SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 18
Descargar para leer sin conexión
CONTENTS
                                       World Section
• Will the Chinese Yuan be the next reserve currency?         3

     Special Feature : Financial Inclusion
• Financial Inclusion:Congealing Altruism & Profitability to   5
  mitigate financial disparity
• Using Microfinance for social upliftment through Financial
  Inclusion.                                                  7

                                      Stock Analysis
• Equity Research Report::Nahar Spinning Mills
                                                              9

                                            Economics
• Analysis of Private Equity Investments in India in Second   11
  half of 2010 and Beyond.                                    13
• Key Trends & Issues in the Global Banking Sector.
• Why Disinvestment For Indian Economy                        15
• The Demise of the Celtic Tiger                              17


2

The Senior Analyst
In the past few       WILL THE CHINESE YUAN BE THE NEXT
                       RESERVE CURRENCY?
      months we
 have seen that        In the past few months we have seen that there has been a lot of speculation and hype about
                       the Chinese Renmimbi (RMB) or the Yuan becoming the next reserve currency. In this article

 there has been        we will focus on the various factors that can help and also the factors that are against the
                       speculation regarding the Yuan, considering the global dynamics of politics and trade.

            a lot of   Let us first understand what exactly is meant by a reserve currency. A reserve currency is one
                       that forms significant part of foreign exchange reserves of governments and institutions which

     speculation       enables a country to meet international debt obligations and to influence their domestic
                       exchange rate.

and hype about         Factors that influence the use of a currency for reserves are as follows:
                       •
The size of the economy
     the Chinese       •
 The importance of the economy in international trade
                       •
The openness of the financial markets
       Renmimbi        •
 The convertibility of the currency
                       •
 Use of the currency as currency peg
    (RMB) or the       •
 Macroeconomic policies, as it influences the domestic environment
                       A Brief on China’s past and current status of economy
Yuan becoming          China’s success story is not new. Till the end of 15th century, China was the leader in
                       technology & had the highest per-capita GDP on the planet. Europe overtook China in per
          the next     capita GDP around 1500 but China remained the world’s biggest economy until well in the

           reserve     19th century. In fact in 1820, the middle kingdom accounted for one third of World’s
                       economy. However the tide turned against China & by 1950 it suffered with one of the lowest

     currency. In      per capita GDP in the World and accounted for less than 5% of world GDP. Since 1980s
                       growth took off again, owing to demographic dividend, export driven growth, cheap &

  this article we      abundant labour availability coupled with potential to become the world’s largest consumer
                       market. With help of State initiatives, China’s fiscal revenues have increased 30 times over the

    will focus on      past 20 years. Having maintained a phenomenal GDP growth rate of 9.5% for decades, China
                       is now the World’s second largest economy.
      the various      Problems with the US dollar as global reserve currency
                       Currently US Dollar is the most widely held reserve currency as two thirds of the foreign
     factors that      reserve of nations is in US Dollar terms. But things are no longer as smooth for the US Dollar
                       as it used to be. There has been a steady decline in the dollar reserve holding percentage by
    can help and       various countries. The global economic crisis of 2008 leading to rising US debt (The U.S.’s
                       ratio of total debt to GDP is likely to exceed 90% this year) which keeps US dependent on
also the factors       foreign financing and the increasing influence of China as a global power along with demand
                       of countries like Russia for a new reserve currency have brought in the possibility of the
that are against       Chinese Yuan as the next reserve currency. But being the most widely accepted reserve

the speculation
                       currency is no easy job and there are various factors at play which go for and against the
                       Yuan. Inspite of the above mentioned facts, one important reason the US dollar remains the

   regarding the       reserve currency is that the U.S. treasury market is the most liquid market which allows
                       central banks to intervene in foreign exchange markets in order to smooth currency

             Yuan,     fluctuations.


considering the
             global
     dynamics of
     politics and
             trade.

3

The Senior Analyst
Now let us look at the factors which might prompt the Chinese government to work towards making the Renmimbi the next reserve
currency. The most important reason is overwhelming dependence of the Chinese on the US dollar. It is estimated that Beijing holds
about $2 (2.6) trillion of dollar assets mainly accumulated through purchase of US Treasuries and through exports to the USA. The USA
has been incurring rising budget deficits in recent years. This is major concern for the Chinese government as a weakening dollar could
seriously dent the Chinese reserves.
Movement towards global reserve currency
There have been many steps taken by the Chinese government aimed at strengthening the cause of Yuan and improving its visibility.
Recently Beijing carried out a series of currency swaps with central banks of countries like Argentina, Hong Kong, Malaysia and South
Korea. This currency swap will remove the need for using the Dollar when it comes to trade with these countries. It also carried out a
trade deal with Brazil valued at $95 billion in two other currencies other than the Dollar. The Chinese government is even thinking of
issuing bonds and loans to trading companies in Yuan rather than in Dollar. In fact banks like HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank are said to
have agreed to issuing bonds in Yuan. China has recently allowed Yuan to trade off shore in Hong Kong. Though the Yuan still remains a
foreign currency market for Hong Kong and the local currency is still the Hong Kong dollar, but the offshore financial centre is being used
as a laboratory to internationalize the Chinese currency.
Problems that needs to be tackled
In spite of the steps taken by the Chinese government there are various factors which pose practical and huge challenges to the Yuan
being the next Reserve Currency. The main challenge is that the dollar is too entrenched in the international currency market. However
the bigger issue is making the Yuan convertible with its value being determined by market conditions, governments and companies
around the world who would be allowed to freely trade, buy and sell the currency. Given the authoritarian nature of the Chinese
government, lowering of these financial trade barriers and allowing foreign trade access to the Chinese securities market seems like a
remote possibility. The absence of a large market for Yuan bonds is also seen as a hindrance. Currently only the Chinese Banks and the
Asian Development bank sell Yuan dominated bonds. According to some experts it is numerically impossible for the Yuan to become the
reserve currency as then China would have to run a large current account deficit so that the governments and the institutions which trade
in Yuan would get a chance to accumulate it. But currently China has a huge current account surplus which does not give foreigners to
accumulate the Yuan.
Things that China can do to favour its case
If the Chinese government does decide to make the Yuan as the next reserve currency, the expected time line is expected to be around
10 to 15 years. It has to push through the reforms before Yuan can be allowed to float freely against the dollar. It can easily take China
around 5 to 10 years to bring about a change through its land reforms, reforms in the energy sector, social welfare. China would have to
gradually make the Yuan convertible on the capital account. It needs a more liquid foreign exchange market, as the US treasury market is
currently the most liquid market. The bond markets and banking system needs to be more developed and there has to be proper
monitoring of cross-border capital flows. The importance of having functioning capital markets cannot be understated as investors and
Central Banks buying Yuan would not want to simply invest in paper currency and instead would want stocks and bonds that trade
transparently
Alternatives to the Yuan
In this context there are various other alternatives which are possible. One such possibility is establishing a multi currency system and the
use of Special Drawing Rights (SDR) which is based on a basket of currencies. The Euro is also gaining prominence and the developing
economies are also playing an increasingly dominant role in world economic order.
Whether the world order changes to accept Yuan or any other currency like Euro or a mixed bag of currency as the next reserve currency
is for all of us to see. The fact remains that hold of US dollar as the reserve currency is slipping and China on its part is using its
economic might through trade exports to penetrate world market to garner support for the Yuan as the next global reserve currency.
-Ankit Agarwal & Shachi Prakash(FMS)



                                                                                                      Whether the world
                                                                                                      order changes to
                                                                                                      accept Yuan or any
                                                                                                      other currency like
                                                                                                      Euro or a mixed bag
                                                                                                      of currency as the
                                                                                                      next reserve currency
                                                                                                      is for all of us to see.



4

The Senior Analyst
INTRODUCTION: UNDERSTANDING
                          THE NEED
                          Financial inclusion is delivery of call microfinance; a method of injecting
                          banking services at an affordable cost capital into highly industrious groups
                          to the vast sections of disadvantaged of people in villages across the
                          and low income groups. This inclusion     developing world. It was a perfect
                          forms the basis of economic               example where profitability and
                          opportunity. It enables the poor to       altruism went hand in hand leading to
                          build savings, make investments and       financial inclusion. Grameen Bank
                          insure themselves against income          made a profit of $ 680,000 in 2007
                          shocks thereby entailing progress of      while providing access to credit to
                          the nation. Yet the statistics on         millions of underprivileged
                          financial ‘exclusion' in India are         Bangladeshi’s. The bank expects to
                          disheartening. Out of the 600,000         loan $1.4 billion in 2010 and continues
                          habitations in the country, only about    to challenge conventional banking
                          30,000, or just 5 per cent, have a        wisdom by banking the "unbankable".
                          commercial bank branch. Just about        2> The success story of Dharavi, a
                          40 per cent of the population across      bustling industrial-slum in Mumbai is
                          the country has bank accounts, and        another heartening example where
                          this ratio is much lower in the north-    Financial inclusion proved to be a
                          east of the country.                      viable business proposition. Hindu
                                                                    Business line reports that Dharavi
                                                                    exports goods worth $500-650 million
                          ALTRUISM &
                                                                    every year. Initially though, Dharavi,
                          PROFITABILITY CAN                         being situated right in the heart of
                          CO-EXIST                                 Mumbai, the most banked city in the
                                                                   country, did not have a commercial
                          Financial inclusion is a potentially bank branch for a long time. The first
                          viable business proposition; it is the commercial bank branch was opened
                          key driver for social change and can in February 2007. In just three years,
                          greatly ameliorate the imbalances in the bank registered business in excess
                          society. Envisioning a plan for financial of Rs 44 crore. Today, there are nine
                          inclusion which is profitable while ATMs in Dharavi, all of them being
                          concurrently being altruistic can lead actively used. This proved that money
                          to rapid growth both in urban and rural management is a well-understood part
                          areas, thereby creating a country that    of everyday life of the poor, and
                          witnesses all-round development.          therefore a viable business proposition.
                          1> One such format was established        From the above successful models of
                          by Muhammad Yunus. He started off in      financial inclusion, it can be stated that
                          the village of Jobra with a belief that   banking the unbanked can indeed be a
                          financial credit is “A Human Right” and win-win opportunity. However, such
                          created a whole system that we now incidences of profitability cum altruistic




         Congealing
           Altruism &     Financial
                          Inclusion
       Profitability to
    mitigate financial
             disparity
5

The Senior Analyst
ALTRUISM &
                                                                                     The primary objective of any business is to make
                                                                                     profits. A failure to achieve this goal makes an
                                                                                     organization unsustainable, thereby all other goals

       PROFITABILITY ARE                                                             redundant. Financial inclusion from this perspective
                                                                                     is a secondary objective. Although there have been

             A MISMATCH
                                                                                     instances where altruism and profitability have gone
                                                                                     hand in hand, there is no denying the fact that
                                                                                     tailoring your organizational goals to meet the goals of
                                                                                     social upliftment can introduce a significant amount of
risk to your returns.
     The second aspect to be considered is the relevance of Micro Finance Institutions in a realm where they charge exorbitant interest
rates. Interest rates of MFIs are currently in the bracket of 35-40 % which sounds very high. But we should not forget that it is high
because of huge risks involved and the demand of funds outstrips the supply. The alternative the consumer faces is that of private lenders
whose interest rates vary from 350-400 % depending on the desperation of customer. Hence, we are stuck in a conundrum where MFIs,
though providing relief from the clutches of private lenders, cannot be considered an effective medium to eradicate poverty. Loans
provided at 30% interest rate cannot be considered a platform for altruism rather resemble more of a profit accruing venture.
     The third aspect is the government policy which forces banks to lend to categorized priority sectors. As the recent report on Non-
Performing Assets of banks has shown, the banks NPAs have grown due to priority sector lending norms. This trend if left unchecked
could well lead to financial crisis. For example the compulsory priority lending requirement has resulted NPAs raising to 3.4% from last
year’s 2.5%. The numbers tell the tale of a clear dichotomy between profitability and altruism with severe repercussions looming large.
     Finally, the market tend to meet the demand for credit (if there are not too many impediments) only if it makes business sense. The
very fact that market has not yet considered this segment as profitable shows that it makes very little business sense or the returns are too
insignificant to be considered desirable. In such a scenario it becomes more pertinent to eradicate barriers which might be preventing
entry while simultaneously creating an enabling environment which would allure institutions to consider delivering a financial inclusion
model which balances altruism as well as profitability.

CONCLUSION
     In today’s world financial exclusion can lead to social exclusion and in order to address this shortfall one needs a holistic approach on
the part of government and private players to bring about innovative financial products.
     After taking a comprehensive look towards the various possibilities and obstructions in amalgamating altruism and profitability it can
be said that banks need to redesign their business strategies to incorporate specific plans to promote financial inclusion of low income
group, treating it both as a business opportunity as well as a corporate social responsibility. They have to make use of all available
resources including technology and expertise available with them as well as the MFIs and NGOs. Taking banking to the sections
constituting “the bottom of the pyramid”, might appear to be considerably difficult and loss-making proposition however it should always
be remembered that even the relatively low margins on high volumes can be a very profitable proposition. Financial inclusion can emerge
as a commercially profitable business provided the government makes the right policy decisions and banks are prepared to think outside
the box!
     -Alnoor S Venkani & Clement Joy Kingsly(FMS)



                                                                                                       In today’s world
                                                                                                       financial exclusion
                                                                                                       can lead to social
                                                                                                       exclusion and in order
                                                                                                       to address this
                                                                                                       shortfall one needs a
                                                                                                       holistic approach on
                                                                                                       the part of
                                                                                                       government and
                                                                                                       private players to
                                                                                                       bring about innovative
                                                                                                       financial products.




