Learn how to solve Data Consistency issues across your local search engine listings with this fact and tip filled presentation from IgnitorDigital.com's Mary Bowling - Presented at SMX Advanced Seattle - June 12, 2013
Sales & Marketing Alignment: How to Synergize for Success
Mary Bowling - Maps and Metros - Solving Data Consistency Issues - SMX Advanced 2013
1. Data Management
for
Local Search
Mary Bowling
Blog: www.MaryBowling.com
Small Biz Marketing: www.IgnitorDigital.com
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
3. NAP Consistency Matters
#3 Off-Site Local Search Ranking Factor!
http://www.davidmihm.com/local-search-ranking-factors.shtml
“Citations will always be a major factor
and can help or seriously hurt a listing if
the data is incorrect across the
ecosystem.” Mike Ramsey
“Your Places page may be naked. Your
website may beg for a mercy killing. You
may not have a single customer review.
But you still may rank OK…if your NAP is
accurate and consistent everywhere it
appears on the web. This is do-or-die.”
Phil Rosek
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
“…I've hardly had a case where the
NAP of the business was perfect across
the board." Nyagoslav Zhekov
4. Why?
Google knows it needs to show accurate
business information or people won’t use its
local search results
Google uses the local phone number as the
unique identifier for a business
Not always the way it works in real life for real businesses,
but…
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
5. Why Doesn’t Everyone Do It?
Don’t understand/believe the positive impact
Mini Case Study: For 8 fat head
terms, went from 0 Local Pack listings to 6
in 90 days just by scrubbing data
Tracked 8 terms in very competitive niche and location
Did not rank in top 50 organically for any of them
Did not appear in Local Pack for any of them
Best Places ranking #17
After 90 days of proactive data cleansing (no organic
work)
Ranked in Local Pack for 6 of the 8 terms
Ranked 7 and 8 in Google Places for the other 2
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
6. Be the One That Does It!
It’s a tough, tough job.
Some of the battles you have to fight:
Don’t understand the process
Can’t just add new, correct listings –update/delete old ones
Time consuming and frustrating
Usually you don’t have logins to modify listings
Most require creating and verifying a new account
What you need to do is different at nearly every site
Takes attention to detail, patience and persistence
Clients/Bosses don’t want to pay for the time it takes
People think it’s easy, so they give job to lowest paid workers
When you think you’re done, you’re not –check & recheck
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
7. Data Scrubbing Process
Quick check the extent of data inconsistency*
Determine your strategy*
Check/update NAP info on ALL websites for that client
Gather the information you need
Discover inconsistent data and prioritize updates
Report duplicates and problems at Google ASAP
Correct/submit/report problems at data providers
Correct/submit/report problems at Tier 2 directories
Correct/submit/report problems at add’l trusted places
Wait 45-90 days
Recheck and repeat
One Way to Do It
*TIP: You need this info before pricing job
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
8. Quick Audit
Quick Check for Data
Inconsistency
Using NAP info on business website:
GetListed.org Tool
Yext.com Tool
Google Places Tool (log in to G)
www.google.com/local/add/g?hl=e
nUS&gl=US#phonelookup
If you have many locations:
Spot check 6-8 in large cities
Ask client where problems are
Ask client which locations are most
important
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
9. Determine Your Strategy
Claim a Listing = You Have to Keep It Updated
How many locations involved?
How much inconsistency discovered?
Time, manpower, budget to do manual updates ?
Budget for submissions?
Time by which you NEED to see some results?
Time to wait for new data to flow through the ecosystem?
Is the company planning a move?
Have logins to most of the places where listed?
Will you bite off in chunks or do it all at once?
Tip: All of the above helps determine cost and time frame.
You can do it fast or you can do it cheap, but not both.
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
10. Get the Info You Need, First
Gather info for each location before starting
Business name
Business street address
Business mailing address
Business local phone number w/area code
Days and hours of operation, methods of payment
List of main services offered
List of main products and brands offered
Pertinent certifications, education, memberships, licenses, etc
Where customers will park ( ex: free adjacent lot, parking garage 1 block)
ZipCodes of areas served and/or radius of area served
Images (must live on Unique URLs on website)
Logo (square and small 100x100)
Storefront (with sign if possible)
Staff (headshots and in action performing services)
Main products
Show people what’s of interest in your niche (wedding cakes, menu
items, hotel lobby, apartment swimming pool, etc.)
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
11. Discover Inconsistent NAP
Ask!
Business name
Business street address
Business mailing address
Business local phone number w/area code
Have you changed phone numbers? (Old numbers?)
Do/have you use more than 1 phone number. (All numbers?)
Have you moved? (All old addresses?)
Have you used call tracking numbers? (All numbers?)
Have you used local phone numbers for areas you serve, but where you don’t
have an office, shop or store? (All numbers?)
