SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 15
Descargar para leer sin conexión
BENNETT, COLEMAN & CO. LTD. | ESTABLISHED 1838 | TIMESOFINDIA.COM | EPAPER.TIMESOFINDIA.COM                   BANGALORE | TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010 | METRO | PAGES 28 | PRICE ` 3 ( ` 5.50 ALONG WITH THE ECONOMIC TIMES)




                                                                                 INCLUSIVE OF 6 PAGES OF BANGALORE TIMES
THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010


                                                                                                                                                                                               STARTING TODAY, EVERY WEEK, WE WILL BRING
                                                                                                                                                                                               THREE PAGES DEDICATED TO ANALYZING THE STATE
                                                                                                                                                                                               OF BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE AND SERVICES.
                                                                                                                                                                                               OVER THE NEXT FEW WEEKS. WE WILL TELL YOU
                                                                                                                                                                                               WHICH ARE THE BEST WARDS IN THE CITY AND
                                                                                                                                                                                               WHICH ARE THE WORST AND WHY THEY ARE SO.
                                                                 MOBILITY                  WATER                                SANITATION                          PUBLIC AMENITIES                            ENVIRONMENT                           CRIME



                   SG H Te
                   LI
                      id S                                       MIDDLING CIVIC SERVICES                                                                                                                                                                               SYED ASIF

GoI standards as benchmark                                                                   Asha Rai | TNN




                                                                 I
The standards used in Bangalore Patrol are those of the                     f The Times of India had held a quiz in which
                              Government of India. The                      it asked the seven million residents of Ban-
                              source of the standards varies                galore to name their best ward, there isn't
                              from indicator to indicator, as               the faintest doubt that the city's biggest news-
                              often each indicator has a                    paper would have got to keep the prize. No-
                              different department setting                  body would have guessed the right answer:
                              the standards. Primary                        Ganesh Mandir. Or for that matter, the worst
                              organizations for standards are               ward: DoddaBidarakallu.
                              Central Public Health and                         These surprise answers are just one small
                              Environmental Engineering                     element of Bangalore Patrol, an ambitious,
                              Organization (CPHEEO), Bureau                 one can even say audacious, attempt by the
                              of Indian Standards (BIS),                    country's largest English newspaper to meas-
                              Ministry of Urban Development                 ure in quantifiable terms the quality of in-
                              (MoUD), Indian Roads Congress                 frastructure and civic services that the lo-
                              (IRC) and Town and Country                    cal government delivers to the city's resi-
                              Planning Organization (TCPO).                 dents.
                              However, some of these                            How often do you find your conversation
                              standards are now up for                      littered with lines like, "the water supply's
revision. For example, the MoUD defines a case of flooding                  pathetic, the traffic is horrendous, and the
as a situation where water is standing for 4 hours for a                    footpaths are such a mess?" More often than
depth of 6 inches or more. This precludes flash floods, and                 you care to know. But how bad or good ex-
fast moving water that doesn’t drain. While this water is                   actly is it? With Bangalore Patrol people fi-
not stagnant it is just as capable of causing damage.                       nally have an answer that's been arrived at
                                                           TOI              empirically For the first time in the coun-
                                                                                         .
                                                                            try, an effort has been made to gather pri-
                                                                            mary data for five services that affect the cit-


                                                                  All the 198 wards of Bangalore have been
                                                                  mapped for delivery against these services
                                                                  on a score of 1 to 10 (in which one is the
                                                                  lowest and ten, the best). The highest
                                                                  scoring ward got a mark of 7.16 and the
                                                                  lowest, 3.19. That roughly means that the
                                                                  best ward in the city gets 70% marks, i.e.
                                                                  first class alright but not distinction while
 Bangalore scores poorly in sanitation standard as
                                                                  the lowest is fail class at just 30%.
 this garbage dumped on BVK Iyengar road testifies
                                                                            izens of a city: Mobility (roads & transport                                                                                                          local governments, and a constabulary that
                                                                            related services), water, health & sanitation,                                                        What is the purpose of doing this               discourages crime while also infusing
                                                                                                                                                                                  study? What impact will it have? We,
Crime data                                                                  public amenities and environment. Only for
                                                                                                                                                                                  at The Times of India, believe that this
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  enough confidence in the people to walk up
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  to the police station and register their com-
                                                                            `crime' which shows how safe the city is, has
The decision to include `Crime’ in this study resulted from                 secondary data been used.                                                                             initiative will be transformational.            plaint.
                           a rhetorical but very serious                        Bangalore Patrol, is a path breaking ini-                                                         That, it will, over time:                           Very importantly it has to be borne in
                           query raised by an eminent                       tiative of The Times of India which has                                                                                                               mind that Bangalore Patrol's scores do not
                           person. “How late will you let                   been conceptualized and executed by Janaa-                                                              Mobilize the people of Bangalore to           mean that Bangalore is a terrible place to
                           your daughter stay out in the                    graha, the Bangalore based non-profit or-                                                               compare where they stand vis-a-vis other      live in. Most obviously it isn't. That's why
                           evenings in your city?”                          ganization that works with people and gov-                                                              wards and demand better services from         the city's population has swelled to seven
                           Implication being that later a                   ernments to change the quality of urban life                                                            their elected representatives.                million and thousands move into Bangalore
                           girl is allowed to return in the                 in India.                                                                                               Make people hold their government and         every month in search of a better life.
                           night, the safer the                                 All the 198 wards of Bangalore have been                                                            elected representatives accountable - not         The main focus of this study is to em-
                           neighbourhood is. However,                       mapped for delivery against these services           rather unfamiliar names. One reason could          for empty promises, but for measurable        power Bangaloreans by putting in their
                           collecting crime data in                         on a score of 1 to 10 (in which one is the low-      simply be that with the renaming of most of        change.                                       hands data with which they can hold their
                           Bangalore proved to be tougher                   est and ten, the best). The highest scoring          the wards, parts of these old areas now fall       The residents of even the better wards will   government and elected representatives ac-
                           than thought as the police was                   ward got a mark of 7.16 and the lowest, 3.19.        under these wards sporting new names. Vas-         demand a higher quality of delivery as        countable and demand of them solutions to
                           not willing to share data on                     That roughly means that the best ward in             anth Nagar which ranks 5th overall has un-         even the best is not good enough.             their daily problems of water, roads, buses,
                           station-wise break-up of crime.                  the city gets 70% marks, i.e. first class alright    der it sections of Sadashivanagar, Sankey                                                        drainage etc.
Hence, crime data was procured at a divisional level with                   but not distinction while the lowest is fail         Raod and the Bangalore Palace area. Also,          People might make decisions on where              But the point this study makes is that
approximations used to allocate crime data to specific                      class at just 30%.                                   very few know that the posh MG Road area           they live based on these scores.              things can be better. That Bangalore
wards.                                                                          This is very surprising as the results           comes under Shantala Nagar ( which inci-                                                         should not settle for second best. Banga-
                                                          TOI               stand on their head conventional wisdom              dentally comes in at a poor 74) . Top ranking       In the US, for example, the school dis-      lore, that is invoked by US President Oba-
                                                                            about the city If you were to ask most Ban-
                                                                                           .                                     Ganesh Mandir is in Banashankari 2nd            tricts, to a large extent determine where peo-   ma in the same breath as Boston should-
                                                                            galoreans to name the posh areas, the ones           stage, home to former prime minister Deve       ple want to live. Those with good schools are    n't be one where walking on footpaths is
                                                                            they think have the best civic amenities, they       Gowda and family The second best ward Sri-
                                                                                                                                                   .                             much sought after while those without, are       at a risk to your ankles, where there is-
                                                                            would automatically name Sadashivanagar,             ramandir is in Rajajingar.                      shunned. Bangalore Patrol, might over time,      n't a single bicycle lane, where one-third
                                                                            Raj Mahal Vilas, Malleswaram, Basa-                     In trying to measure each of the param-      have similar such consequence. Instead of        have no access to public toilets, where al-
                                                                            vanagudi, Koramangala, Indiranagar,                  eters, Bangalore Patrol has used standards      going by the hype, people might vote with        most the whole city has no provision for
                                                                            Jayanagar etc.                                       that would stand the test of scrutiny Hence
                                                                                                                                                                        .        their feet for those areas which deliver qual-   storm water drain.
                                                                                None of these actually figure in the top         the measures are those prescribed by the gov-   ity public services to the citizens, areas           We need to change this, here and now for
                                                                            ten wards. Many who are the top 10 or 20 are         ernment of India's various agencies.            which are seen to have proactive, responsive     we deserve better.




