SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 3
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers
Story highlightsGillian Hadfield: Getting legal help is enormously expensive in the U.S.Hadfield:
Lawyers, judges must change the way they regulate practice of lawShe says we need less expensive
nonlawyers who can provide legal assistanceHadfield: Lower-cost alternative to full-fledged
attorneys is the solution In our country, lawyers and judges regulate their own markets. The upshot
is that getting legal help is enormously expensive and out of reach for the vast majority of
Americans. Anyone faced with a contract dispute, family crisis, foreclosure or eviction must pay a
lawyer with a JD degree to provide service one-on-one in the same way lawyers have done business
for hundreds of years.
Increasingly, the only "persons" with access to legal help are "artificial persons" -- corporations,
organizations and governments. No wonder that in a 2010 New York study, it was shown 95% of
people in housing court are unrepresented. The same is true in consumer credit and child support
cases; 44% of people in foreclosures are representing themselves--against a well-represented bank,
no small number of whom engaged in robo-signing and sued people based on faulty information.
These numbers are just the tip of the iceberg. For every person who is unrepresented in court there
are probably tens of thousands who didn't have any legal advice when they did the things that
landed them in hot water in the first place. Who can afford $200 to $300 an hour to get advice on
local small business regulations, the fine print in a mortgage document, or how not to make mistakes
that will cost you in court when fighting over kids and money with your soon-to-be ex-spouse?
Some legal professionals have called for more public money for legal aid clinics and courts to
provide free legal help and for lawyers to do more pro bono work. But the demand for ordinary legal
help is simply too massive to meet with increased court funding, legal aid or pro bono work.
I believe there is no way to help ordinary people with their legal problems without fundamentally
changing the way lawyers and judges regulate the practice of law.
What we need are more efficient ways of delivering legal help and less expensive nonlawyers who
can provide legal assistance. Supreme court judges in every state have the authority to accomplish
this with the stroke of a pen.
The root of the crisis of access to justice is the scale of the problem. Here's Las Vegas lawyers a little
back-of-the-envelope arithmetic. Using data from surveys conducted by the ABA and state bar
associations, I estimate that, at any given time, roughly half of all American households are dealing
with about two legal problems each-- evictions, divorces, bankruptcies, denials of health care
benefits, and so on.
Giving these American households just one hour of help from a lawyer to manage a maze of legal
documents and court procedures would cost close to $20 billion.
This doesn't even consider the cost of what clients want most from lawyers -- advice about how to
avoid legal problems. Including this service would add additional tens if not hundreds of billions of
dollars.
That's why the only way to increase access to justice is to expand the group of people and
organizations that can provide legal help beyond JD-trained and licensed lawyers.
Authorized nonlawyers and organizations could help ease our overburdened courts in many ways.
Each year, 2.3 million New Yorkers, for http://www.law.du.edu/ example, represent themselves in
state courts. These litigants do not want to be in court or to manage their problems alone, but have
no other practical choice. They frequently labor under huge misunderstandings about legal
procedures, requirements and forms. Oodles of judges and lawyers have complained about the
delays and complications these misunderstandings create.
Imagine how much more efficient the court would be if the unrepresented could obtain low-cost
legal assistance from people expert enough to help them navigate the process. Especially if those
people were using the systems and protocols developed by a large-scale company, maybe even
online.
It doesn't take high-level legal expertise to advise a person facing eviction for unpaid rent that if she
wants to contend that her apartment has no heating and the ceiling is falling down, she should bring
some photographs or other evidence to court to back up her claim. The same applies to people who
need to understand what the arcane legal language in a court order or rule means.
There are many basic issues that could be handled by nonlawyers. Allowing nonlawyers to work for
businesses that invest and specialize in giving this kind of help would supercharge the potential for
reducing the cost of legal help.
The use of non-JD legal assistants and nonlawyer dominated businesses is not a venture into
uncharted waters. The United Kingdom has a long history of allowing a wide variety of differently
trained individuals and organizations provide legal assistance, and studies show that the practice
works very well. In many cases, people are better served by a nonlawyer organization that
specializes in a particular type of legal help--navigating housing or bankruptcy matters, for example-
-than they are by a solo practitioner with a general practice.
Furthermore, when people have access to lower-cost alternatives to full-fledged attorneys, they use
these resources. In practical terms, that means that only 5% to 10% ignore their legal issues in the
United Kingdom. Compare that to New York, where significant majorities of low-income households
with legal problems--65% with housing problems, 59% with financial issues, 50% with health
insurance problems--do nothing in response to their problems. But as often is the case, untreated
problems lead to worse problems--and bigger headaches for our courts.
For too long, the legal profession has focused on legal aid, pro bono and charitable assistance as the
solution to the crisis in access to justice. The approach is admirable, but futile.
Solving the problem requires lawyers--especially those on the bench who bear the ultimate
responsibility for regulating the profession--to share the field with other, less-expensive, non-JD
professionals and nonlawyer dominated organizations who can provide perfectly adequate legal help
in many cases. America's legal profession is in dire need of reform; it's time for those in leadership
positions to step up.
Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion
Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion
http://www.cnn.com/2012/11/23/opinion/hadfield-legal-profession/
Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The way forward: Taking your practice to the next level
The way forward: Taking your practice to the next levelThe way forward: Taking your practice to the next level
The way forward: Taking your practice to the next levelOmar Ha-Redeye
 
