SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 33
INSPIRED CARING:
A Culture of Innovating For Health and Value
            A COMMUNITY HEALTH SYSTEM’S 10 YEAR JOURNEY

                                    Mark Herzog, FACHE
                                       President & CEO

                                          Laura Fielding,
                                 Administrative Director
                             Organizational Development
HFM…Today
HFM’s Silos…2001
EVOLUTION OF OUR ORGANIZATION

               • Systems &
                 Processes          • Culture &        • Reform Readiness
• Strategy &                          Achievement
  Structure    • Quality/                              • Organizational
                 Outcomes/ Safety   • Open               Repositioning
• Business                            Innovation, Fl
  Plans &      • Innovation           exibility        • Proactive
  Facilities     Incubation                              Transformation
                                    • Adaptation
               • Performance
                 Improvement/VIP


    2001             2004                 2008             TODAY
First-Curve to Second-Curve Markets
   HOW WILL HOSPITALS SUCCESSFULLY NAVIGATE THE SHIFT FROM
   FIRST-CURVE TO SECOND-CURVE ECONOMICS?


                                                       VALUE Based
                                               • Payment Rewards Population
                                     THE GAP     Value: Quality & Efficiency
      VOLUME Based
                                               • Quality Impacts Reimbursement
• Fee-for-Service Reimbursement
                                               • Partnerships with Shared Risk
• High Quality Not Rewarded
                                               • Increased Patient Severity
• No Shared Financial Risk
                                               • IT Utilization Essential for
• Acute Inpatient hospital focus                 Population Health Management
• IT Investment Incentives Not                 • Scale Increases in Importance
  Seen by Hospital
                                               • Realigned Incentives,
• Stand-Alone Care Systems Can                   Encouraged Coordination
  Thrive
• Regulatory Actions Impede                      AHA “Hospitals & Care Systems
  Hospital-Physician Collaboration                  of the Future” Fall 2011
                                                                              4
Core Beliefs
    DRIVING HFM’S CARE SYSTEM DESIGN



RIGHT CARE - The most effective evidence based approach possible.

RIGHT SETTING - The most cost effective, safest, highest quality
and greatest value.

RIGHT OUTCOME - Achieve the greatest long term benefit to the
patient and society while minimizing physical and financial risk .

“Moving care to the right” is what makes HFM’s
process, outcomes and value unique.

                                                                5
THE PRICE IS RIGHT QUIZ!
 How much might you pay, on average, for each of
 the following (match the service with the
 estimated price):

 A hospital stay?                 $200
 A doctors office visit?          $2,000
 An outpatient procedure?         $20,000

Which of these is a cornerstone      Doctor’s
of Population Health?               Office Visit
                                                   6
HFM Inpatient & Outpatient Volume Trends
           RELATED TO CHARGES


                                                 25% Reduction in Inpatient &
                                                  Outpatient Market Volume

          5K
   INPATIENT
    VOLUME                                                                      $65M



    Total Charges                               18% Decrease                    $55M
            4K
  (less price increases)
                                                 Since 2001      8% Increase
                                                                  Since 2001
                                                                                $45M

           3K
  OUTPATIENT
   VOLUME                                                43% Decrease           $35M
                                                          Since 2001

                           2001   2003   2005   2007     2009        2011
                                                                            7
10/11/12
Inpatient Market Share
 FOR THE TOTAL SERVICE AREA   (HFM Transformation had minimal market impact)



                                       22% REDUCTION IN INPATIENT
                                       MARKET VOLUME SINCE 2002
     60%

  HFM                                                    4.8% Market Share
                                                        Decrease Since 2002
    40%


Aurora TR
                                                      0.1% Market Share
    20%                                              Decrease Since 2002
                                                            2.9% Market Share
                                                           Increase Since 2002
Aurora
    0%
BayCare
            2001    2003       2005         2007         2009          2011
                                                                               8
HFM Care System Design


