SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 52
WHY CHRONIC PAIN
      PATIENTS ARE
  MISDIAGNOSED: and how to
    make a proper diagnosis
          Course 12
   www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com
Nelson Hendler, MD, MS
Former Assistant Professor of Neurosurgery
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
Past president –American Academy of Pain Management
Missed Diagnoses-Neck and Back Pain
• Hendler et al Overlooked Physical Diagnoses in Chronic Pain
  Patients Involved in Litigation, Psychosomatics, ’93
• N= 60
• 67% were misdiagnosed “lumbar strain, cervical strain, chronic
  pain syndrome, conversion reaction.”
• Hendler, et al, Overlooked Physical Diagnoses in Chronic Pain
  Patients Involved in Litigation: Part II Psychosomatics,‘96
• N= 120
• 40% were misdiagnosed “lumbar strain, cervical strain, chronic
  pain syndrome, conversion reaction”
• These 180 patients, from two studies, really had facet syndrome,
  disrupted discs (internal disc disruption), thoracic outlet
  syndrome, nerve entrapments, and radiculopathy, confirmed by
  objective physiological testing.
Why Patients are Misdiagnosed
• Doctors don’t spend enough time with a patient taking a
  careful history.
• Doctors rely on anatomical tests, such as MRI, CT, and
  X-ray to make diagnosis
• Pain is a physiological condition.
• Physiology is measuring a response to a stimulus.
• Anatomy is taking a picture, but you can’t take picture
  of “pain.”
• If you want to know “Is the oven hot?” would you use a
  photo or a thermometer to determine this?
• Doctors need to use physiological tests, such as
  provocative discogram, facet blocks, root blocks, nerve
  blocks, bone scan, neurometer studies for sensory
  nerves, Indium 111 scans, PET scan, etc.
Cause of Misdiagnoses (cont)
• Failure to recognize that a single clinical
  manifestation may have multiple etiologies (a flat
  tire).
• Failure to realize a single pathological condition
  may have multiple clinical manifestations (Lyme
  disease)
• Failure to take a careful history.
• Failure to understand the specificity and
  sensitivity of tests.
• Relying on anatomical tests to make a diagnosis
  rather than clinical judgment or physiological
  tests.
• Not believing a patient.
Example of Flaws of Anatomical Tests
•   ANATOMICAL TESTING BENEFIT:
•   I have a pain in my thumb.
•   Take a picture and find a vise on my thumb.
•   Perform “visectomy” and the pain goes away.
•   BUT - ANATOMICAL TESTING FAILURE:
•   I have a pain in my thumb.
•   I have hit my thumb many times with a hammer
•   Take a picture, but no hammer is seen
•   What caused the pain? You have to ask why.
•   This demonstrates the need for a careful history
“Misdiagnosed” Definition
• Many patients are misdiagnosed. What is that?
• Misdiagnosis: The referring physician has not
  mentioned a certain diagnosis (overlooked).
• The referring physician has used a descriptive
  “diagnosis” such as “low back pain.”
• The referring physician has offered a wrong diagnosis
  without any objective data to support it, i.e. RSD,
  lumbar strain, fibromyalgia, psychogenic pain,
  fibromyalgia, etc.
• The www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com
  Diagnostic Paradigm establishes a diagnosis, previously
  unmentioned by referring physicians, which can be
  documented by objective or interactive (blocks,
  provocative discograms, etc.) testing.
What is Evidence Based Medicine?
It is using scientific evidence to prove a point.
 • Meta analysis is a review of medical literature.
 • Epidemiology reviews the incidence (number of new
   cases a year) and prevalence (number of cases at any
   one time) of a disease. It is the basis of actuarial data.
 • Outcome studies report the results of surgery or
   interventions. Selection criteria can influence results.
 • Population definitions can alter results. There are
   clinics that will not see claimants with active
   litigation. Other clinics count “return to work” as
   being back on the job only one day. There are
   regional, genetic, and sociological differences, such
   as educational background, training, language
   fluency, age, etc. that influence reported results.
Flaws in Meta-Analysis Research
• Richard Payne, MD (Clin. J. of Pain, ’86) at
  Cornell-Memorial Sloan Kettering did a meta
  analysis of patients with surgical sympathectomies
  for the treatment of causalgia (CPRS II).
• He found the success rates reported in the
  literature ranged from 12% to 97%.
• Sources of flaws in this analysis: diagnostic
  criteria for causalgia, outcome criteria, surgical
  skill, litigation, etc.? Each article was different.
What is a “Chronic Pain Patient?”
• Chronic Pain Patient –each article is like
  blind men describing an elephant. Each
  reports only what was seen in their clinical
  setting, but never sees the entire population.
• The type of patient is rarely mentioned in the
  literature, i.e., litigant versus non-litigant.
• Selection criteria for a patient population is
  essential for determining proper intervention
  and meaningful outcomes.
Waddell Signs as part of a physical exam
• Waddell signs are five physical tests, like hitting a
  patient on the head to see if their low back hurts, etc.
• Fishbain, et. al., (Pain Medicine, vol. 4, ’03) did a meta
  analysis of 61 studies that reported using Waddell signs.
• Positive Waddell signs do not correlate with
  malingering, secondary gain, hysteria, psychological
  distress, abnormal illness behavior, nor somatic
  amplification
• They do not discriminate organic vs. non-organic
  problems, but they are misused that way.
• They do predict poor treatment outcome.
• There may be a real organic basis for positive signs.
Types of Tests Used for Validating
   Pain and What They Measure
• Anatomical Tests: MRI, CT, 3D-CT, X-ray,
  discogram, myelogram – a picture.
• Physiological Tests: Flex-Ex. X-rays, bone
  scan, nerve blocks, root blocks, facet
  blocks, provocative discogram, gallium
  scan, Indium 111 scan, phentolamine test,
  EMG/NCV, neurometers, 2 poster brace,
  body jacket with thigh spika- a response.
Anatomical Versus Physiological
• Anatomical               • Physiological
• Takes a picture of the   • Measures body
  body.                      response- interactive.
• EXAMPLE                  • EXAMPLE
• Oven on wall.            • Oven on wall.
• Take a picture.          • Put thermometer in
• Look at picture.           oven.
• Can you tell if the      • Look at thermometer.
  oven is hot?             • It says 375 F. Is it hot?
Specificity versus Sensitivity
• Sensitive Test                • Specific Test
• Always detects presence       • When positive, it detects
  of a disease.                   only the disease in
• However, may also report        question.
  other diseases as the first   • May overlook mild or
  disease.                        variant forms of the
• Very sensitive, but not so      disease.
  specific- gives false         • Very specific, but not so
  positive readings               sensitive- gives false
• Tine test for TB.               negative results.
                                • Mantou test for TB.
Specificity versus Sensitivity
• Sensitive Test               • Specific Test
•                              • Let’s catch a tuna.
  Let’s catch a tuna.
                               • Use a big mesh net.
• Use a small mesh net.
                               • Everything in net will be
• Will catch a lot of fish,      tuna.
  and never miss a tuna.       • Will catch large tuna, but
• Definitely will catch a        small tuna, mackerel,
  tuna, but will also get        perch, and spot will not be
  mackerel, perch and spot,      in net, so no further
  which will require further     sorting needed. Will miss
  sorting.                       some small tuna we would
                                 have wanted to keep.
• False positive results.      • False negative results.
• Sensitive but not specific
                               • Specific but not sensitive
Flaws with Cervical Radiographs
• Peterson, et. al. (Spine # 28 (2) pp 129-33, ’03).
• 180 patients, mean age 49, 44% male rated pain
  on VAS 0-10 scale & Neck Disability Index
• Neck pain divided into no injury, injury (40.6%)
  and those with litigation (5.1%).
• No correlation between levels of degeneration, or
  severity, and self rated pain or disability ratings.
• Patients with injury had more pain and disability,
  than patients without injury.
• Women reported more pain and disability.
Flaws with Static Cervical X-rays
• Most patients complain of worse pain when they
  lean forward or backwards.
• Static (upright) X-rays do not demonstrate
  movement between the vertebral bodies.
• Flexion-Extension X-rays show what happens to
  the vertebral bodies when there is motion forward
  and backwards.
• Like a partially broken twig- the defect is not
  evident until the twig is put under tension.
Flaws with Just Anatomical Tests
• MRI- Jensen et. al. N. Eng J. Med, ’94, 98
  patients with no back pain, but 27 had
  protruding disc (28% false positive rate).
• MRI with Modic (vertebral end plate
  changes)-21/23 patients had + provocative
  discograms. BUT- in 90 patients with
  positive provocative discograms, only 23%
  had Modic changes, and 77% no changes in
  MRI. (Braithwaite, et al, Eur. Spine J. ’98).
  Therefore a 77% false negative rate for
  MRI
Anatomy and Physiology of a Disc
• A disc is like a jelly donut.
• Pain fibers are found in the rear 1/3 of the annulus
  (donut) (Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and Clinical Management,
  Vol. 13, p.121,Elsevier, 2002)
• A herniated disc has the jelly (nucleus polposa)
  protrude from the donut (annulus).
• Pain fibers can be disrupted, without any anatomical
  distortion of the annulus, so the MRI, CT and
  Myelogram are normal. (Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and
  Clinical Management, Vol. 13, p.119-122,Elsevier, 2002)
• Pain from internal disc disruption (IDD) feels like a
  herniated disc pushing on a nerve root with pain in a
  radicular distribution.(Bogduk and McGuirk, ibid).
Herniated Disc vs. Internal Disc Disruption (IDD)
(Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and Clinical Management, Vol. 13,
                     p.119-122,Elsevier, 2002)