What are the URLs for all of your websites?
Have you done internet advertising through a phone/yellow pages company?
Have you used more than one business name, including variations? (Names?)
What does the sign outside your business say on it?
What name, address , phone number are listed in your local phone book?
Have you ever used a PO Box, UPS Store, virtual office or employee or friend’s
address for your business? (All addresses?)
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
12. Discover Inconsistent NAP
Look!
Check NAP on all websites – correct? in text form?
(preferably in local business schema)
Confusing or conflicting info? Correct it now!
Check address at USPS database
https://tools.usps.com/go/ZipLookupAction!input.action
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
13. Discover Inconsistent NAP
Use Google
Google Places – search all numbers used
www.google.com/local/add/g?hl=enUS&gl=US#phonelookup
Google Maps search – look for Google’s suggestions
Google organic search for name address/phone
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
14. Report Problems at Google ASAP
Use Google Support Options
Report/Edit using Mapmaker
Directly from listing
Find answers
http://support.google.com/places/bin/ans
wer.py?hl=en&answer=176504
Report using trouble shooter
http://productforums.google.com/forum/
#!forum/business
Get a call back-talk to support!
login to Google account
https://support.google.com/business/cont
act/business_c2c
Google Support has IMPROVED!
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
15. Tips for Google
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
New Places Database Much More Stable
No longer completely rebuilt from scratch every 6 weeks
Info updates MUCH more quickly via Mapmaker
interface
Listing verification occurs through Places, review and
approval occur via Mapmaker.
After verification, you still need to go through review
and wait for approval before info goes live
Merges should NOT reoccur after being fixed
For more info on resolving problems at Google Places:
http://ignitordigital.com/solving-common-problems-with-your-google-
places-listing/
16. Tips for Google
Make Things Easier/Better
Consolidate all listings for a single business in 1
Google account for that business only
Use account with a domain-associated email address
Use a bulk upload for 10 + locations (easier
verification)
New business or business unverified at Google Places,
submitting via data providers before claiming could
ease verification (requires more time)*
Not sure what to do at Google+? Don’t do anything, yet
http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!category-
topic/business/I0Royu8V9x8
*TIP: Legit biz in a real place? Don’t worry about verification!
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
17. Tips for Google
Google Map PINs are Critical!
Check Map Pin Location(s)
Type full street address into Maps
Zoom in on Street View
Make sure it’s in the right place
Correct, as needed
TIP: You can rarely do this accurately w/o client involvement.
TIP: Check Google’s driving directions for accuracy, too.
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
18. Discover Inconsistent NAP
Use tools!
GetListed.org – enter business
name(s) and ZipCode(s)
Yext.com – enter business
name(s) and phone(s)
Whitespark Citation Finder Tool
enter name(s) and phone(s)
www.whitespark.ca/local-citation-finder/
Tip: None are 100% - double check
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
19. Discover Inconsistent NAP
Check & Modify or Submit at Data Providers
Most have more than one method to check for existing listings
– use all of them for best results
InfoGroup http://expressupdateusa.com/
Localeze http://webapp.localeze.com/directory/search.aspx
Acxiom http://mybusinesslistingmanager.com/
Universal Business Listing http://search.ubl.org/
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
20. Data Provider Tips
Localeze
Support slow
More listings in account, harder to manage
Can’t always tell if modification incurs a charge or not
Defaults listings to auto-renew – change to do not renew
If they lapse, they are still in account and can be renewed
UBL
Slow support
Data probably not as trusted, but widely distributed
Data feeds to Acxiom and InfoGroup
InfoGroup and Acxiom
Use these to check for bad/duplicate listings
Modify/delete, as needed
If data doesn’t match, phone verification is done
Infogroup – they call biz
Acxiom – biz calls them
TIP: Each requires different formatting & info for bulk uploads
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
21. Local Search Data Distribution
From David Mihm :
http://www.davidmihm.com/blog/local-seo/local-search-ecosytem-fall-2012/
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
22. Local Search Data Distribution
From David Mihm :
http://www.davidmihm.com/blog/local-seo/apple-maps-ecosystem/
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
23. Process
Scrub Your Data Clean – Phase 1
Find & Correct Data: Company Website(s), Google Places and
Major Data Providers
Check and correct any confusion on company website(s)
Use schema coding for NAP
Discover old/bad/duplicate Google Places listings
Use Google
Report Google duplicates, near duplicates, listings w/bad info
Use Report a problem (takes you into Mapmaker)
Use other Google support options
Discover and update/modify bad listings at data providers
Use data providers’ tools
Modify/delete bad listings at data providers
If no listing, add it
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
24. Process
Scrub Your Data Clean – Phase 2
Update or Submit Listings at Tier 2 Local Directories
Trusted industry Directories
Vary by industry – start here:
https://getlisted.org/static/resources/local-citations-by-category.html
Trusted Local Directories
Vary by location – start here:
