SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo

Anais parte i_revistaemerj_206

•
•
Marcia Regina Mourao
Marcia Regina Mourao
1 de 13
Descargar para leer sin conexión
206 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” Os Contratos de Transporte de Pessoa e de Seguro no Novo Código Civil 66666(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2 &&&&&$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5, ))))),/+2,/+2,/+2,/+2,/+2 'HVHPEDUJDGRU 7- 5- 'LUHWRU *HUDO GD (0(5- oD DV ORFRPRWLYDV D YDSRU TXH IRUDP RV SULPHLURV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR 'L]HP TXH DV SULPHLUDV ORFRPRWLYDV GH VHQYROYLDP D HVSDQWRVD YHORFLGDGH GH NP K 'H NP K SDVVRX VH SDUD NP K NP K NP K NP K DWp FKHJDU DRV WUHQV EDOD TXH DLQGD QmR FKHJDUDP DR %UDVLO DRV DYL}HV H DWp PHVPR DRV VXSHUV{QLFRV (QTXDQWR R 3URMHWR GH &OyYLV %HYLOiTXD GRUPLWDYD QR &RQJUHVVR SRU TXDVH WULQWD DQRV R WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR QmR SDURX DR FRQWUiULR DV URGDV JLUD YDP H FDGD YH] PDLV UDSLGDPHQWH 7DQ WR p TXH IRL QHFHVViULR HGLWDU XPD OHL HVSHFLDO SDUD GLVFLSOLQDU R WUDQVSRUWH FR OHWLYR DQWHV PHVPR GH HQWUDU HP YLJRU R &yGLJR &LYLO 5HILUR PH DR 'HFUHWR Qƒ GH TXH VH WRUQRX FRQKHFL GR FRPR D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 7HQKR SDUD PLP TXH R &yGLJR &LYLO QmR IH] UHIHUrQFLD DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH SRUTXH R OHJLVODGRU GHOH VH HVTXHFHX SUHRFXSDGR FRP DV TXHVW}HV GR &RQJUHV VR ROYLGDQGR VH TXH R PXQGR DTXL IRUD QmR KDYLD SDUDGR DQWHV SHOR FRQWUiULR DV URGDV HVWDYDP URGDQGR H FDGD YH] PDLV UiSLGR e LVVR TXH RFRUUH TXDQGR Ki XP GLVWDQFLDPHQWR HQWUH D OHL H R IDWR RX PHOKRU GL]HQGR TXDQGR R OHJLV ODGRU HVWi DOKHLR DR IDWR 3RGH WDPEpP WHU RFRUULGR TXH R OHJLVODGRU LPDJLQRX TXH D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR Mi WHULD VXILFLHQWHPHQWH GLVFLSOLQDGR D TXHVWmR VHP SUHYHU TXH RXWURV PHLRV GH WUDQV SRUWH KDYHULDP GH VXUJLU H SRU LVVR GHL [RX R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DSHQDV FRP D GLVFLSOLQD TXH UHFHEHUD GD /HL GDV (V WUDGDV GH )HUUR 2 FHUWR p SRUpP TXH DV URGDV FRQ WLQXDUDP URGDQGR H RXWURV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH IRUDP VXUJLQGR 3RU LVVR WRU 9DPRV KRMH WUDWDU GH GRLV FRQWUD WRV GD PDLRU UHOHYkQFLD VRFLDO SROtWLFD H HFRQ{PLFD 7DOYH] QmR H[LVWDP RXWURV TXH SRVVDP FRPSHWLU FRP HOHV 4XDQWR j LPSRUWkQFLD GR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH EDVWDULD OHPEUDU TXH QR %UDVLO GLDULDPHQWH VmR WUDQVSRUWDGRV FHUFD GH TXDUHQWD PLOK}HV GH SDVVDJHL URV GH FDVD SDUD R WUDEDOKR H GR WUDED OKR SDUD D FDVD DWUDYpV GH {QLEXV WUHQV PHWU{V HWF ,VVR HYLGHQFLD TXH R WUDQV SRUWH FROHWLYR p UHDOPHQWH XP LQVWUX PHQWR IXQGDPHQWDO SDUD R (VWDGR PR GHUQR FXPSULU VXDV PLVV}HV VRFLDLV H HFRQ{PLFDV 8PD JUHYH QHVVH VHWRU OL WHUDOPHQWH SDUDOLVDULD R SDtV /HPEUD PRV TXH WHPSRV DWUiV XPD VLPSOHV JUH YH GH FDPLQKRQHLURV FKHJRX D DEDODU GH FHUWD PDQHLUD R JRYHUQR 4XDQWR DR WUDQVSRUWH DpUHR WRGRV VDEHPRV TXH p XP JUDQGH DSUR[LPDGRU GH SDtVHV GRV SRYRV GDV SHVVRDV GDV FLGDGHV H XP H[WUDRUGLQiULR IRPHQWDGRU GH QHJyFLRV FLUFXODGRU GH ULTXH]DV 6H JXQGR DV HVWDWtVWLFDV QR DQR GH FHUFD GH GRLV PLOK}HV H PHLR GH SHVVR DV HQWUDUDP QR %UDVLO YLD DpUHD H RX WUDV WDQWDV VDtUDP 1mR REVWDQWH HVVD UHOHYkQFLD HFR Q{PLFD VRFLDO H MXUtGLFD R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH QmR PHUHFHX VHTXHU XPD UHIHUrQFLD QR &yGLJR GH 3RU TXH LVVR" -i VH UHVVDOWRX TXH R 3URMHWR GR &yGLJR GH IRL HODERUDGR SRU &OyYLV %HYLOiTXD QD ~OWLPD GpFDGD GH HP TXDQGR R WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR HUD DLQGD LQFLSLHQWH VHTXHU H[LVWHQWH $ KLVWyULD GR WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR FRPHoRX OLWHUDOPHQWH QR WHPSR GD 0DULD )XPD 3DOHVWUD SURIHULGD QR 6HPLQiULR UHDOL]DGR HP
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 207 QRX VH QHFHVViULR DSOLFDU SRU DQDORJLD D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR DRV GHPDLV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH j PHGLGD HP TXH IRUDP VXUJLQGR ERQGH {QLEXV HWF 'HV VD IRUPD HVVD OHL TXH UHSXWR XPD GDV PDLV DQWLJDV DLQGD HP YLJRU FRQVHJXLX VREUHYLYHU SRU TXDVH XP VpFXOR $ GRX WULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQFLD IL]HUDP FRP D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR DTXLOR TXH %RXUODQJHU GHQRPLQDYD GH ´SRGHU GH UHMXYHQHFLPHQWR GD OHLµ SRGHU TXH FRQ VLVWH HP ID]r ODV YLYHU VHJXQGR RX DWHQ GHQGR jV H[LJrQFLDV GR WHPSR SUHVHQWH 1D UHDOLGDGH VH TXLVHUPRV WHU XPD LGpLD GR SRGHU FULDWLYR GD GRXWULQD H GD MXULV SUXGrQFLD EDVWD HVWXGDU R GHVHQYROYL PHQWR GD LQWHUSUHWDomR H GD DSOLFDomR TXH IRL GDGD j /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR (QWUDQGR HP YLJRU R QRYR &yGLJR &L YLO SHOR PHQRV GRLV HIHLWRV FXULRVRV LUi SURGX]LU HP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQV SRUWH (P SULPHLUR OXJDU LUi UHYRJDU XPD GDV PDLV DQWLJDV OHLV HP YLJRU TXH p D OHL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 7DO OHL VREUHYLYHX j &RQVWLWXLomR GH H DR SUySULR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPL GRU GDGR R DYDQoR GD GLVFLSOLQD TXH HOD HVWDEHOHFHX (P VHJXQGR OXJDU R &yGL JR LUi GLVFLSOLQDU H LQFOXLU QR VHX WH[WR XP FRQWUDWR TXH QmR p QRYR DR FRQWUi ULR p PDLV DQWLJR GR TXH R SUySULR &yGL JR TXH LUi UHYRJDU 3RU LVVR QD UHDOLGD GH QmR HQFRQWUDUHPRV LQRYDo}HV QD GLV FLSOLQD GR QRYR &yGLJR FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH 2 &yGLJR HVWi WmR VRPHQWH SRVLWLYDQGR HVWDEHOHFHQ GR QD OHL DTXLOR TXH IRL VHQGR FULDGR GHVHQYROYLGR H FULVWDOL]DGR SHOD GRXWUL QD H MXULVSUXGrQFLD DR ORQJR GH TXDVH XP VpFXOR 2 QRYR &yGLJR HVWi HP SHU IHLWD VLQWRQLD FRP D GRXWULQD H D MXULV SUXGrQFLD TXH QHVVH SHUtRGR VH ILUPD UDP 'HVWDFDULD LQLFLDOPHQWH R DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO TXH DR GLVFLSOL QDU R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH UHVVDOWRX XP GRV VHXV HOHPHQWRV TXH VHULD DWp GHVQHFHVViULR PDV TXH SDVVRX D WHU UH OHYkQFLD SRU DTXLOR TXH YDPRV HQIDWL]DU ´3HOR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DOJXpP VH REULJD PHGLDQWH UHWULEXLomR D WUDQVSRU WDU GH XP OXJDU SDUD R RXWUR SHVVRDV RX FRLVDVµ 7RGRV VDEHP TXH R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DOpP GH ELODWHUDO p RQHUR VR RX VHMD H[LJH XPD FRQWUDSUHVWDomR &RQWXGR VXUJLX DR ORQJR GHVVH SHUtRGR D GLVFXVVmR DFHUFD GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GR FKDPDGR FRQWUDWR JUDFLRVR RX WUDQVSRUWH JUDWXL WR )RL XPD ORQJD GLVFXVVmR TXH DFDERX JHUDQGR MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7UL EXQDO GH -XVWLoD FRQVDJUDGD QD 6~PXOD 3RLV DJRUD R HQWHQGLPHQWR FULVWDOL ]DGR QD GRXWULQD H QD MXULVSUXGrQFLD SDVVRX D VHU GLVSRVLomR H[SUHVVD GR DU WLJR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR FRQWUDWR JUD WXLWR ´1mR VH VXERUGLQD jV QRUPDV GR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH R IHLWR JUDWXLWD PHQWH SRU DPL]DGH RX FRUWHVLDµ )RL QH FHVViULR UHSHWLU LVVR DTXL SRUTXH KRXYH XP WHPSR HP TXH VH TXHULD HQTXDGUDU DTXHOH TXH WUDQVSRUWDYD JUDWXLWDPHQWH QDV PHVPDV UHJUDV GH UHVSRQVDELOLGD GH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU TXH WHP FRPR HOH PHQWR GR FRQWUDWR R UHFHELPHQWR GD FRQWUDSUHVWDomR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR QDGD PDLV ID] GR TXH UHSHWLU D GLVWLQomR TXH D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQFLD Mi HV WDEHOHFHUDP HQWUH R FRQWUDWR SXUDPHQ WH JUDWXLWR H R DSDUHQWHPHQWH JUDWXLWR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GLVS}H ´QmR VH FRQVL GHUD JUDWXLWR R WUDQVSRUWH TXDQGR HP ERUD IHLWR VHP UHPXQHUDomR R WUDQVSRU WDGRU DXIHULU YDQWDJHP LQGLUHWDµ %DV WDUi TXDOTXHU WLSR GH YDQWDJHP FRPR SRU H[HPSOR QR FDVR GH R HPSUHJDGRU TXH WUDQVSRUWD R HPSUHJDGR R LGRVR RX R HVWXGDQWH TXH WrP SDVVH JUDWXLWR 1HV VDV KLSyWHVHV DOJXpP HVWi SDJDQGR D FRQWD QmR VHQGR HVVH FRQWUDWR HVVHQFL DOPHQWH JUDWXLWR Vy SRGHQGR VHU DVVLP FRQVLGHUDGR DTXHOH TXH VHJXQGR R &y GLJR p IHLWR SRU DPL]DGH RX FRUWHVLD 8P SRQWR TXH PH SDUHFHX LPSRU WDQWH p R DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO 4XDQGR HQWURX HP YLJRU R &yGLJR GR &RQ VXPLGRU VXUJLX XPD TXHVWmR EDVWDQWH LQWHUHVVDQWH 2 &'& HVWDEHOHFH LQGH QL]DomR LOLPLWDGD &RQWXGR R &yGLJR %UD VLOHLUR GD $HURQiXWLFD H D &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD HVWDEHOHFHP LQGHQL]DomR WDULIDGD OLPLWDGD SDUD R WUDQVSRUWH Dp UHR $ TXHVWmR TXH VH FRORFRX IRL HVWD R