• Herniated Disc                  Internal Disc Disruption

                              C                                  C
                              O                                  O
                              R                                  R
                              D                                  D




  MRI- shows disc herniation               MRI -no disc herniation
  and cord compression                     nor cord compression
Provocative Discograms
• A physiological test, not an anatomical test.
• Saline is injected into the donut (annulus)
  portion of the disc, where the pain fibers are.
• This injection distends the pain fibers.
• If this injection reproduces the pain in the
  distribution the patient normally feels pain, this
  is a positive test.
• Local anesthetic injected into the damaged disc
  take away the pain the patient normally feels.
Disc Anatomy and Provocative Discogram:
Saline injection reproduces the pain, confirming
   disc damage due to IDD, not seen on MRI
    Normal Disc            Internally Disrupted Disc (IDD),
                           with normal MRI


                                                            Pain
                  Pain
 Herniated Disc                                             Fibers
                                Internally Disrupted Disc
                  Fibers        (IDD), with normal MRI

                                                     Needle


      Annulus                                        Provocative
                                                     Discogram
      Nucleus Pulposa          Saline
Comparison Herniated Disc versus IDD
 • Herniated Disc     • Internal Disc Disruption

                    Annulus




                    Nucleus
                    polpulsa
 Pain Fibers                   Pain Fibers
Further Debate on MRI vs Discogram
• 53 pts. with pain had both MRI and
  provocative discograms. 79.5% and 74.4%
  of patients with concordant pain on
  provocative discograms had no endplate
  changes (Modic) on T1 and T2 MRI images
  (Sandhu, et al, J. Spinal Disord, 2000).
• In 54 pts without pain, 24% had a “high
  intensity zone on MRI. Provocative
  discogram were + 69% of pts with Modic
  changes, and + 10% of pts without MRI
  findings. (Carragee et al, Spine, 2000).
Further Debate on MRI vs Discogram
          (Simmons, et al, Spine ’91).

 • 164 patients with back pain.
 • MRI abnormalities and + provocative
   discograms were found in 90/164 pts
   (55%).
 • MRI and provocative discograms
   differed in 74/164 (45%) of the
   patients.
 • 108 discs on MRI classified as
   abnormal were asymptomatic (37%).
Errors in MRI interpretation for
       Symptomatic Discs
• False + rate - MRI is 24%-37% in pts
  without pain.
• False neg. rate - MRI in pts with +
  provocative discograms ranges from
  77%-79%.
• False positive rate for provocative
  discogram is 10%, i.e. produced pain
  at an asymptomatic disc.
EMG/NCV: The wrong physiological test. Patient
                 has pain (sensory) not weakness (motor)
        Motor fibers       Sensory fibers        Damaged                    compression
                                                 sensory fibers
 • Cross section of nerve,                      • Cross section of nerve,
   normal                                           damaged by compression




EMG/nerve conduction measures gross electrical activity of a nerve. 90% of electrical activity is
from motor fibers. It takes a lot of pressure for a long time to damage motor nerves. Small sensory
fibers can be easily damaged in a short period of time, but since they have so little electrical
activity, the damage doesn’t show up on EMG/nerve conduction studies. Current perception
threshold test (Neurometer studies) can measure sensory fiber activity
3D-CT versus Regular CT
   (Zinreich, Long & Davis: J. Comput Assist. Tomography 1990)

• Study of 100 patients, without previous surgeries,
  with negative direct axial CT or 2-D multiplanar
  CT reconstructions.
• 3D-CT reconstructions found occult boney
  pathology 56% of time missed by CT.
• Study of 100 patients, with previous fusion, with
  negative direct axial CT or 2-D multiplanar CT
  reconstructions.
• 3D-CT reconstructions found occult boney
  pathology 76% of time missed by CT.
Sprains and Strains
• Sprains are defined as stretching ligaments which hold joints
  together (Bonica and Teitz -The Management of Pain p 375,
  1990).
• Strains are defined as over-extension of a muscle, which move
  bone, with separation of muscle fibers (ibid, p.376).
• Sprain cause an average of 7.5 days restricted activity, 2 days
  of bed disability, and 2.5 days work loss (DHHS # PHS 87-
  1592, 1987).
• Spasm is an epi-phenomena, due to protective mechanism of
  gamma motor reflex loop, a spinal cord reflex. This means the
  spasm is not really the problem, but a result of the problem.
  What are the underlining problems that cause spasm ?
• You cannot have a sprain or strain that lasts 2
  years! It must be something else! What could it
  be?
When a Sprain or Strain Lasts More
      than 6 weeks-What is it?
• If a ligament pull off a bone, there is excessive
  motion around a joint.
• This caused muscle spasm, because the muscles now
  have to do the work of ligaments to hold the bones
  together.
• When a disc is damaged, and there is a loss of disc
  space height, then there is less tension on the
  ligaments that hold vertebrae together, and there is
  excessive motion at that vertebral segment.
Mechanics of a Vertebral Segment


    Normal Size
    Neural Foramin

     Normal Disc
     Height

      Vertebral slippage
      due to reduced disc
      space height and lax
      ligament

 Normal Vertebral Body
 Alignment

Ligament holding vertebral
bodies together
Mechanics of a Vertebral Segment
Taut
ligaments
hold                Normal Segment         Damaged Segment
vertebral
bodies
                                                                     Body
together
                                                                     Moves
Direction of
force



  Shock                                       Flat disc results in
  absorbing disc                              narrowing of space
  holds vertebral    Two contravening         and loose ligaments.
  bodies apart       forces. Vertebral        Vertebral bodies
                     bodies do not move.      move.
Facet Syndrome
    (Empting, Hendler, Kolodny, & Kraus, Tips on hard to manage pain
            syndromes, Patient Care, pp.26-46,April 30, 1990)

• Pain in neck and shoulders and upper arm, or
  low back, and back of thigh.
• Worse with extension, better with flexion.
• Temporary relief by facet blocks, at the level
  above, at the level, and level below, since the
  facet is innervated by three levels.
• Facet denervation has 40% chance of 2 years
  of relief (North, R, Sequelae of facet denervations Pain, ’01)
Facet Blocks and Denervation
    (Empting, Hendler, Kolodny, & Kraus, Tips on hard to manage pain
            syndromes, Patient Care, pp.26-46,April 30, 1990)


      Normal Size
      Neural Foramin

       Normal Disc
       Height

Vertebral slippage due to
reduced disc space height                                     Facet
and lax ligament                                              Block
   Normal Vertebral Body
   Alignment