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in Texas
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in TexasPayday-loan industry spreads the money in Texas
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in Texasobeisantkeepsak29
 
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19Carolyn Elefant
 
Dispelling the Myths - ACC Presentation
Dispelling the Myths - ACC PresentationDispelling the Myths - ACC Presentation
Dispelling the Myths - ACC Presentationacclwv
 
Reference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawReference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawannaiwanski
 
Reference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawReference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawannaiwanski
 
Collections Compliance White Paper
Collections Compliance White PaperCollections Compliance White Paper
Collections Compliance White PaperExperian
 
Brad Fauss - Biography
Brad Fauss - BiographyBrad Fauss - Biography
Brad Fauss - BiographyVivastream
 
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal servicesKathleen Clark
 
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...Michael Swit
 

La actualidad más candente (16)

The way forward: Taking your practice to the next level
The way forward: Taking your practice to the next levelThe way forward: Taking your practice to the next level
The way forward: Taking your practice to the next level
 
NYLJ 3.4.16
NYLJ 3.4.16NYLJ 3.4.16
NYLJ 3.4.16
 
Bankrupty lawyers
Bankrupty lawyersBankrupty lawyers
Bankrupty lawyers
 
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in Texas
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in TexasPayday-loan industry spreads the money in Texas
Payday-loan industry spreads the money in Texas
 
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19
Request to Rescind MSBA Ethics Op. 1992-19
 
Q&B 2016 Rating
Q&B 2016 RatingQ&B 2016 Rating
Q&B 2016 Rating
 
Cslawtalk
CslawtalkCslawtalk
Cslawtalk
 
Dispelling the Myths - ACC Presentation
Dispelling the Myths - ACC PresentationDispelling the Myths - ACC Presentation
Dispelling the Myths - ACC Presentation
 
Using EMMA to Find Great Stories by Yamil Berard
Using EMMA to Find Great Stories by Yamil BerardUsing EMMA to Find Great Stories by Yamil Berard
Using EMMA to Find Great Stories by Yamil Berard
 
23
2323
23
 
Reference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawReference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLaw
 
Reference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLawReference: FindLaw
Reference: FindLaw
 
Collections Compliance White Paper
Collections Compliance White PaperCollections Compliance White Paper
Collections Compliance White Paper
 
Brad Fauss - Biography
Brad Fauss - BiographyBrad Fauss - Biography
Brad Fauss - Biography
 
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services
"Ethics" - an obstacle to innovation in legal services
 
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...
“How Do You Look in Stripes?” -- Understanding and Managing the Potential for...
 