                                                                  TEN BEST WARDS                                                             TEN WORST WARDS How the city                                                                               fares
                                                                  NAME                                  RANK            SCORE*               NAME                                 RANK           SCORE*
                                                                  GANESH MANDIR                          1              7.16                 DODDA BIDARAKALLU                    198            3.19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  1.5




                                                                  SRIRAMAMANDIR                          2              7.12                 BEGUR                                197            3.39
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      %




                                                                  J P NAGAR                              3              7.04                 GARUDACHAR PALYA                     196            3.39
                                                                  NAGAPURA                               4              6.94                 GOTTIGERE                            195            3.61                      30%
 Transport is improving in the city though the road
 surface is pathetic especially after rains.
                                                                  VASANTH NAGAR                          5              6.92                 HORAMAVU                             194            3.76                                               68.5%
                                                                  BASAVESHWARA NAGAR                     6              6.90                 HONGASANDRA                          193            3.77
The study                                                         KAMAKSHIPALYA                          7              6.88                 HAGADUR                              192            3.84
The entire study took a period of six and half months to          HAMPI NAGAR                            8              6.84                 CHOWDESWARI                          191            3.92
complete starting January 2010.
At Janaagraha, a team of 75                                       SUBRAMANYA NAGAR                       9              6.81                 SINGASANDRA                          190            3.95
people worked on the project
including the field team, the                                     JAYANAGAR EAST                         10             6.81                 HEMMIGEPURA                          189            3.97
technology team and office
management. AC Nielsen study                                      * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is the lowest and 10 is the highest
was done over two months. AC                                                                                                                                                                                               WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES OF ABOVE 7
Nielsen collected quantitative
data on cost indicators (water
and transportation), flooding,
                                                                        FOR A DETAILED ASSESSMENT OF EACH WARD, LOG ON TO www.bangalorepatrol.com                                                                          WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES BETWEEN 5 & 7
and household collection of
garbage. These data points are best collected directly from                                 WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR BANGALORE?                                                                                              WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES BETWEEN 3 & 5
citizens, which was the case here. They were then used to
compute scores for these indicators.                                        (A) THE CM (B) THE MAYOR (C) BBMP COMMISSIONER (D) NONE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                    MOST OF BANGALORE ENJOYS A LEVEL OF CIVIC
Radio Mirchi 98.3 FM
                                                                        MAIL US @ banglore.patrol@timesgroup.com or SMS TOIBP <your option> to 58888                                                                SERVICE THAT CAN BE DESCRIBED AS AVERAGE
                                                      ON
TUNE INTO RADIO MIRCHI FROM 7 AM - 11 AM TO DISCUSS
AND DEBATE BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES
                                                                                             NEXT TOPIC              TOP 20 WARDS ON THURSDAY                                                                    Also see page 4 for scores on water, sanitation, mobility,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 environment, public amenities & crime
2                                                                                                                                        THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010


                                                                                                                                                                                            A DETAILED ANALYSIS OF THE QUALITY OF KEY CIVIC
                                                                                                                                                                                            SERVICES LIKE WATER, MOBILITY, SANITATION, PUBLIC
                                                                                                                                                                                            AMENITIES, ENVIRONMENT AND CRIME WILL EMPOWER THE
                                                                                                                                                                                            CITIZENS OF BANGALORE BY PUTTING IN THEIR HANDS THE
                                                                                                                                                                                            DATA REQUIRED TO DEMAND BETTER QUALITY OF SERVICE
                                                                                                                                                                                            FROM THE CITY ADMINISTRATION.
                                                                      MOBILITY                   WATER                            SANITATION                      PUBLIC AMENITIES                           ENVIRONMENT                      CRIME
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 TOI
                                                                                                 Asha Rai | TNN



                 SG H Te
                 LI
                    id S                                              W
                                                                                 hat makes a city livable? What attracts
                                                                                 people to one part of the city even as some
                                                                                 other areas repel? Unfortunately, after six
                                                                                 decades of independence it remains bijli,
                                                                                 sadak and pani. It's the simple things of
                                                                                 life; good water connectivity, regular and
                                                                                 quality supply of power, decent roads,
Water & Environment                                                              speedy, timely transport connections, nice
                                                                                 parks and playgrounds to stroll and play
Bangalore may be thirsty for `more' water, but it has good                       in, good air to breathe and of course, safe
                              water pipeline coverage. Of                        neighbourhoods where people, especially
                              the 198 wards, nearly 132                          women, can move around without fear that
                              wards have scored above 8 on                       define quality of life.
                              10 on this indicator. 11 wards                         Simple as they may seem, these serv-
                              including `Kaveripura' score                       ices are difficult to deliver on the ground.
                              a perfect ten. But the irony is                    Bangalore Patrol's study of the city's 198
                              that while most of the city                        wards reveals that shockingly, on several




                                                                                                                                             HIGH ON
                              has access to a drinking                           parameters, substantial parts of the city
                              water connection, almost two                       score zero implying pathetic quality in the
                              lakh people don't have access                      delivery of the very basic of services.
                              to water.                                              Bangalore Patrol has studied six pa-
                              While Bangalore is celebrated                      rameters: water, mobility (roads, trans-
                              for its green cover, it is a                       port), sanitation, public amenities, envi-




                                                                                                                                             WATER
                              cover that is under threat .                       ronment, and crime. Power, is the only im-
                              Only 11% of Bangalore has                          portant service that has not been includ-
                              access to good parks. A city                       ed in this study, mainly for technical rea-
                              lauded for its gardens has 14                      sons. Of those measured, the city has the
                              wards where there isn't a                          highest score for water and the lowest for
single patch of green. This includes a ward named after                          public amenities. Given the water woes of
the city's founder, Kempegowda! However, hearteningly,                           the city, that Bangalore has the best scores
23 wards have scored a perfect ten for close accessibility                       for this parameter is a pleasant surprise.
to parks.                                                                        This is on account of the city having a very
                                                            TOI                  good pipeline coverage.
                                                                                                                                   LOW ON PUBLIC AMENITIES
                                                                      Over the next few weeks, we will
                                                                      build a number of interactive
                                                                      elements into this campaign so that
                                                                      these scores don't become another
                                                                      bunch of numbers which have little
                                                                      impact on the ground. Bangalore
                                                                      Patrol is a new way to identify and
                                                                      change the problem areas across each
                                                                      and every ward of Bangalore.

