SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 16
Gila River Indian Community Navajo Generating Station Impacts Councilman Augustine Enas & Ann Marie Chischilly, GRIC Law Office January 21, 2011
Gila River Indian Community Profile ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object]
Navajo  Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF  Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts  for the Community  based upon the  AZ Water Settlement
Arizona Water Settlement Act ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Arizona Water Settlement Act Former Gov. Richard Narcia   The specific process for funding this settlement is absolutely, absolutely fundamental to our settlement.  Without it, our settlement simply will not work . . . .  [T]he funding mechanism of this bill is the strongest possible affirmation that the Federal Government is serious about reaching a fair and binding settlement with every Arizona Indian Tribe that is willing to negotiate in good faith.
Arizona Water Settlement Act  Former Gov. Richard Narcia   For the first time, the United States will be able to negotiate with Indian Tribes in Arizona knowing that if they are able to reach a settlement they will have the revenue, a certain quantity of CAP water, and the resources to guarantee that the operations, maintenance, and the replacement costs associated with that water can be paid for both for this generation and the next generation to come. [1] [1]   Testimony of Governor Narcia, Joint Hearing before the Subcommittee on Energy and Natural Resources and the Committee on Indian Affairs on S. 437 (Sept. 30, 2003).
Navajo  Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF  Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts  for the Community  based upon the  AZ Water Settlement
Worst Case Cost Impacts ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Economic Impacts on GRIC ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Economic Impacts on GRIC ,[object Object],[object Object]
United States’ Trust Responsibility ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Navajo  Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF  Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts  for the Community  based upon the  AZ Water Settlement
Cultural Implications For GRIC ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cultural Implications For GRIC ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
GRIC Goal ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation water
Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation waterChapter 6 municipal and irrigation water
Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation waterMohammed Salahat
 
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of Delaware
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of DelawareAccelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of Delaware
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of DelawareKim Beidler
 
Inter-State River Water Disputes in India
Inter-State River Water Disputes in IndiaInter-State River Water Disputes in India
Inter-State River Water Disputes in IndiaAnmol Utsav
 
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo OECD Environment
 
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 final
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 finalEnvironmental and climate justice region iii 2013 final
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 finalNAACP
 
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water how prepared is kaduna state
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water   how prepared is kaduna stateLeaving nobody behind in access to safe water   how prepared is kaduna state
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water how prepared is kaduna stateDogara Bashir
 
Sample Writing3
Sample Writing3Sample Writing3
Sample Writing3Kevin Choi
 
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection Act
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection ActBorn with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection Act
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection ActLOWaterkeeper
 
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubJanuary-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubKern-Kaweah Chapter, Sierrra Club
 
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12cookcountyblog
 
Water conflicts in India
Water conflicts in IndiaWater conflicts in India
Water conflicts in IndiaManar Ramadan
 
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)Home Grown Cow
 

La actualidad más candente (16)

Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation water
Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation waterChapter 6 municipal and irrigation water
Chapter 6 municipal and irrigation water
 
State Of Texas Water Plan
State Of Texas Water PlanState Of Texas Water Plan
State Of Texas Water Plan
 
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of Delaware
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of DelawareAccelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of Delaware
Accelerating Action, Luncheon Keynote by Jerry Kauffman, University of Delaware
 
India must go for sharing of river water
India must go for sharing of river waterIndia must go for sharing of river water
India must go for sharing of river water
 
Inter-State River Water Disputes in India
Inter-State River Water Disputes in IndiaInter-State River Water Disputes in India
Inter-State River Water Disputes in India
 
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo
Session 3 - Global Forum Water-Energy-Food Nexus, November 2014, Lotufo
 
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 final
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 finalEnvironmental and climate justice region iii 2013 final
Environmental and climate justice region iii 2013 final
 
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water how prepared is kaduna state
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water   how prepared is kaduna stateLeaving nobody behind in access to safe water   how prepared is kaduna state
Leaving nobody behind in access to safe water how prepared is kaduna state
 
Sample Writing3
Sample Writing3Sample Writing3
Sample Writing3
 
2014 ballot propositions expanded
2014 ballot propositions   expanded2014 ballot propositions   expanded
2014 ballot propositions expanded
 
