SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 18
Descargar para leer sin conexión
USING EXPERIENCE ZONES
TO IMPROVE OLDER SPORTS
AND ENTERTAINMENT VENUES

                   Best Practices White Paper
                                   Bob Bangham
                                 Seth Rabinowitz
Authors
  Bob Bangham
  Creative Director, RipBang Studios

 Bob is a pioneer in the development of experiential marketing environments and branded
attractions. He founded RipBang Studios to provide sports and entertainment venues with
innovative solutions that build brand loyalty, maximize sponsorship integration, and increase
per-cap revenue. With an eye toward operational efficiency, he creates brand and fan driven
environments and experiential graphics designed to enhance events.
 For over 20 years Bob has employed a combination of marketing savvy, development strategy,
thematic art, graphics, and architecture to create memorable commercial destinations. During
his career as an executive with, Rockwellgroup, NBBJ Sports and Entertainment, Gensler, and the
founder of Olio Inc, Bob has contributed to entertainment landmarks such as Universal City Walk
Hollywood, Treasure Island Resort Casino, Paris Resort Casino, New York New York, Tokyo
Disney Sea, The Seattle Space Needle, Staples Center, The Water Color Inn, Heinz Field,
Meadowlands Xanadu, US Airways Center, Amway Center, and many others.
 The RipBang team has created successful temporary and permanent brand environments for PBS,
The Food Network, Scion, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile, Red Bull, Bright House, Amway, Air Tran,
US Airways, The US Olympics Committee, The FIFA World Cup, The Cricket World Cup, The PGA,
The Breeders Cup, The Phoenix Suns, The Orlando Magic, The Minnesota Twins, and many more.


 Seth Rabinowitz
 Seth Rabinowitz is a veteran sports and entertainment industry executive and consultant. He current-
ly runs Rabinowitz Consulting, an advisory firm specializing in developing fan engagement strategies
for sports organizations, media companies, and consumer electronics manufacturers.




                                                                                         2
1. Introduction
  The past few years have been a thrilling period for stadium and arena
  development. New venues such as the O2 Arena (London, 2007),
  Bird’s Nest (Beijing, 2008), and Dallas Cowboys Stadium (2009) have
  advanced the state-of-the-art in architecture, sightlines, fan amenities,
  and sponsorable inventory. They have also become icons beyond the
  sporting world.
     That these buildings have captured           Zones.” These environments are specifically
the imagination of the sports and facilities      planned, designed, built, and operated to
industries is no surprise – they are spec-        enhance the gameday experience and comple-
tacular testament to the power of vision and      ment the sporting action.More than just
money. Yet, as an industry we cannot allow        another venue “amenity,” they are inventory
this admiration to obscure an important           that is highly sellable and ideal for sponsor
truth: these venues are exceptions rather         activation and fan engagement. Experience
than the rule.                                    Zones have of course been around for decades
     Indeed, in this time of tight budgets and    under different labels, but only in the past few
scarce credit, in most circumstances a            years has the art and science of their success-
new venue – or even a major renovation –          ful development and commercial exploitation
is unlikely at best. Rather, for those with a     been fully studied.
professional interest in stadiums and arenas           Using examples from stadiums and
– sports teams, facility managers, real estate    arena projects around the country, we will
developers, bankers, and public officials – the   illustrate how Experience Zones have helped
most important challenge today is not how to      solve a variety of common venue challenges.
build something new, but rather how to make       We will then distill these examples into a set of
the most of what already exists.                  actionable best practices and identify a process
     This White Paper explores a solution to      of next steps.
this challenge that we call “Experience




This White Paper
explores a solution
to this challenge
that we call
“Experience Zones.”
2. Common Challenges
Making the best of what you have first requires understanding
what you have – and what you lack. Our analysis has identified
five common conditions found in many older venues.

Lack of Sponsorable Inventory
New venues are built for sponsorship, with landmark entrances, large plazas, and other physical
signatures. Older venues may (or may not) have the same functional assets, but they generally
lack the distinction that makes them attractive to sponsors.

Unused / Underused Physical Space
Recent venue designs have generally optimized the physical space to create a cohesive guest
experience. After years of accumulating design modifications, temporary facilities, and
operating practices, older venues often have “dead zones” and other inefficiencies that hinder
the guest’s enjoyment.

Amenities in the Upper Deck
New venue designs and business plans have focused on creating a rich fan experience at all price
points. Older venues typically still reflect a time when just providing a seat was enough, especially
in the “cheap seats.”

A House, but not a Home
Many recent venues, particularly those with a single primary occupant, have been designed to
reflect the brand identity of their tenants. Older venues from an era of multi-purpose planning
are more generic.

Difficult Navigation
New venues in general have solved the challenge of patron wayfinding through a combination
of better design, larger spaces, and effective signage. In older venues, with cramped concourses,
limited sight lines, and multiple signage systems, wayfinding is a constant challenge.




                                                                                          4
3. Examples of Solutions
Experience Zones can be an effective solution to each of these common
challenges. In fact, in many cases, this approach can be one of the most
cost effective and timely improvement strategies. We will explore each
situation in turn.

Lack of Sponsorable Inventory                    utilitarian bridge between the grandstand
                                                 and the infield into DuPont Monster
      What makes something sponsorable is        Bridge, a unique VIP area with 56 seats
its ability to command the engagement of         and a bar.
patrons. Physical landmarks, which serve              The common denominator among
as icons and gathering points, naturally play    these diverse examples is that ordinary
this role and therefore command most of          assets can be made into valuable
the sponsorship attention.The four Cor-          sponsorable inventory when creativity
nerstone Partners at the new Meadowlands         and imagination combine to create a
Stadium (Bud Light, Met Life, Pepsi Max,         memorable guest experience.
and Verizon) each have naming rights for
one of the stadium’s entrances, for example.     Unused / Underused Physical Space
Similarly, the main entrance pavilion at the          As most venues evolve, they accu-
recently-renovated US Airways Center in          mulate physical spaces that are not well
Phoenix is sponsored by Casino Arizona.          utilized. These spaces can be as benign as
     But, if striking physical landmarks         “dead zones” that just lack energy and ap-
are unavailable, there are ways to drive fan     peal, or as bad as “dead ends” that confuse
engagement using assets that are available.      and frustrate patrons. The main entrance
Seats, for example, are obviously abundant       to New York’s Madison Square Garden is
in every venue. In Orlando, the Amway            one such example, where event patrons
Center (opening in October, 2010) takes          mix with subway and train riders in a
seating to the next level in a special section   chaotic and uninspiring entrance plaza.
featuring sponsor Airtran’s Business Class       Recognizing that this is hardly a fitting in-
airplane seats. Game-related equipment is        troduction to “The World’s Most Famous
also plentiful. At the Xcel Energy Center        Arena,” a new entry is a signature element
in Minneapolis (opened in 2000), home of         of the planned $500 million renovation
the NHL’s Minnesota Wild, dozens of High         that will begin this year.
School hockey jerseys are displayed in an
exhibit sponsored by Wells Fargo Bank.
At a very different scale, Dover International
Speedway, a NASCAR track in Delaware
(opened in 1969), also employed a variant
on this theme, by turning an otherwise -
New construction is not the only                Times have clearly changed. Today,
solution, however. A more widely appli-         in an era of rising prices and shrinking
cable, and far less expensive, approach for     purchasing power, a sufficient supply of
“dead” space is to create a targeted new        relatively inexpensive tickets is critical to
use that acknowledges its physical short-       many venues’ business plans. But lower
comings and devises a work-around. One          prices do not mean lower patron expec-
notable example of this approach comes          tations. Indeed, today, patrons at every
not from an arena or stadium, but from          price point demand value. In fact, at the
O’Hare Airport in Chicago. United Air-          lower prices points, which are now just
lines presents “The Sky’s the Limit,” a mul-    as likely to be populated by families as
timedia art installation that leads pedestri-   they are by avid fans, the demand for a
ans through a long subterranean passage.        diversity of attractions and amenities is
Similarly, at Bank of America Stadium in        often greatest.
Charlotte, NC (opened in 1996) the NFL’s              In 2005, for example, when the NBA’s
Carolina Panthers celebrate football with       Phoenix Suns renovated America West
“Carolinas Connection,” a permanent in-         Arena (now US Airways Center), they
stallation of almost 650 helmets from high      built the Verizon Wireless Jungle. This
school and college teams. This exhibit is       10,000 sq. ft. upper-concourse dining and
situated in an endzone concourse of the         entertainment zone is a permanent
uppermost seating area. The NFL’s Mi-           attraction intended to serve for families
ami Dolphins used large installations by        the same role that more traditional club
a famous South Beach artist to add visual       settings serve for adult guests. A similar
interest to the otherwise-dreary and out-       approach was utilized by the NBA’s Char-
dated concrete entrances and helix ramps        lotte Bobcats in the Time Warner Cable
at Sun Life Stadium (opened in 1987).           Arena (opened in 2005) but targeted to
     The takeaway here is that physical         adults.
deficiencies can often be addressed
just as well by “software” (exhibitry
and programming) as by “hardware”
(redesign or reconstruction).

