5. Background—IOP approach:
A farming production system is viewed
as a whole across years.
Several parameters are studied
simultaneously or in close sequence by
researchers of varying disciplines.
Social and ecological components are
encouraged.
13. Methods—Test yield performance in replicated trials
State Variety
Trials at four
research
stations on
organic land
allowing
comparison to
conventional
trials
18. Conclusions—Yield effects of Common Bunt
Yield loss from susceptibility to the
seed born disease, common bunt, was
observed only in the organic plots
because seed was not treated.
Conditions for common bunt
apparently did not materialize in the
years before the susceptible line was
entered in the State Variety Trial.
26. Multiple Years
2009 Organic 2008 Organic
Conventional
Baystate Heartland UNL UNL USDA/ARS
Results: 4-location Composite Samples
4-location
Composite
Samples
2-location
Composite
Samples
4-location Many Locations
Quality Mill Mix and Bake Alveograph Mix and Bake Mill
Mix
and
Bake
Mill
Mix
and
Bake
2008 Red
Red
Red
15
9
17
HATCHER
CAMELOT
NE03490
HATCHER
CAMELOT
NE03490
HATCHER
CAMELOT
NE03490
6
5
5
5
5
5
AVE VG
and
Red 15 WAHOO WAHOO WAHOO 6 5 AVE AVE
Red 13 GOODSTREAK GOODSTREAK GOODSTREAK 4 4 G P
Red 19 PRONGHORN PRONGHORN PRONGHORN 6 7 G VG
Red 18 BUCKSKIN BUCKSKIN BUCKSKIN 7 5
2009 White
White
White
21
20
11
CLARKSCREAM
DANBY
ARROWSMITH
CLARKSCREAM
DANBY
ARROWSMITH
CLARKSCREAM
DANBY
ARROWSMITH 5 6
AVE
G G
P
vs. White
Red
Red
23
22
18
ALICE
KARL92
DARRELL
ALICE
KARL92
DARRELL
ALICE
KARL92
DARRELL
6
5
6
5
G
G
G
VG
VG
G
USDA
Red 22 NE99495 NE99495 NE99495 5 5 P G
Red 23 WESLEY WESLEY WESLEY 5 7 G VG
Red 24 ALLIANCE ALLIANCE ALLIANCE 6 5 P G
Red 17 MILLENNIUM MILLENNIUM MILLENNIUM 5 6 G G
Red 13 OVERLAND OVERLAND OVERLAND 5 3 AVE VP
Red 16 SD05118 SD05118 SD05118 AVE G
White 15 NW03681 NW03681 NW03681 6 7 VG G
Red 16 NE04424 NE04424 NE04424 5 6
Red 18 NE01481 NE01481 NE01481 4 5 VP VG
Red 21 NE05548 NE05548 NE05548
Red 24 NE05425 NE05425 NE05425
White 15 ANTELOPE ANTELOPE ANTELOPE 4 6 P G
27. Conclusions—Bread Quality
Overland and Goodstreak should not be planted if the target market is for
making bread.
Karl 92 is reliable for bread quality mainly because of its high protein content.
Before considering planting NE01481 (a potential release) or Antelope, the
record of poor milling should be discussed with the grain buyer and end-user.
Other experimental lines require more data.
Milling and baking quality of Darrell, Wesley, and Millennium have been
acceptable from most environments.
The
other named varieties, except Alliance, can make a good loaf of bread if
grown in an environment that is likely to produce moderate to high protein.
28. Methods
Workshops for organic farm groups
OCIA, two chapters and International Conferences
Annual Research Farm Tours
Annual Organic Wheat Conference
Jan. 2009—Mead, focusing on Eastern Nebraska
Dec. 2009—Ogallala, focusing on Western Nebraska
Websites
Cropwatch: ‘Variety Testing’ and ‘Organic’
http://organic.unl.edu/wheat/wheat.shtml
30. Example: Misconceptions and barriers identified
OCIA in previous conversations:
seminar
• Some organic farmers believe that a
variety ‘adapts’ to their farms over
time; therefore they continue to grow
the same variety year after year.
• Organic farmers have been led to
think that new germplasm lacks the
genetic background for adaptation to
organic farms.
36. Results:
OCIA • Hopefully corrected some
seminar misconceptions and gained respect
for our method of introducing
variation through crossing.