 Ligament holding vertebral
 bodies together
Missed Diagnoses of CRPS I (RSD)
• Of 38 patients referred to a private clinic with the
  diagnose of RSD (CRPS I) (Differential Diagnosis of CRPS I, Pan Arab
  Journal of Neurosurgery, ’02) only 1/38 (3%) had pure CRPS I
  (RSD) without any other illness.
• 10/38 (26%) had CRPS I (RSD) with nerve entrapment.
• 27/38 (71%) had no signs or symptoms compatible with
  CRPS I (RSD). They had just nerve entrapment(s).
• Dellon (J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj. 2009) found, in 40 patients
  referred for CRPS, 80% had just nerve entrapment.
• CRPS (RSD) is over-diagnosed 71%-80% of the time.
FIBROMYALGIA
                (Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine .abstract 2010)
• A review was conducted of 38 patients referred with the diagnosis
  of fibromyalgia.
• The diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia was not met in 37 of 38
  patients.
• Therefore, 97.3% of patients were misdiagnosed by referring
  doctors as having fibromyalgia, when they did not have it (errors
  of commission).
• Additionally, referring physicians made only 7/50 diagnoses
  (including fibromyalgia) that were confirmed by objective testing
  or diagnostic criteria, which means 86 % of the time they made
  diagnoses that were not confirmed.
• Referring physicians also failed to diagnose 133 medical
  conditions that were confirmed by objective testing, for a failure
  to diagnose rate of 94.3% (errors of omission).
• Of the patients misdiagnosed with fibromyalgia, i.e. told they had
  fibromyalgia when they did not, 94.2% of them were women.
Fibromyalgia Pain Points
The 18 fibromyalgia
pain points of which
11 of 18 are needed
to establish the diagnosis
of fibromyalgia, as long
as the pain at the location      Pain Point
is unexplained by some
other disease.

Control
Point
Fibromyalgia Criteria and Misdiagnoses
• The patient must have pain in at least 11 of 18 points
  unexplained by some other disease
• The patient must have disturbed sleep.
• The patient must experience chronic fatigue.
• Normal blood and laboratory tests.
• In 38 patients referred with fibromyalgia, 37 did not
  meet diagnostic criteria. 133 other diagnoses were
  confirmed on objective tests, and explained the pain.
  (Abstract-Hendler, Murphey and Romero, Academy of Psychosomatic
  Medicine, 2010)
• The overlooked diagnoses was rate 97%.
Fibromyalgia Pain Points or
                Something Else?
                                Occipital Nerve
  Clavicular-sternal            Entrapment
  dislocation
                                 Acromo-Clavicular Joint
   Epicondylitis                     Impingement

                                C3-C4 disc
 Control
                                 Lumbar Facet Syndrome
 Point
                                  These diagnoses
                                  were confirmed by
Chondromalacia                    objective testing in
                                  37 patients
                                  misdiagnoses with
                                  fibromyalgia.
Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
• This is a very often overlooked diagnosis.
• There are two types of thoracic outlet syndrome.
• a) Vascular, which is found intra-operatively in
  less than 10% of cases (Roos).
• b) Neuronal Compression of either lower plexus
  or upper plexus or both.
• Thoracic outlet syndrome can be a combination
  of both vascular and neuro.
• EMG/NCV are of no use to establish diagnoses
The Anatomy of Thoracic Outlet
Clinical Tests for Thoracic Outlet


                                    Shoulder
Roos
                                    Pressure




Adson
Vascular Flow Studies Comparing the Roos
  Maneuver to the Adson for Thoracic Outlet
            (same patient as his own control)
Blocked
blood
flow with
Roos


Still
blood
flow
with
Adson
Individualized Treatment Plans
• No one monomodal program is suitable for all “chronic
  pain patients (CPP).”
• Using a single modality will produce good results in
  some patients, and no results in others. No attempt at
  diagnosis. All are CPP
• Only through a multidisciplinary diagnostic program
  do you establish diagnosis, and then tailor the treatment
  for the disorder.
• Use the www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com tests
  to get diagnoses and treatment plans which recommend
  the proper tests to use.
“Flat tire” patients
• Concept in physiology: Convergence- multiple
  nerves supply a single muscle.
• Divergence: a single nerve supplies multiple
  muscles.
• A single manifestation may have multiple
  etiologies-like a flat tire-nail in tread, leaky valve
  stem, tire off rim or combination of 3.
• A single symptom like pain in last 2 fingers, may
  be C6-7 disc, thoracic outlet or ulnar nerve
  entrapment or combination of all 3.
• Treatment plans must focus on diagnosis, consider
  differential diagnosis, and be individualized.
Patient variables that influence outcomes
 •   Age
 •   Sex
 •   Ethnic background- Harold Merskey MD
 •   Legal status -active or complete, type of suit
 •   Education or I.Q.
 •   Vocational experience
 •   Pre-morbid personality
 •   Stage of pain -acute versus chronic- 4
     stages
Patient Variables in Chronic Pain
      Determine Outcome
• Non-litigant patients: 6% are exaggerating pain
  patients (Psychosomatics, ’79).
• LTD patients: 10% are exaggerating (unpublished
  insurance study).
• Auto Accident and Workers Compensation
  patients: 13% were exaggerating ( Pain, ’85, J.
  Occ. Medicine,’88, J. Neurolog & Ortho. Med. &
  Surgery, ’85, Clinical Neurosurgery, ’89).
Patient Variables-Do they matter?
• In a private clinic study of 120 patients, the average IQ
  of a litigant patient (Workers Compensation or auto
  accident) was 93.6 (75-121), (Psychosomatics ’96).
• The average age was 39 (17-70) (ibid).
• The average duration of pain was 3.63 years (.1-30).
• How do you return to work a 75 IQ, semi-literate truck
  driver, with a 10th grade education, with active workers
  compensation litigation, who is 58 years old, and has
  arachnoiditis for 3 years causing back pain?
• Patient selection impacts outcome statistics.
Type and Stage of Litigation
• Fact- workers compensation patients out of work
  for 2 years or more, return to work less than 1% of
  the time ( Occ. Med, ’68, Occupational Low Back
  Pain, ’84).
• The current Interpretation of this statistic in
  Medical Literature is:
• They have “compensation neurosis, secondary
  gain, financial disincentives, personality flaws,
  depressive equivalents, unmotivated, using the
  system.” No-one ever says they are misdiagnosed.
Type and Stage of Litigation
• An article in J. of Occupational Med. ’89, compared
  83 patients out of work (X = 4.9 yrs.) who had active
  or complete auto accident litigation or workers
  compensation litigation-matched for diagnosis
• They found that after proper diagnosis and treatment,
  there was no difference in the return to work (RTW)
  rate of patients with active or completed litigation-
  however-
• Workers compensation patients 19.5% -RTW
• Auto Accident patients 62.5%- RTW
• Therefore- the type of litigation influenced outcome
Outcome Studies using
  www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com approach
• Johns Hopkins Hospital reduced their workers
  compensation cost 54% by making their injured
  employees see only Johns Hopkins Hospital
  doctors instead of local community doctors
Bernacki EJ, Tsai SP. Ten years' experience using an integrated workers' compensation management
   system to control workers' compensation costs. J Occup Environ Med. 2003 May;45(5):508-16.

• The diagnoses of the Diagnostic Paradigm from
  www.MarylandClincalDiagnostics.com have a
  96% correlation with Johns Hopkins Hospital
  doctors.
Hendler, N, Berzowsky, C and Davis, R Comparison of Clinical Diagnoses to Computerized Test
   Diagnoses, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, pp:8-17, October, 2007.
•
Outcome Studies using
 www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com approach
• Workers’ compensation patients out of work for 2 years
  or more had a return to work rate of less than 1%
( Occ. Med, ’68, Occupational Low Back Pain, ’84).
• Using www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com tests on a
  group of patients out of work for an average of 4.9 years,
  one clinic had a return to work rate of 19.5% for
  workers’ compensation patients, 62.5% for auto accident
  patients, a 90% reduction in use of narcotic medication,
  and 45% reduction in doctors visits. Hendler, N.: "Validating and
   Treating the Complaint of Chronic Back Pain: The Mensana Clinic Approach." Clinical
   Neurosurgery. Vol. 35, Chap. 20:385-397, eds. Black, P., Alexander, E., Barrow, D., et. al.,
   Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, 1988.