 Amenities in the Upper Deck

      At one time, the only thing event
patrons expected for their money was a
seat, especially in inexpensive Upper Deck
sections filled with diehard fans for whom
anything else was just a distraction. As a
result, older stadiums and arenas have few
amenities in their upper reaches.

                                                                                   6
Their 9,000 sq. ft. “Rock the Rooftop” area              Pirate Ship and Buccaneer Cove,
combines interactive exhibits with a sports        a 20,000 sq. ft. pirate-themed retail and
bar, and is marketed as a reason for people        dining concourse. Older venues, on the
in lower seating areas to visit the upper level.   other hand, tended to be more generic. At
Similarly, in 2008, as part of their multi-year    best, these non-descript venues do little or
renovation project, MLB’s Boston Red Sox           nothing to contribute to a team’s brand; at
also enhanced the upper deck seating by con-       worst, they actually can harm a brand, as
verting several luxury suites into the “Coca-      in the case of the NFL’s New York Jets, who
Cola Corner,” a family-friendly section and        for 25 years played in a building named
standing-room section. Teams like the NFL’s        Giants Stadium.
Philadelphia Eagles and New England Patri-               The Jets’ identity crisis was a motiva-
ots have taken a different approach. At both       tion for their (unsuccessful) bid for a dedi-
Lincoln Financial Field (opened in 2003)           cated facility in Manhattan. Here again,
and Gillette Stadium (opened in 2002), the         however, teams in this situation need not
upper deck endzones have plazas that, with         focus only on solutions that involve new
team consent, have been turned into lively de      venues. The NHL’s Detroit Red Wings, for
facto standing sections that for many fans are     example, recently named one entrance at
seemingly preferable to regular seats.             Joe Louis Arena (opened in 1979) not after
      The key here is not the specific design      a sponsor, but after team legend Gordie
or programming solution -- it is the point         Howe. A team’s brand is also about its
that, especially today, low price point            cherished fan rituals.
seating areas merit as much attention as
the VIP areas.

A House, but not a Home

      Sports teams are the primary tenants in
most stadiums and arenas. In newer venues,
this level of importance is often reflected in
the very design of the facility – resulting, for
the team, in a house that is truly a home and
an extension of its brand. The new Yankee
Stadium (opened in 2009), for instance, faith-
fully recreated many of the signature elements
from the 85-year history of its predecessor,
including the unique roofline frieze, the
manually operated outfield scoreboards, and
the Monument Park exhibit area. Raymond
James Stadium (opened in 1998), home of the
NFL’s Tampa Bay Buccaneers, has its iconic
The point here is that
                                                   many details build a brand,
                                                   and when done right the
                                                   details of a venue can help
                                                   the brand to grow and
                                                   stand out in a competitive
                                                   marketplace.
                                                    value of a team that had played for 45
                                                    years in “uncool” Shea Stadium.
                                                         The point here is that many
                                                    details build a brand, and when done
                                                    right the details of a venue can help
                                                    the brand to grow and stand out in a
                                                    competitive marketplace.


 The NHL’s Chicago Blackhawks retained the           Difficult Navigation
signature sound of their famous pipe organ
when they moved from Chicago Stadium to                    Good navigation can make a bad
the United Center in 1994. Another ap-              facility better and poor navigation can
proach is to brand a facility in a way that also    make an otherwise good facility worse.
preserves the equity of the team’s identity,        Like many details, when navigation is done
as the NFL’s Denver Broncos did when they           correctly it is almost invisible; but when
opened INVESCO Field at Mile High in                done incorrectly, the resulting confusion,
2001. The new venue’s name, while some-             bottlenecks, and delays can be glaring.
thing of a mouthful, did retain the essence         Sports facilities provide additional
of the fact that other teams feared playing in      challenges because they are usually
Denver’s thin mile-high air. Finally, in some       circular and multi-level, factors that tend
cases, a team can actually enhance its brand        to cause people lose their bearings.
by borrowing some equity from another                      Fortunately, sub-optimal navigation
property within the facility. When the New          is one of the easiest venue challenges to
York Mets developed the concession plan for         address.
Citi Field (opened in 2009), they included an
outpost of Shake Shack, an iconic New York
burger joint, as part of a strategy to add a
“cool factor” and expand the entertainment

                                                                                     8
One solution is simply to “edit” what       The main message here is
exists, which, especially in older venues,
tends to be an inconsistent and confusing         that simplicity, consistency,
accumulation of different signage and graph-      and memorability are the
ics systems. Starting in 1996, Tropicana Field
                                                  most important elements
(opened in 1990), home of MLB’s Tampa Bay
Rays, undertook a complete signage over-          in facility navigation.
haul. To enhance the stadium’s branding,
the team’s logo was incorporated into new
directional signage, for example, and “old
fashioned” signage designs and lettering were
used to give a more historical feel to a decid-
edly non-historic venue. Another approach
is to create navigation icons that help people
remember where they are and where they
are going without using maps. At University
of Phoenix Stadium in Arizona (opened in
2006), for example, the entrances feature
massive number or letter sculptures to assist
guests in remembering their entry/exit point.
These are as much works of art as signs.
Inspired by shopping malls, yet another
approach is to create anchor uses as orienta-
tion points. In Philadelphia, for example,
Citizens Bank Park (opened in 2004), home
of MLB’s Phillies, anchors its entire out-
field with the Ashburn Alley entertainment
area. To aid navigation of this 50,000 sq. ft,
625-foot-long area, each end has a signature
eatery: “Bulls,” a BBQ joint run by a former
Phillies player, and “Harry the K’s,” which
honors legendary Phillies broadcaster
Harry Kalas.
      The main message here is that
simplicity, consistency, and memorability
are the most important elements in facility
navigation.
4. The Business Case for
                                                  Experience Zones
These days, any capital investment plan has a high burden of proof.
This is especially true in sports venues, where teams have historically
been able to rely on sponsors and other parties to fund their initiatives.
In this section, we suggest six questions that can be useful in evaluating
and building a business case for an investment in Experience Zones.
1). What are my specific objectives?               enhance an asset. (Consider, for example,
Finding the right solution usually starts by       the fact that in Forbes Magazine’s 2009
really understanding the problem. Objectives       valuations of major pro sports franchises,
could include direct revenue (sponsorships),       only about half of the most valuable teams
indirect revenue (ticket sales, retention/         in each league are those with the highest annual
renewal), event day revenues (no-show              operating income. The others are those, like
reduction, per-caps), guest satisfaction, and/or   MLB’s Los Angeles Dodgers or the NHL’s Phila-
brand enhancement.                                 delphia Flyers, with strong national brands.)
                                                   So, brand value should also be considered
2). What are my solution alternatives?             among other long-term considerations.
Once objectives are clearly defined, a range of
possible solutions can be identified. For a        5). Does each alternative help create a point of
complete analysis, the “do nothing” option         difference?
should also be considered, since that is           Stadium- and arena-based offerings com-
usually the default outcome.                       pete against many other forms of entertain
                                                   ment, so ways to stand out in the market
3). For each alternative, what is my cash ROI?
                                                   place are critical.
The first source of ROI is direct revenue, in
this case most likely from incremental
                                                   6). What is the longevity of each alternative?
sponsorships. But it is important that a full
                                                   Any venue improvement initiative consumes
range of indirect revenues also be con-
                                                   not only money but also management
sidered. For example, can the investment
                                                   time and attention. It is important that these
support revenue objectives like increased
                                                   investments have a long useful life, so that
per caps, ticket sales, season ticket holder
                                                   the problem that was solved does not re-
retention, and no-show reduction? Finally,
                                                   emerge in a few short years.
ROI can also come from cost reduction, so
the analysis should consider operational ef-
ficiencies and other savings.