HOSPITAL   PHYSICIANS    SENIOR     MISSION      RECOGNITION
            & NP/PA     LEADERS      FOCUS

90 bed        90        10 Senior    Focus on     Nationally
hospital   Employed      Leaders     Wellness     recognized
           Providers                    &          for Safety,
                                    Prevention    Innovation
                                                  & Thought
                                                  Leadership
                        5 Senior     Focus on
35 bed        35        Leaders      the Sick
hospital   Employed                 Population     Locally
           Physicians                            Recognized


                                                            9
Leading in new ways

▪ Conscious effort to flatten the organization

      57
                               49
                                                     44


             10
                                        6                     5


        2001                     2006                  2012
                  LEADERSHIP          SENIOR LEADERS
    •Overall Reduced:
        -Network leadership by 27%
        -Senior leadership by 50%
    •Annual savings of $3.1 million from reduction
    •Role of outside eyes
HFM’s Margin While Transforming to a
    Second Curve Delivery Model

                                                                          6.0%


          5K
   INPATIENT
    VOLUME                                                                4.0%

 Gain From Operations (%)


                                                                          2.0%
           4K
                                                           8% Increase
                                                            Since 2001
                                                                          0.0%

           3K
  OUTPATIENT
   VOLUME                                           43% Decrease          -2.0%
                                                     Since 2001

                        2001   2003   2005   2007   2009      2011
                                                                     11
Source: WHA
Days Cash on Hand

$220
                                                 HFM
$200

$180

$160

$140

$120

$100
                                                 Aurora
 $80

 $60
       2001   2003   2005   2007   2009   2011

                                                       12
While Competitors Talk This Game,
  only HFM Walks the Talk Locally!

“Cost-Per-Episode vs. Unit Price
Too many health care purchasers focus on unit price, seeking to
save money with the lowest cost provider for X-rays, office visits
or surgical procedures. These initial “savings” are deceiving
because they don’t take into account the most significant piece
of the health care cost equation – how health care services are
utilized. Low unit-price providers can actually increase employer
costs if they order unnecessary tests or provide inefficient care
that delays healing or causes a relapse.”

        As stated on a competitor’s website.
                                                             13
Inpatient vs. Outpatient Volume Trends
           AURORA –TR & BAYCARE FOR TOTAL SERVICE AREA

                                                        70% Increase
                                                         Since 2001                $70M
             6K
                                                                                   $60M
                                                   87% Increase
             5K                                     Since 2001
                                                                                   $50M


                                                                                   $40M
             4K
    Total Charges
  (less price increases)
                                                             1% Decrease           $30M

         3K
  OUTPATIENT
                                                              Since 2001
    Volume

   INPATIENT
          2K
     Volume

                           2001   2003   2005   2007     2009          2011
                                                                              14
10/11/12
Regional Hospital Market Comparison
    HFM’s leadership has kept the lid on the cost of high utilization



                                          39% Market Volume                            80K
                                          Increase Since 2001

                                                                                       60K
  Brown
  County

                                                            30% Market Volume          40K
                                                            Increase Since 2001
Outagamie
 County                                            8% Market Volume
                                                  Increase Since 2001
                                                                                       20K

Local Service
    Area

                  2001       2003       2005       2007         2009      2011
                                                                                  15
Total Hospital Gross Charges 2001-2011
       For the Total Service Area, Brown, and Outagamie Counties


                                                                               $900M

                                             217% Increase
                                               Since 2001
                                                                               $700M

                                                               148% Increase
                                                                 Since 2001    $500M



                                                                               $300M
      Brown
   Outagamie                                                   110% Increase
                                                                 Since 2001
 Total Service Area                                                            $100M

                        2001   2003   2005     2007          2009     2011
12/19/12 Source - WHA
Total Hospital Gross Charges 2001-2011
      For HFM and Aurora TR + BayCare in the Total Service Area


                                                                                $110M

                               89% Increase
                                Since 2001
                                                                                $90M


                                                          Excludes Open Heart
                                                                                $70M
                                        173% Increase
   Holy Family
    Memorial                              Since 2001
                                                                                $50M


   Aurora TR &
    BayCare
                                                                                $30M

                        2001   2003     2005       2007       2009       2011
12/19/12 Source - WHA
If HFM Were the Only Choice
 UNCOVERING COST SAVINGS FOR MANITOWOC COMMUNITY


Amount our Community
 Spent on Hospital Care              $283 Million
      If Manitowoc used
              HFM ONLY              - $255 Million
  Reduced Cost for our
          Community              $28 MILLION!
 That’s the power of “moving care to the right”!!

