any actions pending against either the plaintiff or the defendant, give details: _ 13. 0 Public assistance benefits have been or are now being received for the child(ren) o The Department of Human Services has been contacted to set up, review, change or enforce a child support order regarding the child(ren). (If an order has issued, a copy of the order must be attached to this complaint). If either of the above statements is checked, you must send a copy of this complaint to the Department of Human Services, Support Enforcement Division, Central Office Supervisor, State House Station 11, Augusta, ME 04333-0011. 14. 0 To the personal knowledge of the undersigned, Defendant is not in the Military Service of the United States, as defined in Article I of the "Soldiers' and Sailors' Civil Relief Act of 1940" as amended. This fact is evidenced by the following facts as to residence, employment, etc.: _ THEREFORE, I ASK THE COURT TO: !!1 (a) Order the defendant to stop abusing me and my minor child(ren) living in the household. o (b) Order the defendant to have no contact with me, directly or indirectly E:J or my minor children. 1!1 (c) Order the defendant not to enter my separate residence. [!] (d) Order the defendant to refrain from repeatedly, and without reasonable cause, following me or being at, or in the vicinity of, my home, school, business or place of employment. El (e) Order the defendant not to possess or use a firearm or dangerous weapon. o (f) Give me possession of and order the defendant to leave immediately and not again enter my residence located at: 28 Franklin Terrace, S. Portland, ME o (g) Give me possession of the following personal and household property: o (h) Award me custody of the following child(ren) (names and ages): Mila Malenko, 1 year old. III (i) Give the defendant the following visitation rights with the child(ren): Supervised visitation with an appropriate professional supervisor pending the GAL's investigation and recommendations in the family matter and thereafter such contact as may be agreed upon or ordered in the family matter. !ZI (j) Order the defendant to receive counseling, to pay support for me and/or our child(ren), pay damages for lost 0. (k) Other relief requested: Return of daughter's passport to Plaintiff. V wages or injuries, pay court costs and attorney fees, and enter any ot~ecessary orders. Date: 6/6/08 . . -="7~i:.".;~~;·-·---;>,,£/~-____:=--=~::::::====-- ~laintiff Personally appeared the above named Plaintiff and oath to the truth of the statements in the above complaint, before me, Date: 6/6/08 _Cl~n
  • 7. I am seeking an order for protection from abuse against my husband, Igor Malenko, on behalf of our daughter, Mila, because I am very afraid for her safety based his history of physically abusing me with Mila in my arms and without regard to her safety, throwing things at me that could easily have hit her instead, again without regard to her safety, delusions he has suffered at times that cause me to be concerned about his ability to safely care for her when he is one of those states, and his even mistaking her for the dog on one occasion while in a state. My fear and request for protection are based in part on the following history: Igor has a long history of violence, not just against me but against others. At the age of 16, he knocked a classmate into a coma and was ordered to obtain psychological treatment. After that, Igor suffered incredible atrocities that are not his fault, but that have left him even more dangerous. He was a member of the JNA, the Yugoslav National Army, and was severely tortured in the Balkan war, which was known for its ~"L.~ ••• ~L.~L~l~LJ' .'~~ ~.~~~lL, 1.~ ••~~ r' 11(")I(")01(,.l'Il nl«('.nl'l-rl)"A l'Inn «DAnTTlrnAln l'I psychiatric hospital, and has been diagnosed subsequently with PTSD by True North. I also believe he suffers from bipolar disorder, although I am not certain whether there has ever been a formal diagnosis. There has not been one here, but might have been one in Yugoslavia. When Igor has been in manic states, he has, among other things, thrown things at me, even when I have been holding the baby and nursing the baby, slapped me very hard, also while I was nursing our baby, and thrown a jar at my head. While we were living in Budapest last year, he also repeatedly threatened to kill me, forcing me to flee the country where I had a tenure track academic position. At other times, when Igor is not in a manic state, he can seem quite fine, and I have repeatedly taken him back based on promises he would seek appropriate help or treatment, was sorry, would not behave that way again, and also based on my feeling that my daughter needs her father in her life but that her safety could only be assured by my being there as well. Igor is once again in a manic state, and I am very fearful what he might do. Just two weeks ago, he forced open my bedroom door (which I had blocked) while my daughter and I were asleep, terrifying me, demanding to kiss our sleeping daughter, and making threats if I do anything to "take his daughrer" fmrn him l-iA t1;t1 n(")t«nA('.;fvmbt hA would do, but based on the past specific threats to kill me and past violence during manic attacks, I am extremely concerned by these threats. Also, while the threats were phrased in a conditional way of "if I" did something, he has a history of misperceiving situations and could take almost anything as an effort to ''take his daughter," including this Complaint, especially now that I am seeking protection on our daughter's behalf, which I was trying to avoid on the advice of counsel in order to avoid triggering him if I could otherwise provide for her safety. Without a protection from abuse order, I do not believe that my daughter will be safe or that anything will keep him from grabbing Our daughter since he has made it clear that he intends to do exactly that if there is only an order with respect to me that does not
  • 8. expressly apply to our daughter. Even with a protection from abuse order, I will be very nervous for Mila's safety because Igor's actions tend not to be premeditated but instead impulsive. But the order should ensure an ability for supervised contact that will permit her to be safe while ensuring they are still able to have contact and maintain a relationship.