SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 4
Descargar para leer sin conexión
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
                                                www.emeraldinsight.com/0888-045X.htm




BL
24,2                                 Selecting foreign language books
                                     donated by Asia Foundation and
                                       Asian-US Bridge Foundation
96
                                                                                   Juan Wang
                                         Beijing Normal University, Zhuhai Campus, Zhuhai, Guangdong, China
Received November 2010
Accepted June 2011

                                     Abstract
                                     Purpose – Many Chinese libraries have limited budget to buy foreign language books. The purpose
                                     of this paper is to introduce an available and cheaper suggestion for the budgets of small libraries’
                                     foreign language books acquisition.
                                     Design/methodology/approach – This paper discusses the benefits of selecting donated books
                                     and takes some small libraries in China as examples to conduct the case study.
                                     Findings – Advantages of selecting donated books include: quick arrival, lower cost, and a variety of
                                     title selections. Disadvantages are: no book list, long distance, unsatisfied selection.
                                     Practical implications – Donated books in one’s purchasing program can substantially expand the
                                     range and amount of materials that libraries are able to collect.
                                     Originality/value – This paper will be useful to any library facing budget cuts as well as looking for
                                     ways to continually provide a wide variety of library materials.
                                     Keywords Libraries, Donated books, China, Asia Foundation, Asian-US Bridge Foundation
                                     Paper type Case study


                                     Due to the increasingly higher cost of foreign books, the budget of foreign books
                                     acquisition in most libraries has been tighter and tighter. It is high time to figure out
                                     the cheaper way of enhancing one’s purchasing power: getting foreign language books
                                     from which donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation.

                                     Introduction of Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation
                                     The Asia Foundation is a non-profit, non-governmental organization committed to the
                                     development of a peaceful, prosperous, just, and open Asia-Pacific region. In 2009, the
                                     Foundation provided more than $86 million in program support and distributed nearly
                                     one million books and journals valued at over $43 million (http://asiafoundation.org).
                                     The Asian-US Bridge Foundation is an international nonprofit organization which
                                     supports education and research in developing countries in Asia. The Foundation has
                                     sent more than 2 million books and journals to China and 500,000 to Southeast Asia. In
                                     China, the Ministry of Education coordinates distributions through three centers to
                                     more than 450 schools. Librarians and faculty from the schools visit the centers to
                                     select materials (www.bridge.org).
The Bottom Line: Managing Library
Finances
Vol. 24 No. 2, 2011
pp. 96-99                            The reasons to make use of donated books
q Emerald Group Publishing Limited
0888-045X
                                     There are several reasons to put donated books into the library’s acquisition plan,
DOI 10.1108/08880451111169115        especially for our library, which range from cost, availability, to course requirements.
Limited budget                                                                               Selecting foreign
Getting donated books can stretch one’s budget for acquisition of foreign books. First,       language books
our college is a small private college in China. The budget of library is very limited and
thus a tiny portion of budget remained for acquisition of foreign books by most
expenditure of money on Chinese books and databases. According to the statistics, the
budget of public university’s library is always about 10 million. While our library’
budget is 4 million, and that of foreign language books merely accounts for eight                         97
percent – only 0.3 million. It is really a tight budget for any library.

Arriving library quickly
The speed of traditional purchasing approach is very slow. Most Chinese libraries
purchase foreign language books by import and export corporation, e.g. GNPIEC,
CEPIEC. For example, our library bids for acquisition of foreign language books at
every beginning of the school year. After the processes of bidding off, getting book list
and books selection, the selected books are unable to the reach of the library until six
months later. As for the donated books, you can select them on the spot. One or two
weeks the selected books may come into circulation.

There is the cheapest way to fill in the foreign language collection gaps
Generally speaking, the price of original foreign language copy is more than 100RMB
even in online shop, which costs as twice as Chinese copy’s. The average price of
Chinese copy is ranges from 30RMB to 50RMB depending on the subjects with the
increasingly higher price. But the books donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US
Bridge Foundation are free and what you just need to do is pay for the delivering. In
this case, our library only needs to pay for the freight – 12RMB. Those libraries near
the center spend even less. So, this is the cheapest way.