                                                                                     That Bangalore lags badly in public
                                                                                 amenities shouldn't surprise anybody.
                                                                                 When you walk down the city's main street,
                                                                                 M G Road, how many litterbins have you
                                                                                 found? Do you know of any woman who
                                                                                 has dared used a public toilet when out
                                                                                 shopping? How many in the city have the
                                                                                 luxury of taking their morning walk in a                                                                                                                                        TOI
                                                                                 neighbourhood garden? How many chil-                 Both in sanitation and crime the low-      tions. In one of the poshest stretches in
                                                                                 dren are forced to play cricket on the            est score is zero, which means in parts of    Bangalore, on Sankey Road, just round the
                                                                                 streets rather than in their nearby public        the city hygiene levels, garbage collection   corner from the chief minister's official
                                                                                 playground? How often do the street lights        are unacceptably low and in some other        residence, below the Windsor Manor Ho-
                                                                                 in your area work?                                parts of Bangalore, crime rate unac-          tel bridge, have you tried walking on the
                                                                                     The ward-wise scores for each of the          ceptably high. To those tracking the soar-    footpath? Forget two, even one can't walk
                                                                                 parameters have been decided based on a           ing crime rate in the city, this shouldn't    properly on the narrow ledge. But this
                                                                                 detailed survey on a total 28 indicators.         come as a surprise at all.                    area scores high on other parameters like
                                                                                 Research and accumulated experience in               The wide range in scores, especially in    environment, pushing up its overall rank.
                                                                                 dealing with citizen issues in the past has       categories where some wards have scored           Due to constraints of space, it is not
                                                                                 helped Janaagraha in arriving at these            the lowest possible `zero,' is worrisome. A   possible for us to analyse the scores for all
                                                                                 main parameters. Everything in a ward             wide range implies that the differences in    the 198 wards individually on each of the
 A littered park best exemplifies the poor state of                              counts on this index, right from the qual-        the quality of services citizens enjoy are    parameters as we would have liked to or
 parks and sanitation in Bangalore                                               ity and exact quantity of water supplied          large which isn't a good thing. Lower range   tackle each of the parameter in great
                                                                                 to a house to the streetlights, roads and                                                       depth. All this information however will
                                                                                 public transport in the areas.                                                                  be available on the website.
                                                                                     Quality of civic infrastructure and                                                             Over the next few weeks, we will build
Roads & Sanitation                                                               services is very poor in areas that have                                                        a number of interactive elements into this
The quality of road surface in the city is rather pitiable. Not                  been freshly added to the city. Bangalore                                                       campaign so that these scores don't be-
                                        a single ward gets a                     went from Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike                                                           come another bunch of numbers which
                                        perfect score on this                    (BMP) to BBMP with it becoming `Bruhat,'                                                        have little impact on the ground. Banga-
                                        indicator. Not all                       a few years ago. Most of the new areas of                                                       lore Patrol is a new way to identify and
                                        wards are safe for                       BBMP suffer from haphazard growth                                                               change the problem areas across each and
                                        pedestrians either.                      without any central planning. Hence, here                                                       every ward of Bangalore. We will mobi-
                                        Pedestrian safety at                     there are rarely any provisions for pub-                                                        lize the residents of different wards, the
                                        junctions is best in 63                  lic amenities. Even water, on which the                                                         Resident Welfare Associations (RWAs), the
                                        wards while 77 wards                     city as a whole scores highly, the story, is                                                    corporators, the MLAs and hold town hall
                                        drop down the card                       altogether different in the newer areas.                                                        meetings to get people's grievances ad-
                                        with a big zero. Of                      While there is piped water supply, it is          suggests a consistency in the delivery im-    dressed. A complaint management system
                                        course, there isn't a                    not from Cauvery river but from the bore          plying quality differences to be low. As a    will also be launched by Janaagraha so
                                        single bicycle lane in                   wells dug near-by!                                city grows, the range should narrow and       that people's individual complaints can be
                                        Bangalore. Public                            Environment scores highly in Banga-           not rise.                                     recorded and forwarded to the relevant au-
transport coverage is extremely poor in the exterior wards,                      lore. Saved mainly by the huge lung spaces           A few might be surprised on why some       thorities.
where people have to walk more than a kilometer to get to                        Bangalore still has in the two big gardens        areas which are seen as bad or a standard         We at The Times of India have brought
their bus stops. Availability of information on public                           (Lalbagh and Cubbon Park), the Banga-             thought to be of low quality get decent       to you many innovative and highly pop-
transport such as route maps and timings is poor across                          lore Palace grounds, Indian Institute of          scores. That's because the norms are a bit    ular initiatives that have made a differ-
the city. Only K R Puram, K R Market and Chalavadipalya                          Science campus, the Race Course and the           dated and need some serious upward re-        ence to your life. Lead India Campaign
score above one for presence of litterbins on streets!                           huge army cantonment. Hence, as trees             vision like the flooding norms (explained     helped identify the potential leaders of
Remaining 195 wards have scored less than one with a                             are being cut on a daily basis to make way        in the earlier page). For example, accord-    the country. Teach India Campaign got
majority of them at zero. When it comes to door-to-door                          for bigger roads and other infrastructure         ing to government norms, footpaths in In-     citizens involved with the task of teach-
garbage collection, even Gandhinagar, the pilot ward that                        work, it is imperative that the citizens fight    dia need to be a minimum of 1.2 m wide        ing children. Bangalore Patrol takes the
experimented on zero-waste management scored only 7.73                           to retain the much needed lung cover the          (enough for two people to walk side by        citizen-centric mandate that TOI has set
                                                                                 city desperately needs.                           side), well paved and free of any obstruc-    for itself forward.


Public Amenities
Bangalore’s public amenities are in a poor state. No ward
                                    has a score of perfect
                                                                      PARAMETER TOP WARD                                            SCORES*                     BOTTOM WARD                                    SCORES*                       RANGE**
                                    ten on this measure.
                                    Attur stands out for              MOBILITY                       J P PARK                             6.66                    DODDABIDARAKALLU                                  2.38                         4.28
                                    being the only ward to
                                    score a zero for
                                    cleanliness on roads.             WATER                          SRIRAM MANDIR                        9.81                    BEGUR                                             1.43                         8.38
                                    Over 70 wards have a
                                    zero score on quality
                                    of its toilets. Another
                                                                      SANITATION                     KAMAKSHIPALYA                        8.51                    HORAMAVU                                          3.32                         5.19
                                    71 wards score below
                                    one on this indicator.            PUBLIC AMENITIES               NAGAPURA                             5.54                    BEGUR                                             0.00                         5.54
                                    The state of public
                                    playgrounds is equally
                                    pathetic. Only nine
                                                                      ENVIRONMENT                    ARAMANE NAGARA                       8.35                    GOTTIGERE                                         3.35                         5.00
                                    out of the 198 wards
                                    have a score above                CRIME                          HEROHALLI                            7.61                    DODDABIDARAKALLU                                  0.00                         7.61
one on this indicator. The remaining 189 wards have,
obviously, scored below one and of these at least 114 wards
score an absolute zero
                                                                              * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is the lowest & 10 is the highest | **Shows the wide difference in quality of service
2                                                                                                                                                                                                                          THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2010


                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      TODAY, WE BRING TO YOU THE BEST WARDS TO LIVE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      IN, IN BANGALORE. WARDS WHICH HAVE THE BEST
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      CIVIC AMENITIES. THE LIST HAS SOLID
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      MIDDLE-CLASS AREAS THAT HAVE QUIETLY
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      CLIMBED THE LADDER TO EMERGE ON TOP,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      DISPLACING BETTER-KNOWN CITY AREAS.
                                                                                                                                                       MOBILITY                     WATER                             SANITATION                           PUBLIC AMENITIES                          ENVIRONMENT                                 CRIME



                 SG H Te
                 LI
                    id S                                                                                  GODS SMILE ON OLD WARDS                                                                                                                                                                                                              PICS : CHETAN SHIVAKUMAR
                                                                                                                                                                                Sunitha Rao R | TNN
Mayor’s ward at 93
                                                                                                                                                                  ven a cursory look at the names that make




