Core principles & tactics to steer clear of cross-cultural/boundary marketing mistakes that can damage your brand or marketing program. Presentation delivered at PCMA Convening Leaders 2011 annual convention. Written by Jeannine Woodyear and Oliver Hone
21. 5 Principles for Cross-Cultural Effectiveness Context is King Time-zones Matter When in Rome… What Happens in Vegas, Doesn’t Stay in Vegas The Consumer is in Control
22. 5 Principles for Cross Cultural Effectiveness in Marketing Context is King: everything about a person’s past impacts how they see the world…and your communications
49. 9 Tactical Considerations Language Historical and cultural sensitivities Flags, maps, geography, naming Politics and religion Risqué material Stereotypes: racial, ethnic, cultural, or religious Symbols and symbolism Color Numbers
52. 7 Tactical Considerations 2. Historical and cultural sensitivities Are particular teams represented in the image? If so, are they teams that are actually participating in this event? Do the countries/regions have a mutual history that could result in this image being interpreted as commentary on a historical event, or a current situation?
53. 7 Tactical Considerations 3. Flags, maps, geography: are often sensitive symbols of identity There are many types of flags with meanings relating to nationality, politics, sports, education, fictional entities, etc. Avoid showing or describing flags or national symbols, except when absolutely necessary to the point you are making. e.g. China/TW; India/Kashmir; Israel/Palestine Do not use flags or national symbols to represent languages since many languages are spoken in several countries.. e.g. Canada, Belgium, Switzerland Accurately reflect continents and multinational regions in which countries reside (e.g. use Asia or SE Asia not Far East or Orient)
66. 6. Stereotypes: racial, ethnic, cultural, or religious Be aware of gender specific roles in various cultures Avoid associating values with certain traits (for example, if the heroes in a game all have one trait while the villains share a different trait)
73. Do not use national symbols to represent language, since there is often not a one-to-one association.
74. Historical symbols also can be highly sensitive, and they should be researched thoroughly before being used. Tactical Considerations
75.
76. Avoid using color to convey meaning. This includes using color as metaphor, such as “red alert.”
77. Avoid using color in ways that are considered derogatory, such as referring to villains as “black hats.” Similarly, avoid using a yellow tint to portray the skin color of Asian people.
78. Do not use color as the only way to differentiate content.There is no color that needs to be avoided in every case, but it is important to ensure that colors are used appropriately in context – for example Euro advertising favors “white space” which represents mourning in Asian culture… Tactical Considerations
79. 9. Numbers: Just like colors, there are a number of cultural taboos around the use of numbers. Eg. while the number 4 does not invoke feelings of fear in the US and much of the Western world… In Japan and China the number symbolizes death. In Japan the number 9 is equally unlucky. Although the number 7 is lucky in much of the world, the number 8 is especially auspicious in China. The US and much of Europe the number 13 has historically been avoided Tactical Considerations
82. Final Thoughts Be aware Do your research If possible recruit a local agency in key markets If not look to local contacts to help you with inside information before starting Remember the language and beware straight translation Where possible, do make it as localized as possible If it has to work globally, avoid the tendency to go lowest common denominator
Sure, IT pros in Brazil may well enjoy Playboy and hope for women to realize their full potentialBut what may be appropriate in Brazil is offensive to much of the rest of the worldReally about brand association
Where you on the right track?This marketing ploy references Chinese New Year and the Year of the Rat to sell a device that kills rodents. this is potentially offensive to ethnic Chinese who may see it as callous exploitation of their culture. the sign also confuses solar calendar 2008 with the Year of the Rat, which follows the lunar calendar
Like flags, national symbols are often very sensitive. Did you know that the orchid happens to be the national flower of Singapore ?
Oftentimes people just want to be heard. They want to feel understood and they want to be respectedYet they also want to know that you’ve learned your lesson