SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 10
WATCH PARTY
             FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 1


REQUEST: DID ROMNEY ADVOCATE MORE TROOPS IN
IRAQ?


FACT-CHECK: Yes, but so did Obama. “And finally, Romney
did not say he would leave 30,000 troops in Iraq, but put the
number at somewhere between 10,000 and 30,000. His exact
words were: “[w]e should have left 10-, 20-, 30-thousand
personnel there to help transition to the Iraqis‟ own military
capabilities.” Obama himself was proposing to leave 3,000 to
4,000 troops there at the time negotiations with the Iraqi
government broke down.”
http://factcheck.org/2012/10/homestretch-fact-stretchers/

SOURCE: FACTCHECK.ORG CITING FOXNEWS       INITIALS: LLWS
WATCH PARTY
           FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 2


REQUEST:WHY IS THIS LIBYA THING SO IMPORTANT?




FACT-CHECK: “Lingering questions about the attack are
how much President Barack Obama‟s administration can be
blamed and whether it misled people about what happened
in the days immediately after the attack.” – Politifact,
http://www.politifact.com/georgia/article/2012/oct/18/att
ack-libya-hot-topic-both-candidates/



SOURCE: POLITIFACT              INITIALS: MJ
WATCH PARTY
             FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 3


REQUEST: WHAT IS THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE:




FACT-CHECK:     7.8%
ALSO, IF YOU WANT BREAK DOWN BY REASON FOR
UNEMPLOYMENT:
HTTP://WWW.BLS.GOV/NEWS.RELEASE/EMPSIT.T11.HTM



SOURCE: BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS, SEPTEMBER 2012 INITIALS LWS
WATCH PARTY
              FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 4


REQUEST: DID ROMNEY SAY „CLASS SIZES‟ DON‟T
MATTER?

FACT-CHECK: Yes, multiple times: “the Washington Times
story cited in the ad was about Romney's May visit to a
philadelphia charter school. He joined a roundtable of
teachers and talked about his approach to education while
governor of Massachusetts… Romney continued. "So just
getting smaller classrooms didn‟t seem to be the key.“ Also,
again in Orlando: “"I plotted the one versus the other,
classroom size against student performance. And guess what?
There was no relationship at all.” http://www.politifact.com/truth-
o-meter/statements/2012/aug/23/barack-obama/obama-ad-says-class-
sizes-dont-matter-romney/

SOURCE: POLITIFACT                            INITIALS: LWS
WATCH PARTY
                 FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 5


REQUEST:HAS OBAMA TRULY „STOOD WITH ISRAEL?‟ DID
HE NOT IGNORE PRIME MINISTER?


FACT-CHECK: CNN says the following on daylight comment: “obama's
"explicit" statement Romney is referencing dates back to july 2009,
at a closed meeting between Obama and select Jewish leaders.
According to The Washington Post's account, concerns were building
over the president's reasoning on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Obama sought to assure the leaders that he and his administration
understood the "nuances of the current issues.” Also, Politifact has
rated the Netanyahu ignoring claimFALSE.
http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/08/politics/fact-check-romney-daylight/index.html ,
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/oct/12/paul-ryan/paul-ryan-
said-obama-was-nyc-same-say-bibi-dissed-/




SOURCE: CNN, POLITIFACT                                   INITIALS LLWS
WATCH PARTY
                FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 6


REQUEST: DID OBAMA CRITICIZE U.S. ON HIS “APOLOGY
TOUR?”
FACT-CHECK: YES. While never an Apology Tour (Politifact rates this
claim pants on fire), Obama did say things like “at a town hall meeting in
France in 2009, for example, Obama encouraged Europe to work with the
United States, and admitted that the United States "has shown arrogance
and been dismissive, even derisive." But he immediately said that Europe
has been guilty of a "casual" and "insidious" Anti-Americanism.
At a major address to the United Nations, Obama said, "I took office at a
time when many around the world had come to view America with
skepticism and distrust. Part of this was due to misperceptions and
misinformation about my country. Part of this was due to opposition to
specific policies, and a belief that on certain critical issues, America has
acted unilaterally, without regard for the interests of others. And this
has fed an almost reflexiveAnti-Americanism, which too often has served
as an excuse for collective inaction."

SOURCE: HTTP://WWW.POLITIFACT.COM/TRUTH-O-METER/STATEMENTS/2012/OCT/17/MITT-
ROMNEY/MITT-ROMNEY-SAYS-BARACK-OBAMA-BEGAN/           INITIALSMJ
WATCH PARTY
           FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 7


REQUEST:HOW EXACTLY DO ROMNEY‟S FOREIGN
POLICIES DIFFER FROM OBAMA‟S?