208 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” WUDQVSRUWDGRU DpUHR VHP G~YLGD p XP SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoRV H QR FDVR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH HVWDULD HOH VXMHLWR D SD JDU XPD LQGHQL]DomR LOLPLWDGD FRPR SUH YLVWR QR &'& RX XPD LQGHQL]DomR OLPL WDGD FRPR SUHYLVWR QD &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD H QR &yGLJR %UDVLOHLUR GD $HUR QiXWLFD" 'HVGH R SULPHLUR PRPHQWR VXVWHQWHL FRP EDVH QR HQWHQGLPHQWR GR 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDO )HGHUDO TXH RV WUD WDGRV H FRQYHQo}HV QR QRVVR SDtV QmR VmR VXSUDOHLV QmR VmR OHLV FRQVWLWXFLRQDLV QmR HVWmR DFLPD GDV OHLV RUGLQiULDV PDV QR PHVPR SODQR GHODV (VVD IRL XPD TXHV WmR ORQJDPHQWH GHEDWLGD QR 67) TXH DFD ERX HQWHQGHQGR GHVVD PDQHLUD KDYHQ GR KRMH GLVSRVLomR H[SUHVVD QD &RQVWL WXLomR DUW ,,, D 4XDQGR TXDOTXHU GHFLVmR FRQWUDULDU WUDWDGR RX FRQYHQomR LQWHUQDFLRQDO R UHFXUVR FDEtYHO QmR p R H[WUDRUGLQiULR PDV VLP R HVSHFLDO 6H WUD WDGR IRVVH OHL FRQVWLWXFLRQDO R UHFXUVR GHYHULD VHU R H[WUDRUGLQiULR H QmR R HV SHFLDO +RMH SRUWDQWR SRU H[SUHVVD GLVSR VLomR FRQVWLWXFLRQDO QmR Ki G~YLGDV GH TXH R WUDWDGR HVWi QR PHVPR SODQR GD OHL RUGLQiULD 6HQGR DVVLP HYLGHQWHPHQWH GHYHULD SUHYDOHFHU R &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU SRU VHU D OHL PDLV QRYD (VVD TXHVWmR IRL PXLWR GLVFXWLGD QR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD TXH LQLFLDOPHQWH VH LQFOLQRX SHOD SUHYDOrQFLD GD &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD H GR &yGLJR %UDVLOHLUR GD $H URQiXWLFD (QWUHWDQWR R 67- PXGRX R VHX HQWHQGLPHQWR H QDV XOWLPDV GHFLV}HV GH DOJXQV DQRV SDUD Fi WHP GHFLGLGR TXH R &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU SUHYDOHFH HP UHOD omR j &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD (VVH HQWHQGLPHQWR HVWDUi FRQVD JUDGR QR DUWLJR DUW GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO ´$RV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH HP JHUDO VmR DSOLFiYHLV TXDQGR FRXEHU GHVGH TXH QmR FRQWUDULHP DV GLVSRVLo}HV GHVWH &yGLJR RV SUHFHLWRV FRQVWDQWHV GD OHJLVODomR HVSHFLDO H GH WUDWDGRV H FRQ YHQo}HV LQWHUQDFLRQDLVµ /HQGR HVVH GLV SRVLWLYR QD RUGHP GLUHWD WHUtDPRV DRV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH HP JHUDO VmR DSOLFiYHLV TXDQGR FRXEHUHP RV WUDWD GRV H FRQYHQo}HV LQWHUQDFLRQDLV GHVGH TXH QmR FRQWUDULHP HVVH &yGLJR (TXLYDOH GL]HU TXH VH KRXYHU DOJXPD FRQWUDULH GDGH HQWUH DV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR H TXDOTXHU GLVSRVLomR GH WUDWDGRV RX FRQ YHQomR LQWHUQDFLRQDO GHYHUmR SUHYDOHFHU DV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR &LYLO R TXH PH SDUHFH HVWDU HP SHUIHLWD KDUPRQLD FRP D QRVVD &RQVWLWXLomR H FRP R HQWHQGL PHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO QmR Vy GR 67) FRPR WDPEpP GR 67- 'H VRUWH TXH FRQ IRUPH DV QRYDV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR &L YLO HVVD TXHVWmR HVWDUi QR PHX HQWHQ GHU VXSHUDGD 2 DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO WUDWD GR WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR RX VHMD DTXHOH HP TXH PDLV GH XP WUDQVSRUWD GRU VH HQFDUUHJD GH ID]HU R WUDQVSRUWH HP SHUFXUVRV GLIHUHQWHV 3RU H[HPSOR XP WUDQVSRUWD DWp 3RUWXJDO H RXWUR SHOR UHVWDQWH GD (XURSD 1HVVHV FRQWUDWRV FXPXODWLYRV R &yGLJR HVWDEHOHFHX XPD UHJUD HP UHODomR j UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FL YLO TXH QmR p D GD VROLGDULHGDGH 'L] TXH ´QRV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWL YR FDGD WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH REULJD D FXP SULU R FRQWUDWR UHODWLYDPHQWH DR UHVSHF WLYR SHUFXUVR UHVSRQGHQGR SHORV GDQRV QHOH FDXVDGRV D SHVVRDV H FRLVDV &RQ VHTHQWHPHQWH QmR KDYHUi UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH VROLGiULD 1R HQWDQWR H Dt QmR HQWHQGL EHP R SRUTXr QR DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO TXDQGR WUDWRX GR WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH PHUFDGRULDV R OHJLVODGRU HVWDEHOHFHX D UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH VROLGiULD 1R FDVR GH WUDQVSRUWH FX PXODWLYR WRGRV RV WUDQVSRUWDGRUHV UHV SRQGHP VROLGDULDPHQWH $ GLIHUHQoD GH GLVFLSOLQD WDOYH] WHQKD SRU FDXVD QmR VHU SRVVtYHO GHWHUPLQDU VH FRP SUHFLVmR HP TXH SHUFXUVR RFRUUHX R GDQR R TXH QmR VH YHULILFD QR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV &HUWR p TXH R OHJLVODGRU IH] HVVD GLVWLQ omR HQWUH R WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH PHUFDGRULD H WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH SHVVRDV DWULEXLQGR D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH VROLGiULD jTXHOD PRGDOLGDGH H QmR D DWULEXLQGR TXDQGR VH WUDWDU GH WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH SHVVRDV 2 DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO GLVFLSOLQD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU (VVD PDWpULD SDVVRX SRU YiULDV IDVHV $ /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HU UR HVWDEHOHFLD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO RE MHWLYD SDUD R WUDQVSRUWDGRU HP UHODomR
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 209 DR SDVVDJHLUR (P UHODomR DR SHGHVWUH jTXHOH TXH QmR HUD SDVVDJHLUR D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH HUD VXEMHWLYD DUW GR && &RP D &RQVWLWXLomR GH TXH HVWDEHOHFHX UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD WDPEpP SDUD R SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoR S~ EOLFR R WUDQVSRUWDGRU SDVVRX D WHU UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD WDPEpP HP UHOD omR D WHUFHLUR 9HLR R &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU H HVWDEHOHFHX UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH REMHWLYD SDUD R SUHVWDGRU GH VHU YLoR TXHU FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWDGR TXHU FRP UHODomR DR FRQVXPLGRU GLUHWR FRPR HP UHODomR DR FRQVXPLGRU LQGLUH WR 6y Dt SDVVDPRV D WHU XPD UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH XQLILFDGD GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU FRP UHODomR QmR Vy DR SDVVDJHLUR FRPR WDP EpP HP UHODomR DR WHUFHLUR 2 QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO QR VHX DUWLJR SUDWLFDPHQWH FRQVROLGRX HVVH HQ WHQGLPHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO HVWDEHOH FHQGR D VHJXLQWH UHJUD ´2 WUDQVSRUWD GRU UHVSRQGH SHORV GDQRV FDXVDGRV jV SHVVRDV WUDQVSRUWDGDV HYLGHQWHPHQWH VRPHQWH HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR H VXDV EDJDJHQV VDOYR PRWLYR GH IRUoD PDLRU VHQGR QXOD TXDOTXHU FOiXVXOD H[FOXGHQWH GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHµ 1HVVH GLVSRVLWLYR WHPRV YiULDV TXHVW}HV LPSRUWDQWHV (P SULPHLUR OX JDU WUDWD VH LQTXHVWLRQDYHOPHQWH GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR H DTXL HVWi D FOiXVXOD GH LQFROXPLGDGH HQTXDGUDGD SHORV MXULVWDV IUDQFHVHV TXDQGR SURFXUDUDP FRQVWUXLU XPD QRYD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SDUD R WUDQV SRUWDGRU 1R PHX HQWHQGHU R TXH WH PRV DTXL p D FOiXVXOD GH VHJXUDQoD H[ SUHVVD QR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVX PLGRU 4XHP VH GLVS}H D SUHVWDU VHUYL oRV TXH FDXVDP ULVFRV DR SDVVDJHLUR RX D WHUFHLURV ILFD REULJDGR D SUHVWi OR FRP VHJXUDQoD WHQGR TXH JDUDQWLU D LQFROXPLGDGH GH TXHP TXHU TXH VHMD 2 &yGLJR FRQVDJURX R TXH Mi HVWDYD HVWD EHOHFLGR GHVGH D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 'HVWDFDPRV HP VHJXQGR OXJDU TXH R GLVSRVLWLYR HP H[DPH HVWDEHOHFH FOD UDPHQWH D QXOLGDGH GH TXDOTXHU FOiX VXOD H[FOXGHQWH GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH ,VVR IRL XPD FULDomR GD GRXWULQD GHSRLV GD MXULVSUXGrQFLD H ILQDOPHQWH HVVD YHGDomR HVWi H[SUHVVD QR &yGLJR GH 'H IHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU 4XDOTXHU FOiXVXOD TXH UHGX]D D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH p SOHQD PHQWH QXOD (VVD GLVSRVLomR HVWDUi DJR UD QR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO 7HPRV WDPEpP DTXL R SULQFtSLR GD LQGHQL]DomR LOLPLWDGD TXH HPERUD QmR HVFULWR QR FDSXW R GHSUHHQGHPRV GR SD UiJUDIR ~QLFR TXH GL] ´e OtFLWR DR WUDQV SRUWDGRU H[LJLU D GHFODUDomR GR YDORU GD EDJDJHP D ILP GH IL[DU R OLPLWH GD LQGH QL]DomRµ &RPR VH Yr R &yGLJR VRPHQWH DGPLWLX IL[DU OLPLWH GD LQGHQL]DomR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR j EDJDJHP $ FRQWUDULR VHQVX QmR Ki OLPLWH LQGHQL]DWyULR HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR &RPR QmR SRGH ULD GHL[DU GH VHU KDYHUi KDUPRQLD HQ WUH R QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO H R GR &RQVXPL GRU 6HULD PXLWR UXLP VH R &yGLJR &LYLO SHUPLWLVVH XPD OLPLWDomR WHQGR R &yGL JR GR &RQVXPLGRU HVWDEHOHFLGR FRPR SULQFtSLR FRPR GLUHLWR IXQGDPHQWDO GR FRQVXPLGRU D SOHQD LQGHQL]DomR RX D UHSRVLomR LOLPLWDGD 0HVPR HP VH WUD WDQGR GH EDJDJHP D OLPLWDomR WHUi TXH VHU IHLWD FRP EDVH QXPD GHFODUDomR GR YDORU GD SUySULD EDJDJHP 2 DUWLJR DR SULPHLUR H[DPH SHUPLWH FRQFOXLU TXH D UHVSRQVDELOLGD GH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VRPHQWH VHULD H[ FOXtGD SHOD IRUoD PDLRU $OJXQV GLDV DWUiV FRQYHUVDQGR FRP XPD LOXVWUH FLYLOLVWD HOD PH GLVVH TXH R &yGLJR &LYLO HVWDULD j IUHQWH GR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU SRUTXH VRPHQWH H[FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GH IRUoD PDLRU e R TXH HVWi GLV SRVWR QR DUWLJR GR &yGLJR &LYLO 7R GDYLD R &yGLJR GLVFLSOLQRX D UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU HP PDLV GH XP DUWLJR H QmR DSHQDV HP XP ~QLFR GLVSR VLWLYR $ VHJXLU WHPRV R DUWLJR TXH WUD WD GR IDWR GH WHUFHLUR ( DTXL R &yGLJR QDGD PDLV IH] TXH SRVLWLYDU D DQWLJXtVVLPD V~PXOD GR 67) ´$ UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO GR WUDQVSRUWD GRU SHOR DFLGHQWH FRP SDVVDJHLUR QmR p HOLGLGD SRU FXOSD GH WHUFHLUR FRQWUD R TXDO WHP DomR UHJUHVVLYD µ ,VWR QmR p QRYLGDGH UHSHWLPRV SRUTXH D 6~PXOD
