SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 20
Katie McKnight, Ph.D.
Katie@katherinemcknight.com
The Textbook Challenge
 Often Superficial
 Exceedingly Hard to Read
 Badly Designed
 Authoritarian
 Inaccurate
 Not Written for Students
Six Ways to Use Textbooks
More Effectively
1. Empathy- Do you remember when you had
difficulty in a subject and the text was difficult?
2. Help the students to get started. We need to
“front-load” our teaching.
3. Don’t leave kids alone with their textbooks.
4. Choose wisely. Be more selective with
assignments. Be strategic about what is most
important.
5. Supplement richly.
Textbook Feature Analysis
 Think about the textbooks that your students
encounter. What kinds of features would they find in
these texts?
 How do textbooks affect our students’ study habits and
success?
Now What?
 Consider the role of your textbook in teaching your
subject matter.
 How can you promote critical thinking with
textbooks?
Strategies for Textbooks: A Sample
 Sticky Notes
 Bookmarks
 ReQuest
 Supplement Richly
 Audio Assist
 Making Smaller Book Versions
Daniels, H. and Zimmerman, S. (2004). Subjects
Matter: Every Teachers’ Guide to Content –Area
Reading. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, p 121.
Sketch
Through Text
Stop and Write
Textbook Circles
 Modeled after Literature Circles
 Students work in teams of 4-5 members.
 Going BEYOND the textbook
 Using a wide variety of reading material
 Students choose what they will read.
Getting Started
 Assign groups for some reading experiences.
 When the students are reading a longer work, groups
are formed by choice.
Going Beyond the Textbook
 Other than textbooks, how do we get information?
 Look at the adult world and what do we read and use
to get the information that we need?
Going Beyond the Textbook
 Other than textbooks, how do we get information?
 Look at the adult world and what do we read and use
to get the information that we need?
 Reference Books
 News Stories (Print and Digital Media)
 Historical Accounts
 Memoirs
 Narrated nonfiction
Using a Wide Variety
of Reading Material
 Fiction vs Non Fiction
 Levels of text difficulty
 Different levels of length
 Primary and Secondary Sources
 Multiple Texts and Single Sources
Classroom Libraries
 Articles
 Magazines
 Website Lists
 A wide variety of trade books
Books for Content Reading
 See American Library Association
 http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/yalsa/yals
a.cfm
 The Official Site of the Assembly on Literature for
Adolescents
 http://www.alan-ya.org/
Resources I Like
 Subjects Matter: Every Teacher's Guide to Content-Area
Reading, Harvey Daniels and Steven Zemelman
 Differentiating Textbooks: Strategies to Improve
Student Comprehension and Motivation, James Grant
 The Teacher’s Big Book of Graphic Organizers,
Katherine McKnight
How to Reach Me
 Email: katie@katherinemcknight.com
 Website: katherinemcknight.com
 Twitter: @literacyworld
 Facebook: Katie Siewert McKnight Literacy

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Port Alberni Nov 1.16
Port Alberni Nov 1.16Port Alberni Nov 1.16
Port Alberni Nov 1.16Faye Brownlie
 
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Malu Sciamarelli
 
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL Class
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL ClassReading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL Class
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL ClassMalu Sciamarelli
 
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum Constraints
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum ConstraintsNCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum Constraints
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum ConstraintsMindi Rench
 
Balanced Literacy Presentation
Balanced Literacy PresentationBalanced Literacy Presentation
Balanced Literacy PresentationGLKinTeacher
 
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013Putting It Together NCTE November 2013
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013Stacy Slater
 
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015Keller I S D Presentation November 2015
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015Teri Lesesne
 
Building a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryBuilding a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryddawer
 
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCL
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCLWriting across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCL
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCLFaye Brownlie
 
Reading and writing for the love of it
Reading and writing for the love of itReading and writing for the love of it
Reading and writing for the love of itFaye Brownlie
 
"What is Your Future without the Library?"
"What is Your Future without the Library?""What is Your Future without the Library?"
"What is Your Future without the Library?"kslovesbooks
 
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article)
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article) 5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article)
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article) SVTaylor123
 
Creating Classroom Libraries
Creating Classroom LibrariesCreating Classroom Libraries
Creating Classroom LibrariesAngel Somers
 
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3Faye Brownlie
 
Make the Most of Minilessons
Make the Most of MinilessonsMake the Most of Minilessons
Make the Most of MinilessonsMindi Rench
 