4). Does each alternative build asset value?
In addition to cash ROI, the best invest
ments also build long-term asset value. In
sports, a strong brand is one clear way to

                                                                                      10
4. The Business Case for
   Experience Zones (cont.)
   Experience Zone Costs:                       cost and organizational implications of
       Costs can vary widely, of course,        ongoing upkeep need to be considered. This
  depending on the project’s setting, nature,   is particularly true when technology is in-
  and scope – but certain rules of thumb can    volved, since the state-of-the-art changes so
  be useful in reaching a preliminary cost      rapidly. A second caveat is specificity. Many
  estimate. Experience Zone costs fall into     Experience Zones are built for one specific
  two categories:                               purpose or sponsor, and may be difficult to
                                                adapt to an alternate use. A final concern
      Hard Costss              Soft Costs
                                                is distraction. Like anything, Experience
    Construction             Planning/Design    Zones can be overdone and become a dis-
    Fixtures                 Engineering
    Equipment                Architecture       traction from, rather than a complement to,
                             Permits & Fees     the game or event that should always be the
                             Insurance          focal point of the patron experience.
   Simple projects in an     Typically an
   existing facility start   additional 10%
   at roughly $100 per       to 20% of the
   square foot.              Hard Costs.

   A state-of-the-art
   Family Zone typically
   costs $250 to $350
   per square foot.

   Costs can reach as
   high as $400 per
   square foot for a
   luxury environment.

        When evaluated against these
  criteria, Experience Zones tend to
  compare favorably against other alter-
  natives. Their ROI is usually strong be-
  cause up-front investment is relatively
  low, they are highly sponsorable, and
  they support indirect revenues like per
  caps and no-show reductions by adding
  to the overall event experience. Expe-
  rience Zones also can be good brand
  builders that increase asset value.
        Experience Zones also come with
  a few caveats. The first is commitment.
  Experience Zones need to be main-
  tained and periodically updated, so the
5. Best Practices
Even the most solid business case is no guarantee of success.
Rather, in our experience the most important success factor is the
quality of the implementation of the ideas. As the number of
Experience Zones grows and as their documentation and study im-
prove, a set of best practices can be distilled. Incorporating these best
practices into a project can significantly improve its quality and there-
fore the likelihood of success.

 Start with a Master Plan                              Give People Something to Do,
                                                       Not Just Something to See.
     Any venue improvements should start
with a detailed definition of the objectives               Too many sponsored elements at
and explanation of the business case (see             stadiums and arenas are just “eye candy”
above) and a long-term vision. We call this a         – signs, displays, or exhibits. They are
Master Plan, and it can serve as an invaluable        attractive, but ultimately do not really
touchstone as the years pass. It can also help        engage the fan. A better approach – for
determine the point at which you have done            venues and for sponsors – is to include
“enough,” and help avoid crossing the line            interactive and participatory elements as
of over-commercialization and distraction.            well, so that fans have something to do
Finally, it can also be very valuable in              and are engaged on multiple levels.
maintaining the discipline of your sponsor-            Script the Guest Experience
ship package structuring and ensuring that
you protect sponsor exclusivity to the                     The ultimate takeaway by every
maximum extent.                                       event patron should be fond and lasting
                                                      memories. Especially in sports, where
 Think Engagement, not Inventory
                                                      there is no control of the outcome of
      Value is created by fan engage-                 the game itself, this should not be left
ment, so plan and design from the fans’               to chance. Rather, venue managers and
perspective outward. Create something                 their tenants should work together to
that fans will like and use and the value             literally “script” the entire guest experi-
of the inventory will take care of itself.            ence from arrival to departure to ensure
 Have Specific Target Audiences                       that are many opportunities for positive
                                                      memories.
     Don’t try to be everything to everyone.
Identify subsets of your patron base with specific
needs and wants, and create specific Experience
Zones to serve these. Just make sure that each
Zone clearly communicates its target, so that you
don’t have disappointed 20-somethings in the
family zone.

                                                                                        12
5. Best Practices (cont.)
 Be Dynamic                            If a guest has to look for a sign, he or she is
                                       probably already lost. Don’t let upgrades in
      Especially in sports, with
                                       navigation and wayfinding become after-
large numbers of season ticket
                                       thoughts or victims of the budgeting process.
holders, many stadiums and are-
nas play host to the same people        Think Like a TV Director
over and over again. This creates
                                              Create icons that will look good on
a risk of the “been there, done
                                       television and become signatures of your
that” syndrome, where the nov-
                                       facility. Make these icons unique reflections
elty of new attractions wears off
                                       of the venue’s tenants and home city.
quickly. To counteract this, where
possible Experience Zones should
dynamic, rather than static, attrac-
tions that change frequently and
always offer something new.

 Go Beyond Logo Lock-Ups
       For the benefit of both the
property and the sponsor, venue
sponsorships should be about
much more than just co-presen-
tation of logos. Venues offer a
unique opportunity for a true
merging of brand equities. At
a minimum, Experience Zones
should highlight how the spon-
sor is also fan of the team. Better
still, use Experience Zones to
bring to life the ways in which
the property and the sponsor
truly share brand equities. Best
of all, enlist sponsors early in
the process so that they have full
“ownership” of the outcomes.
 Make it Easy to Find
       The best attractions serve
little purpose if they are hard to
find.
6. Next Steps
Moving forward with any capital project is usually an interative
process, starting with a general concept and then going through stages
of refinement before finally arriving at a definitive plan. In the case
of Experience Zones, we have identified four steps along this process,
discussed below, along with a general estimate of the time and money
involved.

 Step 1: Initial Analysis and Review         Duration:
      The goal of Step 1 is to assess the    Approximately one month; ideally
situation and formulate a plan of ac-        completed before the start of the
tion. If a Master Plan already exists (see   annual selling cycle.
above), the initial analysis will build on
that work; if not, this step can serve as    Estimated Budget Range:
the basis for a future Master Plan. Either   $15,000 to $30,000 in Soft Costs.
way, the following questions should be
addressed.

1).Goals and Objectives.
Why proceed? What problems will this
solve and/or opportunities will it create?

2).Physical Inventory.
What strengths and weaknesses does
the physical space have? What spaces
could be (or must be) reinvigorated or
repurposed?

3). Target Audience(s).
Who will be targeted? What demo
graphic and/or sales data exists for
these groups? What are their needs and
wants?

4). Sponsorship Opportunities.
What national, regional, and/or local
sponsors could be integrated into the
project? What are their key decision
points?

