2. Age of the Earth Assumptions
Science involves a lot of guesswork
Presuppositions affect research outcomes
Scientists with different beliefs look at the same data and
come to very different conclusions
Assumption of Assumption of All theories of
Evolution Creation
Earth’s origins
are based on
Scientific Data assumptions &
theories that
can never be
Evolution is Intelligent Design proven
Seen is Seen
3. Age of the Earth: Evolution
Many scientists today believe that:
• Humans began to evolve 1.4 million years ago
• Fish were seen about
500 million years ago
• Earth’s first life forms
appeared 3.5 billion
years ago
• Our planet is roughly
4,600,000,000 years
old
4. In 1859, Darwin published his theory of
evolution in "The Origin of Species"
• Theory not readily accepted
Earth not believed to be old enough
Scientists look for clues that suggest Earth is very old
• Now scientists use fossil and geologic records to construct
a very long history of life on Earth
5. Age of the Earth: The Bible
• Bishop Ussher (in 1654) estimated Earth was created 6000
years ago (in 4004 BC) - based on the Bible & historical documents
• Most Creationists now estimate earth’s
age to be about 10,000 years old
- based on historical documents & scientific
evidence
Bishop Ussher
(1581-1656)
6. Age of the Earth: Theistic Evolution
Some scientists think evolution and
the Bible fit together perfectly
• Genesis creation account a
metaphor (not a literal 6 days)
• God supernaturally initiated the
evolutionary process
created universe
"planted" DNA on Earth
7. Age of Earth Research
All these theories still being researched
• Theories change based on new data and findings
• Don’t be too hasty to judge until you've really studied all the facts
All these theories require a certain
amount of faith
8. Primordial Soup
Assumes ancient earth atmosphere
of ammonia, hydrogen, methane and
water vapor
• volcano-like environments
Lightning striking methane gas could
form organic compounds
• Amino acids, ATP, sugars and nitrogen
bases synthesized from cyanide in lab
experiment
These simple molecules could
arrange themselves into small,
single-stranded strips of RNA which
in turn produce DNA
Problems:
• 2nd Law of Thermodynamics (entropy)
• Early atmosphere now believed to contain
CO2 & O2
9. Endosymbiont Theory
If a prokaryote ingested some aerobic bacteria, it's possible that they
formed a symbiotic relationship that helped them both survive better.
10. Extraterrestrial Seed Theory
Complex DNA coding would have
been necessary for even the
hypothetical first simple cells.
DNA evidence speaks of intelligent,
information-bearing design.
• Extra-terrestrial civilization
sent/brought DNA to earth
Panspermia - "seeds everywhere"
• archaebacteria, which can be dormant
and withstand harsh environments,
could have existed on another planet,
making its way to Earth via space dust
(meteorites) instead of originating
here
11. Big Bang Theory
A cosmic explosion (or expansion) hurling matter in all
directions created the universe 10-20 billion years ago
Evidence
• distant galaxies are traveling away from
us at great speeds
• Cosmic radiation (from the explosion?)
can be observed
Problems
• 1st Law of Thermodynamics – energy can
neither be created nor destroyed
• Entropy (2nd Law) – every life process
increases the disorder and disorganization
of matter (unless there is some sort of
intervention)
• Doesn’t account for organic (living)
matter, only gas
Probably will never be proven or dispelled
– not a testable theory
12.
13. Review: Earth/Fields of Study
Archeology
• The study of Artifacts
Paleontology
• The study of Fossils
Geology
• The study of Rocks & Earth's composition/history
Embryology
• The study of embryos (pre-born organisms)
Which parts of Earth are
• SOLID inner core & crust
• LIQUID outer core
• SEMI-SOLID mantle
14. Review: Rock Cycle
What are the 3 major rock types?
• Sedimentary
• Metamorphic
• Igneous
What are the steps involved in the
formation of Sedimentary rocks?
• Weathering
• Erosion hint: WED B/C/C
• Deposition
• Burial/Compaction/Cementation
Give an example of weathering
• physical, chemical & biological (tree roots, freezing water, animals burrowing, rust,
acid rain, waves crashing, etc.)
What is erosion?
• soil and sand carried away by water, wind, glaciers, landslides, etc.
Name some ways sediments are deposited.
• settling of biogenic ooze, melting icebergs & glaciers, volcanic eruptions, estuaries,
evaporation
15. Review: Rock Cycle
Describe the process of Burial, Compaction & Cementation.