• Cost savings ranged from $20,000 to $175,000
   http://www.slideshare.net/DiagnoseMyPain/patient-cost-savings-documented-with-letters
Methods to Avoid Misdiagnosis
• See www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com
• The Pain Validity Test can predict, with 95%
  accuracy, who will have moderate or severe
  abnormalities on objective medical tests, and can
  predict, with 85% accuracy who will not (1).
• The Diagnostic Paradigm will give a physician
  diagnoses which have a 96% correlation with
  diagnoses of Johns Hopkins Hospital physician (2)
• The Treatment Algorithm list the proper tests to use
  to confirm the diagnoses, and proper treamtments
(1)Hendler, N. and Baker, A., An Internet questionnaire to predict the presence or absence of organic pathology in chronic back, neck and limb
     pain patients, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, Vol. 12, No. 1, pp: 15-24, April, 2008.
(2) Hendler, N., Berzoksky, C. and Davis, R.J. Comparison of Clinical Diagnoses Versus Computerized Test Diagnoses Using the Mensana
     Clinic Diagnostic Paradigm (Expert System) for Diagnosing Chronic Pain in the Neck, Back and Limbs, Pan Arab Journal of
     Neurosurgery, pp:8-17, October, 2007.

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

This Unbearable Pain
This Unbearable PainThis Unbearable Pain
This Unbearable PainSpinePlus
 
Patient cases
Patient casesPatient cases
Patient casesSpinePlus
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painfulNelson Hendler
 
Pain management
Pain managementPain management
Pain managementSpinePlus
 
Pain management
Pain managementPain management
Pain managementSpinePlus
 
Inguinodynia by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India
Inguinodynia  by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India Inguinodynia  by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India
Inguinodynia by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India Divya Khanna
 
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fractures
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fracturesVertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fractures
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fracturesSpinePlus
 
My crook back
My crook backMy crook back
My crook backSpinePlus
 
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...Kshitij Chaudhary
 
Facet dislocation management
Facet dislocation managementFacet dislocation management
Facet dislocation managementSpinePlus
 
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome Ade Wijaya
 
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2SpinePlus
 
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and Management
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and ManagementAtraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and Management
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and ManagementThe Arm Clinic
 
How we think about back pain?
How we think about back pain?How we think about back pain?
How we think about back pain?SpinePlus
 
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFT
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFTNTG FINAL FINAL DRAFT
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFTShea Dineen
 
Assessment and management of complex pain conditions
Assessment and management of complex pain conditionsAssessment and management of complex pain conditions
Assessment and management of complex pain conditionsSaurab Sharma
 
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham pcsciences
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

This Unbearable Pain
This Unbearable PainThis Unbearable Pain
This Unbearable Pain
 
Patient cases
Patient casesPatient cases
Patient cases
 
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
 
Pain management
Pain managementPain management
Pain management
 
Pain management
Pain managementPain management
Pain management
 
Inguinodynia by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India
Inguinodynia  by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India Inguinodynia  by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India
Inguinodynia by Prof. Ajay Khanna, IMS, BHU, Varanasi, India
 
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fractures
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fracturesVertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fractures
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic crush fractures
 
My crook back
My crook backMy crook back
My crook back
 
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...
Nonoperative care versus surgery in lumbar disc herniation with radiculopathy...
 
Facet dislocation management
Facet dislocation managementFacet dislocation management
Facet dislocation management
 
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
 
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2
Should I order an injection or let the specialist do it? – Part 2
 
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and Management
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and ManagementAtraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and Management
Atraumatic/MDI - Physiotherapy Principles and Management
 
Approach to Failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS ) Agrasen hospital gondia vida...
Approach to Failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS ) Agrasen hospital gondia vida...Approach to Failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS ) Agrasen hospital gondia vida...
Approach to Failed back surgery syndrome (FBSS ) Agrasen hospital gondia vida...
 
How we think about back pain?
How we think about back pain?How we think about back pain?
How we think about back pain?
 
Risk Stratification of Occ Low Back Pain
Risk Stratification of Occ Low Back PainRisk Stratification of Occ Low Back Pain
Risk Stratification of Occ Low Back Pain
 
Pain Management
Pain ManagementPain Management
Pain Management
 
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFT
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFTNTG FINAL FINAL DRAFT
NTG FINAL FINAL DRAFT
 
Assessment and management of complex pain conditions
Assessment and management of complex pain conditionsAssessment and management of complex pain conditions
Assessment and management of complex pain conditions
 
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham
Spondyloarthropathies - Dr Jon Packham
 

Destacado

CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential Diagnosis
CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential DiagnosisCRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential Diagnosis
CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential DiagnosisNelson Hendler
 
More On Listings
More On ListingsMore On Listings
More On ListingsLaw Firm
 
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNS
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNSBohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNS
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNSDr. Rubz
 
Lower Back Pain - Part 2
Lower Back Pain - Part 2Lower Back Pain - Part 2
Lower Back Pain - Part 2cpppaincenter
 
Backache imaging presentation
Backache imaging presentation Backache imaging presentation
Backache imaging presentation Hieder Al-Shami
 
Spinal and-spinal-cord284
Spinal and-spinal-cord284Spinal and-spinal-cord284
Spinal and-spinal-cord284cute_girl89
 
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapse
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapseProf. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapse
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapseAyman Salah
 
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate Spine
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate SpineMRI and X-Ray of the Neonate Spine
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate SpineLynn Davis
 
Complex regional pain syndrome
Complex regional pain syndrome Complex regional pain syndrome
Complex regional pain syndrome pankaj bhosale
 
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPR
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPRLBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPR
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPRE ML
 
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015LejayJacob
 
Appropriate imaging for low back pain
Appropriate imaging for low back painAppropriate imaging for low back pain
Appropriate imaging for low back painSpinePlus
 
1 diagnostic imaging
1 diagnostic imaging1 diagnostic imaging
1 diagnostic imagingSimba Syed
 
Peripheral Nerve Compression Syndrome
Peripheral Nerve Compression SyndromePeripheral Nerve Compression Syndrome
Peripheral Nerve Compression SyndromeGraMedica
 
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spine
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-SpineImage Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spine
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spinealexagerg
 
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.Abdellah Nazeer
 

Destacado (20)

CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential Diagnosis
CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential DiagnosisCRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential Diagnosis
CRPS I (RSD) with pictures. Differential Diagnosis
 
Crps ppt
Crps pptCrps ppt
Crps ppt
 
More On Listings
More On ListingsMore On Listings
More On Listings
 
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNS
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNSBohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNS
Bohomolets Neurology Infectious Dx of CNS
 
Return of the trouble
Return of the troubleReturn of the trouble
Return of the trouble
 
Lower Back Pain - Part 2
Lower Back Pain - Part 2Lower Back Pain - Part 2
Lower Back Pain - Part 2
 
Backache imaging presentation
Backache imaging presentation Backache imaging presentation
Backache imaging presentation
 
Spinal and-spinal-cord284
Spinal and-spinal-cord284Spinal and-spinal-cord284
Spinal and-spinal-cord284
 
Mr imaging of spine
Mr imaging of spineMr imaging of spine
Mr imaging of spine
 
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapse
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapseProf. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapse
Prof. ashraf ezz eldin lp cd prolapse
 
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate Spine
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate SpineMRI and X-Ray of the Neonate Spine
MRI and X-Ray of the Neonate Spine
 
Complex regional pain syndrome
Complex regional pain syndrome Complex regional pain syndrome
Complex regional pain syndrome
 
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPR
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPRLBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPR
LBP - Diagnostic Radiology UPR
 
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015
Complex regional pain syndrome jacob-2015
 
Appropriate imaging for low back pain
Appropriate imaging for low back painAppropriate imaging for low back pain
Appropriate imaging for low back pain
 
1 diagnostic imaging
1 diagnostic imaging1 diagnostic imaging
1 diagnostic imaging
 
Discogenic low back pain Treatment agrasen hospital gondia vidarbha dr sandee...
Discogenic low back pain Treatment agrasen hospital gondia vidarbha dr sandee...Discogenic low back pain Treatment agrasen hospital gondia vidarbha dr sandee...
Discogenic low back pain Treatment agrasen hospital gondia vidarbha dr sandee...
 