   Assuming all hospital services were provided to
Total Service Area residents by HFM from 2001 - 2011
HFM’s CMS Value Based Purchasing

 ▪ Total Performance Score: 57
 ▪ Estimated Net Revenue Change: 0.1%
 ▪ Percentile Rank: 61
                                     50%

                             25%           75%




                    0%                           100%

Source: The Advisory Board Company
HFM’s CMS Readmission
      Performance
 ▪ Estimated Penalty Percentage: 0%
 ▪ Estimated Net Revenue Change: $0

                                     50%
                                                        Hospitals subject to 1%
                                                        Penalty Cap
          25%                              75%
                                                        Hospitals subject to
                                                        Penalty between 0%
                                                        and 1%

                                                        Hospitals Not Subject
  0%                                             100%   to Any Penalty

Source: The Advisory Board Company
UW Population Health Model

     RANKINGS BASED ON THE FOLLOWING:

                  Policies &                                    Health                                Health
                  Programs                                      Factors                              Outcomes
                  FOUR TYPES OF HEALTH FACTORS MEASURED:
                                                             Health Behaviors
                                                                  (30%)
                                                                                                    1. Access to Care
                                                            Clinical Care (20%)
                                                                                                    2. Quality of Care
                                                            Social & Economic
                                                              Factors (40%)
                                                                 Physical
                                                            Environment (10%)
Source: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute County Health Rankings model 2012   21
Manitowoc County Clinical Care Rank
         POPULATION HEALTH



               Health Behaviors
                    (30%)
                                                          Manitowoc’s Clinical Care
                                                          Rank out of 72 WI Counties:
     Clinical Care (20%)
                                                          ▪ 2010: 31

       Social & Economic Factors
                                                          ▪ 2011: 23                             Improvement
                 (40%)
                                                          ▪ 2012: 18                              Since 2009!
           Physical Environment
                       (10%)


Source: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute        22
At 21st & Franklin Street, Sept. 2012




                                        23
Where bars trump grocery stores




                                          More Bars
                Source: flowingdata.com
                                          More Grocery Stores   24
Measuring “Quality” in Healthcare

                          One thing is clear:
     Today there is no universal defining methodology or vendor
          that purchasers, providers and patients agree on!
    Data quality & reporting vary greatly. Oversimplifying is risky.



1. Purchasers, providers or patients who make a major decision on
   solely one data source are not making a fully informed decision.

2. Two types of quality measurement firms:
     I. Independent & objective, or
     II. Aligned with purchasers as a negotiating tool

                                                                       25
HIGH DEDUCTIBLE = CONSUMER DRIVEN

• Employers offer High Deductible Health Plans:
    •   Nationally 17% of employers offer HDHP; Deductibles range $3000 -
        $4000 (Futurescan 2012)
    •   Locally 60+% of large local employers & nearly all small employers
        offer HDHP, Deductibles range $5,000 - $10,000
• Insured population beset by the triple whammy of high
  deductibles, stagnant wages, and fear of job loss
    •   Result is, they prefer “not to know”
• How will insurance exchanges fill the role of care coach for policy-
  shopping consumers? Will they value provider continuity?
• Wellness/Prevention benefits dependent on employer HR leaders
High Deductible= Consumer Driven

 Employers offer High Deductible Health Plans:
    • Nationally 17% of employers offer HDHP; Deductible range $3000 - $4000
       (Futurescan 2012)
    • Locally 60+% of large local employers & nearly all small employers offer
      HDHP; Many deductibles now range $5,000 - $10,000

 Insured population beset by the triple whammy of high
  deductibles, stagnant wages and fear of job loss.
    • Result; they prefer “not to know”.

 How will insurance exchanges fill the role of care coach for policy-
  shopping consumers? Will they value provider continuity?