210 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” Mi GLVSXQKD DVVLP 7RGDYLD R FyGL JR IDOD HP FXOSD GH WHUFHLURV )DWR FXOSRVR GH WHUFHLUR QmR H[FOXL 0DV D TXHVWmR p H R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR" 1mR SRGHPRV HYLGHQWHPHQWH HTXLSDUDU GROR H FXOSD 2 IDWR FXOSRVR GH WHUFHLUR SRGH VHU SHUIHLWDPHQWH LQFOXtGR QDTXL OR TXH PXLWRV DXWRUHV FKDPDP GH IRU WXLWR LQWHUQR )D] SDUWH GR ULVFR GR QHJy FLR GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU 0DV TXDQWR DR IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR FRPR SRU H[HPSOR R DVVDOWR H DJRUD YHUGDGHLURV DWDTXHV D {QLEXV TXH VmR IHLWRV TXDQGR D SROtFLD PDWD DOJXpP QR PRUUR H RV EDQGLGRV GHV FHP SDUD TXHLPDU RV {QLEXV SRGH VH LPSXWDU DR WUDQVSRUWDGRU R GHYHU GH LQ GHQL]DU VH DOJXpP ILFDU IHULGR HP XPD PDQLIHVWDomR GHVVD QDWXUH]D" (QWmR Dt WHPRV R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR 3DUHFH PH TXH FRQWLQXDUHPRV FRP D PHVPD GRX WULQD FRP D PHVPD MXULVSUXGrQFLD H FRP D PHVPD FRQWURYpUVLD TXH DWp DTXL VH WUD YRX +i DTXHOHV TXH HQWHQGHP FRPR HX TXH R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR H[FOXL D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU SRUTXH HOH QmR p TXHVWmR GH LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH PDV VLP GH LQHYLWDELOLGDGH ( Ki RXWURV TXH HQ WHQGHP TXH QmR H[FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH 2 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD Mi WHP GHFLGLGR GRV GRLV PRGRV HPERUD HV WHMD VH LQFOLQDQGR QDV ~OWLPDV GHFLV}HV SHOD QmR H[RQHUDomR GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GH IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR FRPR R DVVDOWR D {QLEXV 7HPRV D VHJXLU D TXHVWmR GR IDWR H[FOXVLYR GD YtWLPD RX GD FXOSD H[FOXVL YD GD YtWLPD TXH p QRUPDOPHQWH RX WUD FDXVD GH H[FOXVmR GH UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH $ FXOSD H[FOXVLYD GD YtWLPD H[ FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRU WDGRU" 2 FyGLJR WUDWRX GHVVD TXHVWmR QR DUWLJR (VVH DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ SHV VRD WUDQVSRUWDGD GHYH VXMHLWDU VH jV QRUPDV HVWDEHOHFLGDV SHOR WUDQVSRUWD GRU FRQVWDQWHV QR ELOKHWH RX DIL[DGDV j YLVWD GRV XVXiULRV µ (P RXWUDV SD ODYUDV HVWi GL]HQGR TXH R SDVVDJHLUR GHYD WHU XP FRPSRUWDPHQWR DGHTXDGR GH DFRUGR FRP DV UHJUDV 'LVS}H R SDUi JUDIR ~QLFR TXH QRV LQWHUHVVD ´6H R SUH MXt]R VRIULGR SHOD SHVVRD WUDQVSRUWDGD IRU DWULEXtYHO j WUDQVJUHVVmR GH QRUPDV H LQVWUXo}HV UHJXODPHQWDUHV R MXL] UHGX ]LUi HTLWDWLYDPHQWH D LQGHQL]DomR QD PHGLGD HP TXH D YtWLPD KRXYHU FRQFRU ULGR SDUD D RFRUUrQFLD GR GDQR µ (LV DTXL D FXOSD FRQFRUUHQWH ( Dt HQWmR D PLQKD FRQFOXVmR 2UD VH R FyGLJR SHUPLWH UH GX]LU D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWD GRU HP UD]mR GD FXOSD FRQFRUUHQWH GR SDVVDJHLUR SRU PDLV IRUWH UD]mR WHUHPRV TXH DGPLWLU D H[FOXVmR GD UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH R GDQR GHFRU UHU GD H[FOXVLYD DWXDomR GD SUySULD YtWL PD (QWmR PDLV XPD YH] RV VXUILVWDV URGRYLiULRV QR PHX HQWHQGHU FRQWLQX DUmR VHP D FREHUWXUD GD LQGHQL]DomR GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH R GDQR GHFRUUHU GH IDWR H[FOXVLYR GD SUySULD YtWLPD 2 DUWLJR WDPEpP p FRQVDJUD omR GH HQWHQGLPHQWR GRXWULQiULR H MXULVSUXGHQFLDO (OH WUDWD GR LQWHUURP SLPHQWR GD YLDJHP 7RGRV QyV MXt]HV Mi GHFLGLPRV KLSyWHVHV GH LQWHUUXSomR GH YLDJHP FRPR RYHUERRNLQJ RX PHOKRU DLQGD FDVRV HP TXH R DYLmR RX HQWmR {QLEXV VRIUH DOJXPD SDQH H WHP TXH SD UDU HP DOJXP OXJDU 1HVVH FDVR WHPRV PDQGDGR SDJDU DV GHVSHVDV GH KRVSH GDJHP DOLPHQWDomR HWF H DUUXPDU ORJR XP PHLR GH WUDQVSRUWH SDUD OHYDU R SDV VDJHLUR VmR H VDOYR DR VHX GHVWLQR e LVVR TXH HVWi QR DUWLJR ´,QWHUURPSHQGR VH D YLDJHP SRU TXDOTXHU PRWLYR DOKHLR j YRQ WDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU DLQGD TXH HP FRQVH TrQFLD GH HYHQWR LPSUHYLVtYHO HLV DTXL R IRUWXLWR LQWHUQR TXH QmR H[FOXL D UHVSRQ VDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU ILFD HOH REUL JDGR D FRQFOXLU R WUDQVSRUWH FRQWUDWDGR HP RXWUR YHtFXOR GD PHVPD FDWHJRULD µ ( DLQGD WHPRV XP DUWLJR LPSRUWDQ WH TXH QmR H[LVWLD HP QHQKXP GLVSRVL WLYR OHJDO FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH R DUWLJR e R GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR TXH IRL DJRUD RXWRUJDGR OHJDOPHQWH DR WUDQV SRUWDGRU ´2 WUDQVSRUWDGRU XPD YH] H[H FXWDGR R WUDQVSRUWH WHP GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR VREUH D EDJDJHP GR SDVVDJHLUR H RXWURV RE MHWRV SHVVRDLV GHVWH SDUD JDUDQWLU VH GR SD JDPHQWR GR YDORU GD SDVVDJHP TXH QmR WLYHU VLGR IHLWR QR LQtFLR RX GXUDQWH R SHUFXUVRµ (VVH GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR TXH Mi HVWDYD SUHYLVWR QR &yGLJR GH SDUD RV FD VRV GH GHSyVLWR H KRVSHGDJHP H DJRUD
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 211 HVWHQGLGR SHOR QRYR &yGLJR WDPEpP DR WUDQVSRUWDGRU 0XLWRV HQWHQGHP TXH HVVH GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR VHULD DUELWUi ULR DOJR FRQWUiULR j OLEHUGDGH HWF GH VRUWH TXH D FRQWURYpUVLD SURVVHJXLUi PRUPHQWH HP IDFH GR &yGLJR GR &RQVX PLGRU 2EVHUYR XPD RPLVVmR QR FyGLJR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SDVVD JHLUR 2PLVVmR HVWD TXH SRGHULD WHU VLGR VXSULGD SRUTXH R FyGLJR WHYH R FXLGDGR GH QmR FRPHWHU HVVD RPLVVmR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH FRLVDV +i XPD TXHVWmR TXH PXLWDV YH]HV FKHJD DR 7UL EXQDO H TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR PRPHQWR HP TXH FRPHoD H HP TXH WHUPLQD D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU (VVD p XPD TXHVWmR LPSRUWDQWH SRUTXH XPD FRLVD p D FHOHEUDomR GR FRQWUDWR H RXWUD p D VXD H[HFXomR 1HP VHPSUH D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU FRPHoD QR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH FHOHEUD R FRQ WUDWR &RPSUR XPD SDVVDJHP GH DYLmR SRU H[HPSOR PDV Vy YRX YLDMDU GDTXL D XP PrV 6H DOJXpP TXH YDL YLDMDU GH DYLmR VRIUHU XP DFLGHQWH TXDQGR HVWi VH GLULJLQGR SDUD R DHURSRUWR D FRPSD QKLD DpUHD QmR WHP QDGD D YHU FRP LVVR 0HVPR TXH D SHVVRD DUJXPHQWH TXH Mi KDYLD FRPSUDGR D SDVVDJHP TXH LD YLD MDU H TXH R FRQWUDWR HVWDYD IHFKDGR QmR LPSRUWD SRLV DLQGD QmR VH KDYLD LQLFLD GR D H[HFXomR GR FRQWUDWR 8PD FRLVD p R FRQWUDWR H RXWUD FRLVD p D VXD H[HFX omR 6HQGR DVVLP VHULD PXLWR LPSRU WDQWH TXH R FyGLJR HVWDEHOHFHVVH R PR PHQWR GR LQtFLR GD H[HFXomR GR FRQWUD WR GH WUDQVSRUWH H R PRPHQWR HP TXH WHUPLQD HVVD REULJDomR $ MXULVSUXGrQ FLD YHP ID]HQGR LVWR FRP EDVWDQWH FXL GDGR 1R DUWLJR R FyGLJR WUDWRX GD TXHVWmR FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH PHUFDGRULD PDV VH HVTXHFHX RX QmR TXLV WUDWDU GLVVR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU H DTXL Mi HVWi QD SDUWH TXH WUDWD GR WUDQVSRUWH GH FRL VDV TXH FRPHoD QR DUWLJR OLPLWD GD DR YDORU FRQVWDQWH GH FRQKHFLPHQWR FR PHoD QR PRPHQWR HP TXH HOH RX VHXV SUHSRVWRV UHFHEHP D FRLVD WHUPLQD TXDQ GR p HQWUHJXH DR GHVWLQDWiULR RX GHSRVLWD GD HP MXt]R VH DTXHOH QmR IRU HQFRQWUDGRµ 4XHU GL]HU HVWDEHOHFHX VH TXDQGR FR PHoD H TXDQGR WHUPLQD R WUDQVSRUWH GH FRLVDV PDV QDGD WUDWRX FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV +i RXWUDV TXHVW}HV UHOHYDQWHV FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH PDV FRPR SURPHWL QmR XOWUDSDVVDU R WHPSR YDPRV WUDWDU GH &RQWUDWR GH 6HJXUR (VVH FRQWUDWR p WDPEpP H[WUDRUGLQiULR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR j VXD UHOHYkQFLD MX UtGLFD HFRQ{PLFD H SROtWLFD *UDQGHV HPSUHHQGLPHQWRV VH WRUQDULDP LQYLiYHLV VH QmR IRVVH D VHJXUDQoD GR VHJXUR ( p SRU LVVR TXH R VHJXUR REWHYH XP GHVHQ YROYLPHQWR IDQWiVWLFR QDV ~OWLPDV GpFD GDV (OH FLUFXOD ELOK}HV GH GyODUHV DQX DOPHQWH ,PDJLQHP R TXH VHULD GD 3HWUREUiV VH QmR IRVVH R VHJXUR TXDQ GR XPD GH VXDV PDLRUHV SODWDIRUPDV SH JRX IRJR H DIXQGRX 8P FXVWR GH ELOK}HV GH GyODUHV R TXH DEDODULD D HFRQRPLD DWp PHVPR GH XPD JUDQGH HPSUHVD ,PDJL QHP R TXH VHULD VH QmR KRXYHVVH XPD UHGH GH VHJXURV H UHVVHJXURV PXQGLDO 1R FDVR GD GHVWUXLomR GDV GXDV WRUUHV JrPHDV HP 1RYD <RUN QmR IRVVH R VHJXUR HVVH IXQHV WR DFRQWHFLPHQWR DEDODULD D HFRQRPLD DWp GH PXLWRV SDtVHV e HVWD D LPSRUWkQFLD TXH WHP R VHJXUR 1R %UDVLO GH DFRUGR FRP DV HVWDWtVWLFDV VRPRV PDLV GH VHVVHQWD PL OK}HV GH VHJXUDGRV QRV YiULRV VHJXURV 4XDOTXHU SHVVRD GH FODVVH PpGLD WHUi SHOR PHQRV XP WLSR GH VHJXUR SRU H[HPSOR GH DXWRPyYHO GH VD~GH HWF (QWmR R TXH YHP D VHU VHJXUR" 3RU TXH HOH WHP HVWD LPSRUWkQFLD HVWD HQRU PH UHOHYkQFLD" &RVWXPR FRQWDU XP IDWR UHDO TXH QRV DMXGDUi D FRPSUHHQGHU 1D GpFDGD GH WULQWD TXDQGR HVWDYDP FRQV WUXLQGR D JUDQGH SRQWH VREUH D %DtD GH 6mR )UDQFLVFR QRV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV RV FRQVWUXWRUHV VH YLUDP HQYROYLGRV FRP XP JUDYH SUREOHPD D VHJXUDQoD GRV WUDED OKDGRUHV 4XHP DLQGD KRMH VREH DR FLPR GH XPD GDV WRUUHV GDTXHOD SRQWH FRP FHUFD GH GX]HQWRV H YLQWH PHWURV GH DO WXUD H ROKD Oi GH FLPD DV iJXDV GD %DtD D FHQWHQDV GH PHWURV DEDL[R QmR GHL[D GH WHU XP DUUHSLR QD HVSLQKD &RPR VH