6

The Senior Analyst
“Financial inclusion is      USING MICROFINANCE
  the timely delivery of
   financial services to      FOR SOCIAL
          disadvantaged
     sections of society.
                             UPLIFTMENT THROUGH
         Firstly, financial
    inclusion refers to a
                             FINANCIAL INCLUSION
                             So why is financial inclusion so important in the Indian context, to the extent of being a
       customer having
                             compulsion, not a choice? There are ample theoretical and empirical evidence to show that
  access to a range of       financial inclusion leads to economic growth and economic growth to poverty reduction. The
         formal financial     works of Levine (1997) and Honohan (2004) show that a robust financial system can become
 services, from simple       an effective poverty alleviation tool. There are large costs to small and poor entrepreneurs due
                             to the market imperfections in a poorly developed financial system. These burdens include
      credit and savings     informational asymmetries, transaction costs, and contract enforcement costs, compounded
  services to the more       by lack of collateral, credit history, and contacts. For these entrepreneurs, access to financial
       complex such as       services would smooth project financing, positively impacting growth and poverty alleviation.
                             Access to finance is also an important incentive for new ideas and technologies. Additionally,
           insurance and
                             a strong financial system encourages expansion in the market and competition for existing
    pensions. Secondly,      firms. It ensures that poor households and small entrepreneurs need not depend on
      financial inclusion     middlemen. On the other hand, an underdeveloped financial system can be uncompetitive,
              implies that   conservative and inimical to poor or small entrepreneurs. In a seminal study looking at India’s
                             vast banking system, Burgess and Pande (2003) show that the rural bank expansion
        customers have       programme, mandated by          the Indian government from 1977 – 1990, can explain
  access to more than        approximately half of the drop in poverty from 61% in 1967 to 31% in 2000. India needs
one financial services        financial inclusion to make available the fruits of sustained 8% growth to all its citizens,
                             especially the minority and the backwards. This can prove
         provider, which
                             to be the answer to a lot of problems we face in our
    ensures a variety of     times like rising extremism, naxalism, rising income
  competitive options.       disparity and so on.
 In the Indian context,      A look back at India’s financial inclusion history might be
                             appropriate at this point. One of the major tipping points
      financial inclusion,    for the nationalization of banks in 1969 was ensuring
        according to the     credit access to agriculture and small-scale cottage
      Finance Minister’s     industries. Towards this end, RBI stipulated that at least
                             40% of bank lending go towards this sector termed as
         2006-07 budget
                             the Priority Sector, 25% of which had to be extended to
  speech, was defined         the weaker sections within the Priority Sector. Other
      as “the process of     features of nationalised banking included the ‘Service
     ensuring access to      Area Approach’ (SAA) wherein a single bank was
                             assigned 15-20 villages, after which other banks could
   timely and adequate       set up branches upon obtaining the initial bank’s
     credit and financial     approval. Similarly, the 1:4 license rule was established
services by vulnerable       in 1977 dictated that a bank could open a branch in a
                             banked location only after opening four branches in
             groups at an
                             unbanked locations. As a result the share of these
        affordable cost”     sectors in the total advances of scheduled commercial
                             banks rose from 14% in 1969 to 33% in 1980. However,
                             the reforms introduced since 1991 in the banking system
                             have had a heavy toll on small borrowers. The spread of
                             banking credit facilities has not only halted but the
                             number of small borrowers getting financial facilities too sharply declined in the post-
                             liberalization period. From 1990-91 to 1996-97, loan accounts to agriculture fell by 5 million.
                             While 52% of bank credit in rural areas went towards agriculture in 1985, the proportion fell to
                             38% in 1998. In fact, the present share (percent) of rural bank offices to total bank offices is
                             equal to that of the 1980s, i.e., 45.69% in 2005 and 45.72% in 1980s.

7

The Senior Analyst
Financial inclusion in a financial system can           volumes that translate low premiums into       is eaten up as bribes in all forms of
be measured by its “depth” and its                     fair profit. The Dr Rangarajan Committee        financial institutions.
“breadth”. While depth is the extent to                report states that 49.77% of Scheduled         How can India achieve its intention of Total
which the system is developed and works                Caste households, 63.68% of Scheduled          Financial Inclusion by 2012? To be frank,
properly, breadth refers to the extent of              Tribe households and 48.58% of Other           standing at the current date, it is next to
outreach of the system to the population.              Backward Class households are financially       impossible. For this certain measures are
Thanks to the nationalization program India            excluded.    There is denial from the          already in place, but need to pursue them
is better placed than many other                       government machineries to extend the           more actively.
developing economies. There are over                   credit to the Scheduled Castes because         Changes at the policy level: A policy
32,000 rural bank branches (with a total of            direct funding from banks is a problem.        change to encourage the public to invest
68,000 rural and semi-urban branches)                  Most schemes require paper work,               their savings should be brought about. RBI
including public and private sector banks              recommendations, forwarding of                 has already introduced policy changes in
and RRBs. There are more than 15,000                   applications, and other processes which        2005. These include introduction of no frills
branches of RRB. Rural co-operative banks              they can’t facilitate. Existing societal       accounts without minimum balance
comprise about 98,000 retail outlets of                mechanisms continue to regulate and            clauses and Kisan Credit Cards for easy
Primary Agricultural Credit Societies
(PACS). The post office system, comprising
154,000 post office branches, has about
114 million savings accounts and services
110 million money orders. One of the major
indicators of health of a financial inclusion
of a system is “access to credit”. Despite
this vast network of banks, only about 30%
of Indians have a savings account. All of us
have heard stories of rural families literally
selling themselves off to moneylenders as
a result of not being able to service the
exorbitant rate of interests (an average of            enforce the customary norms and rules of       transactions, relaxation of Know Your
48%, as compared to 12.5% in commercial                the caste system. Those, who challenge         Customer (KYC) forms for accounts having
banks). There has been a disturbing trend              the system face opposition in the form of      balance of less than 50,000 and less than
of rise in borrowings from moneylenders                social and economic boycott, violence, etc,    100,000 as loans annually, and reasonable
post 1991, after steady decline post                   which negate their right to development. A     pricing by banks for services rendered.
nationalization.                                       major problem is the barriers to credit        Another crucial step is the encouragement
So what is stopping us from utilizing the full         access that these people face. A survey by     of microfinance institutions who have tried
potential of our banking infrastructure and            Invest India Market Solutions (IIMS) shows     to fill up the void created after the
                                                            that there is a strong link between       commercial banks left rural market. More
                                                             annual income and ownership of           and more developmental agencies are
                                                             bank accounts by occupation group.       using microfinance as a tool for sustainable
                                                             A survey of bank managers in             development, a trend started by Self-
                                                             Madhya Pradesh revealed a                Employed Women’s Association, SEWA.
                                                             perception that women borrowers          In conclusion, it can be said that, despite
                                                             were more trustworthy and less of a      having the requisite infrastructure in place,
                                                             default risk (United Nations, 2006).     the sheer apathy and lack of policy
                                                             However, a greater percentage still      implementation is holding back the poor
                                                             believed that women were simply          400 million Indians from realizing their

alleviating ourselves from poverty? The                      being used by men to gain loans. One     potential fully. But change can’t be brought
answer lies in looking at the problems of              more reason is the self exclusion by the       from one side. A population low on
financial inclusion on this country. It is still        low income households from banking             awareness and education can’t fully utilize
                                                       facilities as they get intimidated and         the benefits of institutional finance. For
a dream to see a bank that offers savings
                                                       develop a belief that banks are intended for   that, policies like right to education are
accounts for the poor with cheque book
facility unless she/he keeps Rs 1,000                  more educated and richer individuals. Also,    crucial to raise the general education level,
minimum balance. The health insurance                  almost 90% of the loans disbursed need         especially the rural poor and backwards.
companies set very low hospital tariffs for            collaterals, which in case of rural poor is    Also, strict vigil on eliminating social
                                                       land. Hence, a major part of the landless      ostracization has to be brought in to give
re i m b u r s e m e n t w h i c h m a k e s t h e m
                                                       poor get excluded. Plus, a 2006 UN survey      everybody an equal opportunity to
unattractive. Operational service is lacking
as most insurance companies are ill                    suggests that 10-20% of the loan amount        determine their own destiny.
equipped to handle the necessary large
                                                                                                      -Soumyadipta Chakraborty & Yashowardhan
                                                                                                      Chaturvedi(XLRI)
8

The Senior Analyst
NAHAR SPINNING MILLS
                                  Introduction about Nahar Spinning          contributing 14 % in total industrial
                                  Mills                                      production, 17 % in foreign exchange
                                  It was started as a spinning and           and 4% in GDP. Government policies
                                  hosiery unit in Ludhiana .The Company      like Technology up-gradation fund
                                  is the part of Nahar Group of              scheme (TUFS),Scheme of Integrated
                                  Companies. The group`s portfolio           Textile Park(SITP) technology Mission
                                  include wool combing, spinning,            of Cotton (TMC) and 2 % interest
                                  knitting, fabric, hosiery garments etc.    subvention from exports has helped
                                  Nahar spinning mills is a blue chip in     this sector to grow at a rapid rate.
                                  its group. Nahar Spinning’s T-shirts are   From the recent past the India Textile
                                  being exported to reputed international    products have become cheaper than
                                  brands such as GAP, Arrow, Old Navy,       of china due to the appreciation of
                                  Pierre Cardin, Izod, and Quicksilver.      Chinese Yuan and wage inflation in
                                  Recently the company got Golden            China. The domestic factor which
                                  Trophy by the Apparel Export               supports the growth of this industry
                                  Promotion Council and Gold Trophy by       are increasing purchasing power of
                                  The Cotton Textiles Export Promotion       both domestic and rural markets and
                                  Council.                                   growing organized retail in India.

                                  Key Highlight of the company               Segmented Revenue
                                  •
The company is the best amongst          Nahar has a current capacity of 3.35
                                  its peers and has an attractive P/E        lakh spindles to produce cotton yarn/
                                  ratio of 4.77 and industry P/E is 9.06     Synthetic yarn respectively .It has
                                  •
 Spreads of cotton yarn is               planned for an addition of 90000
                                  increasing continuously                    spindles by July 2011. In the textile
                                  •
The company is developing its            and hosiery garments has a current
                                  own retail brand Cotton County             capacity of 14 lakhs pieces per year.
                                  •
 The board has approved for a            The current capacity utilization of
                                  capital expenditure of 400 Crore under     garments is 50.57% .The domestic
                                  TUFS with a capacity expansion of          and international demand for garments
                                  about 33 percent of current capacity       will have the capability to push the
                                                                             capacity utilization to 87 % by
                                  Textile Sector Analysis                    2013.The wastes are the material
                                  Indian Textile industry is having          waste generated in spinning and
                                  significant presence in domestic and       garments manufacturing sold at a
                                  global economy. Indian textile industry    cheaper price. Around 65-70 percent
                                  plays a major role in Indian economy       of the revenue comes from exports.
                                  by




                                  RESEARCH
            BSE Code:500296
     NSE Code: NAHARSPING
              Industry: Textile
                                  REPORT::NAHAR
                                  SPINNING
Group: B Market Cap :402.13cr
         Promoter holding:63%

9

The Senior Analyst
Expenditure Analysis                           Depreciation Analysis                          Considering the stock will trade at
The major part of the expenditure are          The plant and machinery, Land and              5.5X PE the stock will reach a target
                                               building are the major fixed assets in the      price of Rs200/- in 24 months with a
                                               organization. As per the previous financial     growth rate of 79 percent.
                                               statements the depreciation for plant and
                                               machinery is at the rate of at 10 percent y-
                                                                                              -Sanjeev Kumar & Selva Kumar(NITIE)
                                               o-y .The depreciation for land and building
                                               is at the rate of 12 percent y-o-y. In fiscal
                                               year 2010-2012 it has added machinery in
                                               the yarn segment.




contributed by Raw material cost and
power and the fuel cost .The major part of
the raw material consumed by the
company are Raw cotton and cotton
yarn .In the fiscal year 2010-2011 the
cotton prices had a huge price fluctuations
at the end the Raw cotton per Kg in
January 2011 quoted at Rs 80/- in New
Delhi according to CMIE. Nahar has a
strategy to hold more inventory of Cotton
which forms around 90 percent of the raw
materials to avoid price fluctuation and
weather fluctuations. Power crisis is one of
the major threat to the company .The
company has mitigated the power risk by




installing captive power plant of 4.1 MW
capacity in July 2011.


Interest Analysis
Interest is one of the major expenses to the
company. In the fiscal year 2008-2010
because of the economic recession the
company in order to meet the financial
obligations of the company .The financial
leverage has shown a huge variation in that
particular year. The term loans and the
working capital loans are contracted at
interest rate of 5-8% .The weighted
average cost of interest rate is 5.75%. The
company plans to obtain 400 Cr term loans
at an interest rate of 5% with the help of
TUFS under textile ministry in fiscal year
2011 and 2012.

