Here are the key points about RTI Act provisions from the document:- The RTI Act aims to make the functioning of public authorities more transparent and accountable, and enable people to access information from government departments. - It allows citizens to request information from public officials, and mandates timely response and reasons for denial of information.- Some provisions include reasonable fees for application processing, assisting applicants, timeframes for response, and appeal process for information denial.- It is seen as an important tool for transparency and accountability in governance. However, there are also concerns about delays in response and lack of awareness about the Act.- The document discusses some RTI cases and issues faced by applicants in getting information from
The document discusses the Right to Information Act (RTI Act) of India and provides some examples of how it has been used. It notes that the RTI Act was enacted in 2005 to promote transparency and accountability in government functions and empower citizens to access information. It also mentions some criticisms of the act, including that information requests are not always addressed in a timely manner and there can be issues with frivolous or vexatious requests. Overall, the RTI Act aims to empower citizens versus government and promote transparency, but its implementation faces challenges.
Similar to Here are the key points about RTI Act provisions from the document:- The RTI Act aims to make the functioning of public authorities more transparent and accountable, and enable people to access information from government departments. - It allows citizens to request information from public officials, and mandates timely response and reasons for denial of information.- Some provisions include reasonable fees for application processing, assisting applicants, timeframes for response, and appeal process for information denial.- It is seen as an important tool for transparency and accountability in governance. However, there are also concerns about delays in response and lack of awareness about the Act.- The document discusses some RTI cases and issues faced by applicants in getting information from
Similar to Here are the key points about RTI Act provisions from the document:- The RTI Act aims to make the functioning of public authorities more transparent and accountable, and enable people to access information from government departments. - It allows citizens to request information from public officials, and mandates timely response and reasons for denial of information.- Some provisions include reasonable fees for application processing, assisting applicants, timeframes for response, and appeal process for information denial.- It is seen as an important tool for transparency and accountability in governance. However, there are also concerns about delays in response and lack of awareness about the Act.- The document discusses some RTI cases and issues faced by applicants in getting information from (20)
Here are the key points about RTI Act provisions from the document:- The RTI Act aims to make the functioning of public authorities more transparent and accountable, and enable people to access information from government departments. - It allows citizens to request information from public officials, and mandates timely response and reasons for denial of information.- Some provisions include reasonable fees for application processing, assisting applicants, timeframes for response, and appeal process for information denial.- It is seen as an important tool for transparency and accountability in governance. However, there are also concerns about delays in response and lack of awareness about the Act.- The document discusses some RTI cases and issues faced by applicants in getting information from
5. 5
hnhcmhImi nba¯nse {][m
hyhØIÄ
v
2005 sabv 11þv temI-k` ]mÊm-¡nb hnhcmhImi nb-a-¯nv
AtXhÀjw Pq¬ 15þv cmjv{S-]-Xn-bpsS AwKo-Imcw e`n¨p. 2005 HIvtSm-
_À 12v hnh-cm-h-Imi nbaw {]m_-e-y-¯n h¶p. A[nImc
nÀÆlW¯n kpXmcyX Dd¸m¡n
s¡m−v ImeXmakw, AgnaXn, kzP Hm^okÀ : Cu m«n kXy¯npw
]£]mXw F¶nh CÃmXm¡n Imcy oXn¡pw Hcp hnebpanÃmXmtbm
ssZhta
£ahpw kwip²hpamb Hcp `cW {Ia `mcy : F´p ]än ?
amWv Cu nba¯neqsS hn`mh
Hm^okÀ : CXm CXp It−m
sN¿p¶Xv. Hcph³ ssI¡qenbmbn X¶Xv
apgph³ Ifftm«m
“hnhcw” F¶mÂ
Hcp ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänbpsS (s]mXp Øm]§Ä)
ssIhi¯ntem nb{´W¯ntem Dff tcJ-IÄ, {]am-W-§Ä, Ipdn-¸p-
IÄ, kÀ¡p-e-dp-IÄ, D¯-c-hp-IÄ temKv _p¡pIÄv Icm-dp-IÄ, dnt¸mÀ«p-
IÄ, t]¸-dp-IÄ, Cþ-sa-bn-ep-IÄ,A`n-{]m-b-§Ä, D]-tZ-i-§Ä, ]{X-¡p-dn-¸p-
IÄ, t]¸-dp-IÄ, km¼-nfp-IÄ, amXr-I-IÄ XpS§nbhbpw Ce-Ivt{Sm-WnIv
cq]-¯n tiJ-cn-¨n«pÅ Imcy§fpw DÄs¸-Sp-¶p.
Npcp¡n¸dªm Hm^oknse FÃm hkvXp¡fpw hnhcw F¶
nÀhN¯n hcp¶p.