Contents take priority over condition
There are different kinds of donated books, such as college, graduate and professional
level books, journals and other forms of information in all fields (but especially in
science, engineering, art, and literature), both used and new. Contents take priority over
conditions. Used books are as desirable as new ones if the information of contents is
current and their condition is presentable.

Some books is unavailable
While tens of thousands of books are published in China each year, there will always
be some subjects that are not written about very often. The subject may be obscure, out
of fashion, or simply never well covered. Some subjects of donated books may be one’s
best bet. For example, the foreign language classic literature (1996 version) is not
available for Faculty of Foreign Language in our college, but they find it among
donated books.

Disadvantages
There are so many benefits of using donated books, although there are still some
disadvantages.
BL     No book list
24,2   Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation are both international nonprofit
       organizations which supports education and research in developing countries in Asia.
       They just delivered the donated books to some centers in China. These centers are
       always university’s libraries which have not enough staff to make book lists. This is
       inconvenient for every library which wants to select the donated books.
98
       Centers of donated books are distance
       In China, almost all of the donated books are distributed through three centers which
       are libraries of Ocean University of China, Dalian Technology University and Tongji
       University. Our library is located in Zhuhai city Guangdong province. The nearest
       center – library of Tongji University is almost 2,000 km away from Zhuhai. Therefore,
       our librarians and faculty have to visit the centers to select materials just once each
       semester.

       Unsatisfied book selection
       Some of book selection is not satisfied. First reason may be time limited. Our library
       often needs to select 500 or 600 kinds of books in two or three days. Secondly, some
       staff is not good at English, especially in the specialized field. Thirdly, attitude may be
       according to unsatisfied book selection.

       How to get the donated books
       Some libraries have direct contact with foreign libraries. As a result, they can obtain
       the donated books easily. Most of them have no such solutions, so the Chinese center of
       Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation must be an easier and available
       choice. And the center is open to any library in China. When one want to get the
       donated books, just have to find a phone number of nearest center from internet, or
       other libraries. Then you can call the center for an appointment of selecting donated
       books. Next is easy, just by packing your luggage and going to the center by a train or
       by airplane. You can select anything you want in the book stacks. In addition to, you
       can login in the official websites of Foundations which are http://asiafoundation.org/
       and http://www.bridge.org (www.google.com.hk) (Ming, 2010).

       Conclusion
       International book donation in China has been for 20 years which has brought
       important contributions for the development of higher education in China. According
       to statistics, after 1995 the average amount received from Asian-US Bridge Foundation
       is above 120,000 copies, and the biggest amount is 180,000 copies, the center of Ocean
       University of China (www.google.com.hk). More and more libraries benefit from the
       book donation, especially for small or private libraries such as our library. It shows
       that whole foreign language collection of some libraries is totally composed of donated
       books, such as Tianjin Polytechnic University, Wuhan University of Technology and
       Weifang Medical College (Ming, 2010). In a word, the practice of selecting donated
       books produces so many benefits, which really can stretch one’s budget of foreign
       language books by paying a little freight. Just do it.
Reference                                                                                 Selecting foreign
Ming, Z. (2010), “Management of books donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge       language books
     Foundation”, Library Construction, No. 3, pp. 22-4.

Further reading
Staley, L. and Palo, E. (2010), “Extend one’s budget: buy used books”, The Bottom Line:
      Managing Library Finances, Vol. 23 No. 3, pp. 116-21.                                            99

Corresponding author
Juan Wang can be contacted at: winnieee@126.com




To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com
Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a 2.selecting foreign

Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?Tony Horava
 
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 Webinar
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 WebinarKnowledge Unlatched Round 2 Webinar
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 WebinarKnowledge Unlatched
 
Think globally, service locally support asu’s international students and fa...
Think globally, service locally  support asu’s international  students and fa...Think globally, service locally  support asu’s international  students and fa...
Think globally, service locally support asu’s international students and fa...Virginia Pannabecker
 
Library, Information and Society
Library, Information and SocietyLibrary, Information and Society
Library, Information and SocietySundar B N
 
Evaluating learning resources
Evaluating learning resourcesEvaluating learning resources
Evaluating learning resourcesElvira Lapuz
 