Peripheral Nerve Compression Syndrome
Peripheral Nerve Compression SyndromePeripheral Nerve Compression Syndrome
Peripheral Nerve Compression Syndrome
 
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spine
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-SpineImage Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spine
Image Evaluation: AP Axial C-Spine
 
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.
Presentation1.pptx, normal spinal anatomy.
 

Similar a Course 12 why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed

Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painfulNelson Hendler
 
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburton
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise WarburtonDiagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburton
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburtonpcsciences
 
orthopedic assessment.pptx
orthopedic assessment.pptxorthopedic assessment.pptx
orthopedic assessment.pptxAhmedMufleh1
 
A pain in the neck
A pain in the neckA pain in the neck
A pain in the neckbrizbrain
 
Experts decision making schemes slide share
Experts decision making schemes slide shareExperts decision making schemes slide share
Experts decision making schemes slide shareImad Hassan
 
Chest Pain Evaluation in Corrections
Chest Pain Evaluation in CorrectionsChest Pain Evaluation in Corrections
Chest Pain Evaluation in Correctionsjeffk2996
 
Introduction to internal medicine
Introduction to internal medicineIntroduction to internal medicine
Introduction to internal medicineqbank org
 
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...Nelson Hendler
 
Sdc smacc wrestling with risk
Sdc smacc wrestling with riskSdc smacc wrestling with risk
Sdc smacc wrestling with riskSimon Carley
 
Clinical Reasoning MEDICINE.pptx
Clinical Reasoning    MEDICINE.pptxClinical Reasoning    MEDICINE.pptx
Clinical Reasoning MEDICINE.pptxAmr El-Ghammaz
 
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015Ilan Lieberman
 
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptx
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptxLEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptx
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptxabdimoha4355
 
Module 3 Pain
Module 3 Pain Module 3 Pain
Module 3 Pain Ben Vel
 

Similar a Course 12 why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed (20)

Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painfulCourse 8 medical tests used to diagnose  painful
Course 8 medical tests used to diagnose painful
 
BWT spinal.pptx
BWT spinal.pptxBWT spinal.pptx
BWT spinal.pptx
 
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburton
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise WarburtonDiagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburton
Diagnosis of inflammatory arthritis - Dr Louise Warburton
 
orthopedic assessment.pptx
orthopedic assessment.pptxorthopedic assessment.pptx
orthopedic assessment.pptx
 
A pain in the neck
A pain in the neckA pain in the neck
A pain in the neck
 
Experts decision making schemes slide share
Experts decision making schemes slide shareExperts decision making schemes slide share
Experts decision making schemes slide share
 
Chest Pain Evaluation in Corrections
Chest Pain Evaluation in CorrectionsChest Pain Evaluation in Corrections
Chest Pain Evaluation in Corrections
 
Introduction to internal medicine
Introduction to internal medicineIntroduction to internal medicine
Introduction to internal medicine
 
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...
Evaluating Chronic Pain Patients Using Methods from Johns Hopkins Hospital Ph...
 
Diagnostic test and agreement.pptx
Diagnostic test and agreement.pptxDiagnostic test and agreement.pptx
Diagnostic test and agreement.pptx
 
MBC 101
MBC 101MBC 101
MBC 101
 
Sdc smacc wrestling with risk
Sdc smacc wrestling with riskSdc smacc wrestling with risk
Sdc smacc wrestling with risk
 
Kay Dickersin
Kay DickersinKay Dickersin
Kay Dickersin
 
cprs2
cprs2cprs2
cprs2
 
cprs2
cprs2cprs2
cprs2
 
Clinical Reasoning MEDICINE.pptx
Clinical Reasoning    MEDICINE.pptxClinical Reasoning    MEDICINE.pptx
Clinical Reasoning MEDICINE.pptx
 
Pain.pptx
Pain.pptxPain.pptx
Pain.pptx
 
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015
Forster Dean CPD Chronic Pain Talk Liverpool 11th May 2015
 
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptx
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptxLEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptx
LEC. 1 INTRODUCTION TO SURGERY & APPROACH TO A SURGICAL PATIENT.pptx
 
Module 3 Pain
Module 3 Pain Module 3 Pain
Module 3 Pain
 

Más de Nelson Hendler

Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxThird Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxNelson Hendler
 
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfGIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfNelson Hendler
 
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfTop_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfNelson Hendler
 
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyWalmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyNelson Hendler
 
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidents
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidentsOverlooked diagnoses after auto accidents
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidentsNelson Hendler
 
Thermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painThermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painNelson Hendler
 
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painAlternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painNelson Hendler
 
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painAnatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painNelson Hendler
 
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsMemory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsNelson Hendler
 
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamThoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamNelson Hendler
 
Bipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneBipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneNelson Hendler
 
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyEmg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyNelson Hendler
 
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesValuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesNelson Hendler
 
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffHeadache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffNelson Hendler
 
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions  Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions Nelson Hendler
 
Medication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsMedication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsNelson Hendler
 
List of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesList of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesNelson Hendler
 
List of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesList of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesNelson Hendler
 

Más de Nelson Hendler (20)

Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docxThird Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
Third Party Reporting of Patient Improvement.docx
 
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdfGIGO Problems With AI.pdf
GIGO Problems With AI.pdf
 
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdfTop_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
Top_Down_or_The_Bottom_Up to Save Money.pdf
 
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save moneyWalmart HR head tells how to save money
Walmart HR head tells how to save money
 
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidents
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidentsOverlooked diagnoses after auto accidents
Overlooked diagnoses after auto accidents
 
Thermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic painThermography for psychogenic pain
Thermography for psychogenic pain
 
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic painAlternative treatment for chronic pain
Alternative treatment for chronic pain
 
Si joint dx and rx
Si joint dx and rxSi joint dx and rx
Si joint dx and rx
 
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of painAnatomy and pharmacology of pain
Anatomy and pharmacology of pain
 
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcoticsMemory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
Memory loss benzodiazepines vs narcotics
 
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by teamThoracic outlet diagnosis by team
Thoracic outlet diagnosis by team
 
Bipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactoneBipolar control with spironolactone
Bipolar control with spironolactone
 
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthyEmg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
Emg vs. thermography to diagnose crps and radiculopthy
 
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuriesValuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
Valuable info for orthopedic and neurosurgeons specializing in spinal injuries
 
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staffHeadache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
Headache diagnostc paradigm from former Johns Hopkins Hospital staff
 
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions  Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions
Missed Diagnoses association in Rear end collisions
 
Medication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiodsMedication for pain without opiods
Medication for pain without opiods
 
List of authors of articles
List of authors of articlesList of authors of articles
List of authors of articles
 
List of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of ArticlesList of Authors of Articles
List of Authors of Articles
 
Proctoring Handbook
Proctoring HandbookProctoring Handbook
Proctoring Handbook
 

Último

Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Anamikakaur10
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesDipal Arora
 
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...rajveerescorts2022
 
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...Sheetaleventcompany
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureSeta Wicaksana
 
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...amitlee9823
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Dave Litwiller
 
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableSeo
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...amitlee9823
 
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...allensay1
 
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876dlhescort
 
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...Sheetaleventcompany
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...Aggregage
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptxnandhinijagan9867
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfAdmir Softic
 
Business Model Canvas (BMC)- A new venture concept
Business Model Canvas (BMC)-  A new venture conceptBusiness Model Canvas (BMC)-  A new venture concept
Business Model Canvas (BMC)- A new venture conceptP&CO
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataExhibitors Data
 

Último (20)

Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
Call Now ☎️🔝 9332606886🔝 Call Girls ❤ Service In Bhilwara Female Escorts Serv...
 
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesMysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Mysore Call Girls 8617370543 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
👉Chandigarh Call Girls 👉9878799926👉Just Call👉Chandigarh Call Girl In Chandiga...
 
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
Chandigarh Escorts Service 📞8868886958📞 Just📲 Call Nihal Chandigarh Call Girl...
 
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Napur Call Now 8617697112 Napur Escorts 24x7
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Napur Call Now 8617697112 Napur Escorts 24x7(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Napur Call Now 8617697112 Napur Escorts 24x7
(Anamika) VIP Call Girls Napur Call Now 8617697112 Napur Escorts 24x7
 
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with CultureOrganizational Transformation Lead with Culture
Organizational Transformation Lead with Culture
 
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
 
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
Enhancing and Restoring Safety & Quality Cultures - Dave Litwiller - May 2024...
 