"information" means any material in any form, including records, documents,
memos, e-mails, opinions, advices, press releases, circulars, orders, logbooks, contracts,
reports, papers, samples, models, data material held in any electronic form and information
relating to any private body which can be accessed by a public authority under any other
law for the time being in force;
ChnsS {i²nt¡− Imcyw hnhc§Ä material form Â
Bbncn¡psa¶pffXmWv. Hcp Hm^nkn hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcw
In«nb tNmZyw CXmbncp¶p. "n§Ä Hcp AgnaXn¡mctÃ" AXnv
]n.sF.H. ÂInb adp]Sn "CXpambn _Ôs¸« tcJIsfm¶pw Cu
Hm^okn CÃ". F¶mbncp¶p. ]n.sF.H. AgnaXn¡mcmsW¶Xpambn
_Ôs¸« material form  Dff hnhc§Ä B ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänbnÂ
CÃ F¶XpsIm−mbncn¡mw ]n.sF.H. A{]Imcw adp]Sn sImSp¯Xv.
hnhcw F¶m F´msW¶v CP.No. 514/2007/SIC F¶ hn[nbnÂ
tIcf kwØm hnhcmhImi I½oj³ nÀhNn¨ncn¡p¶Xv
C{]ImcamWv:.
6. 6
"Information meant any material in some form including records and
documents. An unprecipitated indefinite and abstract thing or observation
or a probability cannot be classified as information".
hnhcmhImiw
Cn hnhcmhImiw F´msW¶v tm¡mw
Hcp C´y³ ]ucv C´ybnse GXv hnhcw Xcmw
]_vfnIv AtXmdnänbpsSbpw ssIhi Hcn¡Â Hcp t]meokv tÌjnÂ
¯ntem nb{´W¯ntem DffXpw ta¸ n¶v At]£Is t^mWnÂ
hnfn¨v ]dªphs{X. ""Xm³ Cu
dª “hnhcw” F¶ hn`mK¯n hcp¶ Hm^okn tcn hm hnhcw
Xpamb Imcy§Ä Xmsg sImSp¯ncn¡p¶ Rm³ Xcmw'"
4 hn[¯n e`n¡mpff AhImiamWv
hnhcmhImiw
(i) {]am-W-§-fpw tcJ-I-fpw {]hÀ¯nbpw ]cn-tim-[nbv¡mpff
AhImiw
(ii) -{]-amW-§-fn n¶pw tcJ-Ifn n¶pw Ipdn¸pIÄ FSp-¡p-¶-Xnpw
AhbpsS km£y-s¸-Sp-¯nb tIm¸n-IÄ FSp-¡p-¶Xnpw `mK-
§Äam{Xw FSp-¡p-¶Xnpapff AhImiw
(iii) GXv ]ZmÀ°-¯n-tâbpw km£y-s¸-Sp-¯nb km¼n-fp-IÄ FSp-¡p-¶Xn
pff AhImiw
(iVv) I¼yq-«-dntem AXp-t]m-epÅ aäp kwhn-[m--§fntem CeIvt{SmWnIv
coXnbn tiJ-cn¨v h¨n-«pÅ hnh-c-§Ä UnkvIp-IÄ, ^vtfm¸n-IÄ,
XpS§nbhbn ]IÀ¯ntbm, AsÃ-¦n atä-sX¦nepw CeIv-t{Sm-Wn¡v
cq]-¯ntem, {]nâv Hu«p-IÄ hgntbm FSp¡p¶Xnpapff AhImiw
CXmWv hnhcmhImiw
F¶ tIkn tIcf kw
RP.No. 06/2007/SIC in AP No.76 & 69/2006/SIC
Øm hnhcmhImi I½oj³ hnchcmhImis¯ nÀhNn¨ncn ¡p¶Xv
C{]ImcamWv:
"The RTI Act, 2005 confers right to information on all citizens and it defines right to
information as follows:-
ss{]häv Øm]§Ä Right to information has been amply defined under
ku¯v B{^n¡bnse
C³^Àtaj³ nba{]Imcw Section 2 (j) of the Right to Information Act, 2005. The
ss{]häv Øm]§fpw hnhc§Ä definition is clear that information means and connotes
ÂIm³ _m[yØcmWv. F¶m only an available piece of information available readily
½psS nba¯n ss{]häv
Øm]§fn n¶v hnhc§Ä with the Public Authority. It can not be an opinion/policy
tcn«p e`n¡pIbnÃ. F¶m B yet to be formed. It is not the positive and possible
Øm]§fpsS ta GsX¦nepw decision that can be taken at a later point of time. It is not
]_vfnIv AtXmdnän¡v nba]camb
nb{´Wap−mbncn¡pIbpw an imaginary or a hypothetical answer but it is solid
AhÀ¡v AhnsSbpff hnhc§Ä information available as on the date and time of request."
