SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 12
1




        B.C. School Retrofit Program

            $2.5 billion project
                      +
          $ 7m research program
                      at
       University of British Columbia




Kyoto Seminar          12-14 Jan 2010   Liam Finn
2




 New Ideas for Economic Retrofit
             Deaggregation of hazard

 Performance – based design with drift ratio
          performance criterion

  IDA analyses of 31 generic school models
      9m nonlinear analyses conducted
Seismic performance calculator to access data

            Toolbox of retrofit options


  Kyoto Seminar           12-14 Jan 2010   Liam Finn
Context
• BC’s population:
  4.4 million
• More than 800
  schools in BC’s
  seismic risk areas
• 80% of the
  schools located in
  high seismic risk
  areas (Victoria
  and Vancouver)
Methodology - Motions
    Earthquakes in Similar Tectonic Settings

California         Peru & Chile            Washington




 Mexico       Japan                  Central-America
Methodology - Motions
                                        Characteristic Motion Histories
                   0.3
                         a)
                                                                               Crustal
                    0



               -0.3
                0.3
                         b)                          Time (Sec)

                                                                            Subcrustal
Acceleration (g)




                    0




               -0.3
                0.3
                         c)                          Time (Sec)

                                                                            Subduction
                    0




               -0.3
                   0          10   20     30   40      50         60   70     80   90    100
                                                    Time (sec)
Methodology - Basics
Guidelines Objective:
Probability of Damage            High Probability of
                                 Collapse


    Inter-storey
    Drift
    Deformation


                                            Aleatory
                                            Demand
Buildings – LDRS

Modeling




  School Building

                          Shear Spring Model
Site Conditions   Site Class D
Dense soil and Soft Rock




 Liquefiable Soil               Site Class E
Methodology - Calculator
School Instrumentation

Objectives:

Provide early warning of quake
Improve quality and speed of post-earthquake damage
assessment to ensure early access to safe schools

1. 4 instruments per school for seismic response data.
      Reports to server at UBC
      Passive on site storage

2. 1 Free field instrument linked to early warning
     network
Acknowledgement
1.       Professor Carlos Ventura and Professor Liam Finn
2.       UBC research team
         Dr. Freddy Pina
         Dr. Mehrtash Motammedi
         Bishnu Pandey
         Manuel Archila
         Jose Centeno
3.       British Columbia Ministry of Education
4.       Association of Professional Engineers and
         Geoscientists of British Columbia (APEGBC), Peter
         Mitchell (Project manager)

5.       Peer review committee
         Robert Hanson (FEMA                           John Sherstobitoff (Ausenco Sandwell)
         Farzad Naeim (John A. Martin&Associates)      Dr. Ron DeVall (RJC)
         Michael Mehrain (URS Corporation
                                                        John Wallace (Genivar)
                                                        Clint Low (Bosh, Bohman Partners)
                                                        Dr. Timothy White(Bosh, Bohman Partners)
Thank you!

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN
UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN
UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN Alondra Quiroz
 
PowerPoint Resources
PowerPoint ResourcesPowerPoint Resources
PowerPoint Resourcesgreenkytu
 
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streams
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streamsCp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streams
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streamszubeditufail
 
Secuencia Didáctica nº 2
Secuencia  Didáctica nº 2Secuencia  Didáctica nº 2
Secuencia Didáctica nº 2Marta Quintero
 
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer Ingelheim
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer IngelheimGeorge Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer Ingelheim
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer IngelheimKisaco Research
 
Sistema Nervioso Central
Sistema Nervioso Central Sistema Nervioso Central
Sistema Nervioso Central katherine Viera
 
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016Alejandra Feldman
 
Principles of marketing,branding,advertising
Principles of marketing,branding,advertisingPrinciples of marketing,branding,advertising
Principles of marketing,branding,advertisingAhmed Soliman
 

Destacado (13)

Yes
YesYes
Yes
 
Monstres
MonstresMonstres
Monstres
 
UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN
UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN
UNIDAD 3: TECNOLOGÍAS DE INTEGRACIÓN
 
Sample
SampleSample
Sample
 
PowerPoint Resources
PowerPoint ResourcesPowerPoint Resources
PowerPoint Resources
 
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streams
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streamsCp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streams
Cp gp day02 session 6 - data collection, quantification of waste streams
 
Etapas del embrión
Etapas del embriónEtapas del embrión
Etapas del embrión
 
Secuencia Didáctica nº 2
Secuencia  Didáctica nº 2Secuencia  Didáctica nº 2
Secuencia Didáctica nº 2
 
