SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 10
Can development transform conflict
in Indigenous communities?
Development Futures Conference, Sydney
20 - 21 November 2013
Sophia Close, PhD Candidate
ANU National Centre for Indigenous Studies
National Centre for Indigenous Studies
Key research question
Can Indigenous
communities better
engage with
development
systems to transform
conflict and create
self-determining
development?
National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2010
Development-related Conflict
Indigenous peoples
experience peace
and conflict in
multiple ways; my
research focuses on
conflict that is
exacerbated or
triggered by
development.
National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2010
Initial Field Results: Timor-Leste
• Timing and
sustainability
• Culture and language
• Leadership and elites
• Duplication and gaps
• Poor donor
coordination
• Many layers of
existing conflict
National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2010
Relationships

“Relationship
is
paramount.”
International Development Practitioner
2009: Interview

Source: Close 2010

National Centre for Indigenous Studies
Consent / Choice
Free prior and informed
consent is a decisionmaking process that
does not involve
coercion, is made before
interventions begin and
includes understanding
the full range of potential
impacts.

National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2013
“Capacity Building”
“We are driven by
models which do not
apply here. When
people do it
themselves they do it
better”.
Timorese Development Practitioner 2010:
Interview

National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2010
Self-determined Development
“Self-determination is
also about the right to
development…the
right to make
decisions that
determine the path
development should
take”.
(Nuttall 2008)

National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Source: Close 2010
Thank you
E-mail: sophia.close@anu.edu.au

National Centre for Indigenous Studies
Thank you
E-mail: sophia.close@anu.edu.au

National Centre for Indigenous Studies

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

April15-CitizenEngageFinal
April15-CitizenEngageFinalApril15-CitizenEngageFinal
April15-CitizenEngageFinalWilliam Tarpai
 
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared Space
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared SpaceGWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared Space
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared SpaceAlison Clyde
 
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. Communication
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. CommunicationWorldwide Telecomunications Inc. Communication
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. CommunicationAshley Kruempel
 
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)aiesecmalaysia
 
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...Dr. Kristin Palmer
 
Development cooperation forum
Development cooperation forumDevelopment cooperation forum
Development cooperation forumDr Lendy Spires
 
Development communication
Development communicationDevelopment communication
Development communicationTrinity Dwarka
 
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of poverty
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of povertyPower of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of poverty
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of povertyThe Impact Initiative
 
The future for community based education week 6
The future for community based education week 6The future for community based education week 6
The future for community based education week 6Nikcole2009
 

La actualidad más candente (10)

April15-CitizenEngageFinal
April15-CitizenEngageFinalApril15-CitizenEngageFinal
April15-CitizenEngageFinal
 
SSC2011_Mariia Zimmerman PPT
SSC2011_Mariia Zimmerman PPTSSC2011_Mariia Zimmerman PPT
SSC2011_Mariia Zimmerman PPT
 
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared Space
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared SpaceGWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared Space
GWT International Conference 2022 - Intergenerational Shared Space
 
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. Communication
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. CommunicationWorldwide Telecomunications Inc. Communication
Worldwide Telecomunications Inc. Communication
 
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)
AM1415_Marketing_Global Citizen Programme Sales Pitch (Good Case from UUM)
 
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...
HICE Online Education Outreach in Africa Creates Lasting Economic Impact and ...
 
Development cooperation forum
Development cooperation forumDevelopment cooperation forum
Development cooperation forum
 
Development communication
Development communicationDevelopment communication
Development communication
 
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of poverty
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of povertyPower of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of poverty
Power of partnership conference: Presentation: Pathways out of poverty
 
The future for community based education week 6
The future for community based education week 6The future for community based education week 6
The future for community based education week 6
 

Similar a Sophia Close - How can development transform conflict in Indigenous communities?

Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...
Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...
Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...NHSNWRD
 
Community development & its impact on life
Community development & its impact on lifeCommunity development & its impact on life
Community development & its impact on lifeMahmudul Hasan Tushar
 
What does open development mean to you?
What does open development mean to you?What does open development mean to you?
What does open development mean to you?Tim Davies
 
Conversations engaging our communities
Conversations engaging our communitiesConversations engaging our communities
Conversations engaging our communitiesN/A
 
Community Media Approches and the MDGs
Community Media Approches and the MDGsCommunity Media Approches and the MDGs
Community Media Approches and the MDGsAlfonso Gumucio
 
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through Participation
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through ParticipationUser Involvement: Implications from Pathways through Participation
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through ParticipationInvolveFoundation
 
Participatory communication
Participatory communicationParticipatory communication
Participatory communicationSwati Goyal
 
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizens
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizensLeading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizens
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizensSue Beckingham
 
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptx
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptxCivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptx
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptxaryarejal05
 
De liddo seminar-oct2021-fin
De liddo seminar-oct2021-finDe liddo seminar-oct2021-fin
De liddo seminar-oct2021-finAnna De Liddo
 
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real Time
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real TimeArab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real Time
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real TimeJennifer D. Klein
 
Collective impact presentation by kate frykberg
Collective impact presentation by kate frykbergCollective impact presentation by kate frykberg
Collective impact presentation by kate frykbergKatefnz
 
Week 2 gender and youth in africa
Week 2   gender and youth in africaWeek 2   gender and youth in africa
Week 2 gender and youth in africaLeslie Chan
 

Similar a Sophia Close - How can development transform conflict in Indigenous communities? (20)

Portfolio
PortfolioPortfolio
Portfolio
 
Working with Ryan Olson
Working with Ryan OlsonWorking with Ryan Olson
Working with Ryan Olson
 
portfolio
portfolioportfolio
portfolio
 
Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...
Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...
Let's Talk Research Annual Conference - 24th-25th September 2014 (Sue Wood & ...
 
Community development & its impact on life
Community development & its impact on lifeCommunity development & its impact on life
Community development & its impact on life
 
What does open development mean to you?
What does open development mean to you?What does open development mean to you?
What does open development mean to you?
 
Conversations engaging our communities
Conversations engaging our communitiesConversations engaging our communities
Conversations engaging our communities
 
Community Media Approches and the MDGs
Community Media Approches and the MDGsCommunity Media Approches and the MDGs
Community Media Approches and the MDGs
 
Negotiating Community Engagement: Experiences from the Whole of Community Eng...
Negotiating Community Engagement: Experiences from the Whole of Community Eng...Negotiating Community Engagement: Experiences from the Whole of Community Eng...
Negotiating Community Engagement: Experiences from the Whole of Community Eng...
 
AWOD Orientation
AWOD OrientationAWOD Orientation
AWOD Orientation
 
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through Participation
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through ParticipationUser Involvement: Implications from Pathways through Participation
User Involvement: Implications from Pathways through Participation
 
Participatory communication
Participatory communicationParticipatory communication
Participatory communication
 
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizens
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizensLeading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizens
Leading by example: being belonging and becoming digital citizens
 
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptx
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptxCivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptx
CivilityCivilDialogueLocalGovt class 11.pptx
 
De liddo seminar-oct2021-fin
De liddo seminar-oct2021-finDe liddo seminar-oct2021-fin
De liddo seminar-oct2021-fin
 
Intentional Innovation
Intentional InnovationIntentional Innovation
Intentional Innovation
 
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real Time
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real TimeArab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real Time
Arab Spring: Using Social Media to Teach in Real Time
 
Collective impact presentation by kate frykberg
Collective impact presentation by kate frykbergCollective impact presentation by kate frykberg
Collective impact presentation by kate frykberg
 
Week 2 gender and youth in africa
Week 2   gender and youth in africaWeek 2   gender and youth in africa
Week 2 gender and youth in africa
 
Bridging Communities, Building Community
Bridging Communities, Building CommunityBridging Communities, Building Community
Bridging Communities, Building Community
 

Más de Development Futures

Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securty
Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securtyRuth Phillips - Gender equality and food securty
Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securtyDevelopment Futures
 
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk Analysis
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk AnalysisTomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk Analysis
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk AnalysisDevelopment Futures
 
Brian Hilton - Food Security Advisor
Brian Hilton - Food Security AdvisorBrian Hilton - Food Security Advisor
Brian Hilton - Food Security AdvisorDevelopment Futures
 
Juliet Willetts - Research paradigms for poverty alleviation
Juliet Willetts -  Research paradigms for poverty alleviationJuliet Willetts -  Research paradigms for poverty alleviation
Juliet Willetts - Research paradigms for poverty alleviationDevelopment Futures
 