GsX¦nepw hn[¯nÂ
{]m]yhpamsW¦n B ]_vfnIv
AtXmdnän hgn hnhc§Ä
e`yamIp¶XmWv. ]_vfnIv AtXmdnän (Public authority)
hnhchpw hnhcmhImihpw aÊnem¡n
Ignªm ]ns¶ Adntb−Xv hnhc§Ä FhnsS n¶v e`n¡psa¶XmWv.
hnhc§Ä ssIhiapff Øm]§fmWv ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänIÄ.
20. 20
tm«n^nt¡jpIfpw kÀ¡pedpIfpw
^okv kw_Ôn¨v 2006 tabv 9 v tIcfkÀ¡mÀ ]pds¸Sphn¨
tm«n^nt¡j³ Xmsg sImSp¯ncn¡p¶p.
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION (CO-ORDINATION)DEPT.
NOTIFICATION
No.11259/Cdn. 5/06/GAD, Dated, Thiruvananthapuram, 9th May 2006
S.R.O.385/2006 - In excercise of the powers conferred by subsection (1) and clauses
(b) and (c) of sub-section (2) of section 27 of the Right to information Act,2005 (Central Act
22 of 2005), the Government of Kerala hereby make the following Rules, namely:-
THE KERALA RIGHT TO INFORMATION (REGULATION OF FEE AND COST)
RULES
1. Short title and Commencement.- (1) These rules may be called the Kerala Right to
Information (Regulation of Fee and Cost) Rules, 2006
(2) They shall come into force at once.
2. Definitions.- (1) In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires,-
(a) 'Act' means the Right to Information Act, 2005 (Central Act 22 of 2005)
(b) 'Commission' mean the Kerala State Information Commission constituted
under sub-section (1) of section 15 of the Act;
(c) 'Section' means section of the Act
(2) All other words and expressions used in these Rules but not defined and defined in
the Act shall bave meaning, respectively, assigned to them in the Act.
3. Procedure for seeking information.- (1) A request for obtaining information under
sub-section (1) of section 6 of the Act shall be made to the concerned State Public
Information Officer or through the State Assistant Public Information Officer, as the case
may be, accompanied by an application fee of rupees ten.
(2) The application fee shall be paid in any of the following manners, namely:-
(a) By affixing Court fee Stamp; or
(b) by remitting the amount in the Government Treasury, under
the head of account "0070 other administrative services -60
other services -800 other receipts-42 other items" or
(c) by cash remittance against proper receipt in the office of the
State Public Information Officer/ State Assistant Public
Information Officer, as the case may be; or
(d) by demand draft/banker's cheque/pay order payable to the
State Public Information Officer/ State Assistant Public
Information Officer
(3) An appication under sub-rule(1) amy specify, as far as possible, the particulars
mentioned the Form appended to these rules.
4. Fee for providing information.- (1) For providing information under sub-
section(1) of section 7, the fee shall be charged at the following rates, namely:-
(a) rupees two for each page in 'A4' size paper;
(b) actual charge or cost price of the copy in larger size
paper;
(c) actual cost or price for samples or models, maps,plans
etc., and
(d) for inspection of recordes, no fee for the first hour; and
21. 21
a fee of rupees ten for every subsequently thirty minutes
or fraction thereof.
(2) For providing information under sub-section (5) of section 7, the fee shall be
charged at the following rates, namely.-
(a) for information provided in diskette or floppy or CD or any
other electronic mode, rupees fifty (for each);
(b) for information provided in printed form, rupees two for each
page or the actual price fixed for such publication
(3) The fee specified in sub-rules(1) and(2), shall be collected by way of cash against
proper receipt or by remitting the mount in the Treasury under the head of account "0070
other administrative services -60 other services -800 other receipts-42 other items" or by
demand draft, or bankers cheque or pay order payabale to the concerned State Public
Information Officer.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rules(1) and (2), no fee shall be charged
from the person who are below poverty line as may be determined by the Competent
Authority. Such persons shall produce valid certificate along with the application provind
that they belong to the category of below poverty line.
5. Remittance of fee by way of demand draft etc.- Every demand draft, banker's
cheque or pay order mentioned in Rule 3 or Rule 4 shall be taken in favour of the State
Public Information Officer/ State Assistant Public Information Officer in their official
designation and every demand draft shall the drawn in such a way that the same shall be
encashed at the baranches of any Nationalised Bank/Scheduled Bank situated near the
Officer of the State Public Information Officer/ State Assistant Public Information Officer
APPENDIX
FORM
(See Rule 3)
APPLICATION TO BE SUBMITTED FOR INFORMATION UNDER RIGHT TO
INFORMATION ACT,2005
To
The State Public Information Officer :
(Name of Office/Institution with address)
1. Full name of the applicant
2. Address :
3. Particulars of information required
(Specify the category of subject also) :
4. Year to which the information pertains :
5. Other relevant reference, if any :
Singnature of the Applicant
Place:
Date:
By order of the Governor
E.K. BHARAT BHUSHAN
Principal Secretary to Government
22. 22
EXPLANATORY NOTE
(This does not form part of the notification, but is intended to indicate its general
purport)
In accordance with section 15 of the Right to information Act, 2005, the State
Governemtn have constituted the Kerala State Information Commission with its
Headquarters at Thiruvananthapuram. Section 27 of the empowers the State Government
to make rules prescribing the rate of fee, for providing information the Citizen.