Online assignment
Online assignmentOnline assignment
Online assignment9995217078
 
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...S. L. Faisal
 
Using authentic literature
Using authentic literatureUsing authentic literature
Using authentic literatureIrina K
 
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?Charleston Conference
 
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation (327663795) importance of school library and organisation
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation ranjithkumarbs
 
Book selection policy in libraries for readers.pptx
Book selection policy in libraries  for readers.pptxBook selection policy in libraries  for readers.pptx
Book selection policy in libraries for readers.pptxradhikajoship48
 
book selection policy NOU DLIM Book .pptx
book selection policy  NOU DLIM Book  .pptxbook selection policy  NOU DLIM Book  .pptx
book selection policy NOU DLIM Book .pptxradhikajoship48
 
Collection development policy and procedures
Collection development policy and proceduresCollection development policy and procedures
Collection development policy and procedureswholkesvig
 
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...Lucy Montgomery
 
Building a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryBuilding a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryddawer
 
Online Assignment
Online AssignmentOnline Assignment
Online AssignmentArun Murali
 

Similar a 2.selecting foreign (20)

Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or Solution?
 
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 Webinar
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 WebinarKnowledge Unlatched Round 2 Webinar
Knowledge Unlatched Round 2 Webinar
 
A review on collection management
A review on collection managementA review on collection management
A review on collection management
 
Think globally, service locally support asu’s international students and fa...
Think globally, service locally  support asu’s international  students and fa...Think globally, service locally  support asu’s international  students and fa...
Think globally, service locally support asu’s international students and fa...
 
Library, Information and Society
Library, Information and SocietyLibrary, Information and Society
Library, Information and Society
 
Evaluating learning resources
Evaluating learning resourcesEvaluating learning resources
Evaluating learning resources
 
Online assignment
Online assignmentOnline assignment
Online assignment
 
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...
Library as a Classroom Activity in Primary Education: Activities for Primary ...
 
Using authentic literature
Using authentic literatureUsing authentic literature
Using authentic literature
 
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?
Open Access Author Funds: A Problem or a Solution?
 
Assignment anuja
Assignment anujaAssignment anuja
Assignment anuja
 
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation (327663795) importance of school library and organisation
(327663795) importance of school library and organisation
 
Assignment (1)aswathy
Assignment (1)aswathyAssignment (1)aswathy
Assignment (1)aswathy
 
Book selection policy in libraries for readers.pptx
Book selection policy in libraries  for readers.pptxBook selection policy in libraries  for readers.pptx
Book selection policy in libraries for readers.pptx
 
book selection policy NOU DLIM Book .pptx
book selection policy  NOU DLIM Book  .pptxbook selection policy  NOU DLIM Book  .pptx
book selection policy NOU DLIM Book .pptx
 
Assignment anuja
Assignment anujaAssignment anuja
Assignment anuja
 
Collection development policy and procedures
Collection development policy and proceduresCollection development policy and procedures
Collection development policy and procedures
 
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...
Open and Networked Opportunities for Scholarly Books: Oxford Center for Socio...
 
Building a classroom library
Building a classroom libraryBuilding a classroom library
Building a classroom library
 
Online Assignment
Online AssignmentOnline Assignment
Online Assignment
 

Más de libfsb

Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controlslibfsb
 
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controlslibfsb
 
Foodbeverage
FoodbeverageFoodbeverage
Foodbeveragelibfsb
 
Food and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operationsFood and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operationslibfsb
 
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operatorsFood safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operatorslibfsb
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage booklibfsb
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage booklibfsb
 
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.editionIntroduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.editionlibfsb
 
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd editionHotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd editionlibfsb
 
4.the singularity
4.the singularity4.the singularity
4.the singularitylibfsb
 
3.great profits
3.great profits3.great profits
3.great profitslibfsb
 
2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all2.pleasing all
2.pleasing alllibfsb
 
1.the recession,
1.the recession,1.the recession,
1.the recession,libfsb
 
9.greener library
9.greener library9.greener library
9.greener librarylibfsb
 
8.moving on
8.moving on 8.moving on
8.moving on libfsb
 
7.let them
7.let them7.let them
7.let themlibfsb
 
6.dealing with
6.dealing with6.dealing with
6.dealing withlibfsb
 
5.the management
5.the management5.the management
5.the managementlibfsb
 
4.making the
4.making the4.making the
4.making thelibfsb
 
2.free electronic
2.free electronic2.free electronic
2.free electroniclibfsb
 

Más de libfsb (20)

Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
 
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
Principles of food  beverage  and labor cost controlsPrinciples of food  beverage  and labor cost controls
Principles of food beverage and labor cost controls
 
Foodbeverage
FoodbeverageFoodbeverage
Foodbeverage
 
Food and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operationsFood and beverage_operations
Food and beverage_operations
 
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operatorsFood safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
Food safety basics a reference guide for foodservice operators
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
 
The bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage bookThe bar & beverage book
The bar & beverage book
 
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.editionIntroduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
Introduction.to.management.in.the.hospitality.industry.10th.edition
 
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd editionHotel front office management 3rd edition
Hotel front office management 3rd edition
 
4.the singularity
4.the singularity4.the singularity
4.the singularity
 
3.great profits
3.great profits3.great profits
3.great profits
 
2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all2.pleasing all
2.pleasing all
 
1.the recession,
1.the recession,1.the recession,
1.the recession,
 
9.greener library
9.greener library9.greener library
9.greener library
 
8.moving on
8.moving on 8.moving on
8.moving on
 
7.let them
7.let them7.let them
7.let them
 
6.dealing with
6.dealing with6.dealing with
6.dealing with
 
5.the management
5.the management5.the management
5.the management
 
4.making the
4.making the4.making the
4.making the
 
2.free electronic
2.free electronic2.free electronic
2.free electronic
 

2.selecting foreign

  • 1. The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/0888-045X.htm BL 24,2 Selecting foreign language books donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation 96 Juan Wang Beijing Normal University, Zhuhai Campus, Zhuhai, Guangdong, China Received November 2010 Accepted June 2011 Abstract Purpose – Many Chinese libraries have limited budget to buy foreign language books. The purpose of this paper is to introduce an available and cheaper suggestion for the budgets of small libraries’ foreign language books acquisition. Design/methodology/approach – This paper discusses the benefits of selecting donated books and takes some small libraries in China as examples to conduct the case study. Findings – Advantages of selecting donated books include: quick arrival, lower cost, and a variety of title selections. Disadvantages are: no book list, long distance, unsatisfied selection. Practical implications – Donated books in one’s purchasing program can substantially expand the range and amount of materials that libraries are able to collect. Originality/value – This paper will be useful to any library facing budget cuts as well as looking for ways to continually provide a wide variety of library materials. Keywords Libraries, Donated books, China, Asia Foundation, Asian-US Bridge Foundation Paper type Case study Due to the increasingly higher cost of foreign books, the budget of foreign books acquisition in most libraries has been tighter and tighter. It is high time to figure out the cheaper way of enhancing one’s purchasing power: getting foreign language books from which donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation. Introduction of Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation The Asia Foundation is a non-profit, non-governmental organization committed to the development of a peaceful, prosperous, just, and open Asia-Pacific region. In 2009, the Foundation provided more than $86 million in program support and distributed nearly one million books and journals valued at over $43 million (http://asiafoundation.org). The Asian-US Bridge Foundation is an international nonprofit organization which supports education and research in developing countries in Asia. The Foundation has sent more than 2 million books and journals to China and 500,000 to Southeast Asia. In China, the Ministry of Education coordinates distributions through three centers to more than 450 schools. Librarians and faculty from the schools visit the centers to select materials (www.bridge.org). The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances Vol. 24 No. 2, 2011 pp. 96-99 The reasons to make use of donated books q Emerald Group Publishing Limited 0888-045X There are several reasons to put donated books into the library’s acquisition plan, DOI 10.1108/08880451111169115 especially for our library, which range from cost, availability, to course requirements.