212 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” ULD SRVVtYHO WUDEDOKDU QDTXHODV DOWXUDV VHP R SDYRU GH VH SUHFLSLWDU QR DELVPR D TXDOTXHU PRPHQWR" $ SRQWH HVWDYD RU oDGD HP WULQWD H FLQFR PLOK}HV GH GyOD UHV H RV RSHUiULRV VDELDP TXH SDUD FDGD PLOKmR D VHU JDVWR KDYLD D SHUVSHFWLYD GH TXH XP GHOHV SRGHULD SHUGHU D VXD YLGD ,PSRUWDYD HQWmR HP GL]HU TXH DWp D FRQFOXVmR GD SRQWH FHUFD GH WULQWD H FLQFR WUDEDOKDGRUHV SRGHULDP PRUUHU ( LVWR D WRGD HYLGrQFLD JHURX SkQLFR 7R GRV WUDEDOKDYDP FRP D LGpLD IL[D GH TXH D TXDOTXHU PRPHQWR SRGHULD VH WUDQVIRU PDU HP XPD GDTXHODV WULQWD H FLQFR YtWL PDV 3RU LVVR D REUD FDPLQKDYD OHQWDPHQ WH FDXVDQGR HQRUPHV SUHMXt]RV DWp TXH DOJXpP WHYH D LGpLD GH HVWHQGHU VREUH WRGD H[WHQVmR GD SRQWH XPD JLJDQWHVFD UHGH GH FRUGDV 'H VRUWH TXH VH DOJXP RSHUiULR FDtVVH KDYHULD GH VHU DSDQKDGR SHOD UHGH $ UHGH FXVWRX RLWHQWD PLO GyOD UHV PDV UHYHORX VH GHVGH ORJR XP H[ FHOHQWH LQYHVWLPHQWR 7mR ORJR HOD IRL HV WHQGLGD RV RSHUiULRV UHDGTXLULUDP D FRQ ILDQoD YROWDUDP D WUDEDOKDU QRYDPHQWH D REUD UHDGTXLULX R DQGDPHQWR GHVHMDGR D SRQWH IRL FRQFOXtGD QR SUD]R SUHYLVWR H PHOKRU GR TXH WXGR VHP R VDFULItFLR GH XPD YLGD VHTXHU e TXH DJRUD RV RSHUiUL RV WLQKDP XPD UHVSRVWD WUDQTLOL]DGRUD SDUD DTXHOD LQTXLHWDQWH LQGDJDomR H VH HX FDLU GD SRQWH" 3DUHFH PH TXH HVVH IDWR UHYHOD TXH VHJXUDQoD H SURWHomR VmR QHFHVVLGDGHV EiVLFDV GR VHU KXPDQR SULQFLSDOPHQWH D SDUWLU GH XPD GHWHUPLQDGD FODVVH VR FLDO $ WRGR LQVWDQWH HVWDPRV QRV LQGD JDQGR ´H VH HX FDLU GD SRQWH" H VH HX PRU UHU" H VH HX ILFDU GRHQWH" H VH PLQKD FDVD SHJDU IRJR" H VH URXEDUHP R PHX DXWRPy YHO"µ ( p H[DWDPHQWH Dt TXH HQWUD D LGpLD GR VHJXUR (P XPD OLQJXDJHP ILJXUDGD SRGHUtDPRV GL]HU TXH R VHJXUR p XPD HVSpFLH GH UHGH MXUtGLFR HFRQ{PLFD TXH QRV SURWHJH FRQWUD RV ULVFRV DRV TXDLV WRGRV QyV HVWDPRV H[SRVWRV QD YLGD HP VRFLHGDGH 7RGRV QyV VDEHPRV TXH R VH JXUR p IXQGDGR p DOLFHUoDGR HP WUrV HOH PHQWRV HVVHQFLDLV R ULVFR D PXWXDOLGDGH H D ERD Ip &RVWXPR GL]HU TXH HVVHV WUrV HOHPHQWRV VmR R WULSp GR VHJXUR XPD HVSpFLH GH VDQWtVVLPD WULQGDGH XPD WULORJLD GR VHJXUR 1mR KDYHUi VHJXUR RQGH QmR KRXYHU ULVFR RQGH QmR KRXYHU PXWXDOLGDGH H RQGH QmR KRXYHU ERD Ip 2 ULVFR p R HOHPHQWR EiVLFR R HOH PHQWR PDWHULDO GR VHJXUR $V SHVVRDV Vy ID]HP VHJXUR SRUTXH HVWmR H[SRVWDV D ULVFR 6H YRFr QmR VHQWLU ULVFR GH QDGD QmR YDL ID]HU VHJXUR ( ULVFR p H[DWD PHQWH SHULJR p SUREDELOLGDGH GH GDQR 1yV ID]HPRV VHJXUR TXDQGR VHQWLPRV SUREDELOLGDGH GH GDQR TXDOTXHU TXH VHMD D VXD QDWXUH]D 0XWXDOLGDGH p R HOHPHQWR HFRQ{ PLFR GR VHJXUR e XPD RSHUDomR FROHWL YD GH SRXSDQoD TXH p IHLWD SRU WRGDV DTXHODV SHVVRDV TXH LQWHJUDP XP PHV PR JUXSR GH ULVFR 6DEHQGR TXH SRVVR VRIUHU XP VLQLVWUR VRIUHU XP GDQR HP UD]mR GR ULVFR D TXH HVWRX H[SRVWR SUR FXUR PH SUHFDYHU HVWDEHOHFHQGR DOJR TXH PH SRVVD UHSDUDU R GDQR VH HYHQWXDO PHQWH HOH RFRUUHU ( DVVLP FRP PXLWDV SHVVRDV IRUPD VH XP IXQGR FDSD] GH EDQFDU RV GDQRV GHFRUUHQWHV GRV ULVFRV D TXH SHVVRDV HVWmR H[SRVWDV ( D WRGD HYLGrQFLD WHUi TXH KDYHU Dt HVWi XP SRQWR LPSRUWDQWH R HTXLOtEULR HQWUH ULV FR H SUrPLR 3UrPLR QmR p DTXLOR TXH UHFHER GH LQGHQL]DomR PDV DTXLOR TXH SDJR FRPR VHJXUDGR 7HUi TXH KDYHU XP HTXLOtEULR XPD QHFHVViULD SURSRUFLRQD OLGDGH HQWUH R SUrPLR SDJR H RV ULVFRV D TXH HVWRX H[SRVWR SDUD IRUPDU R SDWUL P{QLR DGHTXDGR H QHFHVViULR SDUD EDQ FDU HVVHV ULVFRV ( LVWR p FDOFXODGR DWUD YpV GH GDGRV HVWDWtVWLFRV FiOFXORV DWX DULDLV D OHL GRV JUDQGHV Q~PHURV H FRP EDVWDQWH SUHFLVmR e GHVVD PDQHLUD TXH R VHJXUR VH HVWUXWXUD 8PD ERD GHILQLomR GH VHJXUR FDOFD GD QR SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH IRL DTXH OD TXH QRV GHL[RX D 5DLQKD (OL]DEHWK , GD ,QJODWHUUD Ki PDLV GH WUrV VpFXORV ´FRP R VHJXUR R GDQR p XP IDUGR TXH SHVD OH YHPHQWH VREUH XP JUDQGH Q~PHUR GH SHV VRDV HP YH] GH LQVXSRUWDYHOPHQWH VREUH XP SHTXHQR Q~PHURµ 0XWXDOLGDGH p LVVR p GLYLVmR GRV ULVFRV GH WDO PDQHLUD TXH VH WRUQH VXSRUWiYHO SRU PXLWRV DTXLOR TXH VHULD LQVXSRUWiYHO SRU SRXFRV $JRUD YHP R WHUFHLUR HOHPHQWR D ERD Ip $ ERD Ip p R HOHPHQWR MXUtGLFR GR
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 213 VHJXUR %RD Ip p R HOHPHQWR TXH OLJD PXWXDOLGDGH H ULVFR 0XWXDOLGDGH H ULV FR MDPDLV DQGDUmR MXQWRV VH QmR KRXYHU ERD Ip e D ERD Ip TXH SHUPLWH HQWUH R VHJXUDGR H R VHJXUDGRU XPD FRQYLYrQ FLD WDO TXH XP FRQWULEXD SDUD IRUPDU XP IXQGR H R RXWUR SRU VXD YH] WHQKD FRQGLo}HV GH UHSDUDU R GDQR R SUHMXt]R VH HYHQWXDOPHQWH R ULVFR D TXH HVWi H[SRVWR R VHJXUDGR YLHU D VH PDWHULDOL ]DU QR VLQLVWUR e SRU LVVR TXH RV DXWR UHV FRVWXPDP GL]HU TXH D ERD Ip p D DOPD p D UD]mR GH VHU GR VHJXUR 2QGH QmR KRXYHU D ERD Ip KDYHUi IUDXGH Pi Ip 3RU HVVD UD]mR VH FRVWXPD GL]HU TXH D IUDXGH p D PDLRU LQLPLJD GR VHJXUR SRUTXH HOD GHVHVWUXWXUD R HTXLOtEULR TXH WHP TXH KDYHU HQWUH PXWXDOLGDGH H R SUrPLR TXH GHYH VHU SDJR 2 &yGLJR DQWHULRU SUDWLFDPHQWH Vy IDODYD QD ERD Ip QR VHJXUR &RVWXPDYD VH GL]HU TXH D ERD Ip HUD XP HOHPHQWR GR VHJXUR SRUTXH Vy QR FRQWUDWR GH VH JXUR HOD HUD H[SUHVVDPHQWH PHQFLRQD GD $TXL QR VHJXUR QmR Vy WHPRV D ERD Ip VXEMHWLYD D ERD LQWHQomR GDV SDUWHV PDV WDPEpP D ERD Ip REMHWLYD SRUTXH PDLV GR TXH HP TXDOTXHU RXWUR FRQWUD WR HVWD p LQGLVSHQViYHO QR VHJXUR TXH p VHPSUH XP FRQWUDWR GH WUDWR VXFHVVL YR )D]HPRV VHJXUR SRU XP SHUtRGR XP DQR SRU H[HPSOR (QWmR R FRQWUDWR YDL VH SURORQJDU H HPERUD DV SDUWHV SRV VDP WHU ERDV LQWHQo}HV QR PRPHQWR GD FHOHEUDomR GR FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR VH QR FXUVR GR FRQWUDWR XPD GHODV SDVVDU D WHU Pi Ip SURFXUDU DXPHQWDU RV ULVFRV SRU H[HPSOR RX SURFXUDU FULDU REVWiFX ORV SDUD D H[HFXomR GR VHJXUR HOH VH WRUQD LQYLiYHO (QWmR WXGR DTXLOR TXH IRL GLWR FRP UHODomR j ERD Ip H TXH KRMH HVWi VHQGR FDQWDGD H GHFDQWDGD SRLV SDVVDUi D VHU XP SULQFtSLR JHUDO GR QRYR &yGLJR Mi HUD XP GRV HOHPHQWRV GR FRQ WUDWR HP JHUDO )HLWDV HVVDV REVHUYDo}HV GLULD DSHQDV TXH R QRYR &yGLJR YDL GDU DR FRQ WUDWR GH VHJXUR XPD GLVFLSOLQD PDLV HQ[XWD PDLV UDFLRQDO +i QR &yGLJR GH PXLWDV GLVSRVLo}HV UHSHWLWLYDV H TXH FRP R GHFRUUHU GR WHPSR VH PRVWUD UDP LQyFXDV GHVQHFHVViULDV 2 QRYR &y GLJR IH] XPD OLPSH]D GHL[DQGR DSHQDV DV FOiXVXODV H UHJUDV TXH VmR UHDOPHQWH UH OHYDQWHV H LPSRUWDQWHV ( FRPR QmR SR GHULD GHL[DU GH VHU RV WUrV HOHPHQWRV ULVFR PXWXDOLGDGH H ERD Ip QmR Vy SHUVLV WHP PDV IRUDP DLQGD PDLV SUHVWLJLDGRV H GHVWDFDGRV SRUTXH VH HVVHV HOHPHQWRV QmR IRUHP SUHVWLJLDGRV R VHJXUR SDVVDUi D VHU DEVROXWDPHQWH LQYLiYHO (QWUHWDQWR R TXH PH SDUHFH PH UHFHU GHVWDTXH p R QRYR FRQFHLWR TXH R &yGLJR GHX DR VHJXUR 2 FRQFHLWR DQWH ULRU HQVHMDYD FDGD GHILQLomR TXH GDWD YHQLD HUD GH FKRUDU &RVWXPDYD VH GL ]HU TXH R VHJXUR WUDQVIHUH R ULVFR GR VH JXUDGR SDUD R VHJXUDGRU ,VVR p XP DE VXUGR GR SRQWR GH YLVWD MXUtGLFR H IiWLFR &RP RX VHP VHJXUR TXHP FRQWLQXD HP ULVFR p R DVVHJXUDGR p R VHX FDUUR p R RSHUiULR TXH HVWi SHQGXUDGR HP DOJXP OXJDU 2 VHJXUR QmR WUDQVIHUH R ULVFR 7DPEpP QmR p DEVROXWDPHQWH FRUUHWR GL]HU TXH R FDUUR IRL VHJXUDGR TXH D SHV VRD IRL VHJXUDGD p XPD PDQHLUD GH VH GL]HU PDV QmR p LVWR TXH IRL VHJXUDGR (QWmR TXDO p UHDOPHQWH R REMHWR GR VH JXUR" 2 TXH p R VHJXUDGRU" 7HPRV QR QRYR &yGLJR XPD GHIL QLomR TXH PH SDUHFH PXLWR EHP FRORFD GD HVWi QR DUWLJR TXH GLVS}H ´3HOR FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR R VHJXUDGRU VH REULJD PHGLDQWH R SDJDPHQWR GR SUrPLR D JDUDQWLU LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR GR VHJXUDGR UHODWLYR D SHVVRD RX D FRLVD FRQWUD ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPL QDGRVµ $TXL ILFR UHDOPHQWH HP G~YLGD SRLV TXHP LUi SDJDU R SUrPLR" 4XHP SDJD R SUrPLR p R VHJXUDGR SRU LVVR HX FRORFDULD ´PHGLDQWH R UHFHELPHQWR GR SUr PLRµ PDV FRPR DVVLP HVWi GLVSRVWR YDPRV HQWHQGHU TXH RQGH VH GL] SDJD PHQWR OHLD VH UHFHELPHQWR TXHP SDJD p R VHJXUDGR H TXHP UHFHEH p R VHJXUD GRU 'HSRLV GL] ´JDUDQWLU LQWHUHVVH OHJtWL PR GR VHJXUDGR UHODWLYR D SHVVRD FRQ WUD ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPLQDGRVµ 3ULPHLUR SRQWR TXH R FRQFHLWR GHVWDFD p R VHJX UDGRU p XP JDUDQWH SRU LVVR GLJR TXH HOH p XP SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoR 2V VHQKRUHV YHMDP TXH VDELDPHQ WH R &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU VDEHQGR TXH KDYHULD PXLWD UHDomR FRORFRX H[SUHV VDPHQWH QR FRQFHLWR GH VHUYLoR D DWLYL
214 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” GDGH EDQFiULD VHFXULWiULD HWF ,QLFLDO PHQWH RV VHJXUDGRUHV TXLVHUDP VXV WHQWDU TXH QmR HUDP SUHVWDGRUHV GH VHU YLoR SRUTXH DILQDO GH FRQWDV QmR SUHVWD YDP VHUYLoR DOJXP 0DV QD UHDOLGDGH HOHV SUHVWDP VHUYLoR HOHV VmR JDUDQWHV 0DV R VHJXUDGRU JDUDQWH R TXr" (OH QmR JDUDQWH D YLGD GR VHJXUDGR SRLV FRP RX VHP VHJXUR R VHJXUDGR SRGH IDOHFHU HOH QmR JDUDQWH TXH R FDUUR HVWDUi VHPSUH FRP R VHJXUDGR 2 TXH HOH JDUDQWH p R LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR TXH R VHJXUDGR WHP HP UHODomR D FRLVDV H HP UHODomR D SHVVRDV 1RUPDOPHQWH VHUi XP LQWHUHVVH SDWULPRQLDO 2 TXH HX TXHUR TXDQGR IDoR XP VHJXUR" 4XHUR VH R PHX FDUUR IRU URXEDGR WHU R SDWULP{QLR QHFHVViULR SDUD FRPSUDU RXWUR SDUD UHSRU R PHX SUHMXt]R e XP LQWHUHVVH HFRQ{PLFR $ PHVPD FRL VD RFRUUH FRP R VHJXUR GH YLGD 2 TXH VH TXHU TXDQGR VH FHOHEUD XP VHJXUR GH YLGD" $ SHVVRD QmR TXHU PRUUHU HOD TXHU YLYHU R Pi[LPR SRVVtYHO PDV FRP D JD UDQWLD D FHUWH]D GH TXH VH PRUUHU DTXH OHV TXH GHSHQGHP GHOD QmR ILFDUmR DR DEDQGRQR p XP LQWHUHVVH HFRQ{PLFR 4XDQGR D SHVVRD ID] XP VHJXUR GH VD~ GH QmR SUHWHQGH SDVVDU GLDV LQWHUQDGR QD 87, QLQJXpP TXHU LVVR QLQJXpP HVWi LQWHUHVVDGR HP REWHU D LQGHQL]DomR GR VHJXUR SHOR FRQWUiULR R TXH VH TXHU p JDUDQWLD VHJXUDQoD WUDQTLOLGDGH e LVVR TXH GHYHPRV HQWHQGHU SRU LQWHUHVVH OH JtWLPR $JRUD HQWmR R &yGLJR HVWDEHOHFH TXH R TXH p VHJXUDGR R TXH p JDUDQWLGR p R LQWHUHVVH PDV Ki TXH VHU XP LQWH UHVVH OHJtWLPR /RJR TXDOTXHU LQWHUHV VH LOtFLWR LOHJtWLPR DLQGD TXH FHOHEUD GR FRP R VHJXUR FRQWUDULD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip FRQWUDULD D SUySULD UD]mR GH VHU GR VHJXUR (VVH FRQFHLWR HVWi SHU IHLWR QR PHX HQWHQGHU ( PDLV DLQGD GHVWDFD DTXL TXH R LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR p JDUDQWLGR FRQWUD RV ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPL QDGRV +i XPD WHQGrQFLD QRVVD LQFOX VLYH GRV PDJLVWUDGRV GH ID]HU GR VHJX UR R VHJXUDGRU XQLYHUVDO ² ´+i VHJXUR HQWmR SDJD WXGR FREUH WXGRµ ,VVR YLROD R SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH 2 FRQWUDWR IRL FHOHEUDGR WHQGR HP YLVWD GHWHUPLQD GRV ULVFRV R SUrPLR FDOFXODGR p VREUH HVVHV ULVFRV HVSHFtILFRV $TXL HVWi R HTXLOtEULR $ SDUWLU