Más contenido relacionado
La actualidad más candente (20)
Judgmentof15june1962 kh
- 7. „fä£gbòš
„t™v£q{ü¤lulš¶ bzû™sõ™ssŸ}Ȼuxšuõ™ɐɖ¶ vsv÷čìqò™ȸ¨fɈ{
¥uuõ™ɐɖv£fâ quž~ýx¨¤lu£l |ȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b lžg¤l}ýqȠ~b¨pq£ȱ{dpª
bzûȧ|gýz©|vdžȾdš¶ }bãpªz™ugɍɂ¥u}sõw}b¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪböăf
q¨vuȿu~ĜɃs¶ ȧ|v£fâ q¤wusš£ȱ{„öbi¨Ⱥk¥uȾdšȿŁf ȶz¨£p |vȾdš
ȿŁf£s¢q¶ ¤wusš¤l}ȿu}bãpªz™uȬvvf㨣ɪcpª£x}¤l}¤wusš£Ⱥ©ýqȠ~
Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ f¶ ȧ|ýxzssŸ}{bȮvuòvȺōvuž~¤wusšu™f¤cĀýx¨¤luȶz|{ª
‡|ĜɀvrȾdšȿŁf£s¢q¶ ɉuȾxdq™{qò¥uȧ|£æĔzɆŃq¤l}ýqȠ~ȬqsbȷȻu
{}ýxz£ȱ{qpŖšȾx¶ ȧ|„©ɉf„¨xšȾxz™uývȩŏ¥u¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ£} ¤wusš
ȮzŸ{u›f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bȮb¤òf¶ ȧ|ýxzssŸ}{buž~ɇu™y²{¥uȧ|Ⱦuýgƒ¨¶
‡|ĜɀvrvuòvȺōv¤l}vɐņbuž~ȧ|ssŸ}{}ýxzxšl¨vžfu™f¤l}ɁɁ¨fz™u“ü
vl™£tȧ|ssŸ}{}ýxz£Ⱥ©~ĜkȻu¶ ɉuȾx¥uuõ™ɐɖȮvuòvȺōv¤l}
vɐņbuž~ýx¨¤lu¤l}ȿuýɆvu™fȮyòăȶf¥uv¨pfgfȻu|vdžȾdšuž~ýx¨¤lu
¤l}ȿuó™|Ⱦxu™fɆŌx|¶ ȧ|vbýɆ{„¨xšl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{böăfuõ™ɐɖýqȠ~Ȼu
£} bzbx™Ȭ|ȵȸ¨fýf £ȱ{|Ÿzȸ¨f¤wusšwf¤l|¶
ÃËÈÄ
ÃÇ z™rȺ
vč隣}cÆÇ
- 8. 4
Ɇ}lšȧ
~qòȿu¸ £ɂb :,1,$56., ývȹu
£ɂb $/)$52 „uývȹu
£ɂb %$6'(9$17 %$'$:, 025(12 48,17$1$ :(//,1*721
.22 6,5 3(5 63(1'(5 6,5 *(5$/' ),7=0$85,( .25(76.
7$1$.$ %867$0$17( 5,9(52 025(//, £ɜýbz
£ɂb *$51,(52,*1(7 ýbɈvč隶
böăf£|¡fbòšýȻɆsýx©~™ɇ|
|Ƀf
ýx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ
q¨ȵf£ȱ{¸
‘b‰qòz £ýs¡f ȧf ȿi™b‰qòzýbzýv›bɏɁiv}þ²f⸠Ȯq¨ȵf
u™f£ȱ{¸
‘b‰qòz „¬b j¨ „däsšýv›bɏ„zɆŌusžqbzùăȮývȬ¨£ɪýv£sȻɁ¨f
iŸ{£ȱ{¸
‘b‰qòz 'HDQ $FKHVRQ ȿi™bdpª£zȹ~ĝ¥uqɂȧ|b¨xž}¥u‚|lîɉ£z|Ĝb
£ɂb 5RJHU 3LQWR ɆĚɆŋȬ|ü¥uzɇ~ĜsɎ}²{gɍvsšýbfȻŘ|ĝ
£ɂb 3DXO 5HXWHU ɆĚɆŋȬ|ü¥uzɇ~ĜsɎ}²{gɍvsšýbfȻŘ|ĝ
Ȯ£zȹ~ĝ
u™f£ȱ{¸
£ɂb %ULFH 0 ODJHWW ȿi™bdpª£zȹ~ĝɆɂ‰sõ|p¯‚|lîɉ£z|Ĝb¥uýbf
bž}žzv¬ć 'LVWULFW RI ROXPELD
- 10. 5
£ɂb~|£uš{¯‘b f™u ȧ£|ġq Ⱥ{b¥uȺ{bȱʼnuyžz™ɆĚò¥ubf£ɀtx}
£cz|yžz™uô Ȯsšýv›bɏ‘b£s
£ɂb Ȭu {žɁŘu Ȯ„dä£}Ȩt™ȧ|¥udpªývq™yž
£ɂb ¤gz æąu Ȯ„dä£}Ȩt™ȧ||f¥udpªývq™yž
u™f
ɁȮȵgýb¥r
q¨ȵf£ȱ{¸
ýx©„fäȿń 9RQJVDPDKLS -DDQNXUD „däɁisžq¥rývȬ¨£ɪýv£s‚žƒf
Ȯq¨ȵf
iŸ{£ȱ{¸
£ɂb 6HQL 3UDPRM ȿi™bdpª£zȹ~ĝ¥uýv£s¥r
£ɂb +HQUL 5ROLQ ɆĚɆŋȬ|üb™qò™{¥u )UHH 8QLYHUVLW RI %UXVVHOV £zȹ~ĝ
¥uɆɂ‰sõ|p¯sšýbf %UXVVHOV
‘b‰qòz 6LU )UDQN 6RVNLFH 403 „qšq„däýx©ɁiɉȮŇ¥uýv£s„f£dþ
£ɂb -DPHV 1HYLQV +GH ȿi™b¥udpª£zȹ~ĝ¥u|lî 1HZ RUN u™fȮ
ȿi™b¥udpª£zȹ~ĝ¥uqɂȧ|b¨xž}‚|lîɉ£z|Ĝb
£ɂb 0DUFHO 6OXVQ £zȹ~ĝ¥uɆɂ‰sõ|p¯sšýbf %UXVVHOV u™fȮɆĚɆŋȬ|ü¥u
)UHH 8QLYHUVLW RI %UXVVHOV
£ɂb - * /H 4XHVQH ȿi™bdpª£zȹ~ĝ¥uýv£s„f£dþ
Ȯ£zȹ~ĝu™fsšýv›bɏgɍv
u™f£ȱ{¸
‰qòz£uš{¯‘b %XVULQGUH %KDNGLNXO „däȺ{b¥u„däȺ{bȱʼnuyžz™ɆĚòyžz™uô
¥r¥uýbŸfȧ|Ƚ|Ȯq™
£ɂb 6XN 3HUXQDYLQ „u£}Ȩt™ȧ||f¥ucsôȧ}²{Ⱥ{b|lîzĚuòš
£ɂb KLQGD 1D 6RQJNKOD „dä£}Ȩt™ȧ||f¥udpªbzûȧ|zcȫ|Ɇȹ|pª
- 11. 6
£ɂb~|£uš{¯£ȸ 3KRRQ 3KRQ $VDQDFKLQWD ɆĚɆŋȬ|ü¥uɆ}Ȳu£}Ȩ
ɆĚò „däȺ{bȱʼnuyžz™ɆĚòyžz™uô¥r¥uýbŸfȧ|Ƚ|Ȯq™
Ȯsšýv›bɏ‘b£s
u™f£ȱ{¸
£ɂb KDSLNRUQ 6UHVKWKDSXWUD ývȹuȺ{bȱʼnuušq™bzû¥u„däȺ{bȱʼnuuõ™
ɐɖu™fušq™bzû¥uýbŸfȧ|v|£s
£ɂb 'DYLG 6 'RZQV £zȹ~ĝqɂȧ|b¨xž}ýv£s„f£dþ
Ȯsšýv›bɏ¤wöbqɂȧ|
qɂȧ|
¤l}ȿuȿȾxlžgȨf£}
~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšlžgȨf£ýȧz¸
ȶz|{ªɆ}lšȧg©¥ræsšÄÈ ¤c‰Ⱦ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈà qɂȧ|ȻuýȬu£Ȭ}
už~„čìýqbzûvmzsšÃ|v|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r £‚ {|b£e kȷqɂȧ|£u©ȿu{ȶŋt™ȧ|
~Ĝu™gè²{£} ~ĜɃs¤l}Ȼuȱbižuqɂȧ|ȧ}xš¥ræsšÈ ¤cqɂ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇË ȶzȽbü
¨|v|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ¶
ȶz|{ªlšȧ£ýzg¤l}ȿuȧ}v|Ĝ£gèslžgȩŏ qɂȧ|Ȼu£ýzgb¨pq
|{ª£x}ýȿvȱbl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtšv¤uóz¶ ¨pɓ¨£|¡fýqȠ~Ȼu£|¢vg¨|ŸgɁ}ýȿv
£tÿ ~Ⱥȧ|ȶzȧ|ȱbižuuž~l¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtšgf£ýȧ{ g©¥ræsšÄ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÈĶ
~Ⱥȧ|ȮɆȹ|pªýqȠ~£tÿ £ƒ fȶzȧ}v|Ĝ£gèslžgq£ɨ¸ Ȭvxš¥ræsšÃ
l}¥ræsšÅ ¤czšȺ £ɪ¥ræsšÇ ¤czšȺ xš¥ræsšÉl}¥ræsšÃ ¤czšȺ xš¥ræsšÃÄl}
¥ræsšÃÅ ¤czšȺ xš¥ræsšÃÇl}¥ræsšÃÉ ¤czšȺ xš¥ræsšÃËl}¥ræsšÄÆ ¤czšȺ u™f
xš¥ræsšÄÈl}¥ræsšÅà ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈĶ £ɪböăf~Ⱥȧ|ȸ¨f£u© qɂȧ|Ɇŋv
sƒȞšb|p¯ u™fȧ|£hþ {qvȼō}ȿq|v£ɂb £ýs¡f ȧf £ɂb 'HDQ $FKHVRQ
- 12. 7
£ɂb 5RJHU 3LQWR u™f£ɂb 3DXO 5HXWHU q¨ȵf“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ u™fýx©„fä
ȿń 9RQJVDPDKLS -DDQNXUD £ɂb 6HQL 3UDPRM £ɂb +HQUL 5ROLQ 6LU )UDQN
6RVNLFH £ɂb -DPHV 1HYLQV +GH q¨ȵf“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r¶
£ɪböăf~Ⱥȧ| Ȭvxš¥ræsšÃÇl}¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ qɂȧ|Ȼu
ɆŋvɆbĀšu™f„öbi¨Ⱥk¤l}Ȼu£ȧ©£ɷ£ȱ{džȾdšȸ¨ffȨf £l z÷šzb£hþ {
u›f¨pɕ|¤l}Ÿ|£ɨxŸb£d böăfȧ|Ɇŋvg£zþ {u™fȧ|Ÿ|qs}£ȱ{Ⱦdš|vcþąu
u™f£ȱ{Ⱦdšvl™vbã u™f£ȱ{£ɜýbzqɂȧ|¶ ɆbĀš¤l}Ȼuwò}yòăȶfȿu
Ɂ{ȺzlžgȨf£ýȧz¸
£ȧ©£ɷ£ȱ{|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ¸
£ɂb Ÿu v¬u „qšq„y™Ȼ}£cqòb¨xft¨ „t™ȧ|¤wöbb™gçȧ|u£ɀȻ{ u™f
|lîȻ}¥uýbŸfzɇ¥wôbzùăȮ ȮɆbĀš¶
£ȧ©£ɷ£ȱ{|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r¸
£ɂbɆĚɆŋȬ|ü :LOOHP 6FKHUPHUKRUQ ýx›sõv|¥uziêzpŊ}vpĎď©
vȵɑ}„uò|Ȯq™ýȿvɃ¤~f¤wusš¤luɉȧ 'HOIW u™fȮȺ{b¥uȺ{bȱʼnu
ýv›bɏ£ɀv}ýȿvziêzpŊ} Ȯ„öbi¨Ⱥk¶
£ɂb )ULHGULFK ( $FNHUPDQQ 'LSO ,QJ ȮɆĚɆŋȬ|ü¥uziêzpŊ}vpĎď©
vȵɑ}„uò|Ȯq™ýȿvɃ¤~f¤wusš¤luɉȧ 'HOIW u™fȮȿi™b¥uȺ{bȱʼnu
ýv›bɏ£ɀv}ýȿvziêzpŊ} ȮɆbĀšu™fȮ„öbi¨Ⱥk¶
£ɂb +HUPDQ 7KHRGRRU 9HUVWDSSHQ Ȯ„öb‘b£sȨfyžz™ȵ˴u~ĜsɎ
ývȹu¤wöbyždxúɆĚò¥uziêzpŊ}vpĎď©vȵɑ}„uò|Ȯq™ýȿvɃ¤~f¤wusš
¤luɉȧ 'HOIW Ȯ„öbi¨Ⱥk¶
£ɪböăf~Ⱥȧ|¤l}ýqȠ~£tÿ £ɪ¥ræsšÃË ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ qɂȧ|Ȼuȼŗb
£‚ {iŸvývi¨ȩŏ£ƒ f~ĜkȮ„Ɇȹ|pª£ɪböăfvuôv £l z÷šsĀȺ¤cĀȾx{uò„¨xš
sšȶ¨fs¨Ⱥ¤l}ȾdšbzùăȮȻuȱbižu £ȱ{ȿu~qòȿu|vq¨ȵfȾdšȸ¨ff
- 13. 8
Ȩf¶ böăf£x}¥uȧ|vɐń¨f¤cĀȾx{uò£Ⱥ© u™f£ȱ{ȿuȧ|„uɐɖqxšývȹu
£ɂb Ÿu v¬u ȻuvȫŖk£ȱ{£fãv„¨xšg¨pɓgȸ¨fɈ{¤l}ȸbsf£ɨu›f
„f䣂q¶
£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|¥uušq™~ĜtšȮɂ{}bãp¯„bĀ| džȾdšȻuȱbižuuž~£gbòš
£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{lžgȨf£ýȧz£u©¸
ȶfȺz“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ¸
£ɪböăfvpĎ›fu™f£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš¸
£ȸ©všȮɁȮȵgýb¥rgž}cþąuŽz™ugž}cþąub±£ȱ{ žzqɂȧ|£zȶŋ£tÿ
ȧ|~Ĝu™gè²{u™fývȧȷ¸
(Ã) ɁȮȵgýb¥r ȿuȧqxÿb™gçýqȠ~lb£gk“ü„už~bfbȿŔ¨fývȱv
ɉ~t ¤l}cþąuȻu£Ȼ©sšȶ¨f£ɪ~Ĝb™pñȱʼnu¥uýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| Ȭvȶ¨f
xšȭŏ¨ÃËÇƶ
(Ä) „t™v£q{ü¤lulš£} ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| Ȯbzû™sõ™|výx©ɁȮȵgýb
bzùăȮ¶
£ɪböăfȧ|£hþ {qv¸
žzqɂȧ|£zȶŋ¸
I.- ýȬu£Ȭ}už~£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ ¤l}ȱbižu£ȱ{ɁȮȵgýb¥r
£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtšqv|v¥r Ȯx™£böăfb|pšȬ¨Ȼgg¨£Ƚ©ȧ|
vȫŖkuž~¨ɉf£‚qȺȺ ýȿvȧ|vl™£tuž~£gbòš£ö ¨v¤uózȺȺ
¤l}u›fɉgȱbižuqɂȧ|£ȱ{ɁȮȵgýb¥rȮ{ȷ£‚q¶
II.- £ýzg£gbòšȶz£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ȸ¨fɈ{ ¤l}ȿu£ɪböăf
vpĎ›f£wò zušq™~Ĝtš£u©|vbzùăȮ u™f£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|vbzùăȮ¶
- 14. 9
žz£zȶŋ~Ĝu™gè²{u™fývȧȷ¸
Ã.- ɁȮȵgýb¥r ȿuȧqxÿb™gçýqȠ~lb£gkuž~bfbȿŔ¨fývȱvɉ~t¤l}
cþąuȻu£Ȼ©sšȶ¨f£ɪ~Ĝb™pñȱʼnu¥uýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| Ȭvȶ¨fxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇƶ
Ä.- „t™v£q{ü¤lulš£} ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| Ȯbzû™sõ™|výx©ɁȮȵgýb
bzùăȮ¶
ȶfȺz“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r¸
£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtšqv¸
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ȷ¸
(Ã) ȧ|ȸzȸ||výx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ £ɪböăfȽbüvpĎ›fu™fl¨£p |ȧ|
ušq™~Ĝtš z™uȿuzž}ȱʼnu£s u™fdv÷šýqȠ~ȻuýȬu£Ȭ}¶
(Ä) ýȻ~Ĝɇuó™q£ɪböăf¤lulš¥uýv£s¥r¸ žzqɂȧ|Ȯsš£ȩ|x£zȶŋ
£tÿ ȧ|~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧlž£gö©¶
£ɪböăf£x}l¨£p |ȧ|¥uušq™~Ĝtšȸk£‚qw}£ȱ{ȼō}ȿq £ɪböăf£x}
v™s~Ⱥȧ| Ⱥ¥ræsšÃÅ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ £zȹ~ĝ¥uýv£s¥rȻu£ö ¨xuɎ|£x}
£tÿ £gbòš£ö ¨gf£ýȧ{böăfȺz“üýv£s¥r |‚žql}£ýȧ{£x}ɆŋvɆbĀšu™f
„öbi¨Ⱥk¶ „öbq¨ȵf|vȾdšbzùăȮýqȠ~Ȼu£ö ¨“üvȫŖksĀuª|vcþąu„¨xš
vɐŖ£u© u™fȻuývȧȷcþąuȿuȧ|£i¡Ȯbȸ¨fýf£} Ⱦx{qò™tz®u™fdq™vpŊ™q
|vqɂȧ|¶ £ýȧ{xšȻux™Ⱦbɏȩŏ|Ÿg qɂȧ|Ȼu£ýzg{}ýxzg¨£Ƚ©ȧ|
£ö ¨£gbòš„uɐɖq£ȱ{cþąu{}£e kȷ vȺōvxšȻuɆŋvɆbĀšu™f„öbi¨Ⱥk
u™f£ɪzu£x}¤l}Ⱦdš¥r£tÿ £gbòš£ö ¨gf£ýȧ{ „öbq¨ȵf|vȾdšbzùăȮɉg
ȱbuž~£gbòš¤b}zĂ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨|vcþąu ýv™u£v cþąuȿuv¨pfgf£tÿ vȺōvxš
ȻuɆŋvɆbĀšu™f„öbi¨Ⱥkȸ¨f£Ⱥ©¶
£gbòš£ö ¨~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}ȱbižuqɂȧ|£ȱ{džȾdš £ɪböăfušq™~Ĝtšȸk
£‚qw}£ȱ{ȼō}ȿq £‚ {Ȯx™£vȺōvxšȧ|£ýzgȨf£l z ȿulžgȨf
£ýȧz¸
- 15. 10
ȶfȺz“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ¸
b £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ ¤l}ýqȠ~ȻuɉuȺ£x}£tÿ ~Ⱥȧ|¥ræsšÇ ¤czšȺ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÈĸ
žzqɂȧ|£zȶŋ¸
Ã. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ¤cĀýx¨¤lu|ɃfbzùăȮu™f¥r £ɪq¨vulf¤|b
dœȮ¤cĀ¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ¤wusš|vdpªbzûȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu|Ƀf‡pŊĐ
g™uu™f£¢z (‰vzù²uõäl}ȿuȾņvu›fl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|vȾdšbzùăȮ)¶
Ä. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ȿusšȶ¨fó™q£ɪböăf¤lu
lš£ýȧz„t™v£q{ü|výx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ¶
Å. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ɁȮȵgýb¥rȿuȧqxÿb™gçýqȠ~lb£gkuž~
bfbȿŔ¨fývȱvɉ~t ¤l}cþąuȻu£Ȼ©sšȶ¨f£ɪ~Ĝb™pñȱʼnu¥uýȻɆsýx©
~Ĝɇ|böăf¤lulšbzùăȮ Ȭvȶ¨fxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆzb¶
Æ. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ Ɂ}|žvgȿŔb ™ɂȬ|Ğb v¨¤pb¥uýȻɆs
d¨|žrûybu™fbɂ}Ⱦiu¯vɁp ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu{b£gkxšýȻɆs£ȱ{
ɉȮŇt|¥r ȶ¨f¤qxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ |ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥rýqȠ~¤qývd}zb“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}
¥uýx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ~Ĝk¶
c £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ ¤l}ȿu£ȯœ©ȷ£gbòš£ö ¨gf£ýȧ{¤l}ýqȠ~ɉu
£ɪböăf~Ⱥȧ| ¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ
žzqɂȧ|£zȶŋ¸
Ã. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ¤wusšq¨vulf¤|b(‰vzù²uõÃ¥ul¨£p |ȧ|
ušq™~Ĝtš|vȾdšbzùăȮ) ȻuýqȠ~dž£ƒ fu™f£Ȼ©xzùwɏ{böăfȺzu™fȮ
ýv£ɀiu¯l}dpªbzûȧ|gýz©b¨pqýx¨¤lu ¤l}Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ f£ȱ{
„uɐɖg©¥ræsšÃÅ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ ȷ¤wusš£u© q¨ȵf“ü£gbòš
£ýzg|vdpªbzûȧ|Ȩf£} £u© u™f£ȱ{Ɇ|£‚qȧ|p¯u™fȶz
£‚qw}¥ub™gçýxz£ýx¢fu™f‡|ĜɀvrvuòvȺōv|vdžȾdš ȷ¤wusš£u©
ȿu}bãpªȮuõ™ɐɖ¶
- 16. 11
Ä. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ¤cĀýx¨¤lu|ɃfbzùăȮu™f¥r£ɪböăfq¨vu
i£ȿŔ©£u©böăfv|Ĝ£~pýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| dœȮ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£}
¤wusš|vdpªbzûȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu|Ƀf‡pŊĐg™u-£¢z (‰vzù²uõ à ¥u
l¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|vbzùăȮ)¶
Å. ~Ĝu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ȿusšȶ¨fó™q£ɪböăf
¤lulš£ýȧz„t™v£q{ü|výx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ¶
Æ ~Ĝu™gè²{u™fývȧȷ ɁȮȵgýb¥rȿuȧqxÿb™gçýqȠ~lb£gkuž~bf
bȿŔ¨fývȱvɉ~t ¤l}cþąuȻu£Ȼ©sšȶ¨f£ɪ~Ĝb™pñȱʼnu¥uýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|
£ɪböăf¤lulšbzùăȮ Ȭvȶ¨fxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆzb¶
Ç Ɏɩu™gè²{£gbòšu™fývȧȷ Ɂ}|žvgȿŔb ™ɂȬ|Ğb v¨¤pb¥uýȻɆs
d¨|žrûybu™fbɂ}Ⱦiu¯vɁp ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu{b£gkxšýȻɆs£ȱ{
