SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 9
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Can market forces make
the NHS more efficient?
        David Pruce
      PruceConsulting

  Yes … but
Do we have a market in
       the NHS?
• Secondary & Tertiary Care
  – Not really

• Primary Care
  – Pharmacy and Optometry
     • Competition, mergers, acquisitions,
       market exit
  – General Practice
     • Limited by relative shortage of GPs
  – Dentistry
     • Very few dentists with NHS contract
Are market
forces positive
 or negative?
Market forces +ve
• Sharpens up organisations
  – Threat of business failure, reward
    of success
• Forces focus on to the customer
• Encourages innovation
  – Doing something better or more
    efficiently brings a competitive
    advantage
Market forces -ve
• Market domination by powerful
  providers
• Battling competitors rather
  than collaborating
• Cost cutting affecting quality
  and safety
• Competition centres on
  profitable services
Reading the runes
• Choice
  – Choice of any willing provider
    (willing to provide NHS care to NHS
    standards at NHS prices)
     • FT, Private hospital, Charity or GP
  – Choice of consultant-led team
  – Choice of GP practice and
  – Choice of treatment
• Choice without information is not
  real choice
Reading the runes
• Competition
  – Any willing provider
  – Monitor’s role to “promote competition” and
    enforce competition law
  – Monitor compared with OFCOM/OFGEM


• All providers of NHS care should be able
  to compete on a level playing field
The unknowns
• Who really decides
  – Commissioner
  – Patient

• Practical issues
  – Shifting care from one provider to
    another
  – Speed of development of measures,
    information, new pricing tariff,
    regulations, etc.
  – Will there be sufficient competition?
Will market forces
     deliver?

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Why the customers switch the supplier an outline
Why the customers switch the supplier   an outline Why the customers switch the supplier   an outline
Why the customers switch the supplier an outline
vikashsrivastava
 
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
gibbslm
 
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
Alexis May
 

La actualidad más candente (13)

“Multi-indication Pricing: Do we want it? Can we operationalize it?”
“Multi-indication Pricing: Do we want it? Can we operationalize it?”“Multi-indication Pricing: Do we want it? Can we operationalize it?”
“Multi-indication Pricing: Do we want it? Can we operationalize it?”
 
Why the customers switch the supplier an outline
Why the customers switch the supplier   an outline Why the customers switch the supplier   an outline
Why the customers switch the supplier an outline
 
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
Jim fitzgerald GPO April 2013
 
Using MCDA for HTA, Opportunities, Challenges and Possible Ways Forward
Using MCDA for HTA, Opportunities, Challenges and Possible Ways ForwardUsing MCDA for HTA, Opportunities, Challenges and Possible Ways Forward
Using MCDA for HTA, Opportunities, Challenges and Possible Ways Forward
 
Making value-based pricing a reality – the case for multi-indication pricing
Making value-based pricing a reality – the case for multi-indication pricing Making value-based pricing a reality – the case for multi-indication pricing
Making value-based pricing a reality – the case for multi-indication pricing
 
Rolf Panel Ross Degnan
Rolf Panel Ross DegnanRolf Panel Ross Degnan
Rolf Panel Ross Degnan
 
Pharmaceutical Pricing and Market Access
Pharmaceutical Pricing and Market AccessPharmaceutical Pricing and Market Access
Pharmaceutical Pricing and Market Access
 
Sunlows feb2014
Sunlows feb2014Sunlows feb2014
Sunlows feb2014
 
What strategies should be employed to win in Biosimilars?
What strategies should be employed to win in Biosimilars?What strategies should be employed to win in Biosimilars?
What strategies should be employed to win in Biosimilars?
 
Strategic purchasing: an approach to bringing citizens' perspectives to the h...
Strategic purchasing: an approach to bringing citizens' perspectives to the h...Strategic purchasing: an approach to bringing citizens' perspectives to the h...
Strategic purchasing: an approach to bringing citizens' perspectives to the h...
 
