SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 2
Descargar para leer sin conexión
SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION
4400 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20016-8017 202-885-2058
www.american.edu/soc
March 14, 2014
Critique of work by Julia Henning
Richard Benedetto, retired USA Today White House correspondent
Adjunct Professor, American University, George Mason University
1. Remains of missing Vietnam Soldiers laid to rest in Arlington
http://www.army.mil/article/106967/Remains_of_missing_Vietnam_Soldiers_laid_to_rest_in
_Arlington/
This a very thorough and emotional story on the burial of the heretofore missing
remains of three Army soldiers killed 43 years ago in a helicopter crash in Vietnam. Her
use of quotes from the sole survivor added a poignant human touch to the story.
She did a nice job explaining the process of finding and identifying the remains with
good details that help spotlight the spirit and dedication of those charged with that task.
She also brought life to outlining the actual incident in which they were killed.
If I were to make suggestions to make a good story even better, I would have her put
something up near the top on why they were missing so long, and tried to get quotes from
family memebers of those being buried.
Overall, this is a good story with great human interest.
2. 100 Year-old WAC Shares Army Memories
http://soldiers.dodlive.mil/2013/06/100-year-old-wac-shares-army-memories/
This is the kind of story people love to read, but sadly don’t get enough of in their
daily newspapers. It has great human interest and captures very nicely the 100-year-old
veteran’s indomitable spirit and undying love of her service to her country some 72 years
after she enlisted.
Ms. Henning used nice imagery in her anecdotal lede describing how the new recruit was
dressed when she joined, and continued using that great eye for detail throughout the
piece. This article was essentially a short biography of Ms. De Mumbrun which gives the
reader a good sense of her personality, her toughness and her joie de vivre.
One suggestion: since this is an Army publication, I would put more about her Army
service higher in the piece.
SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION
4400 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20016-8017 202-885-2058
www.american.edu/soc
3. Evan Tan wins 2013 SA elections by one vote
http://chimes.biola.edu/story/2013/feb/21/biola-as-elections-results/
Good example of deadline-election reporting with the narrowness of the vote being the
main focus.
Great description of the emotions of the winners and losers as they awaited the count and
finally found out the result
Nice on-the-spot reporting, with nice color and quotes from several angles.
Excellent use of team reporting to produce one good, thorough and colorful story.
…Richard Benedetto

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Politicians Losing Control of Messages
Politicians Losing Control of MessagesPoliticians Losing Control of Messages
Politicians Losing Control of MessagesThor Tolo
 
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMatters
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMattersJonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMatters
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMattersJonathan Cramer
 
Hidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterley
Hidden figures by Margot Lee ShatterleyHidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterley
Hidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterleylindatw
 
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-in
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-inWomen in Journalism: A 2010 Check-in
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-inMoxley Carmichael
 
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5shona_r
 
Presidents
PresidentsPresidents
Presidentsraffer12
 
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"Riddhi Bhatt
 
Washington Irving Facebook
Washington Irving FacebookWashington Irving Facebook
Washington Irving FacebookKsundvall
 
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR ME
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR MEPRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR ME
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR MEICFECI
 
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politics
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politicsJohn T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politics
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politicsShirley Rose
 
Anti death penalty
Anti death penaltyAnti death penalty
Anti death penaltyGP10
 

La actualidad más candente (14)

Politicians Losing Control of Messages
Politicians Losing Control of MessagesPoliticians Losing Control of Messages
Politicians Losing Control of Messages
 
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMatters
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMattersJonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMatters
Jonathan Cramer Writing Sample_JournalismMatters
 
Johnathan
Johnathan Johnathan
Johnathan
 
Hidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterley
Hidden figures by Margot Lee ShatterleyHidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterley
Hidden figures by Margot Lee Shatterley
 
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-in
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-inWomen in Journalism: A 2010 Check-in
Women in Journalism: A 2010 Check-in
 
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5
AS Media- Film Introduction Evaluation: Q5
 
Presidents
PresidentsPresidents
Presidents
 
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"
Fairy Tales Traits in "The Great Gatsby"
 
Washington Irving Facebook
Washington Irving FacebookWashington Irving Facebook
Washington Irving Facebook
 
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR ME
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR MEPRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR ME
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR - THEN THEY CAME FOR ME
 
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politics
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politicsJohn T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politics
John T. McCutcheon Cartoons - women in politics
 
President
PresidentPresident
President
 
Anti death penalty
Anti death penaltyAnti death penalty
Anti death penalty
 
President
PresidentPresident
President
 

Similar a School of Communication Critique

My Men In Battle Links to The Past
My Men In Battle Links to The PastMy Men In Battle Links to The Past
My Men In Battle Links to The PastJayson Sawyer
 
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 iiVeteransBraintrust
 
Example Essays Midsummer Night Dream
Example Essays Midsummer Night DreamExample Essays Midsummer Night Dream
Example Essays Midsummer Night DreamTina Hudson
 
Character Sketch Example Essays
Character Sketch Example EssaysCharacter Sketch Example Essays
Character Sketch Example EssaysMelissa Gomez
 
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismFestering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismYHRUploads
 
Poetry Explication Essay
Poetry Explication EssayPoetry Explication Essay
Poetry Explication EssayJenny Jackson
 
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfAdmission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfEllen Blackburn
 
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfAdmission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfJamie Jackson
 
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismFestering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismYHRUploads
 