ɉȮŇt|¥r ȶ¨f¤qxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ |ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥rýqȠ~¤qývd}zb“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥u
ýx©ɁȮȵgýbbzùăȮ~Ĝk¶
ȶfȺz“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r ¸
b £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuɉu£ɪböăf~Ⱥȧ|¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ
Ƚbx²uõu›f£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼuȱb£ȱ{|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ£ɪ
¥ræsšÇ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ |ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥ržzȱbižuqɂȧ|už~£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{
|vcþąu lžgȨf£ýȧz¸
Ã. žzqɂȧ|£zȶŋb¨ssŸ}{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵ£} ȧ|ȸzȸ| ¤l}Ȼu£ö
£ȱ{ȾdšbzùăȮ £ɪböăfbȷcpŊsšÃu™fsšÆ ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}
ȱbižu£ȱ{„öbq¨ȵf|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮ ȧ}xš¥ræg²uô sšÇ ¤czšȺ £ȱ{
£‚qȷȧ|ȸzȸ|ȸ¨fxš|£u©ýqȠ~Ȼuȱb{œq£x}£xb £‚ {z™uȻuvčçĄ}
£ɨböăfȧ|ȸzȸ|ȸ¨fɈ{ ¤l}|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮȻuȿuv¨pfȱbižu
qɂȧ|£ɪböăfvpĎ›f£wò zušq™~Ĝtš£u© Žböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~ĜtšȮɂ{}bãp¯
„bĀ| £‚ {£u©dœȮ£} bl¨vžf¤l}„öbq¨ȵf|vbzùăȮ£} b£ƒ f£ɪ£x}
- 17. 12
¤l}ȩqȻu£tÿ £gbòš£ö ¨|vbzùăȮ¶ £‚qlž£gö©Ⱦdš¥ržz£ö qɂȧ|
ȷz™udŸ|ssŸ}{bȧ|ȸzȸ|ȸ¨f£u©zbx™Ȭ|ȵ£s¶
Ä. Ȯi¨uŸ~Ĝk
Ƚbx²uõu›fȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÃ ¥uȧ|ȸzȸ|ȸ¨fɈ{Ȩf£} £u© Ⱦdš¥ržz
ȱbižuuž~£gbòšuö™ȱʼnulžgȨf£ýȧz¸
(i) £dz™uɉgvɐņbȻuȷ ¤wusš‰vzù²uõà Ȯ‘bɆ|¤l}
qýzȠ~“üȾdšȸ¨f„£ȩ|xȶz£Ⱥ©£s £v £ȸ©všȮȶzcþ›zɆ|
¥u„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ Žȶz£‚qw}£wĀfxš£u©b±£ȱ{ ¶
(ii) ȶzx™q ýv£s¥ru™fýv£sbzùăȮx¨ȻuȬqsbýx¨¤lu¤l}
Ȼudž£ɪ£} ‰vzù²uõà Ȯýx¨¤lu|Ƀfýv£s¥ru™fýv£s
bzùăȮ £ɪböăfq¨vuyö¨lf¤|b£s¶
(iii) £ȱ{Ɇ|£‚qw}ȸ¨fɈ{Ȩf£} £u© ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼu
dž£ɪböăf‰vzù²uõà z™udŸ|{bzbi¨uŸ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}ȿu
ýɆv£ɪȶziŸ|yö¨lf¤|b£Ⱥ©£s ¤l}ȶzx™qýqȠ~ȻuȾdšȸ¨f
xš|£tÿ ȧ|bqȿł}u™fssŸ}{b|Ÿg£‚ {¶
(iv) lž£gö© £ȸ©všȮqɂȧ|{}£e kȷ zývu›fssŸ}{b
zbx™Ȭ|ȵuž~ȧ|ȸzȸ| (I) Ȩf£} Ⱥ£x}£u© ¤l}£ö £ƒ f
£ȱ{bzùăȮ wôă{u›f£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{|v¥rb±£ȱ{ b±¥r
žz£ö ȷ ȧ|ȸzȸ|£u©z™uȿuzž}ȱʼnuýdvýȩu£s ¤wĂbȶz
„fä£gbòš £‚ {dv÷švl™£t£Ȭ}¶
Å žzȱbižu£gbòš£ö ¨v¤uózlžgȨf£ýȧz £l z÷š£hþ {qvu›f£gbòš
£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÄu™fsšÅ|vbzùăȮ¸
(i) ȿuyòăȶfȮ£ýg uvȫŖkȷ ýdv£x}£~ɂ¨Ȩu¹ȸ¨f„
¥rȻu„u~qò„t™v£q{ü£xk£}kböăfq¨vuýȻɆs£u© £ȱ{
ȩœubzùăȮ¶ wôă{£ɨ~Ĝk ýv™u£v „t™v£q{ü£u©ýqȠ~Ȼuvl™£t
- 18. 13
£‚ {ýv™u£v bzùăȮȻu„u~qòzcȫ||lîȻ}|vcþąuȵzŸ{
£ɪböăfq¨vuȨf£} bzûȾx¤vv£Ⱥ©ȿu}bãpªzòfȿŀ}
u™fz™uýȻblývȮ £‚ {£ȸ©ó™qböăfb|pšȵb±£ȱ{ b±z™u
ɉg}v£Ȭ} Žbýz™qȧ|„u~qò„t™v£q{ü£xk£}k|v¥r
£ɪböăfq¨vuȨf£} £u©Ȼu£ƒ {¶
(ii) ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b£ɪböăfq¨vuȨf£} ývȩŏȾd£ýg uu›fg¨£ȵq
rûi¨~ĜkýȻ~Ĝɇu u™fv£fâ qȻuȮýx¨¤luȶzuõ™čì£ɪböăf
q¨vuȨf£} £u© lžgȿu¤gfböăf„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂƶ
(iii) £ɪböăfbýz™q¤l}ȷ ¤dzg¨£ȵqrûz™uývȩŏȸ¨fýf£ɨu›f
¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›blžgȻuvȫŖk“ü£e k£ȱ{ȵ˴ulš£ɪböăf
q¨vu£u© Ⱦxcȩŏ¥uv¤ýzvýzȡ}ȿubýz™qq™gqŸgv«£ȵɒ©
£‚ {z™udŸ|{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵ£s¶
(iv) }bãpªsž£ɨ¥uq¨vu£Ⱥ© „uɐɖq“üȿuýgbgž}£ɨȧu
ýȻɆsxšȨfýv£s¥r |ĝ‘ýgbgž}ýȻɆsxšȨfýv£s
bzùăȮ ýqȠ~£ƒ fȧqg¨£ȵqyö¨cù xšɃ}s¨ȺvbzùăȮ¶
(v) böăfȧ}ª£sª¥u£|¡fbòš£u© £dz™uɉg„u~qò£l z÷šȮýv£ɀiu¯
l}bzùăȮuž~}sõ™ȵzŸ{ ¤l}£} b£ƒ f£ȱ{£zȹ~ĝbzùăȮ
£ƒ { z™uȷȮȧ|{}ýxz (acquiescence) ȧ|z™u¤ývýbƒ©
zòš (estoppel) ŽɉȮŇ{ȧ} (prescription) £Ⱥ©£s¶
(vi) £ȸ©böăfb|pšȵb±£ȱ{ qɂȧ|z™udŸ|„uɐɖq“übzùăȮȱb
£ö ¨ȧ|ȸzȸ|zŸ{ £ȱ{¤wĂb£} ɉȮŇ{ȧ}¤l}x¨ȿu
£} b£ƒ f£ɪb¤uþfȵzŸ{£Ɇ© £ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|v
cþąu Ž|‚žql}i™qgfvčçv¥uȧ|vȫŖk£‚qw}£ȱ{ȼō}
ȿq|vcþąu £s v£} b£ƒ fuž~ȧ|ȸzȸ|¤vv£u©¶
- 19. 14
(vii) £ȸ©böăfb|pšȵb±£ȱ{ yòăȶf¤l}Ȯýv£ɀiu¯l}bzùăȮ
z™uýdvýȩuȸ¨fýf £l z÷šwò}“übzùăȮuž~bzû™sõ™£ȱ{ɉȮŇ
{ȧ}£Ⱥ©£s¶
lž£gö© £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÄu™fsšÅ |vbzùăȮdŸ|ýqȠ~
vl™£t£Ȭ}¶
Æ. v¤uózu™fi¨uŸ“ü£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÆ|vbzùăȮ Ⱦdš¥ržz£ö ȷ
£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{£u© £v sbȮqɂȧ|ssŸ}{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵ b±x¨ȿu
yòăȶfȩ¨ýsȸ}¤q£Ɇ© lž£gö©£‚ {ȧ|ȸzȸ|ȱbižu£ȱ{ȾdšbzùăȮ
£ɪböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÆ£u©z™uɉgȩ¨ýsȻu£s¶
c £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ} ýqȠ~Ȼuȱbižu£ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ vȺōvxš~Ⱥȧ|¶
Ƚbx²uõu›f£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ ¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ}ȱbižu£ȱ{|ȱʼn
y™Ȼ}bzùăȮ ȧ}xš¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ |ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥ržz£ȩ|xȱb£gbòš
£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{ižuqɂȧ|lžgȨf£ýȧz¸
I. Ƚbx²uõu›fȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÃ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ}¸
Ã. yòăȶfȸ¨fzž}£ɪg¨£Ƚ©zcqɂȧ|vȫŖkȷ ¤wusš£ɪböăfq¨vuyö¨
lf¤|b ¤l}Ȯ‰vzù²uõÃ¥ul¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|vbzùăȮz™uýqȠ~Ȼu£d£|¢vg¨
Ž£Ȼ©xzùwɏ{ böăfȺzu™fȮýv£ɀiu¯l}dpªbzûȧ|gýz©b¨pqýx¨¤lu
¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ fȶz„uɐɖ g©¥ræsšÃÅ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ £s¶
£ȱ{¤ƒb dpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ȩf£} |Ÿzȿudpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨f u™fdpª
bzûȧ|£¢z b±v«¤uò‰vzù²uõÃȨf£} ýqȠ~Ȼu£|¢vg¨£ƒ f£ȱ{ ȿi™b
dpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨f¤qȿŏb‘f u™fýqȠ~Ȼu£Ȼ©xzùwɏ{¤qböăfȺzdpªbzûȧ|
ȻɁ¨f¤qȿŏb‘fv«£ȵɒ©¶
Ä. zĚuòšȻɁ¨f¤l}Ȼu£|¢vg¨‰vzù²uõÃȨf£} x¨ȿu„¨ȵg„ÿšwò}ȧ|
vbýɆ{wþĄ~ȧ|Žgf£ýȧ{ȵzŸ{„¨xš£gbòš£ýzg|vdpªbzûȧ|
- 20. 15
gýz©Ȩf£} £Ⱥ©£s £‚ {|Ğq¤qx¨ȿu„¨ȵgböăfȧ|vbýɆ{£ȩ}v¨pf
|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ȩf£} £ɪýqfg¨pɓg¤l}x¨ȿu£gbòš£ýzg
ȵzŸ{ýqȠ~Ȼubqýȶsb£Ⱥ©£s¶
Å. ȩœu£gbòš£ýzg|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ȩf£} ýqȠ~Ȼubqýȶsb
„¨xšýx¨¤lu£ɪýȻ~Ĝɇu£s¶ ýv™u£v dpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ȩf£} x™qȮȻu
ȯu£ɨl}£gbòš£ýzg¤vvȵ£Ⱥ© £gbòš£ýzg£Ⱥ©z™u¤zuȮ
q¨ȵfýq›zýqȠ~£ɪ£} ‰vzù²uõÃȨf£} £u©£s v«¤uòdœȮ£gbòš£ýzg
¤l}ȷ £ɪböăfq¨vuýȻ~Ĝɇu ýx¨¤ludŸ|ýqȡqšȩŏȮzŸ{u›f¤dzg¨£ȵqrû¶
Æ. x¨ȿub™gçýxz£ýx¢f£ýȧ{¹zb£s¢q|vdžȾdš¤l}wò}“ü‰vzù²uõÃ
už~}bãpªȮ£sÿȾdšŽȮ„uɐɖ£s¶
Ç. ‡|Ĝɀvr|vdžȾdš g¨£Ƚ©}bãpªȮ„uɐɖ|v‰vzù²uõÃȨf£}
vȫŖkȷ Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|x¨ȻuȬqsb¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ‰vzù²uõÃ
Ȯ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪyö¨lf¤|b£s÷ {¶ ¥rȻuvuòȧ|ȧuȧv£ȱ{ȩœui£ȿŔ©£ɪ
£} s›blšȸ¨f„£ɪ£} b¨xž}yö¨lf¤|b¶ £ɪsšb¤uþfȵb±£ȱ{ ¤l}ȿu
¤dzg¨£ȵqrû£} yö¨lf¤|b ¤dzg¨£ȵqrû£u©u›fýqȠ~ȻussŸ}{bȮýx¨¤lu
¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£s÷ f£ɪböăfq¨vu£u©ȶzȿýȶÃ¥u„u
ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂƶ
È. £v £ȸ©všȮ‰vzù²uõÃȨf£} £u© ýqȠ~ȻuȬqsbȷȿu}bãpªȮ
„uɐɖb±£ȱ{ b±¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ¤wusš‰vzù²uõãu©u›f
z™uqýzȠ~“üdžȾdš£ȩ|xȶz£ƒ { xš£ýȽ©ȷ ó™q£ɪböăfq¨vui£ȿŔ©£u©
Ƀ¤wĂb£ɨ£} ȧ|Ƀ¤~fz™uýb›q£ɪ£} lšȮb¤òf¶
II. Ƚbx²uõu›fȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÄ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ}
Ã. žzqɂȧ|b¨ssŸ}{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵuž~ȧ|ȸzȸ|£u© xš£ýȽ©ȷ¸
(i) ȧ|ȸzȸ|g¨£Ƚ©q¨vu £ɪböăfv|Ĝ£~pýȻɆsýȻ~Ĝɇu dœȮȧ|
xýfšbȧ|ȸzȸ| ¤l}|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮȻuȱbižu£ɪböăfvpĎ›f
£wò zušq™~Ĝtš£u© u™f£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~ĜtšȮɂ{}bãp¯„bĀ|¶
- 21. 16
(ii) }bãcpŊ¥uȧ|ȸzȸ|ȿuȾxz™ugɍɂ £l z÷š“üqɂȧ|
u™f|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥rɉgb¨pqȻuuž~s¨‚¨s›blš¤l}ýqȠ~ȸzȸ|£Ⱥ©¶
Ä. Ȯi¨uŸ~Ĝk |ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥ržz£} b£ƒ fzòf£s¢quž~bȷcpŊÅ¥u£gbòš
£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{|vcþąu ¤l}Ȼuȱbižuȧ}xš~Ⱥȧ||vqɂȧ|£ɪ
¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈĶ
III. g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÅu™fsšÆ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ}
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r žz£} b£ƒ fzòf£s¢quž~bȷcpŊÅ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{
|vcþąu¤l}Ȼuȱbižuȧ}xš~Ⱥȧ||vqɂȧ| £ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈĶ
IV. g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÇ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ}
Ã. žzqɂȧ|b¨ssŸ}{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵ£} ȧ|ȸzȸ|£u© xš£ýȽ©ȧ|ȸz
ȸ|£u© xýfšbxš£} ȧ|ȸzȸ|¤l}|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮȻuȱbižu£ɪböăfvpĎ›f
£wò zušq™~Ĝtšu™f£ɪböăfl¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~ĜtšȮɂ{}bãp¯„bĀ|¶
Ä. Ȯi¨uŸ~Ĝk ȧ|ýȬu£Ȭ}už~ȧ|ȸzȸ|sšÃ sšÄ u™fsšÅ¥u£gbòš£ö ¨
“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼu¤býzȡ} ýqȠ~¤qȺ¨£ɨl}ȧ|ýȬu£Ȭ}už~ȧ|ȸzȸ|
£u©¶
Å. Ȯi¨uŸ~Ĝk ȧ|ȸzȸ|£u©dŸ|b¨pqg¨£Ƚ©¤q~qóăȸ¨fɈ{ȶzýv£ys
¤l}ýqȠ~vɐņb£ɪböăfȧ|ȸzȸ| ¤l}ýqȠ~vɐņb£ȱ{yòăȶf£ɪg¨£Ƚ©
zcqɂȧ|ȷ ɉȮŇt|¥rȻu{b£gkxšýȻɆs Ȭvȶ¨fxšȭŏ¨ÃËÇƶ
*
* *
£ɪböăfɆ}lšȧ|vcþąug©¥ræsšÄÈ ¤c‰Ⱦ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈà ¤l}ȶz|{ª
Ɇ}lšȧ£u© qɂȧ|ȻussŸ}Ɇł}zqób™gç|vcþąu £l z÷š~Ĝu™gè²{£} i£ȿŔ©¤l}
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮȻuvò›fzbqɂȧ| £ɪ¥ræsšÈ ¤cqɂ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇË qɂȧ|Ȼub¨pq
g¨pɓg~ĜɃslžgȨf£ýȧz£u© ¸
- 22. 17
£ɪböăf¨pɓ¨£|¡f£u© bzùăȮȻu£Ȭsývȧuȧ||Ġ£ɂyv¨Ƚu£ȱ{Ⱦdš¥r
£} „t™v£q{üs›blš|vbzùăȮ£ɪq¨vuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| u™fv|Ĝ£~pi¨~ĜkýȻɆs¶
¥r£hþ {qv~Ĝk£ȱ{vɐņb„©ɉfȷ q¨vu¤l}ȿuvɐŖó™q£ɪȨf¥r¥uýx¨¤lu|Ÿz
|Ƀfýv£sȸ¨fxš| £‚ {ó™q£ɪ£ýȧz„t™v£q{ü|v¥r¶ £u©dœȮi£ȿŔ©„¨xš„t™v
£q{ü¤lulš¶
lž£gö© g¨pɓg~ĜɃs¤l}ȿu£ɪg¨£Ƚ©zcqɂȧ|dœȧ|{}£e kcȩŏ„¨xš
„t™v£q{ü£} q¨vu¥uýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|¶ £l z÷š£ȱ©ýɆ{vɐŖ„t™v£q{ü¤lulš£u©
qɂȧ|ýqȠ~¤qx™u™qü£z }¤cĀýx¨¤lu|Ƀf|lîȸ¨fxš|£ɪböăfq¨vu£Ⱥ©¶ qɂȧ|Ȼu
ssŸ}¤wusšȮ£ýg u £‚ {b±Ȼu£tÿ ȧ|x™Ȭ|ȵzŸ{g¨uŸu|Ÿg£‚ {Ƚbx²uõu›fvɐŖ
£u©¶ qɂȧ|u›fx™u™qüx™Ȭ|ȵ£} ¤wusšušzŸ{¹¥u¤wusšȸ¨f£u© ¤qböăfýbvcpŊ
¤l}qɂȧ|ɉg|b£e k„¨xšzž}£‚qȺȺ ¤l}ȿu£ɪböăf¤wusšýȿv£tÿ ȧ|
£ýzg£gbòš £l z÷š£ȱ©ýɆ{i£ȿŔ©¤qzŸ{dq¤l}Ȼuȱbižuzbqɂȧ| £‚ {
¤l}g¨pɓg~ĜɃs£u©£s v¤qýqȠ~Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȨf£} ¶
*
* *
ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| dœȮvl™|pȱʼnux™™lîu™fȮsšȧŀ|ªvɁpzŸ{ ¤l}
ó™q£ɪýx¨¤lu¥r-bzùăȮ¶ vgçăv÷uö £ȸ©všȮ¤wöbcþ©ýqȠ~Ȼu¤vbȻbb±£ȱ{ b±ýȻɆs
ȿuw}ýv£ɀiu¯¤wöb™}÷ª u™fvɁp~ĜsɎɀŘf£z÷ z £‚ {£ɪ¤q£ýv ýȻȮ
b¤uþftzûɀýȶ¶ ýȻɆs£u©ȶ¨f£ɪ£} x{yö¨cù¤l}ȿu£ȯœ©lžgȩŏ ó™q£ɪ
q¨vuȨf£b q¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ¤l}Ȯtzûȶv£fâ qȻuȮýx¨ývs}|Ƀfýv£sȸ¨fxš|
£ɪböăfq¨vu£u© dœýv£sbzùăȮ£ɪȨfq÷Ąfu™fýv£s¥r£ɪȨf£i f¶ ¤wöbȮ£ýg u
¥uiŸ|yö¨£u© |ŸzwĀ¨£ȱ{ȼō¨frû£Ȭqcù¹£ƒ fýqfxš£} Ƀ}s¨Ⱥv|výv£sbzùăȮ¶
£u©dœȮɆŌuȾx£ɪýx©~Ĝɇ|¤qzòf ¤l}„ȩ|ýȻɆst¨ó™q£ɪýqfb¨xž}¥usšcù
Ɂfýqš£ȧp}{£gk£ɨ|bq¨vus¨Ⱥv¶ Ȭvxš¤dz¥ug¨£ȵqcù ɆŌuȾxsž£ɨ
- 23. 18
¥u¥wôlšȿu}bãpªȮiýȿ}£ȭő©£ɨs™Ȩf£i f|‚žql}s£uþȵzzžu ¤l}ó™q
£ɪböăfýv£s¥r¶
ȶzȧ|x™xp®ȺȨf£} dœȮb¤òfȵȷ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}£l |ȶzv£ȵɑ{
¤dzg¨£ȵqrûŽ£ȸ©všȮböăfbýz™qȵzŸ{b±£ȱ{ £v Ƀ£l |£ɨs™Ȩfq÷Ąfu™fȨf
£b q¥uq¨vuýȻɆs £Ⱥ©q¨vu£u©u›fó™q£ɪböăfýv£s¥r¶ wôă{£ɨ~Ĝk £v ¤cĀ
ýx¨¤lu£l |£ɨs™Ȩf£i fŽ£ɨs™Ȩf£i fu™fȨf}™g £Ⱥ©q¨vuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|
u›fó™q£ɪböăfýv£sbzùăȮ¶
ýv£s¥rȻussžgȷ ¤dz¥ug¨£ȵqrûv£fâ qȻuȮ¤cĀýx¨¤lutzûȮq™u™f
Ȯb¤òf£ɪböăfq¨vu£u©¶ £l z÷šȩ¨ýsȧ|„©ɉf£u© ýv£s¥rȻu£ɀf£ɨl}
yòăȶfȮ‘bɆ|¤l}vɐņbxšhuôª|vȾdšȸ¨fxš| böăfȧ|v£fâ q¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}
u›fz™uýq›z¤qȿu}bãpªtzûȮq™v«£ȵɒ©£s dœ¤rzȸ¨fȮb¤òfu™fz™uɉgȾuýgƒ¨
£s¢qwf lžgȮs£uþ iŸ|yö¨ u™fg¨£ȵqrûcù¤l}ȿuýɆv£u©¶
huôª|vȾdšȸ¨fxš|¤l}gfȻu¤cĀýx¨¤luzŸ{ ¤l}ȿu}bãpªtzûȮq™
u™fȮb¤òf ɉg£hþ {qvȻuȶz£ô |¤qýdv¤cĀvȺōqȵzŸ{ ¤l}£l |ȶzduþf
¤l}ɉgȿł}Ȼuȶzv£ȵɑ{iŸ|yö¨¨Ȩu¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b¶ ýx¨¤luɉgu›f£l |ȶz
¤cĀvȺōqb¨xž}yö¨ ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b Ž¤cĀg¨£ȵqyö¨zŸ{ (£ɪsšȵ¤l}ȿug¨£ȵqyö¨
£‚ {¤l}b|pš£u©£ô |¤qȩœu)¶ lžg¤l}£dȻu£e kȺ£x}vgçăv÷uö£u© Ⱦdš
ȸ¨fxš|Ȼu£ýzg{b¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¶ £tÿ ¤vv£u© £duûqȷȾdšȸ¨fxš|ȻussŸ}
l›fȷ ¤cĀvȺōq¤vv£u© £ȸ©ó™qböăfsšȶ¨fȮbɂbȵzŸ{b±£ȱ{ u›fz™u¤zu
Ȭ¨Ȼgȷ Ȯ¤cĀvȺōqlžgȩŏ£ɨu›f¤cĀvȺōqȶzb¨xž}yö¨Žg¨£ȵqrû£Ⱥ©£s¶ lž£gö©
£dz™uɉguûqȷȾdšȸ¨fxš|ȿuv¨pfȷ £ɪsšȵ¤l}ȿug¨£ȵqyö¨ ýx¨¤luýqȠ~
¤qó™q£ɪȶzv£ȵɑ{g¨£ȵqyö¨£Ⱥ©£ƒ { £ȱ{z™ud™qxšȧ|x™Ȭ|ȵl¥s£s¢q¶
Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|b±Ȼu¤wĂb£} „¨p©„¨ȵfl¥s£s¢q ¤l}ȿu}bãpªȮ|žv~uò
ýv~qò™ɆĚò ɆȺ u™fvɁp~ĜsɎwf¤l| v«¤uòqɂȧ|z™uɉgȬqsb„¨p©
„¨ȵfȸ¨f£Ⱥ©ȷȿu}bãpª¤l}ýqȠ~£ýzgȻuȶzwþĄ~gɍv£ƒ {¶
- 24. 19
*
* *
Ƚbx²uõ£ɨu›fvuôăb¥uyòăȶf £ȱ{¤wĂb£} i¨‚|ȮwþĄ~ȧ|ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖk
“ü£e kȷ £ȸ©všȮbzùăȮȮ£l zvpĎ›f¤l}ȻuȬv£wò zušq™~Ĝtšb±£ȱ{ b±ýv£s¥r
dœȮ„öbȸzȸ|™sõ™|vcþąuȿŏbwf¤l| £ȱ{Ɇ|¤qȧ|ȸzȸ|¤l}cþąuȻuȱbižu
£ɪböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÄ¥ul¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtšqv £‚ {¤l}ȸbs™uu›f„t™v
£q{ü£} ¤lulšzŸ{b¤uþflžgȩŏ¶ ȸ¨fýv£sbzùăȮu™fýv£s¥r£tÿ ȧ|ȸzȸ|
£|¢f¹cþąu £ȱ{x›f¤wĂb£} „f䣂qu™fȧ|„©ɉf¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuvɐņbu™f£} b£ƒ f
£ȱ{ȾdšȿŁfŽȾdšȿŁf£s¢q¶ Ȯȧ|x™qȵ vuôăb¥uyòăȶfȸbsfu›fȧ|
ȸzȸ| ɉý²{£} Ⱦdš¤l}Ȼu„©ɉfŽ£} b£ƒ fböăfȧ|ȸzȸ|ȸ¨f£u©¶
*
* *
|‚žql}£x}¤l}bzùăȮssŸ}Ȼu‘bɁiü£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÇÅ bzùăȮdœȮ¤wöbzŸ{
¥u‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f £‚ {s¨Ⱥbs¨ufȧ|v|£s|vcþąu lžgȩŏu›fýv£s|v‡pŊĐg™u
ȻɁ¨fzŸ{g¨uŸu£wĀf£s¢q¤l| ýqȠ~Ȼu£tÿ £ȱ{ýv£sȻɁ¨f böăfȺz„¨ȵgɉȵ
xɎȻ}¶ Ȯ|Ÿz džȾdšȸ¨fxš|‘bȾxssŸ}Ɇł}ȷ i£ȿŔ©vgçăv÷uöȿuývyxb¨£p q
zbxšȧ|£ȱ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤luböăf„¨ƒăfȭŏ¨ ÃËÂÆ-ÃËÂÊ |ɃfȻɁ¨fu™f£¢z (¤l}
£ýȧ{zbýqȠ~Ȼu£ɷȷ¥r) u™fȮx™£ȷ „t™v£q{ü£} ýx©~Ĝɇ|¤wĂb£} „uɐɖ
ýx¨¤lug©¥ræsšÃÅ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ u™f¤wĂb£} ýx›qò™ȧ|p¯£ýȧ{xš¥ræ£Ⱥ©zb¶
£‚qlž£gö©£‚ {ȻuȮqɂȧ|z™ux™u™qüɆŌuȧ|p¯ ¤l}£b qȿu|ɃfȾdšȸ¨fxš|
zu„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ£Ⱥ©£s¶
vsv÷čìqò™Ƚbx²uõȺȺ¥u„uɐɖg©¥ræsšÃÅ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ ¤l}¤gf
„¨xšýx¨¤lu¥uq¨vuyö¨lf¤|bȨf£b qȿucþ›zɆ|lžgȨf£ýȧz ¸
- 25. 20
ȿýȶ Ã
ýx¨¤lu|Ƀf£¢zu™fbzùăȮ £ɪ£ýq {Ȩf£hÿfs£uþɆv Ȭv£wò zxšȿqȽz
¥uô›f|}Ÿ |Ÿg£l |ȶz¤cĀývȬvxšg¨pɓg£Ⱥ©£ȭő©£ɨs™Ȩf£b q |‚žql}
iŸvu›f¤ýxbb¨xf£s¢z vȺōvzbvq£ƒ f£ɨs™Ȩf£i f £‚ {¤cĀ£u©ývxÿu›f
¤cĀv£ȵɑ{xšg¨pɓgývxÿ£Ⱥ©|‚žql}iŸ|yö¨lf¤|b¶ Ȭvxšsš£Ⱥ©zb ¤cĀýx¨¤lu
£l |ȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b ȿŁfg£ȺŔ©ɉfs£uþȵz¤uu™fs£uþ£zdfä u™fs£uþȵzzžu
£ɪȿŁf£s¢q ¤cĀ£u©ývxÿu›fiŸ|yö¨ȻŘȱf £‚ {£l |ȶzb¨xž}yö¨£u© £ɨs™Ȩf£b q
|‚žql}s£uþ£zdfä¶ £ɪ¤cĀs›bȨf£} Ȭvxšg¨pɓg£Ⱥ© s£uþ£zdfä£ɪ¤qȮýx¨¤lu
¥uɁȮȵgýb£¢zývȶzȿýȶÃ¥uuõ™ɐɖg©¥ræsšÅ ¤cqɂ ȭŏ¨ÃÊËŶ
ȿýȶÅ
l¨£p |ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu|Ƀfýx©ɁȮȵgýb£¢z u™fs›blš¤l}v£fâ qȻu
Ȯ‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f u›fýqȠ~£|¢vg¨£tÿ £ƒ f¶ ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u©u›fýqȠ~„u~qò£ȱ{
dpªbzûȧ|gýz© ¤l}ȿuȿȾxzĚuòš¤qfȶ¨f£ȱ{ýv£sȮvb™gçuɎ
ȸ¨fxš|¶ b™gçȧ|ȸ¨f£Ⱥ©Ƚbx²uõu›fýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼub¨pqböăfȿýȶÃu™fÄ ýxz
ȸ¨fq¨vu¤l}£ɪg£ȺŔ©s£uþɆvu™fzýs¶
Ȯvmz £d£e kȷȿýȶȸ¨f£u©z™uȻuu™ɀ{„¨xšýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|£s¶
£ȱ{£‚qw}£u©£‚ { zuu›fqɂȧ|ɉg£gk£gbòš£ýzgȸbsfu›f„t™v£q{ü
Ⱦx£ɪ£} q¨vuýȻɆsȻu }©ýȶ¤qȻux™u™qüuž~„ÿš¤l}Ȯ¤cĀýx¨¤lu|Ÿgzb¶
vȺōvzb £ȸ©vš}bãpªsž£ɨ¥uýx¨¤lu¤l}b¨pqböăfȿýȶà Ȯ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b
ȶziŸ|yö¨lf¤|b b±v«¤uò£ɀfȶzȿýȶÅ ¤cĀýx¨¤lux™qýȻbl£u© u›fýqȠ~b¨pq
£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȻɁ¨f-£¢z¶ £} xš£u©£ɨ£s¢q ýqȠ~bqȿł}ȷ„ÿš¤l}
ýqȠ~b¨pq£Ⱥ©dœ ýx¨ývs} |Ƀf£¢zu™f‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f £‚ {£ȸ©všȮȧ|b¨pq
ýx¨¤lu£u©Ȯ£ȩ} (prim facie) ýqȠ~¤wĂb£} }bãpª~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}¤gfböăfȿýȶÃb±£ȱ{
b±£ȩ}v¨pf¥uȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u© dœ£l z÷šv£fâ q¤cĀýx¨¤luȮbɂbzŸ{¶ £‚q
- 26. 21
lž£gö© £l z÷š£ýzg£ȩ}£ɡ£u© ¤cĀýx¨¤ludœȮ¤cĀ¤l}£b q£gkxšȧ|ȫ|¥uȧ|
b¨pqýx¨¤lu £} b¤}f¤qȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u©ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖkȷz™uȿux}Ⱦx¶
*
* *
ȾŔz¹£Ⱥ© dpªbzûȧ|gýz©¤l}ȿuȿi™bȻɁ¨f-£¢zýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q
£ƒ f“üssŸ}vuôăbȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪȶzýb£wĀf¹ |Ÿzȸ¨fýbzŸ{g¨uŸu£ɪ
¤wöbȨf£b qiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ¤l}Ȯsšȶ¨fȿuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™q£ɪ¶ dpªbzûȧ|
gýz©£u©ȿuxš|ýbz ȿŁfdœȻɁ¨fu™fȿŁf£s¢qdœ£¢z £tÿ ȧ||Ÿzȩŏ ¤l}zŸ{ýbzȿu
zĚuòšȲu£}Ȩ u™fzĚuòš|lîȻ}iuȮq™ȻɁ¨f £ýȧzȧ|l›bȺ¨|vývȹuȮiuȮq™
ȻɁ¨f £‚ {zŸ{ýbz£s¢qdœȿi™b£¢z£ýȧzȧ|l›bȺ¨|vývȹuȮiuȮq™
£¢z¶ Ƚbx²uõu›fýx¨¤lu£ɪiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ȧ|ȫ||vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©£u©ýqȠ~Ȼu
býz™q“ü£tÿ ¤q£ɪȾdȨf£b q (zòă¨Ȩf£b qýgbb™}) ¤l}ȿuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ȶ¨f
£ɪv«£ȵɒ©¶ £ɪ£x}£u© ȾdȨf}™g¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|bȸ¨fzž}ó™q£ɪböăfýv£s¥r¶
£ȱ{Ɇ|¤q£ɪ£x}ȿul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤luv¤uózȶzuõ™ɐɖg©¥ræsšÄÅ ¤czšȺ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉv«£ȵɒ© £s výbzŸ{g¨uŸuȮvu›fȾdȨf}™gyö¨lf¤|býqȠ~Ȼuȱbböăf
ýv£sbzùăȮ ¤l}£ýȧ{zbq¨vu£u©ȻuȧŔ{Ȯq¨vuýx¨¤lu¶ b™gçȧ|b¨pq
ýx¨¤lu£ɪböăfq¨vuýx¨¤lugf£ýȧ{£u© ýqȠ~Ȼuývd}£ɨ“üdpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÄ
¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ fȶzuõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂɶ
dpªbzûȧ|gýz©¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ fȶz„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ Ȼu
£|¢vg¨b™gçývi¨£} bsšÃ|vcþąu £ɪ¤czbɁ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÇ v«¤uòb™gçývi¨£Ⱥ©z™uȻu£ýzg
¤wöb¥ub™gçývq™vqò™ȧ||vcþąu ¤l}Ƚbx²uõu›fýx¨¤lu£ɪȶzȾdȨf£b q¥uiŸ|yö¨
lf¤|b£s |‚žql}¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈ £v £ȸ©všȮȿu£ɪböăfb¨pq£‚q|vdpª
bzûȧ| £ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈ ȷȿi™biuȮq™ȻɁ¨fzŸ{|žv¥udpªbzûȧ|£u©
dœ„u£uš{¯‘b Tixier Ȼu£tÿ l¨£p |hþfȧqyö¨lf¤|b £ɪ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÇ b±£ȱ{¶
- 27. 22
b™gçývi¨¥ræsšÄ ¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈ ¤l}Ȼuývýx›qò£ɨ£ɪ„fä|~qòȻuýxz£ýx¢fȷ dpª
bzûȧ|£u©dŸ|¤q£ƒ fyö¨lf¤|bxšɃ}s¨ȺvȨfýv£sbzùăȮ £ȱ{hþfȧqýgbb™}
¤l}ó™q£ɪs™Ȩf}™g¥uýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| £‚ {£tÿ l¨£p |£ȭő©£ɨs™Ȩf£b q
ȶzv£ȵɑ{iŸ|yö¨£u©ȶzwþĄ~l¤l} (Žȶz¤cĀvȺōql¤l}) ¤l}„u£uš{¯‘b
Tixier Ȼu£l |hþfȧq£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂǶ b¨pq£‚qývi¨Ȩf£} Ȼuvɐņbȷ Ɂ}ȧ|
g©x™u™qüyžz™ɆĚòȬ¨Ȼgȸ¨f„£ɪg£ȺŔ©wþĄ~£u©u™fiŸ|b¨xž}yö¨ (¤l}wþĄ~£u©£l |
£ô |¤qývȩŏu›fiŸ|b¨xž}yö¨) ɉg{b~Ĝtš£u©zb£ýv ýȻȻu £ȱ{£‚qȷ wþĄ~£u©
ȿugȿŃ{ɀŘfȭŃ{v¨wq¤qxš à£ɨ ÃÇ dšƒĄ¤z«ýqv«£ȵɒ©xšb¨xž}yö¨£ɪȨfȾdš
£¢z¶ x¨ȿuȧ|i¨ȸ£sȷ ývȹuýbzȻɁ¨f u™fývȹuýbz£¢z¥udpªbzûȧ|
gýz© ¤l}Ȯq¨ȵf“üdpªbzûȧ|£u© x™qȮȻu£tÿ l¨£p |ȶzwþĄ~£u© u™fȷ£ɪ
böăf£x}£tÿ l¨£p |£Ⱥ© xŸb£dȻusĀȺýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|¶ v«¤uòx¨ȿub¨pqýȶ
„¨xš£gbòš£ýzgȵzŸ{¤l}ȷxŸb£dɉgȻu£tÿ £Ⱥ©£s¶
£ɪböăfb™gçývi¨£ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈl¤l}£u© b±Ȼuýxz£ýx¢fwf¤l|
ȷȿi™bȿŏb£s¢q¥uýbzȻɁ¨f|vdpªbzûȧ| dœ„u£uš{¯‘b „¬Ċ ýqȠ~Ƀ¤~f
¤wöbȨf£b qȸ¨fzž}¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ¤l}ȿuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ȶ¨f£ɪ £ȱ{Ȭv
£wò zxšgfȨf£b q u™fȷȩqýqȠ~Ȭb£gk£ɨv¨£xkȧ|ȫ|£u©£ɪ¥rævȺōv¶
lž£gö©ȻuvɐņbɀŘfgɍȷ dpªbzûȧ|gýz©£u©x™qȮȿuhuôªx™qýȻbl
böăfȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤luböăfq¨vulf¤|b u™fȷdpªbzûȧ|gýz©£u©ȻuȬq~Ĝȹuȧ|
Ȭ¨Ȼgýdv¤vvɀŘf £l z÷šl¨£p |ȧ|ȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu¶ ȶzx™q ȧ|ȫ|£u©ýqȠ~
Ȼuvčçv£‚ { £ȱ{£‚qȷ£ɪgf¤czbɁ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ ‘b„dä|lîsžqȻɁ¨fývȬ¨
ýbfȻfbbȻuɁ{ȧ|p¯ižu|lîzĚuòšȧ|v|£s£ɪȻŘ|ĝȷ ȩqȻussŸ}l¨p›f
ȮwþĄ~ȧ|xšývȹuýbzȻɁ¨f¥udpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȷ ȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤luȸ¨fzž}ýqȠ~
Ȼuvčçv£ȱ{ȩœu‰vsô~£‚q„ÿš£ƒ { £‚ {ȷ¤cĀýx¨¤luýqȠ~Ȼub¨pqȮɆŌx|
|ŸgɁ}£‚ { £} b¤}f¤q£ɪböăfq¨vu£¢zɁvv«£ȵɒ©¶ £} xš£u©£s¢q £ɪböăf
|Ȼ{ȧ|p¯òšxšb™gçȧ|¥uȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤luȸ¨fzž} g©¥ræsšÄ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ
- 28. 23
£wë ižu|ȱʼny™Ȼ}|vcþąu ývȹuýbzȻɁ¨fȻuu™ɀ{ȷ ȶzv£ȵɑ{yö¨lf¤|b
ȸ¨fzž}u™f|‚žql}s£uþ£zdfä ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤luz™uɉgvfâ“üȿuȧ|}¨Ȼbȵ
zŸ{£s ¶ |Ȼ{ȧ|p¯Ȼu£} b£ƒ fwf¤l|„¨xš¤wusš¤l}w}™q£ȱ{ýv£s¥r
¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu£|¢vg¨£ȱ{„däȺ{bȱʼnuyžz™ɆĚòyžz™uô¥r £ɪsšýbfȻfbb£ɪ£x}
rûš¹£u© ¤l}Ȼudž wþĄ~¤l}dpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ £l |ȶz £ɪyö¨lf¤|b¶
£‚qlž£gö©£‚ { ɃɇblžgȮgɍȵȷýx¨¤luýqȠ~ȻuɃ¤~f u™f
b¨pq|Ÿg£‚ { v«¤uò¨pɕ|dœȷ£q „ÿšȮ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£Ⱥ©? (Ȯx™££ɪq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|)
u|ȵȮ„öbb¨pq? £ȱ{~Ĝtšȵ? £‚ {ȶzvɐņ|vu|ȵ? ȧ|}¨Ȼbböăfȧ|
£hþ {¨pɕ|ȸ¨f£u©dœó™q£ɪýqfȷ vȺōvxšȿub¨pq£‚q¥ub™gçývi¨|vdpª
bzûȧ|sšÃ £ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈ £dz™u£e kȿuȧ|£ɀfv¤uózȸ}¤q£Ɇ©
£ɪböăfb¨pq£‚q¥ub™gçývi¨£ýȧ{¹zb£s¢q òšxšvɐŖýx¨¤lu£ɪböăfq¨vuyö¨lf¤|b
£u©£s¶
£dȻul›fȷ£ɪ£x}£Ⱥ© dpªbzûȧ|Ȼuvčçvb™gçȧ||vcþąu›f¤q„
£ɨ£‚ {£ɪ£} lšȮb¤òf £‚ {£db¨xf|fȬ¨|Ȼ{ȧ|p¯ u™f¤wusšv£ȵɑ©ɉuö
|vzĚuòšȲu£}ȨɆĚò („u£uš{¯‘b „¬Ċ u™f„öb£wĀf£s¢q)¶ |Ȼ{ȧ|p¯u™f
¤wusšȸ¨f£u©z™uȸuȻu£tÿ |ŸgɁ}£‚ {£s|‚žql}¤cbzúª-zšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ ¤l}
ȶztzûȶ£x}£~ɂ£u© dpªbzûȧ|u›fýqȠ~iŸvývi¨ȩŏzòf£s¢q£l z÷šx™u™qüx™Ȭ|ȵ
£} |Ȼ{ȧ|p¯u™f¤wusšȸ¨f£u©¶ £dȻul›fȷ ȿub™gçývi¨zŸ{ýqȠ~Ȼub¨pqȮ
v£ȵɑ©ɉuö£tÿ £ɪ¥ræsšÊ ¤czšȺ¶ £u©x™qȮ£gqȺböăfȧ|£ȧ©ývi¨¤l}ɉg£e k
ȶz|{ª}™c™q£ȧ©ývi¨vȺōuxš‘b„dä|lîsžqȻɁ¨fývȬ¨ýbfȻfbb £wë ižu|lîzĚuòš
ȧ|v|£sȻɁ¨f£ɪsšýbfȻŘ|ĝ g©¥ræsšÄÅ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ £ȱ{ȿu„zuž~
|Ȼ{ȧ|p¯|v£ɂb~|£uš{¯‘b Bernard ývȹuýbzȻɁ¨f¥udpªbzûȧ|¶ £ɪ
böăf}™c™q£Ⱥ©¤l| £ɂb‘b„dä|lîsžq Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȷ ¤wusš¤l}vȫŖk“ü£e k
už~ýx¨¤luɉgýqȠ~Ȼu£tÿ vgçăv÷uöbzûböăf|{ª£x}l±cþšz|zü £‚ {b™gçývi¨£xk„fä
|vȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨fu™f£¢z ýv¤‚}Ȯu›fɉg£|¢vg¨£tÿ £ɪzu¥ræsšÃÇ
- 29. 24
¤czšȺ ¶ v«¤uòȮb¤òf x¨ȿub™gçývi¨ȵzŸ{ýqȠ~ȻuýȻ|’£ƒ f£Ⱥ©£s¶ böăf£x}
ȮzŸ{ȩŏ£Ⱥ©¤l| |ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȸ¨fxš|Ȼul¨£p |ȧ|g|Ȭ£} uõ™ɐɖýx¨¤lurûšzŸ{
£s¢q¶ uõ™ɐɖ£u©¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼug©‚qó£}Ȩ£ɪ¥ræsšÄÅ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ Ȼu
¤gf„¨xšȧ|£ȱ©lž|s›blš u™fvsv÷čìqò™gɍɂȸbsfu›fýx¨¤luȸ¨f„¤l}