                                                                                                          E
                            City Mayor S K Nataraj’s                                                                                                              it to list of the Top 20 wards of Bangalore
                            Sarakki ward ranks 93rd ,                                                                                                             reveals a simple truth: all of them fall un-
                            whereas opposition party                                                                                                              der areas which can be best described as
                            leader (Congress) M Nagaraj’s                                                                                                         old Bangalore. The city offers a clear cut
                            ward bags the 16th place,                                                                                                             division. The older, core areas of Banga-
                            thanks to constant pleas and                                                                                                          lore which have benefited from better plan-
                            uproar in the council to get                                                                                                          ning, resources and have long come under
                            more borewells for his ward.                                                                                                          the Bangalore Municipal Corporation fare
                            Though there were protests                                                                                                            far better than the new additions to the city.
                            held by public in front of                                                                                                            What’s of concern, however, is that there
                            Cauvery Bhavan by residents of                                                                                                        isn’t a single model ward in Bangalore, one
                            Nandini Layout headed by their                                                                                                        that scores a perfect ten. The best ward
                            corporator, the ward scores                                                                                                           scores a hum ho 70% marks. Another fact
                            24th rank in water and 6th                                                                                                            that hits the eye as you run through the
place in public amenities. Nandini layout surpasses number                                                                                                        ranks is that the even among the Top 20,
one ward Ganesh Mandir when it comes to public                                                                                                                    the scores vary dramatically across pa-
amenities, as the latter comes in at number 45.                                                                                                                   rameters. This means that the top ranking
                                                                                                                                                                  wards do not score equally well on all civic
Woes of the exterior                                                                                                                                              services. For example, the number seven
                                                                                                                                                                  ranked Kamakshipalya is ranked a poor
                                  Though Bangalore is
                                                                                                                                                                  113 in mobility (roads & transport) but is
                                  extending herself to the
                                                                                                                                                                  number one in sanitation in the city Vas-
                                                                                                                                                                                                         .
                                  outskirts of the city, the
                                  best areas to put down
                                  roots are in the core areas
                                  of the city, reveals the                                                                                             What has propelled Ganesh Mandir to the
                                  survey. That none of the
                                  wards from the exteriors of                                                                                          top of the charts? As per the Bangalore
                                  Bangalore urban                                                                                                      Patrol survey, a high water (4th) and
                                  agglomeration have made it
                                  to Top 20 shows the lack of                                                                                          mobility (9th) rank have more than
                                  civic amenities among the
                                  newly added 110 villages.
                                                                                                                                                       compensated for the not-so-great scores on
                                  The areas, which were                                                                                                sanitation (51st) and public amenities (45th).
                                  earlier not included within
BBMP limits are still suffering from poor civic amenities;
                                                                                                                                                       Second-ranked Sriram Mandir’s the only
right from poor roads to the water they are supplied with.                                                                                             one among the Top 20 to score ten out of
Though Bangaloreans across the city pay uniform property
tax, all are not privileged to get the best of services that                                                                                           ten for continuity of water supply.                                                                                                                                    BBMP PARK IN GANESH MANDIR
reminds one of the George Orwell who said, “All are equal,
but some are more equal!”
                                                                                                                                                                  antha Nagar, ranked fifth overall, has very          ramanagala. The pleasantly surprised res-                                                          (as per the ministry of urban development
                                                                                                                                                                  good ranking for environment (3) and pub-            idents of Ganesh Mandir aren’t so startled                                                         norms) as a situation where water stands
IISc’s green cover scores highly                                                                                                                                  lic amenities (4) and pathetic ones for crime        because they have been witness to the                                                              for four hours for a depth of 6 inches or
                            Bangalore Patrol has                                                                                                                  (121) and mobility (109). Hence, all the top         steady climb of their ward to the top.                                                             more.
                            discovered that the garden city                                                                                                       20 wards have very good rankings on some             Residents of Ganesh Mandir ward attrib-
                            has its green treasure in                                                                                                             standards and equally poor ones for a few            ute the success largely to the efforts of their                                                    OLD AND BEST
                            Aramane Nagar, which bags the                                                                                                         others which show that the delivery of serv-         former corporator, A H Basavaraju. It was                                                          Jayanagar East, which is one of the oldest
                            first rank in Environment. But                                                                                                        ice even for the best wards in Bangalore is          during his term that the ward got eight                                                            residential areas in the city scores the 10th
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       ,
                            environment score alone does                                                                                                          erratic.                                             parks. The indoor stadium and swimming                                                             rank. The locality, believed to be designed
                            not make the ward score best                                                                                                          The Bangalore Patrol study which assess              pool that were sanctioned during his term                                                          by the maker of modern Karnataka, the
                            as the ward suffers on account                                                                                                        the civic amenities provided to citizens has         are now on the verge of completion. Many                                                           former diwan of Mysore, Sir M Visves-
                            of other civic amenities. It is its                                                                                                   found ward number 165, Ganesh Mandir,                of the ward’s older residents recall the time                                                      varaya, is one of the best planned layouts
                            neighbouring ward                                                                                                                     in Banashankari second stage, coming in              it had muddy roads leading even to former                                                          in Asia.
                            Vasanthnagar that scores the                                                                                                          at the top scoring 7.16 out of 10. The ward          prime minister Deve Gowda’s house. Of             tinuity of water supply Good water rank-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                .
third place in environment score. Even among the top 20                                                                                                           that falls in the Padmanabh Nagar as-                course, that’s history now.                       ing (3rd) and a decent ranking for public        CLEAN AND CLEAR
wards, areas like, Mahalakshmipuram, Maruthi Mandir and                                                                                                           sembly constituency is spread across 1.63            What has propelled Ganesh Mandir to the           amenities (16th) has helped it leapfrog to       When it comes to sanitation, it is Kamak-
Nandini layout score 100th rank in green cover.                                                                                                                   km and houses educational institutions               top of the charts? As per the Bangalore Pa-       the second slot.                                 shipalya in Rajajinagar constituency that
                                                                                                                                                                  like Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sci-            trol survey, a high water (4th) and mobili-                                                        scores the best and tops the list. Kamak-
                                                                                                                                                                  ences (KIMS) and BNM College. Its home               ty (9th) rank has more than compensated           NO FLOODING HERE                                 shipalya which houses areas such as BEML
                                                                                                                                                                  to folk singer Shimoga Subanna and noted             for the not so great scores on sanitation         Ganesh Mandir ward, Dr Raj Kumar ward,           Layout, West of Chord Road I Stage,
                                                                                                                                                                  Kannada writer N S Lakshminarayana                   (51st) and public amenities (45). Second          Sriramamandir, Jayanagara east, JP Na-           Meenakshi Nagar, Cauvery Nagar, KHB
                                                                                                                                                                  Bhatta.                                              ranking Sriram Mandir ward in Rajajina-           gar, Radhakrishna temple ward, Subra-            Colony AK Colony Ashtagrama, Karekallu
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                ,           ,
                                                                                                                                                                  That Ganesh Mandir has emerged as the                gar —which lost the top slot with the slen-       manya Nagar and Nagapura wards have              has fabulous scores for indicators like ac-
                                                                                                                                                                  best ward in Bangalore is a surprise only            derest of margins — is the only ward among        scored ten out of ten in flooding, implying      cess to sewerage network, coverage of
                                                                                                                                                                  to those who live in Sadashivanagar or Ko-           the top 20 that scores ten out of ten for con-    zero flooding. The survey defines flooding       storm water drains, cleanliness on roads.




                                                                                                                                                          TOP                                    BANGALORE’S TOP TWENTY WARDS ARE SPREAD ACROSS THE CITY AND NOT CONCENTRATED

                                                                                                                                                       WARD
                                                                                                                                                                          20    WARD
                                                                                                                                                                                                 IN CERTAIN POCKETS WHICH INDICATES ALL-ROUND DEVELOPMENT OF THE CITY
                                                                                                                                                                                                               WARD             WARD           MOBILITY           WATER      SANITATION        PUBLIC AMENITIES             ENVIRONMENT             CRIME
                                                                                                                                                        NO.                     NAME                           RANK            SCORE*           RANK              RANK         RANK                 RANK                        RANK                RANK
                                                                                                                                                       165        GANESH MANDIR                                 1               7.16            9                  4            51                   45                        26                    49
                                                                                                                                                       108        SRIRAMAMANDIR                                 2               7.12            42                 3            35                   16                        49                    60
                                                                                                                                                       177        J P NAGAR                                     3               7.04            1                  3            1                    15                        75                    114
                                                                                                                                                       67         NAGAPURA                                      4               6.94            17                 47           5                    1                         14                    103
                                                                                                                                                       93         VASANTH NAGAR                                 5               6.92            109                2            98                   4                         3                     121
                                                                     * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 20, where 1 is the lowest and 20 is the highest




                                                                                                                                                       100        BASAVESHWARA NAGAR                            6               6.90            16                 21           45                   26                        26                    25
Grandma enjoys a good outing with her grandson
                                                                                                                                                       101        KAMAKSHIPALYA                                 7               6.88            113                22           1                    27                        26                    16
on a good footpath in Ganesh Mandir.                                                                                                                   133        HAMPI NAGAR                                   8               6.84            25                 23           21                   40                        26                    45
                                                                                                                                                       66         SUBRAMANYA NAGAR                              9               6.81            51                 9            40                   29                        26                    98
               Radio Mirchi 98.3 FM                                                                                                                    170        JAYANAGAR EAST                                10              6.81            30                 6            28                   67                        75                    123
                                                                                                                                                       68         MAHALAKSHIMPURAM                              11              6.72            88                 11           10                   7                         100                   108
   ON          TUNE INTO RADIO MIRCHI FROM 7 AM - 11 AM TO DISCUSS
               AND DEBATE BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES                                                                                          18         RADHAKRISHNA TEMPLE                           12              6.70            6                  40           13                   68                        49                    28
                                                                                                                                                       104        GOVINDARAJA NAGAR                             13              6.69            68                 42           23                   3                         26                    17
                                                                                                                                                       107        SHIVANAGARA                                   14              6.66            5                  28           85                   63                        14                    90
    FOR A DETAILED ASSESSMENT OF EACH WARD,                                                                                                            126        MARUTHI MANDIR                                15              6.63            70                 7            83                   73                        100                   6
       LOG ON TO www.bangalorepatrol.com                                                                                                               43         NANDINI LAYOUT                                16              6.63            48                 24           54                   6                         100                   88
    YOUR DECISION TO LIVE IN AN                                                                                                                        124        HOSAHALLI                                     17              6.62            117                10           9                    55                        75                    50
      AREA IS INFLUENCED BY                                                                                                                            144        SIDDAPURA                                     18              6.61            114                5            41                   61                        49                    131
                                                                                                                                                       106        DR. RAJ KUMAR                                 19              6.58            22                 39           50                   38                        75                    11
    (A) TRANSPORT (B) WATER                                                                                                                            125        MARENAHALLI                                   20              6.57            103                34           12                   24                        75                    2
       (C) COST (D) SAFETY
                     MAIL US @                                                                                                                                     It is encouraging to know that our ward is the                   Mine is the only ward where no flooding takes place when                   It is an encouraging survey report. But as a
                                                                                                                                                                   best. This is largely due to the co operation we                 Bangalore witnesses heavy downpour. It’s because of the                    corporator I look up to the works taken up at the
   banglore.patrol@timesgroup.com or                                                                                                                               receive from officials of different departments.                 extensive de-silting of drains that we have been carrying                  Hanumanthnagar ward. The officials working in
   SMS TOIBP <your option> to 58888
                                                                            VOICES