 Wellness/Prevention benefits dependent on employer HR leaders.
An HDHP Word of Caution

▪ HDHP are generally effective if properly designed and
  reflect an employee’s ability to fund the deductible, and
  they are educated about and compliant with wellness &
  preventive benefits.

▪ Considerable evidence exists that HDHP, combined with a
  soft economy, frequently mean important care &
  prevention forgone (mammo)

▪ Sign of the future: HFM’s Community Care program wrote
  off nearly $450,000 to insured patients, almost all with
  HDHP. (applied to bills to be written off because of
  economic hardship)
                                                              28
HFM Employee Right Care Results

                                                      74.6
                            74.5

               73.6
                                          72.6
  72.2




Avg Age 46   Avg Age 47   Avg Age 47   Avg Age 48   Avg Age 48
85% Female   84% Female   84% Female   85% Female   85% Female

  2008         2009         2010          2011        2012       29
HFM Employee Right Care Results


7%                                             Average of 1,500
                                                   participants
6%
5%
4%
3%
2%
                 No         No         No           No
1%            premium    premium    premium      premium
              increase   increase   increase     increase
0%
       2008    2009       2010       2011          2012
                                                                  30
HFM Employee Right Care Results

                                  Inpatient stays by individuals
                                  covered under HFM’s health plan
  Inpatient stays in 2002 124
 Inpatients stays in 2012 - 91
                            33 Fewer Inpatient Stays

Average Hospital
     Stay=$20k
Recent Recognition

   ▪ REGIONAL RECOGNITION
    ▪ 2010 New North Excellence in the Workplace
    ▪ 2009 Manitowoc Chamber Business of the Year
   ▪ TOP 2% NATIONALLY
    ▪ Solucient 100 Top Performance Improvement Leaders
    ▪ Top 25 Most Wired – Small & Rural Hospitals
    ▪ Healthcare Information & Management Systems –
      Society Stage 6
    ▪ 4x Recipient of HealthGrades Excellence in Patient
      Safety


                                                    32
THANK YOU!
QUESTIONS

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondos
Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondosClase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondos
Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondosCarlos Echeverria Muñoz
 
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven Driggers
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven DriggersMCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven Driggers
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven DriggersMark Herzog
 
App cerâmica uma história contada cota confirmada
App cerâmica uma história contada  cota confirmadaApp cerâmica uma história contada  cota confirmada
App cerâmica uma história contada cota confirmadaMarta Xavier
 
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA Webinar
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA WebinarHFM's Reform Readiness AHA Webinar
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA WebinarMark Herzog
 
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb Carlos Echeverria Muñoz
 

Destacado (9)

paying attention
paying attentionpaying attention
paying attention
 
Dyslexia test
Dyslexia testDyslexia test
Dyslexia test
 
Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondos
Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondosClase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondos
Clase 2 adm financiera del estado y administración de fondos
 
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven Driggers
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven DriggersMCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven Driggers
MCD Healthcare Leader Predictions featuring Mark Herzog and Dr. Steven Driggers
 
App cerâmica uma história contada cota confirmada
App cerâmica uma história contada  cota confirmadaApp cerâmica uma história contada  cota confirmada
App cerâmica uma história contada cota confirmada
 
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA Webinar
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA WebinarHFM's Reform Readiness AHA Webinar
HFM's Reform Readiness AHA Webinar
 
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb
Clase 2 modelos de gestion control gestion y planificacion estrategica junaeb
 
Clase 6 construccion de presupuesto
Clase 6 construccion de presupuestoClase 6 construccion de presupuesto
Clase 6 construccion de presupuesto
 
Top10 Emerging Technologies 2016 Report
Top10 Emerging Technologies 2016 ReportTop10 Emerging Technologies 2016 Report
Top10 Emerging Technologies 2016 Report
 

Similar a Inspired Caring: A Culture of Innovating for Health and Value

Mckubs 120208 web
Mckubs 120208 webMckubs 120208 web
Mckubs 120208 webshivasun
 
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework nhs tayside & scottish government
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework   nhs tayside & scottish government4.3 productivity & efficiency framework   nhs tayside & scottish government
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework nhs tayside & scottish governmentPublicSectorConference
 