FACT-CHECK: ProCon.Org has a side by side comparison on
68 issues between Obama and Romney including Syria,
China, Iran, War on Terror, Israel-Palestinian. You can
find it here:
HTTP://2012ELECTION.PROCON.ORG/VIEW.SOURCE-
SUMMARY-CHART.PHP?TOPIC=64



SOURCE: PRO-CON.ORG            INITIALS MJ
WATCH PARTY
                   FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 8


REQUEST: WERE ROMNEY‟S EDUCATION STATS BEFORE
HE TOOK OFFICE?

FACT-CHECK: Romney was Governor from 2003 to 2007.
A c c o r d i n g t o A L E C ‟ s 1 6 th a n n u a l R e p o r t C a r d o n A m e r i c a n
Education, Massachusetts was ranked #2 behind only
Vermont for “State Final Ranking for Low-Income Children
Overall Scores/Change in Scores on 4th- and 8th-Grade
Reading and Mathematics, 2003-2009.” p. 17 of
http://www.alec.org/docs/2010-report-card_finalcopycondensed.pdf
In 2002, the year before Romney took office, Massachusetts was ranked #2 in the
nation (http://tcf.org/blogs/botc/2012/10/why-romney-shouldnt-take-credit-for-
massachusetts-high-education-ranks). In 2011 according to SERI, #1 in the nation.


SOURCE: ALEC REPORT CARD ON AMERICAN EDUCATION 2010, SERI, THE
CENTURY FOUNDATION, INITIALS MK & LWS
WATCH PARTY
                                      FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 9


REQUEST: OBAMA KEEPS TALKING ABOUT ROMNEY‟S
INVESTMENT IN COMPANIES SHIPPED OVERSEAS. WHAT
IS OBAMA TALKING ABOUT?

FACT-CHECK: Mostly True according to Politifact. “Romney‟s
investment company, Bain Capital, bought a 10.3 percent
share in Global-Tech Appliances through a subsidiary in 1998,
according to a July article in Mother Jones. In a prospectus
that year, Global-Tech described that it had two factories in
China that produced coffee makers, bread makers, and other
small appliances for some of the best known brands, such as
Sunbeam, Hamilton Beach, Mr. Coffee, Oster and others.”
S O U R C E : H T T P : / / W W W . P O L I T I F A C T . C O M / T R U T H - O - M E T E R / S T A T E M E N T S / 2 0 1 2 / S E P / 2 0 / B A R A C K - O B A MA / OB A M A - S A Y S -
R O M N E Y - T A L K S - T O U G H - C H I N A - P U T S - H IS - M ON E Y /
                                                                                                          I N I T I A L S M K & M J
WATCH PARTY
            FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 10


REQUEST: IS LATIN AMERICA‟S ECONOMY THE SAME
SIZE AS CHINA‟S?


FACT-CHECK: No. According to the International
Monetary Fund‟s latest data for 2011, China‟s Gross
Domestic Product (GDP) at Current Prices in US dollars
was   $7,912,147,000 .         The combined GDP for Latin
America & the Caribbean was    $5,614,257,000        .
Find out more about growth rates, imports, exports, and
projections here and here.
SOURCE: INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND, WORLD ECONOMIC OUTLOOK
DATABASE, OCTOBER 2012              INITIALS LWS

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked Statistics
News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked StatisticsNews Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked Statistics
News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked StatisticsSpazioDati
 
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press Institute
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press InstituteThe Fact Checking Project from the American Press Institute
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press InstituteJoe Amditis
 
This History and Current State of Fact Checking
This History and Current State of Fact CheckingThis History and Current State of Fact Checking
This History and Current State of Fact CheckingCraig Silverman
 
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v Fiction
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v FictionLinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v Fiction
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v FictionSusan Chesley Fant
 
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developers
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developersISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developers
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developersSpazioDati
 
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the story
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the storyOpening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the story
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the storySpazioDati
 
B.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital ContentB.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital ContentCraig Silverman
 
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 June
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 JuneCraig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 June
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 JuneGlobal Editors Network
 
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small Businessses
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small BusinesssesMotivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small Businessses
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small BusinesssesVirtuoso Assistant
 
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)Kayako
 

Destacado (11)