Webinar: Guidance on Industry-led R&D
Webinar: Guidance on Industry-led R&DWebinar: Guidance on Industry-led R&D
Webinar: Guidance on Industry-led R&D
 
Are Wider Societal Effects Considered in Healthcare Decision-making? An over...
 Are Wider Societal Effects Considered in Healthcare Decision-making? An over... Are Wider Societal Effects Considered in Healthcare Decision-making? An over...
Are Wider Societal Effects Considered in Healthcare Decision-making? An over...
 
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
Colin Cram, Open Forum Events - Open Forum Events' NHS Commissioning and Proc...
 

Similar a Marketforces

Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and PolicyProvider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Office of Health Economics
 
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formularyMoving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
PM Society
 
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formularyMoving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
PM Society
 
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
Nuffield Trust
 
Self selction of p medicines the journey
Self selction of p medicines the journeySelf selction of p medicines the journey
Self selction of p medicines the journey
James Andrews
 

Similar a Marketforces (20)

mHealth Israel_UK Healthcare, Retail and DTC Market Overview
mHealth Israel_UK Healthcare, Retail and DTC Market OverviewmHealth Israel_UK Healthcare, Retail and DTC Market Overview
mHealth Israel_UK Healthcare, Retail and DTC Market Overview
 
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and PolicyProvider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
Provider Competition in the NHS -- Economics and Policy
 
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formularyMoving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
 
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formularyMoving forward with the greater manchester formulary
Moving forward with the greater manchester formulary
 
Martin Gaynor: "Inside the ‘Black Box’ of Health Care Spending Data?" 2.18.16
Martin Gaynor: "Inside the ‘Black Box’ of Health Care Spending Data?" 2.18.16Martin Gaynor: "Inside the ‘Black Box’ of Health Care Spending Data?" 2.18.16
Martin Gaynor: "Inside the ‘Black Box’ of Health Care Spending Data?" 2.18.16
 
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-ReadPrimary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
Primary Care Trust perspective: Make or Buy - Paul Zollinger-Read
 
Phad 2 pp
Phad 2 ppPhad 2 pp
Phad 2 pp
 
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
Carol Propper: Is choice and competition happening?
 
What You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency Coverage
What You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency CoverageWhat You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency Coverage
What You MUST Know About Compensating Physician Emergency Coverage
 
Best Practices for Physician Call Coverage Compensation
Best Practices for Physician Call Coverage CompensationBest Practices for Physician Call Coverage Compensation
Best Practices for Physician Call Coverage Compensation
 
Designing Publicly Funded Healthcare Markets – FELS – November 2018 OECD disc...
Designing Publicly Funded Healthcare Markets – FELS – November 2018 OECD disc...Designing Publicly Funded Healthcare Markets – FELS – November 2018 OECD disc...
Designing Publicly Funded Healthcare Markets – FELS – November 2018 OECD disc...
 
Are You Prepared? The Next Generation of Orthopaedic Service Lines
Are You Prepared? The Next Generation of Orthopaedic Service LinesAre You Prepared? The Next Generation of Orthopaedic Service Lines
Are You Prepared? The Next Generation of Orthopaedic Service Lines
 
Health care market
Health care marketHealth care market
Health care market
 
Healthcare, Medical and Pharmaceutical Market Access Strategies - John Baresk...
Healthcare, Medical and Pharmaceutical Market Access Strategies - John Baresk...Healthcare, Medical and Pharmaceutical Market Access Strategies - John Baresk...
Healthcare, Medical and Pharmaceutical Market Access Strategies - John Baresk...
 