Oracle - 9iun2011
Oracle - 9iun2011Oracle - 9iun2011
Oracle - 9iun2011Agora Group
 
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management AccretiveHealth
 
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition?
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition? How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition?
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition? valéry ridde
 
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOs
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOsA Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOs
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOsSheri Litchford
 
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery System
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery SystemBuilding Health 2.0 Into the Delivery System
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery Systemscottshreeve
 
owens & minor OMI2005AR
owens & minor  OMI2005ARowens & minor  OMI2005AR
owens & minor OMI2005ARfinance33
 
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_healthchina
 
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health care
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health careMaureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health care
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health careThe King's Fund
 
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...Niels Pflaeging
 
Key Point Sampler 2011
Key Point Sampler 2011Key Point Sampler 2011
Key Point Sampler 2011dsandlerny
 
Key Banc Conference Final[1]
Key Banc Conference Final[1]Key Banc Conference Final[1]
Key Banc Conference Final[1]BSTRINGE
 
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...Tony Freeman
 
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009Koen Klokgieters
 
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year Results
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year ResultsWolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year Results
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year ResultsWolters Kluwer
 
Future of Market Access – a Pharma Perspective
Future of Market Access – a Pharma PerspectiveFuture of Market Access – a Pharma Perspective
Future of Market Access – a Pharma PerspectivePM Society
 
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhys
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhysEntreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhys
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhysSven Awege
 

Similar a Inspired Caring: A Culture of Innovating for Health and Value (20)

Mckubs 120208 web
Mckubs 120208 webMckubs 120208 web
Mckubs 120208 web
 
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework nhs tayside & scottish government
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework   nhs tayside & scottish government4.3 productivity & efficiency framework   nhs tayside & scottish government
4.3 productivity & efficiency framework nhs tayside & scottish government
 
Oracle - 9iun2011
Oracle - 9iun2011Oracle - 9iun2011
Oracle - 9iun2011
 
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management
Accretive Health - Revenue Cycle - Revenue Cycle Management
 
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition?
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition? How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition?
How do policy makers decide on user fee abolition?
 
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOs
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOsA Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOs
A Look Under the Hood: 5 Critical Questions You Should be Asking about ACOs
 
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery System
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery SystemBuilding Health 2.0 Into the Delivery System
Building Health 2.0 Into the Delivery System
 
owens & minor OMI2005AR
owens & minor  OMI2005ARowens & minor  OMI2005AR
owens & minor OMI2005AR
 
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_
China health presentation_dec_2011_v2__compatibility_mode_
 
GRUPO GEDEON
GRUPO GEDEONGRUPO GEDEON
GRUPO GEDEON
 
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health care
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health careMaureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health care
Maureen Bisognano: An international perspective: Leading for better health care
 
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...
Beyond Budgeting - Creating High-Performance Organizations for Today’s Market...
 
Key Point Sampler 2011
Key Point Sampler 2011Key Point Sampler 2011
Key Point Sampler 2011
 
Key Banc Conference Final[1]
Key Banc Conference Final[1]Key Banc Conference Final[1]
Key Banc Conference Final[1]
 
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...
Trends in Global Medical Device OEM Strategies and Issues for the Medical Dev...
 
How Much can eHealth Affect the Economic Growth
How Much can eHealth Affect the Economic GrowthHow Much can eHealth Affect the Economic Growth
How Much can eHealth Affect the Economic Growth
 
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009
E Healthcare Business Model Innovation Research 2009
 
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year Results
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year ResultsWolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year Results
Wolters Kluwer 2011 Half-Year Results
 
Future of Market Access – a Pharma Perspective
Future of Market Access – a Pharma PerspectiveFuture of Market Access – a Pharma Perspective
Future of Market Access – a Pharma Perspective
 
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhys
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhysEntreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhys
Entreprise numerique panorama 2013 cedhys
 