News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked Statistics
News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked StatisticsNews Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked Statistics
News Fact-checking: One Practical Application of Linked Statistics
 
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press Institute
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press InstituteThe Fact Checking Project from the American Press Institute
The Fact Checking Project from the American Press Institute
 
This History and Current State of Fact Checking
This History and Current State of Fact CheckingThis History and Current State of Fact Checking
This History and Current State of Fact Checking
 
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v Fiction
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v FictionLinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v Fiction
LinkedIn, Twitter, and Online Fact v Fiction
 
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developers
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developersISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developers
ISWC 2014 - Dandelion: from raw data to dataGEMs for developers
 
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the story
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the storyOpening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the story
Opening “Big Data Challenge” data: some insights on our role in the story
 
Fact-Checking Workshop by API & PolitiFact
Fact-Checking Workshop by API & PolitiFactFact-Checking Workshop by API & PolitiFact
Fact-Checking Workshop by API & PolitiFact
 
B.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital ContentB.S. Detection for Digital Content
B.S. Detection for Digital Content
 
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 June
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 JuneCraig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 June
Craig Silverman, Poynter Institute, Intro Fact-Checking, 11 June
 
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small Businessses
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small BusinesssesMotivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small Businessses
Motivational and Inspirational Quotes for Startups and Small Businessses
 
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)
Kayako Values - What is it like to work at Kayako? (Old)
 