• Validated some aspects of
farmers’ viewpoints to provide
room for dialogue
37.
38. Methods: Screen in Breeding Nurseries
in addition to State Variety Trials
Three generations
on organic plots
at two locations:
F6
F7
F8-9 Interstate
Nursery
Sidney and Mead
39. Methods—Gaining Input
• Advisors and conference panelists
provide direction for production traits.
• End-users who test varieties from
organic trials contribute to quality
targets discussion.
40. Results—Traits important to organic farmers
• Tall for residue cover
Specific to
Western
Nebraska: • Drought tolerant
• Long coleoptile for planting deep
42. Results—Traits important to organic farmers
Specific to • Resistance to seed-born disease:
Eastern • Common bunt
Nebraska
• Early vigor and canopy cover
• Sprouting resistance
47. Tests added to breeding program:
Whole Wheat Tests:
• Sedimentation
• Digestible Fiber
• Antioxidants
Competitiveness
with weeds
48. Kelloggs
Total Digestible Fiber
Results: Winners Overall:
Karl 92***
Fiber Darrell
Wesley
for Millennium
White
Sidney NE04424
NE01481
2009
Also of note: White
Overland
ClarksCream
50. Preliminary Phenols for Sidney, 21 Varieties
Results 0.9000
0.8000
0.7000
0.6000
Anti- 0.5000
0.4000
Total
Phenols
oxidants
0.3000
0.2000
Total
2008
0.1000
Flavonoids
0.0000
• White varieties Arrowsmith, Antelope and Anton plus the red varieties
Darrell and Mace tested low for total phenols. This study must be redone.
51. Results Phenols Across Four Locations, 12 Varieties
0.7000
0.6000
Anti- 0.5000
0.4000
Total
oxidants 0.3000
0.2000
Phenols
2008 0.1000
Total
Flavonoids
0.0000
• For total phenols, Wahoo stood out. The white varieties, Alice and
NW03681 were significantly lower, but had a higher percentage of flavonoids.
52. Conclusions—Value-added Quality Traits
White varieties are unlikely to be singled out for high
antioxidants or high digestible fiber.
• Clarks Cream may be an exception for digestible fiber, but
hasn’t been tested for antioxidants.
64. Conclusions—Agronomic Traits
Veryfew tall and long-coleoptile lines are
available in the pipeline.
No outstanding lines for cover in 2008.
Lineswith good yield performance like Wahoo
and NE3490 might not be marketable because of
consistently low test weight.
65. Further Research— Wheat Germplasm Development
Evaluate tall crosses between Oklahoma elite
lines and Australian lines with long coleoptiles
and drought resistance.
Introgress traits for soft endosperm and
winterhardiness to obtain lines for the breakfast
cereal market.
See next slide for photos of representative germplasm
66. Further Research— Wheat Germplasm Development
[Chuan-Mai 18/2*Westonia (RHT8)]/Duster//OK07S130W: Ulianovka:
Tall, Long Coleoptile, increased root density (?), Soft Endosperm,
Drought resistant (?), vigorous (?) Winterhardiness
70. Experiments to Optimize Wheat in the Rotation
1. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
Haskell
2. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Sidney 3. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
71. 1. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment, 2008
Methods Top-dress State Variety Trial:
• 2 reps sprayed with Summit 10
Haskell • 2 reps without spray
• 2008—split application at early jointing and
three weeks later for a total of 14 lbs N/acre
• 2009—one application at early boot stage
with 20 lbs N/acre
72. 1. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
Results: Grain Protein Content
2008 2009
Haskell Without With Without With
Summit 10 Summit 10
average 10.2 10.4 10.5 11.2
LSD (.05) 0.1 0.1
• Significant differences were also detected among varieties
for response to the top-dressing treatment.
76. 2. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Results: Yields
• Wheat averaged less following alfalfa (53.8 bu/acre)
than following corn (57.4 bu/acre), possibly from
Haskell competition for moisture by alfalfa re-growth.
• Fall manure application resulted in 7 bu/acre more than
spring or no manure applications.
• Late spring manure application damaged the crop and
reduced yields by 5 bu/acre compared to the no manure
fall application.
77. 2. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Results: Grain Protein Content
Haskell • not affected by manure rate.