7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson
7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson
7th gradebookselectionresourceslessonGittaDenning
 

La actualidad más candente (18)

Port Alberni Nov 1.16
Port Alberni Nov 1.16Port Alberni Nov 1.16
Port Alberni Nov 1.16
 
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching Writing Groups in Language Teaching
Writing Groups in Language Teaching
 
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL Class
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL ClassReading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL Class
Reading Aloud in the EFL and CLIL Class
 
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum Constraints
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum ConstraintsNCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum Constraints
NCTE 2012 Facilitating Choice Within Curriculum Constraints
 
Balanced Literacy Presentation
Balanced Literacy PresentationBalanced Literacy Presentation
Balanced Literacy Presentation
 
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013Putting It Together NCTE November 2013
Putting It Together NCTE November 2013
 
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015Keller I S D Presentation November 2015
Keller I S D Presentation November 2015
 
Building a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryBuilding a classroom library
Building a classroom library
 
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCL
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCLWriting across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCL
Writing across the Curriculum - Middle/Senior Years, MRCL
 
Reading and writing for the love of it
Reading and writing for the love of itReading and writing for the love of it
Reading and writing for the love of it
 
"What is Your Future without the Library?"
"What is Your Future without the Library?""What is Your Future without the Library?"
"What is Your Future without the Library?"
 
Classroom Libraries
Classroom LibrariesClassroom Libraries
Classroom Libraries
 
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article)
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article) 5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article)
5020 week 7 funds of knowl schema comprehen (moll article)
 
Classroom Library
Classroom LibraryClassroom Library
Classroom Library
 
Creating Classroom Libraries
Creating Classroom LibrariesCreating Classroom Libraries
Creating Classroom Libraries
 
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3
BJF.Delta.Nov Redesigned ELA Curriculum K-3
 
Make the Most of Minilessons
Make the Most of MinilessonsMake the Most of Minilessons
Make the Most of Minilessons
 
7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson
7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson
7th gradebookselectionresourceslesson
 

Similar a B 2 trouble with textbooks

NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009
NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009
NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009Brian Housand
 
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3Liz Fogarty
 
Speaking their Language Day 3
Speaking their Language Day 3Speaking their Language Day 3
Speaking their Language Day 3Liz Fogarty
 
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila Oneal
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila OnealLiterate Environment Analysis By Sheila Oneal
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila Onealsheoneal
 
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom Libraries
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom LibrariesIndependent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom Libraries
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom LibrariesMonika Gruss
 
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough Guidance
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough GuidanceWhen Guided Reading Isn't Enough Guidance
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough GuidanceLiz Fogarty
 
2014 reading workshop series day 2
2014 reading workshop series day 22014 reading workshop series day 2
2014 reading workshop series day 2Jennifer Evans
 
Literate Environment Analysis Presentation
Literate Environment Analysis PresentationLiterate Environment Analysis Presentation
Literate Environment Analysis Presentationdozier326
 
Creating Literate Learners
Creating Literate LearnersCreating Literate Learners
Creating Literate LearnersLynnSwaving
 
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...MjManuel6
 
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis Presentation
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis PresentationKinta Atkins Litarary Analysis Presentation
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis PresentationKinta Atkins
 
State library conference_presentation_cody_version
State library conference_presentation_cody_versionState library conference_presentation_cody_version
State library conference_presentation_cody_versionCody Lawson
 
Literate environment analysis for week 7
Literate environment analysis for week 7Literate environment analysis for week 7
Literate environment analysis for week 7Valerie Robinson
 
Literate environment analysis presentation
Literate environment analysis presentationLiterate environment analysis presentation
Literate environment analysis presentationMarie.jeanty
 
A final look at content area literacy
A final look at content area literacyA final look at content area literacy
A final look at content area literacyCiel Educttu
 
Literacy Presentation
Literacy PresentationLiteracy Presentation
Literacy Presentationnichole316
 

Similar a B 2 trouble with textbooks (20)

NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009
NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009
NAGC Wednesday Academy 2009
 
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3
Way Beyond Dick and Jane Day 3
 
Speaking their Language Day 3
Speaking their Language Day 3Speaking their Language Day 3
Speaking their Language Day 3
 
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila Oneal
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila OnealLiterate Environment Analysis By Sheila Oneal
Literate Environment Analysis By Sheila Oneal
 
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom Libraries
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom LibrariesIndependent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom Libraries
Independent Reading, Reading Journals & Classroom Libraries
 