Journalism Essays.pdf
Journalism Essays.pdfJournalism Essays.pdf
Journalism Essays.pdfMary Ballek
 
Awareness about MMIW
Awareness about MMIWAwareness about MMIW
Awareness about MMIW2729951
 
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essay
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essaySuccessful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essay
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essayAshley Matulevich
 
Boston bomber paper
Boston bomber paperBoston bomber paper
Boston bomber papercemert
 
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdf
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdfSlaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdf
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdfRenee Spahn
 
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdf
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdfWaiting For Superman Essay.pdf
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdfSharon Lopez
 
Waiting For Superman Essay
Waiting For Superman EssayWaiting For Superman Essay
Waiting For Superman EssayKaren Goldmas
 
Writing An Abstract For A Book Chapter
Writing An Abstract For A Book ChapterWriting An Abstract For A Book Chapter
Writing An Abstract For A Book ChapterMonique Davis
 
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-int
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-intFA15_Issue 3_features_page5-int
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-intElizabeth Orosco
 
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docxRAJU852744
 

Similar a School of Communication Critique (20)

My Men In Battle Links to The Past
My Men In Battle Links to The PastMy Men In Battle Links to The Past
My Men In Battle Links to The Past
 
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii
25th anniversary cbcvbalc sept202013 ii
 
Example Essays Midsummer Night Dream
Example Essays Midsummer Night DreamExample Essays Midsummer Night Dream
Example Essays Midsummer Night Dream
 
Character Sketch Example Essays
Character Sketch Example EssaysCharacter Sketch Example Essays
Character Sketch Example Essays
 
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismFestering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
 
Poetry Explication Essay
Poetry Explication EssayPoetry Explication Essay
Poetry Explication Essay
 
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfAdmission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
 
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdfAdmission Essay Writing Help.pdf
Admission Essay Writing Help.pdf
 
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racismFestering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
Festering: Amrita Chakrabarti Myers on the wound of racism
 
Journalism Essays.pdf
Journalism Essays.pdfJournalism Essays.pdf
Journalism Essays.pdf
 
Awareness about MMIW
Awareness about MMIWAwareness about MMIW
Awareness about MMIW
 
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essay
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essaySuccessful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essay
Successful Student Essay. Admission essay: Being a college student essay
 
Boston bomber paper
Boston bomber paperBoston bomber paper
Boston bomber paper
 
Essay On Market
Essay On MarketEssay On Market
Essay On Market
 
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdf
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdfSlaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdf
Slaughterhouse Five Essay Topics.pdf
 
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdf
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdfWaiting For Superman Essay.pdf
Waiting For Superman Essay.pdf
 
Waiting For Superman Essay
Waiting For Superman EssayWaiting For Superman Essay
Waiting For Superman Essay
 
Writing An Abstract For A Book Chapter
Writing An Abstract For A Book ChapterWriting An Abstract For A Book Chapter
Writing An Abstract For A Book Chapter
 
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-int
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-intFA15_Issue 3_features_page5-int
FA15_Issue 3_features_page5-int
 
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx
1162019 Model Minority Myth Again Used As A Racial Wedge B.docx
 

School of Communication Critique

  • 1. SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION 4400 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20016-8017 202-885-2058 www.american.edu/soc March 14, 2014 Critique of work by Julia Henning Richard Benedetto, retired USA Today White House correspondent Adjunct Professor, American University, George Mason University 1. Remains of missing Vietnam Soldiers laid to rest in Arlington http://www.army.mil/article/106967/Remains_of_missing_Vietnam_Soldiers_laid_to_rest_in _Arlington/ This a very thorough and emotional story on the burial of the heretofore missing remains of three Army soldiers killed 43 years ago in a helicopter crash in Vietnam. Her use of quotes from the sole survivor added a poignant human touch to the story. She did a nice job explaining the process of finding and identifying the remains with good details that help spotlight the spirit and dedication of those charged with that task. She also brought life to outlining the actual incident in which they were killed. If I were to make suggestions to make a good story even better, I would have her put something up near the top on why they were missing so long, and tried to get quotes from family memebers of those being buried. Overall, this is a good story with great human interest. 2. 100 Year-old WAC Shares Army Memories http://soldiers.dodlive.mil/2013/06/100-year-old-wac-shares-army-memories/ This is the kind of story people love to read, but sadly don’t get enough of in their daily newspapers. It has great human interest and captures very nicely the 100-year-old veteran’s indomitable spirit and undying love of her service to her country some 72 years after she enlisted. Ms. Henning used nice imagery in her anecdotal lede describing how the new recruit was dressed when she joined, and continued using that great eye for detail throughout the piece. This article was essentially a short biography of Ms. De Mumbrun which gives the reader a good sense of her personality, her toughness and her joie de vivre. One suggestion: since this is an Army publication, I would put more about her Army service higher in the piece.
  • 2. SCHOOL OF COMMUNICATION 4400 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20016-8017 202-885-2058 www.american.edu/soc 3. Evan Tan wins 2013 SA elections by one vote http://chimes.biola.edu/story/2013/feb/21/biola-as-elections-results/ Good example of deadline-election reporting with the narrowness of the vote being the main focus. Great description of the emotions of the winners and losers as they awaited the count and finally found out the result Nice on-the-spot reporting, with nice color and quotes from several angles. Excellent use of team reporting to produce one good, thorough and colorful story. …Richard Benedetto