Destacado

Guía formulación planes ordenamiento
Guía formulación planes ordenamientoGuía formulación planes ordenamiento
Guía formulación planes ordenamientoMireya Figueroa
 
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)Mireya Figueroa
 
Quien se ha llevado mi queso spencer johnson
Quien se ha llevado mi queso   spencer johnson Quien se ha llevado mi queso   spencer johnson
Quien se ha llevado mi queso spencer johnson fconavarreteg
 
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights On
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights OnHow IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights On
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights OnOlivia Allen-Price
 
Desarrollo de la embriologia como ciencia
Desarrollo de la embriologia como cienciaDesarrollo de la embriologia como ciencia
Desarrollo de la embriologia como cienciaMireya Figueroa
 
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosial
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi SosialPerubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosial
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosialvennadenisha
 
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)vennadenisha
 

Destacado (14)

#Aula: September 1st
#Aula: September 1st#Aula: September 1st
#Aula: September 1st
 
Guía formulación planes ordenamiento
Guía formulación planes ordenamientoGuía formulación planes ordenamiento
Guía formulación planes ordenamiento
 
Medicomp Skills Fair 2014
Medicomp Skills Fair 2014Medicomp Skills Fair 2014
Medicomp Skills Fair 2014
 
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)
2009 conflictos ambientales_enfoques_definiciones (articulo)
 
#Aula: September 29th
#Aula: September 29th#Aula: September 29th
#Aula: September 29th
 
Quien se ha llevado mi queso spencer johnson
Quien se ha llevado mi queso   spencer johnson Quien se ha llevado mi queso   spencer johnson
Quien se ha llevado mi queso spencer johnson
 
geosfera
geosferageosfera
geosfera
 
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights On
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights OnHow IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights On
How IRL Events Can Serve Your Audience And Keep The Lights On
 
#Aula - August 25th
#Aula - August 25th#Aula - August 25th
#Aula - August 25th
 
Desarrollo de la embriologia como ciencia
Desarrollo de la embriologia como cienciaDesarrollo de la embriologia como ciencia
Desarrollo de la embriologia como ciencia
 
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosial
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi SosialPerubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosial
Perubahan Sosial dan Interaksi Sosial
 
Ailaan Advertising Profile
Ailaan Advertising Profile Ailaan Advertising Profile
Ailaan Advertising Profile
 
Biologia libro
Biologia libroBiologia libro
Biologia libro
 
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)
Software Aplikasi (Aplikasi Komputer)
 

Similar a Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers

Personal Jurisdiction In The United States
Personal Jurisdiction In The United StatesPersonal Jurisdiction In The United States
Personal Jurisdiction In The United StatesJackie Ramirez
 
Pros And Cons Of Class Action Lawsuits
Pros And Cons Of Class Action LawsuitsPros And Cons Of Class Action Lawsuits
Pros And Cons Of Class Action LawsuitsElizabeth Temburu
 
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do Not
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do NotIntroduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do Not
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do NotNicole King
 
Educational Law And The Legal Service
Educational Law And The Legal ServiceEducational Law And The Legal Service
Educational Law And The Legal ServiceCristina Franklin
 
Legal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American FamiliesLegal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American FamiliesJeff Hunter
 
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1Tara Smith
 
Personal Injury Law Firm
Personal Injury Law FirmPersonal Injury Law Firm
Personal Injury Law FirmDenise Enriquez
 
Access to Justice in Canada
Access to Justice in CanadaAccess to Justice in Canada
Access to Justice in CanadaAlison Mazoff
 
LS_LegalNeedsGroup
LS_LegalNeedsGroupLS_LegalNeedsGroup
LS_LegalNeedsGroupSusan Byrtus
 
legalNeedsGroup
legalNeedsGrouplegalNeedsGroup
legalNeedsGroupTSherron
 
Renew Your ABA Membership .docx
Renew Your ABA Membership               .docxRenew Your ABA Membership               .docx
Renew Your ABA Membership .docxdurantheseldine
 
The Pros And Cons Of ADR
The Pros And Cons Of ADRThe Pros And Cons Of ADR
The Pros And Cons Of ADRRachel Quintana
 