  • 2. Limited budget Selecting foreign Getting donated books can stretch one’s budget for acquisition of foreign books. First, language books our college is a small private college in China. The budget of library is very limited and thus a tiny portion of budget remained for acquisition of foreign books by most expenditure of money on Chinese books and databases. According to the statistics, the budget of public university’s library is always about 10 million. While our library’ budget is 4 million, and that of foreign language books merely accounts for eight 97 percent – only 0.3 million. It is really a tight budget for any library. Arriving library quickly The speed of traditional purchasing approach is very slow. Most Chinese libraries purchase foreign language books by import and export corporation, e.g. GNPIEC, CEPIEC. For example, our library bids for acquisition of foreign language books at every beginning of the school year. After the processes of bidding off, getting book list and books selection, the selected books are unable to the reach of the library until six months later. As for the donated books, you can select them on the spot. One or two weeks the selected books may come into circulation. There is the cheapest way to fill in the foreign language collection gaps Generally speaking, the price of original foreign language copy is more than 100RMB even in online shop, which costs as twice as Chinese copy’s. The average price of Chinese copy is ranges from 30RMB to 50RMB depending on the subjects with the increasingly higher price. But the books donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation are free and what you just need to do is pay for the delivering. In this case, our library only needs to pay for the freight – 12RMB. Those libraries near the center spend even less. So, this is the cheapest way. Contents take priority over condition There are different kinds of donated books, such as college, graduate and professional level books, journals and other forms of information in all fields (but especially in science, engineering, art, and literature), both used and new. Contents take priority over conditions. Used books are as desirable as new ones if the information of contents is current and their condition is presentable. Some books is unavailable While tens of thousands of books are published in China each year, there will always be some subjects that are not written about very often. The subject may be obscure, out of fashion, or simply never well covered. Some subjects of donated books may be one’s best bet. For example, the foreign language classic literature (1996 version) is not available for Faculty of Foreign Language in our college, but they find it among donated books. Disadvantages There are so many benefits of using donated books, although there are still some disadvantages.
  • 3. BL No book list 24,2 Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation are both international nonprofit organizations which supports education and research in developing countries in Asia. They just delivered the donated books to some centers in China. These centers are always university’s libraries which have not enough staff to make book lists. This is inconvenient for every library which wants to select the donated books. 98 Centers of donated books are distance In China, almost all of the donated books are distributed through three centers which are libraries of Ocean University of China, Dalian Technology University and Tongji University. Our library is located in Zhuhai city Guangdong province. The nearest center – library of Tongji University is almost 2,000 km away from Zhuhai. Therefore, our librarians and faculty have to visit the centers to select materials just once each semester. Unsatisfied book selection Some of book selection is not satisfied. First reason may be time limited. Our library often needs to select 500 or 600 kinds of books in two or three days. Secondly, some staff is not good at English, especially in the specialized field. Thirdly, attitude may be according to unsatisfied book selection. How to get the donated books Some libraries have direct contact with foreign libraries. As a result, they can obtain the donated books easily. Most of them have no such solutions, so the Chinese center of Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge Foundation must be an easier and available choice. And the center is open to any library in China. When one want to get the donated books, just have to find a phone number of nearest center from internet, or other libraries. Then you can call the center for an appointment of selecting donated books. Next is easy, just by packing your luggage and going to the center by a train or by airplane. You can select anything you want in the book stacks. In addition to, you can login in the official websites of Foundations which are http://asiafoundation.org/ and http://www.bridge.org (www.google.com.hk) (Ming, 2010). Conclusion International book donation in China has been for 20 years which has brought important contributions for the development of higher education in China. According to statistics, after 1995 the average amount received from Asian-US Bridge Foundation is above 120,000 copies, and the biggest amount is 180,000 copies, the center of Ocean University of China (www.google.com.hk). More and more libraries benefit from the book donation, especially for small or private libraries such as our library. It shows that whole foreign language collection of some libraries is totally composed of donated books, such as Tianjin Polytechnic University, Wuhan University of Technology and Weifang Medical College (Ming, 2010). In a word, the practice of selecting donated books produces so many benefits, which really can stretch one’s budget of foreign language books by paying a little freight. Just do it.
  • 4. Reference Selecting foreign Ming, Z. (2010), “Management of books donated by Asia Foundation and Asian-US Bridge language books Foundation”, Library Construction, No. 3, pp. 22-4. Further reading Staley, L. and Palo, E. (2010), “Extend one’s budget: buy used books”, The Bottom Line: Managing Library Finances, Vol. 23 No. 3, pp. 116-21. 99 Corresponding author Juan Wang can be contacted at: winnieee@126.com To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints