SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 3
TERRITORY SCOPE / RESPONSIBILITY
1,300 UNITS
3
Mechanics
4
Mechanics
5 Standby’s
UMASS
Amherst
2 Standby’s
NOTE: Standby Mechanics not available for regular callbacks due to contract requirements
Revenue Margin Vs. Overhead Cost
1990 2002 2014
Revenue
Margin
Overhead
Costs
UNSUSTAINABLE!
CONTRIBUTING FACTORS
• Directed to push revenue margin as #1 priority
• Preventative Maintenance lowest priority
• Upselling and “selling your way out of repair obligations” top priority
• Reduced allotment of labor hours per unit (reduced number of available mechanics), reduced
material spending budget for repairs
• Account managers signing on new contracts that are immediately unprofitable (underpriced)
• Larger than average mix of old and obsolete units increase complexity of repairs
• Mechanic Talent pool issues; reliant on talent provided from local union hall, cannot hire from
outside or violate “seniority” rules when hiring
• No Adjustor level mechanics directly available for troubleshooting most complex repair issues.
Reliant on “borrowing” from other supervisors when available.
• Steady increase in number of units per maintenance route (continuous increase in Unit-to-
Mechanic ratio)
• Geographical challenge – reduced density of units and poor unit-to-mechanic ratio over large
territory directly affects response time to repair callbacks. Significant risk when dealing with
elevator entrapments or large/high priority customers that demand quick response time.
Bottom Line:
low prioritization of preventative maintenance >>>>> increase in callbacks >>>>> less time
available for preventative maintenance >>>>>> vicious cycle >>>>>> unhappy customers >>>>>>
cancelation of contracts

Más contenido relacionado

Más de www.SMARTvt.org

Más de www.SMARTvt.org (20)

Bending the curve - Saving $20M for State of Vermont
Bending the curve - Saving $20M for State of VermontBending the curve - Saving $20M for State of Vermont
Bending the curve - Saving $20M for State of Vermont
 
Rich ii
Rich iiRich ii
Rich ii
 
SMART Holdings USA - SMARTvt Magazine Spring 2017
SMART Holdings USA - SMARTvt Magazine Spring 2017SMART Holdings USA - SMARTvt Magazine Spring 2017
SMART Holdings USA - SMARTvt Magazine Spring 2017
 
Marble - Seeking Quarry Master
Marble - Seeking Quarry MasterMarble - Seeking Quarry Master
Marble - Seeking Quarry Master
 
Carver's cfo
Carver's cfo   Carver's cfo
Carver's cfo
 
James howard ceo
James howard ceoJames howard ceo
James howard ceo
 
Bio rev 1
Bio rev 1Bio rev 1
Bio rev 1
 
Donna walters professional highlights 0516
Donna walters professional highlights 0516Donna walters professional highlights 0516
Donna walters professional highlights 0516
 
Donna walters
Donna waltersDonna walters
Donna walters
 
EB 5 Blame Game Vermont
EB 5 Blame Game VermontEB 5 Blame Game Vermont
EB 5 Blame Game Vermont
 
Wow vermont gas most mistrusted vt employer
Wow vermont gas   most mistrusted vt employerWow vermont gas   most mistrusted vt employer
Wow vermont gas most mistrusted vt employer
 
Blame game pdf
Blame game pdfBlame game pdf
Blame game pdf
 
Fenter project plan
Fenter project planFenter project plan
Fenter project plan
 
The Red Bus - A Ken Martin Company
The Red Bus - A Ken Martin CompanyThe Red Bus - A Ken Martin Company
The Red Bus - A Ken Martin Company
 
What to expect first
What to expect firstWhat to expect first
What to expect first
 
What is smart+ memberships
What is smart+ membershipsWhat is smart+ memberships
What is smart+ memberships
 
Nda cuba
Nda cubaNda cuba
Nda cuba
 
Cuba smar tvt
Cuba smar tvtCuba smar tvt
Cuba smar tvt
 
Carver kipp pptx
Carver kipp pptxCarver kipp pptx
Carver kipp pptx
 
Trespass copy
Trespass copyTrespass copy
Trespass copy
 

Último

FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| DelhiDELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
delhimunirka444
 
