SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 25
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Reproduction, Intention,
                          Construction and Metaphor:
                           How we create our 'World'
                                     in digital Models
                                              (with credit to Herbert Stachowiak)


Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann
Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin / Institut für Bibliotheks- und Informationswissenschaft
stefan.gradmann@ibi.hu-berlin.de


                                                                                   1
Übersicht


Modeling Strategies
   Reproduction
   Construction
   Intention
   Metaphorical and symbolic surplus building
6 Statements on Models




              How we create our 'world' in digital models                     2
     Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A normative Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     3
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A Car Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     4
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A Model Car




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     5
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Ein Model Aeroplane
(An Aeroplane Model?)




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     6
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A 'Structural Model'




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     7
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A Process Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     8
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
An Interaction Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     9
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
The World Dynamics Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     10
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
The V-Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     11
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
The V-Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     12
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
The V-Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     13
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Models as Reproductions




             How we create our 'world' in digital models                     14
    Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Models as Reproductions /
Abstractions




             How we create our 'world' in digital models                     15
    Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Pragmatic Orientation
of Models




    Kepler:
    for Children



             How we create our 'world' in digital models                     16
    Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Pragmatic Orientation
of Models




                                             Field Theory (Einstein):
                                             for Physicists




             How we create our 'world' in digital models                     17
    Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Pragmatic Orientation
of Models




                                      Philosophical-
                                      associative
             How we create our 'world' in digital models                     18
    Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A Construction Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     19
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Model vs. Metaphor: Atoms according to Bohr and
Sommerfeld – and the Universe according to Kopernikus




                    How we create our 'world' in digital models                     20
           Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
A Mythical Model




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     21
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Myth and Representation




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     22
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Myth → Metaphor




            How we create our 'world' in digital models                     23
   Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
Modelling and Scholarship




              How we create our 'world' in digital models                     24
     Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
6 Statements on Models
Models do not just represent “reality” but render a specific
view of the world.
All Models are selective: they reduce and abstract the part
of the world they represent.
Reduction and abstraction always are intentionally guided
in modelling.
Many models have a normative, prescriptive apsect in that
they are instructions for constructing 'reality'.
Powerful models often operate using substantial
metaphorical, connotative and/or symbolic surplus.
In this perspective, works of art simply are exceptionally
powerful models!



                How we create our 'world' in digital models                     25
       Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado (8)

All WP Meeting Athens - Europeana Cloud
All WP Meeting Athens - Europeana CloudAll WP Meeting Athens - Europeana Cloud
All WP Meeting Athens - Europeana Cloud
 
Linked Open Projects (DGI-Konferenz)
Linked Open Projects (DGI-Konferenz)Linked Open Projects (DGI-Konferenz)
Linked Open Projects (DGI-Konferenz)
 
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP4 presentation, Lieke Ploeger (OKF)
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP4 presentation, Lieke Ploeger (OKF)DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP4 presentation, Lieke Ploeger (OKF)
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP4 presentation, Lieke Ploeger (OKF)
 
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP2 RDF Validation, Kai Eckert (University of Ma...
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP2 RDF Validation, Kai Eckert (University of Ma...DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP2 RDF Validation, Kai Eckert (University of Ma...
DM2E Project meeting Bergen: WP2 RDF Validation, Kai Eckert (University of Ma...
 
Introduction to dm2 e final dg
Introduction to dm2 e final dgIntroduction to dm2 e final dg
Introduction to dm2 e final dg
 
Dm2 e okfn-infoday_scholarly_activities_18_nov
Dm2 e okfn-infoday_scholarly_activities_18_novDm2 e okfn-infoday_scholarly_activities_18_nov
Dm2 e okfn-infoday_scholarly_activities_18_nov
 
Pundit @ Vienna 2014
Pundit @ Vienna 2014Pundit @ Vienna 2014
Pundit @ Vienna 2014
 
Vienna 2014-11-18-dm2 e
Vienna 2014-11-18-dm2 eVienna 2014-11-18-dm2 e
Vienna 2014-11-18-dm2 e
 

Similar a Stefan Gradmann - Scholarly Modelling

Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...
Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...
Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana
 
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdfChristian M. Stracke
 
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberation
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberationA presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberation
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberationLu Xiao
 
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public Engagement
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public EngagementHow is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public Engagement
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public EngagementFergus Bisset
 
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unit
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to UnitMAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unit
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unitkozakartclass
 
Ethics and sustainability for techies
Ethics and sustainability for techiesEthics and sustainability for techies
Ethics and sustainability for techiesClaudia Melo
 

Similar a Stefan Gradmann - Scholarly Modelling (10)

Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...
Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...
Beyond Infrastructure - Stefan Gradmann (Leipzig Digital Humanities Seminar, ...
 
Emaps experts final
Emaps experts finalEmaps experts final
Emaps experts final
 
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf
20221205_Online_Education_ChrMStracke_EP.pdf
 
Maker Education
Maker EducationMaker Education
Maker Education
 
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberation
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberationA presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberation
A presentation about my recent projects on goup ideation and deliberation
 
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public Engagement
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public EngagementHow is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public Engagement
How is this relevant to me? A Human Centred Approach to Public Engagement
 
Six rules for e-participation and sucessfull collaboration
Six rules for e-participation and sucessfull collaborationSix rules for e-participation and sucessfull collaboration
Six rules for e-participation and sucessfull collaboration
 
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unit
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to UnitMAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unit
MAD Out of Hand-Intro to Unit
 
Ethics and sustainability for techies
Ethics and sustainability for techiesEthics and sustainability for techies
Ethics and sustainability for techies
 
