SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 13
2-SPIRIT ABORIGINAL PEOPLE LIVING
WITH HIV/AIDS WHO PARTICIPATED IN
ONTARIO’S POSITIVE SPACES,
HEALTHY PLACES STUDY
           Nathan J Lachowsky1,2; Art Zoccole3;
           CE Dewey1,2; AJS Summerlee4; and
           Positive Spaces Healthy Places team
           1 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, ON
           2 Centre for Public Health and Zoonoses, University of Guelph, ON
           3 2-Spirit People of the 1st Nations, Toronto, ON
           4 Department of Biomedical Science, University of Guelph, ON
Background
                            • Some 2-spirit people
                             are at the intersection
                  Gay,       of “populations at-risk”
 Aboriginal     bisexual
  people        and other
                  MSM       • Paucity of research
                             specific to 2-spirit
                             people

          Some
      2-spirit people
Social Determinants of Health
• Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion  Health for All
  • 21 November 1986
  • 2nd item: “shelter” == housing
Objective
• Describe the experiences of 2-spirit Aboriginal people
 living with HIV/AIDS (APHAs), as collected through the
 Positive Spaces, Healthy Places (PSHP) study.
Positive Spaces, Healthy Places (PSHP)
• “First longitudinal community-based research initiative
 in Canada examining the relationship between health
 and housing in the context of HIV to inform housing
 policies and programs that may lead to improved health
 outcomes and health-related quality of life for PWAs.”

• For more information: www.pshp.ca
Method
• 2-Spirit APHA (n=43)
    • HIV-positive at baseline;
    • Identified with an Aboriginal ethnicity; and
    • Identified as gay, bisexual, lesbian or other (defined further)


• Baseline and 24-month follow-up


• Appropriate statistical tests for
 longitudinal/paired/matched data
Results (n=43)
• Age: mean = 41.7 years, sd = 7.4 years
  • Range 26 – 65
• Gender: male = 93%
• Location: Greater Toronto Area = 65.1%
• Aboriginal ethnicity: First Nations = 62.8%
• Education: at least high school graduate = 79.1%
• Currently on treatment: 67.4%
• Diagnosed with HIV: 1978 – 2005
  • ARVs started an average of 3.3 years later
  • Reported AIDS defining illness: 51.2%
Results (n=43)
• Change Over Time (baseline to 24-month follow-up):
  • Highest or lowest CD4 cell count in previous 6 months
    • No change over time (p=0.58 and p=0.83%)
  • Participants’ self-rated “quality of life”
    • 53.5% rated “pretty good” or better at baseline
    • 64.7% rated “pretty good” or better at 24-month follow-up
    • No change over time (p=0.61)
  • Participants’ self-rated “physical/mental health”
    • 86.0% rated “about the same” or better at baseline
    • 82.4% rated “about the same” or 24-months
    • No change over time (p=0.62)
Discussion
• Diverse sample of 2-spirit APHAs in Ontario
  • Majority are educated males living in GTA
• Little change over time in major outcomes explored
  • Stable population: “resilience”
• Results can inform population-specific programming,
 policy and interventions
Strengths & Limitations
• Strengths:
  • Community-based partnership with 2-Spirited People of the 1st
    Nations
  • Rich longitudinal data compliments of PSHP team
  • Unique focus on 2-spirit people


• Limitations:
  • Only possible to have a sample size statistically (n=43)
  • Operational definition of “2-spirit”
Next Steps
• Presentation of interim results with affected community
    members and at 2012 OHTN Research Conference
•   Analyze additional changes over time for this cohort
•   Build regression models to determine most salient factors
    impacting health-related quality of life
•   Develop manuscript for publication
•   Other knowledge translation activities of final findings
Acknowledgements
• Positive Spaces, Healthy Places participants
• Art Zoccole& 2-Spirits
2-SPIRIT ABORIGINAL PEOPLE LIVING
WITH HIV/AIDS WHO PARTICIPATED IN
ONTARIO’S POSITIVE SPACES,
HEALTHY PLACES STUDY
           Nathan J Lachowsky1,2; Art Zoccole3;
           CE Dewey1,2; AJS Summerlee4; and
           Positive Spaces Healthy Places team
           1 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, ON
           2 Centre for Public Health and Zoonoses, University of Guelph, ON
           3 2-Spirit People of the 1st Nations, Toronto, ON
           4 Department of Biomedical Science, University of Guelph, ON