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019Epp gabbia filippo 2019
Epp gabbia filippo 2019
 
SHSMD Physician Engagement
SHSMD Physician EngagementSHSMD Physician Engagement
SHSMD Physician Engagement
 
Excel in Health: Understanding the NHS Landscape
Excel in Health: Understanding the NHS LandscapeExcel in Health: Understanding the NHS Landscape
Excel in Health: Understanding the NHS Landscape
 
BMA White Paper Meeting
BMA White Paper MeetingBMA White Paper Meeting
BMA White Paper Meeting
 
Vertical market expansion hc gleikin2013q4campaign
Vertical market expansion hc gleikin2013q4campaignVertical market expansion hc gleikin2013q4campaign
Vertical market expansion hc gleikin2013q4campaign
 
Self selction of p medicines the journey
Self selction of p medicines the journeySelf selction of p medicines the journey
Self selction of p medicines the journey
 

Más de Socialist Health Association

Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Socialist Health Association
 
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communitiesCommunity development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
Socialist Health Association
 

Más de Socialist Health Association (20)

NHS Diagrams
NHS DiagramsNHS Diagrams
NHS Diagrams
 
Nhsplc
NhsplcNhsplc
Nhsplc
 
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
 
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
Health and well being seen from the ground march 13
 
Community Development and Health
Community Development and HealthCommunity Development and Health
Community Development and Health
 
Nhs diagrams
Nhs diagramsNhs diagrams
Nhs diagrams
 
How can our Labour government’s health inequalities targets become achievable?
How can our Labour government’s  health inequalities targets become achievable?How can our Labour government’s  health inequalities targets become achievable?
How can our Labour government’s health inequalities targets become achievable?
 
25 years after the Black report
25 years after the Black report25 years after the Black report
25 years after the Black report
 
2011 survey article_chartpack
2011 survey article_chartpack2011 survey article_chartpack
2011 survey article_chartpack
 
Integration hsca 2012
Integration hsca 2012Integration hsca 2012
Integration hsca 2012
 
Integration presentation spa sha oct 2012 cameron
Integration presentation spa sha oct 2012 cameronIntegration presentation spa sha oct 2012 cameron
Integration presentation spa sha oct 2012 cameron
 
York integration seminar [5.4.12] (c brand et al)
York integration seminar [5.4.12] (c brand et al)York integration seminar [5.4.12] (c brand et al)
York integration seminar [5.4.12] (c brand et al)
 
Sha spa seminar york local authority and nhs integration 121012
Sha spa seminar york local authority and nhs integration 121012Sha spa seminar york local authority and nhs integration 121012
Sha spa seminar york local authority and nhs integration 121012
 
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communitiesCommunity development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
 
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communitiesCommunity development, transformation and deprived communities
Community development, transformation and deprived communities
 
Disparaties in access sha
Disparaties in access shaDisparaties in access sha
Disparaties in access sha
 
Sha sustrans presentation final
Sha sustrans presentation finalSha sustrans presentation final
Sha sustrans presentation final
 
Groningen 2006 12 mar07
Groningen 2006 12 mar07Groningen 2006 12 mar07
Groningen 2006 12 mar07
 
Groningen2006
Groningen2006Groningen2006
Groningen2006
 
Reintroductioncompetition
ReintroductioncompetitionReintroductioncompetition
Reintroductioncompetition
 

Último

Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan 087776558899
 
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
Sheetaleventcompany
 
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
rajnisinghkjn
 

Último (20)

Ahmedabad Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Ahmedabad Escort Service A...
Ahmedabad Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Ahmedabad Escort Service A...Ahmedabad Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Ahmedabad Escort Service A...
Ahmedabad Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Ahmedabad Escort Service A...
 
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
Cara Menggugurkan Kandungan Dengan Cepat Selesai Dalam 24 Jam Secara Alami Bu...
 
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
Gastric Cancer: Сlinical Implementation of Artificial Intelligence, Synergeti...
 
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book nowChennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
Chennai ❣️ Call Girl 6378878445 Call Girls in Chennai Escort service book now
 
Chandigarh Call Girls Service ❤️🍑 9809698092 👄🫦Independent Escort Service Cha...
Chandigarh Call Girls Service ❤️🍑 9809698092 👄🫦Independent Escort Service Cha...Chandigarh Call Girls Service ❤️🍑 9809698092 👄🫦Independent Escort Service Cha...
Chandigarh Call Girls Service ❤️🍑 9809698092 👄🫦Independent Escort Service Cha...
 