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer Ingelheim
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer IngelheimGeorge Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer Ingelheim
George Heidgerken, Global Head of Animal Health, Boehringer Ingelheim
 
Módulo manejo integrado del agua
Módulo manejo integrado del aguaMódulo manejo integrado del agua
Módulo manejo integrado del agua
 
Sistema Nervioso Central
Sistema Nervioso Central Sistema Nervioso Central
Sistema Nervioso Central
 
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016
Y Ahora Qué Cocina? Revista digital-digital-marzo-2016
 
Principles of marketing,branding,advertising
Principles of marketing,branding,advertisingPrinciples of marketing,branding,advertising
Principles of marketing,branding,advertising
 

Similar a B.C. School Retrofit Program - Liam Finn

AISA Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXions
AISA  Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXionsAISA  Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXions
AISA Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXionsChris Jansen
 
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilities
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilitiesThe use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilities
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilitiesMarco Pautasso
 
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...Engineers Australia
 
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functions
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functionsUse of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functions
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functionsopenseesdays
 
Biodiversity, people and networks
Biodiversity, people and networksBiodiversity, people and networks
Biodiversity, people and networksMarco Pautasso
 

Similar a B.C. School Retrofit Program - Liam Finn (10)

Citizen science
Citizen scienceCitizen science
Citizen science
 
Mark Jessell - Next Generation 3D Modelling
Mark Jessell - Next Generation 3D ModellingMark Jessell - Next Generation 3D Modelling
Mark Jessell - Next Generation 3D Modelling
 
AISA Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXions
AISA  Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXionsAISA  Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXions
AISA Leadership retreat Ghana 2013: Making the conneXions
 
Pore scale dynamics and the interpretation of flow processes - Martin Blunt, ...
Pore scale dynamics and the interpretation of flow processes - Martin Blunt, ...Pore scale dynamics and the interpretation of flow processes - Martin Blunt, ...
Pore scale dynamics and the interpretation of flow processes - Martin Blunt, ...
 
Ncree intro
Ncree introNcree intro
Ncree intro
 
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilities
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilitiesThe use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilities
The use of networks in the study of climate-related vulnerabilities
 
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...
ICWES15 - Optimising Hydropower Generation through Fluid Dynamics Research. P...
 
Team 3
Team 3Team 3
Team 3
 
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functions
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functionsUse of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functions
Use of OpenSees for the development of physics based tsunami fragility functions
 
Biodiversity, people and networks
Biodiversity, people and networksBiodiversity, people and networks
Biodiversity, people and networks
 

Más de EERI

Masonry Construction Around the World
Masonry Construction Around the WorldMasonry Construction Around the World
Masonry Construction Around the WorldEERI
 
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1EERI
 
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2EERI
 
Intro to Confined Masonry
Intro to Confined MasonryIntro to Confined Masonry
Intro to Confined MasonryEERI
 
Virtual sidewalk survey
Virtual sidewalk surveyVirtual sidewalk survey
Virtual sidewalk surveyEERI
 
Sidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveySidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveyEERI
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document reviewEERI
 
Visual categorization
Visual categorizationVisual categorization
Visual categorizationEERI
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document reviewEERI
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document reviewEERI
 
Visual inspection
Visual inspectionVisual inspection
Visual inspectionEERI
 
Sidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveySidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveyEERI
 
Concrete Coalition
Concrete CoalitionConcrete Coalition
Concrete CoalitionEERI
 
What to Count
What to CountWhat to Count
What to CountEERI
 
Tips to tell Concrete Buildings
Tips to tell Concrete BuildingsTips to tell Concrete Buildings
Tips to tell Concrete BuildingsEERI
 
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...EERI
 
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey  – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey  – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...EERI
 
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...EERI
 
John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...
 John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal... John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...
John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...EERI
 
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...EERI
 

Más de EERI (20)

Masonry Construction Around the World
Masonry Construction Around the WorldMasonry Construction Around the World
Masonry Construction Around the World
 
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 1
 
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2
Analysis of Confined Masonry part 2
 
Intro to Confined Masonry
Intro to Confined MasonryIntro to Confined Masonry
Intro to Confined Masonry
 
Virtual sidewalk survey
Virtual sidewalk surveyVirtual sidewalk survey
Virtual sidewalk survey
 
Sidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveySidewalk survey
Sidewalk survey
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document review
 
Visual categorization
Visual categorizationVisual categorization
Visual categorization
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document review
 
Policy document review
Policy document reviewPolicy document review
Policy document review
 
Visual inspection
Visual inspectionVisual inspection
Visual inspection
 
Sidewalk survey
Sidewalk surveySidewalk survey
Sidewalk survey
 
Concrete Coalition
Concrete CoalitionConcrete Coalition
Concrete Coalition
 
What to Count
What to CountWhat to Count
What to Count
 
Tips to tell Concrete Buildings
Tips to tell Concrete BuildingsTips to tell Concrete Buildings
Tips to tell Concrete Buildings
 
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...
Shannon Van Zandt, Texas A & M University – “Poor and Minority Impacts from H...
 
