Axel G. Posluschny: Networking Remote Sensing in Archaeology: Fostering Methods and Knowledge in Europe and Beyond - From International Associations Scattering Towards Globalization
Presentation at the Pacific Neighborhood Congress, Space2Place session, Berkeley/CA, 9/12/2012
1. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Networking Remote Sensing in
Archaeology: Fostering Methods and Knowledge in
Europe and Beyond
---
From International Associations Scattering
Towards Globalization
Dr. Axel G. Posluschny M.A.
ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Roman-Germanic Commission of the
German Archaeological Institute
Palmengartenstr. 10-12
D-60325 Frankfurt
posluschny@rgk.dainst.de
www.archaeolandscapes.eu
2. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Content
• Remote Sensing & Surveying for Cultural
Heritage Management
• Knowledge, Expertise and their Distribution
• ArchaeoLandscapes Europe Network
introduction
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
3. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Landscape Archaeology & Invisible Sites
http://www.aegypten-spezialist.de/uploads/pics/gizeh-cheops-sphinx.jpg http://www.online-reisefuehrer.com/bilder-reisen/tuerkei/ephesos.jpg
introduction – RS for CHM & research
http://www.zum.de/Faecher/G/BW/Landeskunde/w3/provence/vienne/augustus1.jpg http://www.ohiotraveler.com/images/serpent%20mound.jpg
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
4. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Beyond the Fascination of the Visible
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
5. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Beyond the Meaning of the Visible
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Cowley et al. 2010
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
6. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Non-invasive Methods for Research
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
7. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Visualisation – Public outreach & Lobby
Building
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
8. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
RS Data & Visualisations for the Public
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
9. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
RS Data & Visualisations for the Public
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
10. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
RS Data & Visualisations for the Public
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
11. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
RS Data & Visualisations for the Public
introduction – RS for CHM & research
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
12. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Expert Knowledge
• Remote Sensing needs expert knowledge
• RS is more than just pushing buttons
• RS is more than buying data or even worse, their
interpretation
• Archaeologists often pay (technical) experts to do remote sensing for
them
• What they get as a result/product is often a filtered interpretation,
knowledge, expertise & distribution
based on the technicians experience
• They don’t get the real data and even if so, many archaeologists
wouldn’t be able to deal with that
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
13. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Knowledge and its Spread
• Expert knowledge about RS is not evenly distributed amongst
archaeologists in Europe, nor world-wide
• Acquiring RS data as well as dealing with that data in a
sufficient way is not being taught with the same intensity and
on a regular basis at universities all over Europe
knowledge, expertise & distribution
• There is still a lack of education in these methods in many parts of
Europe and also in the rest of the world
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
14. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
ArchaeoLandscape Europe is supported by the
EU within the framework of the Culture 2007-
2013 programme
• Agreement Number: 2010-1486
• Start: 15th September 2010
• End: 14th September 2015
• EU Advancement: 2,5 Mio €
• Total Budget: 5 Mio €
• Partner Institutions: 61(at present)
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Project Leadership: Roman-Germanic Commission of
the German Archaeological Institute
Roman-Germanic Commission www.archaeolandscapes.eu
15. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
61 Project Partner from all over Europe and Beyond
Coordinator/Project Leader 3. Estonian Heritage Society (EE)
1. Roman-Germanic Commission, German Archaeological Institut (DE) 4. Aalto University School of Science and Technology (FI)