Luddites@communication_industry
Luddites@communication_industryLuddites@communication_industry
Luddites@communication_industry
 

Más de Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana

08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01
08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate0108a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01
08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana
 
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v202 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana
 

Más de Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana (20)

DM2E community building
DM2E community buildingDM2E community building
DM2E community building
 
Reasoning with Reasoning (STRiX 2014)
Reasoning with Reasoning (STRiX 2014)Reasoning with Reasoning (STRiX 2014)
Reasoning with Reasoning (STRiX 2014)
 
Wp4 results july dec 2014
Wp4 results july dec 2014Wp4 results july dec 2014
Wp4 results july dec 2014
 
Virtual exhibition presentation pim
Virtual exhibition presentation pimVirtual exhibition presentation pim
Virtual exhibition presentation pim
 
Pisa final all_wp_121214_wp1_dg
Pisa final all_wp_121214_wp1_dgPisa final all_wp_121214_wp1_dg
Pisa final all_wp_121214_wp1_dg
 
10 wp4 community building
10 wp4 community building10 wp4 community building
10 wp4 community building
 
09 pisa finale
09 pisa finale09 pisa finale
09 pisa finale
 
08b final event_experimente
08b final event_experimente08b final event_experimente
08b final event_experimente
 
07 dm2 e_seachange
07 dm2 e_seachange07 dm2 e_seachange
07 dm2 e_seachange
 
08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01
08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate0108a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01
08a punditdm2efinaleventpisa2014 141212080409-conversion-gate01
 
06 dm2 e_pisa-wp2-no-anim
06 dm2 e_pisa-wp2-no-anim06 dm2 e_pisa-wp2-no-anim
06 dm2 e_pisa-wp2-no-anim
 
05 piotrowski
05 piotrowski05 piotrowski
05 piotrowski
 
04 pisa final_event_111214_wp1_dg
04 pisa final_event_111214_wp1_dg04 pisa final_event_111214_wp1_dg
04 pisa final_event_111214_wp1_dg
 
03 isaac dm2-e14-full
03 isaac dm2-e14-full03 isaac dm2-e14-full
03 isaac dm2-e14-full
 
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v202 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2
02 20141210 beyond_dm2_e_sustainable_digital_services_chambers_v2
 
01 welcome violeta_final_event_dm2_e_20141211
01 welcome violeta_final_event_dm2_e_2014121101 welcome violeta_final_event_dm2_e_20141211
01 welcome violeta_final_event_dm2_e_20141211
 
Wp1 2014
Wp1 2014Wp1 2014
Wp1 2014
 
The value of open data and the OpenGLAM network
The value of open data and the OpenGLAM networkThe value of open data and the OpenGLAM network
The value of open data and the OpenGLAM network
 
Dc 2014 baierer-droege
Dc 2014 baierer-droegeDc 2014 baierer-droege
Dc 2014 baierer-droege
 
Pundit2, DHAB meeting, 2 October 2014
Pundit2, DHAB meeting, 2 October 2014Pundit2, DHAB meeting, 2 October 2014
Pundit2, DHAB meeting, 2 October 2014
 

Stefan Gradmann - Scholarly Modelling

  • 1. Reproduction, Intention, Construction and Metaphor: How we create our 'World' in digital Models (with credit to Herbert Stachowiak) Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin / Institut für Bibliotheks- und Informationswissenschaft stefan.gradmann@ibi.hu-berlin.de 1
  • 2. Übersicht Modeling Strategies Reproduction Construction Intention Metaphorical and symbolic surplus building 6 Statements on Models How we create our 'world' in digital models 2 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 3. A normative Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 3 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 4. A Car Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 4 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 5. A Model Car How we create our 'world' in digital models 5 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 6. Ein Model Aeroplane (An Aeroplane Model?) How we create our 'world' in digital models 6 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 7. A 'Structural Model' How we create our 'world' in digital models 7 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 8. A Process Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 8 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 9. An Interaction Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 9 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 10. The World Dynamics Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 10 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 11. The V-Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 11 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 12. The V-Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 12 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 13. The V-Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 13 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 14. Models as Reproductions How we create our 'world' in digital models 14 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 15. Models as Reproductions / Abstractions How we create our 'world' in digital models 15 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 16. Pragmatic Orientation of Models Kepler: for Children How we create our 'world' in digital models 16 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 17. Pragmatic Orientation of Models Field Theory (Einstein): for Physicists How we create our 'world' in digital models 17 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 18. Pragmatic Orientation of Models Philosophical- associative How we create our 'world' in digital models 18 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 19. A Construction Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 19 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 20. Model vs. Metaphor: Atoms according to Bohr and Sommerfeld – and the Universe according to Kopernikus How we create our 'world' in digital models 20 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 21. A Mythical Model How we create our 'world' in digital models 21 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 22. Myth and Representation How we create our 'world' in digital models 22 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 23. Myth → Metaphor How we create our 'world' in digital models 23 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 24. Modelling and Scholarship How we create our 'world' in digital models 24 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013
  • 25. 6 Statements on Models Models do not just represent “reality” but render a specific view of the world. All Models are selective: they reduce and abstract the part of the world they represent. Reduction and abstraction always are intentionally guided in modelling. Many models have a normative, prescriptive apsect in that they are instructions for constructing 'reality'. Powerful models often operate using substantial metaphorical, connotative and/or symbolic surplus. In this perspective, works of art simply are exceptionally powerful models! How we create our 'world' in digital models 25 Prof. Dr. Stefan Gradmann, Berlin, DM2E DHAB meeting, January 21, 2013