Usha Harris - Participatory Media Workshop
Usha Harris - Participatory Media WorkshopUsha Harris - Participatory Media Workshop
Usha Harris - Participatory Media WorkshopDevelopment Futures
 
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural development
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural developmentBill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural development
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural developmentDevelopment Futures
 
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid Program
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid ProgramThomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid Program
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid ProgramDevelopment Futures
 
Tim Budge - Development! Social Movements
Tim Budge - Development! Social MovementsTim Budge - Development! Social Movements
Tim Budge - Development! Social MovementsDevelopment Futures
 
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusion
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusionSuharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusion
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusionDevelopment Futures
 
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability Development Futures
 
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiaries
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiariesSusan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiaries
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiariesDevelopment Futures
 
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?Development Futures
 
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st century
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st centurySarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st century
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st centuryDevelopment Futures
 
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE Asia
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE AsiaRebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE Asia
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE AsiaDevelopment Futures
 
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approaches
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approachesPete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approaches
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approachesDevelopment Futures
 
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South Asia
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South AsiaPaul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South Asia
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South AsiaDevelopment Futures
 
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forward
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forwardPatrick Kilby: Looking back looking forward
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forwardDevelopment Futures
 
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and Development
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and DevelopmentNicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and Development
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and DevelopmentDevelopment Futures
 
Nicola Piper - More than Remittances
Nicola Piper - More than RemittancesNicola Piper - More than Remittances
Nicola Piper - More than RemittancesDevelopment Futures
 
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban Development
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban DevelopmentNayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban Development
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban DevelopmentDevelopment Futures
 

Más de Development Futures (20)

Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securty
Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securtyRuth Phillips - Gender equality and food securty
Ruth Phillips - Gender equality and food securty
 
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk Analysis
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk AnalysisTomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk Analysis
Tomas Freitas - Timor-Leste Country Risk Analysis
 
Brian Hilton - Food Security Advisor
Brian Hilton - Food Security AdvisorBrian Hilton - Food Security Advisor
Brian Hilton - Food Security Advisor
 
Juliet Willetts - Research paradigms for poverty alleviation
Juliet Willetts -  Research paradigms for poverty alleviationJuliet Willetts -  Research paradigms for poverty alleviation
Juliet Willetts - Research paradigms for poverty alleviation
 
Usha Harris - Participatory Media Workshop
Usha Harris - Participatory Media WorkshopUsha Harris - Participatory Media Workshop
Usha Harris - Participatory Media Workshop
 
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural development
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural developmentBill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural development
Bill Bellotti - An undisciplined approach to research for rural development
 
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid Program
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid ProgramThomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid Program
Thomas Davis - Research Use in Australian Aid Program
 
Tim Budge - Development! Social Movements
Tim Budge - Development! Social MovementsTim Budge - Development! Social Movements
Tim Budge - Development! Social Movements
 
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusion
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusionSuharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusion
Suharto Suharto - Community - Based Rehabiliation exclusion
 
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability
Tahira Jabeen - Citizen, Rights and Accountability
 
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiaries
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiariesSusan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiaries
Susan O'Leary- Giving voice to development beneficiaries
 
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?
Susan Harris Rimmer - Does the G20 offer a pathway to end poverty?
 
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st century
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st centurySarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st century
Sarah Cook - Rethinking social development for the 21st century
 
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE Asia
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE AsiaRebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE Asia
Rebecca Barber - Learning from Humanitarian Response in SE Asia
 
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approaches
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approachesPete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approaches
Pete Silvester - Re-configuring economic development approaches
 
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South Asia
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South AsiaPaul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South Asia
Paul Nichols - Partnerships for Sustainable Development in South Asia
 
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forward
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forwardPatrick Kilby: Looking back looking forward
Patrick Kilby: Looking back looking forward
 
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and Development
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and DevelopmentNicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and Development
Nicole Rodger - Gender in Early Childhood Care and Development
 
Nicola Piper - More than Remittances
Nicola Piper - More than RemittancesNicola Piper - More than Remittances
Nicola Piper - More than Remittances
 
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban Development
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban DevelopmentNayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban Development
Nayana Godamunne - Re-imagining Urban Development
 

Sophia Close - How can development transform conflict in Indigenous communities?