SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 12
A Comparative Study of Facilitator Competencies in a Sample of U.S. and S. Korean Facilitators Judith A. Kolb, Penn State Hong Min Kim, Penn State JiHoon Song, Oklahoma State AHRD Conference 2/27/10 Knoxville
+ Rationale for Study ,[object Object]
Address limitation and suggestion for future research from that study—”examine application of this model to other cultures”  (p. 131)
Kolb, J. A., Jin, S., & Song, J. H. (2008). A model of small group facilitator competencies. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 21(2), 119-133. ,[object Object]
+ Research Question What similarities and differences exist between scores and rankings collected from a sample of facilitators working in South Korea and scores and rankings reported by Kolb et al. (2008)?
+ Sample & Analysis ,[object Object],     -40 U.S. Facilitators (2008)      -57 Korean Facilitators (2009) ,[object Object],     -Comparison of competency mean scores and        rankings      -Interdependent t-tests      -Spearman’s rank correlation
+ Results: Overview ,[object Object],     -No significant differences in 15 competencies      -Significant differences in 8 competencies ,[object Object],     -ρ (rho)=.61 (p<.01)     -Significant correlation in rank between       the two data sets
+ Results (continued) Comparison in mean score
+ Results (continued) Comparison in rank
+ Results (continued) Top-ranked 3 competencies  U.S. Korea Listens actively Creates a climate that supports interaction and discussion Encourages group involvement in, and ownership of, issues and tasks Same Stimulates small group insights and creativity Same
+ Results (continued) Score comparison of top-ranked 3 competencies  5 U.S. Korea Listens actively (1st) 4 Encourages  Involvement and ownership (3rd) ~ ~ Stimulates small group insights and creativity (KO 2nd) 3 Creates a climate that supports interaction and discussion (US 2nd)
+ Implications for Research  ,[object Object]

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Stilul de-invatare
Stilul de-invatareStilul de-invatare
Stilul de-invatareElena Filip
 
Teoria şi metodologia evaluării
Teoria şi metodologia evaluăriiTeoria şi metodologia evaluării
Teoria şi metodologia evaluăriiAlexandra Nicolae
 
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficienta
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare EficientaMetode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficienta
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficientaanamaria89
 
Ahead to the past kolb d
Ahead to the past kolb dAhead to the past kolb d
Ahead to the past kolb dDavina Rowe
 
Curs psihologia educatiei
Curs psihologia educatieiCurs psihologia educatiei
Curs psihologia educatieiPaula Chirilă
 
Constantin cucos Pedagogie
Constantin cucos  PedagogieConstantin cucos  Pedagogie
Constantin cucos PedagogieRaluca Chirvase
 
Psihologia Educatiei 2 3
Psihologia Educatiei   2 3Psihologia Educatiei   2 3
Psihologia Educatiei 2 31Leu
 
Tehnici de invatare accelerata
Tehnici de invatare accelerata Tehnici de invatare accelerata
Tehnici de invatare accelerata r_s_
 
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conte
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conteSarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conte
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conteRoxana Andreea
 

Viewers also liked (9)

Stilul de-invatare
Stilul de-invatareStilul de-invatare
Stilul de-invatare
 
Teoria şi metodologia evaluării
Teoria şi metodologia evaluăriiTeoria şi metodologia evaluării
Teoria şi metodologia evaluării
 
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficienta
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare EficientaMetode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficienta
Metode Si Tehnici De Munca Intelectuala Si Invatare Eficienta
 
Ahead to the past kolb d
Ahead to the past kolb dAhead to the past kolb d
Ahead to the past kolb d
 
Curs psihologia educatiei
Curs psihologia educatieiCurs psihologia educatiei
Curs psihologia educatiei
 
Constantin cucos Pedagogie
Constantin cucos  PedagogieConstantin cucos  Pedagogie
Constantin cucos Pedagogie
 
Psihologia Educatiei 2 3
Psihologia Educatiei   2 3Psihologia Educatiei   2 3
Psihologia Educatiei 2 3
 
Tehnici de invatare accelerata
Tehnici de invatare accelerata Tehnici de invatare accelerata
Tehnici de invatare accelerata
 
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conte
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conteSarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conte
Sarah maclean o iubita potrivita pentru un conte
 

Similar to A H R D 2010 Kolb Kim Song 2

Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native Americans
Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native AmericansDavies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native Americans
Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native AmericansPointLeader, Inc
 
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...William Kritsonis
 
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair SkinnerWilliam Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinnerguestfa49ec
 
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair SkinnerDr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair SkinnerWilliam Kritsonis
 