                                                                                                                                                         When ever we find a problem, we approach the                     out. But there’s much that needs to be improved in my ward. The             this ward are very co operative and they address the public
                                                                                                                                                         officials with evidence and urge them to fix the                 sewerage lines were laid about thirty years ago, they must be               grievances immediately. At present this ward is number
                                                                                                                                                         problem immediately. However, there are certain issues           changed. Shortly, sewerage pipeline replacement work will be
   NEXT TOPIC WORST 20                                                                                                                                   that need to be tackled. We want our parks to be like            initiated at Saraswathi Layout and Binni Layout. Also, garbage is
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          another issue in my ward.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      one, but I want make this true even after six months. It is a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      huge responsibility to maintain the status quo of civic
                                                                                                                                                         mini Lalbaghs.”                                                                                                                              amenities in the ward.”
   WARDS ON SATURDAY                                                                                                                                        N K SREEKANTAIAH | PRESIDENT, BANASHANKARI SECOND
                                                                                                                                                             STAGE, GANESH MANDIR RESIDENTS’ WELFARE ASSOCIATION
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     N SHAKUNTHALA
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  CORPORATOR, MARENAHALLI
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              L GOVINDARAJU
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       CORPORATOR, GANESH MANDIR WARD
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010
Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot
2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot
2024 State of Marketing Report – by HubspotMarius Sescu
 
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPT
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPTEverything You Need To Know About ChatGPT
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPTExpeed Software
 
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage EngineeringsProduct Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage EngineeringsPixeldarts
 
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental HealthHow Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental HealthThinkNow
 
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdfAI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdfmarketingartwork
 
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024Neil Kimberley
 
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)contently
 
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024Albert Qian
 
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie InsightsSocial Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie InsightsKurio // The Social Media Age(ncy)
 
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024Search Engine Journal
 
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summarySpeakerHub
 
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd Clark Boyd
 
Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next Tessa Mero
 
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search IntentGoogle's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search IntentLily Ray
 
Time Management & Productivity - Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity -  Best PracticesTime Management & Productivity -  Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity - Best PracticesVit Horky
 
The six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project managementThe six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project managementMindGenius
 
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...RachelPearson36
 

Destacado (20)

2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot
2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot
2024 State of Marketing Report – by Hubspot
 
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPT
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPTEverything You Need To Know About ChatGPT
Everything You Need To Know About ChatGPT
 
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage EngineeringsProduct Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
Product Design Trends in 2024 | Teenage Engineerings
 
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental HealthHow Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
How Race, Age and Gender Shape Attitudes Towards Mental Health
 
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdfAI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
AI Trends in Creative Operations 2024 by Artwork Flow.pdf
 
Skeleton Culture Code
Skeleton Culture CodeSkeleton Culture Code
Skeleton Culture Code
 
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
PEPSICO Presentation to CAGNY Conference Feb 2024
 
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
Content Methodology: A Best Practices Report (Webinar)
 
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
How to Prepare For a Successful Job Search for 2024
 
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie InsightsSocial Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
Social Media Marketing Trends 2024 // The Global Indie Insights
 
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
Trends In Paid Search: Navigating The Digital Landscape In 2024
 
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
5 Public speaking tips from TED - Visualized summary
 
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
ChatGPT and the Future of Work - Clark Boyd
 
Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next Getting into the tech field. what next
Getting into the tech field. what next
 
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search IntentGoogle's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
Google's Just Not That Into You: Understanding Core Updates & Search Intent
 
How to have difficult conversations
How to have difficult conversations How to have difficult conversations
How to have difficult conversations
 
Introduction to Data Science
Introduction to Data ScienceIntroduction to Data Science
Introduction to Data Science
 
Time Management & Productivity - Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity -  Best PracticesTime Management & Productivity -  Best Practices
Time Management & Productivity - Best Practices
 
The six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project managementThe six step guide to practical project management
The six step guide to practical project management
 
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
Beginners Guide to TikTok for Search - Rachel Pearson - We are Tilt __ Bright...
 