Ehs566
Ehs566Ehs566
Ehs566
 
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough Guidance
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough GuidanceWhen Guided Reading Isn't Enough Guidance
When Guided Reading Isn't Enough Guidance
 
Ftla
FtlaFtla
Ftla
 
2014 reading workshop series day 2
2014 reading workshop series day 22014 reading workshop series day 2
2014 reading workshop series day 2
 
Literate Environment Analysis Presentation
Literate Environment Analysis PresentationLiterate Environment Analysis Presentation
Literate Environment Analysis Presentation
 
Creating Literate Learners
Creating Literate LearnersCreating Literate Learners
Creating Literate Learners
 
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...
Building Reading Comprehension Habits in Grades 6-12_ A Toolkit of Classroom ...
 
Independent reading
Independent readingIndependent reading
Independent reading
 
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis Presentation
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis PresentationKinta Atkins Litarary Analysis Presentation
Kinta Atkins Litarary Analysis Presentation
 
State library conference_presentation_cody_version
State library conference_presentation_cody_versionState library conference_presentation_cody_version
State library conference_presentation_cody_version
 
Literate environment analysis for week 7
Literate environment analysis for week 7Literate environment analysis for week 7
Literate environment analysis for week 7
 
Literate environment analysis presentation
Literate environment analysis presentationLiterate environment analysis presentation
Literate environment analysis presentation
 
A final look at content area literacy
A final look at content area literacyA final look at content area literacy
A final look at content area literacy
 
Literacy Presentation
Literacy PresentationLiteracy Presentation
Literacy Presentation
 
NCAGT SEM-R
NCAGT SEM-RNCAGT SEM-R
NCAGT SEM-R
 

Más de Katie McKnight

Verona 1.reading in the content areas
Verona 1.reading in the content areasVerona 1.reading in the content areas
Verona 1.reading in the content areasKatie McKnight
 
K2 a tech workshopfinal
K2 a tech workshopfinalK2 a tech workshopfinal
K2 a tech workshopfinalKatie McKnight
 
Writing With Your Feet
Writing With Your FeetWriting With Your Feet
Writing With Your FeetKatie McKnight
 
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated Instruction
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated InstructionCommon Core State Standards and Differentiated Instruction
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated InstructionKatie McKnight
 
Di and Technology January 12, 2012
Di and Technology January 12, 2012Di and Technology January 12, 2012
Di and Technology January 12, 2012Katie McKnight
 
Di and Tech jan 12, Orlando, FL
Di and Tech  jan 12, Orlando, FLDi and Tech  jan 12, Orlando, FL
Di and Tech jan 12, Orlando, FLKatie McKnight
 
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11Katie McKnight
 
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant Readers
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant ReadersReaching and Teaching Reluctant Readers
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant ReadersKatie McKnight
 
Literature circles start to finish
Literature circles start to finishLiterature circles start to finish
Literature circles start to finishKatie McKnight
 
Critical thinking and homework
Critical thinking and homeworkCritical thinking and homework
Critical thinking and homeworkKatie McKnight
 
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost AchievementGCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement Katie McKnight
 
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightTeaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightKatie McKnight
 
Homework that Makes Students Think
Homework that Makes Students ThinkHomework that Makes Students Think
Homework that Makes Students ThinkKatie McKnight
 
Using Homework to Promote Critical Thinking
Using Homework to Promote Critical ThinkingUsing Homework to Promote Critical Thinking
Using Homework to Promote Critical ThinkingKatie McKnight
 
Trouble with Textbooks
Trouble with TextbooksTrouble with Textbooks
Trouble with TextbooksKatie McKnight
 
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightTeaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightKatie McKnight
 

Más de Katie McKnight (20)

Verona 1.reading in the content areas
Verona 1.reading in the content areasVerona 1.reading in the content areas
Verona 1.reading in the content areas
 
K2 a tech workshopfinal
K2 a tech workshopfinalK2 a tech workshopfinal
K2 a tech workshopfinal
 
Ccss.elizabethton
Ccss.elizabethtonCcss.elizabethton
Ccss.elizabethton
 
Writing With Your Feet
Writing With Your FeetWriting With Your Feet
Writing With Your Feet
 
Content Area Centers
Content Area CentersContent Area Centers
Content Area Centers
 
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated Instruction
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated InstructionCommon Core State Standards and Differentiated Instruction
Common Core State Standards and Differentiated Instruction
 