Accordingly, Government have decided to prescribe the rate of fee to be charged from the
Citizens, for providing information under the Act.
This notification is intended to achieve the above object.
hnc§Ä ÂIm³ th−n Poh¡mÀ kz´w neb¡v sNehm¡p¶ XpI
Poh¡mÀ¡v Xncn¨v In«p¶Xpambn _Ôs¸« kÀ¡peÀ
tIcf kÀ¡mÀ
[Imcy (FIvkvs]. _n) hIp¸v
w.61/2008/[ Xncph´]pcw 2008 HIvtSm_À 15
kÀ¡peÀ
hnjbw: hnhcmhImi nbawþ2005þS]SnIÄ kw_Ôn¨v
kqN: 16þ6þ2004 se s^täm Pd sk{I«dnbpsS I¯v
******
hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcw hnhc§Ä e`n¡p¶Xnpff
At]£m^okv, tcJIÄ¡pff ^okv F¶nh {Sjdnbn ASbv¡pIbmWv
sN¿p¶Xv. F¶m tcJIfpsS ]IÀs¸Sp¡p¶Xnpff kuIcyw an¡
Hm^okpIfnepw e`yaÃm¯Xnm ]e kmt¦XnI _p²nap«pIfpw
Ap`hs¸Sp¶Xmbn kqNbnse I¯n ]cmaÀ in¡p¶p. AXnmÂ
tcJIfpsS ]IÀs¸Sp¡p¶Xnpff ^okv {]tXyIw _m¦v A¡u−nÂ
kq£n¡p¶Xnpw A¡mcy¯n pth−nbpff sNehpIÄ {]kvXpX
A¡u−n n¶v sNehgn¡p¶Xnpw D¯chv ]pds¸Sphn¡Wsa¶v
s^täm Pd sk{I«dnbpsS I¯n ]dbp¶p. nÝnX kab¯nIw
hnhc§Ä ÂIm³ Ignbm¯ ]£w bmsXmcp ^okpw CÃmsX
hnhc§Ä ÂIWsa¶v hnhcmhImi nbaw dqÄ 7(6)þÂ
hniZoIcn¡p¶XnmÂ, C¯cw kwKXnIfn ]Ww Xncn¨p
ÂtI−Xps−¶pw BbXv Xncn¨p ÂIp¶Xnv ta¸dª S]Sn
Ffp¸ambncn¡psa¶pw A`n{]mbs¸Sp¶p.
Cu hnjbw kÀ¡mÀ hniZambn ]cntim[n¨v Xmsg ]dbpw{]Imcw
nÀt±i§Ä ]pds¸Sphn¡p¶p.
hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcw s]mXpP§Ä¡v hnhc§Ä
e`yam¡pt¼mgp−mIp¶ A[nI sNehv hln¡p¶Xntebv¡mbn,
sNehpIÄ¡v th−nhcp¶ XpI BXmXv Hm^oknsâ "05þ4" Hm^okv
sNehpIÄ, aän§Ä Asæn "34 aäp sNehpIÄ" F¶
D]ioÀjI¯n n¶pw hln¡mhp¶XmWv. s]mXpP§Ä hnhc
e`yXbv¡mbn HSp¡p¶ XpI 0070þ60þ800þ36þReceipt under Right to Information
Act-2005 (hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcapff hchvþ2005) F¶ ioÀjI¯nepw
ASbv¡mhp¶XmWv.
hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcw At]£IÀ HSp¡nb XpI Xncn¨p
ÂtI− kmlNcy¯n "" 0070þ60þ900þ99 Ingnhv Xncn¨Sbv¡Â ""
ioÀjI¯n Ipdhv hcp¯n ÂImhp¶XmWv.