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
Business Bay Call Girls || 0529877582 || Call Girls Service in Business Bay Dubai
 
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
Sheetaleventcompany
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Business Bay Call Girls || 0529877582 || Call Girls Service in Business Bay Dubai
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Paschim Vihar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In  Paschim Vihar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In  Paschim Vihar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Paschim Vihar | Delhi
SaketCallGirlsCallUs
 
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Business Bay Call Girls || 0529877582 || Call Girls Service in Business Bay Dubai
 
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
mvxpw22gfc
 

Último (20)

(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Dehradun Call Now 8617697112 Dehradun Escorts 24x7
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Saket | Delhi
 
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
(NEHA) Call Girls Mumbai Call Now 8250077686 Mumbai Escorts 24x7
 
Sirmaur Call Girls Book Now 8617697112 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Service A...
Sirmaur Call Girls Book Now 8617697112 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Service A...Sirmaur Call Girls Book Now 8617697112 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Service A...
Sirmaur Call Girls Book Now 8617697112 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Service A...
 
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| DelhiDELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
DELHI NCR —@9711106444 Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla (MT)| Delhi
 
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls Service # +971588046679 # Call Girls Service In Dubai # (UAE)
 
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to SingStoryboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
Storyboard short: Ferrarius Tries to Sing
 
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
❤️Call girls in Chandigarh ☎️8264406502☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ C...
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Dwarka Mor | Delhi
 
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
UAE Call Girls # 971526940039 # Independent Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
 
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf             .
AaliyahBell_themist_v01.pdf .
 
Editorial sephora annual report design project
Editorial sephora annual report design projectEditorial sephora annual report design project
Editorial sephora annual report design project
 
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Paschim Vihar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In  Paschim Vihar | DelhiFULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In  Paschim Vihar | Delhi
FULL NIGHT — 9999894380 Call Girls In Paschim Vihar | Delhi
 
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
(INDIRA) Call Girl Jammu Call Now 8617697112 Jammu Escorts 24x7
 
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 98765-12871 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Completed Event Presentation for Huma 1305
Completed Event Presentation for Huma 1305Completed Event Presentation for Huma 1305
Completed Event Presentation for Huma 1305
 
Barasat call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Barasat call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingBarasat call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Barasat call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
 
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
Dubai Call Girls # 00971547881831 # Indian Call Girls In Dubai # (UAE)
 
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
VIP Ramnagar Call Girls, Ramnagar escorts Girls 📞 8617697112
 
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
Museum of fine arts Lauren Simpson…………..
 

Otis service managers dilema case study

  • 1. TERRITORY SCOPE / RESPONSIBILITY 1,300 UNITS 3 Mechanics 4 Mechanics 5 Standby’s UMASS Amherst 2 Standby’s NOTE: Standby Mechanics not available for regular callbacks due to contract requirements
  • 2. Revenue Margin Vs. Overhead Cost 1990 2002 2014 Revenue Margin Overhead Costs UNSUSTAINABLE!
  • 3. CONTRIBUTING FACTORS • Directed to push revenue margin as #1 priority • Preventative Maintenance lowest priority • Upselling and “selling your way out of repair obligations” top priority • Reduced allotment of labor hours per unit (reduced number of available mechanics), reduced material spending budget for repairs • Account managers signing on new contracts that are immediately unprofitable (underpriced) • Larger than average mix of old and obsolete units increase complexity of repairs • Mechanic Talent pool issues; reliant on talent provided from local union hall, cannot hire from outside or violate “seniority” rules when hiring • No Adjustor level mechanics directly available for troubleshooting most complex repair issues. Reliant on “borrowing” from other supervisors when available. • Steady increase in number of units per maintenance route (continuous increase in Unit-to- Mechanic ratio) • Geographical challenge – reduced density of units and poor unit-to-mechanic ratio over large territory directly affects response time to repair callbacks. Significant risk when dealing with elevator entrapments or large/high priority customers that demand quick response time. Bottom Line: low prioritization of preventative maintenance >>>>> increase in callbacks >>>>> less time available for preventative maintenance >>>>>> vicious cycle >>>>>> unhappy customers >>>>>> cancelation of contracts