• Layers buried under new sediment
• Particles pressed together by weight of water/sediment above
• Sediment cemented by minerals crystallizing between particles
What forces produce metamorphic rock?
• Heat & Pressure
What types of rock can become
metamorphic rock?
• all types
What is produced when rock is melted
into a semi-solid form?
• magma
What is the difference between an igneous intrusion & igneous
extrusion?
• intrustion: magma that comes up but never reaches the surface (dike/sill/batholith)
intrustion
• extrusion: magma that is spewed or flows out of the crust (lava)
extrusion
16. Review: Fossils
What is a fossil?
• Evidence of organisms that once lived on Earth
Where are most fossils found?
• In sedimentary rock (also tar pits, amber or frozen in ice)
Explain what a MOLD & CAST fossil is?
• organism is buried in mud and disintegrates, leaving a hollow mold which later fills with sediment
Give an example of a TRUE FORM fossil.
• insect incased in amber or frozen wooly mammoth
How does PETRIFACTION occur?
• plant or animal remains are covered with water, and over time minerals from the water are absorbed into it and solidify
Name some examples of TRACE FOSSILS.
• T-Rex footprints, feeding marks, dino poo, tree root cavities, roundworm burrows
17. Review: Geologic Time
What are some ways a scientist might
estimate the age of a fossil or rock layer?
• Stratigraphy
• Dendrochronology
• Radioisotope dating
• Molecular clocks
• Index fossils
Explain the difference between
RELATIVE AGE and ABSOLUTE AGE.
• Relative: compares index fossils and rock layers (stratigraphy) to give an "older
Relative
than" or "younger than" estimation
• Absolute: uses Dendrochronology & Radioisotope dating to give an estimated
Absolute
number of years old
What does the principle of superposition assume?
• that younger rock layers and fossils are deposited on top of older fossils & rocks
18. Review: Geologic Time
What assumptions have
been made in the
formation of the GEOLOGIC
COLUMN pictured here?
• slow, even sedimentation
rates (no hydrologic sorting
or catastrophic events)
• radiometric dating of rock
layers is accurate
• index fossils are reliable
indicators to date rock layers
• lack of transitional fossils &
gaps in fossil record are due
to periods of rapid evolution
19. Review: Paleontology Viewpoints
Phyletic Gradualism (Uniformitarianism)
"The present is key to the past"
Slow sedimentation rates remain relatively constant throughout history
• .2 - 100 cm of sediment laid down per 1000 years
• takes millions of years for sedimentary rock layers to form
Phyletic Discontinuity (Catastrophism)
Catastrophic events cause rapid, widespread sedimentation
• volcanoes, floods, ice ages, etc.
• hydrologic sorting produces distinct rock layers with different fossils
Punctuated Equilibrium
Slow sedimentation rates and evolutionary changes "punctuated"
(interrupted) by catastrophic events and rapid evolution
• Explains mass extinctions, "Cambrian Explosion" & lack of transitional fossils
Sudden disappearance of certain species
Sudden appearance of new species (fossils)
Rapid evolution triggered by sudden environmental changes
20. Review: Classification
What are the 8 levels of classification?
Hint: Did King Philip Came Over For Good Soup?
Domain
Kingdom
Phylum
Class
Order
Family
Genus
Species
What is the type of
evolutionary grouping
shown here called?
• a cladogram
(Tree of Life)
21. Review: Phylogenetic Classification
3 Domains in the "Tree of Life"
• Bacteria
• Archaea
• Eukarya
6 Kingdoms?
• True bacteria
• Ancient bacteria
• Protists
• Fungi
• Plants
• Animals
What do scientists look at when trying to classify organisms
into clades?
• morphology
homologous & analogous features
• embryological development
• genetic similarities
• the fossil record
22. Review: Evolution
What does "descent with modification" mean?
• Given enough time, many small changes in the gene
frequency of a species result in big changes within a
population, resulting in speciation
What adaptations are passed between
generations?
• Only inherited (genetic) traits are given to offspring
What are 3 mechanisms of
evolutionary change?
• genetic variation
• natural selection
adaptations that increase fitness are "chosen" by the
environment to be passed on via reproduction
• genetic drift
random changes in gene frequency
23. Review:
Genetic Variation
Evolutionary change can ONLY happen with
changes to the genes of a population.
What are 3 sources of variation?
• Mutation
caused by errors in DNA replication,
increased by exposure to mutagens
• Gene Flow
genetic exchange due to migration
of individuals
• Sexual Reproduction
meiosis:
• crossing over
• independent assortment
24. Review: Natural Selection
How does it work?