10

The Senior Analyst
ANALYSIS OF PRIVATE EQUITY
INVESTMENTS IN INDIA IN
SECOND HALF OF 2010 AND
BEYOND
Overview of PE Investments in India during July-Dec 2010
Deal volumes reported in September and October were lower compared to August.
Real Estate remained the favorite sector in September and October, unlike Energy in
August. Most of the investments in energy sector came from Blackstone investing in
Moser Baer for around $ 300Mn. Healthcare industry although having large number of
deals remained small in terms of value due to smaller deal sizes. HDFC VC’s 10%
stake purchase in Lodha Group’s “World One”, the world’s tallest residential project
for $ 111Mn was the largest PE deal during the given period in Real Estate, followed


                                                                                        PE Investments in 2010
                                                                                        After two years of drooping Private Equity
                                                                                        Investments in India, year 2010 saw a major
                                                                                        shift with around 100% jump. The level of PE




                                                                                        Investments in 2010 came out to be 7974Mn
                                                                                        $ with around 325 deals. Moreover, the
                                                                                        average investment per deal also rose from
                                                                                        14Mn to 24.5Mn per deal signifying
                                                                                        investments in even bigger projects in 2010.
                                                                                        Interestingly, the level of PE investments in
                                                                                        2010 nearly equaled the prior slowdown year
                                                                                        investments of 2006 of 7485Mn $. The effect
                                                                                        of Global Economic scenario causes the roller
                                                                                        coaster ride of PE investments in India.
                                                                                        However, there are many internal factors
                                                                                        which are impeding the growth of PE
                                                                                        investments:
                                                                                        •
 Strong macroeconomic fundamentals are
                                                                                        making India an attractive destination for PE
                                                                                        investments. However, decreasing investment
                                                                                        opportunities in developed countries is
                                                                                        fuelling enough completion in India.
by Kotak Realty Fund’s $ 55.56Mn in EmaarMGF.
                                                                                        •
 Removing legal roadblocks by regulators,
Month wise analysis of PE investments
                                                                                        which block PE investments in some sectors.
July was the gloomiest period during the past four months, with the number of deals
                                                                                        Thereby, diminishing its potential.
being the least. Also the deal volume was very relatively small. India was witnessing   •
 Reluctance of Indian businesses working
greater inflow of Private equity inflow into the country after the financial meltdown.     with the PE/VC investors may cause their
There were two prime reasons for this drive:                                            businesses remaining untapped. Promoters
•
 Stocks of Indian markets were battered during the slowdown and were trading at       can enhance their business value by aligning
very low premiums, which provided ample opportunity for PE and VC firms to invest        with partners having similar vision.
in some good companies.                                                                 •
PE firms need to understand the
•
 Signals of strong economic growth in the emerging countries while the US and         intricacies of the business in India through
Europe still not showing signs of recovery from the economic recession.                 honing their investment capabilities along
                                                                                        each phase of investment life cycles.
•
 Easy availability of cheap capital in from the US encouraged them to invest in
                                                                                        Average deal size in India has been relatively
some undervalued firms through Private equity.
                                                                                        small when compared to China/other

11

The Senior Analyst
During the month of August, PE firms                            sector would also enhance investments in            compared to investing $ 4.7Bn last year
started investing in India through the debt                    food and beverages industry. Rising                 through 331 deals in Infrastructure sector.
market for the first time. Therefore, the deal                  incomes and inflation are creating                   Infrastructure sector is likely lead the PE
volume during August shot up by around                         favorable condition for investments in this         investment in 2011, leaving behind the
100%. KKR Private Equity was the first to it                    sector.                                             financial services sector, which received
through their global NBFC arm. The prime                       d)	Education                                        the highest investment in 2010, primarily
advantage is enhancing company’s                               Education Industry which saw three fold             due to increasing interest in real estate
v a l u a t i o n , t h e re b y b u i l d i n g b e t t e r   raises in 2009 remained as one of the most          post financial meltdown. Due to large
relationship with the promoters, enhancing                     lucrative sector. With impending reforms in         amount of PE capital being absorbed by
the chances of conversion of PE Deal.                          the sector, the sector might witness                the infrastructure sector, the financial
                                                               phenomenal investments in recent years.             services firms might receive much lesser
Sector wise Analysis of PE Investments                         However, the investment size mismatch is            PE investments compared to $ 2.1Bn in
in India                                                       acting as a major deterrent, due to limited         2010.
a)	Real Estate                                                 number to educational assets to be                  About 20-25% of PE investments would be
Although the poor infrastructure sector in                     employed with investments over $ 25Mn               done in infrastructure sector, primarily due
India being one of the major deterrents for                    which PE firms are targeting.                        to banks unwilling to lend them and
PE investments coming to India, it is                          e)	 A l t e r n a t e E n e r g y a n d C l e a n   secondarily due to small corporate bond
finding the highest preference among the                        Technology                                          market. Thereby, the PE funds would play a
PE Investors in recent times. Thereby,                         Alternate Energy & Clean Technology is              crucial role in the infrastructure investment
Energy, Real Estate & Construction                             emerging as one of the major PE                     sector of India in 2011. Blackstone Group
together accounted for nearly two-thirds of                    investments in recent years as India                alone may invest more than $ 1Bn in India
all PE investments by deal size. The largest                   struggles with power deficit and                     next year.
deal during the six month period came                          environmental worries. Moreover, the                Indian PE firms may face stiff competition
from Blackstone group investing about $                        policies of the government are encouraging          from the foreign PE firms finding good
300Mn in Moser Baer for investing in                           investors to some extent, like levying tax          investment opportunities in 2011. Other
power sector. Blackstone is reported to                        on the use of coal to fund the
further invest $ 1Bn for investing in                          renewable energy projects.
infrastructure for next few years, signifying                  International Finance
the continuing dominance of infrastructure                     Corporation (IFC) made 5
sector.                                                        deals alone since the month
b)	 BFSI, IT & Healthcare                                      of August in this sector.
BFSI, IT and Healthcare sectors attracted                      f)	Logistics
deals of relatively smaller value; however                     Investment in the logistics
they remained relatively significant in terms                   segment has shown
of total investments made.                                     significant decline, the
c)	 Retail and Food & Beverages                                primary reason being the
                                                                             mismatch
                                                                             between
                                                                                 the deal
                                                                                 sizes. While
                                                                                 PE players
                                                                                 are looking
                                                                                 at deals of at least $            than the IPO exit route, secondary sales
                                                                                 50Mn, logistics companies         are likely gain popularity next year, after 18
                                                                                 are agreeing for deals up         secondary sales in 2010. Primarily due to
                                                                                 to $ 20Mn.                        the lack of sufficient capital for next stage
                                                                                 5)	 Roadmap for the               of growth by small Indian PE firms. Like,
                                                                                 Private Equity Investment         Warburg Pincus buying ICICI Venture
                                                                              in 2011                              fund’s stake in Metroplis Healthcare. 2011
                                                                              Like 2010, PE investments            might witness an increasing number of
                                                                              are expected to flow into             fund managers leaving their jobs with
                                                                             India with twice the                  global PE firms to open their own venture,
Industry
                                                               investments in 2010 and even greater                with economy thriving and opening
Investments in retail remained miniscule
                                                               returns. Nearly $ 30Bn is waiting to be             opportunities.
largely due to the untapped retail sector.
                                                               deployed next year, creating chances of
However, the impending decision on multi
                                                               even bigger deals. In 2010, PE firms                 -Shashank(National Institute of Industrial
branding retailing brings possibility for                                                                          Engineering)
                                                               employed $ 8.3Bn through 376 deals,
huge investments. Unlocking the retailing


12

The Senior Analyst
After a   KEY TRENDS & ISSUES IN THE
      catastrophic      GLOBAL BANKING SECTOR
         2008 and a     (2010)
  fragile 2009, the     Introduction
    global banking      After a catastrophic 2008 and a fragile 2009, the global banking industry showed signs of
                        revival in the year 2010 even as numerous challenges, both remnants of the past and some
 industry showed        emerging over the year, continued to lay siege to its strong and sustained recovery. The

signs of revival in     unprecedented easing in liquidity through liberal monetary and fiscal policies helped no
                        doubt, as did the revival in the equity market. The banking sector as a whole showed a rise in
     the year 2010      net income, even though the earning quality remained a major issue, as most of it came from
                        sources other than traditional interest income. Questions also remain over the capital levels in
             even as    the banks as the Governments start to withdraw the stimuli effects and the norms of the
                        enhanced Basel II regime come into force.
          numerous
 challenges, both       Stricter Regulations
  remnants of the       As the epicentre of the financial crisis lay in the banking industry itself, attempts were made
                        to subject it to stricter regulation. The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision introduced
    past and some       ‘The Capital and Liquidity Reform Package’ in July, 2010 introducing new agreed upon

    emerging over       definitions in the treatment of capital, counterparty credit risk, leverage ratio, regulatory
                        buffers and global liquidity standards. The Committee also stressed on introducing counter

            the year,   cyclical provisions and buffers and credit-to-GDP gap was accepted as the best performing
                        indicator for calibrating the same. In September 2010, the Committee introduced the
  continued to lay      enhanced Basel II regime which significantly increased the capital requirements from the
                        existing Basel II norms. In order to prevent the banks from facing immediate liquidity threats,
         siege to its   a phased implementation of the same was suggested, starting from 2013 and continuing till

         strong and     2019. Also, a counter cyclical buffer measure was proposed in addition to the existing capital
                        norms of Basel II.

          sustained
     recovery. The
   unprecedented
easing in liquidity
    through liberal
     monetary and
     fiscal policies
helped no doubt,
as did the revival
       in the equity
             market.




13

The Senior Analyst
Global Financial Markets                         completely recover their losses.
The year 2007 and 2008 has seen an               The opposite was true, however,
unprecedented contraction in the global          for bank stocks in the emerging
money market as counterparty risk                countries, which almost came
increased tremendously and the LIBOR-            back to the pre-crisis level as a
OIS spread reached new heights. However,         result of strong balance sheets
the sustained efforts of the Governments         and better growth prospects.
and Central banks around the world helped        Similar trend was observed for
the money market to settle down in 2010.         credit market which continued its
Nasty surprises still lay in store though as     tedious progress from the freezing
the sovereign debt crisis in Europe again        over during the financial crisis.
put the money market under renewed               Initially aided and abetted by the
stress in the middle of 2010.                    policy measures of the
The sovereign debt crisis posed one of the       Government, it began to recover
strongest challenges to the global financial      on its own as the liquidity and
industry during the year. Governments all        market risks eased at the end of
over the world and especially those in the       2009. However, a large chunk of
fringes of Europe, struggled to recover          the global credit demand is still
from the financial crisis and huge                coming from Governments and
Government stimuli after years of over-          other sovereign entities while
spending, low taxation and massive               private credit market continue to remain                   Fig 1: Change in Return of Equity of Banks
welfare schemes. The tipping point came in       stagnant. The corporate bond spread also                   Across Regions
the end of April 2010 when Standard and          eased a little during the year even as the                 Fig 2: Gross NPA as percentage of total
Poor’s downgraded the Greek bonds to             recovery was affected by the sovereign                     loans in banks
‘junk’ status and at the same time also          debt crisis of Europe.                                     Banks in the emerging economies, which
lowered the ratings of the                                                                                  constitute 25% of global banking market,
Spanish and Portuguese                                                                                           recovered quickly from the financial
bonds. The EU had to stitch                                                                                      crisis. Their business model, which is
together a bail-out package for                                                                                  to act predominantly as gatherers of
Greece and the Greek                                                                                             savers as opposed to aggressive
Government had to undertake                                                                                      lenders like the western banks,
painful cost cutting measures.                                                                                   thrived in the economic conditions
This was followed by a period                                                                                    with rise in domestic savings and
of relative calm until history                                                                                  easy monetary policies. Banks in
was repeated again, this time                                                                                   China have seen a period of boom in
with Ireland. However, the                                                                                      the year 2009, lending twice as much
biggest worry still remained in                                                                                 in 2009 than in 2008.
Spain which had much bigger economy              Fig: Growth Percentage in Credit Markets                   The Challenges Ahead
than Greece, Portugal or Ireland and a                                                                      Looking forward to the days ahead, some
failure which can throw the global economy       Key Trends in Performance of Banks                         of the biggest challenges of the banks over
into disarray. As the year came to a close,      As a general rule in the developed                         the world would to be to meet increasing
the last word had not yet been spoken on         economies, income of banks rose during                     capital requirements, address the issue of
the European debt crisis.                        the year although major part of the same                   rising delinquencies, recover from the
Equity markets across the world moved in         came from trading fees, foreign exchange                   withdrawal of liberal monetary and fiscal
tandem and continued their recovery from         gains, etc. Rising equity markets eased the                policies, redressing balance sheet
the rock bottom of early 2009. However,          pressure on banks and helped them                          weaknesses and dealing with a weak credit
the sovereign debt crisis and sluggish           become profitable by providing them with                    market. The biggest market risk may come
recovery in the advanced economies again         alternative profit sources. Better primary                  sometime in 2011 when the big spending
weakened the equity market in the                markets also allowed a lot of banks to                     European nations as well as USA will have
developed economies. Emerging                    s u b s t i t u t e c a p i t a l f ro m t h e s a m e .   to roll over their sovereign bonds and the
economies, however, had an altogether            Regulatory capital as percentage of risk-                  subsequent pressure on the primary bond
different story to tell and the US Fed policy    weighted assets thus increased for banks                   market may throw it into haywire. How
to keep interest rates at a historic low level   across geographies. The problem of loan                    banks cope with these challenges may
opened up huge foreign investment in             losses and write downs continued,                          very well determine their role in the new
them. Bank stocks in the developed               however, as the percentage of non-                         world economy.
economies continued their slow progress          performing assets kept increasing.                         -Sayan Majumder & Shifa Shalini Tirkey(XLRI)
from the nadir but were unable to

14

The Senior Analyst
Public sector     WHY DISINVESTMENT FOR INDIAN
      undertakings      ECONOMY
were established        PSUs… Why after all?
                        To illustrate the trailing scenario, the average return on capital employed (ROCE) by PSUs
 in India as a part     have been way too low as compared to the cost of borrowing. For instance, between 1940
                        and 2002, the average ROCE was 3.4% as against 8.6% average cost of borrowing. PSE
            of mixed    survey by NCAER shows that PAT has never exceeded 5% of sales for or 6% of capital
                        employed. The government pays a higher interest though, by at least 3 percentage points.
     economy with
  the objective of      As per an NCAER study report the cost structure of PSES is much more than the private
                        sector (the following table shows a comparative scale) :
           providing    	                                  PSES	Private sector
                        POWER & FUELS/NET SALES             19.5	5
          necessary     Wages/net sales	                    23.3 	6.5
                        Interest/net sales	                 11.7	4.7
infrastructure for
   the fast growth      Lack of autonomy, political interference, nepotism & corruption has further deteriorated the
                        situation. For instance, the head of a PSU is appointed by the Government, who in turn
 of economy & to        appoints all employees who play major roles in the organization. So directly or indirectly the
                        Government itself controls the appointment of all manpower in these organizations. It is not
          safeguard     the business of the Government to do business, i.e. it is best controlled by experts and

             against    professional managers.
                        If we look at figures, on 31.3.1997, 242 central PSUs had a investment of Rs.1,93,121 crores.

       monopoly of      By the end of year 2000-01, total investment was touching Rs.274,114 crores. Of these, 104
                        were making losses and about 53 were performing below expectations. Profit making
        industrialist   enterprises are mostly in sectors like petroleum and allied sectors, because they are
                        benefitted from State monopoly. losses of the 104 loss making units were around Rs. 58,620
        community.      crores as on 31.3.1997.which put pressure on capital expenditure and contribute to fiscal

      However, the      deficit.These losses are a permanent phenomenon and keep borrowing just for their
                        functioning is a temporary unsustainable solution.

               entire
                        In this year’s budget revenue expenditure has increased due to interest payments, wages and
   mechanism did        salaries of Government employees and subsidies. This leaves Government with very less
                        money for capital expenditure on social and physical infrastructure. Government is forced to
    not turn out as     put aside resources for the sustenance of many non-viable PSEs. In addition to that there is a

      efficient as it    huge amount of debt overhang, which needs to be serviced and reduced before money is
                        available to invest in infrastructure. Disinvestment of the Maruti Udyog Ltd.will work as a
   ought to be, all     beacon for future.

      thanks to the
          prevailing
     hierarchy and
      bureaucracy.