GR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH FRPHoD D LQFOXLU QR RXWUR ODGR ULV FRV TXH QmR IRUDP OHYDGRV HP FRQVLGH UDomR QR PRPHQWR GD FHOHEUDomR GR FRQ WUDWR VH HVWi TXHEUDQGR R SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH 3RLV DJRUD R &yGLJR DSH VDU GH Mi R ID]HU R DQWHULRU GL] TXH RV ULVFRV GHYHP VHU SUHGHWHUPLQDGRV TXH VmR DTXHOHV TXH IRUDP SUHYLVWRV QR FRQWUD WR QD DSyOLFH (VVD PHVPD UHJUD p HQIDWL]DGD QR DUWLJR TXH GLVS}H ´$ DSyOLFH RX R ELOKHWH GH VHJXUR VHUmR QRPLQDWLYRV j RUGHP RX DR SRUWDGRU H PHQFLRQDUmR RV ULVFRV DVVXPLGRV R LQtFLR H R ILP GH VXD YDOLGDGH R OLPLWH GD JD UDQWLD H R SUrPLR GHYLGR H TXDQGR IRU R FDVR R QRPH GR VHJXUDGR H R GR EHQHILFLiULRµ 0HQFLRQDU RV ULVFRV DVVX PLGRV p YLWDO SDUD VH PDQWHU D PXWXDOLGDGH R HTXLOtEULR 4XDQWR DR LQt FLR H R ILP GH VXD YDOLGDGH Ki XPD GLV FXVVmR PXLWR JUDQGH HP FHUWRV VHJX URV VREUH HP TXH PRPHQWR FRPHoD RX QmR D REULJDomR GR VHJXUDGRU VH p QR PRPHQWR HP TXH FHOHEURX D DSyOLFH VH p QR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH IH] R SULPHLUR SDJDPHQWR RX VH p GHSRLV (VVD p XPD TXHVWmR EDVWDQWH FRQWURYHUWLGD H TXH QRV WUD] PXLWD GLILFXOGDGH QD YLGD SUiWLFD TXDVH VHPSUH QRV LQFOLQDPRV HP IDYRU GR VHJXUDGR VHJXQGR XPD WHQGrQFLD QD WXUDO 2 QRYR &yGLJR GL] H[SUHVVDPHQWH TXH YDL YDOHU DTXLOR TXH HVWi HVFULWR QD DSyOLFH e FODUR TXH VH DTXLOR TXH HVWi HVFULWR YLRODU R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip VH IRU XPD FOiXVXOD DEXVLYD YDPRV HQWHQ GHU TXH LVVR QmR YDOH QDGD p FRPR VH QmR H[LVWLVVH 0DV VH IRU XPD FOiXVXOD UD]RiYHO FRPR SRU H[HPSOR TXH R VH JXUR YDL YDOHU D SDUWLU GH KRUDV RX DSyV R SULPHLUR SDJDPHQWR FRLVDV GHV VH WLSR QyV MXt]HV H SURILVVLRQDLV GH GL UHLWR GHYHPRV UHVSHLWDU SRUTXH p LVVR TXH HVWi HVFULWR DTXL QD OHL 6H QmR KRX YHU FROLGrQFLD FRP XP SULQFtSLR PDLRU FRPR D ERD Ip GHYH SUHYDOHFHU DTXLOR TXH IRL HVWDEHOHFLGR QD DSyOLFH SDUD R LQtFLR H ILP GD YDOLGDGH GR FRQWUDWR 7HPRV QR DUWLJR XPD FOiXVX OD TXH FROLGH GH IUHQWH FRP D MXULVSUX
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 215 GrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD $LQGD QmR p XPD MXULVSUXGrQFLD SDFtIL FD PDV SHOR PHQRV XP DFyUGmR Mi YL TXH PH GHL[RX DWp EDVWDQWH SUHRFXSD GR 2 FDVR GL]LD UHVSHLWR D XP VHJXUDGR TXH HVWDYD HP PRUD DWp LQDGLPSOHQWH SRUTXH HVWDYD VHP SDJDU R SUrPLR Ki YiULRV PHVHV H SUHFLVRX GR VHJXUR 2 VHJXUDGRU QHJRX VH D SDJDU D LQGHQL]D omR OHYDQGR R VHJXUDGR D LQJUHVVDU QD -XVWLoD QD TXDO WHYH JDQKR GH FDXVD 2 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD HQWHQGHX TXH PHVPR HVWDQGR R VHJXUDGR DWUDVD GR VH SDJRX R SUrPLR WHUi GLUHLWR j LQ GHQL]DomR e LVVR TXH SUHRFXSD SRLV RQGH ILFD D ERD Ip" (QWmR IDoR XP VH JXUR GH DXWRPyYHO H HVSHUR VH URXED UHP R PHX DXWRPyYHO YRX Oi H SDJR R TXH GHYR DSHVDU GH Mi WHU RFRUULGR R VL QLVWUR" ,VVR YLROD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip LVVR p Pi Ip SXUD 1mR YHMR QHQKXP EUL OKDQWLVPR QHVVH HQWHQGLPHQWR FRQWUD ULD D HVWUXWXUD GR VHJXUR 2 DUWLJR DJRUD KDEHPXV OHJLV H[SUHVVD GLVS}H R VHJXLQWH ´1mR WHUi GLUHLWR D LQGHQL]DomR R VHJXUDGR TXH HVWLYHU HP PRUD QR SDJDPHQWR GR SUr PLR VH RFRUUHU R VLQLVWUR DQWHV GH VXD SXUJDomRµ 6H HVVD QRUPD QmR YLROD XP SULQFtSLR GH ERD Ip XP SULQFtSLR PDLRU FUHLR TXH HOD GHYHUi VHU UHVSHLWDGD H QR PHX HQWHQGHU p XPD QRUPD DWp PRUDOL]DGRUD SRUTXH LPSHGLUi HP PXL WRV FDVRV H[DWDPHQWH HVWD SRVLomR GR LQGLYtGXR DJXDUGDU VH H TXDQGR RFRUUHU R VLQLVWUR SDUD Vy HQWmR ID]HU R SDJD PHQWR GR SUrPLR $t HOH QmR TXHU HYL GHQWHPHQWH XP VHJXUR SRLV R FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR p DOHDWyULR HOH TXHU XPD LQ GHQL]DomR PHGLDQWH XP SDJDPHQWR LQ VLJQLILFDQWH SRUTXH D LQGHQL]DomR p PXL WR PDLRU GR TXH DTXLOR TXH HOH SDJRX 2 DUWLJR p D UHSHWLomR GDTXLOR TXH HVWi QR &yGLJR DWXDO ´2 VHJXUDGR H R VHJXUDGRU VmR REULJDGRV D JXDUGDU QD FRQFOXVmR H QD H[HFXomR GR FRQWUDWR D PDLV HVWULWD ERD Ip H YHUDFLGDGH WDQWR D UHVSHLWR GR REMHWR FRPR GDV FLUFXQVWkQFL DV H GHFODUDo}HV D HOH FRQFHUQHQWHVµ -i QRV UHIHULPRV D LVVR TXDQGR GLVVHPRV TXH D ERD Ip p DOPD GR VHJXUR R VHX HOHPHQ WR MXUtGLFR PDV p WDPEpP XPD YLD GH PmR GXSOD SRUTXH WDQWR WHP TXH KDYHU ERD Ip GR VHJXUDGRU FRPR GR VHJXUDGR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR p TXH PH SUHRFXSD SRUTXH D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD p WUDQTLOD QR VHQWLGR GH TXH R VH JXUDGR Vy SHUGHUi R GLUHLWR j LQGHQL]D omR VH GH Pi Ip LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH IL ]HU DILUPDo}HV TXH QmR FRUUHVSRQGHP j UHDOLGDGH RPLWLU LQIRUPDo}HV TXH GHYH ULDP VHU SUHVWDGDV LQIRUPDo}HV TXH WH ULDP UHOHYkQFLD QD IRUPDomR GR FRQWUD WR 9DPRV DR H[HPSOR GR VHJXUR GH VD~ GH IDoR XP VHJXUR GH YLGD RX GH VD~GH H QmR LQIRUPR TXH VRIUR GH XPD GHWHU PLQDGD GRHQoD RX VHMD XPD GRHQoD SUHH[LVWHQWH (QWmR WHP VH HQWHQGLGR TXH LVVR p XPD DILUPDomR IDOVD IUDXGX OHQWD H FRQVHTHQWHPHQWH YLRODULD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip 0DV VH HX QmR VRX EHU TXH WHQKR XPD GRHQoD VH HX QmR VRXEHU TXH WHQKR XP SUREOHPD DQWH ULRU" $t QHVVH FDVR QmR HVWDULD GH Pi Ip H SRU LVVR D MXULVSUXGrQFLD FRQVD JURX R HQWHQGLPHQWR GH TXH D DILUPD omR TXH QmR FRUUHVSRQGH j YHUGDGH Vy WLUD R GLUHLWR j LQGHQL]DomR VH HOD IRU IHLWD GH Pi Ip RX VHMD VH R VHJXUDGR FRQKHFHQGR R SUREOHPD GH VD~GH FRQKH FHQGR D GRHQoD QmR D LQIRUPD (QWmR D ERD Ip p SUHVXPLGD H FDEHUi j VHJXUD GRUD SURYDU D Pi Ip GR VHJXUDGR SDUD Vy DVVLP QmR SDJDU LQGHQL]DomR $JRUD R SD UiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR GLVS}H ´6H D LQH[DWLGmR RX RPLVVmR QDV GHFODUDo}HV QmR UHVXOWDU GH Pi Ip GR VHJXUDGR SRLV VH UHVXOWDU GH Pi Ip HOH QmR WHUi GLUHL WR D QDGD R VHJXUDGRU WHUi R GLUHLWR GH UHVROYHU R FRQWUDWR RX D FREUDU PHVPR DSyV R VLQLVWUR D GLIHUHQoD GR SUrPLRµ $TXL HP RXWUD SDODYUDV HVWi GL]HQGR TXH VH R VHJXUDGR HVWDYD GH Pi Ip SHU GHUi WXGR VH HVWLYHU GH ERD Ip PDV IL ]HU XPD DILUPDomR SRU H[HPSOR TXH HVWDYD VDGLR H GHSRLV FRQVWDWRX VH TXH HOH WLQKD XPD GRHQoD R VHJXUDGRU SRGH GL]HU TXH QmR TXHU PDLV R FRQWUDWR TXH HVWH HVWi URPSLGR TXH QmR SDJDUi D LQGH QL]DomR H DLQGD LUi FREUDU GR VHJXUDGR R SUrPLR TXH HVWH GHYLD 4XHU GL]HU WUDWD VH GH XPD FOiXVXOD IHUR] YLROHQWD FRQWUD R VHJXUDGR -i GHYHPRV LU SHQVDQGR QD LQWHUSUHWDomR TXH OKH YDPRV GDU
216 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” $TXL PH SDUHFH KRXYH XP UHWUR FHVVR PDV D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD VDEHUmR GDU R WUDWR DGHTXDGR j TXHV WmR D ILP GH TXH QmR KDMD PDLRUHV SUH MXt]RV HP PDWpULD GH WDO LPSRUWkQFLD 2 &yGLJR GLVFLSOLQRX PHOKRU D TXHVWmR GR DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR (VVH p RXWUR SRQWR LPSRUWDQWH VH TXDQGR FHOHEUD PRV R FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR HVWDEHOHFH PRV XP HTXLOtEULR HQWUH ULVFR H SUrPLR LVVR p PXWXDOLGDGH H HVWH FRQWUDWR GH WUDWR VXFHVVLYR LUi SHUGXUDU VHUi QH FHVViULR TXH DV SDUWHV QD PHGLGD GR SRVVtYHO PDQWHQKDP R VWDWXV TXR 2 VHJXUDGR QmR GHYH DJUDYDU RV VHXV ULV FRV QmR GHYH DXPHQWi ORV VRE SHQD GH HYHQWXDOPHQWH FDXVDU XP GHVHTXLOtEULR QR FRQWUDWR 2 &yGLJR GH IDOD QR DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR H D GRXWULQD H MX ULVSUXGrQFLD FRQVDJUDUDP R HQWHQGL PHQWR GH TXH HVVH DJUDYDPHQWR Vy H[ FOXL D LQGHQL]DomR GR VHJXUDGR VH IRU GH Pi Ip LQWHQFLRQDO 3RU H[HPSOR PRUR HP XPD FLGDGH SDFDWD GR LQWHULRU H WHQKD R PHX FDUUR VHJXUDGR Oi 'H UH SHQWH PXGHL PH SDUD R 5LR GH -DQHLUR RQGH R URXER H IXUWR GH DXWRPyYHLV VmR PXLWR JUDQGHV $XPHQWHL R ULVFR PDV SRU TXDOTXHU UD]mR HVTXHFL PH H QmR FRPXQLTXHL j 6HJXUDGRUD H GH UHSHQ WH R PHX FDUUR p URXEDGR $ 6HJXUDGR UD YDL DOHJDU TXH VH PH PXGHL SDUD R 5LR GH -DQHLUR H QmR FRPXQLTXHL HVWH IDWR SHUGL R GLUHLWR SRU WHU DJUDYDGR R ULVFR +i HQWHQGLPHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO QR VHQWLGR GH Vy DGPLWLU D SHUGD GD LQ GHQL]DomR TXDQGR R DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULV FR IRU LQWHQFLRQDO 2 FHUWR VHUi LPHGLD WDPHQWH FRPXQLFDU R DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR PDV HVWH Vy H[FOXLUi D LQGHQL]D omR VH KRXYHU LQWHQFLRQDOLGDGH $JRUD R DUWLJR p FODUR ´2 VHJXUDGR SHUGHUi R GLUHLWR j JDUDQWLD VH DJUDYDU LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH R ULVFR REMHWR GR FRQWUDWRµ 1mR KDYHQGR DJUDYDPHQ WR LQWHQFLRQDO HYLGHQWHPHQWH QmR KD YHUi TXH VH IDODU HP SHUGD GD LQGH QL]DomR 8PD RXWUD QRUPD LPSRUWDQWH H TXH GH FHUWD PDQHLUD EDWH GH IUHQWH FRP D MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7UL EXQDO GH -XVWLoD p D GR DUWLJR 2V VHQKRUHV VH OHPEUDP GD TXHVWmR FRQ WURYHUWLGD FRP UHODomR D VHJXUR GH DXWR PyYHO VH D LQGHQL]DomR GHYHULD VHU SHOR SUHoR GH PHUFDGR RX VH SHOR YDORU GD DSy OLFH (VVD TXHVWmR IRL PXLWR GLVFXWLGD H Ki UD]}HV SDUD RV GRLV ODGRV $ DOHJDomR SULQFLSDO p HVWD D LQGHQL]DomR QmR SRGH VHU PDLRU GR TXH R YDORU GD FRLVD 4XDQ GR IRL IHLWR R VHJXUR GR DXWRPyYHO R VHX YDORU HUD FLQTHQWD PLO ² HVVH p R YDORU GD DSyOLFH ² PDV TXDQGR RFRUUHX R VLQLV WUR Vy YDOLD TXDUHQWD PLO 4XDO GHYH VHU R YDORU GD LQGHQL]DomR" &LQTHQWD RX TXDUHQWD PLO" 3DUD D VHJXUDGRUD TXDUHQ WD SRUTXH HVWH p R YDORU DWXDO GR EHP 0DV R VHJXUDGR SDJRX R SUrPLR VREUH FLQ THQWD ,VVR FKHJRX DR 6XSHULRU 7ULEX QDO GH -XVWLoD TXH LQLFLDOPHQWH HQWHQ GHX TXH HUD R YDORU GR PHUFDGR H GHSRLV GHX XPD JXLQDGD HP HPEDUJRV GH GLYHU JrQFLD HP XP DFyUGmR HP TXH KDYLD HV WDEHOHFLGR R YDORU GR PHUFDGR 2 UHODWRU IRL R QRVVR HVWLPDGR 0LQLVWUR :DOGHPDU =YHLWHU $ SDUWLU GHVVH PRPHQWR R 6XSH ULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD SDVVRX D HQWHQ GHU TXH GHYHUi VHU R YDORU GD DSyOLFH $JRUD WHPRV DTXL R DUWLJR TXH PH SDUHFH VHU XP REVWiFXOR D HVVH HQ WHQGLPHQWR 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ LQGH QL]DomR QmR SRGH XOWUDSDVVDU R YDORU GR LQWH UHVVH VHJXUDGR QR PRPHQWR GR VLQLVWUR H HP KLSyWHVH DOJXPD R OLPLWH Pi[LPR GD JD UDQWLD IL[DGR QD DSyOLFH VDOYR HP FDVR GH PRUD GR VHJXUDGRUµ (P FDVR GH PRUD GR VHJXUDGRU PDQGD VH SDJDU MXURV H FRU UHomR PRQHWiULD $R TXH WXGR LQGLFD D GLVFXVVmR VHUi UHLQLFLDGD QR VHQWLGR GH VDEHU VH HVVD SRVLomR GR 6XSHULRU D SDU WLU GR &yGLJR QRYR HVWi HP YLJRU RX QmR 7HPRV RXWUD QRUPD LPSRUWDQWH QR DUWLJR H TXH WDPEpP FRQVDJURX R HQWHQGLPHQWR SUHGRPLQDQWH $ WHP R VHX DXWRPyYHO VHJXUDGR YHQGH R SDUD % WUDQVIHULQGR OKH R VHJXUR 'HSRLV TXH R DXWRPyYHO Mi HVWi HP SRGHU GH % p URX EDGR RX IXUWDGR $t R % YHP SHGLU R VHJX UR PDV D VHJXUDGRUD DOHJD TXH WLQKD VH JXUR FRP $ H TXH HVWH DR WUDQVIHULU R DXWRPyYHO VHP QDGD DYLVDU DJUDYRX R ULV FR UD]mR SHOD TXDO QmR SDJDUi D LQGHQL ]DomR +i QR &yGLJR GH XPD FHUWD G~YLGD VH HUD RX QmR SRVVtYHO HVVD WUDQV IHUrQFLD GR VHJXUR +RMH R DUWLJR FRQ VDJUD R HQWHQGLPHQWR TXH SUHYDOHFHX QD
Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 217 GRXWULQD H MXULVSUXGrQFLD ´VDOYR GLVSRVL omR HP FRQWUiULR DGPLWH VH D WUDQVIHUrQ FLD GR FRQWUDWR D WHUFHLUR FRP D DOLHQD omR RX FHVVmR GR LQWHUHVVH VHJXUDGRµ 2XWUD TXHVWmR TXH IRL FRQVWUXomR GD GRXWULQD H GD MXULVSUXGrQFLD HVWi FRQVDJUDGD QR DUWLJR D VXE URJD omR 4XDQGR LQJUHVVHL QD PDJLVWUDWX UD XPD GDV TXHVW}HV WRUPHQWRVDV HUD VH R VHJXUDGRU WLQKD RX QmR R GLUHLWR GH VXE URJDU VH QRV GLUHLWRV GR VHJXUDGR GHSRLV GH SDJDU D LQGHQL]DomR +DYLD WHVHV SDUD WRGRV RV ODGRV )LQDOPHQWH D MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 67) FULVWDOL]DGD QD 6~PXOD Qž FRQVDJURX R HQWHQGLPHQ WR GH TXH R VHJXUDGRU VXE URJD VH QR GLUHLWR GR VHJXUDGR (VVD V~PXOD HVWi KRMH SRVLWLYDGD QR DUWLJR TXH GLV S}H ´3DJD D LQGHQL]DomR R VHJXUDGRU VXE URJD VH QRV OLPLWHV GR YDORU UHVSHF WLYR QRV GLUHLWRV H Do}HV TXH FRPSHWL UHP DR VHJXUDGR FRQWUD R DXWRU GR GDQRµ 2 SDUiJUDIR SULPHLUR WHP XPD FHUWD H[ FHomR TXH QmR QRV LQWHUHVVD QR PRPHQ WR 2V DUWLJRV H WUDWDUDP GH GXDV TXHVW}HV WRUPHQWRVDV QR VHJXUR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO Ki XPD FRUUHQWH TXH Ki PXLWR WHPSR YLQKD GHIHQGHQGR D DG PLVVLELOLGDGH GD DomR GLUHWD GR WHUFHLUR FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU 8PD SHVVRD WHP VHJXUR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO FRP UHODomR DR VHX DXWRPyYHO EDWH HP DO JXpP H GH UHSHQWH HVVH TXH FDXVRX R DFLGHQWH QmR WHP FRQGLo}HV GH UHSDUDU R GDQR PDV R VHJXUDGRU WHP (QWmR D TXHVWmR p HVVD VH D YtWLPD VH R WHUFHL UR TXH VRIUHX R SUHMXt]R SRGHULD PRYHU DomR LQGHQL]DWyULD GLUHWDPHQWH FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU +i PXLWR WHPSR TXH HVVD LGpLD YHP VHQGR WUDEDOKDGD QR VHQWLGR GH TXH SRGH 2 &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU GHX XP SDVVR DYDQoDGR HPERUD QmR SHUPLWD D GHQXQFLDomR GD OLGH DR VHJX UDGRU SRUTXH VHQmR HOH YHP SDUD FRP SOLFDU R SURFHVVR SHUPLWH WRGDYLD R FKDPDPHQWR DR SURFHVVR ( VH HOH p FKDPDGR D H[HFXomR SRGH VHU IHLWD GL UHWDPHQWH FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU (UD D RSRUWXQLGDGH GH VH GDU XP SDVVR H GH VH HVWDEHOHFHU D DomR GLUHWD FRQWUD R VH JXUDGRU QR FDVR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FL YLO 2 DUWLJR QmR R IH] GLVSRQGR R VHJXLQWH ´1R VHJXUR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO R VHJXUDGRU JDUDQWH R SDJDPHQWR GH SHUGDV H GDQRV GHYLGRV SHOR VHJXUDGR D WHUFHLURµ 1RV SDUiJUDIRV ž ž ž H ž HVWDEHOHFH XPD VpULH GH H[LJrQFLDV SDUD TXH R VHJXUDGR QmR SHUFD HVVH GLUHLWR 1R DUWLJR HQWUHWDQWR DGPLWLX D DomR GLUHWD QR FDVR GH VHJXUR REULJD WyULR PDV QmR QR FDVR GR VHJXUR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO ´1RV VHJXURV GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH OHJDOPHQWH REULJDWyULRV D LQGHQL]DomR SRU VLQLVWURV VHUi SDJD SHOR VHJXUDGRU GLUHWDPHQWH DR WHUFHLUR SUH MXGLFDGRµ ( HVVD p D QRUPD TXH PH SD UHFH GHYHULD HVWDU Oi QR DUWLJR WDP EpP 6HULD XP DYDQoR HOLPLQDULD XPD FDUUDGD GH Do}HV TXH DLQGD KRMH DFRQ WHFHP R TXH GH FHUWD PDQHLUD QD SUi WLFD PXLWDV VHJXUDGRUDV Mi ID]HP 4XDQGR RFRUUH R DFLGHQWH R YHtFXOR p HQFDPLQKDGR SDUD XPD RILFLQD DXWRUL ]DGD H DOL FRQVHUWDGR GLUHWDPHQWH &RP UHODomR DR VHJXUR GH SHVVRDV JRVWDULD GH GHVWDFDU DSHQDV GRLV GLVSR VLWLYRV R SULPHLUR GHOHV p R DUWLJR TXH WDPEpP p XPD FRQVDJUDomR QD OHL GDTXLOR TXH IRL FRQVWUXtGR SHOD MXULVSUX GrQFLD 4XDQGR HQWUHL QD PDJLVWUDWX UD VH DOJXpP IL]HVVH XP VHJXUR GH YLGD SDUD D VXD FRQFXELQD TXH HUD XP SDOD YUmR QmR WHULD YDOLGDGH &RQVWUXLX VH GHEDWHX VH GLVFXWLX VH H D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD SUDWLFDPHQWH Vy QmR DGPLWH FRPR EHQHILFLiULD GR VHJXUR D DPDQWH 0DV QR FDVR GH FRPSDQKHLUD GH FRQYLYrQ FLD DGPLWH VH WUDQTLODPHQWH R VHJXUR HP VHX IDYRU 2 DUWLJR DJRUD FRQVD JUD HVVD UHJUD ´e YiOLGD D LQVWLWXLomR GR FRPSDQKHLUR FRPR EHQHILFLiULR VH DR WHPSR GR FRQWUDWR R VHJXUDGR HUD VHSD UDGR MXGLFLDOPHQWH RX Mi VH HQFRQWUDYD VHSDUDGR GH IDWRµ 1mR SUHFLVD QHP VHU D XQLmR HVWiYHO 6H KRXYHU VHSDUDomR GH IDWR VHUi YiOLGD D LQVWLWXLomR YDL GHVD SDUHFHU GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO SRUWDQWR R DUWLJR GR &yGLJR GH TXH GLV S}H ´QmR VH SRGH LQVWLWXLU EHQHILFLiULR SHVVRD TXH IRU OHJDOPHQWH LQLELGD H UH FHEHU D GRDomR GR VHJXUDGRµ 3RU ~OWLPR JRVWDULD GH GHVWDFDU R DUWLJR PXLWR FXULRVR SRLV DJRUD YD
218 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” PRV WHU VXLFtGLR FRP SUD]R GH FDUrQFLD 2V VHQKRUHV VDEHP TXH FRP UHODomR DR VXLFtGLR D MXULVSUXGrQFLD WDQWR GR 6X SUHPR FRPR GR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XV WLoD HQWHQGHX TXH Vy QmR p GHYLGD D LQ GHQL]DomR VH VH WUDWDU GH VXLFtGLR SUH PHGLWDGR e UDUtVVLPR R FDVR GH VXLFtGLR SUHPHGLWDGR 4XDVH VHPSUH p IUXWR GH GHSUHVVmR H SRU LVVR D LQGHQL]DomR p VHPSUH GHYLGD DWp SRUTXH SURYDU D SUH PHGLWDomR QmR p IiFLO (VVD SURYD FDEH ULD DR VHJXUDGRU 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H R VHJXLQWH ´2 EHQHILFLiULR QmR WHP GLUHL WR DR FDSLWDO HVWLSXODGR TXDQGR R VHJX UDGR VH VXLFLGD QRV SULPHLURV GRLV DQRV GH YLJrQFLD LQLFLDO GR FRQWUDWR RX GD VXD UHFRQGXomR GHSRLV GH VXVSHQVR REVHU YDGR R GLVSRVWR QR SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR DQWHFHGHQWHµ 6H D ILQDOLGDGH DTXL HUD DIDVWDU D SUHPHGLWDomR DFDERX VH HVWDEHOHFHQGR DSHQDV XP SUD]R PDLRU GH SUHPHGLWDomR $JRUD VHUi SUHFLVR SOD QHMDU XP VXLFtGLR FRP QR PtQLPR GRLV DQRV GH DQWHFHGrQFLD 6H p FXULRVR RX QmR p R TXH HVWi HVFULWR DTXL 2 OHJLVOD GRU HQWHQGHX TXH QLQJXpP YDL SUHPH GLWDU XP VXLFtGLR FRP GRLV DQRV GH DQ WHFHGrQFLD GH VRUWH TXH VH R VXLFtGLR RFRUUHU GRLV DQRV DSyV R VHJXUR SUHVX PH VH TXH QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR 0DV VH RFRUUHU DQWHV DLQGD TXH VHMD XP LQIH OL] FRP SURIXQGD GHSUHVVmR HP XP HV WDGR GH DOXFLQDomR HWF PHVPR DVVLP VH DSOLFDUPRV D OHL FRPR HVWi HVFULWR QmR KDYHUi LQGHQL]DomR e FODUR TXH DTXL WDPEpP YDPRV WHU TXH ID]HU GLVWLQomR FDGD FDVR p XP FDVR 6H HYLGHQFLDGR TXH R VXLFtGLR GHFRUUHX GH XPD VLWXDomR GH DQJ~VWLD GH DIOLomR GH SHUWXUEDomR GH GHSUHVVmR GHYLGD VHUi D LQGHQL]DomR 7DOYH] VHUi FDVR GH VH LQYHUWHU R {QXV GD SURYD 'XUDQWH HVVHV GRLV DQRV WHUi TXH VH SURYDU TXH R VXLFtGLR QmR IRL SUH PHGLWDGR 'HSRLV GH GRLV DQRV KDYHUi XPD SUHVXQomR DEVROXWD GH TXH R VXLFt GLR QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR $ LQWHUSUHWDomR TXH IDoR GHVGH DJRUD p TXH QHVVH SHUt RGR GH GRLV DQRV VHUi SUHFLVR SURYDU TXH R VXLFtGLR QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR 'HSRLV GRV GRLV DQRV KDYHUi SUHVXQomR DEVROX WD GH TXH QmR KRXYH SUHPHGLWDomR (QFHUUR UHODWDQGR D KLVWyULD GH XP PHQLQR TXH PRUDYD QR LQWHULRU GH 0L QDV *HUDLV H TXH XP GLD YHLR SDVVHDU QR 5LR GH -DQHLUR FRP D VXD PmH RQGH WHYH D RSRUWXQLGDGH GH FRQKHFHU R PDU )RL XP GHVOXPEUDPHQWR %ULQFRX QD SUDLD FDWRX FRQFKLQKDV SXORX RQGDV H TXDQGR UHWRUQRX D VXD FLGDGH]LQKD QD WDO UHODWRX HPSROJDGR DR VHX DY{ D VXD QRYD DYHQWXUD ( WHUPLQRX R VHX UHODWR ID]HQGR XPD SHUJXQWD YRY{ YRFr WDP EpP FRQKHFH R PDU" (OH TXH HUD XP YH OKR PDUXMR FRP PDLV GH WULQWD DQRV GH QDYHJDomR DR VH UHOHPEUDU HP XP LQV WDQWH GDV VXDV SURIXQGDV H[SHULrQFLDV FRP R RFHDQR UHVSRQGHX FRP FHUWD LQ VHJXUDQoD TXH WDPEpP FRQKHFLD R PDU 8P QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO p XP RFHDQR SRLV DTXL HVWi WRGD D HVWUXWXUD GD RUGHP MXUtGLFD EUDVLOHLUD (VWRX TXHUHQGR GL]HU TXH HVVH RFHDQR TXH HVWi DTXL GLDQWH GH WRGRV QyV SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR GH GXDV PDQHLUDV SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR FRPR SRU DTXHOH PHQLQR TXH EULQFRX QD SUDLD H LPDJLQRX TXH FRQKHFLD R PDU H SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR FRPR SRU DTXHOH PDUXMR TXH QDYHJRX WULQWD DQRV QR RFHDQR HQIUHQ WRX WRGR WLSR GH WHPSHVWDGH H DLQGD WL QKD FHUWD LQVHJXUDQoD DR GL]HU TXH FR QKHFLD R PDU 7RGRV QyV WHUHPRV TXH QDYHJDU QHVVH QRYR RFHDQR H LVVR FRPH oDUi QR GLD TXH HVVH &yGLJR HQWUDU HP YLJRU 3RGHUHPRV ILFDU QD SUDLD EULQFDQ GR RX SRGHUHPRV LQLFLDU XPD YLDJHP IDQ WiVWLFD H TXH QmR WHUi ILP 2 REMHWLYR GD (0(5- p HVWLPXODU D WRGRV D TXH FRQKH oDPRV SURIXQGDPHQWH HVVH &yGLJR H SRV VDPRV DVVLP GDU D HOH D DSOLFDomR TXH HOH PHUHFH 2EULJDGR SHOD DWHQomR

