Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Human factors lecture 3pp
1. 1
INTRODUCTION TO
HUMAN FACTORS
Dr Nathan Perry n.perry@uws.edu.au
101183 Behavioural Science
What is Human Factors?
Understand human interactions with a
system
Factors that influence human performance
What is Human Factors?
Human
Characteristics
Task Characteristics Environment
Attention capacity Workload Illumination
Working memory
capacity
Level of training Noise
Expertise Display design Vibration
Communication skills Organisational
Culture
Climate
Personality Technological
reliability
Altitude
2. 2
Human Error
Shooter A Shooter B
Variable Error Constant Error
Reason (1990)
Information Processing
Information Processing
Wickens & Carswell (2006)
Information Processing Errors
Slips
Not Deliberate
Failure of attention
Lapses
Not Deliberate
Failure of memory
Mistakes
Deliberate
Wrong course of action
Reason (1990)
3. 3
Perception
Question
You are designing a new phone book. Which of
the following formats would you choose?
(a) Nathan Perry n.perry@uws.edu.au 97726139
(b) Nathan Perry n.perry@uws.edu.au 97726139
Cognitive Factors
Perception
Definition: Extraction of meaning from information
Processes
1. Bottom-up processing
2. Top-down processing
Cognitive Factors
Perception
Bottom-up processing
Analysis and integration of features
Characteristics
Slow
Effortful
Does not require experience
Cognitive Factors
4. 4
Perception
Top-down processing
Perception shaped by previous experience
Recognition of the whole
Characteristics
Fast
Relatively automatic
Requires previous experience
Cognitive Factors
Perception: Human Factors Implications
Feature degradation reduces ability for
bottom-up perception
Top-down processing still possible with
degraded features
Cognitive Factors
Perception: Human Factors Implications
Display of information
In context: words perceived top-down
Random numbers: perceived bottom-up
If display provides both text and numbers
display numbers in larger font to aid bottom-up
Wickens et al. (2004)
Cognitive Factors
5. 5
Perception
Question
You are designing a new phone book. Which of
the following formats would you choose?
(a) Nathan Perry n.perry@uws.edu.au 97726139
(b) Nathan Perry n.perry@uws.edu.au 97726139
Wickens et al. (2004)
Cognitive Factors
Perception
Cognitive Factors
Cognitive Factors
Perception
6. 6
Cognitive Factors
Perception
Cognitive Factors
Memory
Working Memory: Short-term memory store
which enables the manipulation of
information
Long-Term Memory:prolonged storage of
information for later retrieval
Cognitive Factors
Memory: Human Factors Implications
Working Memory: Processing
requirements exceed working memory
capacity performance decline
Long-term memory: Inability to retrieve
information
7. 7
Cognitive Factors
Working Memory
Rail Control Example
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making
Definition: Choice between alternative options
or courses of action
Theorised to involve:
(a) Information acquisition
(b) Information interpretation
(c) Planning and selecting choices
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making
Use a range of different decision
strategies
Simple Complex
8. 8
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making
Situation Simple or Complex
Requires Accuracy Complex
Little Time Available Simple
Vast amount of
information
Simple
Little Task Experience Complex
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making: Expertise
Interviews with expert Fire Ground Commanders
Don’t compare and contrast decision options
Recognise the situation
Use cues present in the environment to recall similar
situations from memory
Use strategy taken in previous situation
Klein (1989)
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making: Human Factors Implications
Tendency to limit info. analysis
Effortful & time-consuming
Reduced potential for accuracy
Implement systems to reduce effort
associated with info. analysis
Perry et al. (2012)
9. 9
Cognitive Factors
Decision-Making: Human Factors Implications
Display critical information
Advises on a course of action
Determines and executes course of action
Traffic Collision Avoidance System (TCAS)
Climb! Climb!
Descend! Descend!
Cognitive Factors
Attention
Information processes require attention
Limited attention capacity
Cannot attend to everything
Without attention information unlikely
to be processed
Cognitive Factors
Attention: Human Factors Implications
Attention required for info processing
Ensure that operators attend to crucial
information
Design systems to ensure attention is given
to crucial information
10. 10
Design
Lever underneath seat in van
Q: What will happen if
the lever is pulled?
A: Seat detaches from floor
Design
A: Mop sink
Design
11. 11
Design
System Design
Airbus A320 accident in Strasbourg 1992
Pilot engaged behaviour that was inappropriate for current
mode
Appropriate for different mode
Preparing to land – autopilot
Needed change flight angle to 3.3 degrees
Flight management system set in the vertical
speed mode
Pilot dialled 3.3 into flight control unit
In this mode this meant a speed of 3300 feet per minute!
Instead of 800 feet per minute
Overreliance on Automation
Role of human operator with automated system is
often to monitor
Humans have a tendency to put a lot of trust in
automated systems
Out-of-the-loop performance problem
Automation Induced Complacency
Automation Bias
Skill Loss
12. 12
Automation-Induced Complacency
System Monitoring Tracking
Fuel Management
Parasuraman et al. (1993)
Task
Computer-based flight
simulation
Participants task to detect
automation failures
Reliability of automation
manipulated
Constant vs. Variable
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Constant
Variable
Total Automation Failure
0
Probabilityofdetecting
systemmalfunction
Trial Block
Modified from Parasuraman et al. (1993)
Automation-Induced Complacency
Reliability
Automation-Induced Complacency
Automation: Human Factors Implications
1. Keep the operator informed
2. Keep the operator trained
3. Keep the operator in the loop
4. Select appropriate levels of
automation
Wickens et al. (2004)
13. 13
Accident Causation
Reason (2000)
Summary
Human factors issues are complex
Role of human factors specialist
Facilitate the fit between humans and the system
Role of psychologist
Consider the psychological issues to ensure fit between
humans and system