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey  – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey  – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...
Nate Wood, United States Geological Survey – “Population Vulnerability to Ts...
 
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...
“Nursing Home Vulnerability in Hurricane Irene” - Samantha Penta, University ...
 
John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...
 John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal... John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...
John Marshall, Georgia State University – “Large-scale Disasters and Federal...
 
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...
California Geological Survey – “Probabilistic Tsunami Modeling and Public Pol...
 

B.C. School Retrofit Program - Liam Finn

  • 1. 1 B.C. School Retrofit Program $2.5 billion project + $ 7m research program at University of British Columbia Kyoto Seminar 12-14 Jan 2010 Liam Finn
  • 2. 2 New Ideas for Economic Retrofit Deaggregation of hazard Performance – based design with drift ratio performance criterion IDA analyses of 31 generic school models 9m nonlinear analyses conducted Seismic performance calculator to access data Toolbox of retrofit options Kyoto Seminar 12-14 Jan 2010 Liam Finn
  • 3. Context • BC’s population: 4.4 million • More than 800 schools in BC’s seismic risk areas • 80% of the schools located in high seismic risk areas (Victoria and Vancouver)
  • 4. Methodology - Motions Earthquakes in Similar Tectonic Settings California Peru & Chile Washington Mexico Japan Central-America
  • 5. Methodology - Motions Characteristic Motion Histories 0.3 a) Crustal 0 -0.3 0.3 b) Time (Sec) Subcrustal Acceleration (g) 0 -0.3 0.3 c) Time (Sec) Subduction 0 -0.3 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Time (sec)
  • 6. Methodology - Basics Guidelines Objective: Probability of Damage High Probability of Collapse Inter-storey Drift Deformation Aleatory Demand
  • 7. Buildings – LDRS Modeling School Building Shear Spring Model
  • 8. Site Conditions Site Class D Dense soil and Soft Rock Liquefiable Soil Site Class E
  • 10. School Instrumentation Objectives: Provide early warning of quake Improve quality and speed of post-earthquake damage assessment to ensure early access to safe schools 1. 4 instruments per school for seismic response data. Reports to server at UBC Passive on site storage 2. 1 Free field instrument linked to early warning network
  • 11. Acknowledgement 1. Professor Carlos Ventura and Professor Liam Finn 2. UBC research team  Dr. Freddy Pina  Dr. Mehrtash Motammedi  Bishnu Pandey  Manuel Archila  Jose Centeno 3. British Columbia Ministry of Education 4. Association of Professional Engineers and Geoscientists of British Columbia (APEGBC), Peter Mitchell (Project manager) 5. Peer review committee  Robert Hanson (FEMA  John Sherstobitoff (Ausenco Sandwell)  Farzad Naeim (John A. Martin&Associates)  Dr. Ron DeVall (RJC)  Michael Mehrain (URS Corporation  John Wallace (Genivar)  Clint Low (Bosh, Bohman Partners)  Dr. Timothy White(Bosh, Bohman Partners)

Notas del editor

  1. British Columbia has a population of 4.4 million people. There are over 800 schools in seismic areas and 80% of these are located in areas of high seismic hazard.The seismic hazard may be disaggregated into 3 categories, subduction, sub-crustal nd crustal earthquakes as shown in Fig.1. The se earthquakes are all generated by the subduction of the Juan de Fuca Plate beneath the North American Plate at a rate of 10mm year.
  2. The performance of a building during an earthquake is expressed in terms of drift ratio. The performance standard required for establishing retrofit requirements may be either damage control or life safety. The allowable drit ratio for damage control is much less than that for life safety. For the school project the ministry of Education opted for life safety as the PBEE criterion for retrofit. For wood frame building the associated drift ratio is 4% and this still allows a significant drift margin against collapse. The adoption of a life safety standard allows more economical retrofits.
  3. Drift ratios are estimate by nonlinear dynamic analysis of each of the generic school building types. Describe the procedure for calculation of the probability of drift exceedance. Need to discuss the reliability of any analysis.