Domestic Violence And Child Protection Essay
Domestic Violence And Child Protection EssayDomestic Violence And Child Protection Essay
Domestic Violence And Child Protection EssayNicole King
 
Medical Malpractice Essay
Medical Malpractice EssayMedical Malpractice Essay
Medical Malpractice EssayJoy Smith
 
Rights Of The Legal System
Rights Of The Legal SystemRights Of The Legal System
Rights Of The Legal SystemTara Hardin
 

Similar a Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers (20)

Oakville Family Law
Oakville Family LawOakville Family Law
Oakville Family Law
 
Personal Jurisdiction In The United States
Personal Jurisdiction In The United StatesPersonal Jurisdiction In The United States
Personal Jurisdiction In The United States
 
Pros And Cons Of Class Action Lawsuits
Pros And Cons Of Class Action LawsuitsPros And Cons Of Class Action Lawsuits
Pros And Cons Of Class Action Lawsuits
 
Paralegal
ParalegalParalegal
Paralegal
 
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do Not
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do NotIntroduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do Not
Introduction. Women In The Legal Profession Today Do Not
 
Educational Law And The Legal Service
Educational Law And The Legal ServiceEducational Law And The Legal Service
Educational Law And The Legal Service
 
Legal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American FamiliesLegal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American Families
 
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1
Essay On Bus 520 Assignment 1
 
Personal Injury Law Firm
Personal Injury Law FirmPersonal Injury Law Firm
Personal Injury Law Firm
 
Access to Justice in Canada
Access to Justice in CanadaAccess to Justice in Canada
Access to Justice in Canada
 
LS_LegalNeedsGroup
LS_LegalNeedsGroupLS_LegalNeedsGroup
LS_LegalNeedsGroup
 
Legal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American FamiliesLegal Needs of American Families
Legal Needs of American Families
 
legalNeedsGroup
legalNeedsGrouplegalNeedsGroup
legalNeedsGroup
 
Renew Your ABA Membership .docx
Renew Your ABA Membership               .docxRenew Your ABA Membership               .docx
Renew Your ABA Membership .docx
 
The Pros And Cons Of ADR
The Pros And Cons Of ADRThe Pros And Cons Of ADR
The Pros And Cons Of ADR
 
Domestic Violence And Child Protection Essay
Domestic Violence And Child Protection EssayDomestic Violence And Child Protection Essay
Domestic Violence And Child Protection Essay
 
Self-Represented Litigants
Self-Represented LitigantsSelf-Represented Litigants
Self-Represented Litigants
 
Anti Terror Laws
Anti Terror LawsAnti Terror Laws
Anti Terror Laws
 
Medical Malpractice Essay
Medical Malpractice EssayMedical Malpractice Essay
Medical Malpractice Essay
 
Rights Of The Legal System
Rights Of The Legal SystemRights Of The Legal System
Rights Of The Legal System
 

Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers

  • 1. Lawyers, make room for nonlawyers Story highlightsGillian Hadfield: Getting legal help is enormously expensive in the U.S.Hadfield: Lawyers, judges must change the way they regulate practice of lawShe says we need less expensive nonlawyers who can provide legal assistanceHadfield: Lower-cost alternative to full-fledged attorneys is the solution In our country, lawyers and judges regulate their own markets. The upshot is that getting legal help is enormously expensive and out of reach for the vast majority of Americans. Anyone faced with a contract dispute, family crisis, foreclosure or eviction must pay a lawyer with a JD degree to provide service one-on-one in the same way lawyers have done business for hundreds of years. Increasingly, the only "persons" with access to legal help are "artificial persons" -- corporations, organizations and governments. No wonder that in a 2010 New York study, it was shown 95% of people in housing court are unrepresented. The same is true in consumer credit and child support cases; 44% of people in foreclosures are representing themselves--against a well-represented bank, no small number of whom engaged in robo-signing and sued people based on faulty information. These numbers are just the tip of the iceberg. For every person who is unrepresented in court there are probably tens of thousands who didn't have any legal advice when they did the things that landed them in hot water in the first place. Who can afford $200 to $300 an hour to get advice on local small business regulations, the fine print in a mortgage document, or how not to make mistakes that will cost you in court when fighting over kids and money with your soon-to-be ex-spouse? Some legal professionals have called for more public money for legal aid clinics and courts to provide free legal help and for lawyers to do more pro bono work. But the demand for ordinary legal help is simply too massive to meet with increased court funding, legal aid or pro bono work. I believe there is no way to help ordinary people with their legal problems without fundamentally changing the way lawyers and judges regulate the practice of law. What we need are more efficient ways of delivering legal help and less expensive nonlawyers who can provide legal assistance. Supreme court judges in every state have the authority to accomplish this with the stroke of a pen. The root of the crisis of access to justice is the scale of the problem. Here's Las Vegas lawyers a little back-of-the-envelope arithmetic. Using data from surveys conducted by the ABA and state bar associations, I estimate that, at any given time, roughly half of all American households are dealing with about two legal problems each-- evictions, divorces, bankruptcies, denials of health care benefits, and so on. Giving these American households just one hour of help from a lawyer to manage a maze of legal documents and court procedures would cost close to $20 billion. This doesn't even consider the cost of what clients want most from lawyers -- advice about how to avoid legal problems. Including this service would add additional tens if not hundreds of billions of dollars. That's why the only way to increase access to justice is to expand the group of people and organizations that can provide legal help beyond JD-trained and licensed lawyers.
  • 2. Authorized nonlawyers and organizations could help ease our overburdened courts in many ways. Each year, 2.3 million New Yorkers, for http://www.law.du.edu/ example, represent themselves in state courts. These litigants do not want to be in court or to manage their problems alone, but have no other practical choice. They frequently labor under huge misunderstandings about legal procedures, requirements and forms. Oodles of judges and lawyers have complained about the delays and complications these misunderstandings create. Imagine how much more efficient the court would be if the unrepresented could obtain low-cost legal assistance from people expert enough to help them navigate the process. Especially if those people were using the systems and protocols developed by a large-scale company, maybe even online. It doesn't take high-level legal expertise to advise a person facing eviction for unpaid rent that if she wants to contend that her apartment has no heating and the ceiling is falling down, she should bring some photographs or other evidence to court to back up her claim. The same applies to people who need to understand what the arcane legal language in a court order or rule means. There are many basic issues that could be handled by nonlawyers. Allowing nonlawyers to work for businesses that invest and specialize in giving this kind of help would supercharge the potential for reducing the cost of legal help. The use of non-JD legal assistants and nonlawyer dominated businesses is not a venture into uncharted waters. The United Kingdom has a long history of allowing a wide variety of differently trained individuals and organizations provide legal assistance, and studies show that the practice works very well. In many cases, people are better served by a nonlawyer organization that specializes in a particular type of legal help--navigating housing or bankruptcy matters, for example- -than they are by a solo practitioner with a general practice. Furthermore, when people have access to lower-cost alternatives to full-fledged attorneys, they use these resources. In practical terms, that means that only 5% to 10% ignore their legal issues in the United Kingdom. Compare that to New York, where significant majorities of low-income households with legal problems--65% with housing problems, 59% with financial issues, 50% with health insurance problems--do nothing in response to their problems. But as often is the case, untreated problems lead to worse problems--and bigger headaches for our courts. For too long, the legal profession has focused on legal aid, pro bono and charitable assistance as the solution to the crisis in access to justice. The approach is admirable, but futile. Solving the problem requires lawyers--especially those on the bench who bear the ultimate responsibility for regulating the profession--to share the field with other, less-expensive, non-JD professionals and nonlawyer dominated organizations who can provide perfectly adequate legal help in many cases. America's legal profession is in dire need of reform; it's time for those in leadership positions to step up. Follow us on Twitter @CNNOpinion Join us on Facebook/CNNOpinion http://www.cnn.com/2012/11/23/opinion/hadfield-legal-profession/