Election Saw Big Wins for State and Local Conservation Projects
Election Saw Big Wins for State and Local Conservation ProjectsElection Saw Big Wins for State and Local Conservation Projects
Election Saw Big Wins for State and Local Conservation Projects
 
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection Act
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection ActBorn with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection Act
Born with a Grey Beard: Canada's Navigable Waters Protection Act
 
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubJanuary-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2006 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
 
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12
Cook County Solid Waste Action Plan--Passed 4/3/12
 
Water conflicts in India
Water conflicts in IndiaWater conflicts in India
Water conflicts in India
 
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)
National Farmers Union Newsletter (May 2011)
 

Similar a Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts

Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for TransitionGrand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transitionen3pro
 
Prior Appropriation
Prior AppropriationPrior Appropriation
Prior AppropriationDotha Keller
 
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubNovember-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubKern-Kaweah Chapter, Sierrra Club
 
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...Ohio Environmental Council
 
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptx
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptxKirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptx
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptxLarry Bodine
 
Water Supply In Ethiopia
Water Supply In EthiopiaWater Supply In Ethiopia
Water Supply In EthiopiaAshley Davis
 
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities  Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities Z8Y
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Stationen3pro
 
Mesa County Town Hall Meeting
Mesa County Town Hall MeetingMesa County Town Hall Meeting
Mesa County Town Hall MeetingWalter Davidson
 
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.Water Law and Policy in the U.S.
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.Chuck Bowen
 
Crunch IWI Presentation : David Baize
Crunch IWI Presentation : David BaizeCrunch IWI Presentation : David Baize
Crunch IWI Presentation : David BaizeConfluence Conference
 
January-February 2004 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2004  Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubJanuary-February 2004  Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2004 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubKern-Kaweah Chapter, Sierrra Club
 
Environmental and Natural Resource Protection
Environmental and Natural Resource ProtectionEnvironmental and Natural Resource Protection
Environmental and Natural Resource ProtectionConnie Sue Martin
 
Hannah Light Deep Dive - Iowa
Hannah Light Deep Dive - IowaHannah Light Deep Dive - Iowa
Hannah Light Deep Dive - IowaHannah Light
 
Final paper for ESM 222
Final paper for ESM 222Final paper for ESM 222
Final paper for ESM 222Trevor Lee
 
Al W & W 2008 11 05
Al W & W  2008 11 05Al W & W  2008 11 05
Al W & W 2008 11 05mjchurchman
 

Similar a Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts (20)

Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for TransitionGrand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
Grand Canyon Trust - Opportunity for Transition
 
Prior Appropriation
Prior AppropriationPrior Appropriation
Prior Appropriation
 
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubNovember-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
November-December 2003 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
 
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...
Western Lake Erie “impairment” designation: What does it mean? How can it hap...
 
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptx
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptxKirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptx
Kirsten Engel Water Presentation LD18 5-23-23.pptx
 
Great Lakes Compact Challenges and Opportunities
Great Lakes Compact Challenges and OpportunitiesGreat Lakes Compact Challenges and Opportunities
Great Lakes Compact Challenges and Opportunities
 
Water Supply In Ethiopia
Water Supply In EthiopiaWater Supply In Ethiopia
Water Supply In Ethiopia
 
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities  Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities
Through the Eye of a Hurricane: Rebuilding Just Communities
 
IGR Final Draft
IGR Final DraftIGR Final Draft
IGR Final Draft
 
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating StationCAP and the Navajo Generating Station
CAP and the Navajo Generating Station
 
Sustainable Water Supplies WS - Bill Golden
Sustainable Water Supplies WS - Bill GoldenSustainable Water Supplies WS - Bill Golden
Sustainable Water Supplies WS - Bill Golden
 
Mesa County Town Hall Meeting
Mesa County Town Hall MeetingMesa County Town Hall Meeting
Mesa County Town Hall Meeting
 
Gila River Indian Community Case Study
Gila River Indian Community Case StudyGila River Indian Community Case Study
Gila River Indian Community Case Study
 
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.Water Law and Policy in the U.S.
Water Law and Policy in the U.S.
 