z™uȻu¤gf£ɪböăfl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{¥uuõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆzu¶
lž£gö© dpªbzûȧ|gýz©b¨pqýx¨¤lusšÄýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ fȶzuõ™ɐɖ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÂɶ lžg¤l}Ȼu£} b£ƒ fxšȨf£l z b™gçȧ|zŸ{g¨uŸu|vdpªbzûȧ|£u©
dœ b¨pq¤wöb¥uq¨vuyö¨lf¤|b¤l}z™uó™q£ɪ£ýȧzzqób™gç|vdpªbzûȧ|sšÃ
u™ɀ{“üg¨Ȭvxšýgbb™}£ɨs™Ȩf}™g lž£gö©£‚ {z™u|ŸzvčçĄ}q¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|
¤l}ó™q£ɪs™Ȩf£b q¥uýgb£Ⱥ©£s¶ ȶzx™qȿuȧ|ȫ|Ȯuȩŏcþ©¹|Ƀfdpª
bzûȧ|ȸ¨fxš|£ɪböăfq¨vub™} v«¤uòȧ|ȫ|Ȯuȩŏ£u©z™uɂquõ›fl}q¨vuýx©
~Ĝɇ|£Ⱥ©£s¶ £ȸ©ȮɀŘfȵbòš £ɪŽ£ɪ¤b÷|ýgbb™}ȿuyòăȶf£ɪböăfb¨pqýȶ
|vdpªbzûȧ|sšÄ ¤l}ȷ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}dž£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|£u© ȻuȾņv
ȮzŸ{¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}ȿuýɆv ¤l}qýzf£ȭő©£ɨȨf£b q|‚žql}q¨vuýȻɆs
u™f‚Ÿq¨vuýȻɆs£u©£ɨ£s¢q¶ £dx¨ȿux²q®ȿuȮbɂbȷ£q ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£u©Ȯ
„ÿš£Ⱥ©£s Žȷ£q ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£u©ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ f£ȱ{|£v¢vȵ£s v«¤uòȿuȧ|
uûqzŸ{ȿuszæu|Ğfȿ¨£ɪýdvȧ}ª£sª ¤l}ȷ£ȸ©ȶz|£v¢vȵb±£ȱ{¤cĀ
ýx¨¤lu£u© dœȮ}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|Ƀ¤~f|vdpªbzûȧ|sšÃ u™f¤l}ývȹuýbz
ȻɁ¨f|£|böăf|Ȼ{ȧ|p¯g©¥ræsšÄ ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ £ȱ{Ȼuvɐņbȷ
ȧ|ȫ|Ƀ¤~f£u©ýqȠ~Ȼuvčçv|ŸgɁ}£ȱ{z™uiŸvȧ|}¨Ȼbȸ}¤q£Ɇ©¶ ȶz
ȿýȶÆ¥uuõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ qɂȧ|bq¨ȩ}£e kȷ £ȸ©všȮdpªbzûȧ|
gýz©sšÄȿuȾ|b™gçb¨pq ýx¨¤lurûš ȶzuõ™ɐɖ£Ⱥ©b±£ȱ{ ȶzývȧ| III ¥u
x™tšɆ|¤l}ȾņvȮzŸ{uõ™ɐɖdpªbzûȧ|£u© b±ȿuȾ|b™gçb¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪ
¤wöbȸ¨f„¥uýx¨¤lulžgȿu¤gfböăfývȧ| I ¥ux™tšɆ|£u©¶ vsv÷čìqò™gf£ýȧ{
£u©ȸbsfu›fiŸ|yö¨lf¤|bȸ¨fzž} Ȭvxšg¨pɓgzŸ{£ɪȽbbȵɑ}ȾdȨf}™g¥u
iŸ|yö¨£u©vuòl}iŸ|yö¨ȻŘȱf£ɪȾdȨf£b q¥uyö¨lf¤|b|Ÿgvuò|‚žql}s£uþ£zdfä¶
- 30. 25
lž£gö© ýv™u£v ȾdȨf£b q¥uyö¨lf¤|bu™fq¨vuyö¨ȻŘȱf z™uȸuýqȠ~Ȼub¨pq
ýx¨¤lu£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÃ (ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ) £Ⱥ©dpªbzûȧ|sšÄ (ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ)
ȿuȾ|b™gç£tÿ ȧ|ȫ|£u©¶ £ýɗxšȧ|ȫ|Ȯuȩŏ¤l}Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȨf£} (£ȱ{
z™uɂquõ›fl}ýx©~Ĝɇ|) dpªbzûȧ|£u©z™uȻu£tÿ b™gçȧ|£u©£s £‚qlž£gö©
£‚ {ȧ|uûq dœȷȧ|ȫ|Ƀ¤~f£u©ýqȠ~Ȼu£tÿ |ŸgɁ}£‚ {¶
Ȯb¤òf dpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÃz™uȻu£|¢vg¨b™gçývi¨ȮwþĄ~ȧ|ȵzŸ{£ƒ {
£ýȧ{¥ræsšÃË ¤czbɁ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂɶ £dz™uýqȠ~£yþg£sȷ £ɪ£x}¤l}b™gçývi¨¤vv
£u©dŸ|¤qýqȠ~Ȼu£d£|¢vg¨£tÿ £ƒ f böăf£ȩ}v¨pfvčçvb™gçȧ||vdpªbzûȧ|
ȧ|Ȭvɉ|zûp¯£ɪböăfýv£sȸ¨fxš| u™fxš¨ȵbvdä}¤l}ȻussŸ}™sõ™x™£
£l z÷šv¨£xkb™gçȧ|u™fv£čçkzq™böăfȺzxŸb£d£} b™gçȧ|ȸ¨f£u© dœ£ȼŋq£} ȧ|
£ýzgȻuuž~uõ™ɐɖg©¥ræsšÄÅ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂɶ ȧ|bfÿ}Ȯgz÷f|v
xŸb£d Ȯx™£|v£ɂb~|£uš{¯‘b Bernard z™u¤zuȧ|z™uȻuvčçvȮx™tšȧ|
už~}sõw}¥uȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu ¤l}xŸb£dýqȠ~v¨£xkbuþfzb£s¶
l¨ȵbȧ}gf£ýȧ{¥uývq™vqò™ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu dœȮȧ|£|¢vg¨u™f£Ȼ©xzù
wɏ{¤wusš¶ g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|„u~qòȧ|ȫ|v£gçb£s£u© |ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢z¤l}£ɪ£x}
£Ⱥ©x¨ȿuz£tɎȻ{ýdvýȩu Ȼu£ö ȮwþĄ~ȧ|“üzĚuòšȲu£}ȨȻɁ¨fdž¤wusš
böăfq¨vuýx¨¤lu£u©¶ ɃbücpŊsšzŸ{¥ub¨pq£‚q|vb™gçývi¨dpªbzûȧ|gýz©
sšÃ £ɪ¥ræsšÄË ¤c~Ĝgè™ȧ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÇ ȻuvɐņbɀŘfgɍȷ ¨£p £u©ȻussŸ}
ȧ|‘bȾxxšýbz£¢z¥udpªbzûȧ|£u© ¤l}ɉgȮ„öbwòąg£wò zd¨u™q£s¢qwf
£ȱ{£‚qȷ£ɪböăf}™c™qzŸ{ g©£ɪ¥ræsšÄ ¤cšɇ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ ¤l}£ɪböăf}™c™q
£u©‘b„dä|lîsžq£¢z£ɪsšýbfȻŘ|ĝȻu£wë ižu£ɨ|ȱʼny™Ȼ}|vcþąu „¨xš¤wusš
¤l}Ȯ}sõw}gf£ýȧ{¥uȧ|dž¤wusš £ɂbsžq£¢z|žv£u©Ȼu£ɀf£}
dpªbzûȧ|gýz©b¨pqýx¨¤lu u™f¨£p |vdpªbzûȧ|£¢z¤l}£ö “ü
dpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨fȮ„öb£|¢vg¨¤wusšýx¨¤lu£wĀf¹ £s¢qwf¶ ȧ|p¯£u©dœȮu£ɀ
Ȼ{gɍɂ|vɉȮŇt|£¢z ¤l}ýqȠ~ȻuvɐņbɆȮrûš£ɪböăfdpªbzûȧ|
- 31. 26
gýz©sšÄ (ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ) ¤l}ȷ ‚£~Ĝb£¢zȻu£ö ¨l}ȿi™bȻɁ¨f¥udpª
bzûȧ|£u©“ü„u~qòȧ|dž¤wusšyžz™ɆĚò£u© lžg¤l}ȿu£ɪböăfb¨pq£‚q¥u
b™gçývi¨ ¥ræsšÈ ¤cz™rȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂʶ
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȻɁ¨fȻuȬq~Ĝȹuȧ|Ȭ¨Ȼg £l z÷š“üb™gçȧ|£u©ýqȠ~„u~qòȻu£ȱ{
zĚuòš£ɀȹȻɁ¨fzŸ{ýbzȿuȩŏÆȺb¤l}böăf£Ⱥ©ÅȺb dœ£ɂb„u£uš{¯‘b
Tixier, Kerler u™f De Batz ȹŔvȮȿi™b|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÃ¶ ýbz£u©Ȼu
£tÿ ȧ|£ýȧzȧ|l›bȺ¨sž£ɨ|v~|£uš{¯‘b Bernard £‚ {£ɪgf|s|lž~ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ
ýbz£u©Ȼuvčçv¤wusšzŸ{£¬|ĝ¤l}ȿug¨uŸuÃÃȼō¨f ýdvlpĎvzŸ{Ⱦdt¨¥u
ýx¨¤lu|Ƀf£¢zu™f‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f |ŸzvčçĄ}ȸ¨f¤wöbȸ¨fɈ{¤l}Ƚbx²uõ£ɪböăf
£|¡fbòš£u©¶ ¤wusšȸ¨f£u©ýqȠ~Ȼu£Ȼ©xzù u™fwĀxÿwɏ{£ȱ{ýbz‚¬udž¤wusšl±
}÷š}ɍk|vȻɁ¨fzŸ{¤l}ȿu£ȯœ©ȷ H. Barrère¶
¤wusšȸ¨fÃÃȼō¨f£u©ýqȠ~včéĄu£ɨ“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢z £ɨȶzušq™~Ĝtšýq›zýqȠ~
Ȯ¤wusš¤l}|ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢zȻu£ö ¨ £‚ {qɂȧ|u›fx™Ȭ|ȵ„¨xšȧ}ª£sª
¥uȧ|včéĄu¤wusš u™fȧ|uö™ȱʼnu¤wĂb£} ȧ|ýȻý²{ȸbsfȩŏ£u©£ɪ£x}£ýȧ{¶
¤wusšÅȼō¨fböăfg¨£ȵz¤wusšȸ¨f„ýqȠ~¤}f£ýv ȧ|£b q£ȱ{ýx›qò™ȧ|p¯ £ýȽ©ȷ
q¨vuýx¨¤luȬ¤l}¤wusšȸ¨f£u©ȻuvȫŖk ‡ƒĄ~£u©Ȼuó™q£ɪböăfs›blš|v
bzùăȮȸ¨fýf£ɀfȶzuõ™ɐɖ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂɶ ɉý²{£‚q£u© £¢zz™u
ýqȠ~Ȼu£ö ¨“üssŸ}{bŽvl™£t¤wusšȸ¨f£u©£ƒ {¶ v«¤uò¤wusš£wĀf£s¢q£ɪ
¤qȿuýv£ɀiu¯l¤l}ýȿvýv£s£¢z¶ böăfg¨£ȵz¤wusšȸ¨f£u© ȿu¤wusš
zŸ{Ȯ¤wöb¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ¤l}ȿuýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ȶ¨f£ɪ £‚ {£ɪ£} ¤wusš£Ⱥ©
£dȻudž¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}„©ɉfȷ Ȯ}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu u™f¤l}Ȼu
ȱbx{yö¨ýx©~Ĝɇ|ȸ¨fzž} ýxzȸ¨fq¨vuýȻɆs£s¢qwfó™q£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ¶
lž£gö©ýv™u£v ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu£tÿ £ƒ f£ɪȾdȨf£b q¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b
Ȼub¨pqŽȿuv¨pfb¨pqȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b £Ⱥ©¤wusš£u©ɉgȬqsbȷ
ȻuvȫŖk¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¤vv£u©£‚ {¶ ¤wusš£u© ýqȠ~Ȼu£|¢vg¨£ƒ f£ȱ{ýv£s
- 32. 27
bzùăȮ£ɪböăf‰vzù²uõÃ¥ul¨£p |ȧ|ušq™~Ĝtš|vcþąu £‚ {ýqȠ~Ȼu£dl›f£ɪböăf£|¡fbòš
£u©ȷȮ¤wusš‰vzù²uõ à (u›fýqȠ~£ɀf£ɪböăfɆ}lšȧ£u©)¶
¤wusš£u©£‚ {¤l}bzùăȮ{b£tÿ Ȯzž}ȱʼnugz÷f £l z÷šȩ¨ýsl}ȧ|ȸzȸ|
„t™v£q{ü|vcþąu£} ýȻɆs£u©¶ wôă{£ɨ~Ĝk ýv£s¥rqɃŘg¨£Ƚ©ȧ|ȸzȸ|
ȵzŸ{ ¤l}¤wĂb£} ¤wusš£u© £ȱ{ȿu¨ɉf£‚qlžgq£ɨ¸ sšzŸ{ ¤wusš£u©
z™u¤zuȻuzbxšȧ|ȫ||vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©£s £‚qlž£gö©£‚ {£s v¤wusš£u©
x¨ȿu}bãpªȬvvf㨶 sšxš| £ɪýqfq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ| ¤wusš£u© ȿub¨‚¤wöb¨Ⱦ|ª
¤l}z™uɉgxuü}Ȼu £ȱ{¤wĂb£} ȧ|„u~qòuž~„¨ȵghȺōu™sõ™böăfȧ|¤b¤ýv
¤l}dpªbzûȧ|ɉgȿu¶ £ɀfȶzȧ|qɃŘ|v¥r b¨‚£Ⱥ©dœȷ¤cĀýx¨¤lu
¤l}ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖk£} ¤wusš£u© z™u¤zuȮ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻblböăfq¨vu£u©£s
£‚ {ȷýv™u£v ɃȮ¤cĀvȺōq¤l}džȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻbl£Ⱥ© q¨vu
ýȻɆs£u©u›fó™qböăfs›blš¥r¶ ¥rȻuqɃŘv¤uóz£s¢qȷ £v u™ɀ{„¨xšq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|
cþąuz™u¤l}ssŸ}{b¤wusš£u©Ž¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}ȻuvȫŖk£ɪ£} ¤wusš£u© ɀŘf
£ɇgȵȸbsf£ɨu›fýx©~Ĝɇ| ¤l}ȧ|ssŸ}Ɇł}£u©qýzȠ~“ücþąuýqȠ~„u~qò
ȶz£Ⱥ©£s¶ z«Ɏf~Ĝk£s¢q ýv™u£v ¥rx™qȮȻussŸ}{b¤wusš£u© dœ¥r£tÿ lž£gö©
b±£ȱ{Ɇ|¤qcþąuȿui¨£u¡£ȱ{ȿuȧ|y²uòýgƒ¨ȷ ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£} ¤wusš£u©ýqȠ~Ȼu
£ddžýq›zýqȠ~£ɨȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¶
£ɪ£x}£u© qɂȧ|u›fx™Ȭ|ȵ¤q£ɨ£} ȧ|qɃŘsšÃv«£ȵɒ© £ȱ{¤wĂb
£} sƒȞšb|p¯¤l}qɂȧ|{}£e kȷýq›zýqȠ~ £Ƚ}dœ¤wusš£u©z™uȹŔv¤l}Ȼu
ssŸ}ȧ|‘bȾxȮwþĄ~ȧ|xšdpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÃ£s £ȱ{£‚qȷdpªbzûȧ|£u©
¤}fl¨£p |ȧ|ȶ¨fxšv«Ⱥœu¤czu£x}w}™qȻu¤wusš£u©£z«þ©¶ b¨pqýȶz™uȻu
vȫŖkȷ £q ¤wusšu™f¤cĀvȺōq£u©Ȼu¤wĂbȶz£gbòš£ýzgŽȧ|¤pȺ¨ȵzŸ{
xšdpªbzûȧ|l}zĚuòšȲu£}Ȩ £ɪ£x}dpªbzûȧ|b¨xfȿul¨£p |ȧ|£Ⱥ©£s¶
„ÿš¤l}gɍ£Ⱥ©dœȷ ¤wusš£u©ýȻblȮȻu¤wĂb£} zž}ȱʼnuȵzŸ{£‚ { £‚ {
qɂȧ|{}£ȱ{x¨ȿu~Ĝzq™fĀ²{£ƒ {ȷ ¤wusš£u©Ȼu¤wĂb£ɨ£} ȧ|ȫ||v
- 33. 28
zĚuòšȲu£}Ȩ£ɪq¨vuyö¨lf¤|b¶ £ȱ{¤wusš£u© Ȯ¤wusšzŸ{böăfg¨£ȵz£¬|ĝ¤wusš
¥uq¨vuýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼuw}™q£ȱ{„öbi¨ȺkȲu£}ȨɆĚò|v|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȻɁ¨f
ȶz¨£p |vɉȮŇt|£¢z ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu£Ȼ©xzùu™fwĀxÿwɏ{£ȱ{ýbz‚¬u}÷š
£ȯœ©zŸ{£ɪȻŘ|ĝ ýdvg¨pɓgȸ¨f„ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖkɀŘfgɍ£ɪ£} ¤wusš£u©
£‚qlž£gö©£‚ { ¤wusš£u©ȿu}bãpªwþĄ~ȧ| £‚ {¤wusš£u©ȿu„¨ȵg|vcþąu
ȶz}bãpªv£gçb£s £‚ {¤wusš£u©ȿuývyxb¨£p qývbv£ȱ{}bãpªgɍ
¤sf‡q“üzuô™}fĀ²{¶ £ȸ©ȮɀŘfȵb±£ȱ{ qɂȧ|uö™ȱʼnuȷ £ɪ£x}Ȭv
£wò z u™f£ɪ£x}w}™q¤wusš£u©x¨ȿu}bãpªqýzȠ~“üdžȾdš„u~qòȶz£s¶
*
* *
¥rȻuvȫŖk£‚qw}ȷ £ȱ{Ɇ|x¨ȿuȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤luȵzŸ{¤l}
Ȼu{}ýxz u™f„uz²q£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ž£ȱ{¤wĂb£} ȧ|¤pȺ¨|vcþąu
ȶzɆœ|qš¥uȿýȶÃ¥u„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ ¤cĀýx¨¤luȬ¨ȻgýqȠ~¤q„u~qò£ȱ{zœf
ȿŘqȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻbl £‚ {ȷ£ɪq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|¤cĀvȺōq£u©u›fȱb
ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɪböăfs›blš¥r¶ £v sbȮssŸ}Ɇł}ȷ dpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȿu
hȺōu™sõ™zŸ{g¨uŸuböăfȧ|ȫb£gkxš¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b £l z÷š£i¢ɃfȾxz™uývýbqš
u™fȿuhȺōu™sõ™x™u™qü£} £‚qȧ|p¯£ɪȶzq¨vuȮb¤òfsõɆt£Ⱥ© b±¥r
i¨ȸȷ ȧ|ȫb£gkȵzŸ{ lžgȮȧ|ȱbýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ
u›f£tÿ “ü£} ~ĜɆ}Ⱦx¥u„¨ȵghȺōu™sõ™¤l}dpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȿu £ȱ{z™u
Ȼux™ȾbɏgɍɂȮzŸ{|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȸ¨fxš|¶
£v sbȮcþ›zɆ|¥uȧ|i¨ȸɉgȿu£ȱ{ȧ|£} b£ƒ f£ȱ{cþąu‘f£u©bòš
qɂȧ|{}£e kȷ ȧ|i¨ȸ£u©z™ug¨vɐŖȮb¤òfȽbx²uõ£ɪsš£u©£s¶ £v sb
Ȯx¨ȿuȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪ¤v«bȨf£b q¥uyö¨lf¤|b ¤l}Ȼu{}ýxzu™f„uz²q
£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|gýz©b±£ȱ{ b±Ȯb¤òfȻu£v bwþĄ~“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȸ¨fxš|ssŸ}{b
už~ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪq¨vu£Ⱥ©Ȼu £ȱ{£ýv ýȻȧ|ȫ||vȿi™bv£gçb£s
- 34. 29
¥udpªbzûȧ|gýz©¶ g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤luȵzŸ{¤l}ȫb£gkxš¤cĀ¤vf¤gb
s›b £v ¤wĂbȶzȧ|qɃŘ|v¥r £ȱ{£‚qȷȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu¤l}ȻugfĂă}vȫŖk
£ɪ£} ¤wusš‰vzù²uõà z™u¤zuȮȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©£Ⱥ©x¨
ȿu£‚qw}„ÿš¤l}ýqȠ~x™Ⱦbɏȷ £q ȧ|ȫb£gk¤l}ɉg£b qȿu£ɪq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|
ó™q£ɪböăf„¨ȵghȺōu™sõ™|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©£Ⱥ©Žb±„q£s¶ £‚qw}£ɪ
ýqfȷ ȶzx™qɃýqȠ~ó™qböăf„¨ȵg|v|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȸ¨fÄ £l z÷š£ýzg„¨xšȧ|ȫb
£gk¤vv£u©¶
£‚qlž£gö©£‚ { vɐŖx™qýȻbl¤l}ȮvɐŖ¨ȨuzŸ{£ɪböăf£|¡fbòš£u©
dœȷ £q Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|x™qȮȻussŸ}Ɇł}¤wusš‰vzù²uõäl|Ž£s? £‚ {ȷ£q ¤cĀ
vȺōq¤l}gfĂă}vȫŖk£ɪ£} ¤wusš£u© Ȯ}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£ɪböăf
q¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ| ¤l}Ⱥ¨“ü¤wusš£u©ȿu}bãpªqýzȠ~“ü„u~qòȶz£ȱ{Ȩuz™uȻu
¤l|Ž£s?