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
Premium Call Girls Nagpur {9xx000xx09} ❤️VVIP POOJA Call Girls in Nagpur Maha...
 
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
👉 Chennai Sexy Aunty’s WhatsApp Number 👉📞 7427069034 👉📞 Just📲 Call Ruhi Colle...
 
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Rishikesh Just Call 9667172968 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Kathua Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Kathua Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Kathua Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Kathua Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
7 steps How to prevent Thalassemia : Dr Sharda Jain & Vandana Gupta
 
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
Bhawanipatna Call Girls 📞9332606886 Call Girls in Bhawanipatna Escorts servic...
 
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
❤️Chandigarh Escorts Service☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl service in Chandigarh☎️ ...
 
Call Girls Shahdol Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Shahdol Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Shahdol Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Shahdol Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
Race Course Road } Book Call Girls in Bangalore | Whatsapp No 6378878445 VIP ...
 
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacytongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
tongue disease lecture Dr Assadawy legacy
 
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala 💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃 Top Class Call Girl Se...
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala  💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃  Top Class Call Girl Se...Kolkata Call Girls Naktala  💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃  Top Class Call Girl Se...
Kolkata Call Girls Naktala 💯Call Us 🔝 8005736733 🔝 💃 Top Class Call Girl Se...
 
❤️Call Girl Service In Chandigarh☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl in Chandigarh☎️ Cha...
❤️Call Girl Service In Chandigarh☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl in Chandigarh☎️ Cha...❤️Call Girl Service In Chandigarh☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl in Chandigarh☎️ Cha...
❤️Call Girl Service In Chandigarh☎️9814379184☎️ Call Girl in Chandigarh☎️ Cha...
 
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
Cheap Rate Call Girls Bangalore {9179660964} ❤️VVIP BEBO Call Girls in Bangal...
 
Call Girl In Chandigarh 📞9809698092📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Chandigarh Call Girls ...
Call Girl In Chandigarh 📞9809698092📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Chandigarh Call Girls ...Call Girl In Chandigarh 📞9809698092📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Chandigarh Call Girls ...
Call Girl In Chandigarh 📞9809698092📞 Just📲 Call Inaaya Chandigarh Call Girls ...
 
💰Call Girl In Bangalore☎️63788-78445💰 Call Girl service in Bangalore☎️Bangalo...
💰Call Girl In Bangalore☎️63788-78445💰 Call Girl service in Bangalore☎️Bangalo...💰Call Girl In Bangalore☎️63788-78445💰 Call Girl service in Bangalore☎️Bangalo...
💰Call Girl In Bangalore☎️63788-78445💰 Call Girl service in Bangalore☎️Bangalo...
 

Marketforces

  • 1. Can market forces make the NHS more efficient? David Pruce PruceConsulting Yes … but
  • 2. Do we have a market in the NHS? • Secondary & Tertiary Care – Not really • Primary Care – Pharmacy and Optometry • Competition, mergers, acquisitions, market exit – General Practice • Limited by relative shortage of GPs – Dentistry • Very few dentists with NHS contract
  • 4. Market forces +ve • Sharpens up organisations – Threat of business failure, reward of success • Forces focus on to the customer • Encourages innovation – Doing something better or more efficiently brings a competitive advantage
  • 5. Market forces -ve • Market domination by powerful providers • Battling competitors rather than collaborating • Cost cutting affecting quality and safety • Competition centres on profitable services
  • 6. Reading the runes • Choice – Choice of any willing provider (willing to provide NHS care to NHS standards at NHS prices) • FT, Private hospital, Charity or GP – Choice of consultant-led team – Choice of GP practice and – Choice of treatment • Choice without information is not real choice
  • 7. Reading the runes • Competition – Any willing provider – Monitor’s role to “promote competition” and enforce competition law – Monitor compared with OFCOM/OFGEM • All providers of NHS care should be able to compete on a level playing field
  • 8. The unknowns • Who really decides – Commissioner – Patient • Practical issues – Shifting care from one provider to another – Speed of development of measures, information, new pricing tariff, regulations, etc. – Will there be sufficient competition?