Inspired Caring: A Culture of Innovating for Health and Value

  • 1. INSPIRED CARING: A Culture of Innovating For Health and Value A COMMUNITY HEALTH SYSTEM’S 10 YEAR JOURNEY Mark Herzog, FACHE President & CEO Laura Fielding, Administrative Director Organizational Development
  • 3. EVOLUTION OF OUR ORGANIZATION • Systems & Processes • Culture & • Reform Readiness • Strategy & Achievement Structure • Quality/ • Organizational Outcomes/ Safety • Open Repositioning • Business Innovation, Fl Plans & • Innovation exibility • Proactive Facilities Incubation Transformation • Adaptation • Performance Improvement/VIP 2001 2004 2008 TODAY
  • 4. First-Curve to Second-Curve Markets HOW WILL HOSPITALS SUCCESSFULLY NAVIGATE THE SHIFT FROM FIRST-CURVE TO SECOND-CURVE ECONOMICS? VALUE Based • Payment Rewards Population THE GAP Value: Quality & Efficiency VOLUME Based • Quality Impacts Reimbursement • Fee-for-Service Reimbursement • Partnerships with Shared Risk • High Quality Not Rewarded • Increased Patient Severity • No Shared Financial Risk • IT Utilization Essential for • Acute Inpatient hospital focus Population Health Management • IT Investment Incentives Not • Scale Increases in Importance Seen by Hospital • Realigned Incentives, • Stand-Alone Care Systems Can Encouraged Coordination Thrive • Regulatory Actions Impede AHA “Hospitals & Care Systems Hospital-Physician Collaboration of the Future” Fall 2011 4
  • 5. Core Beliefs DRIVING HFM’S CARE SYSTEM DESIGN RIGHT CARE - The most effective evidence based approach possible. RIGHT SETTING - The most cost effective, safest, highest quality and greatest value. RIGHT OUTCOME - Achieve the greatest long term benefit to the patient and society while minimizing physical and financial risk . “Moving care to the right” is what makes HFM’s process, outcomes and value unique. 5
  • 6. THE PRICE IS RIGHT QUIZ! How much might you pay, on average, for each of the following (match the service with the estimated price): A hospital stay? $200 A doctors office visit? $2,000 An outpatient procedure? $20,000 Which of these is a cornerstone Doctor’s of Population Health? Office Visit 6
  • 7. HFM Inpatient & Outpatient Volume Trends RELATED TO CHARGES 25% Reduction in Inpatient & Outpatient Market Volume 5K INPATIENT VOLUME $65M Total Charges 18% Decrease $55M 4K (less price increases) Since 2001 8% Increase Since 2001 $45M 3K OUTPATIENT VOLUME 43% Decrease $35M Since 2001 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 7 10/11/12
  • 8. Inpatient Market Share FOR THE TOTAL SERVICE AREA (HFM Transformation had minimal market impact) 22% REDUCTION IN INPATIENT MARKET VOLUME SINCE 2002 60% HFM 4.8% Market Share Decrease Since 2002 40% Aurora TR 0.1% Market Share 20% Decrease Since 2002 2.9% Market Share Increase Since 2002 Aurora 0% BayCare 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 8
  • 9. HFM Care System Design HOSPITAL PHYSICIANS SENIOR MISSION RECOGNITION & NP/PA LEADERS FOCUS 90 bed 90 10 Senior Focus on Nationally hospital Employed Leaders Wellness recognized Providers & for Safety, Prevention Innovation & Thought Leadership 5 Senior Focus on 35 bed 35 Leaders the Sick hospital Employed Population Locally Physicians Recognized 9
  • 10. Leading in new ways ▪ Conscious effort to flatten the organization 57 49 44 10 6 5 2001 2006 2012 LEADERSHIP SENIOR LEADERS •Overall Reduced: -Network leadership by 27% -Senior leadership by 50% •Annual savings of $3.1 million from reduction •Role of outside eyes
  • 11. HFM’s Margin While Transforming to a Second Curve Delivery Model 6.0% 5K INPATIENT VOLUME 4.0% Gain From Operations (%) 2.0% 4K 8% Increase Since 2001 0.0% 3K OUTPATIENT VOLUME 43% Decrease -2.0% Since 2001 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 11 Source: WHA
  • 12. Days Cash on Hand $220 HFM $200 $180 $160 $140 $120 $100 Aurora $80 $60 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 12