Bangalore Patrol coverage, Nov 9 - Dec 2, 2010

  • 1. BENNETT, COLEMAN & CO. LTD. | ESTABLISHED 1838 | TIMESOFINDIA.COM | EPAPER.TIMESOFINDIA.COM BANGALORE | TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010 | METRO | PAGES 28 | PRICE ` 3 ( ` 5.50 ALONG WITH THE ECONOMIC TIMES) INCLUSIVE OF 6 PAGES OF BANGALORE TIMES
  • 2. THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010 STARTING TODAY, EVERY WEEK, WE WILL BRING THREE PAGES DEDICATED TO ANALYZING THE STATE OF BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE AND SERVICES. OVER THE NEXT FEW WEEKS. WE WILL TELL YOU WHICH ARE THE BEST WARDS IN THE CITY AND WHICH ARE THE WORST AND WHY THEY ARE SO. MOBILITY WATER SANITATION PUBLIC AMENITIES ENVIRONMENT CRIME SG H Te LI id S MIDDLING CIVIC SERVICES SYED ASIF GoI standards as benchmark Asha Rai | TNN I The standards used in Bangalore Patrol are those of the f The Times of India had held a quiz in which Government of India. The it asked the seven million residents of Ban- source of the standards varies galore to name their best ward, there isn't from indicator to indicator, as the faintest doubt that the city's biggest news- often each indicator has a paper would have got to keep the prize. No- different department setting body would have guessed the right answer: the standards. Primary Ganesh Mandir. Or for that matter, the worst organizations for standards are ward: DoddaBidarakallu. Central Public Health and These surprise answers are just one small Environmental Engineering element of Bangalore Patrol, an ambitious, Organization (CPHEEO), Bureau one can even say audacious, attempt by the of Indian Standards (BIS), country's largest English newspaper to meas- Ministry of Urban Development ure in quantifiable terms the quality of in- (MoUD), Indian Roads Congress frastructure and civic services that the lo- (IRC) and Town and Country cal government delivers to the city's resi- Planning Organization (TCPO). dents. However, some of these How often do you find your conversation standards are now up for littered with lines like, "the water supply's revision. For example, the MoUD defines a case of flooding pathetic, the traffic is horrendous, and the as a situation where water is standing for 4 hours for a footpaths are such a mess?" More often than depth of 6 inches or more. This precludes flash floods, and you care to know. But how bad or good ex- fast moving water that doesn’t drain. While this water is actly is it? With Bangalore Patrol people fi- not stagnant it is just as capable of causing damage. nally have an answer that's been arrived at TOI empirically For the first time in the coun- . try, an effort has been made to gather pri- mary data for five services that affect the cit- All the 198 wards of Bangalore have been mapped for delivery against these services on a score of 1 to 10 (in which one is the lowest and ten, the best). The highest scoring ward got a mark of 7.16 and the lowest, 3.19. That roughly means that the best ward in the city gets 70% marks, i.e. first class alright but not distinction while Bangalore scores poorly in sanitation standard as the lowest is fail class at just 30%. this garbage dumped on BVK Iyengar road testifies izens of a city: Mobility (roads & transport local governments, and a constabulary that related services), water, health & sanitation, What is the purpose of doing this discourages crime while also infusing study? What impact will it have? We, Crime data public amenities and environment. Only for at The Times of India, believe that this enough confidence in the people to walk up to the police station and register their com- `crime' which shows how safe the city is, has The decision to include `Crime’ in this study resulted from secondary data been used. initiative will be transformational. plaint. a rhetorical but very serious Bangalore Patrol, is a path breaking ini- That, it will, over time: Very importantly it has to be borne in query raised by an eminent tiative of The Times of India which has mind that Bangalore Patrol's scores do not person. “How late will you let been conceptualized and executed by Janaa- Mobilize the people of Bangalore to mean that Bangalore is a terrible place to your daughter stay out in the graha, the Bangalore based non-profit or- compare where they stand vis-a-vis other live in. Most obviously it isn't. That's why evenings in your city?” ganization that works with people and gov- wards and demand better services from the city's population has swelled to seven Implication being that later a ernments to change the quality of urban life their elected representatives. million and thousands move into Bangalore girl is allowed to return in the in India. Make people hold their government and every month in search of a better life. night, the safer the All the 198 wards of Bangalore have been elected representatives accountable - not The main focus of this study is to em- neighbourhood is. However, mapped for delivery against these services rather unfamiliar names. One reason could for empty promises, but for measurable power Bangaloreans by putting in their collecting crime data in on a score of 1 to 10 (in which one is the low- simply be that with the renaming of most of change. hands data with which they can hold their Bangalore proved to be tougher est and ten, the best). The highest scoring the wards, parts of these old areas now fall The residents of even the better wards will government and elected representatives ac- than thought as the police was ward got a mark of 7.16 and the lowest, 3.19. under these wards sporting new names. Vas- demand a higher quality of delivery as countable and demand of them solutions to not willing to share data on That roughly means that the best ward in anth Nagar which ranks 5th overall has un- even the best is not good enough. their daily problems of water, roads, buses, station-wise break-up of crime. the city gets 70% marks, i.e. first class alright der it sections of Sadashivanagar, Sankey drainage etc. Hence, crime data was procured at a divisional level with but not distinction while the lowest is fail Raod and the Bangalore Palace area. Also, People might make decisions on where But the point this study makes is that approximations used to allocate crime data to specific class at just 30%. very few know that the posh MG Road area they live based on these scores. things can be better. That Bangalore wards. This is very surprising as the results comes under Shantala Nagar ( which inci- should not settle for second best. Banga- TOI stand on their head conventional wisdom dentally comes in at a poor 74) . Top ranking In the US, for example, the school dis- lore, that is invoked by US President Oba- about the city If you were to ask most Ban- . Ganesh Mandir is in Banashankari 2nd tricts, to a large extent determine where peo- ma in the same breath as Boston should- galoreans to name the posh areas, the ones stage, home to former prime minister Deve ple want to live. Those with good schools are n't be one where walking on footpaths is they think have the best civic amenities, they Gowda and family The second best ward Sri- . much sought after while those without, are at a risk to your ankles, where there is- would automatically name Sadashivanagar, ramandir is in Rajajingar. shunned. Bangalore Patrol, might over time, n't a single bicycle lane, where one-third Raj Mahal Vilas, Malleswaram, Basa- In trying to measure each of the param- have similar such consequence. Instead of have no access to public toilets, where al- vanagudi, Koramangala, Indiranagar, eters, Bangalore Patrol has used standards going by the hype, people might vote with most the whole city has no provision for Jayanagar etc. that would stand the test of scrutiny Hence . their feet for those areas which deliver qual- storm water drain. None of these actually figure in the top the measures are those prescribed by the gov- ity public services to the citizens, areas We need to change this, here and now for ten wards. Many who are the top 10 or 20 are ernment of India's various agencies. which are seen to have proactive, responsive we deserve better. TEN BEST WARDS TEN WORST WARDS How the city fares NAME RANK SCORE* NAME RANK SCORE* GANESH MANDIR 1 7.16 DODDA BIDARAKALLU 198 3.19 1.5 SRIRAMAMANDIR 2 7.12 BEGUR 197 3.39 % J P NAGAR 3 7.04 GARUDACHAR PALYA 196 3.39 NAGAPURA 4 6.94 GOTTIGERE 195 3.61 30% Transport is improving in the city though the road surface is pathetic especially after rains. VASANTH NAGAR 5 6.92 HORAMAVU 194 3.76 68.5% BASAVESHWARA NAGAR 6 6.90 HONGASANDRA 193 3.77 The study KAMAKSHIPALYA 7 6.88 HAGADUR 192 3.84 The entire study took a period of six and half months to HAMPI NAGAR 8 6.84 CHOWDESWARI 191 3.92 complete starting January 2010. At Janaagraha, a team of 75 SUBRAMANYA NAGAR 9 6.81 SINGASANDRA 190 3.95 people worked on the project including the field team, the JAYANAGAR EAST 10 6.81 HEMMIGEPURA 189 3.97 technology team and office management. AC Nielsen study * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is the lowest and 10 is the highest was done over two months. AC WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES OF ABOVE 7 Nielsen collected quantitative data on cost indicators (water and transportation), flooding, FOR A DETAILED ASSESSMENT OF EACH WARD, LOG ON TO www.bangalorepatrol.com WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES BETWEEN 5 & 7 and household collection of garbage. These data points are best collected directly from WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR BANGALORE? WARDS THAT HAVE SCORES BETWEEN 3 & 5 citizens, which was the case here. They were then used to compute scores for these indicators. (A) THE CM (B) THE MAYOR (C) BBMP COMMISSIONER (D) NONE MOST OF BANGALORE ENJOYS A LEVEL OF CIVIC Radio Mirchi 98.3 FM MAIL US @ banglore.patrol@timesgroup.com or SMS TOIBP <your option> to 58888 SERVICE THAT CAN BE DESCRIBED AS AVERAGE ON TUNE INTO RADIO MIRCHI FROM 7 AM - 11 AM TO DISCUSS AND DEBATE BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES NEXT TOPIC TOP 20 WARDS ON THURSDAY Also see page 4 for scores on water, sanitation, mobility, environment, public amenities & crime