g¨£Ƚ©vɐŖ£u© ¥rvl™£t£ȱ{„©ɉfȷcþąuývȧu{b‡|Ĝɀvr„bzû
v«£ȵɒ©g¨£Ƚ©„ÿš¤l}£b q£ƒ f£ýȧ{zb£s¢q¶ ¥rb±„©ɉfwf¤l|ȷ bzûȾx¤l}
Ƚbx²uõ£ýg u£ɨu›fȧ|cbȨuz™uȻui¨ȸ z™uýdvýȩuȷcþąuȮȾdšȻu{}ýxz
£ɨ£} ȧ|ȫb£gk£ɪýx©~Ĝɇ| xš¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¤l}ȿu¤gf£ɪböăfȿýȶÃ¥u„u
ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ |‚žql}ȷŏb£tÿ “üv«©Ƚ}l}„t™v£q{ü£} q¨vuýȻɆs£Ⱥ©£s¶
qɂȧ|{}£e k£wĀfg¨£Ƚ©vɐŖ£u©¶ ȶzb¨pq£‚qvȫŖkgɍȷ
ȧ|£Ȼ©xzùwɏ{u™fȧ|včéąu¤wusšȸ¨fÃÃȼō¨f ¤l}Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȨf£} |Ÿzȸ¨f
¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃwf dœȮýx›qò™ȧ|p¯¨ȨuzŸ{¶ £u©z™u¤zuýȩu¤qȮȧ|£ȱ©lž|
ȩŏ|Ƀf|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȻɁ¨fu™f£¢z£Ⱥ©£s ¤q£v lž£Ȭŏ©¤zu£Ⱥ©Ƀɉgȿu}bãpªýdv
ýȩuȶzwþĄ~gɍv¶ wôă{£ɨ~Ĝk ¤wusšȸ¨f„ýqȠ~ȻuwĀxÿwɏ{ɀŘfsž}¨sžɂ{
£ɨl}ýdvziêȱʼnuv£gçb£sȽbx²uõȸ¨f„ ýxzȸ¨fȻuižul¨p›fl}ɆŌv²u
yžz™ɆĚòȯuzc£ɪböăfýv£s¨Ȩu¹ u™f£ɨl}ziêȱʼnul¥s£s¢qböăfq¨vu
¤l}ȿuȧ|Ƚbx²uõu›fɆŌu£vbbzûȧ|sžq£¢z„z|ȱʼny™Ȼ}„f£dþ ɉƒœz«f
- 35. 30
|Āăš u™fɉ£z|Ĝb u™f£ɨl}ýdvȿi™bȸ¨f„¥udpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȻɁ¨f-£¢z
wf¤l|¶ ȧ|¤gbȬ{£l zl¨vžfȿug¨uŸuÃÈÂgɍv ¤l}zŸ{gɍv¹ȿuÃÃȼō¨f¶
¤wusšÇ ýqȠ~Ȼu¤gb£ɨ“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢z¶ ȧ|¤l}¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃýqȠ~Ȼu
¤gbižu£l z÷šȮȧ|vȫŖkxš}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu dœvȫŖkgɍ£ɪböăf
}™c™qg©¥ræsšÄ ¤cšɇ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ |v„däɁisžq¥r£ɪsšýbfȻŘ|ĝ £wë ižu
|lîzĚuòšȧ|v|£s£ɪsšýbfȻfbb ¤l}böăf}™c™q£Ⱥ©£ɂbȻuȿuývɆu¯ȷ
ȸbsfu›f¨£p |vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©b¨pqýx¨¤lu u™fȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|
£¢z ¤l}¨“üȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨f£|¢vg¨¤wusšýx¨¤lu£wĀf¹ ‡ƒĄ~£u©
ȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|ȻɁ¨fȻu£|¢vg¨ȧ|ȫ||vcþąugv|ŸgɁ}£‚ { ¶ £ɂbȻu
v¤uóz£s¢qȷ £ɂbȻussŸ}¤wusšÃ£¬|ĝ £l z÷švčéĄu£ɨ“ü|lîzĚuòšýbŸfȧ|v|£s
£¢z¶ £ɂbȻuvuò£|¢vɁv„¨xšvč隣ȯœ©¤wusšȸ¨fÃÃȼō¨f ¤l}zŸ{ȼō¨fȿu
ÇÂgɍv |Ÿzȸ¨f¤wusšq¨vuyö¨lf¤|bwf¶ £ɪgfvčçv £ɂbȻuu™ɀ{ȷȩq
|bɏsb¤wusšušzŸ{¹g¨uŸuÄgɍv £‚ {zŸ{gɍv£s¢q£wë £ɨɆŌu£vbbzûȧ|sžq
ušzŸ{¹ £ɪsšýbfƒăf ¤v¬bɈ¨f ýv£s|Āăš u™f‚|lîɉ£z|Ĝb¶
ȿuȧ|i¨ȸböăfȺzýv£s¥rȷ ȧ|včéĄu¤wusš£ȱ{ɉȮŇt|ȻɁ¨f£u©
£v u™ɀ{“üg¨£ɨdœ£tÿ £ȱ{Ⱦdš¤qȿŁf£s £‚ {ȷýv£s¥rz™uýqȠ~Ȼu£ö ¨ŽȻu
vɐņbȷcþąuȻussŸ}¤wusš£u©ȮwþĄ~ȧ|£ƒ {¶ ȶzx™q£ɨ lžg¤l}£du›f£e k
ȮvuòvȺōv£s¢q ȧ|ssŸ}Ɇł}¤l}ýqȠ~£tÿ £ƒ fȶz|£v¢vzŸ{ɀŘfgɍɂ
dœȶz|{ª‡|Ĝɀvr|v¥r¶ v«¤uò £v sbȮz™ulžg£u©b±£ȱ{ b±gɍȵȷ
ȿuȧ}ª£sªȮ£ýg uýȿv“üɉȮŇt|£¢zȿuývq™bzûböăf|{ª£x}z|zü
ýv™u£v cþąuȿuv¨pfz™u{}ýxzu›f¤wusš£u© ŽȿuvɐŖtæutæ|ȵzŸ{ýqȠ~£} b
£ƒ fȸbsfu›f¤wusš£u©¶ ɉȮŇt|£¢zz™uȻuv£čçkývq™bzû¤vv£u©£s ȸ¨f£ɪ
£x}£Ⱥ©Ž„Ȯ£ýg uȭŏ¨vȺōvzb lž£gö©£‚ {ýqȠ~ȬqsbȷȻucg™qòssŸ}{b¶
g¨£Ƚ©¤wusš‰vzù²uõà Ƀz™uýȩu¤qȮȧ}ª£sª¥uȧ|včéĄu¤wusš£u©
u™f¤wusšl¥s£s¢q£Ⱥ©£s ¤l}vfâ“üȿuývq™bzûxšȾdš£¢z ýv™u£v ývq™bzû£u©
- 36. 31
ȿu¤zu£Ⱥ©¶ v«¤uò b±ȿuȧ|gfĂă}vȫŖkwf¤l| £ɪ£} ¥wô¥uuþ›b¤wusš¤l}
qýzȠ~“üȿuývq™bzû ýv™u£v ɉȮŇt|£¢zȿu£‚qw}i¨ȸȷ¤wusš£Ⱥ© z™u
q¨ȵf“ü}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£s¶ lžg¤l}Ȼux™xp®Ⱥ|Ÿgzb£‚ {
¤wusš£u© |ŸzȮzŸ{¤wusšl¥s£s¢q ýqȠ~Ȼuývd}£ɨ“üȿi™b£¢z¥udpª
bzûȧ|gýz©¶ ȿi™bȸ¨f£u©Ȭ¨ȻgýqȠ~¤ql›f (u™fȶz|{ªxŸb£d£Ⱥ© |ȱʼny™Ȼ}
£¢zýqȠ~¤qȻul›f) ȷ¤wusš£u©z™uɉgq¨ȵf“ü„ÿš¹¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu„uz²qȮwþĄ~ȧ|
£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|gýz©£s £‚ {£ȱ{£‚q£u©xŸb£dz™uɉgýqȠ~Ȼuýgƒ¨£ȱ{Ɇ|
g¨pf£i f¤wusš¤l}ȿu£ȯœ©ȷ lf¤|b-dpªbzûȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu|Ƀf‡pŊĐg™u
u™f£¢z £‚ {z™uɉgȺ¨£ɨl}ȧ|uûqȷ ɃȮȧ|„©ɉfuž~z™sõw}|v
dpªbzûȧ|gýz©£Ⱥ©£s¶ z«Ɏf£s¢q ýv™u£v ȿi™b¥udpªbzûȧ|£¢zuûq
£wĀfxš£u© £ȸ©všz™uȻuvɐņbböăfb¨pq£‚qb±£ȱ{ b±ȧ|p¯£u©ɉg£b qȿu
xš£ýȽ©ȷ ȶzȧ|x™qdpªbzûȧ|gýz©Ȼu£tÿ £gbòš£ýzg¤l}Ȯzž}ȱʼnuýȿv
{bzb£tÿ ¤wusš £‚ {£ȱ{Ɇ|ȧ|£ýzg£u© ȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|£¢zx™qȮ
Ȼul›f|Ÿg£ɨ£‚ {¶
ȿi™bdpªbzûȧ|£¢z ýqȠ~¤qȻu£e kwf¤l|už~b¨pqȿł}¤l}
ȿu£ɪýifȨf£} ¤v«bȨf£hÿf¥uuþ›b¤wusš¤l}vȫŖkȷ ȧ|ȫ|£ɪ£} lšȮb
¤òfýqȠ~Ȼuývq™vqò™£ȱ{„u£uš{¯‘b Kerler u™f „¬Ċ ¶ £ȱ{Ɇ|¤q„öbȸ¨f£Ⱥ©
Ȼuȿu~qòȿu£ɪböăf„fäývi¨|vdpªbzûȧ| ¤l}Ȼuývýx›qò£ɨȧ}xš¥ræsšÄ
¤ctöĄ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÈ lž£gö© xŸb£dýqȠ~¤qȻul›fȷ £ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©„u£uš{¯‘b „¬Ċ Ȼu
ssŸ}vɐņ“ü£ɨ£tÿ ȧ|Ƀ¤~f£ɪ¤v«bȨf£b q¥uiŸ|yö¨lf¤|b ¤l}ýdvlpĎvȸ¨f
ýx©~Ĝɇ|wf¤l| £‚ {b±l›f¤l|ȷ ȩqýqȠ~Ȭb£gk£ɪ¥rævȺōv£l z÷š„u~qòȧ|ȫ|£u©¶
„öbȸ¨f£Ⱥ©z™uȻuu™ɀ{„ÿšȸ¨f„ ȸ¨f£ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©u™f£ýȧ{¹zb£s¢q£l z÷š
£ö ¨ȷ ¤wusš£u©z™u¤zuȮ}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£sŽ¤wusš£u©ȿuȾx
z™uýq›zýqȠ~b±£s¤l|¶
- 37. 32
ȧ|p¯¤l}ɉȮŇt|£¢zȶz|{ª‡|Ĝɀvr|vcþąuȻuvɐņbȷȻussŸ}
¤wusšȸ¨f£Ⱥ©u™fssŸ}Ɇł}už~}bãpª¥u¤wusšȸ¨f£Ⱥ© u™f„ÿš¤l}¤wusšȸ¨f£Ⱥ©
q¨ȵf“ü dœýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖkȶz|{ªbzûȾx|v|lîzĚuòšýbŸfzɇ¥wô ýx©„fäȿń
ȱz |ġf böăfȧ|¤rþf„¨p|dpg¨£Ƚ©‘b„dä|lîsžqȻɁ¨f£ɪsšýbfȻfbb g¨£Ƚ©¤wusš
ȸ¨f£u© u™f£ö ¨“ü£ɂb‘b„dä|lîsžqwò}ÃÇgɍv£s¢q¥u¤wusšušzŸ{¹ £l z÷švčéĄu
£ɨ“ü„y™Ȼ}£cqò|v£¢zȮ£ýg u£s¢qwf¶
yòăȶfv¤uóz£s¢q ýqȠ~Ȼu{b£gkxšȧ|x™Ⱦbɏȩŏ|vdpbªzûȧ|
ývq™Ȭ|Ğb (Commission of Transcription) ȮvuòvȺōv ¤l}ȻuiŸvývi¨ȩŏ£ɪsšýbf
Ȼfbb £ɪ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂË u™fv«Ⱥœu¤c£ýȧ{zb£s¢q¶ £u©dœȮdpªbzûȧ|
gýz©ȻɁ¨f-£¢zzŸ{ ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuv£fâ q£ƒ f£ȱ{Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|¤l}ȿu£ȩ}v¨pf
Ȭv£wò zȧ|ȫ|yžz™ɆĚò|v£¢zȮwþĄ~ȧ| ȶz|{ªȧ|včçĄ}ȩŏuž~Ɂ}ȧ|ȫ|
ȸ¨f„|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©ȸ¨fxš| ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆu™fÃËÂɶ £ȩ}v¨pf¨Ȩudœ
ýqȠ~v¨¤vþf¤wusš¤l}ȿuýɆv“ü£ɨȮsýzf£¢~£ɮ¤wusšýŸ}£z }u™f£tÿ “üȽbü
£xgu¯ȻɁ¨f-£¢z ¤l}£ýv ýȻböăf¤wusš£Ⱥ©zzž}ýq›zýqȠ~£ɪböăfȾɆl¥s£s¢q¶
£ɪböăf£x}v¨£xkȧ|ȫ||vdpªbzûȧ|£u© z™uȿuȧ|£ö ¨ȵzŸ{ýqȠ~Ȼu£tÿ
£ƒ fȷ ¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃŽ¤cĀvȺōq£u©z™uɉgssŸ}{bȻu£Ⱥ©£s¶
ȿuȧ|ȸzȸ|böăfȺz¥rȷ ¤wusš¤l}ssŸ}ȻuxšýbfȻŘ|ĝ£Ⱥ© Ȼu
£e k£ȱ{zĚuòšqžgȶg¤l}z™uȿui¨ȺkȨf¤wusš¤qv«£ȵɒ© u™fz™uȻul›f„ÿš
ȸ¨f„„¨xšýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|¶ ȶzx™q £ɪböăf|{ª£x}ušq™~Ĝtšȸk£‚qw}£ȱ{
ȼō}ȿq ȿuȧ|£} b£ƒ fȷ ȩœuu|ȵȿŏb£ɪýv£s£¢z£ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©Ȼul›f
„¨xšýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|Žcÿ}Ȩŕ{„¨xšýȻɆs£u©£s¶
qɂȧ|z™uɉgssŸ}{buž~ȧ|i¨ȸ£u©£s ȸ¨f„f䣂q ȸ¨f„fägɍv¶
ýv™u£v ɉȮŇt|£¢zx™qȮȻuvȫŖk¤wusšȸ¨f£u©l}¤qzĚuòšqžgȶg £Ⱥ©ɉȮŇt|
£¢zx™qȮȻu£tÿ bzûȾxɀŘfývr{ývȷu£u©£ȱ{cþąu‘f £‚ {ȶz|{ª„fä
£‚q£u© ȧ|ȸzȸ||v¥rz™uɉgssŸ}Ȼuuž~ȧ|ȩ¨ýs£} ȭb„uò|Ȯq™£ƒ {¶
- 38. 33
v«¤uò lžg¤l}Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȨf£} ýv~qò™¥u£|¡fɁŘ~£u©vȫŖkgɍȷ¤wusš£u©ýqȠ~
Ȼu£e k£ȱ{vdä}Ȯ£ýg ulžgȮ ýx©„fäȿń £l ɃŘ~fĀ£ Ȯ|lîzĚuòšȧ|v|£s
ýx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf Ȯ|lîzĚuòšzɇ¥wô ȿi™b£¢z|vdpªbzûȧ|gýz©sšÃ
ȿi™b£¢z|vdpªbzûȧ|ývq™Ȭ|Ğb u™fýqȠ~Ȼuuö™ȱʼnuwf¤l|ȷ ¤wusš
‰vzù²uõãu© ýqȠ~Ȼu£e k£ȱ{„y™Ȼ}£cqòcžbȨu (Khukhan) Ȯ£cqò|v
£¢z £ɪȮvu›fq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|ȾdȨf£i f ¤l}ȩqȮ„y™Ȼ}£cqòȿŏbböăfg¨£ȵz
„y™Ȼ}£cqòzŸ{g¨uŸu¤l}ýqȠ~ssŸ}Ȼu¤wusšrqgzþfv¤uóz ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu£ö ¨
v¤uóz£ȱ{ýx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf¶ z™uȿuvdä}ȵȿŏbböăfg¨£ȵzvdä}ȸ¨f£u©
ȮzĚuòšqžgȶg£Ⱥ©£s¶ zĚuòšȸ¨f„Ž£ô |¤qȸ¨f„Ɇł}yžz™ɆĚò£ɪq¨vu£Ⱥ©¶
zĚuòšcþ©£s¢qýȻblȮɆł}q¨vulf¤|b¶ ȶz|{ª‘bɆ|£ɪböăf¨pɓ¨£|¡fvȫŖk
gɍȷ ýx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf ȿug¨ȵvɉ|zûp¯ȼō}cþąuɀŘfȨŔ¨f£} ȧ|ȫ|
b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u©u™fȿug¨£p©l›fýȮ}£ýɞ„¨xšýȻɆsvɁp¶ Ƀz™uɉg£i¡Ȼu
ȸ}¤q£Ɇ©¤l}ȷ „y™Ȼ}£cqòcžbȨu (Khukhan) ¤l}Ȯ£cqòv£fâ q£ƒ fȮv
ȮzŸ{ýx©~Ĝɇ| |‚žql}ȿul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ z™ul›f„¨xš„qó™Ⱦx|v
ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|£Ⱥ©£s¶
£ȸ©Ȯb|pšȵb±£ȱ{ ȧ|i¨ȸȮ}bãpªx™£|v¥r£u© ýqȠ~Ȼu
vl™£tɀŘfgɍýb¤ƒq ȶz|{ª‘bɆ|zŸ{¤l}¥rcþąu‘fȻuqzâ} £‚ {ȶz
‘bɆ|£Ⱥ© ýȻɆs£u©ýqȠ~Ȼu|b£e kȮrûš£ɪȭŏ¨ÃÊËË £ȱ{ýx©„fäȿń£¢z
£ȯœ© Ɇuȼšq „zl¨£p |£ȱ{zĚuòš u™f„öbzc„öbȧ|zž}ȱʼnuýv¤‚}ÃÇ£ɨ
ÄÂȺb ¤l}böăf£Ⱥ©s¨ufȮȿu„y™Ȼ} u™f„y™Ȼ}|f£cqòcžbȨu (Khukhan)
wf¤l|¶ lžg£u©ɃvȫŖk“ü£e kȷ ýȩu¤qböăf|{ª£x}Ëȭŏ¨v«£ȵɒ© zu£x}ɉȮŇt|
£¢zssŸ}Ȼu¤wusš‰vzù²uõãu© ȿuzĚuòšȮucùȮ£ýg u£ɪýv£s£¢zȻu
l›f„¨xšýx©~Ĝɇ|¶
£} xš£u©£s¢q qɂȧ|{}£e kȷz™uȿuzž}ȱʼnugɍvg¨£Ƚ©vgç²{
¤l}cþąuxɎɀzȸk{b£gbòš£ö ¨£gkxš„f䣂qȷ £ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©z™uȿuu|ȵ
- 39. 34
ȿŏb£ɪýv£s¥r Ȼul›f„¨xšɆ|ª¨Ȩu¥uýȻɆsŽcÿ}Ȩŕ{„¨xšýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|¶
ȶzwþĄ~gɍv ȧ|¤bqýzȠ~ýx¨¤luz™uɉgȸzȸ|£ȱ{j|£} zž}ȱʼnuȷ q¨vuýx¨¤lu
zŸ{¤ývȮȿuɆ|ª¨Ȩu £ȱ{z™uȻul›fŽz™ufĀ²{£ɪ£x}v£fâ qýx¨¤lu£Ⱥ©
£s¶
*
* *
ȶzȧ||b£e kȮ‚ž|¤‚Ȼu“ül›fȷ ɉȮŇt|£¢zx™qȮȻussŸ}£ȱ{
ýq›zýqȠ~už~¤wusš‰vzù²uõãu© £‚ {ȷɉȮŇt|£¢zȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš£u©¶
v«¤uò£ɪ£x}£u© Ƚbx²uõ£ɨu›fq¨vu¥uýx©~Ĝɇ|¤l}xÿ¥ræȿuȧ|i¨ȸböăfȺz
ýv£s¥r ȷȿub¨‚¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼuývýx›qòȮb¨‚¤l}ɉȮŇt|£¢zz™uȻul›f
£ɪ£x}¤l}cþąuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusšȺ£x}£Ⱥ©¶
ȶz~Ĝȹu¥ugɍvdœȷ ȾdšzŸ{z™uýqȠ~Ȼu„uɐɖq“ü£} b£ƒ f„¨xšb¨‚
ȷ ȮȹqwĀ¨£l z÷š£tÿ “ü£ɨȮ£ȿeªuž~ȧ|{}ýxzȻu£s ýv™u£v Ⱦdš¤l}£} b
£ƒ f£Ⱥ©Ȼu|Ÿzg¨¤pbývýx›qòb¨‚ £ȱ{‡|Ĝɀvrcþąu‘fŽɉgv£čçĔb¨‚Ȼu
Žýv™u£v böăfɆŌuȾx¤l}Ⱦdš£Ⱥ©ȿu}sõȾxl›f„¨xšb¨‚¤l}ɉg£b qȿu¶
qɂȧ|{}£e kȷýȩu¤qdpz÷qò™u™fzqóȾx|vvdä}¥uȾdš¥r¤l}Ȼu
£e k¤wusš‰vzù²uõäqv«£ȵɒ© b±u›f£tÿ “üȿuȧ|}¨Ȼbg¨£Ƚ©ýv£s¥r böăfȧ|
„©ɉf„¨xšb¨‚£u©ȵȶzwþĄ~gɍv¶ „öbȸ¨f£u©ɁvvčçĄ}ȸ¨fȿi™b¥u
dpªbzûȧ|ýx¨¤lu£u©¤qzòf ¤l}cþąuȿuzqób™gç£} ¤wöb£u©¥uýx¨¤lu¶ v«¤uò
£ýɗxš£u©qɂȧ|{}£e kȷ ȿuȧ}ª£sª£wĀf£s¢qȮ£ýg uȽbx²uõu›f¤wusš
‰vzù²uõãu© ¤l}£tÿ “üȧ|„©ɉf„¨xšb¨‚£u©}¨Ȼbu›fssŸ}{b¶
ȧ|x™u™qüx™g²{zŸ{vȫŖkȷ ¤wusš£u©Ȼuȸkȧ|Ȭvɉzûp¯ɀŘf
ýŸgýɆ}g¨£Ƚ©q¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ| ¤l}ȩœuvdä}Ƚbx²uõŽȩœuvdä}ȵȿŏbȿu
Ⱦ|b™gçx™u™qüx™g²{¤wusš ɉgcbȨuz™uȻu£e k„ÿš¤l}ȻuvȫŖk£ɪböăf¤wusš
- 40. 35
Ƚbx²uõu›fq¨vu£Ⱥ©£s¶ lžg¤l}ýv£s¥rȻu£} b£ƒ f ýv™u£v |žvȵ˴u
yžz™ɆĚò¥usšb¤uþf£Ⱥ© wò}}bãpªgɍɂg¨£Ƚ©u|ȵb±£ȱ{¤l}ȹŔv£ɨ
l}sš£Ⱥ© x™qȮ£e kȷ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›býqȠ~£l |ȶzv£ȵɑ{¤cĀg¨£ȵqrû (ýv™u
