SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 33
Does the Soft Stuff Really  Matter? Jeff Walsh EVP KLC Associates Karen Cornelius President KLC Associates
What do the data show?* ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What do the data show?* ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What do the data show?* ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What do the data show?* Post merger performance of acquirers versus industry sector peers on financial indices: *Vestring et. al. 2003 Proactive cultural integration +5.1% Ignored cultural integration -4.4%
What do the data show?* Post merger performance of acquirers versus industry sector peers on financial indices: *Vestring et. al. 2003 Scale-driven deals Scope-driven deals Proactive cultural integration +5.1% +6.4% Ignored cultural integration -7.9% -0.5%
Summary : what do the data show? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Managing Cultural Integration
Corporate Cultural Differences ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Corporate Cultural Differences ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],The problem with CCDs… Partners from different corporate cultures will :
Corporate Cultural Differences Our research has identified  12 dimensions of organizational culture  with the potential to  derail   mergers   (as well as partnerships, joint ventures, supplier relationships, etc.).  The top five: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Corporate Cultural Differences The supporting seven : ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Corporate Cultural Differences Managing Differences ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Corporate Cultural Differences ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],What could  go wrong  ?
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Corporate Cultural Differences What could  go wrong  ?
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Corporate Cultural Differences What could  go wrong  ?
… So, what do you do to avoid  pitfalls  and successfully manage  integration ? Corporate Cultural Differences Successful Integration
Implementing Cultural Integration Before the Letter Of Intent is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration Before the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration Before the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration Before the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Definitive Agreement is Signed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Deal Has Closed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Involving employees generates ‘best’ solutions and builds commitment to the integration
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Deal Has Closed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration After the Deal Has Closed ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Implementing Cultural Integration Outcomes Customers and Stakeholders
Managing Cultural Integration  –   The Soft Stuff Does Matter Karen Cornelius President KLC Associates Jeff Walsh EVP KLC Associates
Backup ,[object Object],[object Object]
Where M&A pays or  strays Strategic motivation Opportunistic motivation Value acquiring Momentum growth/glamour Focused/related acquiring Unrelated diversification Credible synergies Unrealistic synergies Use excess cash profitably Just to use excess cash Negotiated private purchase Auction of public firm Cross border for advantage Cross border naively Go hostile Negotiate w/resistant target
Where M&A pays or  strays Buy during cold M&A market Buy during hot M&A market Pay with cash Pay with stock High tax benefits to acquirer Low tax benefits to acquirer Judicious leverage Over-lever Earnouts/staged payments Pay in full up front True merger of equals Not a merger of equals Mgt has significant stake Mgt has low or no stake Shareholder-oriented Entrenched management Active investors Passive investors
Data sources: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

M&A success & failures research
M&A success & failures researchM&A success & failures research
M&A success & failures researchSteve Coote
 
There are various factors that contribute to the firm
There are various factors that contribute to the firmThere are various factors that contribute to the firm
There are various factors that contribute to the firmnurnadrah2
 
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2Jake Raymond
 
Contract theory
Contract theoryContract theory
Contract theoryav190286
 
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)Managing In Turbulent Times (2)
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)kathryncook81
 
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1Mansour Jumaa
 
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...Alexander Decker
 
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.Fahad Mahmood
 
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...Scorpio Partnership
 
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism Event
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism EventNIRI Boston Shareholder Activism Event
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism EventNIRI Boston
 
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost Fundraising
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost FundraisingSegmenting the Investor Community to Boost Fundraising
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost FundraisingNavatar
 
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit management
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit managementUnit v strategic issues in nonprofit management
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit managementDeborah Sharon
 
BA225 Week seven chapter 11 ppt
BA225 Week seven   chapter 11 pptBA225 Week seven   chapter 11 ppt
BA225 Week seven chapter 11 pptBealCollegeOnline
 
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_Report
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_ReportLP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_Report
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_ReportTres Moore
 
VALUES-Bin_Luo
VALUES-Bin_LuoVALUES-Bin_Luo
VALUES-Bin_LuoRobin Luo
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