Does Size Really Matter
Does Size Really MatterDoes Size Really Matter
Does Size Really Matterpolan1km
 
Does Size Really Matter
Does  Size  Really  MatterDoes  Size  Really  Matter
Does Size Really Matterpolan1km
 
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...Cross Cultural & Strategic Management
 
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...Travis Burns
 
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY .docx
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY         .docxRunning head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY         .docx
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY .docxsusanschei
 
The relationship between Language testing & SLA
The relationship between Language testing & SLAThe relationship between Language testing & SLA
The relationship between Language testing & SLAKobra( Minoo) Tajahmadi
 
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Matthew Prost
 
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...Rick Vogel
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...William Kritsonis
 
NEPA attractiveness poster
NEPA attractiveness posterNEPA attractiveness poster
NEPA attractiveness posterBrent Buckley
 
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentation
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentationRapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentation
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentationJames Beebe
 
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1Ellen Dollarhide
 
Automated Trait Scores For GRE Writing Tasks
Automated Trait Scores For GRE   Writing TasksAutomated Trait Scores For GRE   Writing Tasks
Automated Trait Scores For GRE Writing TasksKate Campbell
 

Similar to A H R D 2010 Kolb Kim Song 2 (20)

Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J SheldonAea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
 
Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J SheldonAea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
Aea Conference Presentation November 2007 J Sheldon
 
Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native Americans
Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native AmericansDavies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native Americans
Davies, S., (2010). Standardized Test Score Differences for Native Americans
 
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...
Dr. Donald Ray Brown, Jr., PhD Dissertation Defense, Dr. William Allan Kritso...
 
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair SkinnerWilliam Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD - Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
 
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair SkinnerDr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
Dr. William Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner
 
Does Size Really Matter
Does Size Really MatterDoes Size Really Matter
Does Size Really Matter
 
Does Size Really Matter
Does  Size  Really  MatterDoes  Size  Really  Matter
Does Size Really Matter
 
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...
Hong et al. (2016): The Effect of Leadership Styles, Rank, and Seniority on A...
 
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...
2012 VERA Conference Presentation on Organizational Justice and Organizationa...
 
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY .docx
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY         .docxRunning head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY         .docx
Running head DOCTORAL RESEARCH ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY .docx
 
The relationship between Language testing & SLA
The relationship between Language testing & SLAThe relationship between Language testing & SLA
The relationship between Language testing & SLA
 
Final Paper
Final PaperFinal Paper
Final Paper
 
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
 
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...
A Comparison Of Study Session Formats On Attendance And Quiz Performance In A...
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Desiree Adair Skinner, Di...
 
NEPA attractiveness poster
NEPA attractiveness posterNEPA attractiveness poster
NEPA attractiveness poster
 
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentation
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentationRapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentation
Rapid Qaulitative Inquiry, extended presentation
 
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1
Oklahoma-A-F-Hiding-Poor-Achievement-1
 
Automated Trait Scores For GRE Writing Tasks
Automated Trait Scores For GRE   Writing TasksAutomated Trait Scores For GRE   Writing Tasks
Automated Trait Scores For GRE Writing Tasks
 

A H R D 2010 Kolb Kim Song 2

  • 1. A Comparative Study of Facilitator Competencies in a Sample of U.S. and S. Korean Facilitators Judith A. Kolb, Penn State Hong Min Kim, Penn State JiHoon Song, Oklahoma State AHRD Conference 2/27/10 Knoxville
  • 2.
  • 3. Address limitation and suggestion for future research from that study—”examine application of this model to other cultures” (p. 131)
  • 4.
  • 5. + Research Question What similarities and differences exist between scores and rankings collected from a sample of facilitators working in South Korea and scores and rankings reported by Kolb et al. (2008)?
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. + Results (continued) Comparison in mean score
  • 9. + Results (continued) Comparison in rank
  • 10. + Results (continued) Top-ranked 3 competencies U.S. Korea Listens actively Creates a climate that supports interaction and discussion Encourages group involvement in, and ownership of, issues and tasks Same Stimulates small group insights and creativity Same
  • 11. + Results (continued) Score comparison of top-ranked 3 competencies 5 U.S. Korea Listens actively (1st) 4 Encourages Involvement and ownership (3rd) ~ ~ Stimulates small group insights and creativity (KO 2nd) 3 Creates a climate that supports interaction and discussion (US 2nd)
  • 12.
  • 13. Kolb et al.’s (2008) belief that listening would be highly ranked in another culture was supported
  • 14. Need to analyze qualitative data from this study that will give depth to findings reported here
  • 15.