5. National Museum of the Faroe Islands (FO)
Co-organisers:
6. Université de Franche Comté (FR)
1. In Flanders Fields Museum, Belgium (BE)
2. Cyprus Research and Education Foundation (STARC) (CY) 7. University of Applied Sciences - i3mainz (DE)
3. Holstebro Museum (DK) 8. University of Bamberg (DE)
4. State Heritage Service Baden-Wü rttemberg (DE) 9. University of Frankfurt (DE)
5. Institute for Mediterranean Studies (FORTH) (GR) 10. Aerial Archaeology Research Group (international)
6. Baranya County Museum Authority (HU) 11. Culture Lab - International Cultural Expertise (BE)
7. Institute of Archaeology (IS) 12. Dutch Expertise Centre for Archaeological Remote Sensing (NL/BE)
8. Discovery Programme (IE)
13. Dundalk Institute of Technology (IE)
9. University College Dublin (IE)
10. University of Foggia (IT) 14. Latvian Academy of Culture (LV)
11. University of Salento (LabTAF), Lecce (IT) 15. University of Granada (ES)
12. University of Siena (LAP&T) (IT) 16. University of Uppsala (SE)
13. University of Klaipeda (LT) 17. University of Ulster (IE)
14. University of Leiden (NL) 18. Landscape & Geophysical Services (IE)
15. Norwegian Institute for Cultural Heritage Research (NIKU) (NO) 19. Macquarie University, NSW (AU)
16. Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań (PL)
20. The DART Project - University of Leeds (UK)
17. Institute for Cultural Memory (CIMEC) (RO)
18. Institute of Archaeology (RS) 21. Leuven University (BE)
19. Slovak Academy of Sciences (SK) 22. Department of Earth and Environment of the Italian National
20. Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts (ZRC SAZU) (SI) Research Council (IT)
ArchaeoLandscapes network
21. University of Ljubljana (SI) 23. University of Zagreb (HR)
22. Instituto de Estudos Galeos Padre Sarmiento (ES) 24. VU Amsterdam (NL)
23. English Heritage (UK) 25. Moesgaard Museum (DK)
24. University of Exeter (UK) 26. The Rathcroghan Heritage Centre (IE)
25. University of Glasgow (UK)
27. The Landscape Research Centre (UK)
26. Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland
(UK) 28. Polytechnic Institute of Tomar University (PT)
29. ArchaeoPhysica (UK)
Associated Partners: 30. University of Bologna (IT)
1. University of Vienna (AT) 31. Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NO)
2. University of West Bohemia (CZ) 32. Szczecin University - Institute of History and International Relations,
Department of Archaeology (PL)
33. University of California, Merced (USA)
34. Cyprus University of Technology (CY)
...
Roman-Germanic Commission www.archaeolandscapes.eu
16. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Project Aims
• "To increase public appreciation, understanding and
conservation .....
– of the landscape and archaeological heritage
– of Europe ....
– through the application and international sharing of skills
ArchaeoLandscapes network
and experience ....
• in airborne and other forms of remote sensing"
Roman-Germanic Commission www.archaeolandscapes.eu
17. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
A busy 5-year Programme ...
• Create a self-supporting ArchaeoLandscapes Network Europe
• Communicate the value of aerial survey, remote sensing and
landscape studies
• Promote the pan-European exchange of people, skills and
experience
• Enhance teaching in aerial survey, remote sensing and
landscape studies
• Exploit existing air-photo archives more effectively
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Support aerial survey, remote sensing and landscape exploration
• Explore laser, satellite and other forms of remote sensing to a
larger extent
• Provide technical guidance and advice on best practice
Roman-Germanic Commission www.archaeolandscapes.eu
18. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Networking and Collaborating
• Building a network of experts
• Teaching with workshops & schools
• Sharing knowledge via publications, website and exchange
visits
• Supporting students & young scholars
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Raising awareness for both the archaeological experts and
the laymen
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
19. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Addressing the Archaeological Community
• Technical Workshops: LiDAR, Aerial Archaeology, Geophysics, Satellite
Imagery, UAV, Integrated Data Analyses, …
• Aerial Archaeology Training Schools
• 2 International Conferences (2013 Dublin, 2015 Frankfurt)
• Symposia, Workshops, Meetings, Conference Sessions, ...
• Publications (2 Monographs, Flyer, Conference Papers, Best Practices
ArchaeoLandscapes network
Guides, ...)