än. sI. atmPv IpamÀ
sk{I«dn ([Imcy FIvkvs]ân¨À
23. 23
Hcp At]£bnÂXs¶ Iptdtbsd ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänbpambn _Ôs¸«
hnhc§Ä tNmZn¡pIbmsW¦nÂ
Hcp At]£bn Xs¶ [mcmfw ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänbpambn
_Ôs¸« hnhc§Ä tNmZn¡pIbmsW¦n At]£IfpsS ]IÀ¸pIÄ
_Ôs¸« ]_vfnIv AtXmdnänIÄ¡v ssIamdp¶Xnv ]Icw ]_vfnIv
AtXmdnänIfpsS A{Ukv At]£Iv ÂIn B Hm^okpIfnteb¡v
tcn«v At]£ ÂIm³ D]tZin¡mhp¶XmWv F¶v tI{µ kÀ¡mcnsâ
Department of Personnel & Training ]pds¸Sphn¨ Hm^okv
sat½mdm−¯n nÀtZin¨ncn¡p¶p. sat½mdm¯nsâ ]IÀ¸v Xmsg
sImSp¯ncn¡p¶p
No-F-10/2/2008-IR
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, PG and Pensions
Department of Personnel & Training
*****
North Block, New Delhi
Dated September 24, 2010
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: RTI applications received by a public authority regarding information
concerning other public authority/authorities
*****
The undersigned is directed to refer to this Departments's OM of even number
dated 12th June, 2008 on the above noted subject, clause(iii) of para 3 of which
provides that if a person makes an application to the public authority for
information, a part of which is available with that public authority and the rest of
the information is scattered with more than one other public authorities, the Public
Information Officer (PIO) of the public authority receiving the application should
give information relating to it and advise the applicant to make separate
applications to the concerned public authorities for obtaining information from
them. It further provides that if no part of the information is available with the
public authority receiving the application but scattered with more than one other
public authorities, the PIO should inform the applicant that information is not
available with the public authority and that the applicant should make separate
application to the concerned public authorities for obtaining information from
them.
2. The matter has been examined in consultaion with the Chief Information
Commissioner, Central Information Commission and it has been decided to advise
the PIOs that if the details of public authorities who may have this information
sought by the applicant are available with the PIO, such details may also be
provided to the applicant.
3. Contents of the OM may be brought to the notice of all concerned.
(Sd/-)
(K.G.Verma)
Director
Tel.23092158
All the Minister/Departments of the Government of India
25. 25
F´psIm−v F¶ tNmZyw hnhcmhImi¯nsâ ]cn[nbn hcptam
F´psIm−v F¶pff tNmZyw hnhcmhImi nba¯nsâ
]cn[nbn hcp¶nÃ. IqSmsX hniZoIcW§fpw hymJym§fpw
hnhcmhImi nba¯nsâ ]cn[nbn hcp¶nÃ. CXv kw_Ôn¨v tKmh
sslt¡mSXnbpsS hn[nbpsS ASnØm¯n Un.H.]n.Sn ]ps¸Sphn¨
Hm^okv sat½mdm−w Xmsg sImSp¯ncn¡p¶p.
No.1/7/2009-IR
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions
Department of Personnel & Training
North Block, New Delhi
Dated, the 1st June, 2009
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Decision dated 3.4.2008 of the High Court of Bombay at Goa
in Writ Petition No.419 of 2007 in the case of Dr. Celsa Pinto
Vs Goa State Information Commission regarding information
under the Right to Information Act, 2005.
******
The undersigned is directed to say that the High Court of Bombay at Goa in
the above referred case has held on 3.4.2008 that the term “information” as defined
in the Right to Information Act does not include answers to the questions like ‘why’.
The relevant part of the judgement is reproduced below:
“The definition of information cannot include within its fold answers to the
question “why” which would be same thing as asking the reason for a justification for a
particular thing. The public information authorities cannot expect to communicate to
the citizen the reason why a certain thing was done or not done in the sense of
justification because the citizen makes a requisition about information. Justifications
are matter within the domain of adjudicating authorities and cannot properly be
classified as information”.
2. This may be brought to the notice of all concerned.
Sd/-
( K. G. Verma )
Director
Tel: 23092158
hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcapff At]£ Hm^okn e`n¨mÂ
kzoIcnt¡− S]SnIfpsS cXvNpcp¡w
Check List
]_vfnIv C³^Àta-j³ Hm^o-k-dpsS {][m Npa-X-e-IÄ
1. At]-£-I-n n¶v At]£ kzo-I-cn-¡pI.
2. 10 cq]-bpsS ^okv kln-X-amtWm At]£ F¶v ]cn-tim-[n-¡pI.
3. ^okv CsÃ-¦n B hnh-cw At]-£-Is Adnbn¡pI.
4. _n.]n.FÂ. At]-£-I-m-sW-¦n _n.Un.H./ap³kn-¸Â sk{I-«dn ÂInb kÀ«n-^n-
¡äv Dt−m F¶v ]cn-tim-[n-¡pI. G.O. (M.S.)- No-198/2007/LSGD, Dt. 16/08/2007) 2nd Circular
5. tcn«v h¶mWv At]-£n-¡p-¶-sX-¦n At]-£-Iv cioXv ÂIpI.
6. At]£ X]m hgn-bmWv e`n-¨-sX-¦n t]mÌ IhÀ At]-£tbm-sSm¸w ]n³ -
sNbvXv kq£n-¡pI.