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a 18 nate lachnowskynov1

Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating InequalitiesPalliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
mckenln
 
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
lmcmc
 
Finished Presentation
Finished PresentationFinished Presentation
Finished Presentation
Michael Kugel
 
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be AwareHealth Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
Jacqueline Leskovec
 

Similar a 18 nate lachnowskynov1 (20)

Assessing the Unmet Clinical and Social Needs of a Community
Assessing the Unmet Clinical and Social Needs of a CommunityAssessing the Unmet Clinical and Social Needs of a Community
Assessing the Unmet Clinical and Social Needs of a Community
 
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS HealthcareHospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
 
Hospice Basics and Benefits
Hospice Basics and BenefitsHospice Basics and Benefits
Hospice Basics and Benefits
 
Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating InequalitiesPalliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
Palliative and End of Life Care: Tackling Variations, Eradicating Inequalities
 
Hospice Basics and Benefits
Hospice Basics and BenefitsHospice Basics and Benefits
Hospice Basics and Benefits
 
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS HealthcareHospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
 
Aplicações clínicas da espiritualidade
Aplicações clínicas da espiritualidadeAplicações clínicas da espiritualidade
Aplicações clínicas da espiritualidade
 
CRDP Stakeholder Briefing Slide Deck_Oakland_9.25.23_OHE version_1054am.pptx.pdf
CRDP Stakeholder Briefing Slide Deck_Oakland_9.25.23_OHE version_1054am.pptx.pdfCRDP Stakeholder Briefing Slide Deck_Oakland_9.25.23_OHE version_1054am.pptx.pdf
CRDP Stakeholder Briefing Slide Deck_Oakland_9.25.23_OHE version_1054am.pptx.pdf
 
Holistic Health Indicators: From Context to Application
Holistic Health Indicators: From Context to ApplicationHolistic Health Indicators: From Context to Application
Holistic Health Indicators: From Context to Application
 
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
1, 2. Research proposal & Res. Article.pptx
 
Pediatric history and_physical_examination
Pediatric history and_physical_examinationPediatric history and_physical_examination
Pediatric history and_physical_examination
 
Ethical issues of extremely preterm babies’ care: the “grey zone” experiences
Ethical issues of extremely preterm babies’ care: the “grey zone” experiencesEthical issues of extremely preterm babies’ care: the “grey zone” experiences
Ethical issues of extremely preterm babies’ care: the “grey zone” experiences
 
social autopsy preventive medicine seminar PPT.pptx
social autopsy preventive medicine seminar PPT.pptxsocial autopsy preventive medicine seminar PPT.pptx
social autopsy preventive medicine seminar PPT.pptx
 
fantahun.ppt
fantahun.pptfantahun.ppt
fantahun.ppt
 
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
Julliard Diversity Presentation 2013
 
Finished Presentation
Finished PresentationFinished Presentation
Finished Presentation
 
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS HealthcareHospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
Hospice Basics and Benefits | VITAS Healthcare
 
Descriptive Epidemiology.pptx
Descriptive Epidemiology.pptxDescriptive Epidemiology.pptx
Descriptive Epidemiology.pptx
 
Added value of Positive health concept to WHO health definition in peoples’ p...
Added value of Positive health concept to WHO health definition in peoples’ p...Added value of Positive health concept to WHO health definition in peoples’ p...
Added value of Positive health concept to WHO health definition in peoples’ p...
 
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be AwareHealth Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
Health Disparities: Don't Despair, Be Aware
 

Más de CBRC

Day 1 1100 - travis salway hottes
Day 1   1100 - travis salway hottesDay 1   1100 - travis salway hottes
Day 1 1100 - travis salway hottes
CBRC
 
Day 1 1530 - christian hui & alan li
Day 1   1530 - christian hui & alan liDay 1   1530 - christian hui & alan li
Day 1 1530 - christian hui & alan li
CBRC
 
Day 2 1300 - investigaytors
Day 2   1300 - investigaytorsDay 2   1300 - investigaytors
Day 2 1300 - investigaytors
CBRC
 
Day 1 1100 - panel - millenials
Day 1   1100 - panel - millenialsDay 1   1100 - panel - millenials
Day 1 1100 - panel - millenials
CBRC
 
Day 2 0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
Day 2   0900 - robin parry & ben klassenDay 2   0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
Day 2 0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
CBRC
 
Day 2 0900 - ashleigh rich
Day 2   0900 - ashleigh richDay 2   0900 - ashleigh rich
Day 2 0900 - ashleigh rich
CBRC
 
Day 2 0900 - robert ablenas
Day 2   0900 - robert ablenasDay 2   0900 - robert ablenas
Day 2 0900 - robert ablenas
CBRC
 
Day 2 1500 - chris atchison
Day 2   1500 - chris atchisonDay 2   1500 - chris atchison
Day 2 1500 - chris atchison
CBRC
 
Day 2 1530 - mark gilbert
Day 2   1530 - mark gilbertDay 2   1530 - mark gilbert
Day 2 1530 - mark gilbert
CBRC
 
Day 1 0930 - nathaniel lewis
Day 1   0930 - nathaniel lewisDay 1   0930 - nathaniel lewis
Day 1 0930 - nathaniel lewis
CBRC
 
Day 1 0915 - terry trussler
Day 1   0915 - terry trusslerDay 1   0915 - terry trussler
Day 1 0915 - terry trussler
CBRC
 
Day 2 1100 - phillip hammack
Day 2   1100 - phillip hammackDay 2   1100 - phillip hammack
Day 2 1100 - phillip hammack
CBRC
 
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
CBRC
 
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
CBRC
 
1045 3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
1045   3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace1045   3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
1045 3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
CBRC
 
115 2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
115   2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler115   2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
115 2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
CBRC
 
915 beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
915   beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green915   beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
915 beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
CBRC
 
115 1 beyond behaviours minority stress
115   1 beyond behaviours minority stress115   1 beyond behaviours minority stress
115 1 beyond behaviours minority stress
CBRC
 
23 chad smithnov1
23 chad smithnov123 chad smithnov1
23 chad smithnov1
CBRC
 
22 patricia millernov1
22 patricia millernov122 patricia millernov1
22 patricia millernov1
CBRC
 

Más de CBRC (20)

Day 1 1100 - travis salway hottes
Day 1   1100 - travis salway hottesDay 1   1100 - travis salway hottes
Day 1 1100 - travis salway hottes
 
Day 1 1530 - christian hui & alan li
Day 1   1530 - christian hui & alan liDay 1   1530 - christian hui & alan li
Day 1 1530 - christian hui & alan li
 
Day 2 1300 - investigaytors
Day 2   1300 - investigaytorsDay 2   1300 - investigaytors
Day 2 1300 - investigaytors
 
Day 1 1100 - panel - millenials
Day 1   1100 - panel - millenialsDay 1   1100 - panel - millenials
Day 1 1100 - panel - millenials
 
Day 2 0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
Day 2   0900 - robin parry & ben klassenDay 2   0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
Day 2 0900 - robin parry & ben klassen
 
Day 2 0900 - ashleigh rich
Day 2   0900 - ashleigh richDay 2   0900 - ashleigh rich
Day 2 0900 - ashleigh rich
 
Day 2 0900 - robert ablenas
Day 2   0900 - robert ablenasDay 2   0900 - robert ablenas
Day 2 0900 - robert ablenas
 
Day 2 1500 - chris atchison
Day 2   1500 - chris atchisonDay 2   1500 - chris atchison
Day 2 1500 - chris atchison
 
Day 2 1530 - mark gilbert
Day 2   1530 - mark gilbertDay 2   1530 - mark gilbert
Day 2 1530 - mark gilbert
 
Day 1 0930 - nathaniel lewis
Day 1   0930 - nathaniel lewisDay 1   0930 - nathaniel lewis
Day 1 0930 - nathaniel lewis
 
Day 1 0915 - terry trussler
Day 1   0915 - terry trusslerDay 1   0915 - terry trussler
Day 1 0915 - terry trussler
 
Day 2 1100 - phillip hammack
Day 2   1100 - phillip hammackDay 2   1100 - phillip hammack
Day 2 1100 - phillip hammack
 
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
1045 2 bb presentation vancouver
 
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
 
1045 3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
1045   3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace1045   3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
1045 3 1 final-beyond behaviours slides april 15 v5 Daniel Grace
 
115 2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
115   2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler115   2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
115 2 the gradient copy Terry Trussler
 
915 beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
915   beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green915   beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
915 beyond behaviors conference 2013 Adam Green
 
115 1 beyond behaviours minority stress
115   1 beyond behaviours minority stress115   1 beyond behaviours minority stress
115 1 beyond behaviours minority stress
 
23 chad smithnov1
23 chad smithnov123 chad smithnov1
23 chad smithnov1
 
22 patricia millernov1
22 patricia millernov122 patricia millernov1
22 patricia millernov1
 

18 nate lachnowskynov1

  • 1. 2-SPIRIT ABORIGINAL PEOPLE LIVING WITH HIV/AIDS WHO PARTICIPATED IN ONTARIO’S POSITIVE SPACES, HEALTHY PLACES STUDY Nathan J Lachowsky1,2; Art Zoccole3; CE Dewey1,2; AJS Summerlee4; and Positive Spaces Healthy Places team 1 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, ON 2 Centre for Public Health and Zoonoses, University of Guelph, ON 3 2-Spirit People of the 1st Nations, Toronto, ON 4 Department of Biomedical Science, University of Guelph, ON
  • 2. Background • Some 2-spirit people are at the intersection Gay, of “populations at-risk” Aboriginal bisexual people and other MSM • Paucity of research specific to 2-spirit people Some 2-spirit people
  • 3. Social Determinants of Health • Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion  Health for All • 21 November 1986 • 2nd item: “shelter” == housing
  • 4. Objective • Describe the experiences of 2-spirit Aboriginal people living with HIV/AIDS (APHAs), as collected through the Positive Spaces, Healthy Places (PSHP) study.
  • 5. Positive Spaces, Healthy Places (PSHP) • “First longitudinal community-based research initiative in Canada examining the relationship between health and housing in the context of HIV to inform housing policies and programs that may lead to improved health outcomes and health-related quality of life for PWAs.” • For more information: www.pshp.ca
  • 6. Method • 2-Spirit APHA (n=43) • HIV-positive at baseline; • Identified with an Aboriginal ethnicity; and • Identified as gay, bisexual, lesbian or other (defined further) • Baseline and 24-month follow-up • Appropriate statistical tests for longitudinal/paired/matched data
  • 7. Results (n=43) • Age: mean = 41.7 years, sd = 7.4 years • Range 26 – 65 • Gender: male = 93% • Location: Greater Toronto Area = 65.1% • Aboriginal ethnicity: First Nations = 62.8% • Education: at least high school graduate = 79.1% • Currently on treatment: 67.4% • Diagnosed with HIV: 1978 – 2005 • ARVs started an average of 3.3 years later • Reported AIDS defining illness: 51.2%
  • 8. Results (n=43) • Change Over Time (baseline to 24-month follow-up): • Highest or lowest CD4 cell count in previous 6 months • No change over time (p=0.58 and p=0.83%) • Participants’ self-rated “quality of life” • 53.5% rated “pretty good” or better at baseline • 64.7% rated “pretty good” or better at 24-month follow-up • No change over time (p=0.61) • Participants’ self-rated “physical/mental health” • 86.0% rated “about the same” or better at baseline • 82.4% rated “about the same” or 24-months • No change over time (p=0.62)
  • 9. Discussion • Diverse sample of 2-spirit APHAs in Ontario • Majority are educated males living in GTA • Little change over time in major outcomes explored • Stable population: “resilience” • Results can inform population-specific programming, policy and interventions
  • 10. Strengths & Limitations • Strengths: • Community-based partnership with 2-Spirited People of the 1st Nations • Rich longitudinal data compliments of PSHP team • Unique focus on 2-spirit people • Limitations: • Only possible to have a sample size statistically (n=43) • Operational definition of “2-spirit”
  • 11. Next Steps • Presentation of interim results with affected community members and at 2012 OHTN Research Conference • Analyze additional changes over time for this cohort • Build regression models to determine most salient factors impacting health-related quality of life • Develop manuscript for publication • Other knowledge translation activities of final findings
  • 12. Acknowledgements • Positive Spaces, Healthy Places participants • Art Zoccole& 2-Spirits
  • 13. 2-SPIRIT ABORIGINAL PEOPLE LIVING WITH HIV/AIDS WHO PARTICIPATED IN ONTARIO’S POSITIVE SPACES, HEALTHY PLACES STUDY Nathan J Lachowsky1,2; Art Zoccole3; CE Dewey1,2; AJS Summerlee4; and Positive Spaces Healthy Places team 1 Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, ON 2 Centre for Public Health and Zoonoses, University of Guelph, ON 3 2-Spirit People of the 1st Nations, Toronto, ON 4 Department of Biomedical Science, University of Guelph, ON