£v ȧ|p¯£u©x™q¤zu£Ⱥ© „f䣂q£u©x™qȮȿuɀŘfgɍȵ£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ)
lž£gö© ¤wusš£u©ȻuvȫŖk“ü£e kgɍȷ ¤cĀvȺōq|v¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃz™uȻu
£l |£ɨȶz¤cĀg¨£ȵqrû£s£ɪböăfq¨vu£Ⱥ© £ȱ{£‚qȷ¤cĀvȺōq£u©ýqȠ~Ȼudž
“ü£ɪȭŃ{£ɨȨf£i fx{¥uyö¨ýx©~Ĝɇ|ȸ¨fzž}¶ ȩœuu|ȵȿŏb¤l}£z }¤wusš
£u© £‚ {{}ýgƒ¨„¨xš¤wusš£u©£Ⱥ©£s¶
£} xš£u©£ɨ£s¢q ¤wusš£u©Ȼub¨pqɀŘfgɍuž~sšȶ¨fýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|
ó™qböăfs›blšbzùăȮ £ȱ{£ýv |žvɐɖ¤l}ɇblžgȮȧ|vȫŖkuž~vþfýqȡ¹¥usšȶ¨f
ýȻɆsu™fȧ¨i£pĎ |¤l}q¨ȵf“üýȻɆs£u©¶
lž£gö© ɃɇblžgȮȿux²q®ȿuýdvýȩu£‚ { £ɪböăf¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃ
£l z÷šȧqzuô™}fĀ²{ g¨£Ƚ©„öb¤l}ȿuȾ|b™gçýqȠ~x™u™qüx™g²{¤wusš£u©Žg¨£Ƚ©
u|ȵb±£ȱ{¤l}Ȼud™qȷ ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b£ɪq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|dŸ|¤q£l |ȶz¤cĀ
g¨£ȵqrû¶ ‚Ÿxš£u©£ɨ£s¢q lžg¤l}ȻugfĂă}vȫŖk|Ÿgzb£‚ { |ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢z
Ȼul›fŽýqȠ~ȻuuûqȷȻul›fȶz|{ªȿi™b£¢z¥udpªbzûȧ|gýz© ȷ¤wusš
‰vzù²uõÃz™u¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu„uz²qȮwþĄ~ȧ|£ȱ{dpªbzûȧ|£u©£s¶ ɉȮŇt|£¢z
Ȼul›f|Ÿg£‚ {ȷ ¤wusš£u©dœȮ}sõw}ȧ|ȫ||vzĚuòšȲu£}ȨɆĚòȻɁ¨f
¤l}ɉȮŇt|£¢zcþąu‘fȻuwò}i¨£u¡sbg™qò“ü£tÿ ȧ|ȫ|w}™q¤wusšȸ¨f£u©¶
ɉȮŇt|£¢zȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš£u©£ȱ{z™uȻu£tÿ ȧ|ýɆ~ýȮ~‘bɁiüȵ
zŸ{ lžg£u©£‚ {‡ƒĄ~£u© ɉȮŇt|£¢zz™uɉg„©ɉf„¨xšb¨‚£l z÷š}v£Ȭ}
už~ȧ|{}ýxzx™qýȻbl|vxŸb£d£Ⱥ©Ȼu£s¶ £‚qlž£gö©£‚ { qɂȧ|uö™ȱʼnu
ȷ ȧ|£} b£ƒ f„¨xšb¨‚z™uɉg{bȮȧ|Ȼu£s¶
‡ƒĄ~qɂȧ|u›fx™Ȭ|ȵ£} ýx›qò™ȧ|p¯ȺȺ£ýȧ{l¨ȵbȧ}ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ
-ÃËÂ˶
- 41. 36
xšzuzb ɉȮŇt|£¢zz™uȻu£} b¨pɕ|ȵzŸ{„¨xš¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃ
|Ƀfcþąu‘fu™fȻɁ¨fŽbzùăȮ Žvl™£t¤wusš£u©Ȯg¨‚£Ⱥ©£s |‚žql}ȧ|g|Ȭȭŏ¨
ÃËÇÊ £ɪsšýbfȻfbb £s vɉȮŇt|£¢z£} b{bvɐŖ¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃzbu™ɀ{
u™fvl™£t¤wusš£u©Ȯg¨‚£ɪböăfȧ|x™Ⱦbɏ|Ƀf¥ru™fbzùăȮ „¨xšvɐŖýȻɆs
ýx©~Ĝɇ|böăfg¨£ȵzvɐŖ£wĀf£s¢q¶ x¨ȿuvɐŖȵzŸ{ýqȠ~Ȼu£} b£ƒ f žz÷š¤q
£ýȧ{ȭŏ¨ÃËÅÆ-ÃËÅÇ £ɪ£x}¤l}¥r£tÿ ȧ|Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{cþąu‘f£ɪböăfq¨vu£u©
£‚ {ȶzsĀuª|v¥r ȧ|Ƀ¤~f£u©vȫŖkȷȿuȾxcȩŏ|Ƀf¤cĀvȺōq£ɪ
£} ¤wusšu™f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻbl ¤l}ȾxcȩŏzŸ{Ⱥ¨£ɨl}ȧ|ȱbýȻɆs
ýx©~Ĝɇ|böăfs›blšbzùăȮ¶ £ýȧ{ȧ}v|Ĝ£gès£u©zb £ȸ©vš¥r£x}cþ©Ȼuw}™q
¤wusšzŸ{g¨uŸu£ȱ{cþąu‘f¤l}vȫŖkȷ ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™qböăfs›blš¥rb±£ȱ{
b±¥r£ɪ¤qvuò£ýv ýȻȸ¨fýȿv£ȩ}v¨pfwþĄ~ȧ|u™fɆȹ|pªuž~¤wusš‰vzù²uõ
ÃŽ¤wusšl¥s£s¢q¤l}ȻuvȫŖkȷ ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™q£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ£ȱ{
z™uȻu£} b£ƒ fuž~¨pɕ|ȵzŸ{„¨xšvɐŖ£u©£s (ȧ|xuü}|v¥r „¨xšvɐŖ£u©
u›fýqȠ~{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵȺ£x}£ýȧ{)¶ £} xš£u©£s¢q qɂȧ|ȿuȧ|}¨Ȼb
u›f£z }|Ġ}fuž~£‚qȧ|p¯¤l}ȷ Ȯ‰ȸ‚|p¯ £ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÅÉ £ýȧ{xšȧ|
Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{¥rcþąu‘f£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÅÆ-ÃËÅÇ £‚ {¤l}£ɪȭŏ¨l¤l}£Ⱥ©ȿuȧ|
g©uõ™ɐɖȮzŸ{ȻɁ¨f ¤l}böăf£Ⱥ©ȿuȧ|„©ɉf£ƒ f~Ĝkuž~ýx¨¤lu|Ÿz¤l}Ȼu
b¨pq|Ÿg£‚ { „däȺ{bȱʼnuyžz™ɆĚòyžz™uô£¢zȻuw}™q¤wusšzŸ{vȫŖkȷ
ýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™q£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ¶
¥rȿu“ȧȮ£ýg ulf £l z÷š£} b£ƒ f„¨xšvɐŖ¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃȮzŸ{
ɉȮŇt|ȻɁ¨f¶ Ȯvmz ȿuȧ|g|Ȭ£} uõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÄÇu™fÃËÅÉ òšxšz™qòȾx
Ƚp™iébzûu™fȺɃg|p¯|ɃfȻɁ¨fböăfȺz‡pŊĐg™uu™f£¢z¶ £v sbȮuõ™ɐɖ
ȸ¨f£u©Ȼu¤gf„¨xšušq™~Ĝtšsž£ɨýȿv£ £|ĝ£ƒ f~ĜkŽi¨uŸb™gçýxz£ýx¢fzu¹ b±
uõ™ɐɖȸ¨f£u©z™uɁvvčçĄ}ýx¨¤lu ¤l}ȿuýɆvböăfušq™~Ĝtš¤l| £ȱ{£‚qȷ
ýx¨¤lu£u©ýqȠ~Ȼub¨pqȶzl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤lu£ɪȭŏ¨ÃÊËÅ ÃËÂÆ u™fÃËÂÉ
|Ÿg£‚ {¶ £‚qlž£gö©£‚ { u™fȶzvsv÷čìqò™Ȯb¤òfzŸ{g¨uŸu£s¢q Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|
- 42. 37
Ȼuqzâ}sbȮȻuȧ|g¨£Ƚ©ýx¨¤lu¤l}ȿuýɆv £ȸ©všýx¨¤lu£Ⱥ©ɀŘfȵb±
£ȱ{¶ ȸ¨f£u©dœȮ“ȧ¤l}ȶztzûȶ¥rdŸ|¤qȻu£} bvɐŖ£u© ýv™u£v cþąu
{}£e kȷ¤wusš£u©gfĂă}vȫŖkýx¨¤lu£ɪýqfýx©~Ĝɇ|z™uýq›zýqȠ~ (Ȯx™£
ȸbsfu›fȧ|g|Ȭuõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÅÉ ¤l}£tÿ £ƒ f¤qÄȭŏ¨v«£ȵɒ©vȺōvxšȧ|
Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{¥rcþąu‘f£} q¨vuýx¨¤lu£u© ¤l}ȻuvȫŖk“ü£e kȶzȧ|{}
£e k|v¥rȷ ȿuȾxcȩŏɀŘfȨŔ¨f|Ƀf¤cĀvȺōq£} ¤wusšu™f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b
£ɪýqfýx©~Ĝɇ|) ¤l}böăf“ȧȸ¨f£Ⱥ©¥rdŸ|¤qȻu u™fýqȠ~¤q£} bvɐŖ£u©£ƒ f
ýv™u£v ¥r£i¡Ȯbȷlž£Ȭŏ©¤zu¶ Ȯb¤òf ¥rz™uýq›z¤qz™uȻu£} b£ƒ fv«£ȵɒ©
£s v«¤uò¤rzȸ¨fw}™q¤wusšzŸ{£ȱ{cþąu‘f£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÅÉ ¤l}vȫŖkȷ ýx©~Ĝɇ|
ó™q£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ£s¢qwf¶ £ȸ©Ȯ¤wusš£u© £tÿ £ƒ fböăfv¨pf{bzb£ýv ýȻ
ýȿv£ȩ}£ɡ¥wôböăf£ɀȹb±£ȱ{ v«¤uòɃz™uȻu£tÿ “üqɂȧ|{}£e kȷ Ƀz™u
ȿuq¥zþȮyòăȶf£sböăfsĀuª|výv£s¥r£Ⱥ©¶ £dɉg£tÿ ȧ|uö™ȱʼnuȷ
Ȯx™££ɪböăfȧ}ª£sªȭŏ¨ÃËÅÉ ¥rȻuŽ£ɪ¤qȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš¥u
‰vzù²uõà u™f¤cĀvȺōq¤l}¤wusš£u©ȻugfĂă}vȫŖk £ȸ©vš¥r{}ȷ Ƀz™uýq›z
ýqȠ~ u™f£ȸ©vš£ýȧ{£x}cþąuȻu£tÿ ȧ|Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{cþąu‘f£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÅÆ-ÃËÅÇ
b±£ȱ{ ¥rȻud™qȷcþąuȻul›fȷ ¤wusš£u©z™uýq›zýqȠ~¶
£ɪ£x}¤l}¥rȻugž}ȧuȧvȮv£ȵɑ©ɉuö¤wöbzŸ{g¨uŸu¥uýv£s
bzùăȮ |Ÿzȸ¨fýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÆà ýbŸfx²q®ȿu¥rȻu£Ȼ©xzùwɏ{Ɇŏ¥lzŸ{
ȿug¨pf£i fȷ ¥rböăf£x}Ɇŋ|ýv£sȮq™£ƒ f~Ĝk ¤l}böăf£Ⱥ©Ȼuu™ɀ{
Ƚbx²uõl}ýx©~Ĝɇ|ȷ ‡ƒĄ~ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ýqȠ~Ȼuýv£s¥r{bzb~Ĝk£‚ {¶
g¨pɓgȨf£} £u© ýqȠ~Ȼu¥rvbýɆ{ȷȮb¨‚|vzĚuòšqžgȶgȿŏb¶ z«Ɏf£s¢q
ȾɆý£l¢fȩŏ£u© ¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼu£ýv ýȻ£ȱ{q¨ȵf|v¥r£ɪböăfȧ|g|Ȭs›b
lš|ɃfbzùăȮu™f¥r £ɪsšýbfȻfbb £ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÇÊ vȫŖkȷ¥r£s v¤qȻugž}ȧu
ȧvýx©~Ĝɇ|böăfýv¤‚}ȭŏ¨ÃËÆÂv«£ȵɒ©¶
- 43. 38
vȺōvxšĚȫłz|Ÿg ȶz|{ªb™gçýxz£ýx¢fl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{¤c~Ĝgè™ȧ ȭŏ¨ÃËÆÈ
ȮzŸ{ȻɁ¨f ¥rȻussŸ}{buž~ȧ|ýqƒv£ɨ|bɆŌuȾx£l z (status quo ante)
lžgzuȭŏ¨ÃËÆÃ~Ĝk¶ ¥r„©ɉfȷȧ|~Ĝ}ýqƒv£ɨ|bɆŌuȾx£l z£u© (status quo)
z™uv«©Ƚ}l}q¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|£s £ȱ{Ɇ|¥rȻuȿu„t™v£q{ü£} q¨vu£u©ȶ¨fxš
zuĚȫłz£z«þ©¶ qɂȧ|z™uȬ¨Ȼgx™Ⱦbɏ£} ȧ|„©ɉf£u©£s xš£ýȽ©vɐŖ¤l}ȷ
£q ¥rȿuŽx¨ȿu„t™v£q{ü£Ⱥ© dœȮvɐŖgɍɂ£ɪböăfušq™~Ĝtš£u©£‚ {¶ vȺōv
xšýx›qò™ȧ|p¯Ěȫłz|Ÿgzb g¨pɓg¨Ȩu£Ⱥ©dœȷ ȻɁ¨fýxz£ýx¢fv£fâ qdpªbzûȧ|
ýz©ýzȡ}ȻɁ¨f-£¢z ¤l}|Ÿzȿuq¨ȵfxš||žvzbxšȾdšušzŸ{¹u™fȿi™b
„xɎýb›qvš|žv ¤l}ȿuȾ|b™gçȮx™£x™u™qüu™fwò}„uɆu¯£ȱ{j|£} zž}
ȱʼnuztz®g¨£Ƚ©Ɂ}vpĎ›fŽ¨£p ¨£ £|ĝ£ƒ f~Ĝk ¤l}¥rɉgȿuv¨pfu›f
£ö £ƒ f„¨xšȧ|£ȱ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤luȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆu™fÃËÂÉ böăfg¨£ȵzvɐŖl¥s£s¢q¶
dpªbzûȧ|£u©ȻuiŸvývi¨ȩŏ£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÆÉ £ɪsšýbfɃŘšu£ȶu £‚ {£ɪsš£Ⱥ©
£‚ { ¤l}Ȯ“ȧl±ýv£ |ýȿv¥rȸzȸ|“ü£tÿ ȧ|¤bqýzȠ~ýx¨¤lu£ɪq¨vuýx©
~Ĝɇ|£ȱ{j|£} zž}ȱʼnuȷ ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u©ȿub¨‚tæutæ|¤l}ɉgȺ¨“ü
¥rvl™£tȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu£u© ýv™u£v cþąuȻul›f„¨xšb¨‚£u©£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ-
ÃËÂË ¤zu£Ⱥ©¶ ȶzx™q £v sbȮ¥rȻuvò›fȮ£ýg ulf„¨xš¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪböăfq¨vu
Ȯ£ýg ub±£ȱ{ b±¥rz™uȻuvò›fȸ}¤q£Ɇ©„¨xšq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|¶ z™uýq›z¤qv«£ȵɒ©
£ɪ¥ræsšÃÄ ¤c‰Ⱦ ȭŏ¨ÃËÆÉ ¥r¤rzȸ¨fȻuȱbižu£ɨdpªbzûȧ|už~¤wusš
zŸ{¤l}vȫŖkȷýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™q£ɪböăfýv£sbzùăȮ£s¢qwf¶ ¥r„©ɉfȷ ȧ|p¯
£u©z™uȿuw}v«©Ƚ}Ȯ„~Ĝiéȿug¨£Ƚ©ȧ|ȸzȸ|™sõ™£} ýȻɆs£s xš£ýȽ©q¨vu
ýȻɆsz™u¤zuȮbzû~qóă¥uȧ|x™Ⱦbɏ|vdpªbzûȧ|£u©£s dœq¨vu£wĀf£s¤l}
Ȯbzû~qóă¥uȧ|x™Ⱦbɏ£u© £‚ {dœ¤wusš¤l}ȸbsfu›fq¨vuȸ¨f£Ⱥ©£s¤l}ýqȠ~
Ȼu{bzb£ýv ýȻ¶ v«¤uò„f䣂qvȫŖkgɍɂȷ ¥rȻu£} bvɐŖl¥s
£s¢qȮ£ýg u v«¤uòz™uȻu£} b„¨xšvɐŖýx©~Ĝɇ|¤l}qýzȠ~“üȿuȧ|xuü}£s¶
£ȱ{z™ud™q„¨xšvɐŖ£wĀf£s¢q £ɀfȶz£‚qȧ|p¯¤l}£b q£ƒ fzŸ{g¨uŸu£ɪ
zž}ȱʼnuȸbsfu›fýȻɆs£u© ¥rȻul›fɀŘfgɍ£ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©ȷ ȻɁ¨fȻu
- 44. 39
Ȭqsbȷ ýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™q£ɪböăfs›blšbzùăȮ lžg¤l}ȻuvȫŖkböăf¤wusšdž£ȱ{
ɉȮŇt|ȻɁ¨f u™fȻuvčéĄu“ü|ȱʼny™Ȼ}£¢z£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ £v sbȮȧ|p¯£u©z™u
Ȼuvɐņbgɍ£gkxš¤cĀýx¨¤lubòš¶ Ȯrûšzòf£s¢q ȧ|uö™ȱʼnuȮtzûȶ„¨xšȧ|cb
Ȩu|v¥rböăfȧ|£} b£ƒ f„¨xšýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɪböăf“ȧ£Ⱥ© dœȷcþąuz™uȻuqɃŘlž£Ȭŏ©
xš£ýȽ©cþąuȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤cĀýx¨¤luýqfg¨pɓg£u© lžg¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ¤wusš
£ȱ{z™ud™qȷ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£u©£l |Žz™u£l |ȶz¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b£s¶
g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|£ýv ýȻ¤wusš¤l}vȫŖkȷýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™qböăfýv£sbzùăȮ ¥r
|bɏi¨‚|ȷ £u©Ȯ£‚qw}¤wöb¤wusšsõɆt £‚ {b±ȩœu¤wusšl¥s£s¢q£s Žb±
z™uȿu¤wusš¤l}ȫ{ýŸ}£ýv Žz™uȿu¤wusšȵ¤l}ȿuȿýqȱʼnuýq›zýqȠ~böăf
£x}£Ⱥ©£ƒ {¶ qɂȧ|{}£e kȷȧ|xuü}£u©z™uɉg£i¡Ȼu£s¶ ȮzŸ{
u›fȧ|vuò£ýv ýȻ¤wusš£u© ¥rdŸ|¤qȻu£tÿ ȧ||bɏ™sõ™výzfȮzŸ{ȻɁ¨fg¨£Ƚ©Ⱦx
ýq›zýqȠ~|v¤wusš£u©¶ v«¤uò¥rz™uȻu£tÿ lž£gö©£s¶
g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|cbȨu|v¥r žz÷š¤q£} b£ƒ f„¨xšvɐŖ¤wusš£u©|‚žql}
ȭŏ¨ÃËÇÊ£Ⱥ© ¥r„©ɉfȷ £ȱ{Ɇ|cþąuȻuȧuȧvýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɪýdvz²{ȧ}
¨Ȩu¹ȸ¨f„ £‚qlž£gö©£‚ {£s v¥rz™uȬ¨Ȼg£} bvɐŖ£u©£s¶ ¥rȻuȧ|Ƚ|
s£fÿ |vcþąu£ȱ{¤wĂb£} bzûȾxȮb¤òf£ɪzž}ȱʼnuȮyòăȶf ȷcþąuz™u¤l}
ýxzssŸ}{b¤cĀvȺōq‰vzù²uõãɪ‘ýx©~Ĝɇ|ȸ}¤q£Ɇ© £‚ {„©ɉfȷ£v cþąu
z™u¤l}ȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤cĀvȺōq£Ⱥ©wf gɍȵcþąuz™uȬ¨Ȼgvl™£t¤cĀ
vȺōq£Ⱥ©£s lž£gö©£‚ {£dx¨ɉg£tÿ £gbòšuö™ȱʼnuȮ„~ĜiéȿuȵzŸ{£gkxšȧ|
cbȨu|vcþąuböăfȧ|£tÿ lž£Ȭŏ©£s¶ q¥zþ¥uȧ|xuü}£u© ýqȠ~¤qɉý²{ɀŘfx™q
ýȻbl£ɨ£} g¨pɓg¤l}ýqȠ~l›fȷ £q ‡|Ĝɀvr£ɪ£} lšȮb¤òf|v¥r ɉgwò}
ȮyòăȶfýdvýȩuȮývq™bzû (ex post facto) £l z÷švȫŖkȷ cþąuz™u¤l}ýxz