7. F.]n.sF.H. CsÃ-¦n ta¸-dª S-]-Sn-IÄ kzo-I-cn-¡m³ nÀtZiw ÂtI-−Xv
]n.sF.H.bpsS IÀ¯-h-y-amWv.
27. 27
3. hnh-c-§Ä Ign-bp-sa-¦n cPnÌÀ X]m aptJ At]-£-Iv ssIam-dpI.
4. tcn«v h¶v ssI¸-äp-I-bm-sW-¦n At]-£-I-n n¶v ssI¸äv cioXn hm§pI.
5. hnh-c-§Ä ÂIp-¶-tXm-sSm-¸-apÅ I¯n A¸o hnh-c-§Ä nÀ_-Ô-ambpw tcJ-
s¸-Sp-¯pI.
6. hnh-c-§Ä ÂIp-t¼mÄ ]n.sF.H.bpsS t]cpw H¸pw D−m-bn-cn-t¡-−-XmWv.
7. ta Imc-y§Ä cPn-Ì-dn tcJ-s¸-Sp-¯pI.
At]-£-I³ tcJ-IÄ ]cn-tim-[n-¡m-mbn h¶mÂ
1. tcJ-IÄ ]cn-tim-[-bv¡v ÂIm-hp-¶-XmtWm F¶v hni-I-ew sNbvXv Xocm-am--
¯n F¯pI.
2. ÂIm-mhp-¶-Xm-sW-¦n 30 Znh-k-¯n-pÅnepÅ Hcp XobXn ap³Iq-dmbn Is−¯n
At]-£-Is Adnbn-¡pI.
3. Sn Xob-Xn-IÄ Adnbn-¨p-sIm−v Cu Xob-Xn-IÄ¡v Ggp Znh-kw aps¼-¦nepw e`n-bv¡-
¯-¡ hn[-¯n At]-£-Iv I¯-b-bv¡pI.
4. ]cn-tim-[--bpsS S-]-Sn-{I-a-§Ä ^okv hnh-c-§Ä F¶nh I¯n D−m-bn-cn-
¡Ww(11259/Cdn.5/06GAD,kÀ¡p-eÀ ImWp-I).
5. At]-£-I³ ]cn-tim[bv¡mbn h¶m tcJ-IÄ At]£Is ImWn-¡p-¶-Xn-mbn
Hcmsf Npa-X-e-s¸-Sp-¯pI.
6. ]cn-tim-[-bv¡v tijw At]-£Isâ H¸v hm§pI.
H¶mw A¸o (sk£³ 19(1))
1. F.]n.sF.H At]-£-I-n n¶v A¸o kzo-I-cn-¡pI.
2. _Ô-s¸« A¸-teäv AtXm-dn-änbv¡v ssIam-dpI.
3. Sn Imc-y-§Ä cPn-Ì-dn tcJ-s¸-Sp-¯pI.
c−mw A¸o (sk-£³ 19(3))
1. F.]n.sF.H. At]-£-I-n n¶v A¸o kzo-I-cn-¡pI.
2. A¸o C³^Àta-j³ I½o-j³ sk{I-«-dn¡v Ab-¨p-sIm-Sp-¡pI.
3. Sn Imc-y-§Ä cPn-Ì-dn tcJ-s¸-Sp-¯pI.
Nne hnjb§fn tIcf kwØm hnhcmhImi
I½ojsâ Xocpam§Ä
tIcf kwØm hnhcmhImi I½oj³ Nne hnjb§fnÂ
]pds¸Sphn¨ hn[nIfpsS {]kà`mK§fmWv Xsg sImSp¯ncn¡p¶Xv.
({_m¡än I½ojsâ D¯chv ¼À sImSp¯ncn¡p¶p.) kam
hnjb§fn At]£ XoÀ¸mt¡−nhcpt¼mÄ I½ojsâ Xocpamw
amÀ¤ZÀinbm¡mhp¶XmWv F¶m FÃmbvt]mgpw I½ojsâ XoÀ¸v
Cu hn[¯n Xs¶bmbncn¡psa¶v {]Xo£n¡mmhnÃ. kmlNcy§fpw
IqSn ]cnKWn¨mbncn¡mw I½ojsâ Xocpamw F¶pw
HmÀ¯ncnt¡−XmWv.