Crunch IWI Presentation : David Baize
Crunch IWI Presentation : David BaizeCrunch IWI Presentation : David Baize
Crunch IWI Presentation : David Baize
 
January-February 2004 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2004  Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra ClubJanuary-February 2004  Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
January-February 2004 Roadrunner Newsletter, Kern-Kaweah Sierrra Club
 
Environmental and Natural Resource Protection
Environmental and Natural Resource ProtectionEnvironmental and Natural Resource Protection
Environmental and Natural Resource Protection
 
Hannah Light Deep Dive - Iowa
Hannah Light Deep Dive - IowaHannah Light Deep Dive - Iowa
Hannah Light Deep Dive - Iowa
 
Final paper for ESM 222
Final paper for ESM 222Final paper for ESM 222
Final paper for ESM 222
 
Al W & W 2008 11 05
Al W & W  2008 11 05Al W & W  2008 11 05
Al W & W 2008 11 05
 

Más de en3pro

Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justiceen3pro
 
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and RenewablesJohn Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewablesen3pro
 
NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance
NGS Emissions and Air Quality ComplianceNGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance
NGS Emissions and Air Quality Complianceen3pro
 
Peabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona OperationsPeabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona Operationsen3pro
 
DOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a SolutionDOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a Solutionen3pro
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline DiscussionNGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussionen3pro
 
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justiceen3pro
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011en3pro
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSen3pro
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribeen3pro
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationen3pro
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economyen3pro
 
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth HollandAir Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Hollanden3pro
 

Más de en3pro (13)

Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS: Securing Environmental and Climate Justice
 
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and RenewablesJohn Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
John Coggins/SRP - Coal-fired Plants and Renewables
 
NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance
NGS Emissions and Air Quality ComplianceNGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance
NGS Emissions and Air Quality Compliance
 
Peabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona OperationsPeabody - Arizona Operations
Peabody - Arizona Operations
 
DOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a SolutionDOI - Framework for a Solution
DOI - Framework for a Solution
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline DiscussionNGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
NGS Owners Initial Proposal Timeline Discussion
 
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate JusticeForgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice
 
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
NGS Owners Initial Proposal 1 21-2011
 
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGSNavajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
Navajo Nation EPA - Comments to ANPRM for BART FIP for FCPP and NGS
 
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi TribeArizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
Arizona Coal: Economic Development for the Hopi Tribe
 
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentationUSEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
USEPA 2011-01-07 presentation
 
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green EconomyBlack Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
Black Mesa Water Coalition - Green Economy
 
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth HollandAir Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
Air Pollution over Navajo and Hopi Lands - Beth Holland
 

Gila River Indian Community and NGS Impacts

  • 1. Gila River Indian Community Navajo Generating Station Impacts Councilman Augustine Enas & Ann Marie Chischilly, GRIC Law Office January 21, 2011
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4. Navajo Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts for the Community based upon the AZ Water Settlement
  • 5.
  • 6. Arizona Water Settlement Act Former Gov. Richard Narcia The specific process for funding this settlement is absolutely, absolutely fundamental to our settlement. Without it, our settlement simply will not work . . . . [T]he funding mechanism of this bill is the strongest possible affirmation that the Federal Government is serious about reaching a fair and binding settlement with every Arizona Indian Tribe that is willing to negotiate in good faith.
  • 7. Arizona Water Settlement Act Former Gov. Richard Narcia For the first time, the United States will be able to negotiate with Indian Tribes in Arizona knowing that if they are able to reach a settlement they will have the revenue, a certain quantity of CAP water, and the resources to guarantee that the operations, maintenance, and the replacement costs associated with that water can be paid for both for this generation and the next generation to come. [1] [1] Testimony of Governor Narcia, Joint Hearing before the Subcommittee on Energy and Natural Resources and the Committee on Indian Affairs on S. 437 (Sept. 30, 2003).
  • 8. Navajo Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts for the Community based upon the AZ Water Settlement
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Navajo Generating Station (increase OM&R costs) LCRBDF Energy Costs Gila River Indian Community Impacts cost of water Two Impacts for the Community based upon the AZ Water Settlement
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.