• Website http://www.archaeolandscapes.eu (the site will be updated
continuously during the 3 coming years of the project)
• Grants for Students and Young Researchers to participate in Workshops,
Schools and Conferences
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
20. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Addressing the Public
• Travelling exhibition, starting on 8th May 2013 in Dublin
• Conference about RS & Community Archaeology as a
starting event for the travelling exhibition (8th – 11th May 2013
in Dublin)
• Website http://www.archaeolandscapes.eu (the site will be
updated continuously during the 3 coming years of the
project)
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Flyer, sticker
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
21. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Addressing the Public
• Newspaper, radio & TV interviews:
• Spiegel Online: http://www.spiegel.de/international/zeitgeist/remote-
scanning-techniques-revolutionize-archaeology-a-846793.html -
copied or used as the basis for other articles:
• http://videnskab.dk/teknologi/flyvende-lasere-afslorer-begravede-
fortidsminder (DK)
• http://www.niburu.nl/archeologie/vliegende-lasers-sporen-ondergrondse-
bouwwerken-op.html (NL)
• Politiken (DK)
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• http://nachrichten.t-online.de/fliegender-laser-verraet-verschuettete-
bauten/id_58398140/index (DE)
• http://yle.fi/radio1/kulttuuri/kultakuume/ => Kun hakku ja lapio eivä t
enä ä riitä (FI)
• Planned: TV documentaries about RS in archaeology
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
22. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Previous Activities
• Technical Workshops:
• Bibracte/FR – LiDAR
• Slane/IE – Geophysics, kite photography, data integration
• Poznan/PL – satellite & aerial images
• Klaipeda/LT – geophysics
• Ljubljana/SL – 3D data
• Rethymno/GR – geophysics, satellite & aerial images
• Aerial Archaeology Training Schools:
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Kostolac/RS
• Velling/DK
• Merida/ES
• Pilsen/CZ
• Kocaeli/TR
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
23. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Previous Activities
• Symposia, Workshops, Meetings, Conference Sessions:
• CAA 2012, Southampton – ArcLand session
• EAA 2011, Oslo – ArcLand session
• EAA 2012, Helsinki – ArcLand session
• UNESCO Best Practice Conference 2012, Menorca – 3 ArcLand
related papers
• ESOF – European Science Open Forum 2012, Dublin – ArcLand
session
• …
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Publications (2 Monographs in print, Flyer, Conference Papers)
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
24. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Previous Activities
• Grants for Students and Young Researchers to participate in
Workshops, Schools and Conferences
• 43 grants have been paid from ArcLand:
• 19 for aerial archaeological training schools
• 16 for technical workshops
• 6 exchange visits / mobility grants
• 2 conference grants
ArchaeoLandscapes network
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
25. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Future Activities
• Technical Workshops:
• Belgrade/RS – Archiving questions
• Bamberg/DE – Airphoto interpretation
• Rathcroghan/IE – Geophysics, LiDAR, data integration
• Esslingen/DE – LiDAR
• Montferrand/FR – LiDAR
• Aerial Archaeology Training Schools:
• Leuven/BE
ArchaeoLandscapes network
• Pecs/HU
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
26. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Measuring Impact (?)
• Webpage hits – estimated number of visits until the end of the
project: 15,000
• number of visits by September 2012: 20,600 !!!
ArchaeoLandscapes network
2 main peaks:
•start of the Facebook page in January
•Spiegel Online article in late July
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
27. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Measuring Distribution
ArchaeoLandscapes network
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
28. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Resume
• Knowing that the use of all modern RS techniques and
methods need skill, expertise and experience and being
aware of the fact that these factors are not evenly distributed
all over Europe (as well as in the rest of the world), the
ArchaeoLandscapes Europe project, supported by the EU
Culture 2007–2013 programme, aims for a better
understanding and a more excessive use of modern
archaeological surveying techniques as well as for an
exchange of people, working in these fields, their expertise
and of new ideas.
• Moreover, we think that involving the public in various ways is
conclusion
an important aspect of our work, fostering an understanding
as well as public support for archaeological remote sensing.
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
29. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
Further information
If you want to know more about the project and
the various (future) activities, opportunities and
so on, visit our website
http://www.archaeolandscapes.eu
arcland
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
30. ArchaeoLandscapes Europe
posluschny@rgk.dainst.de
Thank you very much for your attention
Roman-Germanic Commission of the German Archaeological Institute www.archaeolandscapes.eu
Notas del editor
Dear colleagues, First of all I would like to thank the organisers of this meeting for the invitation and the opportunity to present the ArcLand project that I am currently working for. Prospection in all its various forms, has always been one of the major sources for archaeological knowledge. Especially aerial archeology has been of greater importance since crop marks, soils marks and so on became recognized as hints to former human remains and landscape artifacts. These methods have been supplemented by the growing application of computer or otherwise technologically based prospection methods like geophysics, LiDAR or satellite imagery. For your better understanding: When I talk about Remote Sensing I include geophysics as well, though of course one could argue that these techniques are not remote at all but to make things a bit easier I define these contactless methods as remote as well
This meeting aims not to discuss technologies – in which you all are far more experienced than I am – but to focus on modern technologies and their impact on the conservation and communication of cultural heritage. To cite the invitation from Stefano and Maurizio: “ Networking and education at global scale of remote sensing in archaeology will also be a main topic of the conference. ” So I will give a very very brief overview about RS for cultural heritage before I will talk about certain aspects of knowledge distribution which form the background for the introduction to the ArchaeoLandscapes Europe project.