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
Nelamangala Call Girls: 🍓 7737669865 🍓 High Profile Model Escorts | Bangalore...
 
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
Call Girls Service In Old Town Dubai ((0551707352)) Old Town Dubai Call Girl ...
 
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
Call Girls in Delhi, Escort Service Available 24x7 in Delhi 959961-/-3876
 
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
Call Girls Zirakpur👧 Book Now📱7837612180 📞👉Call Girl Service In Zirakpur No A...
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Mahipalpur Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdfDr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
Dr. Admir Softic_ presentation_Green Club_ENG.pdf
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 
Business Model Canvas (BMC)- A new venture concept
Business Model Canvas (BMC)-  A new venture conceptBusiness Model Canvas (BMC)-  A new venture concept
Business Model Canvas (BMC)- A new venture concept
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 

Course 12 why chronic pain patients are misdiagnosed

  • 1. WHY CHRONIC PAIN PATIENTS ARE MISDIAGNOSED: and how to make a proper diagnosis Course 12 www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com Nelson Hendler, MD, MS Former Assistant Professor of Neurosurgery Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine Past president –American Academy of Pain Management
  • 2. Missed Diagnoses-Neck and Back Pain • Hendler et al Overlooked Physical Diagnoses in Chronic Pain Patients Involved in Litigation, Psychosomatics, ’93 • N= 60 • 67% were misdiagnosed “lumbar strain, cervical strain, chronic pain syndrome, conversion reaction.” • Hendler, et al, Overlooked Physical Diagnoses in Chronic Pain Patients Involved in Litigation: Part II Psychosomatics,‘96 • N= 120 • 40% were misdiagnosed “lumbar strain, cervical strain, chronic pain syndrome, conversion reaction” • These 180 patients, from two studies, really had facet syndrome, disrupted discs (internal disc disruption), thoracic outlet syndrome, nerve entrapments, and radiculopathy, confirmed by objective physiological testing.
  • 3. Why Patients are Misdiagnosed • Doctors don’t spend enough time with a patient taking a careful history. • Doctors rely on anatomical tests, such as MRI, CT, and X-ray to make diagnosis • Pain is a physiological condition. • Physiology is measuring a response to a stimulus. • Anatomy is taking a picture, but you can’t take picture of “pain.” • If you want to know “Is the oven hot?” would you use a photo or a thermometer to determine this? • Doctors need to use physiological tests, such as provocative discogram, facet blocks, root blocks, nerve blocks, bone scan, neurometer studies for sensory nerves, Indium 111 scans, PET scan, etc.
  • 4. Cause of Misdiagnoses (cont) • Failure to recognize that a single clinical manifestation may have multiple etiologies (a flat tire). • Failure to realize a single pathological condition may have multiple clinical manifestations (Lyme disease) • Failure to take a careful history. • Failure to understand the specificity and sensitivity of tests. • Relying on anatomical tests to make a diagnosis rather than clinical judgment or physiological tests. • Not believing a patient.
  • 5. Example of Flaws of Anatomical Tests • ANATOMICAL TESTING BENEFIT: • I have a pain in my thumb. • Take a picture and find a vise on my thumb. • Perform “visectomy” and the pain goes away. • BUT - ANATOMICAL TESTING FAILURE: • I have a pain in my thumb. • I have hit my thumb many times with a hammer • Take a picture, but no hammer is seen • What caused the pain? You have to ask why. • This demonstrates the need for a careful history
  • 6. “Misdiagnosed” Definition • Many patients are misdiagnosed. What is that? • Misdiagnosis: The referring physician has not mentioned a certain diagnosis (overlooked). • The referring physician has used a descriptive “diagnosis” such as “low back pain.” • The referring physician has offered a wrong diagnosis without any objective data to support it, i.e. RSD, lumbar strain, fibromyalgia, psychogenic pain, fibromyalgia, etc. • The www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com Diagnostic Paradigm establishes a diagnosis, previously unmentioned by referring physicians, which can be documented by objective or interactive (blocks, provocative discograms, etc.) testing.
  • 7. What is Evidence Based Medicine? It is using scientific evidence to prove a point. • Meta analysis is a review of medical literature. • Epidemiology reviews the incidence (number of new cases a year) and prevalence (number of cases at any one time) of a disease. It is the basis of actuarial data. • Outcome studies report the results of surgery or interventions. Selection criteria can influence results. • Population definitions can alter results. There are clinics that will not see claimants with active litigation. Other clinics count “return to work” as being back on the job only one day. There are regional, genetic, and sociological differences, such as educational background, training, language fluency, age, etc. that influence reported results.
  • 8. Flaws in Meta-Analysis Research • Richard Payne, MD (Clin. J. of Pain, ’86) at Cornell-Memorial Sloan Kettering did a meta analysis of patients with surgical sympathectomies for the treatment of causalgia (CPRS II). • He found the success rates reported in the literature ranged from 12% to 97%. • Sources of flaws in this analysis: diagnostic criteria for causalgia, outcome criteria, surgical skill, litigation, etc.? Each article was different.
  • 9. What is a “Chronic Pain Patient?” • Chronic Pain Patient –each article is like blind men describing an elephant. Each reports only what was seen in their clinical setting, but never sees the entire population. • The type of patient is rarely mentioned in the literature, i.e., litigant versus non-litigant. • Selection criteria for a patient population is essential for determining proper intervention and meaningful outcomes.
  • 10. Waddell Signs as part of a physical exam • Waddell signs are five physical tests, like hitting a patient on the head to see if their low back hurts, etc. • Fishbain, et. al., (Pain Medicine, vol. 4, ’03) did a meta analysis of 61 studies that reported using Waddell signs. • Positive Waddell signs do not correlate with malingering, secondary gain, hysteria, psychological distress, abnormal illness behavior, nor somatic amplification • They do not discriminate organic vs. non-organic problems, but they are misused that way. • They do predict poor treatment outcome. • There may be a real organic basis for positive signs.
  • 11. Types of Tests Used for Validating Pain and What They Measure • Anatomical Tests: MRI, CT, 3D-CT, X-ray, discogram, myelogram – a picture. • Physiological Tests: Flex-Ex. X-rays, bone scan, nerve blocks, root blocks, facet blocks, provocative discogram, gallium scan, Indium 111 scan, phentolamine test, EMG/NCV, neurometers, 2 poster brace, body jacket with thigh spika- a response.
  • 12. Anatomical Versus Physiological • Anatomical • Physiological • Takes a picture of the • Measures body body. response- interactive. • EXAMPLE • EXAMPLE • Oven on wall. • Oven on wall. • Take a picture. • Put thermometer in • Look at picture. oven. • Can you tell if the • Look at thermometer. oven is hot? • It says 375 F. Is it hot?
  • 13. Specificity versus Sensitivity • Sensitive Test • Specific Test • Always detects presence • When positive, it detects of a disease. only the disease in • However, may also report question. other diseases as the first • May overlook mild or disease. variant forms of the • Very sensitive, but not so disease. specific- gives false • Very specific, but not so positive readings sensitive- gives false • Tine test for TB. negative results. • Mantou test for TB.
  • 14. Specificity versus Sensitivity • Sensitive Test • Specific Test • • Let’s catch a tuna. Let’s catch a tuna. • Use a big mesh net. • Use a small mesh net. • Everything in net will be • Will catch a lot of fish, tuna. and never miss a tuna. • Will catch large tuna, but • Definitely will catch a small tuna, mackerel, tuna, but will also get perch, and spot will not be mackerel, perch and spot, in net, so no further which will require further sorting needed. Will miss sorting. some small tuna we would have wanted to keep. • False positive results. • False negative results. • Sensitive but not specific • Specific but not sensitive