Di and Technology January 12, 2012
Di and Technology January 12, 2012Di and Technology January 12, 2012
Di and Technology January 12, 2012
 
Di and Tech jan 12, Orlando, FL
Di and Tech  jan 12, Orlando, FLDi and Tech  jan 12, Orlando, FL
Di and Tech jan 12, Orlando, FL
 
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11
Ccss.ga.present.final jan 11
 
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant Readers
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant ReadersReaching and Teaching Reluctant Readers
Reaching and Teaching Reluctant Readers
 
Literature circles start to finish
Literature circles start to finishLiterature circles start to finish
Literature circles start to finish
 
Critical thinking and homework
Critical thinking and homeworkCritical thinking and homework
Critical thinking and homework
 
Content lit strat
Content lit stratContent lit strat
Content lit strat
 
Content area centers
Content area centersContent area centers
Content area centers
 
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost AchievementGCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement
GCE: Strategies to Enhance Student Engagement and Boost Achievement
 
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightTeaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
 
Homework that Makes Students Think
Homework that Makes Students ThinkHomework that Makes Students Think
Homework that Makes Students Think
 
Using Homework to Promote Critical Thinking
Using Homework to Promote Critical ThinkingUsing Homework to Promote Critical Thinking
Using Homework to Promote Critical Thinking
 
Trouble with Textbooks
Trouble with TextbooksTrouble with Textbooks
Trouble with Textbooks
 
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknightTeaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
Teaching the Classics in the Inclusive Classroom.mcknight
 

B 2 trouble with textbooks

  • 2. The Textbook Challenge  Often Superficial  Exceedingly Hard to Read  Badly Designed  Authoritarian  Inaccurate  Not Written for Students
  • 3. Six Ways to Use Textbooks More Effectively 1. Empathy- Do you remember when you had difficulty in a subject and the text was difficult? 2. Help the students to get started. We need to “front-load” our teaching. 3. Don’t leave kids alone with their textbooks. 4. Choose wisely. Be more selective with assignments. Be strategic about what is most important. 5. Supplement richly.
  • 4. Textbook Feature Analysis  Think about the textbooks that your students encounter. What kinds of features would they find in these texts?  How do textbooks affect our students’ study habits and success?
  • 5. Now What?  Consider the role of your textbook in teaching your subject matter.  How can you promote critical thinking with textbooks?
  • 6. Strategies for Textbooks: A Sample  Sticky Notes  Bookmarks  ReQuest  Supplement Richly  Audio Assist  Making Smaller Book Versions
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10. Daniels, H. and Zimmerman, S. (2004). Subjects Matter: Every Teachers’ Guide to Content –Area Reading. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann, p 121. Sketch Through Text
  • 12. Textbook Circles  Modeled after Literature Circles  Students work in teams of 4-5 members.  Going BEYOND the textbook  Using a wide variety of reading material  Students choose what they will read.
  • 13. Getting Started  Assign groups for some reading experiences.  When the students are reading a longer work, groups are formed by choice.
  • 14. Going Beyond the Textbook  Other than textbooks, how do we get information?  Look at the adult world and what do we read and use to get the information that we need?
  • 15. Going Beyond the Textbook  Other than textbooks, how do we get information?  Look at the adult world and what do we read and use to get the information that we need?  Reference Books  News Stories (Print and Digital Media)  Historical Accounts  Memoirs  Narrated nonfiction
  • 16. Using a Wide Variety of Reading Material  Fiction vs Non Fiction  Levels of text difficulty  Different levels of length  Primary and Secondary Sources  Multiple Texts and Single Sources
  • 17. Classroom Libraries  Articles  Magazines  Website Lists  A wide variety of trade books
  • 18. Books for Content Reading  See American Library Association  http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/yalsa/yals a.cfm  The Official Site of the Assembly on Literature for Adolescents  http://www.alan-ya.org/
  • 19. Resources I Like  Subjects Matter: Every Teacher's Guide to Content-Area Reading, Harvey Daniels and Steven Zemelman  Differentiating Textbooks: Strategies to Improve Student Comprehension and Motivation, James Grant  The Teacher’s Big Book of Graphic Organizers, Katherine McKnight
  • 20. How to Reach Me  Email: katie@katherinemcknight.com  Website: katherinemcknight.com  Twitter: @literacyworld  Facebook: Katie Siewert McKnight Literacy