At]£Iv hnhcw ÂImpff A[nImcw F.]n.sF.H. bv¡nÃ
The assistant Public Information Officer has no right to provide the information to
the appellant. (A.P. No. 1081(5)/2008/SIC)
sNehv F{]Imcw ASbv¡Wsa¶v ]n.sF. H.bv¡v nÀtZin¡mw
The fee towards cost of providing the information shall be remitted in the manner in
which it is sought to be remitted by the Public Information Officer.(AP
No.1036(2)2008/SIC)
At]£Isâ nPØnXn Atzjn¨dntb−
The Public Information Officer has no right to investigate or conduct an enquiry as
to the identity of the person. (CP. No. 272(4)/2008/SIC)
28. 28
H¶ntesd t]À tNÀ¶v Hcp At]£ Abbv¡mmhnÃ
the name of the person should invariably be given beneath his signature. Also, the
request could be made only by a single person and not by two persons (CP
No.1270(1)/2009/SIC)
^otkmSp IqSnb At]£t¡ nba{]m_eyapffq
the request could not be considered for want of sufficient application fee. (CP
No.1300(1)/2009/SIC)
HcmÄ¡v th−n asämcmÄ At]£ kaÀ¸n¡mmhnÃ
A personal right could not be delegated to a power of attorney holder.
(AP.No.237(4)/2008/SIC)
Hm^okv `cW S]SnIfn CSs]SmmhnÃ
The Commission cannot enter into the administrative matters of the Public
Authority. The executive has the freedom to decide an administrative matter
according to its administrative convenience. (A.P. No. 268(5)/2008/SIC)
hnhcw saäoccnb cq]¯nepffXmbncn¡Ww
Information is an item of information. And the statute contemplates reference to
single item of information because the words used are singular as "any form and
any material (AP.No.239/2007/SIC)
N«§fpsS hymJymw nba¯nsâ ]cn[nbn hcp¶nÃ
seeking certain clarifications/interpretations etc., of the Rules. This would not come
under the purview of the RTI Act. (AP.No.102/2007/SIC)
30 Znhkw F¶ kab]cn[n Hgnhp Znhkw DÄs¸sSbmWv
The RTI Act does not make any allowance for holidays. (Complaint No
261/2006/SIC)
_n.]n.FÂ. At]£I³ nba{]Imcapff tcJ lmPcm¡Ww
As per the Fee & Cost Rules notified by the State Government, BPL certificate
issued by the Block Development Officer (BDO) concerned for persons residing in
rural areas and Secretary of the Municipality/Corporation concerned for those
residing in Municipal/Corporation areas only was acceptable for claiming
exemption from payment of fee & cost under the RTI Act. (CP No.748(1)/2009/SIC)
]IÀ¸v km£ys¸Sp¯n ÂIWw
Right to Information means right to authenticated information. Section 2(j)(ii)
makes it clear that the informant is entitled for certified copies, In other words,
authenticated copies. (AP.No.222/2007/SIC)
Hm^okv S]Sn{Ias¯ tNmZyw sN¿mmhnÃ
The RTI Act does not provide for evaluation of adequacy of administrative actions
taken by public authorities. (AP No.1041(2)2008/SIC)
29. 29
At]£ XoÀ¸m¡m³ IqSpX kabw tNmZn¡mmhnÃ
there is no provision for seeking more time for disposal of a request under the RTI
Act (CP No.1178(1)/2009/SIC)
h³tXmXn hnhc§Ä Bhiys¸«mÂ
Public authorities were not provided with extra staff for manning RTI requests.
When the information sought had to be culled out from old and voluminous records,
the public authority could have very well asked the Requester to peruse the records
and take down notes/obtain copy of documents after remitting the requisite cost, as
per Section 7(9) of the RTI Act. (CP No.613(1)/2009/SIC)
At]£ e`n¨ kab¯v e`yamb hnhc§Ä ÂInbm aXn. ]n.sF.H.
bpw At]£Ipw X½o XpSÀ¨bmbn Fgp¯pIp¯pIÄ St¯−XnÃ
"there was continuous correspondence between the PIO, Industries
Department and the requestor about the development of the enquiry and, the final
reply was furnished on 2.5.2007. This practice is not contemplated under the Act.
Information as available at the point of time of the request alone need to have been
given. "( AP.No.104/2007/SIC)
At]£Isâ t]cnÃm¯ At]£ ]cnKWn¡mmhnÃ.
The request made by the Secretary of an association without mentioning his name
cannot be considered as an application made by a citizen ( A.P. No.
606(5)/2007/SIC)
Hcp S]Sn ]qÀ¯oIcn¨v hnhcw ÂtI−
""B-h-i-ys¸« hnhc§Ä kw_-Ôn¨ S-]-Sn-IÄ ]qÀ¯nbm¡n hnh-c-§Ä
tiJ-cn¨v ÂtI−XnÃ. e`yamb hnhc§Ä ÂInbm aXn "" (CP
No.452/2007/SIC)
hnhc¯nsâ sNehv tImÀ«v ^okmbn kzoIcn¡mmhnÃ.
"hnhcw ÂIp¶Xnpff sNehv tImÀ«v ^o Ìm¼mbn kzoIcn¡phm³
kwØm kÀ¡mÀ ]pds¸Sphn¨n«pff N«§fn hyhØbnÃm¯XmWv "
(CP.632(2)/2008/SIC)
6(3) {]Imcw At]£ ssIamdn¡gnªm ]n¶oSv AXn³ta dnt¸mÀ«v
Bhiys¸Sm³ AhImianÃ.