Watch party fact check requests

  • 1. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 1 REQUEST: DID ROMNEY ADVOCATE MORE TROOPS IN IRAQ? FACT-CHECK: Yes, but so did Obama. “And finally, Romney did not say he would leave 30,000 troops in Iraq, but put the number at somewhere between 10,000 and 30,000. His exact words were: “[w]e should have left 10-, 20-, 30-thousand personnel there to help transition to the Iraqis‟ own military capabilities.” Obama himself was proposing to leave 3,000 to 4,000 troops there at the time negotiations with the Iraqi government broke down.” http://factcheck.org/2012/10/homestretch-fact-stretchers/ SOURCE: FACTCHECK.ORG CITING FOXNEWS INITIALS: LLWS
  • 2. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 2 REQUEST:WHY IS THIS LIBYA THING SO IMPORTANT? FACT-CHECK: “Lingering questions about the attack are how much President Barack Obama‟s administration can be blamed and whether it misled people about what happened in the days immediately after the attack.” – Politifact, http://www.politifact.com/georgia/article/2012/oct/18/att ack-libya-hot-topic-both-candidates/ SOURCE: POLITIFACT INITIALS: MJ
  • 3. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 3 REQUEST: WHAT IS THE UNEMPLOYMENT RATE: FACT-CHECK: 7.8% ALSO, IF YOU WANT BREAK DOWN BY REASON FOR UNEMPLOYMENT: HTTP://WWW.BLS.GOV/NEWS.RELEASE/EMPSIT.T11.HTM SOURCE: BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS, SEPTEMBER 2012 INITIALS LWS
  • 4. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 4 REQUEST: DID ROMNEY SAY „CLASS SIZES‟ DON‟T MATTER? FACT-CHECK: Yes, multiple times: “the Washington Times story cited in the ad was about Romney's May visit to a philadelphia charter school. He joined a roundtable of teachers and talked about his approach to education while governor of Massachusetts… Romney continued. "So just getting smaller classrooms didn‟t seem to be the key.“ Also, again in Orlando: “"I plotted the one versus the other, classroom size against student performance. And guess what? There was no relationship at all.” http://www.politifact.com/truth- o-meter/statements/2012/aug/23/barack-obama/obama-ad-says-class- sizes-dont-matter-romney/ SOURCE: POLITIFACT INITIALS: LWS
  • 5. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 5 REQUEST:HAS OBAMA TRULY „STOOD WITH ISRAEL?‟ DID HE NOT IGNORE PRIME MINISTER? FACT-CHECK: CNN says the following on daylight comment: “obama's "explicit" statement Romney is referencing dates back to july 2009, at a closed meeting between Obama and select Jewish leaders. According to The Washington Post's account, concerns were building over the president's reasoning on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Obama sought to assure the leaders that he and his administration understood the "nuances of the current issues.” Also, Politifact has rated the Netanyahu ignoring claimFALSE. http://www.cnn.com/2012/10/08/politics/fact-check-romney-daylight/index.html , http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/oct/12/paul-ryan/paul-ryan- said-obama-was-nyc-same-say-bibi-dissed-/ SOURCE: CNN, POLITIFACT INITIALS LLWS
  • 6. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 6 REQUEST: DID OBAMA CRITICIZE U.S. ON HIS “APOLOGY TOUR?” FACT-CHECK: YES. While never an Apology Tour (Politifact rates this claim pants on fire), Obama did say things like “at a town hall meeting in France in 2009, for example, Obama encouraged Europe to work with the United States, and admitted that the United States "has shown arrogance and been dismissive, even derisive." But he immediately said that Europe has been guilty of a "casual" and "insidious" Anti-Americanism. At a major address to the United Nations, Obama said, "I took office at a time when many around the world had come to view America with skepticism and distrust. Part of this was due to misperceptions and misinformation about my country. Part of this was due to opposition to specific policies, and a belief that on certain critical issues, America has acted unilaterally, without regard for the interests of others. And this has fed an almost reflexiveAnti-Americanism, which too often has served as an excuse for collective inaction." SOURCE: HTTP://WWW.POLITIFACT.COM/TRUTH-O-METER/STATEMENTS/2012/OCT/17/MITT- ROMNEY/MITT-ROMNEY-SAYS-BARACK-OBAMA-BEGAN/ INITIALSMJ
  • 7. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 7 REQUEST:HOW EXACTLY DO ROMNEY‟S FOREIGN POLICIES DIFFER FROM OBAMA‟S? FACT-CHECK: ProCon.Org has a side by side comparison on 68 issues between Obama and Romney including Syria, China, Iran, War on Terror, Israel-Palestinian. You can find it here: HTTP://2012ELECTION.PROCON.ORG/VIEW.SOURCE- SUMMARY-CHART.PHP?TOPIC=64 SOURCE: PRO-CON.ORG INITIALS MJ
  • 8. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 8 REQUEST: WERE ROMNEY‟S EDUCATION STATS BEFORE HE TOOK OFFICE? FACT-CHECK: Romney was Governor from 2003 to 2007. A c c o r d i n g t o A L E C ‟ s 1 6 th a n n u a l R e p o r t C a r d o n A m e r i c a n Education, Massachusetts was ranked #2 behind only Vermont for “State Final Ranking for Low-Income Children Overall Scores/Change in Scores on 4th- and 8th-Grade Reading and Mathematics, 2003-2009.” p. 17 of http://www.alec.org/docs/2010-report-card_finalcopycondensed.pdf In 2002, the year before Romney took office, Massachusetts was ranked #2 in the nation (http://tcf.org/blogs/botc/2012/10/why-romney-shouldnt-take-credit-for- massachusetts-high-education-ranks). In 2011 according to SERI, #1 in the nation. SOURCE: ALEC REPORT CARD ON AMERICAN EDUCATION 2010, SERI, THE CENTURY FOUNDATION, INITIALS MK & LWS
  • 9. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 9 REQUEST: OBAMA KEEPS TALKING ABOUT ROMNEY‟S INVESTMENT IN COMPANIES SHIPPED OVERSEAS. WHAT IS OBAMA TALKING ABOUT? FACT-CHECK: Mostly True according to Politifact. “Romney‟s investment company, Bain Capital, bought a 10.3 percent share in Global-Tech Appliances through a subsidiary in 1998, according to a July article in Mother Jones. In a prospectus that year, Global-Tech described that it had two factories in China that produced coffee makers, bread makers, and other small appliances for some of the best known brands, such as Sunbeam, Hamilton Beach, Mr. Coffee, Oster and others.” S O U R C E : H T T P : / / W W W . P O L I T I F A C T . C O M / T R U T H - O - M E T E R / S T A T E M E N T S / 2 0 1 2 / S E P / 2 0 / B A R A C K - O B A MA / OB A M A - S A Y S - R O M N E Y - T A L K S - T O U G H - C H I N A - P U T S - H IS - M ON E Y / I N I T I A L S M K & M J
  • 10. WATCH PARTY FACT-CHECKING REQUEST # 10 REQUEST: IS LATIN AMERICA‟S ECONOMY THE SAME SIZE AS CHINA‟S? FACT-CHECK: No. According to the International Monetary Fund‟s latest data for 2011, China‟s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) at Current Prices in US dollars was $7,912,147,000 . The combined GDP for Latin America & the Caribbean was $5,614,257,000 . Find out more about growth rates, imports, exports, and projections here and here. SOURCE: INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND, WORLD ECONOMIC OUTLOOK DATABASE, OCTOBER 2012 INITIALS LWS