15

The Senior Analyst
In an era of globalization, liberalization       We have seen every socialist country adopt       Disinvestment will provide positive signs
and dissolution of boundaries between            industrialization, rather efficient               for the Indian equity markets and will work
nations, industrial competitiveness has          industrialization, for appropriate growth,       as a magnet to attract foreign and domestic
especially assumed an important role,            be it China or Russia. We preferred              money into the markets. It will allow PSU
necessitating privatization or disinvestment     Russia’s old model. Now that we have seen        to raise capital to fund their expansion
of PSUs. Though it is claimed by many            even the social countries succeed with           plans and improve resource allocation in
that ownership isn’t all that an important       privatization and fail without it, it is high    the economy. Disinvestment will help
indicator of an organization’s functioning       time we implement it too in major respects.      government in stimulating the economy
as is its management, it has been proven by                                                       while accessing less debt market borrowing.
an ample number of examples that private         Implications of Disinvestment on                 Disinvestment will allow government to
controls of an organization bring about          Indian Economy:                                  have much better control over the market
drastic changes in its effectiveness. This is    If India wants a continuous increased            economy without upsetting norms of
especially true today when competitiveness       growth, it has to scale to the next level of     market behavior.
is essential not only for leading the industry   performance. This is not an option but a
but for mere survival.                           necessity and disinvestment is a tool to get     In future disinvestment will assume the role
                                                 there. Increased population,                     of a major instrument of policy
Bureaucracy has been an inherent part of         unemployment, and poverty levels are main        intervention by government as 48 PSUs
PSUs and attempts to overcome it have            reasons why India needs to scale. The cost       listed on BSE as of February 8, 2010,
been unsuccessful if not inadequate.             of not scaling to the next level will see        account for close to the 30% of the total
Private management has proven to be a            India eclipsed by China and other South          market cap of the exchange. This is
panacea in most such cases, including            East Asian aspirants leaving India to its        significant as a total of 4,880 odd
VSNL and Delhi Vidyut Board. The                 internal chaos. It needs a 10% rate of           companies were listed on the exchange. As
success of these organizations after             growth every year in its GDP to continue to      of February 8, 2010, the BSE PSU index
privatization has been evident by turning        be competitive with China and potential          had a total market cap of Rs 17,14,466.96
from red to black within a short span of         emergent nations in South East Asia.             crore.
time. PSUs no longer enjoy the privileges        In the context of macroeconomics, time
as they did in past times in terms of                                                             As certain no. of shares are reserved for
reputation and awe, on the contrary are                                                             retail investors & Splitting the stocks of
stigmatized by the lack of efficiency and                                                            some big PSUs ,will attract more retail
social considerations of past times.                                                                investors. Market cap of PSUs can go
                                                                                                    higher in future & can provide extra
Despite huge injection of funds in the past                                                         money in the kitty of govt. 5%
decades the functioning of many public                                                              Reservation for employees will work as an
sector units (PSUs) has traditionally been                                                          incentive & will keep momentum going.
characterized by poor management, slow                                                              This will be true democratization of
decision making procedures, lack of                                                                 capital. Disinvestment would encourage
accountability, low productivity,                                                                   citizens’ participation in management of
unsatisfactory quality of goods, excessive                                                          public enterprises and improve the
manpower utilization, labor intensive                                                               capitalization of stock markets. When
units, lack of technological up gradation,                                                          companies get listed on the bourse they
inadequate attention to R&D, inadequate          has shown us how countries like Chile ,UK,       adds certain economic and financial
human resource development and low rate          China , New zealand ,Poland successfully         benefits to the economy. Which is called
of return on capital. However, with              used disinvestment to achieve new                financial deepening, a term coined by
increasing privatization, disinvestment or       economic heights. Many countries used            development economists. Financial
change of control into hands of                  disinvestment as a sure means of restoring       deepening improves the efficiency of the
professional managers, many organizations        budgetary balance & to revive growth on a        financial system as well as contributes to
have seen the tables turn. Some examples         sustainable basis after facing economic          GDP growth.
are IRCTC and CRIS to facilitate the             crisis in 80s.Analysis of these countries
functioning of Indian Railways etc.              before & after disinvestment shows that
                                                 market-driven economies are more efficient        Latest loan bribery case(in LIC,PNB etc.)
                                                 than the state-planned economies                 has shown the wrongdoing, loopholes &
Inefficient PSU’s contributed largely for                                                          drawbacks in the working of PSUs. If India
the macro-economic crisis faced by India         At the micro level, the change in ownership      has to become a economic super power,
during 1980’s. Primary purpose to establish      will increase domestic competition, hence        working way of PSUs have to be changed.
them was to provide employment and help          efficiency; and encourage public                  PSUs contribute about more than 1/4th in
the government to generate revenue               participation in domestic stock market – all     the GDP of India & a large chunk of
surplus. But they were unable to perform to      of which will promote ‘popular ‘capitalism       working population is employed in
the expectations. Experts are in consensus       that rewards risk taking and private             PSUs .Economic super power dream is not
that disinvestment is unavoidable for the        initiative, that is expected to yield superior   possible without PSUs coming at par with
success of second generation reforms.            economic outcomes. Disinvestment shows           private sector.
Health of the stock market is also linked        that govt means business which will attract      -Jagriti Gupta & Vipin Patel(FMS)
with the progress of economic reforms.           FDI, FII to finance projects in India.

16

The Senior Analyst
The Demise of the Celtic Tiger
Eschewed sovereign bonds. Record high          reported a 13 billion euros decrease in its             as it is the major economy driver and it
government borrowings. Large fiscal             deposits this year, which is almost 17%.                would be drastic setback for the growth
deficit. Collapsing banking sector. So many     The crisis hit banks were the most                      opportunities if it were to be altered.
problems and still the government of           concerning factor for the government as                 The package is a bit different from the one
Ireland was not willing to agree to external   they somehow needed funds to support                    given to Greece earlier. The interest rate for
rumours that it needed an aid package.         the sector and revive the declining                     the package is higher than Greece’s but
The Irish government kept supporting its       economy. Apart from this, currently the                 Ireland has 10 years to pay-off its loans
claim by stating just two reasons. Firstly,    country is spending close to 19 billion                 whereas Greece was only given a time of 3
their loan was not supposed to be              euros which is more than what it receives               years. The first instalment would be due
refinanced till 2011 and secondly, they did     from its revenues and taxes. The rising                 within 4.5 years.
not want to lose control over their fiscal      budget deficits are yet another factor of                Has it worked?
policy and end up discouraging foreign         c o n c e r n f o r t h e a l re a d y b u rd e n e d   The bailout package has been paid out and
investment which is the key driver of the      government.                                             everyone had positive expectations from it.
country’s growth for almost two decades        The plan of Action                                      But have these expectations been met?
now.                                           The country was coming under pressure                   The answer to the question can be seen
Finally on 21st November, the Irish            from all the Eurozone members to accept                 from the fact that private investors have
government gave in and announced that to       the fact that the economy was not in a                  still no urge to buy Irish government bonds.
uplift the deteriorating condition of the      condition to survive on its own as they                 The demand for bonds which was lacking
banking sector, an external state financial
aid was required.                              feared that the damaging effects might                  initially is still the same and government is
What led to the bailout?                       spread to other debt ridden European                    not likely to be able to raise more money
The economy was a hub for financial             countries like Portugal and Spain. The                  from the market.
investors since the 90’s as it charged a       belief was unanimous that Ireland asking                So what exactly went wrong?
corporate tax rate of 12.5% which is the       for a bailout package might actually result             The main cause for the failure of the bailout
lowest among the EU nations. This has          in relaxing the tense atmosphere and in                 mechanism is that EU members have a
attracted many companies to setup their        fact ease pressure on other countries with              common centralized monetary authority
base in the country and due to this the        mounting debts.                                         but a decentralized fiscal authority. This
economy had been booming. The first             – the Eurozone, EU and the IMF. Each                    leads to a situation where the two policies
major setback came with the burst of the       contributed 22.5 billion euros which                    don’t complement each other making it
real estate bubble in 2008. This was closely   amounts to roughly 29.8 billion USD. The                impossible to solve these situations.
followed by the fall of Lehmann Brothers       rest of the amount was given by Sweden,                 The bailout mechanism relies on getting
which sent the world economies into            Denmark and Britain as bilateral loans.                 money from stronger countries like
recession mode. The Irish banks were           Irish PM, Brian Cowen disclosed that the                Germany, which in fact is from the common
severely hit by both these developments.       package would be having two major steps.                tax payer there. The complaints from them
Since then the budget deficits have been        First would be to revamp the deteriorated               being troubled for no reason at all
constantly increasing and have reached a       Irish banks and make them much smaller                  continuously increase. This money is then
high recently, amounting to about one-third    than they were. Second would be to                      transferred to an affected economy which
of the economic output this year. This led     reduce the budget deficits by decreasing                 is forced to cut its spending and survive
to a rapid surge in bond yields which are      government spending and increasing                      under severe austerity measures. The
currently at an all-time high. The Finance     taxes.                                                  whole concept is flawed from within as it
Minister, Mr. Lenihan announced that the       To address to the first step, 10 billion euros           simply adds more debt to a country’s
increasing interest rates would make it        have been immediately given to the                      economic situation which is already under
impossible for the government to raise         government-backed banks so that they                    a load of debt.
money the next year and hence the              have sum back-up funds for their                        All in all, the money has been forwarded to
banking sector would need a back-up fund       sustenance. Another 25 billion euros have               the country, the measures and the
to support itself.                             been set aside particularly for the banking             deadlines have been set, but the effect
This deteriorating financial health of the      sector only. The rest of the loans have been            which was perceived is far from achieved.
economy was immediately perceived by           set aside for the second step. Ireland has              Jean Claude Trichet, the head of Europe’s
the citizens and they started withdrawing      been given time till 2015 to decrease its               monetary authority has a very major role to
their funds. The government holds a major      annual deficit to 3%, which currently is at              play now. He must review the policies
stake in many large banks but provides         an all time high of 32%.                                being used in EU, related to the common
only a blanket guarantee to them. Due to       As far as the taxation rules were                       monetary authority and the common
this, the two largest banks of the country,    concerned, Ireland got its way and the                  currency and also he must check the
Allied Irish Bank and Anglo Irish Bank were    government was given full freedom to set                efficiency of loaning large amounts to
finding it immensely difficult to get any        its own tax plans. Regarding this, Mr.                  already debt stricken countries, or in other
deposits from the market. Allied Irish Bank    Cowen commented that the 12.5%                          words what they call the bailout package.
                                               corporation tax would remain unchanged                  -Harpreet Singh & Vaibhav Juneja(FMS)

17

The Senior Analyst
Senior analyst jan 11(1)

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONS
QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONSQUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONS
QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONSVeena Mohandas
 
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in India
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in IndiaA Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in India
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in Indiascmsnoida5
 
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone China kills three birds with “yuan” stone
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone QNB Group
 
Why is the Japanese Yen so Strong
Why is the Japanese Yen so StrongWhy is the Japanese Yen so Strong
Why is the Japanese Yen so Strongs1180091
 
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy Tool
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy ToolQuantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy Tool
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy ToolMohammadali Surti
 
devaluation of Japaneses currency
devaluation of Japaneses currency devaluation of Japaneses currency
devaluation of Japaneses currency nishant bhatia
 
Quantitative easing - II
Quantitative easing - IIQuantitative easing - II
Quantitative easing - IICijil Diclause
 
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groups
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country GroupsExternal Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groups
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groupspaperpublications3
 
Yuan Impact On India & World
Yuan Impact On India & WorldYuan Impact On India & World
Yuan Impact On India & WorldBhanu Teja
 
Ele ex11 2
Ele ex11 2Ele ex11 2
Ele ex11 2s1190124
 
Currency devaluation
Currency devaluationCurrency devaluation
Currency devaluationSana Usman
 
How is the_japanese_yen
How is the_japanese_yenHow is the_japanese_yen
How is the_japanese_yenKazuma Arimori
 
Currency Project
Currency ProjectCurrency Project
Currency Projectdpark1
 
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazil
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazilIn defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazil
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazilFernando Alcoforado
 
Devaluation of Pakistani rupee
Devaluation of Pakistani rupeeDevaluation of Pakistani rupee
Devaluation of Pakistani rupeemahnoorzmalik
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONS
QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONSQUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONS
QUANTITATIVE EASING AND ITS IMPLICATIONS
 
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in India
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in IndiaA Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in India
A Study on Exchange Rate Volatility and its Macro Economic Determinants in India
 
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone China kills three birds with “yuan” stone
China kills three birds with “yuan” stone
 
Purezen7
Purezen7Purezen7
Purezen7
 
Financial environment
Financial environmentFinancial environment
Financial environment
 
Why is the Japanese Yen so Strong
Why is the Japanese Yen so StrongWhy is the Japanese Yen so Strong
Why is the Japanese Yen so Strong
 
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy Tool
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy ToolQuantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy Tool
Quantitative Easing: A Monetary Policy Tool
 
devaluation of Japaneses currency
devaluation of Japaneses currency devaluation of Japaneses currency
devaluation of Japaneses currency
 
Quantitative easing - II
Quantitative easing - IIQuantitative easing - II
Quantitative easing - II
 
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groups
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country GroupsExternal Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groups
External Debt - A Comparative Analysis of Various Country Groups
 
Yuan Impact On India & World
Yuan Impact On India & WorldYuan Impact On India & World
Yuan Impact On India & World
 
Ele ex11 2
Ele ex11 2Ele ex11 2
Ele ex11 2
 
RMB Devaluation baogao
RMB Devaluation baogaoRMB Devaluation baogao
RMB Devaluation baogao
 
Currency devaluation
Currency devaluationCurrency devaluation
Currency devaluation
 
TJEF January Issue
TJEF January IssueTJEF January Issue
TJEF January Issue
 
How is the_japanese_yen
How is the_japanese_yenHow is the_japanese_yen
How is the_japanese_yen
 
Currency Project
Currency ProjectCurrency Project
Currency Project
 
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazil
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazilIn defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazil
In defense of exchange rate fixed as one of brazil
 
Devaluation of Pakistani rupee
Devaluation of Pakistani rupeeDevaluation of Pakistani rupee
Devaluation of Pakistani rupee
 
Ib
IbIb
Ib
 

Destacado

Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-I
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-IGuia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-I
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-IDavid Leon Sicilia
 
Housing and the Family
Housing and the FamilyHousing and the Family
Housing and the FamilyAndy Carswell
 
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011id
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011idRevista Arqitec Media Kit 2011id
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011idarqitec
 
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden Treasure
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden TreasureHomebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden Treasure
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden TreasureAndy Carswell
 
Being green in the workplace
Being green in the workplaceBeing green in the workplace
Being green in the workplaceJessica Brookes
 
Electronic Software Delivery at IOM
Electronic Software Delivery at IOMElectronic Software Delivery at IOM
Electronic Software Delivery at IOMFlexera
 
Getting smarter about discovery streaming
Getting smarter about discovery streamingGetting smarter about discovery streaming
Getting smarter about discovery streamingMatt Strine
 
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.Jessica Brookes
 
Q Pres Marzo 2010
Q Pres Marzo 2010Q Pres Marzo 2010
Q Pres Marzo 2010Quadrante
 
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFG
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFGGuia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFG
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFGDavid Leon Sicilia
 
Pradip's art profile 2015
Pradip's art profile 2015Pradip's art profile 2015
Pradip's art profile 2015Freelancer
 
Fixing Design-Time Validation Errors
Fixing Design-Time Validation ErrorsFixing Design-Time Validation Errors
Fixing Design-Time Validation ErrorsFlexera
 
Crafting Virtual Space
Crafting Virtual SpaceCrafting Virtual Space
Crafting Virtual SpaceArthur Hash
 
Workflow Manager Datasheet
Workflow Manager DatasheetWorkflow Manager Datasheet
Workflow Manager DatasheetFlexera
 
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolah
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolahJebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolah
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolahzaenal mukodir
 
Smart Response VE
Smart Response VESmart Response VE
Smart Response VEMatt Strine
 

Destacado (20)

Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-I
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-IGuia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-I
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013-I
 
Profesh2016
Profesh2016Profesh2016
Profesh2016
 
Workflows en Moss2007
Workflows en Moss2007Workflows en Moss2007
Workflows en Moss2007
 
Housing and the Family
Housing and the FamilyHousing and the Family
Housing and the Family
 
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011id
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011idRevista Arqitec Media Kit 2011id
Revista Arqitec Media Kit 2011id
 
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden Treasure
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden TreasureHomebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden Treasure
Homebuyer Assistance: Discovering Hidden Treasure
 
Being green in the workplace
Being green in the workplaceBeing green in the workplace
Being green in the workplace
 
Turkey report full
Turkey report fullTurkey report full
Turkey report full
 
Electronic Software Delivery at IOM
Electronic Software Delivery at IOMElectronic Software Delivery at IOM
Electronic Software Delivery at IOM
 
Getting smarter about discovery streaming
Getting smarter about discovery streamingGetting smarter about discovery streaming
Getting smarter about discovery streaming
 
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.
Becoming one with the world. Child poverty. The Facts.
 
Q Pres Marzo 2010
Q Pres Marzo 2010Q Pres Marzo 2010
Q Pres Marzo 2010
 
Anthro Pln
Anthro PlnAnthro Pln
Anthro Pln
 
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFG
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFGGuia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFG
Guia de ordenamiento para la firma del libro de acta 2013 PFG
 
Pradip's art profile 2015
Pradip's art profile 2015Pradip's art profile 2015
Pradip's art profile 2015
 
Fixing Design-Time Validation Errors
Fixing Design-Time Validation ErrorsFixing Design-Time Validation Errors
Fixing Design-Time Validation Errors
 
Crafting Virtual Space
Crafting Virtual SpaceCrafting Virtual Space
Crafting Virtual Space
 
Workflow Manager Datasheet
Workflow Manager DatasheetWorkflow Manager Datasheet
Workflow Manager Datasheet
 
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolah
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolahJebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolah
Jebakan hukum swakelola rehabilitasi sekolah
 
Smart Response VE
Smart Response VESmart Response VE
Smart Response VE
 

Similar a Senior analyst jan 11(1)

Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan
Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan
Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan mnathani
 
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...Hiram Ruiz
 
Devaluation presentation 1
Devaluation presentation 1Devaluation presentation 1
Devaluation presentation 1Asma4646
 
The RMB in Global Markets
The RMB in Global Markets The RMB in Global Markets
The RMB in Global Markets Tuck Seng Low
 
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tail
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tailCase Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tail
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tailkhalid ekram
 
Influence of SDR on RMB Internationalization
Influence of SDR on RMB InternationalizationInfluence of SDR on RMB Internationalization
Influence of SDR on RMB InternationalizationIJAEMSJORNAL
 
Future of Currency - Initial Persepctive
Future of Currency  - Initial PersepctiveFuture of Currency  - Initial Persepctive
Future of Currency - Initial PersepctiveFuture Agenda
 
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currency
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currencyIs it the right time to introduce new global reserve currency
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currencyRatan Kumar
 
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?Brien Desilets
 
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyright
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyrightResearch_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyright
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyrightWilliam Shonk
 
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment Currency
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment CurrencyA Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment Currency
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment CurrencyThe Economist Media Businesses
 

Similar a Senior analyst jan 11(1) (16)

Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan
Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan
Understanding the coming domination of Chinese Yuan
 
Tianjin Case Study
Tianjin Case StudyTianjin Case Study
Tianjin Case Study
 
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...
The trilemma as a framework for understanding China and India’s recent moneta...
 
Internationalization of the yuan and Latin America.docx
Internationalization of the yuan and Latin America.docxInternationalization of the yuan and Latin America.docx
Internationalization of the yuan and Latin America.docx
 
Devaluation presentation 1
Devaluation presentation 1Devaluation presentation 1
Devaluation presentation 1
 
The RMB in Global Markets
The RMB in Global Markets The RMB in Global Markets
The RMB in Global Markets
 
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tail
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tailCase Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tail
Case Study: The Chinese Yuan-Beware of Dragon’s tail
 
Influence of SDR on RMB Internationalization
Influence of SDR on RMB InternationalizationInfluence of SDR on RMB Internationalization
Influence of SDR on RMB Internationalization
 
Future of Currency - Initial Persepctive
Future of Currency  - Initial PersepctiveFuture of Currency  - Initial Persepctive
Future of Currency - Initial Persepctive
 
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currency
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currencyIs it the right time to introduce new global reserve currency
Is it the right time to introduce new global reserve currency
 
Dollar Drums
Dollar DrumsDollar Drums
Dollar Drums
 
presentation
presentationpresentation
presentation
 
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?
Will the US Rebound Cause Another Emerging Markets Crisis?
 
INTERNATIONAL FINANCE
INTERNATIONAL FINANCEINTERNATIONAL FINANCE
INTERNATIONAL FINANCE
 
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyright
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyrightResearch_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyright
Research_Project_Final_Draft._Shonk,_Will DONE copyright
 
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment Currency
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment CurrencyA Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment Currency
A Delicate Stage: The Future of Renminbi as a Global Investment Currency
 

Último

Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Pooja Nehwal
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfGale Pooley
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdfFinTech Belgium
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spiritegoetzinger
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxhiddenlevers
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryPooja Nehwal
 
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Bookingroncy bisnoi
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...ssifa0344
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingMaristelaRamos12
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfGale Pooley
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdfAdnet Communications
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Modelshematsharma006
 
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja Nehwal
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...shivangimorya083
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 

Último (20)

Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 23.pdf
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Jodhpur Park 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
06_Joeri Van Speybroek_Dell_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pdf
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
 
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Koregaon Park Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
 
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
20240429 Calibre April 2024 Investor Presentation.pdf
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
20240417-Calibre-April-2024-Investor-Presentation.pdf
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
 
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
 

Senior analyst jan 11(1)

