This document discusses the concept of colorblind racism in the United States. It begins by providing historical context on shifts from de jure and de facto racism pre-1960 to the challenges of covert racism post-civil rights movement. While civil rights eliminated legalized racism, racial disparities remain in areas like income, education, health, and incarceration. The document then examines these disparities in more detail and discusses how colorblind racism rationalizes them through notions of diversity, meritocracy, and blaming people of color rather than addressing systemic inequalities or covert racism.
2. Historical Shifts
Pre 1960 the United States had both De Jure and De
Facto Racism
The Role of the Civil Rights Movement Challenging
Covert Racism
Tactics:
Pleas for Racial Equality
Elimination of Difference; Race seen as Racism
Integration
Racism as ‘Mean’/ Immoral
3.
4. Yet, Racial Disparities Continue...
Civil Rights eliminated De Jure Racism
Did not rectify unequal advantages and disadvantages
“Racism Lite”
6. Income
Median Family Income (2010):
White: $62,545
Black/ African American: $38,409
Asian/ Pacific Islander: $75,027*
Hispanic/Latino: $30,653
Percent Below Poverty Level (2009)
White Alone: 12.3%
Black Alone: 25.8%
Asian Alone: 12.5%
Hispanic: 25.3%
United States Census Bureau (2010). “Money Income of
Families, Median Value.
________. (2010). “Percent Below the Poverty Level.
7. A Closer Look at those Asian
Numbers....
2007-2009 Poverty Rates broken down by
Asian Ethnic group...
Ethnic Group Percent in Poverty
Hmong 26%
Bangladeshi 20%
Cambodian 18%
Pakastani 15%
Vietnamese 14%
Thai 14%
Total Population (US) 14%
Asian
American
Center
for
Advancing
Justice.
A
Community
of
Contrasts:
Asian
Americans
in
the
United
States.
(2011).
“Poverty
by
Ethnic
Group”
8. Income Gaps Across Educational
Attainment
United
States
Census.
(2010).
“Degrees
Earned
by
Level
and
Race/Ethnicity”
9. Education
Drop-Out Rates (2012)
White: 5.1%
Black: 8.0%
Hispanic: 15.1%
API: 4.2%
American Indian/Alaska Native: 12.4%
Schools with high rates of Latino and African American Students
(CA):
Have an 11 times higher rate of having under-qualified teachers.
74% more likely to lack textbooks for students to use for homework.
73% more likely to report having issues with cockroaches, rats or
mice.
U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics. (2012). The Condition of
Education 2012 (NCES 2012-045),Indicator 33.
American Civil Liberties Union. (2007). Race and Ethnicity in America.
10. Separate out the API Category for
Education...
Educational Attainment by Ethnic Group (2007-2009)
Ethnic Group High School
Degree or Higher
College Degree
or Higher
Total Population 85% 28%
Thai 84% 42%
Chinese (Except
Taiwanese)
82% 50%
Bangladeshi 81% 47%
Vietnamese 72% 27%
Laotion 66% 12%
Cambodian 62% 14%
Hmong 61% 14%
Asian
American
Center
for
Advancing
Justice.
A
Community
of
Contrasts:
Asian
Americans
in
the
United
States.
(2011).
“Educational
Attainment
by
Ethnic
Group”
12. Health
Infant Mortality Rates Per Every 1,000 live births (2007)
Black: 13.3
American Indian: 9.22
Puerto Rican: 7.71
Non-Hispanic White: 5.63
API: 4.78
People Without Health Insurance (2008)
Hispanics: 30.4%
African American/Black: 17%
White: 9.9%
McDorman, M., Matthews, T. (2011). “Understanding Racial and Ethnic Disparities in U.S. Infant Mortality Rates”.
NCHS Data Brief, 74.
Centers for Disease Control. (2008). “People Without Health Insurance Coverage by Race/Ethnicity”
13. Incarceration- For Men
1 in 3
1 in 6
1 in 17
Mauer,
Marc.
(2011).
“Addressing
Racial
Disparities
in
Incarceration”
Prison
Journal,
91.
14. Incarceration- For Women
1 out of 18
1 out of 45
1 out of 111
Mauer,
Marc.
(2011).
“Addressing
Racial
Disparities
in
Incarceration”
Prison
Journal,
91.
15. Rates of Incarceration
(Per 100,000 People)
Race National California
White 412 460
Black 2290 2992
Hispanic/Latino 742 782
The Sentencing Project. (2007) “Uneven Justice: State Rates of Incarceration by Race and Ethnicity”
16. What Gives?
Civil Rights Movement erased overt
discrimination and racism.
Structural advantage/disadvantage remains
Racial ideology remains
Tim Wise on Institutionalized Racism and Incarceration
17. What is Colorblind Racism?
“Explains contemporary racial inequality as the
outcome of non-racial dynamics...whites
rationalize minorities’ contemporary status as
the product of market dynamics, naturally
occurring phenomena, and blacks’ [and other
people of color] imputed cultural limitations”
(Bonilla-Silva, 2)
18. Diversity and Multiculturalism
Diversity:
Consumption of popular culture
Tension between individual acceptance of personal difference
vs. resistance to group changes
Diversity is deeply racialized; a way to talk about race without
talking about it.
Multiculturalism
No mention of inequality
Assumes white center, everyone else brings culture
19. Colorblind Rhetoric About
Disparities
“They just don’t
value education as
much as we do”
“Asians were able to
assimilate and do well,
why can’t these other
minorities?”
“Well, there are more
Blacks and Latinos in
prison because they
commit more crimes”
“Where are
you from?”
“I don’t see race, I just
see people”
“They just don’t
work as hard; if
they wanted it
more, they would
make more
money”
20. Consequences
If we don’t talk about race, we can’t fix it
Blames People of Color for their own failures;
bases White success on personal merit
Allows for racist laws, and policies to be
implemented without being labeled racist
21. Discussion Questions
What are the differences between Colorblind
Racism (CBR) of today and the Overt Racism
of the 1950s?
What are some examples of de facto racism
today?
How are the concepts of diversity and
multiculturalism evidence of CBR?
What are examples of the economic, cultural,
or natural explanations of racial disparity that
CBR uses?