Before I started to work for ArcLand, I was involved in a number of landscape archaeological investigations – in fact I would call myself a landscape archaeologist. This is the background for my understanding of what I do now as well – seeing archaeological prospection and remote sensing as tools for landscape archaeology. But of course these things are also tools for site based research, conservation, documentation and so on – especially when we deal with all those invisible things that seem to be far less attractive or at least far less visible than the things that the general public thinks of when hearing the word “ archaeology ”
Making things visible is one of the main aims of remote sensing but making things visible is not only necessary for archaeologists who investigate a site or a landscape or for cultural heritage managers who aim to protect sites and landscapes – it can also be crucial to raise awareness for a specific site or for cultural heritage in general amongst the public.
Satellite images or LiDAR make it possible to monitor landscapes or to find the archaeological features that have to be protected before a looter can find it.
I am not going to preach to the converted – you all know what remote sensing, geophysics and other prospection methods can bring for archaeological research, for the investigation of a site, for the understanding of a landscape and its development over a period of thousands of years.
But remote sensing can do more than that, remote sensing can produce aesthetic pictures which attract people, which combine 2 things that many people have a positive connotation with – archaeology and high tech. We can explain things that are hard to understand as they are not visible and we can make them even interesting – for our colleagues as well as for the public, for those that we collaborate with as well as for those that pay our wages with their taxes.
Geophysics, LiDAR and aerial images can be simply nice to see, but they can also be speaking – speaking also for those that are not archaeological experts.
Google Earth has brought a totally new tool, a tool that not only archaeologists can use and understand but which also is of interest for the public. The picture of a gigantic earthwork like this one here in Romania (the length of the red line is about 2800 m) shows the fascination of remote sensing even when it is done from an arm chair.
And of course LiDAR with its ability to look beyond the forest canopy is still not just a useful tool but it also creates astonishing effects both for the experts and the laymen
as this example from an early Iron Age hillfort in the Czech republic shows
The big problem is, that Remote Sensing needs a lot of expert knowledge. RS is more than just pushing buttons, moreover, it ’ s more than buying data or even worse, their interpretation. Archaeologists like me – and in this case I am excluding people like you here in the audience who all are technical experts as well – often pay (technical) experts to do remote sensing for them. What they get as a result/product is often a filtered interpretation, based on the technicians experience. They don ’ t get the real data and even if so, many archaeologists wouldn ’ t be able to deal with that
Expert knowledge about RS is not evenly distributed amongst archaeologists in Europe, nor world-wide Acquiring RS data as well as dealing with that data in a sufficient way is not being taught with the same intensity and on a regular basis at universities all over Europe There is still a lack of education in these methods in many parts of Europe and also in the rest of the world
Based on the experience that the knowledge and the use of landscape archaeology in general and modern surveying techniques in particular are not evenly distributed all over Europe we have created the ArchaeoLandscapes Europe project, short ArcLand . Wit a budget of 5 Million Euros all in all (which more or less equals to 6.5 Million US Dollars) we aim to equal these differences and to develop a self-sustaining network that will carry on with this task even beyond the project ’ s life span of 5 years.
The project consortium so far consists of 61 partner institutions from all over Europe as well as one partner from Australia and one from the USA. These partners represent experts in various fields of remote sensing, geophysics, aerial archaeology, GIS and so on and also partners that act as network hubs in their country or region to act as a multiplicator of knowledge and expertise.