Puzzlebox comp 2010
Puzzlebox comp 2010Puzzlebox comp 2010
Puzzlebox comp 2010
 
M&A success & failures research
M&A success & failures researchM&A success & failures research
M&A success & failures research
 
There are various factors that contribute to the firm
There are various factors that contribute to the firmThere are various factors that contribute to the firm
There are various factors that contribute to the firm
 
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2
floyd_adv_q42014_ddd_report_030315r2
 
Contract theory
Contract theoryContract theory
Contract theory
 
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)Managing In Turbulent Times (2)
Managing In Turbulent Times (2)
 
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1
Managing In Turbulent Times 2 1233075645985895 1
 
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...
An empirical analysis of factors influencing indian individual equity investo...
 
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.
Recognizing Opportunities and generating Ideas.
 
Security Valuation and Risk Analysis
Security Valuation and Risk AnalysisSecurity Valuation and Risk Analysis
Security Valuation and Risk Analysis
 
Case study
Case studyCase study
Case study
 
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...
The Influential Investor. How UHNW and HNW investor behaviour is redefining p...
 
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism Event
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism EventNIRI Boston Shareholder Activism Event
NIRI Boston Shareholder Activism Event
 
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost Fundraising
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost FundraisingSegmenting the Investor Community to Boost Fundraising
Segmenting the Investor Community to Boost Fundraising
 
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit management
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit managementUnit v strategic issues in nonprofit management
Unit v strategic issues in nonprofit management
 
Alison Cornell CV NC
Alison Cornell CV NCAlison Cornell CV NC
Alison Cornell CV NC
 
BA225 Week seven chapter 11 ppt
BA225 Week seven   chapter 11 pptBA225 Week seven   chapter 11 ppt
BA225 Week seven chapter 11 ppt
 
Small Business Cr Seminar Oct 2007
Small Business Cr Seminar Oct 2007Small Business Cr Seminar Oct 2007
Small Business Cr Seminar Oct 2007
 
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_Report
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_ReportLP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_Report
LP_Perspective_ on Emerging Managers_Report
 
VALUES-Bin_Luo
VALUES-Bin_LuoVALUES-Bin_Luo
VALUES-Bin_Luo
 

Similar a M&As Does The Soft Stuff Really Matter

The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7
The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7
The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7Scott McLean
 
Cultural Due Diligence
Cultural Due DiligenceCultural Due Diligence
Cultural Due DiligenceTheo Kroese
 
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011Simon Burne
 
Nef measuring what matters
Nef measuring what mattersNef measuring what matters
Nef measuring what mattersTim Curtis
 
Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change
 Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change
Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting ChangeJeff Willinger
 
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity Presentation
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity PresentationDHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity Presentation
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity PresentationJenny Cavnar
 
How Companies Achieve High Performance
How Companies Achieve High PerformanceHow Companies Achieve High Performance
How Companies Achieve High PerformanceDave Dowling
 
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careers
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation CareersSustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careers
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careerschesapeakecareers
 
Wcm Cm Lecture 5 2004
Wcm   Cm   Lecture 5   2004Wcm   Cm   Lecture 5   2004
Wcm Cm Lecture 5 2004richard kemp
 
Grantwriting for Credit Union Leagues
Grantwriting for Credit Union LeaguesGrantwriting for Credit Union Leagues
Grantwriting for Credit Union Leaguesrealsolutions
 
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted FinalJ. Paul Oxer
 
Business case presentation_adel etman
Business case presentation_adel etmanBusiness case presentation_adel etman
Business case presentation_adel etmanadeletman
 
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence Prospects
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence ProspectsNine Ways to Win Investors and Influence Prospects
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence ProspectsAtlas Integrated
 
Getting your shift together making sense of organizational culture and change
Getting your shift together   making sense of organizational culture and changeGetting your shift together   making sense of organizational culture and change
Getting your shift together making sense of organizational culture and changeDani
 
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docx
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docxGrading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docx
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docxshericehewat
 
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!dmdk12
 

Similar a M&As Does The Soft Stuff Really Matter (20)