Recomendados

Vivendo mundo espiritos_patricia
Vivendo mundo espiritos_patriciaVivendo mundo espiritos_patricia
Vivendo mundo espiritos_patriciaFERNANDO HINSCHING
 
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapman
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapmanAs cinco linguagens do amor gary chapman
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapmanJaneEyreFernandes
 
Cantos hora santa ocacional
Cantos hora santa ocacionalCantos hora santa ocacional
Cantos hora santa ocacionaltorrasko
 
A casa abandonada
A casa abandonadaA casa abandonada
A casa abandonadaMarco Antonio Oliveira
 
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlook
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlookCurso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlook
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlookjunior Revoredo
 
Apostila gestao do conhecimento
Apostila gestao do conhecimentoApostila gestao do conhecimento
Apostila gestao do conhecimentoclaudio guimaraes
 
Gastronomia boas maneiras
Gastronomia boas maneirasGastronomia boas maneiras
Gastronomia boas maneirasaletriak
 
Introducao ao direito sebentua
Introducao ao direito sebentuaIntroducao ao direito sebentua
Introducao ao direito sebentuaNoemia
 

Recomendados

Vivendo mundo espiritos_patricia
Vivendo mundo espiritos_patriciaVivendo mundo espiritos_patricia
Vivendo mundo espiritos_patriciaFERNANDO HINSCHING
 
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapman
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapmanAs cinco linguagens do amor gary chapman
As cinco linguagens do amor gary chapmanJaneEyreFernandes
 
Cantos hora santa ocacional
Cantos hora santa ocacionalCantos hora santa ocacional
Cantos hora santa ocacionaltorrasko
 
A casa abandonada
A casa abandonadaA casa abandonada
A casa abandonadaMarco Antonio Oliveira
 
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlook
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlookCurso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlook
Curso de manutenção e mecânica de bicicletas.armlookjunior Revoredo
 
Apostila gestao do conhecimento
Apostila gestao do conhecimentoApostila gestao do conhecimento
Apostila gestao do conhecimentoclaudio guimaraes
 
Gastronomia boas maneiras
Gastronomia boas maneirasGastronomia boas maneiras
Gastronomia boas maneirasaletriak
 
Introducao ao direito sebentua
Introducao ao direito sebentuaIntroducao ao direito sebentua
Introducao ao direito sebentuaNoemia
 
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.comAmante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.comRita De Cássia Costa
 
02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textual02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textualAlaine Soares
 
Presentation_1370606544514
Presentation_1370606544514Presentation_1370606544514
Presentation_1370606544514Alexander Nevidimov
 
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoVagner de Alencar
 
Aprend internet
Aprend internet Aprend internet
Aprend internet webphotoshop
 
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonadaH.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonadaTiago Inacio
 
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167Maggie Beltran
 
Lgbt professores
Lgbt professoresLgbt professores
Lgbt professoresLicínia Simões
 
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cubaErnesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cubaPraxisfhycs
 
1649604
16496041649604
1649604estevaomoraes
 
101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negocios101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negociostalporcual
 
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de ÓrgãosAula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de ÓrgãosJaqueline Almeida
 
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e AcolhimentoRegulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e AcolhimentoRodrigo Zardo
 
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...Elvio Hellbilly Bosetti
 
Catalogo Pantalonetas Surf
Catalogo Pantalonetas SurfCatalogo Pantalonetas Surf
Catalogo Pantalonetas SurfErick Venegas Herrera
 
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivasPosible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivasCentro Universitario Villanueva
 
Vortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung SchimmelpilzVortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung SchimmelpilzLars Bobach
 
Propuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SWPropuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SWAlberto Almeida
 
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redesBCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redesMario Abate Liotti Falco
 
Vortrag zum Thema Issue Management
Vortrag zum Thema Issue ManagementVortrag zum Thema Issue Management
Vortrag zum Thema Issue ManagementKuhn, Kammann und Kuhn
 
Full moon
Full moonFull moon
Full moonErika Castillo
 
Revistas octubre03.compressed
Revistas octubre03.compressedRevistas octubre03.compressed
Revistas octubre03.compressedTatiana Villalobos
 

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.comAmante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.comRita De Cássia Costa
 
02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textual02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textualAlaine Soares
 
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoVagner de Alencar
 
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonadaH.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonadaTiago Inacio
 
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167Maggie Beltran
 
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cubaErnesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cubaPraxisfhycs
 
101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negocios101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negociostalporcual
 
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de ÓrgãosAula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de ÓrgãosJaqueline Almeida
 
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e AcolhimentoRegulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e AcolhimentoRodrigo Zardo
 
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...Elvio Hellbilly Bosetti
 

La actualidad más candente (14)

Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.comAmante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
Amante elegante www.downloadsrapidao.com
 
02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textual02 tipologia textual
02 tipologia textual
 
Presentation_1370606544514
Presentation_1370606544514Presentation_1370606544514
Presentation_1370606544514
 
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
 
Aprend internet
Aprend internet Aprend internet
Aprend internet
 
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonadaH.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
H.P. Lovecraft - A Casa abandonada
 
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
El amor de tu vida es scribd com 167
 
Lgbt professores
Lgbt professoresLgbt professores
Lgbt professores
 
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cubaErnesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
Ernesto guevara el socialismo y el hombre en cuba
 
1649604
16496041649604
1649604
 
101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negocios101 ideas de negocios
101 ideas de negocios
 
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de ÓrgãosAula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
Aula de Bioética sobre Transplante de Órgãos
 
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e AcolhimentoRegulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
Regulacao Politica Nacional de Humanizacao e Acolhimento
 
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
Cruz e bosetti 2008 - Geography and paleontology: perspectives on their inte...
 