ssŸ}{b¤cĀýx¨¤lu|v‰vzùuõ²Ã £ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ ȸbsfu›fýx©~Ĝɇ| u™fȬqsb
cþąu‘fȷȿu„t™v£q{ü£} q¨vuýȻɆs£u©ýdvz²{ȧ}¨Ȩu¹ȸ¨f„Ȼu
¤l|Ž£s¶
- 45. 40
*
* *
qɂȧ|Ȼux™Ȭ|ȵyòăȶfwò}£ȱ{¥r ȶz|{ªbzûȾx|lîȻ}|v
zĚuòšcþąu£ɪq¨vuýx©~Ĝɇ|ŽȽbx²uõu›fýx©~Ĝɇ|¶ ȻɁ¨f £‚ {£ýȧ{zbbzùăȮȶz
Ȳuª|vcþąu¤l}ȿu¤gf£ɪböăf„uɐɖÃËÂÆ Ȼu£tÿ ¤qbzûȾx|lîȻ}ȶz
sȿŔvvuò™gvuòąg¤qv«£ȵɒ©£ɪböăfq¨vuȱgýɀ}qžgzŸ{£u©¶ ¥rȻussŸ}Ɇł}
ɀŘfgɍɂ£ɪböăf£x}£tÿ ~Ⱥȧ|ȼō}ȿqȷ £v bzùăȮssŸ}Ȼu„t™v£q{ü
£} q¨vuýȻɆs£u©ȶzɆœ|qš¥ul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤luȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ £‚ {£ýȧ{zb
bzùăȮb±z™uȻu£Ȼ©vf£Ȭ}„t™v£q{ü£u©£s g¨¤pb‘ýv£s¥rz™u¤l}ȻussŸ}
„t™v£q{ü£u©ȶz|{ªɉȮŇ{ȧ}}sõbzû£u©£s¶ lž£gö© bzûȾxȮb¤òf|v
¥rýqȠ~Ȼu£} b£ƒ fȮyòăȶf¥ubzûȾx Ȯ„¨ȵgýdvýdf¤l}ȿu}bãpª
ýdvýȩu £l z÷švl™£tg¨£Ƚ©ȧ|£} b£ƒ f¤l}ȷ ȶzl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{„uɐɖ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ ¥rȻuýxzssŸ}{bȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu¤l}ȿuɉuȾxwò}„t™v£q{ü
£} ýx©~Ĝɇ|£ɨ“übzùăȮ¶ lž£gö©ȶzsĀuª£u© qɂȧ|ýqȠ~¤qx™Ȭ|ȵu™fɃ{q¥zþ
£} bzûȾxȸ¨f£u©¶ vɐŖx™qýȻbldœȷ £q bzûȾxȸ¨f„£u©ýdvýȩu£l z÷š
}v£Ȭ}ŽsbȮ£ȿeª¤l|Ž£s už~ȧ|vȫŖkhuôªɀŘfgɍ„¨xšȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b
¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪýx©~Ĝɇ| ¤l}Ȯ}sõw}¥uȧ|x™Ȭ|ȵ¤l}Ȼux™ȾbɏȨf£}
|Ÿg£‚ {£Ⱥ©¶
bzûȾx¤l}Ƚbx²uõ dœsõ¤qȮbzûȾx|vɉȮŇt|zž}ȱʼnuu™fȷŏb
£cqò¤qv«£ȵɒ© £} b¤}f¤qb|pš¨Ȩu¹zŸ{Žxš|¤l}ýqȠ~£} b£ƒ fȺ£x}£u©¶
£ɪböăfbýz™q¤l}bzûȾxȸ¨f£u©Ȼu£b q£ƒ f £dz™ugɍ£sȷbzûȾxȸ¨f
£u© ȿuȧ|Ƚbx²uõu›fb¨xž}yö¨ýx©~Ĝɇ|u™fq¨vuýȻɆsȼō}ȮȮfȽbx²uõu›fb¤uþf
¤b÷|¹q¨vu£Ⱥ©¶ v«¤uò£ȸ©ȮɀŘfb±£ȱ{ qɂȧ|x™Ȼbu›fȬqsbȷ bzûȾx
ȷŏbzž}ȱʼnu¤vv£u© Ȯȧ|£tÿ £ȿebzûu™fi¨ȸuž~i¨‚|šgȫŕbu™fz™u¤ývývȡ}
|vɉȮŇt|£¢zȷŏbbȵɑ}£u© ȸbsfu›f¤cĀýx¨¤lulžgȿudžböăf¤wusš¶
- 46. 41
ȸbsf£ɨu›f£|¡f£u© ýx›qò™ȧ|p¯l±¨Ȩuv¨wq£Ⱥ©dœȧ|£tÿ sĀub™gç£ɨ
ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|böăfȭŏ¨ÃËÅ £ȱ{ýx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf „qšq|lîzĚuòšzɇ¥wô £‚ {
£ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©Ȯývȹu~ĜsɎɆŌuyžz™uô£¢zssŸ}vuôăbȧ|ȫ|ȸbsfu›fvȵɒ}²{
Ȯq™u™fvžiuš{ȱʼnuvɁp~qóă~ĜsɎ¶ sĀub™gç£u© dœȮ¤wöbzŸ{¥ul¨£p |sĀub™gç
vɁp~qóă~ĜsɎ|výx©„fäȿń£ȱ{ȿuȧ|„uɐɖqxšýx©zɇbĀýq£¢z u™fl¨£p |
sĀub™gç£u©ȿu}bãpª£ô |¤qwþĄ~ȧ|ɀŘfgɍ¶ £ɪ£x}ýx©„fäȿń£ɨl}
ýx©~Ĝɇ| ýx©„fäȿńýqȠ~ȻussŸ}ȮwþĄ~ȧ|£ȱ{„öbq¨ȵfȻɁ¨f ¤l}ývȬ¨£ɪ
£cqò|vbzùăȮböăfȺz„öbq¨ȵfȮucùȻɁ¨f|vcþąu £ȱ{ȿuvfāĄqsfȮq™
ȻɁ¨f£s¢qwf¶ ýx©„fäȿńýv¤‚}Ȯz™us¨ufȮz™u{}už~„qóu²{¥uȧ|ssŸ}
¤vv£u©£Ⱥ©£s¶ £dýv¤‚}Ȯu›fx™Ȼb|b„¨p©„¨ȵfvɐņbxšbzû™sõ™|vȾdš
‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f“ügɍȮf£u©ȵ¶ ȧ|p¯£u© ȸzȸ|“üȿuývq™bzû ¤q¥rz™u
ȿuývq™bzû„ÿš£Ɇ©¶ £} xš£u©£s¢q £ɪ£x}ýx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf ýqƒv£ɨ
Ȼfbb~Ĝk Ȼu£wë |žvrqzŸ{g¨uŸu¥u“ȧ£Ⱥ©ižu„öbq¨ȵfȻɁ¨f£s¢qwf ýx©„fä
Ȼu£ýv ȾɆ¤l}ɇblžgȮssŸ}Ɇł}ȷ ȶz|{ª„öbq¨ȵf|vcþąu ȻɁ¨fȻu
£l |qŸȺsšȮýv£sȿńwô©¶
£gbòšxuü}ȸbsfu›fl¨£p |sĀub™gç|výx©„fäȿń ȱz |ġf böăfȺz
ýv£s¥r z™uɉg“üqɂȧ|£i¡ȮbȻu£s¶ £ȱ{x™u™qü£z }£‚qȧ|p¯ȸ¨fzž}
£e kȷ ȿuȧ|ssŸ}Ɇł}£ȱ{qpŖšȾx|v£¢z g¨£Ƚ©„t™v£q{ü|vbzùăȮ
(£ýȧzɉȵxɎȻ}ȻɁ¨f) £} ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ| £‚ {ȶz|{ªȧ|cbȨu|v
£¢zz™uȻuv£ɐńkývq™bzûȶzz£tɎȻ{ȵzŸ{ £ɪböăfȧ}ª£sª¤l}ȸzȸ|
“üȿuývq™bzû£l z÷švɐņbŽȧ|Ƚ|bzû™sõ™Ȯȿń £ɪg¨£Ƚ©zc¥uȧ|ȸzȸ|qv
£ȱ{Ȯb¤òf£Ⱥ©¶ „ÿš¤l}ɇblžgȮgɍɂ£Ⱥ©dœȷȧ|x™q£¢zz™uýȻbl
cþąu‘fȷcþąuȿubzû™sõ™£Ⱥ©£s -£‚ {£u©dœývȩŏȸ¨fýf£ɨu›f‡|Ĝɀvr|v
£¢zȶ¨fxš£l zzb u™f£ýȧ{zb£s¢qg¨£Ƚ©¤wusšu™f¤cĀvȺōq‰vzù²uõà -Žb±Ȼu
£ýzgȷ z™u„©ɉfuž~bzû™sõ™|vcþąu£s ¤l}Ȯrûšzòf£s¢q£u©ȿuu²{ȷ cþąuȻu
- 47. 42
ýxzssŸ}{bȧ|ȸzȸ||vȻɁ¨fŽȻuýxzssŸ}{býx¨¤lu£ɪýx©~Ĝɇ| lžg¤l}
Ȼudž£ɪböăf¤wusš£Ⱥ©£‚ {¶
*
* *
„f䣂qȽbx²uõȸ¨fɈ{¤l}£ɪ£} ýqȠ~¤q£} b{bzbu™ɀ{
Ⱥ£x}£u©¶ £ɪ¤cbzúª ȭŏ¨ÃËÆË z™u{ž|v«ȺœuvȺōvxšȻuvčçvušq™~Ĝtš¥udpª
bzûȧ|ýz©ýzȡ}ȻɁ¨f-£¢z ¤l}£ɪböăf|{ª£x}l¨£p |ȧ|dpªbzûȧ|£Ⱥ©
Ȯb¤òf¥rz™uȻu£} bvɐŖýx©~Ĝɇ|£s ȻɁ¨fȻu£wë b¨pqsžqzŸ{ižu|ȱʼny™Ȼ}
¥r £ȱ{vɐņbȷcþąuȻussŸ}|Ȼ{ȧ|p¯òšxšȧ|ȶ¨f£ɪ¥uȭœ¨£¢zg¨uŸu Æ Ⱥb
£ɪýȻɆs£u© u™f£ö ¨“üwò}x²q®ȿu ¶ x¨ȿuȧ|£hþ {qvg¨£Ƚ©b¨pqsžq£u©£s
£‚ {b±z™uȿuȧ|£hþ {qv£ɨu›fb¨pqsžqzŸ{£ýȧ{zb£s¢q £ɪ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÆË
¤l|¶ £ɪ¤c‰Ⱦ ȭŏ¨ÃËÆË ȻɁ¨fȻu£wë b¨pqsžqzŸ{£s¢qcþš v«¤uòȿuu²{ɀŘf
gɍ„¨xšzž}£‚q¤l}ȻɁ¨fȬqsbȷ ýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™qböăfýv£sbzùăȮ u™fgfĂă}
vȫŖkȷ¤wusš¤l}w}™q£ȱ{¥rcþąu‘fb±ȻussŸ}Ɇł}£‚qȧ|p¯£u©¶ ȻɁ¨f
Ȼu£ö ¨“ülbȭœ¨ȸ¨f£Ⱥ©£gk¶ £v sbȮȿub¨‚£ɪböăfb¨pqsžq£u©bòš cþ›zɆ|
¥ub¨pqsžq£Ⱥ©dœȷ ȿuȧ|„©ɉfvɐņb¤l}z™uɉgýv¤bbȻu„¨xš„t™v£q{ü¶
b¨pqsžq|vȻɁ¨f£u© b±x¨ssŸ}Ȼuȧ|£hþ {qv¤l|¶ £ɪ¤cbbâȱ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇ ȻɁ¨f
Ȼu£wë b¨pqsžqzŸ{v¤uóz£s¢q¶ b¨pqsžq£u© b±£ɪ¤qx¨ssŸ}Ȼuȧ|£hþ {qv¤l|¶
£ɪböăfȧ}ª£sªȸ¨f£u© £ɪ£x}ssŸ}Ȼu‘bɁiüȭŏ¨ÃËÇÅ bzùăȮȻu
£ö včéĄuȭœ¨Ž„öbɀzböăfȺzcþąu‘f£ɨȧuýȻɆs£u© £l z÷šȮȧ|vɐņbŽȧ|
|bɏi¨‚||vcþąu¶ v«¤uò£ȱ{£e kȷ ȭœ¨¥rȿu~qòȿu£ɪsš£Ⱥ©|Ÿg£‚ { ȭœ¨bzùăȮ
b±Ȼulbzb~Ĝk £‚ {bzùăȮb±Ȼu£wë b¨pqsžqzŸ{g©¤czbɁ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ £ɨ
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r£ö ¨x²q®ȿu¶ b¨pqsžq£u©ýȩu¤qssŸ}Ȼuȧ|vɐņbȷȻussŸ}
v«£ȵɒ© £ȱ{ȩœu£gbòšxuü}„ÿš£ƒ {¶ žz÷š¤qzbl}£x}£u©bòš b±x¨ȿuȧ|
„©ɉfȮwþĄ~ȧ|ȵzŸ{„¨xšȧ|ȸzȸ||v¥r¤l|¶ £ɪgf¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ £ȱ{
- 48. 43
{}£e kȷ ȩœuȧ|£hþ {qvȮl¨b¨yŸug¨£Ƚ©b¨pqsžq|vcþąuxšzu |ȱʼny™Ȼ}
bzùăȮȻuižul¨p›f£ɨ|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥rȷ £ɪ£x}£u©bzùăȮ£ö ¨ȱbbfs²xbzùăȮ
zŸ{g¨uŸui¨uŸȭœ¨Ž„öb¤r|bɏ|vbzùăȮ¤l}Ȼulb£gkxšzuzb¶ £ɪböăfb¨pq
sžq£u© bzùăȮȻuu™ɀ{£ɀfȮx™££ɨ£} ȧ|¨ɉf£‚qw}¥uȧ|ȸzȸ|
|vbzùăȮ¤l}ȿu£ɪböăfb¨pqsžq|vȻɁ¨f ¤c‰Ⱦ ȭŏ¨ÃËÆ˶ b¨pqsžq
|vbzùăȮ£u©b±z™uȻussŸ}ȧ|£hþ {qv¤l|¶ £ȸ©ȮɀŘfȵb±£ȱ{ bzùăȮz™u
ȻuvčéĄuȸɇu£ɨsš£Ⱥ©£s £‚ {£ɪ¤cz™rȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ bzùăȮȻu£wë b¨pqsžq
v¤uóz£s¢q£ɨýv£s¥r £ȱ{vɐņbȷ ȶzx²q®ȿu¤l}ȻussŸ}dœȷ ȸɇu¥r
£ɪȧuȧvsš£Ⱥ©|Ÿg£‚ { £‚ {bzùăȮȼŗbȧ|včéĄuȸɇu|vcþąu£ɨsš£Ⱥ©
böăf£ȩ}v¨pfz™u£tÿ “üɆŌuȧ|p¯tæutæ|¶ b¨pqsžq£Ⱥ©b±vuò£ö “ü¥rŽzŸ{lb
s²x|vcþąu£gk ŽzŸ{b±wò}sĀuª|v¥ròšxšvɐŖ£u©l}bzùăȮ¶ b¨pqsžq
£u©b±z™uȻussŸ}ȧ|£hþ {qvlžgxšzu¤l|¶ v«¤uò ȸɇu|v¥r (¤l}ȶzx™q
qɂȧ|l›fȷxŸbȸ¨f£Ⱥ©ȮbȿŔ¨fv«ž}š) £ɪ¤qȿu~qòȿu£ɪsš£Ⱥ©l¤l}¶ lž£gö©
Ȯrûšzòf£s¢q ɃɇblžgȮȷýv£s¥r £v sbȮȿu~Ĝȹuȧ|zŸ{g¨uŸu£ɪ£} lšȮb
¤òf b±¥rz™uȻu£ýq¢zvl™£tȧ|ȸzȸ||vȻɁ¨f u™fbzùăȮböăfbýz™qȧ|sžq£s¶
x¨ȿu}™c™qȧ|sžqv¤uóz£s¢q ýqȠ~Ȼu{bzbvȫŖkqɂȧ|£s¶ v«¤uò
Ȯ{ȷ£‚q£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÇÊ ȿuuö™šszŸ{ýqȠ~ȻuýȻ|’£ƒ f£ɪsšýbfȻfbb
|Ƀfýv£s¥ru™fbzùăȮ £l z÷šx™Ⱦbɏ„¨xšvɐŖzŸ{g¨uŸuȸbsfu›fs›blš¤l}ȿu
i£ȿŔ©|Ƀf|ɃfȾdšȸ¨fxš||ŸzȿuvɐŖýx©~Ĝɇ|wf¤l|¶ q¨ȵf|v¥rȻuvl™£t
z™ux™Ⱦbɏ£} s™lîȾxgɍv¥uvɐŖ£u©£s £‚ {ȧ|g|ȬȻuvɁi²{ £‚ {bzùăȮ
ȻuȬqȧ|ȶzušq™~Ĝtš£u©¶
*
* *
£ɪ£x}£u© qɂȧ|u›f£tÿ £gbòš£ö ¨£ȱ{lbýf£gkxš„f䣂q lžg
ȿuȨf£} ¶ £v sbȮȿuȧ|fĀ²{cþ©g¨£Ƚ©ȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b|v£¢zuž~¤wusš
- 49. 44
£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ £‚ {¤l}Ȯ£‚qȺ¨“ücþąuýxzssŸ}{býx¨¤lu¤l}gfĂă}vȫŖk£}
¤wusš£Ⱥ© qɂȧ|£ȱ{¤wĂb£} ýx›qò™ȧ|p¯ȮvuòvȺōv{}£e kȷ ‡ƒĄ~£u©
ȶz|{ª‡|Ĝɀvr|vcþąu¥rz™uýqȠ~Ȼu„uɐɖq“ü„©ɉfȷ cþąuz™uȻuýxzssŸ}
{b¤wusš£u©£Ⱥ©£s¶ „|{ª£x} ÇÂȭŏ¨ ýv£s£u©ȻussŸ}w}ýv£ɀiu¯
ýdv¤vvɀŘf¤l}„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ wò}“ücþąuɀŘf£ɇgȵ b±w}ýv£ɀiu¯
¥uýx¨¤luzŸ{¤l}ȿuó™|Ⱦx¤l|¶ ȶz|{ªȻɁ¨f bzùăȮu™fȻɁ¨f £i¡ȷýv£s
¥rssŸ}{b¤wusš£u©¶ £ȱ{Ɇ|¤qȩœuȾdšȵzŸ{ɉg„©ɉf„¨xšb¨‚ lž£gö©Ƀ
z™uȿuýv£ɀiu¯„ÿšböăfȧ|¤ÿf{}„¨xšȧ|£i¡sbg™qò¤l}ɉý²{£} ȧ|£i¡Ȯb
ȷ¤wusš£u©ýq›zýqȠ~Žz™uýq›zýqȠ~£Ⱥ©£s¶ ‡ƒĄ~£u© £ȱ{£ɪ¤qvuò£} b£ƒ fxšw}
ýv£ɀiu¯ u™fɉý²{w}¤l}ssŸ}Ȼuxšl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{£u© ¥rz™uɉgvl™£tȷ
cþąuz™u¤l}ȮȾdš{}ýxzg¨£Ƚ©l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{£u©Ȼu£s¶
£ȸ©všȮɀŘfȵb±£ȱ{ qɂȧ|{}£e kȷ £ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ-ÃËÂË ¥r
x™qȮȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš‰vzù²uõà ȷȮ}sõw}¥uȧ|ȫ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu¤l}
Ȯ£‚qȺ¨“ücþąussŸ}Ɇł}¤cĀvȺōq£ɪ£} ¤wusš£Ⱥ© Ȯ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}ɉuȾx
¥uȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b£u© dœȱbýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™qböăfs›blšbzùăȮ¶ qɂȧ|{}£e k
v¤uóz£s¢qȷ ýv™u£v x™u™qü£z }Ȯ|Ÿz ‡|ĜɀvrȮvuòvȺōv|v¥r vɐņbu™f
ȩ¨ýsȧ|ýxzssŸ}{bxšl¨vžf|vcþąu £‚ {ȷbzûȾxȮb¤òf|vcþąuz™uýdv
ýȩu£l z÷švl™£tȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b£u©Ȼu£s¶ ȶz|{ª‡|Ĝɀvr|vcþąu Ⱦdš
ȸ¨fxš|ȻussŸ}Ɇł}¤cĀvȺōq£u© Ȯzž}£‚qȺ¨“üxŸb£dx™qȮȻuýxz£ýx¢fȩŏ
Ȭqsb¤cĀvȺōq£u© Ȯ¤cĀýx¨¤lu ¶
*
* *
‡ƒĄ~£u© qɂȧ|ýqȠ~x™Ȭ|ȵ£} vɐŖxš|£s¢q¶ ¥r„©ɉfȷ Ȭvȶ¨fxš
ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ £‚ {Ȯx™£ |‚žql}ȿuȧ|Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{cþąu‘f ȭŏ¨ÃËÅÆ-ÃËÅÇ
¥r£i¡Ȯbȷ ¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ£} ¤wusšýqȡqšȩŏu™f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b lž£gö©£‚ {ýv™u
- 50. 45
£v ¥rssŸ}{b¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ£} ¤wusš£Ⱥ© cþąu£tÿ lž£Ȭŏ©b±£ȱ{Ɇ|ȿui¨£u¡¤vv
£Ⱥ©¤l|¶ ȿuyòăȶfvɐņbȷ ȧ|„©ɉf¤vv£u©x™qȮz™ušgȫŕbȩŏȸ}¤q£Ɇ©
ȮzŸ{u›fȧ|„©ɉf¤l}¥rȻu£} b£ƒ fɀŘfȨŔ¨fȧŔ u™fýŸgýɆ}ȷ bzûȾx
ȺȺböăfȧ|„u~qò„t™v£q{ü Ȯb¤òfȻuvɐņbɀŘfgɍuž~i¨£u¡|vcþąuȷ cþąu
ȿu„t™v£q{ü£} q¨vuýȻɆs£u© ¸ ýv™u£v ¥rx™qȮ{}ýgƒ¨„¨xš¤cĀýx¨¤lu
‰vzù²uõà ¤zu£Ⱥ© - ȿuu²{ȷ ýv™u£v ¥r{}ȷ ¤cĀýx¨¤lu‰vzù²uõÃgfĂă}
vȫŖkăuž~¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›býq›zýqȠ~£Ⱥ© - £Ⱥ©cþąugɍȮȻu£i¡ȷ q¨vuýȻɆs
£u©ó™qböăfs›blšbzùăȮɀŘfx™qýȻbl (£ȱ{¤wĂb£} zž}ȱʼnu¥u¤wusš¤l}cþąuȻu
ýxzssŸ}{b£Ⱥ©)¶ ýv™u£v ¥rȿui¨£u¡¤vv£u©¤zu £‚ {i¨£u¡£u©vfâv£ɪböăf
Ɂ}ȧ|„©ɉf ¤l}ȷcþąuȻuýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš‰vzù²uõãu©£ȱ{Ɇ|¤qcþąu
d™qȷ¤wusš£u©ýq›zýqȠ~ £Ⱥ©bzûȾx|vcþąu£ɪ£} sšȶ¨fȮb¤òfýqȠ~ȻuȬq
sbȷȮȧ||Ġ£ɂyv¨Ƚu£ȱ{£gqȺ£} „t™v£q{ü (¤wĂb£} ȧ|uö™ȱʼnulžgȻu
£|¢vɁvȨf£} ) ¤l}£tÿ “üȿuȧ|uûqȷ ¥rȻul›fȷbzùăȮȧuȧvq¨vuýȻɆs
£u©¶ £gbòš£ö ¨dœȷ ¥rz™uɉg„©ɉfȷcþąuȿuȧ|y²uòýgƒ¨böăfȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b
¤cĀýx¨¤lu‰vzù²uõà ¤l}Ȯȧ|wôă{ýƒ©£ɨu›f£‚qw}¤l}cþąuȻuwò}ȸbsf
u›fbzûȾxȮb¤òf|vcþąulžgȮȷ cþąuȿui¨£u¡Ȼuȧuȧv„t™v£q{üböăf
q¨vu£u©¶
£dɉg{}£e kv¤uózȻuȷ £v sbȮȧ|£} b£ƒ f„¨xšȧ|y²uòýgƒ¨|v
¥rɉgssŸ}{bȻuȮ£ȩ}ȧ|p¯b±£ȱ{ b±¥rdŸ|¤q£} b£ƒ fȾŔzvȺōvxšȻu
£tÿ ȧ|Ƀ¤~f£ȱ{cþąu‘f£} q¨vui£ȿŔ©£u©böăfȭŏ¨ÃËÅÆ-ÃËÅǶ ȶ¨fxš£x}
