SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 7
The Living Standards Measurement Study:
      Potential Uses in Impact Evaluation
                                      Gero Carletto
                                     Lead Economist
               Development Economics Research Group
                                     The World Bank
What is an LSMS?

• 30 plus-year-old global initiative in Development Reserach
  Group at the World Bank
• Main goals:
  - Gain a better understanding of the impact of policies and
    programs on poverty reduction
  - Build in-country capacity in the design and implementation of
    household surveys
  - Support methodological improvements in the measurement of key
    indicators
  - Champion the dissemination and use of data and analytical
    findings
What is an LSMS? (cont’d)

• Main features:
   - Nationally representative
   - Multi-topic (HD, labor, assets, nutrition, food security, …)
   - Consumption-based money metric to measure poverty
   - Open access
   - LSMS-Integrated Surveys on Agriculture
      • Working in 7 countries in SSA
      • Panels
      • Focus on agriculture
      • Disaggregated (gender, plot)
      • Geo-referenced (hh, plots) for improved link to spatial data
      • Use of technology (GPS for land area, CAPI)
What are the issues?


• Beneficiary identification
• Sample size
• Timing
• Randomization
  - Identification strategy
Potential uses

• Oversample in project areas
• Control group based on matching
• Small area estimation (welfare measure)
• Methodology
   - Questionnaires
   - Data collection protocols
   - Validation e.g. poverty predictors, asset index, …
     • On-going work in DECPI
Some recent examples …


• Malawi Fertilizer Input Subsidy Program
 using the Integrated Household Survey


• MCC Water Project in two districts using
 Tanzania National Panel Survey
Some final thoughts …

• LSMS is one tool in the evaluation toolbox
• Offers many opportunities to inform IFAD’s
 theory of change agenda
• In terms of evaluation, synergies if ...
   - Plan ahead for best results and team up with
     national team at time of project’s
     inception/design
   - Clearly define “measurable” objectives
   - Identify target areas and intended beneficiaries
   - Think multiple identification strategies
   - Take advantage of expanding collection of
     panels

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Gero Carletto: Potential use of the Living Standards Measurement Study (LSMS) for impact evaluation

Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact Francois Stepman
 
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...IFPRI-PIM
 
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...Barb Knittel
 
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015Cecilia Ochoa
 
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13CORE Group
 
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...JSI
 
Health planning and management
Health planning and managementHealth planning and management
Health planning and managementmgmcricommunitymed
 
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques  Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques  Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...Sarath Thomas
 
Scaling up nutrition: what and how
Scaling up nutrition: what and howScaling up nutrition: what and how
Scaling up nutrition: what and howTransform Nutrition
 
Evaluations to improve organisational effectiveness
Evaluations to improve organisational effectivenessEvaluations to improve organisational effectiveness
Evaluations to improve organisational effectivenessInnocent Karugota Muhumuza
 
Project Management- Unit II
Project Management- Unit IIProject Management- Unit II
Project Management- Unit IILamay Sabir
 
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...activehealthykidsglobalalliance
 
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14NEQOS
 
Purnima Menon - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officials
Purnima Menon  - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officialsPurnima Menon  - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officials
Purnima Menon - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officialsPOSHAN
 
Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa
 Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa
Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of AfricaILRI
 
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every community
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every communityTransitioning from reach every district to reach every community
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every communityJSI
 

Similar a Gero Carletto: Potential use of the Living Standards Measurement Study (LSMS) for impact evaluation (20)

Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
Setting the scene – Trends in programming Research and Innovation for Impact
 
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
Seminar on Advisory and Knowledge Services: Evidence for What Works (Sept 17,...
 
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
 
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015
Cies 2015 global literacy & going to scale sc presentation 11march2015
 
Hm 418 harris ch09 ppt
Hm 418 harris ch09 pptHm 418 harris ch09 ppt
Hm 418 harris ch09 ppt
 
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13
ICCM_Sara Riese_10.16.13
 
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
Using case-based methods to assess scalability and sustainability: Lessons fr...
 
Health planning and management
Health planning and managementHealth planning and management
Health planning and management
 
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques  Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques  Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
Participative Rural Appraisal,Tools,Techniques Requirements, Scope,Risks, by...
 
Docc casp
Docc  caspDocc  casp
Docc casp
 
Framework user guide presentation cpw dec132015
Framework user guide presentation cpw dec132015Framework user guide presentation cpw dec132015
Framework user guide presentation cpw dec132015
 
Scaling up nutrition: what and how
Scaling up nutrition: what and howScaling up nutrition: what and how
Scaling up nutrition: what and how
 
Evaluations to improve organisational effectiveness
Evaluations to improve organisational effectivenessEvaluations to improve organisational effectiveness
Evaluations to improve organisational effectiveness
 
Project Management- Unit II
Project Management- Unit IIProject Management- Unit II
Project Management- Unit II
 
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...
A Step-By-Step Guide to Developing a National Report Card on the Physical Act...
 