  • 15. Flaws with Cervical Radiographs • Peterson, et. al. (Spine # 28 (2) pp 129-33, ’03). • 180 patients, mean age 49, 44% male rated pain on VAS 0-10 scale & Neck Disability Index • Neck pain divided into no injury, injury (40.6%) and those with litigation (5.1%). • No correlation between levels of degeneration, or severity, and self rated pain or disability ratings. • Patients with injury had more pain and disability, than patients without injury. • Women reported more pain and disability.
  • 16. Flaws with Static Cervical X-rays • Most patients complain of worse pain when they lean forward or backwards. • Static (upright) X-rays do not demonstrate movement between the vertebral bodies. • Flexion-Extension X-rays show what happens to the vertebral bodies when there is motion forward and backwards. • Like a partially broken twig- the defect is not evident until the twig is put under tension.
  • 17. Flaws with Just Anatomical Tests • MRI- Jensen et. al. N. Eng J. Med, ’94, 98 patients with no back pain, but 27 had protruding disc (28% false positive rate). • MRI with Modic (vertebral end plate changes)-21/23 patients had + provocative discograms. BUT- in 90 patients with positive provocative discograms, only 23% had Modic changes, and 77% no changes in MRI. (Braithwaite, et al, Eur. Spine J. ’98). Therefore a 77% false negative rate for MRI
  • 18. Anatomy and Physiology of a Disc • A disc is like a jelly donut. • Pain fibers are found in the rear 1/3 of the annulus (donut) (Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and Clinical Management, Vol. 13, p.121,Elsevier, 2002) • A herniated disc has the jelly (nucleus polposa) protrude from the donut (annulus). • Pain fibers can be disrupted, without any anatomical distortion of the annulus, so the MRI, CT and Myelogram are normal. (Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and Clinical Management, Vol. 13, p.119-122,Elsevier, 2002) • Pain from internal disc disruption (IDD) feels like a herniated disc pushing on a nerve root with pain in a radicular distribution.(Bogduk and McGuirk, ibid).
  • 19. Herniated Disc vs. Internal Disc Disruption (IDD) (Bogduk and McGuirk, Pain Research and Clinical Management, Vol. 13, p.119-122,Elsevier, 2002) • Herniated Disc Internal Disc Disruption C C O O R R D D MRI- shows disc herniation MRI -no disc herniation and cord compression nor cord compression
  • 20. Provocative Discograms • A physiological test, not an anatomical test. • Saline is injected into the donut (annulus) portion of the disc, where the pain fibers are. • This injection distends the pain fibers. • If this injection reproduces the pain in the distribution the patient normally feels pain, this is a positive test. • Local anesthetic injected into the damaged disc take away the pain the patient normally feels.
  • 21. Disc Anatomy and Provocative Discogram: Saline injection reproduces the pain, confirming disc damage due to IDD, not seen on MRI Normal Disc Internally Disrupted Disc (IDD), with normal MRI Pain Pain Herniated Disc Fibers Internally Disrupted Disc Fibers (IDD), with normal MRI Needle Annulus Provocative Discogram Nucleus Pulposa Saline
  • 22. Comparison Herniated Disc versus IDD • Herniated Disc • Internal Disc Disruption Annulus Nucleus polpulsa Pain Fibers Pain Fibers
  • 23. Further Debate on MRI vs Discogram • 53 pts. with pain had both MRI and provocative discograms. 79.5% and 74.4% of patients with concordant pain on provocative discograms had no endplate changes (Modic) on T1 and T2 MRI images (Sandhu, et al, J. Spinal Disord, 2000). • In 54 pts without pain, 24% had a “high intensity zone on MRI. Provocative discogram were + 69% of pts with Modic changes, and + 10% of pts without MRI findings. (Carragee et al, Spine, 2000).
  • 24. Further Debate on MRI vs Discogram (Simmons, et al, Spine ’91). • 164 patients with back pain. • MRI abnormalities and + provocative discograms were found in 90/164 pts (55%). • MRI and provocative discograms differed in 74/164 (45%) of the patients. • 108 discs on MRI classified as abnormal were asymptomatic (37%).
  • 25. Errors in MRI interpretation for Symptomatic Discs • False + rate - MRI is 24%-37% in pts without pain. • False neg. rate - MRI in pts with + provocative discograms ranges from 77%-79%. • False positive rate for provocative discogram is 10%, i.e. produced pain at an asymptomatic disc.
  • 26. EMG/NCV: The wrong physiological test. Patient has pain (sensory) not weakness (motor) Motor fibers Sensory fibers Damaged compression sensory fibers • Cross section of nerve, • Cross section of nerve, normal damaged by compression EMG/nerve conduction measures gross electrical activity of a nerve. 90% of electrical activity is from motor fibers. It takes a lot of pressure for a long time to damage motor nerves. Small sensory fibers can be easily damaged in a short period of time, but since they have so little electrical activity, the damage doesn’t show up on EMG/nerve conduction studies. Current perception threshold test (Neurometer studies) can measure sensory fiber activity
  • 27. 3D-CT versus Regular CT (Zinreich, Long & Davis: J. Comput Assist. Tomography 1990) • Study of 100 patients, without previous surgeries, with negative direct axial CT or 2-D multiplanar CT reconstructions. • 3D-CT reconstructions found occult boney pathology 56% of time missed by CT. • Study of 100 patients, with previous fusion, with negative direct axial CT or 2-D multiplanar CT reconstructions. • 3D-CT reconstructions found occult boney pathology 76% of time missed by CT.
  • 28. Sprains and Strains • Sprains are defined as stretching ligaments which hold joints together (Bonica and Teitz -The Management of Pain p 375, 1990). • Strains are defined as over-extension of a muscle, which move bone, with separation of muscle fibers (ibid, p.376). • Sprain cause an average of 7.5 days restricted activity, 2 days of bed disability, and 2.5 days work loss (DHHS # PHS 87- 1592, 1987). • Spasm is an epi-phenomena, due to protective mechanism of gamma motor reflex loop, a spinal cord reflex. This means the spasm is not really the problem, but a result of the problem. What are the underlining problems that cause spasm ? • You cannot have a sprain or strain that lasts 2 years! It must be something else! What could it be?
  • 29. When a Sprain or Strain Lasts More than 6 weeks-What is it? • If a ligament pull off a bone, there is excessive motion around a joint. • This caused muscle spasm, because the muscles now have to do the work of ligaments to hold the bones together. • When a disc is damaged, and there is a loss of disc space height, then there is less tension on the ligaments that hold vertebrae together, and there is excessive motion at that vertebral segment.
  • 30. Mechanics of a Vertebral Segment Normal Size Neural Foramin Normal Disc Height Vertebral slippage due to reduced disc space height and lax ligament Normal Vertebral Body Alignment Ligament holding vertebral bodies together
  • 31. Mechanics of a Vertebral Segment Taut ligaments hold Normal Segment Damaged Segment vertebral bodies Body together Moves Direction of force Shock Flat disc results in absorbing disc narrowing of space holds vertebral Two contravening and loose ligaments. bodies apart forces. Vertebral Vertebral bodies bodies do not move. move.
  • 32. Facet Syndrome (Empting, Hendler, Kolodny, & Kraus, Tips on hard to manage pain syndromes, Patient Care, pp.26-46,April 30, 1990) • Pain in neck and shoulders and upper arm, or low back, and back of thigh. • Worse with extension, better with flexion. • Temporary relief by facet blocks, at the level above, at the level, and level below, since the facet is innervated by three levels. • Facet denervation has 40% chance of 2 years of relief (North, R, Sequelae of facet denervations Pain, ’01)
  • 33. Facet Blocks and Denervation (Empting, Hendler, Kolodny, & Kraus, Tips on hard to manage pain syndromes, Patient Care, pp.26-46,April 30, 1990) Normal Size Neural Foramin Normal Disc Height Vertebral slippage due to reduced disc space height Facet and lax ligament Block Normal Vertebral Body Alignment Ligament holding vertebral bodies together
  • 34. Missed Diagnoses of CRPS I (RSD) • Of 38 patients referred to a private clinic with the diagnose of RSD (CRPS I) (Differential Diagnosis of CRPS I, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, ’02) only 1/38 (3%) had pure CRPS I (RSD) without any other illness. • 10/38 (26%) had CRPS I (RSD) with nerve entrapment. • 27/38 (71%) had no signs or symptoms compatible with CRPS I (RSD). They had just nerve entrapment(s). • Dellon (J Brachial Plex Peripher Nerve Inj. 2009) found, in 40 patients referred for CRPS, 80% had just nerve entrapment. • CRPS (RSD) is over-diagnosed 71%-80% of the time.