                                                                        14
6. Next Steps (cont.)
 Step 2: Business Case                      Step 3: Detailed Project Planning
     The goal of Step 2 is to reach a go/         The goal of Step 3 – which only takes
no-go decision by presenting a detailed     place if a project is approved – is to create a
business case.                              detailed concept plan and, concurrently, a
                                            sales kit to market the opportunity to
1). Project Expense Budget.                 potential partners.
How much will the project cost,                   This step is divided into two parts, one
and over what time period? What             of which should be contingent on sponsor
financing sources are available (e.g.,      interest, while the other should proceed with
 operating budget, capital budget, “cost    or without a sponsor attached.
of revenue” offset to sponsorship
income)?
                                             Part One: Signage and Graphics
2). Revenue Projection.
                                            1). Signage and Graphics System.
How much can the project’s sponsorship
                                            Create a system that simplifies wayfinding,
inventory be sold for, and over what
                                            reduces clutter, and reinforces the brand of
deal term? How will the project
                                            the venue and/or the
contribute indirectly to the growth
                                            tenants.
of other revenues?
                                            2). Sponsor / Partner Integration.
3). Brand Building.
                                            Ensure that venue naming rights holders
How, specifically, will the project help
                                            and other sponsors and partners are
build the brand and create differentia-
                                            integrated into the system in a way that
tion from the competition?
                                            maximizes their visibility.
Duration:
                                            3). Fabrication.
Approximately two weeks                     Create the signs and graphical
of work; length of approval                 elements.
cycles will vary.
                                            4). Installation.
Estimated Budget Range:
                                            Finally, install the elements throughout the
No out-of-pocket costs.                     facility.
Duration:                                      4). Deal Terms.
                                               Negotiate final pricing and other
Approximately three months;
                                               deal terms.
ideally done in the off-season.
                                               Duration:
Estimated Budget Range:
                                               One to three months;
Soft Costs of $100,000 to
                                               ideally completed at the
$500,000, depending on the
                                               start of the annual selling
project scope and venue
                                               cycle.
type. Hard Costs can vary
widely, with a signage up-                     Estimated Budget Range:
grade costing starting at
about $100,000, while and                      $15,000 to $30,000 in
entire signage and graphics                    “soft costs” per concept;
system for an arena or sta-                    $5,000 to $10,000 per
dium can cost $1.5 million to                  additional sales pitch.
$5 million.
Part Two: Experience Zone Design and Sales
    Unlike signage, Experience Zone
elements should generally have a sponsor
commiment before they are constructed.

1). Concept Development.
Prepare specific Experience Zone concepts,
with detailed illustrations and photo
simulations.

2). Sponsor Pitches.
Communicate concepts and specific spon-
sorship opportunities to potential partners,
using co-branded pitch documents.

3). Sponsor Integration.
Once a sponsor has committed, collaborate
to maximize sponsor integration, value, and
brand messaging.


                                                                        16
6. Next Steps (cont.)
Step 4: Construction, Fabrication, and Installation

     Finally, in Step 4 the project turns
to the implementation of the Experience
Zones themselves.

1). Final Design.
Translate concept designs into detailed,
construction-ready blueprints.

2).Construction.
Build (and/or demolish) as necessary to
create the desired physical environment.

3). Fabrication.
Create the exhibits, interactive attractions,
and other Zone elements.

4). Installation.
Finally, install the exhibits and attractions
as well as any other fixtures or equipment.

Duration:

Three to six month construction
period, depending on size and
complexity of the project and
other uses of the facility; ideally
completed during the facility’s
off-season.
Estimated Budget Range:

Construction Hard Costs of
$250,000 to $2,500,000,
depending on a wide range
of facility- and project-specific
factors.
7. Conclusion
      Decision makers grappling with          For venues that embrace this level of
how to enhance aging stadiums and are-        commitment, however, they can be a
nas have more options than they may first     highly effective solution that at once
think. New construction or substantial        improves the guest experience and the
renovation will always be tempting – and      sponsorship proposition.
when the economics and politics allow,               We predict that Experience Zones
probably the best strategy. But in most       will continue to gain popularity as venue
cases today, this option will simply not be   managers, sports teams, public officials,
on the table and more creative approach-      and other interested parties address the
es will be necessary. Experience Zones        challenge of keeping all stadiums and
are one best practice to maximize the         arenas – not just the aging ones – fresh
utility and value of what exists through      and relevant to an increasingly distracted
smart and targeted investments.               public. Doing this with limited financial
      If conceived, built, and operated       resources will make the need for creative
properly, Experience Zones can generate       solutions even more keen. Adopting the
a measurable ROI and boost the appeal of      growing body of best practices in this
a venue and its tenants. Like any capital     area will serve the entire industry well by
improvement, they are not cheap, per se,      providing additional success stories. It
but their cost tends to compare favor-        will also drive further innovation by rais-
ably to other venue-enhancement strate-       ing the bar of performance in an industry
gies. Nor are they hands-off. Experience      that has competition at its essence.
Zones require an ongoing commitment
to physical maintenance and content
updates. the guest experience and the
sponsorship proposition.




                                                                                 18

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study
The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study
The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study Raffy Karamanian
 
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca College
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca CollegeFlare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca College
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca CollegePriyanka Samtani
 
Kotler Keller Branding Slides
Kotler Keller Branding SlidesKotler Keller Branding Slides
Kotler Keller Branding SlidesMoises Cielak
 
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063Joshua C
 
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdf
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdflifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdf
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdfSiddheshShete1
 
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy bareesh
 
Brand equity (detailed ppt)
Brand equity (detailed ppt)Brand equity (detailed ppt)
Brand equity (detailed ppt)Vipin Kumar
 
Metabical - Marketing Case Study
Metabical - Marketing Case StudyMetabical - Marketing Case Study
Metabical - Marketing Case StudyShrishti Gupta
 
Chapter 1 brands and brand management
Chapter 1   brands and brand managementChapter 1   brands and brand management
Chapter 1 brands and brand managementgabbsy
 
L'Oreal Repositioning
L'Oreal Repositioning L'Oreal Repositioning
L'Oreal Repositioning zenankita
 
Saxonville sausage company- A Case Study
Saxonville sausage company- A Case StudySaxonville sausage company- A Case Study
Saxonville sausage company- A Case StudySameer mathur
 
Portfolio analysis - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joy
Portfolio analysis  - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin JoyPortfolio analysis  - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joy
Portfolio analysis - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joymanumelwin
 
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)Siddharth Barjatya
 
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVE
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVESALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVE
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVEkuruvillaachankunju
 
Submission to Journal of Logistics
Submission to Journal of LogisticsSubmission to Journal of Logistics
Submission to Journal of LogisticsLora Cecere
 

La actualidad más candente (17)

The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study
The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study
The Birth of the Swatch - HBR Case Study
 
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca College
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca CollegeFlare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca College
Flare Fragrances - Harvard Business Case by Priyanka Samtani, Seneca College
 
Kotler Keller Branding Slides
Kotler Keller Branding SlidesKotler Keller Branding Slides
Kotler Keller Branding Slides
 
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063
Channels24222_Report_Johnson11211063
 
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdf
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdflifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdf
lifebuoy-case-study-final_compress.pdf
 
Shopper Marketing
Shopper MarketingShopper Marketing
Shopper Marketing
 
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy
How Competitive Forces Shape Strategy
 
Brand equity (detailed ppt)
Brand equity (detailed ppt)Brand equity (detailed ppt)
Brand equity (detailed ppt)
 
Metabical - Marketing Case Study
Metabical - Marketing Case StudyMetabical - Marketing Case Study
Metabical - Marketing Case Study
 
Chapter 1 brands and brand management
Chapter 1   brands and brand managementChapter 1   brands and brand management
Chapter 1 brands and brand management
 
L'Oreal Repositioning
L'Oreal Repositioning L'Oreal Repositioning
L'Oreal Repositioning
 
Saxonville sausage company- A Case Study
Saxonville sausage company- A Case StudySaxonville sausage company- A Case Study
Saxonville sausage company- A Case Study
 
Portfolio analysis - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joy
Portfolio analysis  - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin JoyPortfolio analysis  - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joy
Portfolio analysis - strategic implementation - Manu Melwin Joy
 
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)
Reliance Baking Soda: Optimizing Promotional Spending (HBR Brief Case)
 