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14
Collaborating for Better Care Stakeholder workshop presentation 14 03 14
 
Purnima Menon - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officials
Purnima Menon  - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officialsPurnima Menon  - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officials
Purnima Menon - Strategic capacity building in nutrition for district officials
 
Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...
Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...
Evidence On Trial: weighing the value of evidence in academic enquiry, policy...
 
Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa
 Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa
Technical consortium for building resilience in the Horn of Africa
 
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every community
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every communityTransitioning from reach every district to reach every community
Transitioning from reach every district to reach every community
 

Más de IFAD International Fund for Agricultural Development

Más de IFAD International Fund for Agricultural Development (20)

Happy facts
Happy factsHappy facts
Happy facts
 
3 bsp awards-gfrd2015
3 bsp    awards-gfrd20153 bsp    awards-gfrd2015
3 bsp awards-gfrd2015
 
Gfrd awards world remit
Gfrd awards world remitGfrd awards world remit
Gfrd awards world remit
 
Marco nicoli greenback
Marco nicoli   greenbackMarco nicoli   greenback
Marco nicoli greenback
 
Malaysia greenback project june 2015 alison ang
Malaysia greenback project june 2015 alison angMalaysia greenback project june 2015 alison ang
Malaysia greenback project june 2015 alison ang
 
Pedro de vasconcelos
Pedro de vasconcelosPedro de vasconcelos
Pedro de vasconcelos
 
Tomas miller fomin
Tomas miller fominTomas miller fomin
Tomas miller fomin
 
David khoudour
David khoudourDavid khoudour
David khoudour
 
Bela hovy
Bela hovy Bela hovy
Bela hovy
 
Dilip ratha
Dilip rathaDilip ratha
Dilip ratha
 
Josephine cervero
Josephine cerveroJosephine cervero
Josephine cervero
 
Nicolaas de zwager 10.1 b
Nicolaas de zwager 10.1 bNicolaas de zwager 10.1 b
Nicolaas de zwager 10.1 b
 
Mai anonuevo
Mai anonuevoMai anonuevo
Mai anonuevo
 
Lee sorensen shuraako
Lee sorensen shuraakoLee sorensen shuraako
Lee sorensen shuraako
 
Sierra leone stats chuwku
Sierra leone stats chuwkuSierra leone stats chuwku
Sierra leone stats chuwku
 
1 kinglsey
1 kinglsey1 kinglsey
1 kinglsey
 
Sabasaba mosinghi
Sabasaba mosinghiSabasaba mosinghi
Sabasaba mosinghi
 
De zwager iasci 7.1 b
De zwager iasci 7.1 bDe zwager iasci 7.1 b
De zwager iasci 7.1 b
 
Gfrd pinci v2
Gfrd pinci v2Gfrd pinci v2
Gfrd pinci v2
 
Simone di castro gsma
Simone di castro gsmaSimone di castro gsma
Simone di castro gsma
 

Gero Carletto: Potential use of the Living Standards Measurement Study (LSMS) for impact evaluation

  • 1. The Living Standards Measurement Study: Potential Uses in Impact Evaluation Gero Carletto Lead Economist Development Economics Research Group The World Bank
  • 2. What is an LSMS? • 30 plus-year-old global initiative in Development Reserach Group at the World Bank • Main goals: - Gain a better understanding of the impact of policies and programs on poverty reduction - Build in-country capacity in the design and implementation of household surveys - Support methodological improvements in the measurement of key indicators - Champion the dissemination and use of data and analytical findings
  • 3. What is an LSMS? (cont’d) • Main features: - Nationally representative - Multi-topic (HD, labor, assets, nutrition, food security, …) - Consumption-based money metric to measure poverty - Open access - LSMS-Integrated Surveys on Agriculture • Working in 7 countries in SSA • Panels • Focus on agriculture • Disaggregated (gender, plot) • Geo-referenced (hh, plots) for improved link to spatial data • Use of technology (GPS for land area, CAPI)
  • 4. What are the issues? • Beneficiary identification • Sample size • Timing • Randomization - Identification strategy
  • 5. Potential uses • Oversample in project areas • Control group based on matching • Small area estimation (welfare measure) • Methodology - Questionnaires - Data collection protocols - Validation e.g. poverty predictors, asset index, … • On-going work in DECPI
  • 6. Some recent examples … • Malawi Fertilizer Input Subsidy Program using the Integrated Household Survey • MCC Water Project in two districts using Tanzania National Panel Survey
  • 7. Some final thoughts … • LSMS is one tool in the evaluation toolbox • Offers many opportunities to inform IFAD’s theory of change agenda • In terms of evaluation, synergies if ... - Plan ahead for best results and team up with national team at time of project’s inception/design - Clearly define “measurable” objectives - Identify target areas and intended beneficiaries - Think multiple identification strategies - Take advantage of expanding collection of panels