• increased from 13.3 to 13.7% for the later
timing.
• increased from 13.3 to 13.6% for the higher N
top-dressing rate.
78. Experiments to Optimize Wheat in the Rotation
1. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
Haskell
2. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Sidney 3. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
79. 3. Preliminary Protein Enhancement Experiment
Results: Grain Protein Content (%)
2008 2009
Sidney Without With
Summit
10
Average 11.7 12.0
LSD (.05) 0.4
• No significant differences were detected among
varieties for response to the top-dressing treatment.
80. 4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009-10
Methods:
Treatments:
N = Summit 10
Manure:
• 0
• 5
• 10 tons/acre
Fallow:
• with pea disked
• without peas
81. 4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Wheat yield, moisture and testweight
Results: following green manure and black fallow
Treatment Grain Yield Grain Test Weight
bu./acre Moisture lbs./bu
Sidney %
Green Manure 44.2 b 12.8 a 56.6 b
Black Fallow 47.5 a 10.8 b 60.6 a
All means are statistically different at the 5 % probability level
82. 4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Results: Grain Protein Content
• Very few treatment differences among
composted manure, green manure or Summit
Ten top-dressing.
Sidney
• Grain Protein averaged 12.1% for all
treatments.
• This protein level is well above the
threshold for bread market acceptance.
83. 4. Cover Crop/Fertility Experiment, 2009
Results: Nitrogen Removal
• Nitrogen removal was 76.5 and 82.5 lb/acre
following green manure and black fallow,
respectively.
Sidney
• There was no difference in nitrogen removal
rates between composted manure and Summit
Ten treatments
84. Conclusions:
Grain protein was affected somewhat by treatments
in the eastern environment but not in the more arid
western environment.
Haskell represented perfectly the targeted N-
deficient environment. Protein levels at Sidney were
above the market threshold because of dry conditions
and adequate soil nitrogen fortification during previous
years of the rotation.
Benefits of treatments may require several years to
be realized in the semi-arid environment because of
slow mineralization rates particularly in dry years.
85.
86. Experiments to Optimize Wheat in the Rotation
1. Flaming Wheat as Cover Crop or Grain Crop
Haskell
2. Suppression of Cover Crops after Wheat
88. 1. Flaming of wheat as cover crop or as grain crop
60
a) SES
50 b) FNS
c) BS
40 43 %
Yield Loss (%)
30
32 %
20
25 %
10
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
!1
Propane rate (kg ha )
89. 1. Flaming of wheat as cover crop or as grain crop
Conclusions:
95. 2. Suppression of Cover Crops after Winter Wheat
The roller does not work well when
Conclusions: the cover crop is dry.
Flaming only worked a bit better.
Yield performance of corn and
soybeans after winter kill of cover crops
following winter wheat is acceptable.
102. Further Research— Cropping Systems
Haskell—test promising wheat lines in low
and high nitrogen environments.
Clay Center (irrigated)—crimp an early
maturing triticale before soybeans.
At Sidney—annual medic (Medicago
rigidula) green manure in place of peas.
East locations—use hooded flamer to control
weeds in soybeans.
103. Further Research— Cropping Systems
In the final year, we will take systems
developed with appropriate varieties to organic
farms in each ecoregion for further testing and
refinement.
104. Dr. Stephen Baenziger, Small Grains Breeding
Lincoln Dr. Vicki Schlegel, Food Science
Dr. Stephen Wegulo, Plant Pathology
Dr. Teshome Regassa, State Variety Trial Testing
Richard Little, Breeding Specialist and Coordinator
Dr. Drew Lyon, Cropping Systems and Site Co-Manager
HPAL
Dr. Dipak Santra, Alternative Crops and Co-Manager
Vernon Florke, Organic Field Technician
Mead ARDC Dr. James Brandle, Forestry and Site Manager
Mike Cieslik, Organic Field Technician
Dr. Charles Shapiro, Soil Fertility and Site Manager
Haskell Dr. Stevan Knezevic, Weed Science
Mike Mainz, Field Technologist
Liz Sarno, Organic Extension Educator
Santiago Ulloa, Graduate Student
Dr. Bob Wright, Entomology and Site Manager
Clay Center
Ryan Gerloff, Organic Field Technician