  • 35. FIBROMYALGIA (Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine .abstract 2010) • A review was conducted of 38 patients referred with the diagnosis of fibromyalgia. • The diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia was not met in 37 of 38 patients. • Therefore, 97.3% of patients were misdiagnosed by referring doctors as having fibromyalgia, when they did not have it (errors of commission). • Additionally, referring physicians made only 7/50 diagnoses (including fibromyalgia) that were confirmed by objective testing or diagnostic criteria, which means 86 % of the time they made diagnoses that were not confirmed. • Referring physicians also failed to diagnose 133 medical conditions that were confirmed by objective testing, for a failure to diagnose rate of 94.3% (errors of omission). • Of the patients misdiagnosed with fibromyalgia, i.e. told they had fibromyalgia when they did not, 94.2% of them were women.
  • 36. Fibromyalgia Pain Points The 18 fibromyalgia pain points of which 11 of 18 are needed to establish the diagnosis of fibromyalgia, as long as the pain at the location Pain Point is unexplained by some other disease. Control Point
  • 37. Fibromyalgia Criteria and Misdiagnoses • The patient must have pain in at least 11 of 18 points unexplained by some other disease • The patient must have disturbed sleep. • The patient must experience chronic fatigue. • Normal blood and laboratory tests. • In 38 patients referred with fibromyalgia, 37 did not meet diagnostic criteria. 133 other diagnoses were confirmed on objective tests, and explained the pain. (Abstract-Hendler, Murphey and Romero, Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine, 2010) • The overlooked diagnoses was rate 97%.
  • 38. Fibromyalgia Pain Points or Something Else? Occipital Nerve Clavicular-sternal Entrapment dislocation Acromo-Clavicular Joint Epicondylitis Impingement C3-C4 disc Control Lumbar Facet Syndrome Point These diagnoses were confirmed by Chondromalacia objective testing in 37 patients misdiagnoses with fibromyalgia.
  • 39. Thoracic Outlet Syndrome • This is a very often overlooked diagnosis. • There are two types of thoracic outlet syndrome. • a) Vascular, which is found intra-operatively in less than 10% of cases (Roos). • b) Neuronal Compression of either lower plexus or upper plexus or both. • Thoracic outlet syndrome can be a combination of both vascular and neuro. • EMG/NCV are of no use to establish diagnoses
  • 40. The Anatomy of Thoracic Outlet
  • 41. Clinical Tests for Thoracic Outlet Shoulder Roos Pressure Adson
  • 42. Vascular Flow Studies Comparing the Roos Maneuver to the Adson for Thoracic Outlet (same patient as his own control) Blocked blood flow with Roos Still blood flow with Adson
  • 43. Individualized Treatment Plans • No one monomodal program is suitable for all “chronic pain patients (CPP).” • Using a single modality will produce good results in some patients, and no results in others. No attempt at diagnosis. All are CPP • Only through a multidisciplinary diagnostic program do you establish diagnosis, and then tailor the treatment for the disorder. • Use the www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com tests to get diagnoses and treatment plans which recommend the proper tests to use.
  • 44. “Flat tire” patients • Concept in physiology: Convergence- multiple nerves supply a single muscle. • Divergence: a single nerve supplies multiple muscles. • A single manifestation may have multiple etiologies-like a flat tire-nail in tread, leaky valve stem, tire off rim or combination of 3. • A single symptom like pain in last 2 fingers, may be C6-7 disc, thoracic outlet or ulnar nerve entrapment or combination of all 3. • Treatment plans must focus on diagnosis, consider differential diagnosis, and be individualized.
  • 45. Patient variables that influence outcomes • Age • Sex • Ethnic background- Harold Merskey MD • Legal status -active or complete, type of suit • Education or I.Q. • Vocational experience • Pre-morbid personality • Stage of pain -acute versus chronic- 4 stages
  • 46. Patient Variables in Chronic Pain Determine Outcome • Non-litigant patients: 6% are exaggerating pain patients (Psychosomatics, ’79). • LTD patients: 10% are exaggerating (unpublished insurance study). • Auto Accident and Workers Compensation patients: 13% were exaggerating ( Pain, ’85, J. Occ. Medicine,’88, J. Neurolog & Ortho. Med. & Surgery, ’85, Clinical Neurosurgery, ’89).
  • 47. Patient Variables-Do they matter? • In a private clinic study of 120 patients, the average IQ of a litigant patient (Workers Compensation or auto accident) was 93.6 (75-121), (Psychosomatics ’96). • The average age was 39 (17-70) (ibid). • The average duration of pain was 3.63 years (.1-30). • How do you return to work a 75 IQ, semi-literate truck driver, with a 10th grade education, with active workers compensation litigation, who is 58 years old, and has arachnoiditis for 3 years causing back pain? • Patient selection impacts outcome statistics.
  • 48. Type and Stage of Litigation • Fact- workers compensation patients out of work for 2 years or more, return to work less than 1% of the time ( Occ. Med, ’68, Occupational Low Back Pain, ’84). • The current Interpretation of this statistic in Medical Literature is: • They have “compensation neurosis, secondary gain, financial disincentives, personality flaws, depressive equivalents, unmotivated, using the system.” No-one ever says they are misdiagnosed.
  • 49. Type and Stage of Litigation • An article in J. of Occupational Med. ’89, compared 83 patients out of work (X = 4.9 yrs.) who had active or complete auto accident litigation or workers compensation litigation-matched for diagnosis • They found that after proper diagnosis and treatment, there was no difference in the return to work (RTW) rate of patients with active or completed litigation- however- • Workers compensation patients 19.5% -RTW • Auto Accident patients 62.5%- RTW • Therefore- the type of litigation influenced outcome
  • 50. Outcome Studies using www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com approach • Johns Hopkins Hospital reduced their workers compensation cost 54% by making their injured employees see only Johns Hopkins Hospital doctors instead of local community doctors Bernacki EJ, Tsai SP. Ten years' experience using an integrated workers' compensation management system to control workers' compensation costs. J Occup Environ Med. 2003 May;45(5):508-16. • The diagnoses of the Diagnostic Paradigm from www.MarylandClincalDiagnostics.com have a 96% correlation with Johns Hopkins Hospital doctors. Hendler, N, Berzowsky, C and Davis, R Comparison of Clinical Diagnoses to Computerized Test Diagnoses, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, pp:8-17, October, 2007. •
  • 51. Outcome Studies using www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com approach • Workers’ compensation patients out of work for 2 years or more had a return to work rate of less than 1% ( Occ. Med, ’68, Occupational Low Back Pain, ’84). • Using www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com tests on a group of patients out of work for an average of 4.9 years, one clinic had a return to work rate of 19.5% for workers’ compensation patients, 62.5% for auto accident patients, a 90% reduction in use of narcotic medication, and 45% reduction in doctors visits. Hendler, N.: "Validating and Treating the Complaint of Chronic Back Pain: The Mensana Clinic Approach." Clinical Neurosurgery. Vol. 35, Chap. 20:385-397, eds. Black, P., Alexander, E., Barrow, D., et. al., Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore, 1988. • Cost savings ranged from $20,000 to $175,000 http://www.slideshare.net/DiagnoseMyPain/patient-cost-savings-documented-with-letters
  • 52. Methods to Avoid Misdiagnosis • See www.MarylandClinicalDiagnostics.com • The Pain Validity Test can predict, with 95% accuracy, who will have moderate or severe abnormalities on objective medical tests, and can predict, with 85% accuracy who will not (1). • The Diagnostic Paradigm will give a physician diagnoses which have a 96% correlation with diagnoses of Johns Hopkins Hospital physician (2) • The Treatment Algorithm list the proper tests to use to confirm the diagnoses, and proper treamtments (1)Hendler, N. and Baker, A., An Internet questionnaire to predict the presence or absence of organic pathology in chronic back, neck and limb pain patients, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, Vol. 12, No. 1, pp: 15-24, April, 2008. (2) Hendler, N., Berzoksky, C. and Davis, R.J. Comparison of Clinical Diagnoses Versus Computerized Test Diagnoses Using the Mensana Clinic Diagnostic Paradigm (Expert System) for Diagnosing Chronic Pain in the Neck, Back and Limbs, Pan Arab Journal of Neurosurgery, pp:8-17, October, 2007.