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVE
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVESALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVE
SALES AND DISTRIBUTION MANAGEMENT OF COLGATE PALMOLIVE
 
Submission to Journal of Logistics
Submission to Journal of LogisticsSubmission to Journal of Logistics
Submission to Journal of Logistics
 
V-Guard Big Idea
V-Guard Big IdeaV-Guard Big Idea
V-Guard Big Idea
 

Destacado

Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-August
Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-AugustSocial Media Report - NFL Teams July-August
Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-AugustUnmetric
 
Kellogg's Digital Marketing Strategy
Kellogg's Digital Marketing StrategyKellogg's Digital Marketing Strategy
Kellogg's Digital Marketing StrategyIcelyn Williams
 
Gamification in Banking & Financials Examples
Gamification in Banking & Financials ExamplesGamification in Banking & Financials Examples
Gamification in Banking & Financials ExamplesMario Herger
 
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing Automation
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing AutomationHow Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing Automation
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing AutomationSimplyCast
 
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015smeinc
 
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting Bret Werner
 
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done Right
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done RightFan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done Right
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done RightPursuant Sports
 
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagement
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagementSports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagement
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagementDeloitte United States
 

Destacado (11)

Final presentation
Final presentationFinal presentation
Final presentation
 
Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-August
Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-AugustSocial Media Report - NFL Teams July-August
Social Media Report - NFL Teams July-August
 
Tema
TemaTema
Tema
 
Kellogg's Digital Marketing Strategy
Kellogg's Digital Marketing StrategyKellogg's Digital Marketing Strategy
Kellogg's Digital Marketing Strategy
 
Top 5 Gamification Examples
Top 5 Gamification ExamplesTop 5 Gamification Examples
Top 5 Gamification Examples
 
Gamification in Banking & Financials Examples
Gamification in Banking & Financials ExamplesGamification in Banking & Financials Examples
Gamification in Banking & Financials Examples
 
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing Automation
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing AutomationHow Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing Automation
How Football Teams Drive Fan Engagement With Marketing Automation
 
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015
Top 5 Trends in Fan Engagement for 2015
 
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting
Fan Engagement Study -- IMG Consulting
 
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done Right
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done RightFan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done Right
Fan Engagement: Sports Social Media Done Right
 
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagement
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagementSports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagement
Sports Loyalty: Exploring fan engagement
 

Similar a Experience Zone Best Practices

Future of stadium design
Future of stadium designFuture of stadium design
Future of stadium designImad Kayyali
 
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping Centres
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping CentresReconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping Centres
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping CentresSCG International
 
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentation
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar PresentationMilder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentation
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentationdanthinc
 
Creating Places Where People Want To Be
Creating Places Where People Want To BeCreating Places Where People Want To Be
Creating Places Where People Want To BeSCG International
 
KH Career Portfolio
KH Career PortfolioKH Career Portfolio
KH Career Portfoliojoketa97
 
Development Design Group Intro
Development Design Group IntroDevelopment Design Group Intro
Development Design Group IntroTony Van Vliet
 
Crocs portfolio compressed
Crocs portfolio compressedCrocs portfolio compressed
Crocs portfolio compressedadlerk
 
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...UX STRAT
 
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)Charles Tang
 
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art MuseumMichael Edson
 
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire Family
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire FamilyCreating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire Family
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire FamilySu-Fei Sakamoto
 
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...Alaina McBride, Marketing Manager
 
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by Design
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by DesignYW White Paper Changing Behaviour by Design
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by DesignDavid Blyth
 

Similar a Experience Zone Best Practices (20)

Non-traditional Floor Plans
Non-traditional Floor PlansNon-traditional Floor Plans
Non-traditional Floor Plans
 
Future of stadium design
Future of stadium designFuture of stadium design
Future of stadium design
 
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping Centres
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping CentresReconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping Centres
Reconception - Intelligent Asset Management for Shopping Centres
 
Foresight at Arup
Foresight at ArupForesight at Arup
Foresight at Arup
 
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentation
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar PresentationMilder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentation
Milder-Dane 3.4.16 APA CSD Webinar Presentation
 
Diamond Proposal
Diamond ProposalDiamond Proposal
Diamond Proposal
 
Creating Places Where People Want To Be
Creating Places Where People Want To BeCreating Places Where People Want To Be
Creating Places Where People Want To Be
 
KH Career Portfolio
KH Career PortfolioKH Career Portfolio
KH Career Portfolio
 
Development Design Group Intro
Development Design Group IntroDevelopment Design Group Intro
Development Design Group Intro
 
Crocs portfolio compressed
Crocs portfolio compressedCrocs portfolio compressed
Crocs portfolio compressed
 
Experience
ExperienceExperience
Experience
 
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...
UX STRAT Europe 2017: Willem Boijens: “Creating an adidas Ecosystem Experienc...
 
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)
Engilsh- Interview with CharlesTang from the magazine (Architectural knowledge)
 
Corporate Naming Rights and Sponsorship - Conference 2009 (B1)
Corporate Naming Rights and Sponsorship - Conference 2009 (B1)Corporate Naming Rights and Sponsorship - Conference 2009 (B1)
Corporate Naming Rights and Sponsorship - Conference 2009 (B1)
 
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum
"Long Tail" Web strategy paper for Smithsonian American Art Museum
 
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire Family
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire FamilyCreating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire Family
Creating Play Spaces for Kids that draw the Entire Family
 
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...
Community Character Development, Urban Placemaking, Urban Land Institute ULI,...
 
Story wars part 1 - group 3
Story wars part 1  -  group 3Story wars part 1  -  group 3
Story wars part 1 - group 3
 
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by Design
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by DesignYW White Paper Changing Behaviour by Design
YW White Paper Changing Behaviour by Design
 
Interior Design Portfolio
Interior Design PortfolioInterior Design Portfolio
Interior Design Portfolio
 

