SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
TAKING CHARGE OF ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Legal Considerations in the Retention of Electronically Stored Information
Overview ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Quick Glance at the Rules ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Omnia Presumuntur Contra Spoliatorem ,[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Your job is to avoid that from ever being muttered
What is ESI? ,[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges of Managing ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Reasons to Retain ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Costs and Risks Associated with ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP You can store too much electronic information…
Retention Issues in Litigation © DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP What is a litigation hold? A communication within an organization that orders all information relating to a dispute that is the subject of  current or  ‘reasonably anticipated’  litigation be  preserved for possible production during litigation
Don’t be the Spoliator ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Failures have resulted in >$1 billion awards ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Scope: Source: FRCP 35(a ) “ Reasonably Accessible” = Discoverable
“ Reasonably Accessible” = Discoverable ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Standard:
What ESI is Reasonably Accessible? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Courts determine what is ‘reasonably accessible’ by balancing the following considerations:
What ESI is Reasonably Accessible? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Continued… Sampling of ESI may be required to gauge the likelihood of finding relevant information.
Safe Harbor from Sanctions   © DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Absent exceptional circumstances, a court may not impose sanctions under these rules on a party for failing to provide ESI lost as a result of the routine, good-faith operation of an electronic information system. FRCP 37(f)
Ten steps to a routine, good-faith operation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP
Conclusion: Take Charge of ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],© DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP

More Related Content

What's hot

Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowElectronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowEd Sothcott
 
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfSecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfJames Arlen
 
CTIN EDiscovery
CTIN EDiscoveryCTIN EDiscovery
CTIN EDiscoveryCTIN
 
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfDEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfJames Arlen
 
E-Discovery and Electronic Evidence
E-Discovery and Electronic EvidenceE-Discovery and Electronic Evidence
E-Discovery and Electronic Evidencewcodell
 
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...Knobbe Martens - Intellectual Property Law
 
Chapter 12 twelve issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2
Chapter 12 twelve  issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2Chapter 12 twelve  issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2
Chapter 12 twelve issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2difordham
 
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for Success
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for SuccessE-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for Success
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for SuccessInnoTech
 
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)Peter Michaelson
 
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...SHIMOKAJI IP
 
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South America
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South AmericaNew Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South America
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South AmericaCédric Laurant
 
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?Resilient Systems
 
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2Bryan Beel
 
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation Prall
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation PrallWhat Can Be Done Ip Litigation Prall
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation PrallCardinaleWay Mazda
 

What's hot (18)

Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to KnowElectronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
Electronic Discovery - GODWIN PC - What you Need to Know
 
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfSecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
SecTor 2009 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
 
CTIN EDiscovery
CTIN EDiscoveryCTIN EDiscovery
CTIN EDiscovery
 
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing YourselfDEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
DEFCON17 - Your Mind: Legal Status, Rights and Securing Yourself
 
E-Discovery and Electronic Evidence
E-Discovery and Electronic EvidenceE-Discovery and Electronic Evidence
E-Discovery and Electronic Evidence
 
Michael Legg
Michael LeggMichael Legg
Michael Legg
 
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...
The PTAB May Be Taking a More Balanced Approach in Biotech and Pharmaceutical...
 
Chapter 12 twelve issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2
Chapter 12 twelve  issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2Chapter 12 twelve  issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2
Chapter 12 twelve issues in electronic discovery civ lit 2
 
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for Success
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for SuccessE-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for Success
E-Discovery: The Path, The Perils, and a Plan for Success
 
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)
ABA_LAND_v007n06__patent_arbitration_it_still_makes_good_sense(re-print)
 
RIM In Law Firm Environment
RIM In Law Firm EnvironmentRIM In Law Firm Environment
RIM In Law Firm Environment
 
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...
Document Retention Policies Intersect Electronic Discovery Obligations - by M...
 
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South America
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South AmericaNew Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South America
New Data Protection Laws and Case Law Trends in Central & South America
 
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?
CT, HI & VT - Oh My! What Do the Latest Privacy Regulations Mean to You?
 