https://getlisted.org/static/resources/local-citations-by-city.html
Local phone provider – print and online directories
Historic providers of business data & still matter
Google tends to trust local landline numbers and info
associated with them
Bing Business Portal
Yahoo Local
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
25. Process
Scrub Your Data Clean – Phase 3
Prioritize Updating and Submissions at Other Directories
Using Whitespark Tool
Experience will help you to spot the good outliers , scraper
sites and junk sites
The more work you do in a niche or location, the easier this gets
Don’t bother updating listings on low quality sites
SEOmoz domain authority provided by Whitespark Tool
Eyeball the site – you can tell its quality
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
26. How Long Do Updates Take?
http://blumenthals.com/blog/2012/09/26/infographic-citations-time-to-live/
From Mike Blumenthal & David Mihm
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
27. Measuring Success
Baseline and Compare
Organic rankings
Rankings in Local Packs and Maps
Number of inconsistent listings at trusted sites
Amount of website traffic in general
Amount of traffic from Google Maps
For multiple locations, amount of website traffic to
location-specific landing pages
Number of referrals from sites important in your niche
TIP: Can happen more quickly, but give yourself 3-6 months.
TIP: Advise business on how to keep all data consistent going
forward so they don’t have to do this again.
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
28. Materials Available
View presentations and get checklists here:
http://ignitordigital.com/smxlocalsearch/
http://ignitordigital.com/solving-common-
problems-with-your-google-places-listing/
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
29. Thanks!
Twitter @MaryBowling IgnitorDigital.com + MaryBBowling@gmail.com
Mary Bowling
Blog: www.MaryBowling.com
SMB Marketing: www.IgnitorDigital.com
Get the Slides: IgnitorDigital.com/SMXLocalSearch
Class information:
http://www.marybowling.com/local-search-
optimization/local-search-classes-at-planet-ocean/
Notas del editor
Consulting, Training, Writing and Doing
When we talk about data , we’re mostly talking about NAP – Name, Address, LOCAL phone numberIf you’re not familiar with David Mihm’s Local Search Ranking Factors Survey, please take a look .
There is most definitely a positive effect of cleaning up inconsistent data in trusted places
If you need to make this case to a client or boss to put in the effort to do this for many locations, consider doing it for a trial location and documenting it.
Because this is so time-consuming and mind numbing, hardly anyone does it. Be the one that does!It’s much easier to create listings than it is to get rid of them. A side effect of creating accounts is often a lot of unwanted sales calls
First two items help you price work more accurately.You will dig yourself into a hole if you don’t figure out how much work is involved before you price and promise
It’s the operators in the large cities that tend to be most aggressive with their marketing.Chains and franchises often have particular locations they spend more resources on than others.
Once in claim at listing at most sites, info from the data providers is not likely to override it. You will then have to manually update them whenever a change is made. Make certain you record and organize all your logins, submission dates, updates made, etc.
For greatest efficiency, have the client give you everything you need before getting started
You have to start with as much information as you can pry out of the client for clues to inconsistent data.I’ve found I get much better info if I ask the questions on the phone instead of expecting them to fill it out thoroughly and accurately.
Not unusual to find multiple websites for one or more businesses owned by same company with conflicting or confusing NAP
Google can help you uncover instances of inconsistent NAP in it’s index
If you haven’t tried Google Support lately, you’ll be amazed at the improvement.
You don’t need to worry about verification unless you’re doing something off-white.
You don’t need to worry about verification unless you’re doing something off-white.
With many locations, every local operator may need to check their own and send screen shots of corrections needed.
With GetListed and Whitespark, you’ll get URLs to see your listings. GetListed coaches you through updates and submissionsWith Yext, there are a lot of directories you don’t need to worry about updating
Not usual to find a listing via one of the search options and not the other.Not 100% - there may be listings you cannot find or cannot modify for some reason – contact support
My personal experiences with data providers
Use this to see how the data flows from the major data providers across the web
For Apple Maps, also check your data at Yelp. Email them to have duplicates and/or old listings removed. TomTom and OpenStreetMap also appear to be significant sources of data, so check those, too.
I sort my spreadsheets by DA and ignore anything in the bottom 1/4 to 1/3 of list
It can really depend on where you hit each data provider in its distribution cycle. Read this article to get a better understanding of that. Although some data providers are working on quicker updates, right now you can expect it to take 30-90 days for this process to show results, depending on how widespread inconsistency is.
It can really depend on where you hit each data provider in its distribution cycle. Read this article to get a better understanding of that. Although some data providers are working on quicker updates, right now you can expect it to take 30-90 days for this process to show results, depending on how widespread inconsistency is.