To cite the words of our project application, we aim "To increase public appreciation, understanding and conservation ..... of the landscape and archaeological heritage of Europe .... through the application and international sharing of skills and experience .... in airborne and other forms of remote sensing ”
The project consist of a number of so-called actions or work packages. We want to … Create a self-supporting ArchaeoLandscapes Network Europe Communicate the value of aerial survey, remote sensing and landscape studies Promote the pan-European exchange of people, skills and experience Enhance teaching in aerial survey, remote sensing and landscape studies Exploit existing air-photo archives more effectively Support aerial survey, remote sensing and landscape exploration Explore laser, satellite and other forms of remote sensing to a larger extent Provide technical guidance and advice on best practice
We want to reach our aims by a number of activities: We do not find it necessary to preach to the converted, but we think that building up a network of experts is a very important aspect of our work. Teaching with workshops & schools Sharing knowledge via publications, website and exchange visits Supporting students & young scholars Raising awareness for both the archaeological experts and the laymen
ArcLand is a project both for the experts and for the interested laymen. Our activities that address the archaeological community consist of: Technical Workshops: LiDAR, Aerial Archaeology, Geophysics, Satellite Imagery, UAV, Integrated Data Analyses, … Aerial Archaeology Training Schools 2 International Conferences (2013 Dublin, 2015 Frankfurt) Symposia, Workshops, Meetings, Conference Sessions, ... Publications (2 Monographs, Flyer, Conference Papers, Best Practices Guides, ...) Website http://www.archaeolandscapes.eu (the site will be updated continuously during the 3 coming years of the project) Grants for Students and Young Researchers to participate in Workshops, Schools and Conferences
Our activities that address the public consist of: Travelling exhibition, starting on 8 th May 2013 in Dublin Conference about RS & Community Archaeology as a starting event for the travelling exhibition (8 th – 11 th May 2013 in Dublin) Website http://www.archaeolandscapes.eu (the site will be updated continuously during the 3 coming years of the project) Flyer, sticker
Of course we try to be present in the media as well. Newspaper, radio & TV interviews: Spiegel Online: http://www.spiegel.de/international/zeitgeist/remote-scanning-techniques-revolutionize-archaeology-a-846793.html - copied or used as the basis for other articles: http://videnskab.dk/teknologi/flyvende-lasere-afslorer-begravede-fortidsminder (DK) http://www.niburu.nl/archeologie/vliegende-lasers-sporen-ondergrondse-bouwwerken-op.html (NL) Politiken (DK) http://nachrichten.t-online.de/fliegender-laser-verraet-verschuettete-bauten/id_58398140/index (DE) http://yle.fi/radio1/kulttuuri/kultakuume/ => Kun hakku ja lapio eivät enää riitä (FI) Planned: TV documentaries about RS in archaeology
So far one of the main aspects of our work was teaching in various forms, especially with our workshops and aerial archaeology training schools. Technical Workshops Bibracte/FR – LiDAR Slane/IE – Geophysics, kite photography, data integration Poznan/PL – satellite & aerial images Klaipeda/LT – geophysics Ljubljana – 3D data Rethymno/GR – geophysics, satellite & aerial images Aerial Archaeology Training Schools Kostolac/RS Velling/DK Merida/ES Pilsen/CZ Kocaeli/TR
We have been visible and involved in a large number of conferences, workshops and meetings which besides supporting our outreach activities was also important to build up and widen our network and to stay in touch with the newest developments in archaeological remote sensing and surveying.
Grants for Students and Young Researchers to participate in Workshops, Schools and Conferences 43 grants have been paid from ArcLand : 19 for aerial archaeological training schools 16 for technical workshops 6 exchange visits / mobility grants 2 conference grants
We do plan of course more activities for the future, including more workshops and more aerial archaeology training schools as well as the aforementioned conference and exhibition, which either deal with or directly aim for a dialog with the broader public.
very successful as regards the hits and visits we expected 15.000 visits by the end of the project but have already reached 20.600 by now! we have 2 main peaks in the graph, one relates to opening a Facebook page in January and to a number of posts there which obviously made people curious about our work the second peak is clearly related to the aforementioned article on Spiegel Online in late July this year the article - available both in English and German - was copied or at least used as the basis for other online articles in at least Denmark and the Netherlands which also reflects the great interest the general public has in topics that connect archaeology and high tech.
the origin of visitors is in the meantime from all over the world. we even have people from Guyana, the Dutch Antilles, Gibraltar and from the Turks- and Caicos Islands (wherever that may be) but the majority of visitors come from Europe, Germany being the leading country, the United Kingdom, Spain, Italy, Poland and Ireland
Knowing that the use of all modern RS techniques and methods need skill, expertise and experience and being aware of the fact that these factors are not evenly distributed all over Europe (as well as in the rest of the world), the ArchaeoLandscapes Europe project, supported by the EU Culture 2007–2013 programme, aims for a better understanding and a more excessive use of modern archaeological surveying techniques as well as for an exchange of people, working in these fields, their expertise and of new ideas. Moreover, we think that involving the public in various ways is an important aspect of our work, fostering an understanding as well as public support for archaeological remote sensing.
If you want to know more about the project and the various (future) activities, opportunities and so on, visit our website
Thank you very much for your attention, I am looking forward to your question and hope we will have an interesting discussion!