  • 1.
  • 2. CONTENTS World Section • Will the Chinese Yuan be the next reserve currency? 3 Special Feature : Financial Inclusion • Financial Inclusion:Congealing Altruism & Profitability to 5 mitigate financial disparity • Using Microfinance for social upliftment through Financial Inclusion. 7 Stock Analysis • Equity Research Report::Nahar Spinning Mills 9 Economics • Analysis of Private Equity Investments in India in Second 11 half of 2010 and Beyond. 13 • Key Trends & Issues in the Global Banking Sector. • Why Disinvestment For Indian Economy 15 • The Demise of the Celtic Tiger 17 2 The Senior Analyst
  • 3. In the past few WILL THE CHINESE YUAN BE THE NEXT RESERVE CURRENCY? months we have seen that In the past few months we have seen that there has been a lot of speculation and hype about the Chinese Renmimbi (RMB) or the Yuan becoming the next reserve currency. In this article there has been we will focus on the various factors that can help and also the factors that are against the speculation regarding the Yuan, considering the global dynamics of politics and trade. a lot of Let us first understand what exactly is meant by a reserve currency. A reserve currency is one that forms significant part of foreign exchange reserves of governments and institutions which speculation enables a country to meet international debt obligations and to influence their domestic exchange rate. and hype about Factors that influence the use of a currency for reserves are as follows: • The size of the economy the Chinese • The importance of the economy in international trade • The openness of the financial markets Renmimbi • The convertibility of the currency • Use of the currency as currency peg (RMB) or the • Macroeconomic policies, as it influences the domestic environment A Brief on China’s past and current status of economy Yuan becoming China’s success story is not new. Till the end of 15th century, China was the leader in technology & had the highest per-capita GDP on the planet. Europe overtook China in per the next capita GDP around 1500 but China remained the world’s biggest economy until well in the reserve 19th century. In fact in 1820, the middle kingdom accounted for one third of World’s economy. However the tide turned against China & by 1950 it suffered with one of the lowest currency. In per capita GDP in the World and accounted for less than 5% of world GDP. Since 1980s growth took off again, owing to demographic dividend, export driven growth, cheap & this article we abundant labour availability coupled with potential to become the world’s largest consumer market. With help of State initiatives, China’s fiscal revenues have increased 30 times over the will focus on past 20 years. Having maintained a phenomenal GDP growth rate of 9.5% for decades, China is now the World’s second largest economy. the various Problems with the US dollar as global reserve currency Currently US Dollar is the most widely held reserve currency as two thirds of the foreign factors that reserve of nations is in US Dollar terms. But things are no longer as smooth for the US Dollar as it used to be. There has been a steady decline in the dollar reserve holding percentage by can help and various countries. The global economic crisis of 2008 leading to rising US debt (The U.S.’s ratio of total debt to GDP is likely to exceed 90% this year) which keeps US dependent on also the factors foreign financing and the increasing influence of China as a global power along with demand of countries like Russia for a new reserve currency have brought in the possibility of the that are against Chinese Yuan as the next reserve currency. But being the most widely accepted reserve the speculation currency is no easy job and there are various factors at play which go for and against the Yuan. Inspite of the above mentioned facts, one important reason the US dollar remains the regarding the reserve currency is that the U.S. treasury market is the most liquid market which allows central banks to intervene in foreign exchange markets in order to smooth currency Yuan, fluctuations. considering the global dynamics of politics and trade. 3 The Senior Analyst
  • 4. Now let us look at the factors which might prompt the Chinese government to work towards making the Renmimbi the next reserve currency. The most important reason is overwhelming dependence of the Chinese on the US dollar. It is estimated that Beijing holds about $2 (2.6) trillion of dollar assets mainly accumulated through purchase of US Treasuries and through exports to the USA. The USA has been incurring rising budget deficits in recent years. This is major concern for the Chinese government as a weakening dollar could seriously dent the Chinese reserves. Movement towards global reserve currency There have been many steps taken by the Chinese government aimed at strengthening the cause of Yuan and improving its visibility. Recently Beijing carried out a series of currency swaps with central banks of countries like Argentina, Hong Kong, Malaysia and South Korea. This currency swap will remove the need for using the Dollar when it comes to trade with these countries. It also carried out a trade deal with Brazil valued at $95 billion in two other currencies other than the Dollar. The Chinese government is even thinking of issuing bonds and loans to trading companies in Yuan rather than in Dollar. In fact banks like HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank are said to have agreed to issuing bonds in Yuan. China has recently allowed Yuan to trade off shore in Hong Kong. Though the Yuan still remains a foreign currency market for Hong Kong and the local currency is still the Hong Kong dollar, but the offshore financial centre is being used as a laboratory to internationalize the Chinese currency. Problems that needs to be tackled In spite of the steps taken by the Chinese government there are various factors which pose practical and huge challenges to the Yuan being the next Reserve Currency. The main challenge is that the dollar is too entrenched in the international currency market. However the bigger issue is making the Yuan convertible with its value being determined by market conditions, governments and companies around the world who would be allowed to freely trade, buy and sell the currency. Given the authoritarian nature of the Chinese government, lowering of these financial trade barriers and allowing foreign trade access to the Chinese securities market seems like a remote possibility. The absence of a large market for Yuan bonds is also seen as a hindrance. Currently only the Chinese Banks and the Asian Development bank sell Yuan dominated bonds. According to some experts it is numerically impossible for the Yuan to become the reserve currency as then China would have to run a large current account deficit so that the governments and the institutions which trade in Yuan would get a chance to accumulate it. But currently China has a huge current account surplus which does not give foreigners to accumulate the Yuan. Things that China can do to favour its case If the Chinese government does decide to make the Yuan as the next reserve currency, the expected time line is expected to be around 10 to 15 years. It has to push through the reforms before Yuan can be allowed to float freely against the dollar. It can easily take China around 5 to 10 years to bring about a change through its land reforms, reforms in the energy sector, social welfare. China would have to gradually make the Yuan convertible on the capital account. It needs a more liquid foreign exchange market, as the US treasury market is currently the most liquid market. The bond markets and banking system needs to be more developed and there has to be proper monitoring of cross-border capital flows. The importance of having functioning capital markets cannot be understated as investors and Central Banks buying Yuan would not want to simply invest in paper currency and instead would want stocks and bonds that trade transparently Alternatives to the Yuan In this context there are various other alternatives which are possible. One such possibility is establishing a multi currency system and the use of Special Drawing Rights (SDR) which is based on a basket of currencies. The Euro is also gaining prominence and the developing economies are also playing an increasingly dominant role in world economic order. Whether the world order changes to accept Yuan or any other currency like Euro or a mixed bag of currency as the next reserve currency is for all of us to see. The fact remains that hold of US dollar as the reserve currency is slipping and China on its part is using its economic might through trade exports to penetrate world market to garner support for the Yuan as the next global reserve currency. -Ankit Agarwal & Shachi Prakash(FMS) Whether the world order changes to accept Yuan or any other currency like Euro or a mixed bag of currency as the next reserve currency is for all of us to see. 4 The Senior Analyst
  • 5. INTRODUCTION: UNDERSTANDING THE NEED Financial inclusion is delivery of call microfinance; a method of injecting banking services at an affordable cost capital into highly industrious groups to the vast sections of disadvantaged of people in villages across the and low income groups. This inclusion developing world. It was a perfect forms the basis of economic example where profitability and opportunity. It enables the poor to altruism went hand in hand leading to build savings, make investments and financial inclusion. Grameen Bank insure themselves against income made a profit of $ 680,000 in 2007 shocks thereby entailing progress of while providing access to credit to the nation. Yet the statistics on millions of underprivileged financial ‘exclusion' in India are Bangladeshi’s. The bank expects to disheartening. Out of the 600,000 loan $1.4 billion in 2010 and continues habitations in the country, only about to challenge conventional banking 30,000, or just 5 per cent, have a wisdom by banking the "unbankable". commercial bank branch. Just about 2> The success story of Dharavi, a 40 per cent of the population across bustling industrial-slum in Mumbai is the country has bank accounts, and another heartening example where this ratio is much lower in the north- Financial inclusion proved to be a east of the country. viable business proposition. Hindu Business line reports that Dharavi exports goods worth $500-650 million ALTRUISM & every year. Initially though, Dharavi, PROFITABILITY CAN being situated right in the heart of CO-EXIST Mumbai, the most banked city in the country, did not have a commercial Financial inclusion is a potentially bank branch for a long time. The first viable business proposition; it is the commercial bank branch was opened key driver for social change and can in February 2007. In just three years, greatly ameliorate the imbalances in the bank registered business in excess society. Envisioning a plan for financial of Rs 44 crore. Today, there are nine inclusion which is profitable while ATMs in Dharavi, all of them being concurrently being altruistic can lead actively used. This proved that money to rapid growth both in urban and rural management is a well-understood part areas, thereby creating a country that of everyday life of the poor, and witnesses all-round development. therefore a viable business proposition. 1> One such format was established From the above successful models of by Muhammad Yunus. He started off in financial inclusion, it can be stated that the village of Jobra with a belief that banking the unbanked can indeed be a financial credit is “A Human Right” and win-win opportunity. However, such created a whole system that we now incidences of profitability cum altruistic Congealing Altruism & Financial Inclusion Profitability to mitigate financial disparity 5 The Senior Analyst
  • 6. ALTRUISM & The primary objective of any business is to make profits. A failure to achieve this goal makes an organization unsustainable, thereby all other goals PROFITABILITY ARE redundant. Financial inclusion from this perspective is a secondary objective. Although there have been A MISMATCH instances where altruism and profitability have gone hand in hand, there is no denying the fact that tailoring your organizational goals to meet the goals of social upliftment can introduce a significant amount of risk to your returns. The second aspect to be considered is the relevance of Micro Finance Institutions in a realm where they charge exorbitant interest rates. Interest rates of MFIs are currently in the bracket of 35-40 % which sounds very high. But we should not forget that it is high because of huge risks involved and the demand of funds outstrips the supply. The alternative the consumer faces is that of private lenders whose interest rates vary from 350-400 % depending on the desperation of customer. Hence, we are stuck in a conundrum where MFIs, though providing relief from the clutches of private lenders, cannot be considered an effective medium to eradicate poverty. Loans provided at 30% interest rate cannot be considered a platform for altruism rather resemble more of a profit accruing venture. The third aspect is the government policy which forces banks to lend to categorized priority sectors. As the recent report on Non- Performing Assets of banks has shown, the banks NPAs have grown due to priority sector lending norms. This trend if left unchecked could well lead to financial crisis. For example the compulsory priority lending requirement has resulted NPAs raising to 3.4% from last year’s 2.5%. The numbers tell the tale of a clear dichotomy between profitability and altruism with severe repercussions looming large. Finally, the market tend to meet the demand for credit (if there are not too many impediments) only if it makes business sense. The very fact that market has not yet considered this segment as profitable shows that it makes very little business sense or the returns are too insignificant to be considered desirable. In such a scenario it becomes more pertinent to eradicate barriers which might be preventing entry while simultaneously creating an enabling environment which would allure institutions to consider delivering a financial inclusion model which balances altruism as well as profitability. CONCLUSION In today’s world financial exclusion can lead to social exclusion and in order to address this shortfall one needs a holistic approach on the part of government and private players to bring about innovative financial products. After taking a comprehensive look towards the various possibilities and obstructions in amalgamating altruism and profitability it can be said that banks need to redesign their business strategies to incorporate specific plans to promote financial inclusion of low income group, treating it both as a business opportunity as well as a corporate social responsibility. They have to make use of all available resources including technology and expertise available with them as well as the MFIs and NGOs. Taking banking to the sections constituting “the bottom of the pyramid”, might appear to be considerably difficult and loss-making proposition however it should always be remembered that even the relatively low margins on high volumes can be a very profitable proposition. Financial inclusion can emerge as a commercially profitable business provided the government makes the right policy decisions and banks are prepared to think outside the box! -Alnoor S Venkani & Clement Joy Kingsly(FMS) In today’s world financial exclusion can lead to social exclusion and in order to address this shortfall one needs a holistic approach on the part of government and private players to bring about innovative financial products. 6 The Senior Analyst
  • 7. “Financial inclusion is USING MICROFINANCE the timely delivery of financial services to FOR SOCIAL disadvantaged sections of society. UPLIFTMENT THROUGH Firstly, financial inclusion refers to a FINANCIAL INCLUSION So why is financial inclusion so important in the Indian context, to the extent of being a customer having compulsion, not a choice? There are ample theoretical and empirical evidence to show that access to a range of financial inclusion leads to economic growth and economic growth to poverty reduction. The formal financial works of Levine (1997) and Honohan (2004) show that a robust financial system can become services, from simple an effective poverty alleviation tool. There are large costs to small and poor entrepreneurs due to the market imperfections in a poorly developed financial system. These burdens include credit and savings informational asymmetries, transaction costs, and contract enforcement costs, compounded services to the more by lack of collateral, credit history, and contacts. For these entrepreneurs, access to financial complex such as services would smooth project financing, positively impacting growth and poverty alleviation. Access to finance is also an important incentive for new ideas and technologies. Additionally, insurance and a strong financial system encourages expansion in the market and competition for existing pensions. Secondly, firms. It ensures that poor households and small entrepreneurs need not depend on financial inclusion middlemen. On the other hand, an underdeveloped financial system can be uncompetitive, implies that conservative and inimical to poor or small entrepreneurs. In a seminal study looking at India’s vast banking system, Burgess and Pande (2003) show that the rural bank expansion customers have programme, mandated by the Indian government from 1977 – 1990, can explain access to more than approximately half of the drop in poverty from 61% in 1967 to 31% in 2000. India needs one financial services financial inclusion to make available the fruits of sustained 8% growth to all its citizens, especially the minority and the backwards. This can prove provider, which to be the answer to a lot of problems we face in our ensures a variety of times like rising extremism, naxalism, rising income competitive options. disparity and so on. In the Indian context, A look back at India’s financial inclusion history might be appropriate at this point. One of the major tipping points financial inclusion, for the nationalization of banks in 1969 was ensuring according to the credit access to agriculture and small-scale cottage Finance Minister’s industries. Towards this end, RBI stipulated that at least 40% of bank lending go towards this sector termed as 2006-07 budget the Priority Sector, 25% of which had to be extended to speech, was defined the weaker sections within the Priority Sector. Other as “the process of features of nationalised banking included the ‘Service ensuring access to Area Approach’ (SAA) wherein a single bank was assigned 15-20 villages, after which other banks could timely and adequate set up branches upon obtaining the initial bank’s credit and financial approval. Similarly, the 1:4 license rule was established services by vulnerable in 1977 dictated that a bank could open a branch in a banked location only after opening four branches in groups at an unbanked locations. As a result the share of these affordable cost” sectors in the total advances of scheduled commercial banks rose from 14% in 1969 to 33% in 1980. However, the reforms introduced since 1991 in the banking system have had a heavy toll on small borrowers. The spread of banking credit facilities has not only halted but the number of small borrowers getting financial facilities too sharply declined in the post- liberalization period. From 1990-91 to 1996-97, loan accounts to agriculture fell by 5 million. While 52% of bank credit in rural areas went towards agriculture in 1985, the proportion fell to 38% in 1998. In fact, the present share (percent) of rural bank offices to total bank offices is equal to that of the 1980s, i.e., 45.69% in 2005 and 45.72% in 1980s. 7 The Senior Analyst