"hnhcmhImi nbaw 6(3) hIp¸v {]Imcw Hcp At]£ ssIamäw
sNbvXp e`n¨p Ignªm At]£ XoÀ¸m¡pIsb¶ÃmsX At]£
Ab¨p X¶ ]_vfnIv C³^Àtaj³ Hm^okÀ¡v dnt¸mÀ«v kaÀ¸n¡phm³
_m²yXbnsöv I½nj³ nco£n¨p. " (AP. 04/2008/SIC)
At]£ BcpsS t]cn e`n¨mepw kzoIcn¡Ww
citizen is not expected to understand the official hierarchy of Assistant Public
Information Officers, PIOs and Appellate Authorities. It is for the departmental officers
to guide them (AP.No.132/2007/SIC)
30. 30
H¶mw A¸oen ]pXnb Hcp Bhiyw (At]£bnÂ
Bhiys¸SmXncp¶Xv) D¶bn¡phm³ nÀÆmlanÃ.
" There is no scope for change of requirement and thrusting in additional information in
the appeal and that is outside the scope of the appeal. An appeal is only a continuation of
the original proceedings and not the beginning of a new one. " (AP.No.15/2007/SIC)
Poh¡mcpsS kz¯v hnhcw ÂIWw.
"property statement of employee of a Public Office is not a personal
information of the employee. Employees of a Public Authority are public servants
and the property statements of a public servant cannot be deemed as a personal
information so long as the employee is in the service of the Public Authority. "(
AP.No.15/2007/SIC)
Hcp ]n.sF.H. asämcp ]n.sF.H bv¡v nÀtZiw ÂIcpXv.
asämcp "]»nIv AtXmdn«n' Bb klIcW _m¦ns kw_Ôn¨
hnhc§Ä Bhiys¸«m B At]£ klIcW_m¦nv
ssIamdpIbÃmsX, hnhc§Ä ÂIm³ nÀt±in¨psIm−v D¯chp
]pds¸Sphn¡m³ klIcWkwLw cPnkv{SmÀ Hm^oknse ]»nIv
C³^Àtaj³ Hm^okÀ¡v nÀÆmlanÃ. (2386/SIC/2006 22/11/2006)
B[mc¯nsâ ]IÀ¸v _n.]n.FÂ.Imc³ kuPyambn
Bhiys¸«m ÂtI−Xpt−m
"The simple differentiation between exemption of fee under the RTI Act for persons
claiming BPL status was that for information under the RTI Act and for information that
emanates as a result of the RTI Act, no fee, is to be realised. But if a departmental statute
prescribes certain fee for providing information like the copy of the document from the Sub
Registrar Office or copy of the BTR register etc., that departmental fee will have to be
remitted by the appellant. He could not claim exemption on that ground"
.(AP.No.600(4)/2008/SIC)
GENERAL AWARENESS
Quasi Judicial Function
oXnymbt¡mSXnIfnse hnNmcWbpsS ]qÀ® kz`mhw Csænepw GXm−v
AXpt]mse ymbbpàamb S]Sn{Ia§fpkcn¨v XocpamsaSpt¡−XnmWv
Quasi Judicial function F¶p ]dbp¶Xv. hnhcmhImi nba{]Imcw Xocpam§Ä
FSp¡pt¼mÄ H¶mw A¸eäv AtXmdnän Quasi Judicial coXnbn {]hÀ¯n¡Ww
hnthNm[nImcw (Discretion Power)
Hcp Imcyw sN¿p¶Xntm AYhm sN¿mXncn¡p¶Xntm nch[n
amÀ¤§fpffXn GsX¦nepsam¶v sXcsªSp¡p¶Xnpff A[nImcs¯bmWv
hnthNm[nImcw (Discretion Power) F¶p ]dbp¶Xv. tXm¶nba«nÂ
{]hÀ¯n¡mpff A[nImcaà CXv. hnthNm[nImcw Hcp DtZymKØnÂ
n£n]vXamIp¶Xv nbaw aqeamWv. hnhcmhIminbaw S¸nem¡p¶bhkc¯nÂ
]n.sF.H.¡v hnthNm[nImcw {]tbmKn¡mhp¶XmWv. F¶m A¸o kab¯v CXv
ymboIcn¡phm³ IgnbWw.
BIvSpw dqfqw
]mÀesasâm nbak`Itfm BWv BIvSv nÀ½n¡p¶X.v BIvSv
nÀ½n¡pt¼mÄ AXnse hyhØIÄ {]mtbmKnI Xe¯n S¸m¡p¶Xnpff
kuIcy¯nmbn dqÄ (N«§Ä) D−m¡mpff nÀtZiw _Ôs¸« A[nImcnIÄ¡v