Experience Zone Best Practices

  • 1. USING EXPERIENCE ZONES TO IMPROVE OLDER SPORTS AND ENTERTAINMENT VENUES Best Practices White Paper Bob Bangham Seth Rabinowitz
  • 2. Authors Bob Bangham Creative Director, RipBang Studios Bob is a pioneer in the development of experiential marketing environments and branded attractions. He founded RipBang Studios to provide sports and entertainment venues with innovative solutions that build brand loyalty, maximize sponsorship integration, and increase per-cap revenue. With an eye toward operational efficiency, he creates brand and fan driven environments and experiential graphics designed to enhance events. For over 20 years Bob has employed a combination of marketing savvy, development strategy, thematic art, graphics, and architecture to create memorable commercial destinations. During his career as an executive with, Rockwellgroup, NBBJ Sports and Entertainment, Gensler, and the founder of Olio Inc, Bob has contributed to entertainment landmarks such as Universal City Walk Hollywood, Treasure Island Resort Casino, Paris Resort Casino, New York New York, Tokyo Disney Sea, The Seattle Space Needle, Staples Center, The Water Color Inn, Heinz Field, Meadowlands Xanadu, US Airways Center, Amway Center, and many others. The RipBang team has created successful temporary and permanent brand environments for PBS, The Food Network, Scion, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile, Red Bull, Bright House, Amway, Air Tran, US Airways, The US Olympics Committee, The FIFA World Cup, The Cricket World Cup, The PGA, The Breeders Cup, The Phoenix Suns, The Orlando Magic, The Minnesota Twins, and many more. Seth Rabinowitz Seth Rabinowitz is a veteran sports and entertainment industry executive and consultant. He current- ly runs Rabinowitz Consulting, an advisory firm specializing in developing fan engagement strategies for sports organizations, media companies, and consumer electronics manufacturers. 2
  • 3. 1. Introduction The past few years have been a thrilling period for stadium and arena development. New venues such as the O2 Arena (London, 2007), Bird’s Nest (Beijing, 2008), and Dallas Cowboys Stadium (2009) have advanced the state-of-the-art in architecture, sightlines, fan amenities, and sponsorable inventory. They have also become icons beyond the sporting world. That these buildings have captured Zones.” These environments are specifically the imagination of the sports and facilities planned, designed, built, and operated to industries is no surprise – they are spec- enhance the gameday experience and comple- tacular testament to the power of vision and ment the sporting action.More than just money. Yet, as an industry we cannot allow another venue “amenity,” they are inventory this admiration to obscure an important that is highly sellable and ideal for sponsor truth: these venues are exceptions rather activation and fan engagement. Experience than the rule. Zones have of course been around for decades Indeed, in this time of tight budgets and under different labels, but only in the past few scarce credit, in most circumstances a years has the art and science of their success- new venue – or even a major renovation – ful development and commercial exploitation is unlikely at best. Rather, for those with a been fully studied. professional interest in stadiums and arenas Using examples from stadiums and – sports teams, facility managers, real estate arena projects around the country, we will developers, bankers, and public officials – the illustrate how Experience Zones have helped most important challenge today is not how to solve a variety of common venue challenges. build something new, but rather how to make We will then distill these examples into a set of the most of what already exists. actionable best practices and identify a process This White Paper explores a solution to of next steps. this challenge that we call “Experience This White Paper explores a solution to this challenge that we call “Experience Zones.”
  • 4. 2. Common Challenges Making the best of what you have first requires understanding what you have – and what you lack. Our analysis has identified five common conditions found in many older venues. Lack of Sponsorable Inventory New venues are built for sponsorship, with landmark entrances, large plazas, and other physical signatures. Older venues may (or may not) have the same functional assets, but they generally lack the distinction that makes them attractive to sponsors. Unused / Underused Physical Space Recent venue designs have generally optimized the physical space to create a cohesive guest experience. After years of accumulating design modifications, temporary facilities, and operating practices, older venues often have “dead zones” and other inefficiencies that hinder the guest’s enjoyment. Amenities in the Upper Deck New venue designs and business plans have focused on creating a rich fan experience at all price points. Older venues typically still reflect a time when just providing a seat was enough, especially in the “cheap seats.” A House, but not a Home Many recent venues, particularly those with a single primary occupant, have been designed to reflect the brand identity of their tenants. Older venues from an era of multi-purpose planning are more generic. Difficult Navigation New venues in general have solved the challenge of patron wayfinding through a combination of better design, larger spaces, and effective signage. In older venues, with cramped concourses, limited sight lines, and multiple signage systems, wayfinding is a constant challenge. 4
  • 5. 3. Examples of Solutions Experience Zones can be an effective solution to each of these common challenges. In fact, in many cases, this approach can be one of the most cost effective and timely improvement strategies. We will explore each situation in turn. Lack of Sponsorable Inventory utilitarian bridge between the grandstand and the infield into DuPont Monster What makes something sponsorable is Bridge, a unique VIP area with 56 seats its ability to command the engagement of and a bar. patrons. Physical landmarks, which serve The common denominator among as icons and gathering points, naturally play these diverse examples is that ordinary this role and therefore command most of assets can be made into valuable the sponsorship attention.The four Cor- sponsorable inventory when creativity nerstone Partners at the new Meadowlands and imagination combine to create a Stadium (Bud Light, Met Life, Pepsi Max, memorable guest experience. and Verizon) each have naming rights for one of the stadium’s entrances, for example. Unused / Underused Physical Space Similarly, the main entrance pavilion at the As most venues evolve, they accu- recently-renovated US Airways Center in mulate physical spaces that are not well Phoenix is sponsored by Casino Arizona. utilized. These spaces can be as benign as But, if striking physical landmarks “dead zones” that just lack energy and ap- are unavailable, there are ways to drive fan peal, or as bad as “dead ends” that confuse engagement using assets that are available. and frustrate patrons. The main entrance Seats, for example, are obviously abundant to New York’s Madison Square Garden is in every venue. In Orlando, the Amway one such example, where event patrons Center (opening in October, 2010) takes mix with subway and train riders in a seating to the next level in a special section chaotic and uninspiring entrance plaza. featuring sponsor Airtran’s Business Class Recognizing that this is hardly a fitting in- airplane seats. Game-related equipment is troduction to “The World’s Most Famous also plentiful. At the Xcel Energy Center Arena,” a new entry is a signature element in Minneapolis (opened in 2000), home of of the planned $500 million renovation the NHL’s Minnesota Wild, dozens of High that will begin this year. School hockey jerseys are displayed in an exhibit sponsored by Wells Fargo Bank. At a very different scale, Dover International Speedway, a NASCAR track in Delaware (opened in 1969), also employed a variant on this theme, by turning an otherwise -
  • 6. New construction is not the only Times have clearly changed. Today, solution, however. A more widely appli- in an era of rising prices and shrinking cable, and far less expensive, approach for purchasing power, a sufficient supply of “dead” space is to create a targeted new relatively inexpensive tickets is critical to use that acknowledges its physical short- many venues’ business plans. But lower comings and devises a work-around. One prices do not mean lower patron expec- notable example of this approach comes tations. Indeed, today, patrons at every not from an arena or stadium, but from price point demand value. In fact, at the O’Hare Airport in Chicago. United Air- lower prices points, which are now just lines presents “The Sky’s the Limit,” a mul- as likely to be populated by families as timedia art installation that leads pedestri- they are by avid fans, the demand for a ans through a long subterranean passage. diversity of attractions and amenities is Similarly, at Bank of America Stadium in often greatest. Charlotte, NC (opened in 1996) the NFL’s In 2005, for example, when the NBA’s Carolina Panthers celebrate football with Phoenix Suns renovated America West “Carolinas Connection,” a permanent in- Arena (now US Airways Center), they stallation of almost 650 helmets from high built the Verizon Wireless Jungle. This school and college teams. This exhibit is 10,000 sq. ft. upper-concourse dining and situated in an endzone concourse of the entertainment zone is a permanent uppermost seating area. The NFL’s Mi- attraction intended to serve for families ami Dolphins used large installations by the same role that more traditional club a famous South Beach artist to add visual settings serve for adult guests. A similar interest to the otherwise-dreary and out- approach was utilized by the NBA’s Char- dated concrete entrances and helix ramps lotte Bobcats in the Time Warner Cable at Sun Life Stadium (opened in 1987). Arena (opened in 2005) but targeted to The takeaway here is that physical adults. deficiencies can often be addressed just as well by “software” (exhibitry and programming) as by “hardware” (redesign or reconstruction). Amenities in the Upper Deck At one time, the only thing event patrons expected for their money was a seat, especially in inexpensive Upper Deck sections filled with diehard fans for whom anything else was just a distraction. As a result, older stadiums and arenas have few amenities in their upper reaches. 6