  • 8. Financial inclusion in a financial system can volumes that translate low premiums into is eaten up as bribes in all forms of be measured by its “depth” and its fair profit. The Dr Rangarajan Committee financial institutions. “breadth”. While depth is the extent to report states that 49.77% of Scheduled How can India achieve its intention of Total which the system is developed and works Caste households, 63.68% of Scheduled Financial Inclusion by 2012? To be frank, properly, breadth refers to the extent of Tribe households and 48.58% of Other standing at the current date, it is next to outreach of the system to the population. Backward Class households are financially impossible. For this certain measures are Thanks to the nationalization program India excluded. There is denial from the already in place, but need to pursue them is better placed than many other government machineries to extend the more actively. developing economies. There are over credit to the Scheduled Castes because Changes at the policy level: A policy 32,000 rural bank branches (with a total of direct funding from banks is a problem. change to encourage the public to invest 68,000 rural and semi-urban branches) Most schemes require paper work, their savings should be brought about. RBI including public and private sector banks recommendations, forwarding of has already introduced policy changes in and RRBs. There are more than 15,000 applications, and other processes which 2005. These include introduction of no frills branches of RRB. Rural co-operative banks they can’t facilitate. Existing societal accounts without minimum balance comprise about 98,000 retail outlets of mechanisms continue to regulate and clauses and Kisan Credit Cards for easy Primary Agricultural Credit Societies (PACS). The post office system, comprising 154,000 post office branches, has about 114 million savings accounts and services 110 million money orders. One of the major indicators of health of a financial inclusion of a system is “access to credit”. Despite this vast network of banks, only about 30% of Indians have a savings account. All of us have heard stories of rural families literally selling themselves off to moneylenders as a result of not being able to service the exorbitant rate of interests (an average of enforce the customary norms and rules of transactions, relaxation of Know Your 48%, as compared to 12.5% in commercial the caste system. Those, who challenge Customer (KYC) forms for accounts having banks). There has been a disturbing trend the system face opposition in the form of balance of less than 50,000 and less than of rise in borrowings from moneylenders social and economic boycott, violence, etc, 100,000 as loans annually, and reasonable post 1991, after steady decline post which negate their right to development. A pricing by banks for services rendered. nationalization. major problem is the barriers to credit Another crucial step is the encouragement So what is stopping us from utilizing the full access that these people face. A survey by of microfinance institutions who have tried potential of our banking infrastructure and Invest India Market Solutions (IIMS) shows to fill up the void created after the that there is a strong link between commercial banks left rural market. More annual income and ownership of and more developmental agencies are bank accounts by occupation group. using microfinance as a tool for sustainable A survey of bank managers in development, a trend started by Self- Madhya Pradesh revealed a Employed Women’s Association, SEWA. perception that women borrowers In conclusion, it can be said that, despite were more trustworthy and less of a having the requisite infrastructure in place, default risk (United Nations, 2006). the sheer apathy and lack of policy However, a greater percentage still implementation is holding back the poor believed that women were simply 400 million Indians from realizing their alleviating ourselves from poverty? The being used by men to gain loans. One potential fully. But change can’t be brought answer lies in looking at the problems of more reason is the self exclusion by the from one side. A population low on financial inclusion on this country. It is still low income households from banking awareness and education can’t fully utilize facilities as they get intimidated and the benefits of institutional finance. For a dream to see a bank that offers savings develop a belief that banks are intended for that, policies like right to education are accounts for the poor with cheque book facility unless she/he keeps Rs 1,000 more educated and richer individuals. Also, crucial to raise the general education level, minimum balance. The health insurance almost 90% of the loans disbursed need especially the rural poor and backwards. companies set very low hospital tariffs for collaterals, which in case of rural poor is Also, strict vigil on eliminating social land. Hence, a major part of the landless ostracization has to be brought in to give re i m b u r s e m e n t w h i c h m a k e s t h e m poor get excluded. Plus, a 2006 UN survey everybody an equal opportunity to unattractive. Operational service is lacking as most insurance companies are ill suggests that 10-20% of the loan amount determine their own destiny. equipped to handle the necessary large -Soumyadipta Chakraborty & Yashowardhan Chaturvedi(XLRI) 8 The Senior Analyst
  • 9. NAHAR SPINNING MILLS Introduction about Nahar Spinning contributing 14 % in total industrial Mills production, 17 % in foreign exchange It was started as a spinning and and 4% in GDP. Government policies hosiery unit in Ludhiana .The Company like Technology up-gradation fund is the part of Nahar Group of scheme (TUFS),Scheme of Integrated Companies. The group`s portfolio Textile Park(SITP) technology Mission include wool combing, spinning, of Cotton (TMC) and 2 % interest knitting, fabric, hosiery garments etc. subvention from exports has helped Nahar spinning mills is a blue chip in this sector to grow at a rapid rate. its group. Nahar Spinning’s T-shirts are From the recent past the India Textile being exported to reputed international products have become cheaper than brands such as GAP, Arrow, Old Navy, of china due to the appreciation of Pierre Cardin, Izod, and Quicksilver. Chinese Yuan and wage inflation in Recently the company got Golden China. The domestic factor which Trophy by the Apparel Export supports the growth of this industry Promotion Council and Gold Trophy by are increasing purchasing power of The Cotton Textiles Export Promotion both domestic and rural markets and Council. growing organized retail in India. Key Highlight of the company Segmented Revenue • The company is the best amongst Nahar has a current capacity of 3.35 its peers and has an attractive P/E lakh spindles to produce cotton yarn/ ratio of 4.77 and industry P/E is 9.06 Synthetic yarn respectively .It has • Spreads of cotton yarn is planned for an addition of 90000 increasing continuously spindles by July 2011. In the textile • The company is developing its and hosiery garments has a current own retail brand Cotton County capacity of 14 lakhs pieces per year. • The board has approved for a The current capacity utilization of capital expenditure of 400 Crore under garments is 50.57% .The domestic TUFS with a capacity expansion of and international demand for garments about 33 percent of current capacity will have the capability to push the capacity utilization to 87 % by Textile Sector Analysis 2013.The wastes are the material Indian Textile industry is having waste generated in spinning and significant presence in domestic and garments manufacturing sold at a global economy. Indian textile industry cheaper price. Around 65-70 percent plays a major role in Indian economy of the revenue comes from exports. by RESEARCH BSE Code:500296 NSE Code: NAHARSPING Industry: Textile REPORT::NAHAR SPINNING Group: B Market Cap :402.13cr Promoter holding:63% 9 The Senior Analyst
  • 10. Expenditure Analysis Depreciation Analysis Considering the stock will trade at The major part of the expenditure are The plant and machinery, Land and 5.5X PE the stock will reach a target building are the major fixed assets in the price of Rs200/- in 24 months with a organization. As per the previous financial growth rate of 79 percent. statements the depreciation for plant and machinery is at the rate of at 10 percent y- -Sanjeev Kumar & Selva Kumar(NITIE) o-y .The depreciation for land and building is at the rate of 12 percent y-o-y. In fiscal year 2010-2012 it has added machinery in the yarn segment. contributed by Raw material cost and power and the fuel cost .The major part of the raw material consumed by the company are Raw cotton and cotton yarn .In the fiscal year 2010-2011 the cotton prices had a huge price fluctuations at the end the Raw cotton per Kg in January 2011 quoted at Rs 80/- in New Delhi according to CMIE. Nahar has a strategy to hold more inventory of Cotton which forms around 90 percent of the raw materials to avoid price fluctuation and weather fluctuations. Power crisis is one of the major threat to the company .The company has mitigated the power risk by installing captive power plant of 4.1 MW capacity in July 2011. Interest Analysis Interest is one of the major expenses to the company. In the fiscal year 2008-2010 because of the economic recession the company in order to meet the financial obligations of the company .The financial leverage has shown a huge variation in that particular year. The term loans and the working capital loans are contracted at interest rate of 5-8% .The weighted average cost of interest rate is 5.75%. The company plans to obtain 400 Cr term loans at an interest rate of 5% with the help of TUFS under textile ministry in fiscal year 2011 and 2012. 10 The Senior Analyst
  • 11. ANALYSIS OF PRIVATE EQUITY INVESTMENTS IN INDIA IN SECOND HALF OF 2010 AND BEYOND Overview of PE Investments in India during July-Dec 2010 Deal volumes reported in September and October were lower compared to August. Real Estate remained the favorite sector in September and October, unlike Energy in August. Most of the investments in energy sector came from Blackstone investing in Moser Baer for around $ 300Mn. Healthcare industry although having large number of deals remained small in terms of value due to smaller deal sizes. HDFC VC’s 10% stake purchase in Lodha Group’s “World One”, the world’s tallest residential project for $ 111Mn was the largest PE deal during the given period in Real Estate, followed PE Investments in 2010 After two years of drooping Private Equity Investments in India, year 2010 saw a major shift with around 100% jump. The level of PE Investments in 2010 came out to be 7974Mn $ with around 325 deals. Moreover, the average investment per deal also rose from 14Mn to 24.5Mn per deal signifying investments in even bigger projects in 2010. Interestingly, the level of PE investments in 2010 nearly equaled the prior slowdown year investments of 2006 of 7485Mn $. The effect of Global Economic scenario causes the roller coaster ride of PE investments in India. However, there are many internal factors which are impeding the growth of PE investments: • Strong macroeconomic fundamentals are making India an attractive destination for PE investments. However, decreasing investment opportunities in developed countries is fuelling enough completion in India. by Kotak Realty Fund’s $ 55.56Mn in EmaarMGF. • Removing legal roadblocks by regulators, Month wise analysis of PE investments which block PE investments in some sectors. July was the gloomiest period during the past four months, with the number of deals Thereby, diminishing its potential. being the least. Also the deal volume was very relatively small. India was witnessing • Reluctance of Indian businesses working greater inflow of Private equity inflow into the country after the financial meltdown. with the PE/VC investors may cause their There were two prime reasons for this drive: businesses remaining untapped. Promoters • Stocks of Indian markets were battered during the slowdown and were trading at can enhance their business value by aligning very low premiums, which provided ample opportunity for PE and VC firms to invest with partners having similar vision. in some good companies. • PE firms need to understand the • Signals of strong economic growth in the emerging countries while the US and intricacies of the business in India through Europe still not showing signs of recovery from the economic recession. honing their investment capabilities along each phase of investment life cycles. • Easy availability of cheap capital in from the US encouraged them to invest in Average deal size in India has been relatively some undervalued firms through Private equity. small when compared to China/other 11 The Senior Analyst
  • 12. During the month of August, PE firms sector would also enhance investments in compared to investing $ 4.7Bn last year started investing in India through the debt food and beverages industry. Rising through 331 deals in Infrastructure sector. market for the first time. Therefore, the deal incomes and inflation are creating Infrastructure sector is likely lead the PE volume during August shot up by around favorable condition for investments in this investment in 2011, leaving behind the 100%. KKR Private Equity was the first to it sector. financial services sector, which received through their global NBFC arm. The prime d) Education the highest investment in 2010, primarily advantage is enhancing company’s Education Industry which saw three fold due to increasing interest in real estate v a l u a t i o n , t h e re b y b u i l d i n g b e t t e r raises in 2009 remained as one of the most post financial meltdown. Due to large relationship with the promoters, enhancing lucrative sector. With impending reforms in amount of PE capital being absorbed by the chances of conversion of PE Deal. the sector, the sector might witness the infrastructure sector, the financial phenomenal investments in recent years. services firms might receive much lesser Sector wise Analysis of PE Investments However, the investment size mismatch is PE investments compared to $ 2.1Bn in in India acting as a major deterrent, due to limited 2010. a) Real Estate number to educational assets to be About 20-25% of PE investments would be Although the poor infrastructure sector in employed with investments over $ 25Mn done in infrastructure sector, primarily due India being one of the major deterrents for which PE firms are targeting. to banks unwilling to lend them and PE investments coming to India, it is e) A l t e r n a t e E n e r g y a n d C l e a n secondarily due to small corporate bond finding the highest preference among the Technology market. Thereby, the PE funds would play a PE Investors in recent times. Thereby, Alternate Energy & Clean Technology is crucial role in the infrastructure investment Energy, Real Estate & Construction emerging as one of the major PE sector of India in 2011. Blackstone Group together accounted for nearly two-thirds of investments in recent years as India alone may invest more than $ 1Bn in India all PE investments by deal size. The largest struggles with power deficit and next year. deal during the six month period came environmental worries. Moreover, the Indian PE firms may face stiff competition from Blackstone group investing about $ policies of the government are encouraging from the foreign PE firms finding good 300Mn in Moser Baer for investing in investors to some extent, like levying tax investment opportunities in 2011. Other power sector. Blackstone is reported to on the use of coal to fund the further invest $ 1Bn for investing in renewable energy projects. infrastructure for next few years, signifying International Finance the continuing dominance of infrastructure Corporation (IFC) made 5 sector. deals alone since the month b) BFSI, IT & Healthcare of August in this sector. BFSI, IT and Healthcare sectors attracted f) Logistics deals of relatively smaller value; however Investment in the logistics they remained relatively significant in terms segment has shown of total investments made. significant decline, the c) Retail and Food & Beverages primary reason being the mismatch between the deal sizes. While PE players are looking at deals of at least $ than the IPO exit route, secondary sales 50Mn, logistics companies are likely gain popularity next year, after 18 are agreeing for deals up secondary sales in 2010. Primarily due to to $ 20Mn. the lack of sufficient capital for next stage 5) Roadmap for the of growth by small Indian PE firms. Like, Private Equity Investment Warburg Pincus buying ICICI Venture in 2011 fund’s stake in Metroplis Healthcare. 2011 Like 2010, PE investments might witness an increasing number of are expected to flow into fund managers leaving their jobs with India with twice the global PE firms to open their own venture, Industry investments in 2010 and even greater with economy thriving and opening Investments in retail remained miniscule returns. Nearly $ 30Bn is waiting to be opportunities. largely due to the untapped retail sector. deployed next year, creating chances of However, the impending decision on multi even bigger deals. In 2010, PE firms -Shashank(National Institute of Industrial branding retailing brings possibility for Engineering) employed $ 8.3Bn through 376 deals, huge investments. Unlocking the retailing 12 The Senior Analyst
  • 13. After a KEY TRENDS & ISSUES IN THE catastrophic GLOBAL BANKING SECTOR 2008 and a (2010) fragile 2009, the Introduction global banking After a catastrophic 2008 and a fragile 2009, the global banking industry showed signs of revival in the year 2010 even as numerous challenges, both remnants of the past and some industry showed emerging over the year, continued to lay siege to its strong and sustained recovery. The signs of revival in unprecedented easing in liquidity through liberal monetary and fiscal policies helped no doubt, as did the revival in the equity market. The banking sector as a whole showed a rise in the year 2010 net income, even though the earning quality remained a major issue, as most of it came from sources other than traditional interest income. Questions also remain over the capital levels in even as the banks as the Governments start to withdraw the stimuli effects and the norms of the enhanced Basel II regime come into force. numerous challenges, both Stricter Regulations remnants of the As the epicentre of the financial crisis lay in the banking industry itself, attempts were made to subject it to stricter regulation. The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision introduced past and some ‘The Capital and Liquidity Reform Package’ in July, 2010 introducing new agreed upon emerging over definitions in the treatment of capital, counterparty credit risk, leverage ratio, regulatory buffers and global liquidity standards. The Committee also stressed on introducing counter the year, cyclical provisions and buffers and credit-to-GDP gap was accepted as the best performing indicator for calibrating the same. In September 2010, the Committee introduced the continued to lay enhanced Basel II regime which significantly increased the capital requirements from the existing Basel II norms. In order to prevent the banks from facing immediate liquidity threats, siege to its a phased implementation of the same was suggested, starting from 2013 and continuing till strong and 2019. Also, a counter cyclical buffer measure was proposed in addition to the existing capital norms of Basel II. sustained recovery. The unprecedented easing in liquidity through liberal monetary and fiscal policies helped no doubt, as did the revival in the equity market. 13 The Senior Analyst