The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7
The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7
The Integration Of Culture In M&A V7
 
Cultural Due Diligence
Cultural Due DiligenceCultural Due Diligence
Cultural Due Diligence
 
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011
Corporate partnerships strategy IoF 2011
 
Association sales professional 102
Association sales professional 102Association sales professional 102
Association sales professional 102
 
Nef measuring what matters
Nef measuring what mattersNef measuring what matters
Nef measuring what matters
 
Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change
 Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change
Finding the Fulcrum, Tipping Boulders: Strategic Approaches to Effecting Change
 
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity Presentation
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity PresentationDHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity Presentation
DHG Financial Services Strategic Planning and Cybersecurity Presentation
 
How Companies Achieve High Performance
How Companies Achieve High PerformanceHow Companies Achieve High Performance
How Companies Achieve High Performance
 
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careers
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation CareersSustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careers
Sustainable Solutions: Next Generation Careers
 
Wcm Cm Lecture 5 2004
Wcm   Cm   Lecture 5   2004Wcm   Cm   Lecture 5   2004
Wcm Cm Lecture 5 2004
 
Grantwriting for Credit Union Leagues
Grantwriting for Credit Union LeaguesGrantwriting for Credit Union Leagues
Grantwriting for Credit Union Leagues
 
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final
150909 ECC Mtg. JPO Prsntn Formatted Final
 
Business case presentation_adel etman
Business case presentation_adel etmanBusiness case presentation_adel etman
Business case presentation_adel etman
 
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence Prospects
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence ProspectsNine Ways to Win Investors and Influence Prospects
Nine Ways to Win Investors and Influence Prospects
 
Getting your shift together making sense of organizational culture and change
Getting your shift together   making sense of organizational culture and changeGetting your shift together   making sense of organizational culture and change
Getting your shift together making sense of organizational culture and change
 
Mentoring.pptx
Mentoring.pptxMentoring.pptx
Mentoring.pptx
 
Mentoring.pptx
Mentoring.pptxMentoring.pptx
Mentoring.pptx
 
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docx
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docxGrading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docx
Grading Guide Advisory Memo Reasonable Accommodation and Undue H.docx
 
2018 strategy
2018 strategy2018 strategy
2018 strategy
 
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!
Model for Merger Management - This is a work in progress!!
 

M&As Does The Soft Stuff Really Matter

  • 1. Does the Soft Stuff Really Matter? Jeff Walsh EVP KLC Associates Karen Cornelius President KLC Associates
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. What do the data show?* Post merger performance of acquirers versus industry sector peers on financial indices: *Vestring et. al. 2003 Proactive cultural integration +5.1% Ignored cultural integration -4.4%
  • 6. What do the data show?* Post merger performance of acquirers versus industry sector peers on financial indices: *Vestring et. al. 2003 Scale-driven deals Scope-driven deals Proactive cultural integration +5.1% +6.4% Ignored cultural integration -7.9% -0.5%
  • 7.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. … So, what do you do to avoid pitfalls and successfully manage integration ? Corporate Cultural Differences Successful Integration
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28. Implementing Cultural Integration Outcomes Customers and Stakeholders
  • 29. Managing Cultural Integration – The Soft Stuff Does Matter Karen Cornelius President KLC Associates Jeff Walsh EVP KLC Associates
  • 30.
  • 31. Where M&A pays or strays Strategic motivation Opportunistic motivation Value acquiring Momentum growth/glamour Focused/related acquiring Unrelated diversification Credible synergies Unrealistic synergies Use excess cash profitably Just to use excess cash Negotiated private purchase Auction of public firm Cross border for advantage Cross border naively Go hostile Negotiate w/resistant target
  • 32. Where M&A pays or strays Buy during cold M&A market Buy during hot M&A market Pay with cash Pay with stock High tax benefits to acquirer Low tax benefits to acquirer Judicious leverage Over-lever Earnouts/staged payments Pay in full up front True merger of equals Not a merger of equals Mgt has significant stake Mgt has low or no stake Shareholder-oriented Entrenched management Active investors Passive investors
  • 33.