• A change in traits occurs
due to genetic variation
i.e. a green beetle has brown baby
• There is differential reproduction
environmental changes affect who survives to
reproduce
i.e. green beetles get eaten by birds, so only brown
beetles survive to reproduce
• Inherited traits are passed on
i.e. surviving brown beetles have brown babies
because this trait has a genetic basis
What is an ADAPTATION?
• a feature that becomes common in a population
because it provides some improved function
necessary for survival and/or reproduction
What is evolutionary fitness?
• the ability to survive and reproduce
25. Review: Evolution
What is the likelihood of a mutation being beneficial?
• extremely small - most mutations are neutral, harmful, or lethal
Which cells in an organism pass on their DNA to offspring?
• gametes (egg, sperm, pollen, etc. - reproductive cells)
What contributes to an organism "FITNESS"?
• ability to compete for resources
• health/hardiness
• reproductive success
• predator evasion
• resistance to disease, starvation, effects of aging
What is extinction?
• when a species (and their DNA) fails to survive (they all die)
26. Review: Types of Evolution
What is microevolution?
• changes in traits (and gene frequency) within a species
Name some examples of microevolution.
• Peppered moth industrial melanism, beetle colors, Darwin's
finches, antibiotic-resistant bacteria
What is macroevolution?
• changes above species level
Name some examples of macroevolution.
• ferns pine trees, fish amphibians, dinosaurs birds, whales
horses **never observed in nature
What is coevolution?
• when two different species affect each others' adaptations
What close relationships between organisms could
contribute to coevolution?
• Competitive, mutualistic, predator/prey, parasite/host
27. Review: Age of Earth Theories
• How old do "Young- • How old do Evolutionists
Earth" Creationists estimate earth’s age to
believe earth to be? be:
about 10,000 yrs about 4,600,000,000 yrs
• What is Theistic Evolution?
a theory of creation that assumes each "day" of creation was perhaps
millions of years long
incorporates the idea of evolutionary formation of living species but
identifies a Creator (God) as the instigator (DNA-planter?)
Editor's Notes
So why do we study something that cannot be proven? Scientific Method = “best guess” theory is tested over and over until disproved. Whether right or wrong, a lot is learned along the way.
In 1859, Darwin proposed a theory that all life is related and has descended from a common ancestor in his book, "The Origin of Species" Darwin’s theory was not readily accepted because Earth was not believed to be old enough for the evolutionary processes he described to occur Scientist then began looking for clues that might suggest our planet is very old Since Darwin proposed his theory of evolution, scientists have used the fossil and geologic records to construct a very long history of life on Earth
In 1654 Bishop Ussher calculated that the Earth was created 6000 years ago (in 4004 BC) using evidence from the Bible and other Middle Eastern literature Based on all know scientific data available, most Creationists now estimate earth’s age to be about 10,000 years old
Proposed first by American biologist Lynn Margulis in the early 1960's.
There have been around 22,000 documented meteorite discoveries on Earth and many have been found to hold organic compounds. In 1996, a group of scientists announced they had spotted strong evidence of microfossils on a Martian meteorite found in Antarctica showing that life may have existed on the Red Planet some 3.6 billion years ago. After years of intense debate, the issue whether the Martian meteorite contains life or not remains unresolved.
solid Iron inner core, liquid outer core, semi-solid Mantle (magma)
Why do you think very few fossils are found in igneous or metamorphic rock? Fossils are usually found in sedimentary rock. Since most sedimentary rock is laid down by water, it follows that most fossils were laid down by water as well. The vast majority of the fossil record is made up of clams and other hard-shelled creatures. Most of the remaining fossils are of either water-dwelling creatures or insects. Only a tiny, tiny fraction of the fossils we find are of plants, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Many of the fossils we find are of plants and animals which are still alive today. Some of the fossils we find are of plants and animals which are now extinct. The fossils found in one layer of stratified rock can be considerably different than the fossils found in another layer of the same stratified rock.
Mt . St. Helens displaced huge amounts of dirt, rock and snow, carving a mini grand canyon and leaving over 50 feet of sediment deposited across the valley within a matter of minutes
K: Animalia P: Chordata C: Aves
Archaebacteria ("ancient" extremophiles) are genetically more similar to eukaryotes than bacteria.
adaptations that increase fitness are "chosen" by the environment to be passed on via reproduction