£Ⱥ©zb ¥rz™uɉgȷcþąuȮ„öb|f£ýȩ©£ȱ{ȧ|y²uòýgƒ¨ȵzŸ{£ƒ {¶
*
* *
Ȯgf£ýȧ{ ȿus™lîȾxzŸ{£s¢q¥u£|¡fbòš£u©¤l}Ȭ¨Ȼgqɂȧ|ýqȠ~£} b
- 51. 46
{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵ¶ qɂȧ|{}£e kȷ ȧ|ýxzssŸ}{b¤wusš‰vzù²uõà £ȱ{
Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|Ⱥ¨“ü¤wusš£u©gž}£ɨböăfl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{uõ™ɐɖ u™fȧŔ{Ȯ¤wöbzŸ{
¤l}z™uɉgȧqȼŋgȻu¥ul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{uõ™ɐɖ£u©¶ £dz™uɉgu™ɀ{Ȼuȷ
l¨£p |ȧ|£u©ȫb£gkxš ŽɉgȮȧ||Ġ£ɂyv¨Ƚu£} }bãcpŊȸ¨fɈ{¥u„uɐɖ
ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ £Ⱥ©Ȼu£s £ɪɁ}b|pš¤l}¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ£} ¤wusšȫb£gkxš¤cĀ¤vf
¤gbs›b £ȱ{£‚qȷ £v £ɀf£ɨȶzȧ|{}|vqɂȧ|xšvɐŖ£u©¤wusšýqȠ~
ȻuýxzssŸ}{b£ȱ{Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÊ £‚ { (£ȸ©všɃýqȠ~Žz™uýqȠ~ýdv
s™lîȾxȸ¨f„£ɨu›f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qb±£ȱ{) u™f£ýȧ{zbȬqsbȷȮ}sõ
w}¥uȧ|vbýɆ{£ȱ{|ȱʼny™Ȼ}ȸ¨fxš| „¨xšȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu¤l}uõ™ɐɖ£u©
qýzȠ~“üȿu¶ z«Ɏf£s¢q £ɪ£x}£Ⱥ©Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|Ȼu£ýzg{bȧ|vbýɆ{
zŸ{£u©¥ul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{uõ™ɐɖ¤l}ȷ böăfb|pšȿuȧ|cȩŏȮzŸ{u›f¤cĀ
¤vf¤gbs›b ¤cĀýx¨¤lu¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ¤wusš£u© ȿuɉuȾx£} }v£} vs
v÷čìqò™£wĀf£s¢q|vuõ™ɐɖ¶ v«¤uò £v sbȮ£ɪ£x}£u© qɂȧ|ýqȠ~Ȼu£ö ¨
“ü£ȱ©ýɆ{vɐŖ òšxšȧ|vbýɆ{tzûȶ¥uuõ™ɐɖ¤qv«£ȵɒ©b±£ȱ{ b±qɂȧ|
Ȭqsbȷ ȧ|vbýɆ{¤l}ýqȠ~wò}“üu›fȿuȾxlžgȩŏȶz£‚qw}lžgq£ɨ¶
Ȯsž£ɨ £ɪ£x}¤l}ýv£sxš|b¨pqýx¨¤luzŸ{ȮzŸ{ȩŏ £ȩ}v¨pf
gz÷fzŸ{böăfg¨£ȵz£ȩ}v¨pf‘£s¢q dœ£l z÷š£ýzgȻul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{¤l}ȿu
ó™|Ⱦxu™fȮɆŌx|¶ Ƀz™uɉg£tÿ £ɨ|Ÿg£s ýv™u£v ¤cĀvȺōq¤l}ýqȠ~Ȼub¨pq
£ƒ f£u©ɉg£} bzb£ȬsȮvɐŖ£ɪ£x}ȵzŸ{b±Ȼu £ȱ{¤wĂbȶzl¨£p |ȧ|
¤l}£g©¤q£v bg¨‚|‚žq £‚ {£v ™uȮȧ|¤bqýzȠ~ɉg£tÿ Ȼu£ɪ£x}ȵ¤l}|b
£e kȷȿuȾxz™uýq›zýqȠ~ȵzŸ{£ȱ{£t¢v£ɨu›fvsv÷čìqò™ȵzŸ{£ɪböăf
uõ™ɐɖzž}ȱʼnu£Ⱥ©¶ l¨£p |ȧ||£v¢v£u©ɉgvuò £ȱ{ȩœusšvčçv u™fz™uɉg
ȯul}l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ȮɆŌx|Ȼu£s lɁvȵ£dɉg£ɪ¤q|b£e kb¨‚¤l}
ɉg£b qȿu£Ⱥ©¶ ýx¨¤lu|£v¢v£u© £ýɗxšȩœuó™|ȾxɉgȧŔ{Ȯýx¨¤lu¤l}z™u
£s¢fȸq¶ £dýqȠ~¤qŸ|ȷ £‚q„ÿšȻuȮȾdšȸ¨fxš|Ȼuýxz£ýx¢f£tÿ ȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu
£‚ {z™u£ȩ|x{bȶzvsv÷čìqò™¥uuõ™ɐɖ¤l}vɐņbýȻvȷ ýx¨¤lu£ɪböăf
- 52. 47
q¨vu£Ⱥ©dœȮ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¶ ȿuuõ™ɐɖýx¨¤luȮ£ýg u¤l}z™uȻu¤gf„ÿš£}
xš¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bŽ¤cĀcöfyö¨£ƒ { £‚ {¤l}ȩœu¤gfvsv÷čìqò™ȵzŸ{ýȿvȧ|
b¨pqýx¨¤luȵzŸ{Ȯȧ|v¤uóz£s¶ Ⱦdš£ɪböăf£|¡fbòš£u©gɍȮȿu£‚qw}
£l z÷švuòi¨ɇu£} xš£u©£ɨ£s¢q¶ £‚qw}¤qzŸ{dœ £ȱ{Ɇ|¤q£dȬqsbȧ|
gfĂă}vȫŖk¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bȷz™uýdvýȩu £l z÷š£ýzgȻuuž~Ⱦxgɍɂ u™f
ɆŌx|¶ £l z÷š£ýzgȻuuž~£ȩ}v¨pf£u© £s v£dȫb£ɨ|bȧ|b¨pqýx¨¤lu u™f
¤cĀvȺōq£ɪ£} ¤wusš¶
bȶŋȮ£ýg u£s¢qȩ¨ýssĀuª¤l}ȷ £ȩ}v¨pfgz÷f|vȾdšȸ¨fxš|
böăfl¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ýx¨¤lu£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ-ÃËÂÊ dœ£l z÷š£ýzg“üȻuuž~l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{
gɍɂu™fɆŌx|¶ ȶz|{ªyòăȶf¤l}Ȼuȱbižuqɂȧ| u™fȶzg£zþ {
|vdžȾdšȼō} Ƀgɍȵȷ £ɪ„¨ƒăfzuȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ vɐŖȸ¨fzž}¥uýx¨¤lul±
¤~f|Ƀf£¢zȮzŸ{‡pŊĐg™uȻɁ¨f ȻuȧŔ{Ȯvxÿ£‚q¥uȾxz™ugɍɂ bfÿ}
u™f„|ĜȾx ¤l}vȵɑ}“ü£b qȿu£|¡fɁŘ~ lžg¤l}Ȼu£|¢vɁv£ɪböăf‘bɆ|zŸ{
ȱbižuqɂȧ|òšxšȾx¥u ȧ|£b u£ƒ f¥uȾxȶuq›f £ɪböăfs¨Ⱥbs¨uf|Ƀf
£¢zu™fȻɁ¨f¶ qɂȧ|ɉg£tÿ £gbòšuö™ȱʼnu£ȱ{ývgɍvȷ £ȩ}v¨pf
¨ȨuŽb±ɉgȬqsbȷ Ȯ£ȩ}v¨pft¨£tf¥ul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{böăf„¨ƒăfȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ-
ÃËÂÊ (¤l}Ⱥ¨zbuž~l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{sž£ɨ¥uvɐŖýx¨¤lu¤l}£ɪ£}ȸ¨f„
|Ƀfýv£sȸ¨fxš|) dœ£l z÷švčçvȾxȶuq›f£u©u™f£l z÷š£ýzgȻuuž~ó™|Ⱦx
ýx¨¤lu £ȱ{j|£} zž}ȱʼnu¥uȾxgɍɂu™fɆŌx|¶
£ɪböăfv£|bȷ¥uuõ™ɐɖýx¨¤luȻɁ¨f-£¢z g©¥ræsšÄÅ ¤czšȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÂÉ
Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|Ȼuývȧȷ Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|ȿuhuôª ȹȺ“üȻuuž~l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{gf£ýȧ{
¥uɁ}vɐŖȸ¨f„ ȸbsf£ɨu›fýx¨¤lu|Ÿz‡pŊĐg™uu™f£¢z ¶ bãšȾxzŸ{£s¢q
¥uhuôªlžgȩŏ£u© ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖk£ɪböăf£gqȺ¤l}gfȻuýx¨¤lutzûȮq™u™fȮb¤òf
lžg¤l}ȿuyòăȶf£ýg u£} }v£ɪböăf‘bɆ| u™f¤l}ýqȠ~ȻuvȫŖk£ȱ{Ⱦdš
ȸ¨fxš|¶ lžg¤l}qɂȧ|Ȼu£|¢vɁvȨf£} £v sbȮȧ|p¯£u©£ȱ{‘b‘fz™u¤zu
- 53. 48
Ȯ£‚qw}ýȿvývȧuȷ ýx¨¤luýqȠ~¤q£l |ȶz¤cĀtzûȮq™u™fȮb¤òfbòš b±v«¤uò
ȧ|p¯£u©x™qȮȩ¨ýssĀuªȷ Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|gfȻuuž~l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{gɍɂ
u™fɆŌx|ȶz|{ª¤cĀtzûȮq™u™fȮb¤òf¶
sĀuªlžgȩŏ£u©ýqȠ~Ȼuȩ¨ýsɀŘfȨŔ¨fȧŔ £ȱ{‡|Ĝɀvr|vȾdšȸ¨fxš|
g¨£Ƚ©ýx¨¤lu£ɪböăfuõ™ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÄÇu™fÃËÅɶ £ȱ{z™uɁvvčçĄ}ɀŘfȮb
ɂbuž~vɐŖýx¨¤luxšl¨£p |ȧ|¥uȧ|£ £|ĝuõ™ɐɖȺȺxšzu£ƒ f~Ĝk ¤l}uõ™
ɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÄÇu™fÃËÅÉ Ȼu„u~qòȶz£Ⱥ© Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|Ȼu¤òf“ü£e kuž~Ɇ|ª
¨Ȩul±‰qòăfä‰qòz ¤l}£dȻuwɏ|Ⱦņv£ɨu›fȾxɆŌx|£ɪböăfvɐŖýx¨¤lu£u©¶
‡|Ĝɀvr|vȾdšȸ¨fxš|£ɪböăfȭŏ¨ÃËÄÇu™fÃËÅÉ ɉgýqȠ~ȻuȬqsbȷȮ
yòăȶf£ȱ{ýq›zýqȠ~¤l}ȷȾdšȸ¨fxš|ȿu£gqȺlžgȩŏ dœgfȻuuž~l¨£ȵ©ýɆ{
ɆŌx|£ɪböăf„¨ƒăfȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ-ÃËÂÊ wf¤l|¶
ȧ|gfĂă}vȫŖk¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b£ɪböăfȿýȶÃ¥u„uɐɖȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ dœýȩu
¤qȮz£tɎȻ{Ȯb¤òfu™fȫ{ýŸ}v«£ȵɒ© böăfȧ|£|¢vɁvuž~¤cĀýx¨¤luzŸ{
ývbv£ȱ{qɎuz²q £ȸ©Ȯȶz}bãcpŊsž£ɨbòš¶ v«¤uò x¨ȿu£‚qw}ȵzŸ{
¤l}ýqȠ~{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵȷ Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš|Ȼu“üɆ|ª¨Ȩux™£ȵzŸ{£ɨu›f
¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›b¤vv£u©£s £v £ýv¢v£t¢v£ɨu›fɆ|ª¨Ȩu¤l}ȿuɉs™Ⱦx £Ƚ}
dœw}ýv£ɀiu¯¥ul¨£ȵ©ýɆ{ɆŌx|böăfȧ|£ȩ|xȶz¤cĀ£ɪ£} ¤wusš lžg¤l}
ýqȠ~Ȼub¨pqu™fýqȠ~ȻuýxzssŸ}{b£ȱ{Ⱦdšȸ¨fxš||Ÿg£‚ {¶ £‚qlžg£u©
qɂȧ|{}ȷ ȶzsĀuª¥uȧ|vbýɆ{uõ™ɐɖýqȠ~£ýzg{b¤cĀvȺōq
ýx¨¤lulžg¤l}Ȼudž£ɪ£} ¤wusšböăfq¨vui£ȿŔ©¶
*
* *
£ȱ{¤wĂb£} zž}£‚qȸ¨fɈ{¤l}qɂȧ|{bzb£tÿ Ȯzž}ȱʼnuböăfȧ|
£ýzg£gbòš|vcþąu qɂȧ|z™uȬ¨Ȼgx™Ȭ|ȵȷ £q £ɪýx©~Ĝɇ|¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ
- 54. 49
£} ¤wusš x™qȮýqȠ~£ɨu›f¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻbl£ɪböăfq¨vuȸ¨f£u©Žx™qȮýqȠ~
£ɨu›fȭŏ¨ÃËÂÆ-ÃËÂÊ Žýv™u£v z™ulž£gö©£s £q ¤cĀ¤vf¤gbs›bx™qýȻbl£Ⱥ©
£l ||£v¢vȵ¶
*
* *
Ȯgf£ýȧ{ £ȱ{£ɀf£} £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{¤l}Ȼuȱbižuqɂȧ|
£ɪ£x}včçvušq™~Ĝtšȸk£‚qw}ȼō}ȿq ¤l}ȻugfĂă}vȫŖk£ɪböăf£gbòš
£wò z¥uɆ}lšȧ£u© qɂȧ||b£e kȷ £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÃu™fsšÄ|v
bzùăȮ ¤l}¨“üývȧuž~ȲuªȶzwþĄ~gɍv¥u¤wusš‰vzù²uõÃu™f¤cĀýx¨¤lu£ɪ
böăfq¨vui£ȿŔ©ɉgssŸ}{bzbx™Ȭ|ȵȻu¤qböăf}bãcpŊȷ £gbòš£ö ¨“ü
~Ĝu™gè²{ȸ¨f£u© ȿuvɐņbxšzž}£‚q £‚ {z™u¤zuȮȧ|ȸzȸ|¤l}ýqȠ~{bzb
£ȱ©ýɆ{£ɪböăfvčìqò™„u~qò¥uɆ}lšȧ£u©£s¶ zɎŘf£s¢q qɂȧ||b£e kȷ
£ýȧ{xšȻu£} b£ƒ fuž~ȧ|ȸzȸ||vcþąuȽbx²uõu›f„t™v£q{ü£} ýx©~Ĝɇ| ¥r
Ȼu£} b£ƒ f£ɪböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{|vcþąuýq›z¤q„¨p©„¨ȵf u™fȧ|
vl™£t¤l}i¨ȸ£ɨu›fȧ|qɃŘ|vȾdšȿŁf£s¢q £ȱ{sb“üqɂȧ|ȶb¤qf
Ƚbü£xgu¯zýv „¨xš£‚qw}ȸ¨fɈ{¤l}qɂȧ|{bȮzž}ȱʼnuýȿvȧ|
~Ĝu™gè²{|vcþąu¶
£ɪg¨£Ƚ©zc ¥uvpĎ›fȸzȸ|¤l}Ȼuȱbižuzbqɂȧ|£ȱ{ýv£s
bzùăȮ u™f¥r£|¢f¹cþąuȸbsfu›f„t™v£q{ü£} ýx©~Ĝɇ|¤l}Ⱥ¨“üȿui£ȿŔ©|Ƀf
|lîȸ¨fxš|£u© qɂȧ|ȩ¨ýsbzùăȮ £ȱ{„u£ɂz£ɨȶz£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÅ
|vcþąu¶ qɂȧ|b±ȩ¨ýsbzùăȮwf¤l| ȸbsfu›f£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÆòšxšȧ|
lbbfbȿŔ¨f£ɀȹ¶
g¨£Ƚ©£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÇ|vbzùăȮ„¨xšȧ|£tÿ vl™ȸu qɂȧ|
{}£e kȷ ¨£p ¤l}Ȼu£} b£ƒ f£ɪböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{£u© x¨¤zuȮ
ȧ|xýfšbv¤uóz£} vpĎ›fȸzȸ|£l z|vbzùăȮ£s (¤l}£ɪböăfb|pš£u© ¨£p £u©
- 55. 50
z™udŸ|ýqȠ~ȻussŸ}{b£s£ɪ£x}¤l}¨£p £u©ýqȠ~Ȼu£ö Ȯ£} bl¨vžf£Ⱥ©)¶
v«¤uò lžg£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÆ¤l| £gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÇȮvȽbx²uõ£ɨu›f
vpĎ›fȸzȸ|„t™v£q{ü¤l}Ȯ£‚qȺ¨£ɨl}ȧ|£tÿ vl™ȸu¶ zɎŘf£s¢q z™uȿu
yòăȶfȮb¤òfýqȠ~Ȼuȱbižuqɂȧ| ¤l}vȫŖkȮ~Ĝiéȿuȷ~qóăȸ¨fɈ{¤l}
Ȼu£} b£ƒ fböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{£u© x™qȮýqȠ~Ȼu{b£gkxšýȻɆsu™f
q¨vuýȻɆs£u©£ȱ{¥r Ȭvȶ¨fxšȧ|ȧuȧv|v¥r£} ýȻɆs£u©£ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÇÆ
£Ⱥ©£s¶ Ȯȧ|x™q£‚ {¤l}ȷ ¥rz™uȻuvl™£tȨŔ¨fȧŔ£sg¨£Ƚ©ȧ|£Ȭsývȧu
£u© ¤l}cþąuz™uȸ¨fȻui¨ȸȷ ¨£p £u©z™uɉgssŸ}{bȻu£Ⱥ©wf¶ £ȸ©vš
ȮɀŘfȵb±£ȱ{ b±böăfȧ}ª£sª¤vv£u© vɐŖ¥uȧ|£tÿ vl™ȸu dœȮvɐŖzŸ{
¤l}qɂȧ|ýȩu¤qɉg£ȱ©ýɆ{Ȯ£ȩ}ȧ|p¯£ȱ{ȩ¨ýsbzùăȮ £ȱ{z™u
vɐņb„¨xš~qóăȵzŸ{x™qýȻbl£Ⱥ©£s¶
¤wĂb£} ¨ɉf£‚qȸ¨f£u©
qɂȧ|
£ȱ{ȿu¨£ƒfËs}u›fÅ
£ýzgȷ ýȻɆsýx©~Ĝɇ|ó™qböăfs›blš £ýȧz„t™v£q{ü|výv£sbzùăȮ¶
£ýzgvȺōvzb£s¢qȷ
£ȱ{ȿu¨£ƒfËs}u›fÅ
ýv£s¥rȿuȧqxÿb™gçlbbfbȿŔ¨fs²x Žv«ž}š Ž„öb¤r|bɏ Žȭœ¨l¥s£s¢q
¤l}¥rȻuȱbböăfýȻɆsŽböăfq¨vu¤b÷|ýȻɆs¤l}ó™qböăfs›blšbzùăȮ¶
£ȱ{¨£ƒfÉs}u›fÇ
£ýzgȷ ýv£s¥rȿuȧqxÿb™gçývd}zb“üýv£sbzùăȮ~Ĝk už~~qóăȸ¨fɈ{
ȶzýv£ys¤l}Ȼuvɐņb£ɪböăf£gbòš£ö ¨“ü~Ĝu™gè²{sšÇ|vbzùăȮ ¤l}ýqȠ~
Ȼu{b£gkxšýȻɆsŽq¨vuýȻɆs£ȱ{ɉȮŇt|Ƚbx²uõ|v¥r Ȭvȶ¨fxš
ȧ}v|Ĝ£gès¥uȧ|ȧuȧvýȻɆs£u©£ȱ{ýv£s¥r £ɪȭŏ¨ÃËÇƶ
£tÿ ȮȾɆ„f£dþu™fȾɆȻɁ¨f¶ „qóvsȾɆ„f£dþ{bȮwþĄ~ȧ|¶ £tÿ £ɪ
- 56. 51
~Ĝȿuuò™ȾxýbfɈ£„ ¥ræsšÃÇ ¤cz™rȺ ȭŏ¨ÃËÈÄ ȮÅgɍv zŸ{gɍv|bɏsb
£ɪvpñɆ|ȱʼnu|vqɂȧ| u™fgɍvl¥s£s¢qvčéĄu£ɨ|ȱʼny™Ȼ}bzùăȮu™f
|ȱʼny™Ȼ}¥r£|¢f¹cþąu¶
ývȹu
(‚qó£}Ȩ) B. WINIARSKI
ýbɈvčéš
(‚qó£}Ȩ) GARNIER-COIGNET
- 57. 52
Ɇ}lšȧ£u©
ýqȠ~Ȼu£|¢vg¨vb¤ývȮȾɆ¤cû|ȶzd¨u™qwíąg£wí zl±cùfcù|v
‘b‰qòzvpŊ™qȾȬ|ü c ɉu ‰vȺ{b|lîzĚuòš
|lîzĚuòšssŸ}vuôăbsšòšȧ|dpª|lîzĚuòš
‘b‰qòz £ɂbi¨ȸ~ „£ɂb lžgȿuɁ{ȺzȨf£ýȧz
Ȼugž}|ŸzɀŘfbzûböăfȧ|ȫ|vb¤ýv£u© ÷
vb¤ýv£ȱ{ ¸
Ã- £ɂb z«f zuöšg|Ĝɀ £ɜýbzqɂȧ|b¨xž}
Ä- £ɂb {ž| ‰qòɁ £ɜýbzqɂȧ|b¨xž}
x™u™qü¤býzȡ}£ȱ{ ¸
Ã- ‘b‰qòz £‚f~fĀ v¬uȭq sšýv›bɏɁi|ȱʼny™Ȼ} u™fȮ„u
ývȹuýbzýv›bɏ„öbgɍv
ʒ- ‘b‰qòz ɃŘ d›z‚f £s|lîzĚuòšssŸ}vuôăbb™gçȧ|ýx¨¤lu
ʓ- vpŊ™q Ȯ ɃŘu£lq sšýv›bɏ‘b‰qòz c ɉu
ʔ- ‘b‰qòz q›b£|ġq ¨£|g |lî£}Ȩt™ȧ|sšòšȧ|dpª|lîzĚuòš
ʕ- vpŊ™q Ȭv ȷ|Ĝsõ sšýv›bɏ u™fȮȺ{bcsôȧ}²{
£ɂbi¨ȸ~ ¤z«u ¨„u
ʖ- vpŊ™q b›z |²qö~™™lî sšýv›bɏ u™fȮȺ{bcsôȧ}²{
‘b‰qòz c ɉu
ʗ- vpŊ™q ¬Ċ ȿŘv sšýv›bɏ‘b‰qòz c ɉu