  • 7. Their 9,000 sq. ft. “Rock the Rooftop” area Pirate Ship and Buccaneer Cove, combines interactive exhibits with a sports a 20,000 sq. ft. pirate-themed retail and bar, and is marketed as a reason for people dining concourse. Older venues, on the in lower seating areas to visit the upper level. other hand, tended to be more generic. At Similarly, in 2008, as part of their multi-year best, these non-descript venues do little or renovation project, MLB’s Boston Red Sox nothing to contribute to a team’s brand; at also enhanced the upper deck seating by con- worst, they actually can harm a brand, as verting several luxury suites into the “Coca- in the case of the NFL’s New York Jets, who Cola Corner,” a family-friendly section and for 25 years played in a building named standing-room section. Teams like the NFL’s Giants Stadium. Philadelphia Eagles and New England Patri- The Jets’ identity crisis was a motiva- ots have taken a different approach. At both tion for their (unsuccessful) bid for a dedi- Lincoln Financial Field (opened in 2003) cated facility in Manhattan. Here again, and Gillette Stadium (opened in 2002), the however, teams in this situation need not upper deck endzones have plazas that, with focus only on solutions that involve new team consent, have been turned into lively de venues. The NHL’s Detroit Red Wings, for facto standing sections that for many fans are example, recently named one entrance at seemingly preferable to regular seats. Joe Louis Arena (opened in 1979) not after The key here is not the specific design a sponsor, but after team legend Gordie or programming solution -- it is the point Howe. A team’s brand is also about its that, especially today, low price point cherished fan rituals. seating areas merit as much attention as the VIP areas. A House, but not a Home Sports teams are the primary tenants in most stadiums and arenas. In newer venues, this level of importance is often reflected in the very design of the facility – resulting, for the team, in a house that is truly a home and an extension of its brand. The new Yankee Stadium (opened in 2009), for instance, faith- fully recreated many of the signature elements from the 85-year history of its predecessor, including the unique roofline frieze, the manually operated outfield scoreboards, and the Monument Park exhibit area. Raymond James Stadium (opened in 1998), home of the NFL’s Tampa Bay Buccaneers, has its iconic
  • 8. The point here is that many details build a brand, and when done right the details of a venue can help the brand to grow and stand out in a competitive marketplace. value of a team that had played for 45 years in “uncool” Shea Stadium. The point here is that many details build a brand, and when done right the details of a venue can help the brand to grow and stand out in a competitive marketplace. The NHL’s Chicago Blackhawks retained the Difficult Navigation signature sound of their famous pipe organ when they moved from Chicago Stadium to Good navigation can make a bad the United Center in 1994. Another ap- facility better and poor navigation can proach is to brand a facility in a way that also make an otherwise good facility worse. preserves the equity of the team’s identity, Like many details, when navigation is done as the NFL’s Denver Broncos did when they correctly it is almost invisible; but when opened INVESCO Field at Mile High in done incorrectly, the resulting confusion, 2001. The new venue’s name, while some- bottlenecks, and delays can be glaring. thing of a mouthful, did retain the essence Sports facilities provide additional of the fact that other teams feared playing in challenges because they are usually Denver’s thin mile-high air. Finally, in some circular and multi-level, factors that tend cases, a team can actually enhance its brand to cause people lose their bearings. by borrowing some equity from another Fortunately, sub-optimal navigation property within the facility. When the New is one of the easiest venue challenges to York Mets developed the concession plan for address. Citi Field (opened in 2009), they included an outpost of Shake Shack, an iconic New York burger joint, as part of a strategy to add a “cool factor” and expand the entertainment 8
  • 9. One solution is simply to “edit” what The main message here is exists, which, especially in older venues, tends to be an inconsistent and confusing that simplicity, consistency, accumulation of different signage and graph- and memorability are the ics systems. Starting in 1996, Tropicana Field most important elements (opened in 1990), home of MLB’s Tampa Bay Rays, undertook a complete signage over- in facility navigation. haul. To enhance the stadium’s branding, the team’s logo was incorporated into new directional signage, for example, and “old fashioned” signage designs and lettering were used to give a more historical feel to a decid- edly non-historic venue. Another approach is to create navigation icons that help people remember where they are and where they are going without using maps. At University of Phoenix Stadium in Arizona (opened in 2006), for example, the entrances feature massive number or letter sculptures to assist guests in remembering their entry/exit point. These are as much works of art as signs. Inspired by shopping malls, yet another approach is to create anchor uses as orienta- tion points. In Philadelphia, for example, Citizens Bank Park (opened in 2004), home of MLB’s Phillies, anchors its entire out- field with the Ashburn Alley entertainment area. To aid navigation of this 50,000 sq. ft, 625-foot-long area, each end has a signature eatery: “Bulls,” a BBQ joint run by a former Phillies player, and “Harry the K’s,” which honors legendary Phillies broadcaster Harry Kalas. The main message here is that simplicity, consistency, and memorability are the most important elements in facility navigation.
  • 10. 4. The Business Case for Experience Zones These days, any capital investment plan has a high burden of proof. This is especially true in sports venues, where teams have historically been able to rely on sponsors and other parties to fund their initiatives. In this section, we suggest six questions that can be useful in evaluating and building a business case for an investment in Experience Zones. 1). What are my specific objectives? enhance an asset. (Consider, for example, Finding the right solution usually starts by the fact that in Forbes Magazine’s 2009 really understanding the problem. Objectives valuations of major pro sports franchises, could include direct revenue (sponsorships), only about half of the most valuable teams indirect revenue (ticket sales, retention/ in each league are those with the highest annual renewal), event day revenues (no-show operating income. The others are those, like reduction, per-caps), guest satisfaction, and/or MLB’s Los Angeles Dodgers or the NHL’s Phila- brand enhancement. delphia Flyers, with strong national brands.) So, brand value should also be considered 2). What are my solution alternatives? among other long-term considerations. Once objectives are clearly defined, a range of possible solutions can be identified. For a 5). Does each alternative help create a point of complete analysis, the “do nothing” option difference? should also be considered, since that is Stadium- and arena-based offerings com- usually the default outcome. pete against many other forms of entertain ment, so ways to stand out in the market 3). For each alternative, what is my cash ROI? place are critical. The first source of ROI is direct revenue, in this case most likely from incremental 6). What is the longevity of each alternative? sponsorships. But it is important that a full Any venue improvement initiative consumes range of indirect revenues also be con- not only money but also management sidered. For example, can the investment time and attention. It is important that these support revenue objectives like increased investments have a long useful life, so that per caps, ticket sales, season ticket holder the problem that was solved does not re- retention, and no-show reduction? Finally, emerge in a few short years. ROI can also come from cost reduction, so the analysis should consider operational ef- ficiencies and other savings. 4). Does each alternative build asset value? In addition to cash ROI, the best invest ments also build long-term asset value. In sports, a strong brand is one clear way to 10
  • 11. 4. The Business Case for Experience Zones (cont.) Experience Zone Costs: cost and organizational implications of Costs can vary widely, of course, ongoing upkeep need to be considered. This depending on the project’s setting, nature, is particularly true when technology is in- and scope – but certain rules of thumb can volved, since the state-of-the-art changes so be useful in reaching a preliminary cost rapidly. A second caveat is specificity. Many estimate. Experience Zone costs fall into Experience Zones are built for one specific two categories: purpose or sponsor, and may be difficult to adapt to an alternate use. A final concern Hard Costss Soft Costs is distraction. Like anything, Experience Construction Planning/Design Zones can be overdone and become a dis- Fixtures Engineering Equipment Architecture traction from, rather than a complement to, Permits & Fees the game or event that should always be the Insurance focal point of the patron experience. Simple projects in an Typically an existing facility start additional 10% at roughly $100 per to 20% of the square foot. Hard Costs. A state-of-the-art Family Zone typically costs $250 to $350 per square foot. Costs can reach as high as $400 per square foot for a luxury environment. When evaluated against these criteria, Experience Zones tend to compare favorably against other alter- natives. Their ROI is usually strong be- cause up-front investment is relatively low, they are highly sponsorable, and they support indirect revenues like per caps and no-show reductions by adding to the overall event experience. Expe- rience Zones also can be good brand builders that increase asset value. Experience Zones also come with a few caveats. The first is commitment. Experience Zones need to be main- tained and periodically updated, so the