  • 13. While Competitors Talk This Game, only HFM Walks the Talk Locally! “Cost-Per-Episode vs. Unit Price Too many health care purchasers focus on unit price, seeking to save money with the lowest cost provider for X-rays, office visits or surgical procedures. These initial “savings” are deceiving because they don’t take into account the most significant piece of the health care cost equation – how health care services are utilized. Low unit-price providers can actually increase employer costs if they order unnecessary tests or provide inefficient care that delays healing or causes a relapse.” As stated on a competitor’s website. 13
  • 14. Inpatient vs. Outpatient Volume Trends AURORA –TR & BAYCARE FOR TOTAL SERVICE AREA 70% Increase Since 2001 $70M 6K $60M 87% Increase 5K Since 2001 $50M $40M 4K Total Charges (less price increases) 1% Decrease $30M 3K OUTPATIENT Since 2001 Volume INPATIENT 2K Volume 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 14 10/11/12
  • 15. Regional Hospital Market Comparison HFM’s leadership has kept the lid on the cost of high utilization 39% Market Volume 80K Increase Since 2001 60K Brown County 30% Market Volume 40K Increase Since 2001 Outagamie County 8% Market Volume Increase Since 2001 20K Local Service Area 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 15
  • 16. Total Hospital Gross Charges 2001-2011 For the Total Service Area, Brown, and Outagamie Counties $900M 217% Increase Since 2001 $700M 148% Increase Since 2001 $500M $300M Brown Outagamie 110% Increase Since 2001 Total Service Area $100M 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 12/19/12 Source - WHA
  • 17. Total Hospital Gross Charges 2001-2011 For HFM and Aurora TR + BayCare in the Total Service Area $110M 89% Increase Since 2001 $90M Excludes Open Heart $70M 173% Increase Holy Family Memorial Since 2001 $50M Aurora TR & BayCare $30M 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 12/19/12 Source - WHA
  • 18. If HFM Were the Only Choice UNCOVERING COST SAVINGS FOR MANITOWOC COMMUNITY Amount our Community Spent on Hospital Care $283 Million If Manitowoc used HFM ONLY - $255 Million Reduced Cost for our Community $28 MILLION! That’s the power of “moving care to the right”!! Assuming all hospital services were provided to Total Service Area residents by HFM from 2001 - 2011
  • 19. HFM’s CMS Value Based Purchasing ▪ Total Performance Score: 57 ▪ Estimated Net Revenue Change: 0.1% ▪ Percentile Rank: 61 50% 25% 75% 0% 100% Source: The Advisory Board Company
  • 20. HFM’s CMS Readmission Performance ▪ Estimated Penalty Percentage: 0% ▪ Estimated Net Revenue Change: $0 50% Hospitals subject to 1% Penalty Cap 25% 75% Hospitals subject to Penalty between 0% and 1% Hospitals Not Subject 0% 100% to Any Penalty Source: The Advisory Board Company
  • 21. UW Population Health Model RANKINGS BASED ON THE FOLLOWING: Policies & Health Health Programs Factors Outcomes FOUR TYPES OF HEALTH FACTORS MEASURED: Health Behaviors (30%) 1. Access to Care Clinical Care (20%) 2. Quality of Care Social & Economic Factors (40%) Physical Environment (10%) Source: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute County Health Rankings model 2012 21
  • 22. Manitowoc County Clinical Care Rank POPULATION HEALTH Health Behaviors (30%) Manitowoc’s Clinical Care Rank out of 72 WI Counties: Clinical Care (20%) ▪ 2010: 31 Social & Economic Factors ▪ 2011: 23 Improvement (40%) ▪ 2012: 18 Since 2009! Physical Environment (10%) Source: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and the University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute 22
  • 23. At 21st & Franklin Street, Sept. 2012 23
  • 24. Where bars trump grocery stores More Bars Source: flowingdata.com More Grocery Stores 24
  • 25. Measuring “Quality” in Healthcare One thing is clear: Today there is no universal defining methodology or vendor that purchasers, providers and patients agree on! Data quality & reporting vary greatly. Oversimplifying is risky. 1. Purchasers, providers or patients who make a major decision on solely one data source are not making a fully informed decision. 2. Two types of quality measurement firms: I. Independent & objective, or II. Aligned with purchasers as a negotiating tool 25
  • 26. HIGH DEDUCTIBLE = CONSUMER DRIVEN • Employers offer High Deductible Health Plans: • Nationally 17% of employers offer HDHP; Deductibles range $3000 - $4000 (Futurescan 2012) • Locally 60+% of large local employers & nearly all small employers offer HDHP, Deductibles range $5,000 - $10,000 • Insured population beset by the triple whammy of high deductibles, stagnant wages, and fear of job loss • Result is, they prefer “not to know” • How will insurance exchanges fill the role of care coach for policy- shopping consumers? Will they value provider continuity? • Wellness/Prevention benefits dependent on employer HR leaders
  • 27. High Deductible= Consumer Driven  Employers offer High Deductible Health Plans: • Nationally 17% of employers offer HDHP; Deductible range $3000 - $4000 (Futurescan 2012) • Locally 60+% of large local employers & nearly all small employers offer HDHP; Many deductibles now range $5,000 - $10,000  Insured population beset by the triple whammy of high deductibles, stagnant wages and fear of job loss. • Result; they prefer “not to know”.  How will insurance exchanges fill the role of care coach for policy- shopping consumers? Will they value provider continuity?  Wellness/Prevention benefits dependent on employer HR leaders.
  • 28. An HDHP Word of Caution ▪ HDHP are generally effective if properly designed and reflect an employee’s ability to fund the deductible, and they are educated about and compliant with wellness & preventive benefits. ▪ Considerable evidence exists that HDHP, combined with a soft economy, frequently mean important care & prevention forgone (mammo) ▪ Sign of the future: HFM’s Community Care program wrote off nearly $450,000 to insured patients, almost all with HDHP. (applied to bills to be written off because of economic hardship) 28
  • 29. HFM Employee Right Care Results 74.6 74.5 73.6 72.6 72.2 Avg Age 46 Avg Age 47 Avg Age 47 Avg Age 48 Avg Age 48 85% Female 84% Female 84% Female 85% Female 85% Female 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 29
  • 30. HFM Employee Right Care Results 7% Average of 1,500 participants 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% No No No No 1% premium premium premium premium increase increase increase increase 0% 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 30
  • 31. HFM Employee Right Care Results Inpatient stays by individuals covered under HFM’s health plan Inpatient stays in 2002 124 Inpatients stays in 2012 - 91 33 Fewer Inpatient Stays Average Hospital Stay=$20k
  • 32. Recent Recognition ▪ REGIONAL RECOGNITION ▪ 2010 New North Excellence in the Workplace ▪ 2009 Manitowoc Chamber Business of the Year ▪ TOP 2% NATIONALLY ▪ Solucient 100 Top Performance Improvement Leaders ▪ Top 25 Most Wired – Small & Rural Hospitals ▪ Healthcare Information & Management Systems – Society Stage 6 ▪ 4x Recipient of HealthGrades Excellence in Patient Safety 32

Notas del editor

  1. HPOE is the AHA strategy for accelerating performance improvement.HPOE started by initially focusing on 4 topics: (preventing infections, harm, medication safety and patient flow).In the last few months HPOE added 2 more topics: care coordination and implementing HIT.The next topic for HPOE is improving efficiency.
  2. Purpose: Show some of the more tangible ways HFM has changed as a response
  3. Data on this graph represents both Inpatient and Outpatient in the: HFM Total Service Area (includes all hospitals/clinics in our Service AreaOutagamie County (All Clinics and Hospitals in that county)Brown County (all Clinics and Hospitals in that county)
  4. Add percentages
  5. Visual connecting slides
  6. May be able to add Mammography info
  7. May be able to add Mammography info