1. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
TH NÀO LÀ C PHÊ PHÁN?
Hãy tick vào u nh ng câu h i mà th y (cô) nghĩ r ng ngư i c c n tr l i hay cân nh c
trong quá trình c phê phán:
Ngư i vi t ang mu n nói i u gì?
Theo b n, i u mà ngư i vi t ang mu n xu t ho c ng ý là gì? Làm sao b n bi t
ư c i u ó?
M c tiêu c a ngư i vi t là gì?
i tư ng ngư i c mà ngư i vi t ang hư ng t i?
Có ph i tác gi ang vi t áp l i ý ki n c a m t ngư i khác?
Ý chính c a ngư i vi t là gì?
Ngư i vi t ã khai tri n ý chính ó như th nào?
Ngư i vi t s d ng th c t (facts), ý ki n (opinions) hay k t h p c hai?
Li u ngư i vi t ã có d n ch ng và ví d ?
Mô hình khai tri n ý c a ngư i vi t là gì? Mô hình này có ph i là s l a ch n t t nh t?
Thông tin c a ngư i vi t ưa ra có xác th c? H p lý? Công b ng không?
B n có hi u ư c (d ng ý) s d ng t c a ngư i vi t?
B n có hi u ư c ý tư ng c a ngư i vi t?
B n có ng ý v i quan i m c a ngư i vi t?
Cách trình bày ý tư ng như th gi ng/ không gi ng v i cách trình bày khác (c a tác gi
khác khi vi t v cùng n i dung ó) mà b n ã t ng c như th nào?
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 1|Page

2. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
M T VÍ D V BÀI T P TÌNH HU NG
Ngu n: Market Leader, Elementary
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 2|Page

3. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
C U TRÚC N I DUNG CHƯƠNG TRÌNH H C &
M C TIÊU 06 BÀI H C V K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN
CHO SINH VIÊN CH T LƯ NG CAO (NĂM 3)
KHOA NN&VH ANH M ( HNN – HQGHN)
Trong tâm bu i h c Câu h i KN PP tương ng
Xác nh m c ích và i tư ng - M c tiêu c a ngư i vi t là gì?
Bài 1
ngư i c mà tác giá hư ng t i - i tư ng mà ngư i vi t ang hư ng t i?
- Ý chính c a ngư i vi t là gì?
- Ngư i vi t ã khai tri n ý chính ó như th
Phân bi t th c t và ý ki n;
nào?
Bài 2 Nh n xét v b c c và hình th c
- Ngư i vi t s d ng các d ki n, ý ki n hay k t
khai tri n ý tư ng c a tác gi
h p c hai?
- Li u ngư i vi t ã có d n ch ng và ví d ?
Ki m nh tính xác th c c a n i - Thông tin c a ngư i vi t ưa ra có xác th c?
Bài 3 dung thông tin và xác nh thành H p lý? Công b ng không?
ki n c a ngư i vi t
Nh n xét v vi c dùng t c a - B n có hi u ư c (d ng ý) s d ng t c a
Bài 4
ngư i vi t ngư i vi t?
Bài Nh n xét v l p lu n và s d ng - B n có ng ý v i quan i m c a ngư i vi t?
5,6 s li u c a ngư i vi t
_____________________________________
M T VÍ D V M T BÀI T P TÌNH HU NG MÀ GIÁO VIÊN T
THI T K VÀ TRÌNH BÀY
(trang sau)
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 3|Page

4. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ARE BLONDES REALLY DUMB?
__________________________________________
After reading a series of jokes about blonde girls at
http://www.comedy-
zone.net/jokes/laugh/blondes/index.htm ,Van askes Chris.
Van: Oh dear! These blondes are stupid in these
stories! How come people think of blonde girls
that way, Chris?
Chris: Not really all of them. Look at the article I cut from
Weekly World News on October 15, 1996 in my
scrapbook!
“See? With this piece of scientific evidence, noone can say that blondes are dumb
anymore!” Chris proudly concludes.
As a friend, what would you like to say to Van and/or Chris?
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 4|Page

5. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
M T VÍ D V PH N T NG K T LÝ THUY T
SAU KHI TH C HI N BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 5|Page

6. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
M T VÍ D V BIÊN B N H P NHÓM C A SINH VIÊN
KHI TH C HI N TH O LU N BÀI T P TÌNH HU NG
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 6|Page

7. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
M T S VÍ D KHÁC (D NG PLAIN TEXT, RÚT G N) V
BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG K T H P V I M NG
INTERNET DO GIÁO VIÊN T THI T K
Ví d 1 (s d ng trong bài 1: Xác nh m c ích và i tư ng ngư i c mà tác giá hư ng
t i)
Rose is a native speaker of English and she is invited to give a presentation to the CLC students
next week. Since the theme they are studying is Environment, she decides to choose
“Earthquakes” as the topic. She herself is not an expert in the field so she feels lucky when
finding three websites with plenty of information about the topic. However, she does not know
which should be the most proper source of information for her presentation. Can you help?
_ http://earthquake.usgs.gov/learning/kids.php
_ http://projects.crustal.ucsb.edu/understanding/
_ http://scitation.aip.org/EarthquakeSpectra/
Ví d 2: (s d ng trong bài 2: Phân bi t th c t và ý ki n)
Van, Rose’s Vietnamese friend, met her at the university canteen.
Rose: Hi, Van. You know what? Ricky Martin’s just welcomed his new twins. As his fan,
I’m so thrilled!
Van: I know. I read an article on the Net too. So he decides to come out after all.
Rose: Huh? What do you mean?
Who seems to misunderstand here and what caused this? Find out by going to the sites Rose
surfed to (http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,407341,00.html and
http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20220372,00.html) and the one that Van got
(http://vnexpress.net/GL/Van-hoa/2008/08/3BA05B7B/).
Ví d 3&4 (s d ng trong bài 3: Ki m nh tính xác th c c a n i dung thông tin và xác
nh thành ki n c a ngư i vi t)
3. Rose: Hot news! Miley Cirus has been killed in an accident!
Van: Oh dear. Please tell me you’re kidding. I adore her in Hannah Montana.
Rose: Take a look (showing her the page
http://www.discovervancouver.com/forums/miley%20cyrus%20died%20in%20a%20terrible
%20car%20accident/Breaking-News-Actress-Miley-Cyrus-Died-Terrible-t296424/
If you were Van, what would you say in this situation?
4. Two years ago, Rose was a freshman and in trouble finding which place to live: on or off
campus. But after reading an article from
http://www.vanguard.edu/uploadedFiles/ResidenceLife/Living%20On%20or%20Off%20Ca
mpus.pdf, she immediately made up her mind. What do you think about her decision?
Ví d 5 (s d ng trong bài 4: Nh n xét v vi c dùng t c a ngư i vi t)
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 7|Page

8. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
At the canteen, Rose orders some bean sprouts for her an Van. Upon looking at the dish, Van
cringes: “Keep it away from me!” Rose is slightly offended until Van sends her a webpage:
http://antimedia.wordpress.com/2007/07/17/su-an-uong-da-man/. Despite her poor
Vietnamese, it finally dawns on Rose what is really going on. Do you know?
Ví d 6&7 (s d ng trong bài 5,6: Nh n xét v l p lu n và cách s d ng s li u c a ngư i
vi t)
6. Van, Chris and Rose all team up for a presentation on the issues of traffic in Vietnam. After a
few days collecting information, they meet again and have a quick discussion:
Van: Let me see … for the next part, we intended to discover the reasons for the
traffic situations in Vietnam. I hope you guys do not find it too hard to
understand websites in Vietnamese.
Chris: Actually I do. That’s why I’ve just got a very short commentary from
http://www.hanoimoi.com.vn/vn/41/129222/ From this, I can see that the
increase in traffic accidents in Vietnam is due to people’s poor knowledge of
traffic rules.
Van: (Taking notes) Uh huh? Interesting. What about you, Rose?
Rose: Same here. Just a very short article from
http://www.vatgia.com/hoidap/4444/17917/mot-so-noi-o-viet-nam-minh-co-
duong-ray-xe-lua-o-tren-via-he-pho-thao-nao-tai-nan-xe-lua-nhieu-den-
the!.html. I often hang out in the Night Bazaar in the Ancient Quarter and notice
the railways running across several streets, which is really dangerous. I can say
that explains for the increasing number of train accidents in Vietnam.
Van: (Taking notes) Well, so far so … bad (laugh) But the good news is things are
looking up, aren’t they? I mean we have take actions, like compulsory helmet
wearing for motorcyclists, which accounts for the number of a remarkable
reduction in the number of traffic accidents. Here is the evidence … (sharing the
article from http://www.baovietnam.vn/xa-hoi/139923/11/So-nguoi-chet-giam-
manh-sau-mot-nam-doi-mu-bao-hiem).
Rose: Great. That’s it! Let’s work on the presentation now.
Chris: Just a sec, Rose. To be on the safe side, I think we may need time to look at our
arguments in this part again.
Rose: Come on, Chris. Isn’t it crystal clear now (showing Van’s notes below)?
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 8|Page

9. S D NG BÀI T P NGHIÊN C U TÌNH HU NG VÀ M NG INTERNET NH M PHÁT TRI N K NĂNG C PHÊ PHÁN C A
SINH VIÊN NĂM TH 3, KHOA ANH ( I H C NGO I NG , I H C QU C GIA HÀ N I)
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
So we’ve come up with all the concrete conclusions to explain for these
problems and improvements, many of which are obvious and claimed
repetitively by the mass media like people’s ignorance of the traffic rules. Why
bother checking them again?
They both now turn to Van for a decision. If you were her, who would you agree with,
Rose or Chris? Why?
7. Van found Rose sitting at the school canteen with her MP3 and earphones on.
Van: (tapping Rose’s back) Hi, Rose. How’s the song?
Rose: (taking off the earphones) Hi, Van. Oh you must hear this song by Lazyboys. The
song is full of great facts about the world that will sure take you aback! Look at
the lyrics (Giving a printed webpage at:
http://www.lyricsmania.com/lyrics/lazyboy_lyrics_3486/lazyboy_tv_lyrics_10920
/facts_of_life_lyrics_126662.html). Look! “5% of the population is gay”.
Van: I know.
Rose: You know?
Van: Yeah, I read from an article somewhere that Alfred Kinsey’s “Sexual Behavior in
the Human Male” (1948) announced that 10% of the male population is gay. The
2000 U.S. Census Bureau even found that homosexual couples constitute less
than 1% of American households. The National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
estimates three to eight percent of both sexes, and …
Rose: (interrupt) …and Wow! I’m bemused by what you know! Don’t tell me that you
are …
Van: (blushing) Sorry to disappoint you but no. Just because you’ve asked someone
who made a presentation on Gay Marriage last week (laugh)
Rose: (laugh) Ok, but seriously I’m confused. Which source of data is more reliable? It
must be the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force in my opinion. They must know
well enough to come up with that figure.
Van: Well, I think …
How far do you agree with Rose and what do you think Van is going to say?
________________________________________Vu Hai Ha, HULIS 9|Page