  • 3. 2 THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 9, 2010 A DETAILED ANALYSIS OF THE QUALITY OF KEY CIVIC SERVICES LIKE WATER, MOBILITY, SANITATION, PUBLIC AMENITIES, ENVIRONMENT AND CRIME WILL EMPOWER THE CITIZENS OF BANGALORE BY PUTTING IN THEIR HANDS THE DATA REQUIRED TO DEMAND BETTER QUALITY OF SERVICE FROM THE CITY ADMINISTRATION. MOBILITY WATER SANITATION PUBLIC AMENITIES ENVIRONMENT CRIME TOI Asha Rai | TNN SG H Te LI id S W hat makes a city livable? What attracts people to one part of the city even as some other areas repel? Unfortunately, after six decades of independence it remains bijli, sadak and pani. It's the simple things of life; good water connectivity, regular and quality supply of power, decent roads, Water & Environment speedy, timely transport connections, nice parks and playgrounds to stroll and play Bangalore may be thirsty for `more' water, but it has good in, good air to breathe and of course, safe water pipeline coverage. Of neighbourhoods where people, especially the 198 wards, nearly 132 women, can move around without fear that wards have scored above 8 on define quality of life. 10 on this indicator. 11 wards Simple as they may seem, these serv- including `Kaveripura' score ices are difficult to deliver on the ground. a perfect ten. But the irony is Bangalore Patrol's study of the city's 198 that while most of the city wards reveals that shockingly, on several HIGH ON has access to a drinking parameters, substantial parts of the city water connection, almost two score zero implying pathetic quality in the lakh people don't have access delivery of the very basic of services. to water. Bangalore Patrol has studied six pa- While Bangalore is celebrated rameters: water, mobility (roads, trans- for its green cover, it is a port), sanitation, public amenities, envi- WATER cover that is under threat . ronment, and crime. Power, is the only im- Only 11% of Bangalore has portant service that has not been includ- access to good parks. A city ed in this study, mainly for technical rea- lauded for its gardens has 14 sons. Of those measured, the city has the wards where there isn't a highest score for water and the lowest for single patch of green. This includes a ward named after public amenities. Given the water woes of the city's founder, Kempegowda! However, hearteningly, the city, that Bangalore has the best scores 23 wards have scored a perfect ten for close accessibility for this parameter is a pleasant surprise. to parks. This is on account of the city having a very TOI good pipeline coverage. LOW ON PUBLIC AMENITIES Over the next few weeks, we will build a number of interactive elements into this campaign so that these scores don't become another bunch of numbers which have little impact on the ground. Bangalore Patrol is a new way to identify and change the problem areas across each and every ward of Bangalore. That Bangalore lags badly in public amenities shouldn't surprise anybody. When you walk down the city's main street, M G Road, how many litterbins have you found? Do you know of any woman who has dared used a public toilet when out shopping? How many in the city have the luxury of taking their morning walk in a TOI neighbourhood garden? How many chil- Both in sanitation and crime the low- tions. In one of the poshest stretches in dren are forced to play cricket on the est score is zero, which means in parts of Bangalore, on Sankey Road, just round the streets rather than in their nearby public the city hygiene levels, garbage collection corner from the chief minister's official playground? How often do the street lights are unacceptably low and in some other residence, below the Windsor Manor Ho- in your area work? parts of Bangalore, crime rate unac- tel bridge, have you tried walking on the The ward-wise scores for each of the ceptably high. To those tracking the soar- footpath? Forget two, even one can't walk parameters have been decided based on a ing crime rate in the city, this shouldn't properly on the narrow ledge. But this detailed survey on a total 28 indicators. come as a surprise at all. area scores high on other parameters like Research and accumulated experience in The wide range in scores, especially in environment, pushing up its overall rank. dealing with citizen issues in the past has categories where some wards have scored Due to constraints of space, it is not helped Janaagraha in arriving at these the lowest possible `zero,' is worrisome. A possible for us to analyse the scores for all main parameters. Everything in a ward wide range implies that the differences in the 198 wards individually on each of the A littered park best exemplifies the poor state of counts on this index, right from the qual- the quality of services citizens enjoy are parameters as we would have liked to or parks and sanitation in Bangalore ity and exact quantity of water supplied large which isn't a good thing. Lower range tackle each of the parameter in great to a house to the streetlights, roads and depth. All this information however will public transport in the areas. be available on the website. Quality of civic infrastructure and Over the next few weeks, we will build Roads & Sanitation services is very poor in areas that have a number of interactive elements into this The quality of road surface in the city is rather pitiable. Not been freshly added to the city. Bangalore campaign so that these scores don't be- a single ward gets a went from Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike come another bunch of numbers which perfect score on this (BMP) to BBMP with it becoming `Bruhat,' have little impact on the ground. Banga- indicator. Not all a few years ago. Most of the new areas of lore Patrol is a new way to identify and wards are safe for BBMP suffer from haphazard growth change the problem areas across each and pedestrians either. without any central planning. Hence, here every ward of Bangalore. We will mobi- Pedestrian safety at there are rarely any provisions for pub- lize the residents of different wards, the junctions is best in 63 lic amenities. Even water, on which the Resident Welfare Associations (RWAs), the wards while 77 wards city as a whole scores highly, the story, is corporators, the MLAs and hold town hall drop down the card altogether different in the newer areas. meetings to get people's grievances ad- with a big zero. Of While there is piped water supply, it is suggests a consistency in the delivery im- dressed. A complaint management system course, there isn't a not from Cauvery river but from the bore plying quality differences to be low. As a will also be launched by Janaagraha so single bicycle lane in wells dug near-by! city grows, the range should narrow and that people's individual complaints can be Bangalore. Public Environment scores highly in Banga- not rise. recorded and forwarded to the relevant au- transport coverage is extremely poor in the exterior wards, lore. Saved mainly by the huge lung spaces A few might be surprised on why some thorities. where people have to walk more than a kilometer to get to Bangalore still has in the two big gardens areas which are seen as bad or a standard We at The Times of India have brought their bus stops. Availability of information on public (Lalbagh and Cubbon Park), the Banga- thought to be of low quality get decent to you many innovative and highly pop- transport such as route maps and timings is poor across lore Palace grounds, Indian Institute of scores. That's because the norms are a bit ular initiatives that have made a differ- the city. Only K R Puram, K R Market and Chalavadipalya Science campus, the Race Course and the dated and need some serious upward re- ence to your life. Lead India Campaign score above one for presence of litterbins on streets! huge army cantonment. Hence, as trees vision like the flooding norms (explained helped identify the potential leaders of Remaining 195 wards have scored less than one with a are being cut on a daily basis to make way in the earlier page). For example, accord- the country. Teach India Campaign got majority of them at zero. When it comes to door-to-door for bigger roads and other infrastructure ing to government norms, footpaths in In- citizens involved with the task of teach- garbage collection, even Gandhinagar, the pilot ward that work, it is imperative that the citizens fight dia need to be a minimum of 1.2 m wide ing children. Bangalore Patrol takes the experimented on zero-waste management scored only 7.73 to retain the much needed lung cover the (enough for two people to walk side by citizen-centric mandate that TOI has set city desperately needs. side), well paved and free of any obstruc- for itself forward. Public Amenities Bangalore’s public amenities are in a poor state. No ward has a score of perfect PARAMETER TOP WARD SCORES* BOTTOM WARD SCORES* RANGE** ten on this measure. Attur stands out for MOBILITY J P PARK 6.66 DODDABIDARAKALLU 2.38 4.28 being the only ward to score a zero for cleanliness on roads. WATER SRIRAM MANDIR 9.81 BEGUR 1.43 8.38 Over 70 wards have a zero score on quality of its toilets. Another SANITATION KAMAKSHIPALYA 8.51 HORAMAVU 3.32 5.19 71 wards score below one on this indicator. PUBLIC AMENITIES NAGAPURA 5.54 BEGUR 0.00 5.54 The state of public playgrounds is equally pathetic. Only nine ENVIRONMENT ARAMANE NAGARA 8.35 GOTTIGERE 3.35 5.00 out of the 198 wards have a score above CRIME HEROHALLI 7.61 DODDABIDARAKALLU 0.00 7.61 one on this indicator. The remaining 189 wards have, obviously, scored below one and of these at least 114 wards score an absolute zero * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is the lowest & 10 is the highest | **Shows the wide difference in quality of service