  • 12. 5. Best Practices Even the most solid business case is no guarantee of success. Rather, in our experience the most important success factor is the quality of the implementation of the ideas. As the number of Experience Zones grows and as their documentation and study im- prove, a set of best practices can be distilled. Incorporating these best practices into a project can significantly improve its quality and there- fore the likelihood of success. Start with a Master Plan Give People Something to Do, Not Just Something to See. Any venue improvements should start with a detailed definition of the objectives Too many sponsored elements at and explanation of the business case (see stadiums and arenas are just “eye candy” above) and a long-term vision. We call this a – signs, displays, or exhibits. They are Master Plan, and it can serve as an invaluable attractive, but ultimately do not really touchstone as the years pass. It can also help engage the fan. A better approach – for determine the point at which you have done venues and for sponsors – is to include “enough,” and help avoid crossing the line interactive and participatory elements as of over-commercialization and distraction. well, so that fans have something to do Finally, it can also be very valuable in and are engaged on multiple levels. maintaining the discipline of your sponsor- Script the Guest Experience ship package structuring and ensuring that you protect sponsor exclusivity to the The ultimate takeaway by every maximum extent. event patron should be fond and lasting memories. Especially in sports, where Think Engagement, not Inventory there is no control of the outcome of Value is created by fan engage- the game itself, this should not be left ment, so plan and design from the fans’ to chance. Rather, venue managers and perspective outward. Create something their tenants should work together to that fans will like and use and the value literally “script” the entire guest experi- of the inventory will take care of itself. ence from arrival to departure to ensure Have Specific Target Audiences that are many opportunities for positive memories. Don’t try to be everything to everyone. Identify subsets of your patron base with specific needs and wants, and create specific Experience Zones to serve these. Just make sure that each Zone clearly communicates its target, so that you don’t have disappointed 20-somethings in the family zone. 12
  • 13. 5. Best Practices (cont.) Be Dynamic If a guest has to look for a sign, he or she is probably already lost. Don’t let upgrades in Especially in sports, with navigation and wayfinding become after- large numbers of season ticket thoughts or victims of the budgeting process. holders, many stadiums and are- nas play host to the same people Think Like a TV Director over and over again. This creates Create icons that will look good on a risk of the “been there, done television and become signatures of your that” syndrome, where the nov- facility. Make these icons unique reflections elty of new attractions wears off of the venue’s tenants and home city. quickly. To counteract this, where possible Experience Zones should dynamic, rather than static, attrac- tions that change frequently and always offer something new. Go Beyond Logo Lock-Ups For the benefit of both the property and the sponsor, venue sponsorships should be about much more than just co-presen- tation of logos. Venues offer a unique opportunity for a true merging of brand equities. At a minimum, Experience Zones should highlight how the spon- sor is also fan of the team. Better still, use Experience Zones to bring to life the ways in which the property and the sponsor truly share brand equities. Best of all, enlist sponsors early in the process so that they have full “ownership” of the outcomes. Make it Easy to Find The best attractions serve little purpose if they are hard to find.
  • 14. 6. Next Steps Moving forward with any capital project is usually an interative process, starting with a general concept and then going through stages of refinement before finally arriving at a definitive plan. In the case of Experience Zones, we have identified four steps along this process, discussed below, along with a general estimate of the time and money involved. Step 1: Initial Analysis and Review Duration: The goal of Step 1 is to assess the Approximately one month; ideally situation and formulate a plan of ac- completed before the start of the tion. If a Master Plan already exists (see annual selling cycle. above), the initial analysis will build on that work; if not, this step can serve as Estimated Budget Range: the basis for a future Master Plan. Either $15,000 to $30,000 in Soft Costs. way, the following questions should be addressed. 1).Goals and Objectives. Why proceed? What problems will this solve and/or opportunities will it create? 2).Physical Inventory. What strengths and weaknesses does the physical space have? What spaces could be (or must be) reinvigorated or repurposed? 3). Target Audience(s). Who will be targeted? What demo graphic and/or sales data exists for these groups? What are their needs and wants? 4). Sponsorship Opportunities. What national, regional, and/or local sponsors could be integrated into the project? What are their key decision points? 14
  • 15. 6. Next Steps (cont.) Step 2: Business Case Step 3: Detailed Project Planning The goal of Step 2 is to reach a go/ The goal of Step 3 – which only takes no-go decision by presenting a detailed place if a project is approved – is to create a business case. detailed concept plan and, concurrently, a sales kit to market the opportunity to 1). Project Expense Budget. potential partners. How much will the project cost, This step is divided into two parts, one and over what time period? What of which should be contingent on sponsor financing sources are available (e.g., interest, while the other should proceed with operating budget, capital budget, “cost or without a sponsor attached. of revenue” offset to sponsorship income)? Part One: Signage and Graphics 2). Revenue Projection. 1). Signage and Graphics System. How much can the project’s sponsorship Create a system that simplifies wayfinding, inventory be sold for, and over what reduces clutter, and reinforces the brand of deal term? How will the project the venue and/or the contribute indirectly to the growth tenants. of other revenues? 2). Sponsor / Partner Integration. 3). Brand Building. Ensure that venue naming rights holders How, specifically, will the project help and other sponsors and partners are build the brand and create differentia- integrated into the system in a way that tion from the competition? maximizes their visibility. Duration: 3). Fabrication. Approximately two weeks Create the signs and graphical of work; length of approval elements. cycles will vary. 4). Installation. Estimated Budget Range: Finally, install the elements throughout the No out-of-pocket costs. facility.
  • 16. Duration: 4). Deal Terms. Negotiate final pricing and other Approximately three months; deal terms. ideally done in the off-season. Duration: Estimated Budget Range: One to three months; Soft Costs of $100,000 to ideally completed at the $500,000, depending on the start of the annual selling project scope and venue cycle. type. Hard Costs can vary widely, with a signage up- Estimated Budget Range: grade costing starting at about $100,000, while and $15,000 to $30,000 in entire signage and graphics “soft costs” per concept; system for an arena or sta- $5,000 to $10,000 per dium can cost $1.5 million to additional sales pitch. $5 million. Part Two: Experience Zone Design and Sales Unlike signage, Experience Zone elements should generally have a sponsor commiment before they are constructed. 1). Concept Development. Prepare specific Experience Zone concepts, with detailed illustrations and photo simulations. 2). Sponsor Pitches. Communicate concepts and specific spon- sorship opportunities to potential partners, using co-branded pitch documents. 3). Sponsor Integration. Once a sponsor has committed, collaborate to maximize sponsor integration, value, and brand messaging. 16
  • 17. 6. Next Steps (cont.) Step 4: Construction, Fabrication, and Installation Finally, in Step 4 the project turns to the implementation of the Experience Zones themselves. 1). Final Design. Translate concept designs into detailed, construction-ready blueprints. 2).Construction. Build (and/or demolish) as necessary to create the desired physical environment. 3). Fabrication. Create the exhibits, interactive attractions, and other Zone elements. 4). Installation. Finally, install the exhibits and attractions as well as any other fixtures or equipment. Duration: Three to six month construction period, depending on size and complexity of the project and other uses of the facility; ideally completed during the facility’s off-season. Estimated Budget Range: Construction Hard Costs of $250,000 to $2,500,000, depending on a wide range of facility- and project-specific factors.
  • 18. 7. Conclusion Decision makers grappling with For venues that embrace this level of how to enhance aging stadiums and are- commitment, however, they can be a nas have more options than they may first highly effective solution that at once think. New construction or substantial improves the guest experience and the renovation will always be tempting – and sponsorship proposition. when the economics and politics allow, We predict that Experience Zones probably the best strategy. But in most will continue to gain popularity as venue cases today, this option will simply not be managers, sports teams, public officials, on the table and more creative approach- and other interested parties address the es will be necessary. Experience Zones challenge of keeping all stadiums and are one best practice to maximize the arenas – not just the aging ones – fresh utility and value of what exists through and relevant to an increasingly distracted smart and targeted investments. public. Doing this with limited financial If conceived, built, and operated resources will make the need for creative properly, Experience Zones can generate solutions even more keen. Adopting the a measurable ROI and boost the appeal of growing body of best practices in this a venue and its tenants. Like any capital area will serve the entire industry well by improvement, they are not cheap, per se, providing additional success stories. It but their cost tends to compare favor- will also drive further innovation by rais- ably to other venue-enhancement strate- ing the bar of performance in an industry gies. Nor are they hands-off. Experience that has competition at its essence. Zones require an ongoing commitment to physical maintenance and content updates. the guest experience and the sponsorship proposition. 18