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2
Patent Law Review - IP Year in Review CLE v2
 
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation Prall
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation PrallWhat Can Be Done Ip Litigation Prall
What Can Be Done Ip Litigation Prall
 
June's ARTICLES
June's ARTICLESJune's ARTICLES
June's ARTICLES
 
Totto meeting memo
Totto meeting memoTotto meeting memo
Totto meeting memo
 

Similar to Managing Electronically Stored Information

Document Retention And Destruction Power Point
Document Retention And Destruction Power PointDocument Retention And Destruction Power Point
Document Retention And Destruction Power Pointlnarvid
 
EDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery PresentationEDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery Presentationscubastog
 
Proportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in EdiscoveryProportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in EdiscoveryJosh Kubicki
 
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?CallPM
 
Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.Bill Daniels
 
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competence
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-CompetenceLaw, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competence
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competencejcassd619
 
E Discovery General E Discovery Presentation
E Discovery General E Discovery PresentationE Discovery General E Discovery Presentation
E Discovery General E Discovery Presentationjvanacour
 
Electric Insurance ESI Planning
Electric Insurance   ESI PlanningElectric Insurance   ESI Planning
Electric Insurance ESI PlanningJohn Jablonski
 
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Brendan Kenny
 
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008Seth Row
 
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby DrakeDBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby DrakeKlemchuk LLP
 
Total Evidence White Paper
Total Evidence White PaperTotal Evidence White Paper
Total Evidence White PaperKevin Featherly
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizurerlhicksjr
 
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-Discovery
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-DiscoveryThe Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-Discovery
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-DiscoveryDan Michaluk
 
Amcto presentation final
Amcto presentation finalAmcto presentation final
Amcto presentation finalDan Michaluk
 
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008John Jablonski
 
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breachesacfesj
 
Electronic Document Retention And Legal Holds
Electronic Document Retention And Legal HoldsElectronic Document Retention And Legal Holds
Electronic Document Retention And Legal HoldsJohn Jablonski
 

Similar to Managing Electronically Stored Information (20)

Document Retention And Destruction Power Point
Document Retention And Destruction Power PointDocument Retention And Destruction Power Point
Document Retention And Destruction Power Point
 
EDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery PresentationEDiscovery Presentation
EDiscovery Presentation
 
Proportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in EdiscoveryProportionality in Ediscovery
Proportionality in Ediscovery
 
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
Who's Afraid of eDiscovery?
 
Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.Class Action Seminar.
Class Action Seminar.
 
E Discovery
E DiscoveryE Discovery
E Discovery
 
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competence
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-CompetenceLaw, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competence
Law, Ethics & Technology: e-Discovery and e-Competence
 
E Discovery General E Discovery Presentation
E Discovery General E Discovery PresentationE Discovery General E Discovery Presentation
E Discovery General E Discovery Presentation
 
Electric Insurance ESI Planning
Electric Insurance   ESI PlanningElectric Insurance   ESI Planning
Electric Insurance ESI Planning
 
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
 
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008
Powerpoint For Delete! Litigation Risk Management Seminars, H&K Llp, Fall 2008
 
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby DrakeDBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
DBA Presentation On E-Discovery by Kirby Drake
 
Total Evidence White Paper
Total Evidence White PaperTotal Evidence White Paper
Total Evidence White Paper
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
 
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-Discovery
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-DiscoveryThe Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-Discovery
The Sedona Canada Panel on Privacy and E-Discovery
 
Amcto presentation final
Amcto presentation finalAmcto presentation final
Amcto presentation final
 
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008
Legal Hold Workshop - ARMA International - Las Vegas - Oct 23, 2008
 
E discovery 101
E discovery 101E discovery 101
E discovery 101
 
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches
08/19/2010 Meeting - Litigation Holds and Security Breaches
 
Electronic Document Retention And Legal Holds
Electronic Document Retention And Legal HoldsElectronic Document Retention And Legal Holds
Electronic Document Retention And Legal Holds
 

Managing Electronically Stored Information

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10. Retention Issues in Litigation © DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP What is a litigation hold? A communication within an organization that orders all information relating to a dispute that is the subject of current or ‘reasonably anticipated’ litigation be preserved for possible production during litigation
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Safe Harbor from Sanctions © DuBois, Bryant & Campbell LLP Absent exceptional circumstances, a court may not impose sanctions under these rules on a party for failing to provide ESI lost as a result of the routine, good-faith operation of an electronic information system. FRCP 37(f)
  • 18.
  • 19.

Editor's Notes

  1. Email Application files Voice mail Instant messages Web pages Within your organization’s IT System hard drives, laptops, servers, voice mail, back-up systems Outside of your organization’s IT System home computers, cell phones, pda’s, flash drives, the internet…
  2. RESULTING IN
  3. A litigation hold is a communication within an organization ordering that all information relating to a dispute that is the subject of current or reasonably anticipated litigation be preserved for possible production in the litigation.
  4. Profile ESI and relevant communication and storage system infrastructure Assess infrastructure needs and automated software tools Develop storage strategy that is consistent with RMP