  • 4. 2 THE TIMES OF INDIA, BANGALORE THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 11, 2010 TODAY, WE BRING TO YOU THE BEST WARDS TO LIVE IN, IN BANGALORE. WARDS WHICH HAVE THE BEST CIVIC AMENITIES. THE LIST HAS SOLID MIDDLE-CLASS AREAS THAT HAVE QUIETLY CLIMBED THE LADDER TO EMERGE ON TOP, DISPLACING BETTER-KNOWN CITY AREAS. MOBILITY WATER SANITATION PUBLIC AMENITIES ENVIRONMENT CRIME SG H Te LI id S GODS SMILE ON OLD WARDS PICS : CHETAN SHIVAKUMAR Sunitha Rao R | TNN Mayor’s ward at 93 ven a cursory look at the names that make E City Mayor S K Nataraj’s it to list of the Top 20 wards of Bangalore Sarakki ward ranks 93rd , reveals a simple truth: all of them fall un- whereas opposition party der areas which can be best described as leader (Congress) M Nagaraj’s old Bangalore. The city offers a clear cut ward bags the 16th place, division. The older, core areas of Banga- thanks to constant pleas and lore which have benefited from better plan- uproar in the council to get ning, resources and have long come under more borewells for his ward. the Bangalore Municipal Corporation fare Though there were protests far better than the new additions to the city. held by public in front of What’s of concern, however, is that there Cauvery Bhavan by residents of isn’t a single model ward in Bangalore, one Nandini Layout headed by their that scores a perfect ten. The best ward corporator, the ward scores scores a hum ho 70% marks. Another fact 24th rank in water and 6th that hits the eye as you run through the place in public amenities. Nandini layout surpasses number ranks is that the even among the Top 20, one ward Ganesh Mandir when it comes to public the scores vary dramatically across pa- amenities, as the latter comes in at number 45. rameters. This means that the top ranking wards do not score equally well on all civic Woes of the exterior services. For example, the number seven ranked Kamakshipalya is ranked a poor Though Bangalore is 113 in mobility (roads & transport) but is extending herself to the number one in sanitation in the city Vas- . outskirts of the city, the best areas to put down roots are in the core areas of the city, reveals the What has propelled Ganesh Mandir to the survey. That none of the wards from the exteriors of top of the charts? As per the Bangalore Bangalore urban Patrol survey, a high water (4th) and agglomeration have made it to Top 20 shows the lack of mobility (9th) rank have more than civic amenities among the newly added 110 villages. compensated for the not-so-great scores on The areas, which were sanitation (51st) and public amenities (45th). earlier not included within BBMP limits are still suffering from poor civic amenities; Second-ranked Sriram Mandir’s the only right from poor roads to the water they are supplied with. one among the Top 20 to score ten out of Though Bangaloreans across the city pay uniform property tax, all are not privileged to get the best of services that ten for continuity of water supply. BBMP PARK IN GANESH MANDIR reminds one of the George Orwell who said, “All are equal, but some are more equal!” antha Nagar, ranked fifth overall, has very ramanagala. The pleasantly surprised res- (as per the ministry of urban development good ranking for environment (3) and pub- idents of Ganesh Mandir aren’t so startled norms) as a situation where water stands IISc’s green cover scores highly lic amenities (4) and pathetic ones for crime because they have been witness to the for four hours for a depth of 6 inches or Bangalore Patrol has (121) and mobility (109). Hence, all the top steady climb of their ward to the top. more. discovered that the garden city 20 wards have very good rankings on some Residents of Ganesh Mandir ward attrib- has its green treasure in standards and equally poor ones for a few ute the success largely to the efforts of their OLD AND BEST Aramane Nagar, which bags the others which show that the delivery of serv- former corporator, A H Basavaraju. It was Jayanagar East, which is one of the oldest first rank in Environment. But ice even for the best wards in Bangalore is during his term that the ward got eight residential areas in the city scores the 10th , environment score alone does erratic. parks. The indoor stadium and swimming rank. The locality, believed to be designed not make the ward score best The Bangalore Patrol study which assess pool that were sanctioned during his term by the maker of modern Karnataka, the as the ward suffers on account the civic amenities provided to citizens has are now on the verge of completion. Many former diwan of Mysore, Sir M Visves- of other civic amenities. It is its found ward number 165, Ganesh Mandir, of the ward’s older residents recall the time varaya, is one of the best planned layouts neighbouring ward in Banashankari second stage, coming in it had muddy roads leading even to former in Asia. Vasanthnagar that scores the at the top scoring 7.16 out of 10. The ward prime minister Deve Gowda’s house. Of tinuity of water supply Good water rank- . third place in environment score. Even among the top 20 that falls in the Padmanabh Nagar as- course, that’s history now. ing (3rd) and a decent ranking for public CLEAN AND CLEAR wards, areas like, Mahalakshmipuram, Maruthi Mandir and sembly constituency is spread across 1.63 What has propelled Ganesh Mandir to the amenities (16th) has helped it leapfrog to When it comes to sanitation, it is Kamak- Nandini layout score 100th rank in green cover. km and houses educational institutions top of the charts? As per the Bangalore Pa- the second slot. shipalya in Rajajinagar constituency that like Kempegowda Institute of Medical Sci- trol survey, a high water (4th) and mobili- scores the best and tops the list. Kamak- ences (KIMS) and BNM College. Its home ty (9th) rank has more than compensated NO FLOODING HERE shipalya which houses areas such as BEML to folk singer Shimoga Subanna and noted for the not so great scores on sanitation Ganesh Mandir ward, Dr Raj Kumar ward, Layout, West of Chord Road I Stage, Kannada writer N S Lakshminarayana (51st) and public amenities (45). Second Sriramamandir, Jayanagara east, JP Na- Meenakshi Nagar, Cauvery Nagar, KHB Bhatta. ranking Sriram Mandir ward in Rajajina- gar, Radhakrishna temple ward, Subra- Colony AK Colony Ashtagrama, Karekallu , , That Ganesh Mandir has emerged as the gar —which lost the top slot with the slen- manya Nagar and Nagapura wards have has fabulous scores for indicators like ac- best ward in Bangalore is a surprise only derest of margins — is the only ward among scored ten out of ten in flooding, implying cess to sewerage network, coverage of to those who live in Sadashivanagar or Ko- the top 20 that scores ten out of ten for con- zero flooding. The survey defines flooding storm water drains, cleanliness on roads. TOP BANGALORE’S TOP TWENTY WARDS ARE SPREAD ACROSS THE CITY AND NOT CONCENTRATED WARD 20 WARD IN CERTAIN POCKETS WHICH INDICATES ALL-ROUND DEVELOPMENT OF THE CITY WARD WARD MOBILITY WATER SANITATION PUBLIC AMENITIES ENVIRONMENT CRIME NO. NAME RANK SCORE* RANK RANK RANK RANK RANK RANK 165 GANESH MANDIR 1 7.16 9 4 51 45 26 49 108 SRIRAMAMANDIR 2 7.12 42 3 35 16 49 60 177 J P NAGAR 3 7.04 1 3 1 15 75 114 67 NAGAPURA 4 6.94 17 47 5 1 14 103 93 VASANTH NAGAR 5 6.92 109 2 98 4 3 121 * Scores are on a scale of 1 to 20, where 1 is the lowest and 20 is the highest 100 BASAVESHWARA NAGAR 6 6.90 16 21 45 26 26 25 Grandma enjoys a good outing with her grandson 101 KAMAKSHIPALYA 7 6.88 113 22 1 27 26 16 on a good footpath in Ganesh Mandir. 133 HAMPI NAGAR 8 6.84 25 23 21 40 26 45 66 SUBRAMANYA NAGAR 9 6.81 51 9 40 29 26 98 Radio Mirchi 98.3 FM 170 JAYANAGAR EAST 10 6.81 30 6 28 67 75 123 68 MAHALAKSHIMPURAM 11 6.72 88 11 10 7 100 108 ON TUNE INTO RADIO MIRCHI FROM 7 AM - 11 AM TO DISCUSS AND DEBATE BANGALORE’S INFRASTRUCTURE SERVICES 18 RADHAKRISHNA TEMPLE 12 6.70 6 40 13 68 49 28 104 GOVINDARAJA NAGAR 13 6.69 68 42 23 3 26 17 107 SHIVANAGARA 14 6.66 5 28 85 63 14 90 FOR A DETAILED ASSESSMENT OF EACH WARD, 126 MARUTHI MANDIR 15 6.63 70 7 83 73 100 6 LOG ON TO www.bangalorepatrol.com 43 NANDINI LAYOUT 16 6.63 48 24 54 6 100 88 YOUR DECISION TO LIVE IN AN 124 HOSAHALLI 17 6.62 117 10 9 55 75 50 AREA IS INFLUENCED BY 144 SIDDAPURA 18 6.61 114 5 41 61 49 131 106 DR. RAJ KUMAR 19 6.58 22 39 50 38 75 11 (A) TRANSPORT (B) WATER 125 MARENAHALLI 20 6.57 103 34 12 24 75 2 (C) COST (D) SAFETY MAIL US @ It is encouraging to know that our ward is the Mine is the only ward where no flooding takes place when It is an encouraging survey report. But as a best. This is largely due to the co operation we Bangalore witnesses heavy downpour. It’s because of the corporator I look up to the works taken up at the banglore.patrol@timesgroup.com or receive from officials of different departments. extensive de-silting of drains that we have been carrying Hanumanthnagar ward. The officials working in SMS TOIBP <your option> to 58888 VOICES When ever we find a problem, we approach the out. But there’s much that needs to be improved in my ward. The this ward are very co operative and they address the public officials with evidence and urge them to fix the sewerage lines were laid about thirty years ago, they must be grievances immediately. At present this ward is number problem immediately. However, there are certain issues changed. Shortly, sewerage pipeline replacement work will be NEXT TOPIC WORST 20 that need to be tackled. We want our parks to be like initiated at Saraswathi Layout and Binni Layout. Also, garbage is another issue in my ward. one, but I want make this true even after six months. It is a huge responsibility to maintain the status quo of civic mini Lalbaghs.” amenities in the ward.” WARDS ON SATURDAY N K SREEKANTAIAH | PRESIDENT, BANASHANKARI SECOND STAGE, GANESH MANDIR RESIDENTS’ WELFARE ASSOCIATION N SHAKUNTHALA CORPORATOR, MARENAHALLI L GOVINDARAJU CORPORATOR, GANESH MANDIR WARD