  • 14. Global Financial Markets completely recover their losses. The year 2007 and 2008 has seen an The opposite was true, however, unprecedented contraction in the global for bank stocks in the emerging money market as counterparty risk countries, which almost came increased tremendously and the LIBOR- back to the pre-crisis level as a OIS spread reached new heights. However, result of strong balance sheets the sustained efforts of the Governments and better growth prospects. and Central banks around the world helped Similar trend was observed for the money market to settle down in 2010. credit market which continued its Nasty surprises still lay in store though as tedious progress from the freezing the sovereign debt crisis in Europe again over during the financial crisis. put the money market under renewed Initially aided and abetted by the stress in the middle of 2010. policy measures of the The sovereign debt crisis posed one of the Government, it began to recover strongest challenges to the global financial on its own as the liquidity and industry during the year. Governments all market risks eased at the end of over the world and especially those in the 2009. However, a large chunk of fringes of Europe, struggled to recover the global credit demand is still from the financial crisis and huge coming from Governments and Government stimuli after years of over- other sovereign entities while spending, low taxation and massive private credit market continue to remain Fig 1: Change in Return of Equity of Banks welfare schemes. The tipping point came in stagnant. The corporate bond spread also Across Regions the end of April 2010 when Standard and eased a little during the year even as the Fig 2: Gross NPA as percentage of total Poor’s downgraded the Greek bonds to recovery was affected by the sovereign loans in banks ‘junk’ status and at the same time also debt crisis of Europe. Banks in the emerging economies, which lowered the ratings of the constitute 25% of global banking market, Spanish and Portuguese recovered quickly from the financial bonds. The EU had to stitch crisis. Their business model, which is together a bail-out package for to act predominantly as gatherers of Greece and the Greek savers as opposed to aggressive Government had to undertake lenders like the western banks, painful cost cutting measures. thrived in the economic conditions This was followed by a period with rise in domestic savings and of relative calm until history easy monetary policies. Banks in was repeated again, this time China have seen a period of boom in with Ireland. However, the the year 2009, lending twice as much biggest worry still remained in in 2009 than in 2008. Spain which had much bigger economy Fig: Growth Percentage in Credit Markets The Challenges Ahead than Greece, Portugal or Ireland and a Looking forward to the days ahead, some failure which can throw the global economy Key Trends in Performance of Banks of the biggest challenges of the banks over into disarray. As the year came to a close, As a general rule in the developed the world would to be to meet increasing the last word had not yet been spoken on economies, income of banks rose during capital requirements, address the issue of the European debt crisis. the year although major part of the same rising delinquencies, recover from the Equity markets across the world moved in came from trading fees, foreign exchange withdrawal of liberal monetary and fiscal tandem and continued their recovery from gains, etc. Rising equity markets eased the policies, redressing balance sheet the rock bottom of early 2009. However, pressure on banks and helped them weaknesses and dealing with a weak credit the sovereign debt crisis and sluggish become profitable by providing them with market. The biggest market risk may come recovery in the advanced economies again alternative profit sources. Better primary sometime in 2011 when the big spending weakened the equity market in the markets also allowed a lot of banks to European nations as well as USA will have developed economies. Emerging s u b s t i t u t e c a p i t a l f ro m t h e s a m e . to roll over their sovereign bonds and the economies, however, had an altogether Regulatory capital as percentage of risk- subsequent pressure on the primary bond different story to tell and the US Fed policy weighted assets thus increased for banks market may throw it into haywire. How to keep interest rates at a historic low level across geographies. The problem of loan banks cope with these challenges may opened up huge foreign investment in losses and write downs continued, very well determine their role in the new them. Bank stocks in the developed however, as the percentage of non- world economy. economies continued their slow progress performing assets kept increasing. -Sayan Majumder & Shifa Shalini Tirkey(XLRI) from the nadir but were unable to 14 The Senior Analyst
  • 15. Public sector WHY DISINVESTMENT FOR INDIAN undertakings ECONOMY were established PSUs… Why after all? To illustrate the trailing scenario, the average return on capital employed (ROCE) by PSUs in India as a part have been way too low as compared to the cost of borrowing. For instance, between 1940 and 2002, the average ROCE was 3.4% as against 8.6% average cost of borrowing. PSE of mixed survey by NCAER shows that PAT has never exceeded 5% of sales for or 6% of capital employed. The government pays a higher interest though, by at least 3 percentage points. economy with the objective of As per an NCAER study report the cost structure of PSES is much more than the private sector (the following table shows a comparative scale) : providing PSES Private sector POWER & FUELS/NET SALES 19.5 5 necessary Wages/net sales 23.3 6.5 Interest/net sales 11.7 4.7 infrastructure for the fast growth Lack of autonomy, political interference, nepotism & corruption has further deteriorated the situation. For instance, the head of a PSU is appointed by the Government, who in turn of economy & to appoints all employees who play major roles in the organization. So directly or indirectly the Government itself controls the appointment of all manpower in these organizations. It is not safeguard the business of the Government to do business, i.e. it is best controlled by experts and against professional managers. If we look at figures, on 31.3.1997, 242 central PSUs had a investment of Rs.1,93,121 crores. monopoly of By the end of year 2000-01, total investment was touching Rs.274,114 crores. Of these, 104 were making losses and about 53 were performing below expectations. Profit making industrialist enterprises are mostly in sectors like petroleum and allied sectors, because they are benefitted from State monopoly. losses of the 104 loss making units were around Rs. 58,620 community. crores as on 31.3.1997.which put pressure on capital expenditure and contribute to fiscal However, the deficit.These losses are a permanent phenomenon and keep borrowing just for their functioning is a temporary unsustainable solution. entire In this year’s budget revenue expenditure has increased due to interest payments, wages and mechanism did salaries of Government employees and subsidies. This leaves Government with very less money for capital expenditure on social and physical infrastructure. Government is forced to not turn out as put aside resources for the sustenance of many non-viable PSEs. In addition to that there is a efficient as it huge amount of debt overhang, which needs to be serviced and reduced before money is available to invest in infrastructure. Disinvestment of the Maruti Udyog Ltd.will work as a ought to be, all beacon for future. thanks to the prevailing hierarchy and bureaucracy. 15 The Senior Analyst
  • 16. In an era of globalization, liberalization We have seen every socialist country adopt Disinvestment will provide positive signs and dissolution of boundaries between industrialization, rather efficient for the Indian equity markets and will work nations, industrial competitiveness has industrialization, for appropriate growth, as a magnet to attract foreign and domestic especially assumed an important role, be it China or Russia. We preferred money into the markets. It will allow PSU necessitating privatization or disinvestment Russia’s old model. Now that we have seen to raise capital to fund their expansion of PSUs. Though it is claimed by many even the social countries succeed with plans and improve resource allocation in that ownership isn’t all that an important privatization and fail without it, it is high the economy. Disinvestment will help indicator of an organization’s functioning time we implement it too in major respects. government in stimulating the economy as is its management, it has been proven by while accessing less debt market borrowing. an ample number of examples that private Implications of Disinvestment on Disinvestment will allow government to controls of an organization bring about Indian Economy: have much better control over the market drastic changes in its effectiveness. This is If India wants a continuous increased economy without upsetting norms of especially true today when competitiveness growth, it has to scale to the next level of market behavior. is essential not only for leading the industry performance. This is not an option but a but for mere survival. necessity and disinvestment is a tool to get In future disinvestment will assume the role there. Increased population, of a major instrument of policy Bureaucracy has been an inherent part of unemployment, and poverty levels are main intervention by government as 48 PSUs PSUs and attempts to overcome it have reasons why India needs to scale. The cost listed on BSE as of February 8, 2010, been unsuccessful if not inadequate. of not scaling to the next level will see account for close to the 30% of the total Private management has proven to be a India eclipsed by China and other South market cap of the exchange. This is panacea in most such cases, including East Asian aspirants leaving India to its significant as a total of 4,880 odd VSNL and Delhi Vidyut Board. The internal chaos. It needs a 10% rate of companies were listed on the exchange. As success of these organizations after growth every year in its GDP to continue to of February 8, 2010, the BSE PSU index privatization has been evident by turning be competitive with China and potential had a total market cap of Rs 17,14,466.96 from red to black within a short span of emergent nations in South East Asia. crore. time. PSUs no longer enjoy the privileges In the context of macroeconomics, time as they did in past times in terms of As certain no. of shares are reserved for reputation and awe, on the contrary are retail investors & Splitting the stocks of stigmatized by the lack of efficiency and some big PSUs ,will attract more retail social considerations of past times. investors. Market cap of PSUs can go higher in future & can provide extra Despite huge injection of funds in the past money in the kitty of govt. 5% decades the functioning of many public Reservation for employees will work as an sector units (PSUs) has traditionally been incentive & will keep momentum going. characterized by poor management, slow This will be true democratization of decision making procedures, lack of capital. Disinvestment would encourage accountability, low productivity, citizens’ participation in management of unsatisfactory quality of goods, excessive public enterprises and improve the manpower utilization, labor intensive capitalization of stock markets. When units, lack of technological up gradation, companies get listed on the bourse they inadequate attention to R&D, inadequate has shown us how countries like Chile ,UK, adds certain economic and financial human resource development and low rate China , New zealand ,Poland successfully benefits to the economy. Which is called of return on capital. However, with used disinvestment to achieve new financial deepening, a term coined by increasing privatization, disinvestment or economic heights. Many countries used development economists. Financial change of control into hands of disinvestment as a sure means of restoring deepening improves the efficiency of the professional managers, many organizations budgetary balance & to revive growth on a financial system as well as contributes to have seen the tables turn. Some examples sustainable basis after facing economic GDP growth. are IRCTC and CRIS to facilitate the crisis in 80s.Analysis of these countries functioning of Indian Railways etc. before & after disinvestment shows that market-driven economies are more efficient Latest loan bribery case(in LIC,PNB etc.) than the state-planned economies has shown the wrongdoing, loopholes & Inefficient PSU’s contributed largely for drawbacks in the working of PSUs. If India the macro-economic crisis faced by India At the micro level, the change in ownership has to become a economic super power, during 1980’s. Primary purpose to establish will increase domestic competition, hence working way of PSUs have to be changed. them was to provide employment and help efficiency; and encourage public PSUs contribute about more than 1/4th in the government to generate revenue participation in domestic stock market – all the GDP of India & a large chunk of surplus. But they were unable to perform to of which will promote ‘popular ‘capitalism working population is employed in the expectations. Experts are in consensus that rewards risk taking and private PSUs .Economic super power dream is not that disinvestment is unavoidable for the initiative, that is expected to yield superior possible without PSUs coming at par with success of second generation reforms. economic outcomes. Disinvestment shows private sector. Health of the stock market is also linked that govt means business which will attract -Jagriti Gupta & Vipin Patel(FMS) with the progress of economic reforms. FDI, FII to finance projects in India. 16 The Senior Analyst
  • 17. The Demise of the Celtic Tiger Eschewed sovereign bonds. Record high reported a 13 billion euros decrease in its as it is the major economy driver and it government borrowings. Large fiscal deposits this year, which is almost 17%. would be drastic setback for the growth deficit. Collapsing banking sector. So many The crisis hit banks were the most opportunities if it were to be altered. problems and still the government of concerning factor for the government as The package is a bit different from the one Ireland was not willing to agree to external they somehow needed funds to support given to Greece earlier. The interest rate for rumours that it needed an aid package. the sector and revive the declining the package is higher than Greece’s but The Irish government kept supporting its economy. Apart from this, currently the Ireland has 10 years to pay-off its loans claim by stating just two reasons. Firstly, country is spending close to 19 billion whereas Greece was only given a time of 3 their loan was not supposed to be euros which is more than what it receives years. The first instalment would be due refinanced till 2011 and secondly, they did from its revenues and taxes. The rising within 4.5 years. not want to lose control over their fiscal budget deficits are yet another factor of Has it worked? policy and end up discouraging foreign c o n c e r n f o r t h e a l re a d y b u rd e n e d The bailout package has been paid out and investment which is the key driver of the government. everyone had positive expectations from it. country’s growth for almost two decades The plan of Action But have these expectations been met? now. The country was coming under pressure The answer to the question can be seen Finally on 21st November, the Irish from all the Eurozone members to accept from the fact that private investors have government gave in and announced that to the fact that the economy was not in a still no urge to buy Irish government bonds. uplift the deteriorating condition of the condition to survive on its own as they The demand for bonds which was lacking banking sector, an external state financial aid was required. feared that the damaging effects might initially is still the same and government is What led to the bailout? spread to other debt ridden European not likely to be able to raise more money The economy was a hub for financial countries like Portugal and Spain. The from the market. investors since the 90’s as it charged a belief was unanimous that Ireland asking So what exactly went wrong? corporate tax rate of 12.5% which is the for a bailout package might actually result The main cause for the failure of the bailout lowest among the EU nations. This has in relaxing the tense atmosphere and in mechanism is that EU members have a attracted many companies to setup their fact ease pressure on other countries with common centralized monetary authority base in the country and due to this the mounting debts. but a decentralized fiscal authority. This economy had been booming. The first – the Eurozone, EU and the IMF. Each leads to a situation where the two policies major setback came with the burst of the contributed 22.5 billion euros which don’t complement each other making it real estate bubble in 2008. This was closely amounts to roughly 29.8 billion USD. The impossible to solve these situations. followed by the fall of Lehmann Brothers rest of the amount was given by Sweden, The bailout mechanism relies on getting which sent the world economies into Denmark and Britain as bilateral loans. money from stronger countries like recession mode. The Irish banks were Irish PM, Brian Cowen disclosed that the Germany, which in fact is from the common severely hit by both these developments. package would be having two major steps. tax payer there. The complaints from them Since then the budget deficits have been First would be to revamp the deteriorated being troubled for no reason at all constantly increasing and have reached a Irish banks and make them much smaller continuously increase. This money is then high recently, amounting to about one-third than they were. Second would be to transferred to an affected economy which of the economic output this year. This led reduce the budget deficits by decreasing is forced to cut its spending and survive to a rapid surge in bond yields which are government spending and increasing under severe austerity measures. The currently at an all-time high. The Finance taxes. whole concept is flawed from within as it Minister, Mr. Lenihan announced that the To address to the first step, 10 billion euros simply adds more debt to a country’s increasing interest rates would make it have been immediately given to the economic situation which is already under impossible for the government to raise government-backed banks so that they a load of debt. money the next year and hence the have sum back-up funds for their All in all, the money has been forwarded to banking sector would need a back-up fund sustenance. Another 25 billion euros have the country, the measures and the to support itself. been set aside particularly for the banking deadlines have been set, but the effect This deteriorating financial health of the sector only. The rest of the loans have been which was perceived is far from achieved. economy was immediately perceived by set aside for the second step. Ireland has Jean Claude Trichet, the head of Europe’s the citizens and they started withdrawing been given time till 2015 to decrease its monetary authority has a very major role to their funds. The government holds a major annual deficit to 3%, which currently is at play now. He must review the policies stake in many large banks but provides an all time high of 32%. being used in EU, related to the common only a blanket guarantee to them. Due to As far as the taxation rules were monetary authority and the common this, the two largest banks of the country, concerned, Ireland got its way and the currency and also he must check the Allied Irish Bank and Anglo Irish Bank were government was given full freedom to set efficiency of loaning large amounts to finding it immensely difficult to get any its own tax plans. Regarding this, Mr. already debt stricken countries, or in other deposits from the market. Allied Irish Bank Cowen commented that the 12.5% words what they call the bailout package. corporation tax would remain unchanged -Harpreet Singh & Vaibhav Juneja(FMS) 17 The Senior Analyst