Destacado

Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivasPosible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivasCentro Universitario Villanueva
 
Vortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung SchimmelpilzVortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung SchimmelpilzLars Bobach
 
Propuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SWPropuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SWAlberto Almeida
 
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redesBCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redesMario Abate Liotti Falco
 
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher Zuweiserbeziehungen
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher ZuweiserbeziehungenSeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher Zuweiserbeziehungen
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher ZuweiserbeziehungenSwiss eHealth Forum
 
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der Arztpraxen
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der ArztpraxenSeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der Arztpraxen
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der ArztpraxenSwiss eHealth Forum
 
Können Games die Welt verändern?
Können Games die Welt verändern?Können Games die Welt verändern?
Können Games die Welt verändern?Moritz Zumbühl
 
Ergonomía básica1
Ergonomía básica1Ergonomía básica1
Ergonomía básica1AndrecythoOo
 
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4aldomat07
 
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglas
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglasPlan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglas
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglasDeximar Boza
 
Manuales prezi y blogger
Manuales prezi y bloggerManuales prezi y blogger
Manuales prezi y bloggertabatha96
 
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOS
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOSDANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOS
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOSsmithies
 

Destacado (20)

Catalogo Pantalonetas Surf
Catalogo Pantalonetas SurfCatalogo Pantalonetas Surf
Catalogo Pantalonetas Surf
 
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivasPosible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
Posible trabajo para los alumnos sobre habilidades directivas
 
Vortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung SchimmelpilzVortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
Vortrag Sanierung Schimmelpilz
 
Propuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SWPropuesta de proyecto SW
Propuesta de proyecto SW
 
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redesBCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
BCV Al encuentro n° 12- noviembre 2014.redes
 
Vortrag zum Thema Issue Management
Vortrag zum Thema Issue ManagementVortrag zum Thema Issue Management
Vortrag zum Thema Issue Management
 
Full moon
Full moonFull moon
Full moon
 
Revistas octubre03.compressed
Revistas octubre03.compressedRevistas octubre03.compressed
Revistas octubre03.compressed
 
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher Zuweiserbeziehungen
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher ZuweiserbeziehungenSeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher Zuweiserbeziehungen
SeHF 2015 | Prozesse zur Gestaltung erfolgreicher Zuweiserbeziehungen
 
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der Arztpraxen
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der ArztpraxenSeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der Arztpraxen
SeHF 2015 | Optimierungspotenziale im Überweisungs-Management der Arztpraxen
 
3. medición y error
3. medición y error3. medición y error
3. medición y error
 
Können Games die Welt verändern?
Können Games die Welt verändern?Können Games die Welt verändern?
Können Games die Welt verändern?
 
Ergonomía básica1
Ergonomía básica1Ergonomía básica1
Ergonomía básica1
 
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4
Tema 12 Operadores Matemáticos 4
 
Parachute
ParachuteParachute
Parachute
 
Proyecto de inserción
Proyecto de inserciónProyecto de inserción
Proyecto de inserción
 
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglas
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglasPlan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglas
Plan de negocio para micro, pequeña y mediana empresa douglas
 
Manuales prezi y blogger
Manuales prezi y bloggerManuales prezi y blogger
Manuales prezi y blogger
 
Veneconomía El Escorpión y la rana...
Veneconomía El Escorpión y la rana...Veneconomía El Escorpión y la rana...
Veneconomía El Escorpión y la rana...
 
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOS
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOSDANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOS
DANZAS LÚDICAS Y JUEGOS COREOGRÁFICOS
 

Similar a Anais parte i_revistaemerj_206

A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoVagner de Alencar
 
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoVagner de Alencar
 
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...CIDAADS
 
historia do brasil pauloprado
historia do brasil paulopradohistoria do brasil pauloprado
historia do brasil paulopradoOnésimo Remígio
 
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismo
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismoEducação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismo
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismowsshist
 
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletasCurso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletasSerginho Sucesso
 
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletasManutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletasEdson Lopes
 
Projecto ES de Amares
Projecto ES de AmaresProjecto ES de Amares
Projecto ES de Amaresjsilva76
 
1ª Antología. Primera Parte
1ª Antología. Primera Parte1ª Antología. Primera Parte
1ª Antología. Primera Parteautobombo
 
1ª Antología. Segunda Parte
1ª Antología. Segunda Parte1ª Antología. Segunda Parte
1ª Antología. Segunda Parteautobombo
 
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmicaMH63
 

Similar a Anais parte i_revistaemerj_206 (20)

A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
 
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismoA construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
A construção da imagem do pcc no jornalismo
 
Patologia das construções usp
Patologia das construções uspPatologia das construções usp
Patologia das construções usp
 
Manual de yoga
Manual de yogaManual de yoga
Manual de yoga
 
ATUALIZAÇÃO DO CÓDIGO COMERCIAL BRASILEIRO
ATUALIZAÇÃO DO CÓDIGO COMERCIAL BRASILEIROATUALIZAÇÃO DO CÓDIGO COMERCIAL BRASILEIRO
ATUALIZAÇÃO DO CÓDIGO COMERCIAL BRASILEIRO
 
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...
Electricidaads - A importância dos Museus como Lugares de Aprendizagem - Joaq...
 
Licao1 aluno
Licao1 alunoLicao1 aluno
Licao1 aluno
 
Retrato do brasil
Retrato do brasilRetrato do brasil
Retrato do brasil
 
historia do brasil pauloprado
historia do brasil paulopradohistoria do brasil pauloprado
historia do brasil pauloprado
 
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismo
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismoEducação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismo
Educação. do liberalismo ao neoliberalismo
 
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletasCurso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Curso de manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
 
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletasManutenção e reparos de bicicletas
Manutenção e reparos de bicicletas
 
Projecto ES de Amares
Projecto ES de AmaresProjecto ES de Amares
Projecto ES de Amares
 
Um seu ze
Um seu zeUm seu ze
Um seu ze
 
1ª Antología. Primera Parte
1ª Antología. Primera Parte1ª Antología. Primera Parte
1ª Antología. Primera Parte
 
1ª Antología. Segunda Parte
1ª Antología. Segunda Parte1ª Antología. Segunda Parte
1ª Antología. Segunda Parte
 
Filosofia aula1
Filosofia aula1Filosofia aula1
Filosofia aula1
 
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica
( Apometria) apostila de apometria cosmica
 
Goleman-2.pdf
Goleman-2.pdfGoleman-2.pdf
Goleman-2.pdf
 
Enfermidades de pacus e patingas
Enfermidades de pacus e patingasEnfermidades de pacus e patingas
Enfermidades de pacus e patingas
 

Más de Marcia Regina Mourao

1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarialMarcia Regina Mourao
 
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarialMarcia Regina Mourao
 

Más de Marcia Regina Mourao (8)

Demografia
DemografiaDemografia
Demografia
 
Capitalismo socialismo 9 ano
Capitalismo socialismo 9 anoCapitalismo socialismo 9 ano
Capitalismo socialismo 9 ano
 
Blocoeconomico8ano0810
Blocoeconomico8ano0810Blocoeconomico8ano0810
Blocoeconomico8ano0810
 
Cantigas de amor
Cantigas de amorCantigas de amor
Cantigas de amor
 
copa 2014
copa 2014copa 2014
copa 2014
 
America do sul
America do sulAmerica do sul
America do sul
 
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
 
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
1. ramos, andré luiz santa cruz direito empresarial
 

Anais parte i_revistaemerj_206

  • 1. 206 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” Os Contratos de Transporte de Pessoa e de Seguro no Novo Código Civil 66666(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2(5*,2 &&&&&$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5,$9$/,(5, ))))),/+2,/+2,/+2,/+2,/+2 'HVHPEDUJDGRU 7- 5- 'LUHWRU *HUDO GD (0(5- oD DV ORFRPRWLYDV D YDSRU TXH IRUDP RV SULPHLURV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR 'L]HP TXH DV SULPHLUDV ORFRPRWLYDV GH VHQYROYLDP D HVSDQWRVD YHORFLGDGH GH NP K 'H NP K SDVVRX VH SDUD NP K NP K NP K NP K DWp FKHJDU DRV WUHQV EDOD TXH DLQGD QmR FKHJDUDP DR %UDVLO DRV DYL}HV H DWp PHVPR DRV VXSHUV{QLFRV (QTXDQWR R 3URMHWR GH &OyYLV %HYLOiTXD GRUPLWDYD QR &RQJUHVVR SRU TXDVH WULQWD DQRV R WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR QmR SDURX DR FRQWUiULR DV URGDV JLUD YDP H FDGD YH] PDLV UDSLGDPHQWH 7DQ WR p TXH IRL QHFHVViULR HGLWDU XPD OHL HVSHFLDO SDUD GLVFLSOLQDU R WUDQVSRUWH FR OHWLYR DQWHV PHVPR GH HQWUDU HP YLJRU R &yGLJR &LYLO 5HILUR PH DR 'HFUHWR Qƒ GH TXH VH WRUQRX FRQKHFL GR FRPR D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 7HQKR SDUD PLP TXH R &yGLJR &LYLO QmR IH] UHIHUrQFLD DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH SRUTXH R OHJLVODGRU GHOH VH HVTXHFHX SUHRFXSDGR FRP DV TXHVW}HV GR &RQJUHV VR ROYLGDQGR VH TXH R PXQGR DTXL IRUD QmR KDYLD SDUDGR DQWHV SHOR FRQWUiULR DV URGDV HVWDYDP URGDQGR H FDGD YH] PDLV UiSLGR e LVVR TXH RFRUUH TXDQGR Ki XP GLVWDQFLDPHQWR HQWUH D OHL H R IDWR RX PHOKRU GL]HQGR TXDQGR R OHJLV ODGRU HVWi DOKHLR DR IDWR 3RGH WDPEpP WHU RFRUULGR TXH R OHJLVODGRU LPDJLQRX TXH D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR Mi WHULD VXILFLHQWHPHQWH GLVFLSOLQDGR D TXHVWmR VHP SUHYHU TXH RXWURV PHLRV GH WUDQV SRUWH KDYHULDP GH VXUJLU H SRU LVVR GHL [RX R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DSHQDV FRP D GLVFLSOLQD TXH UHFHEHUD GD /HL GDV (V WUDGDV GH )HUUR 2 FHUWR p SRUpP TXH DV URGDV FRQ WLQXDUDP URGDQGR H RXWURV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH IRUDP VXUJLQGR 3RU LVVR WRU 9DPRV KRMH WUDWDU GH GRLV FRQWUD WRV GD PDLRU UHOHYkQFLD VRFLDO SROtWLFD H HFRQ{PLFD 7DOYH] QmR H[LVWDP RXWURV TXH SRVVDP FRPSHWLU FRP HOHV 4XDQWR j LPSRUWkQFLD GR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH EDVWDULD OHPEUDU TXH QR %UDVLO GLDULDPHQWH VmR WUDQVSRUWDGRV FHUFD GH TXDUHQWD PLOK}HV GH SDVVDJHL URV GH FDVD SDUD R WUDEDOKR H GR WUDED OKR SDUD D FDVD DWUDYpV GH {QLEXV WUHQV PHWU{V HWF ,VVR HYLGHQFLD TXH R WUDQV SRUWH FROHWLYR p UHDOPHQWH XP LQVWUX PHQWR IXQGDPHQWDO SDUD R (VWDGR PR GHUQR FXPSULU VXDV PLVV}HV VRFLDLV H HFRQ{PLFDV 8PD JUHYH QHVVH VHWRU OL WHUDOPHQWH SDUDOLVDULD R SDtV /HPEUD PRV TXH WHPSRV DWUiV XPD VLPSOHV JUH YH GH FDPLQKRQHLURV FKHJRX D DEDODU GH FHUWD PDQHLUD R JRYHUQR 4XDQWR DR WUDQVSRUWH DpUHR WRGRV VDEHPRV TXH p XP JUDQGH DSUR[LPDGRU GH SDtVHV GRV SRYRV GDV SHVVRDV GDV FLGDGHV H XP H[WUDRUGLQiULR IRPHQWDGRU GH QHJyFLRV FLUFXODGRU GH ULTXH]DV 6H JXQGR DV HVWDWtVWLFDV QR DQR GH FHUFD GH GRLV PLOK}HV H PHLR GH SHVVR DV HQWUDUDP QR %UDVLO YLD DpUHD H RX WUDV WDQWDV VDtUDP 1mR REVWDQWH HVVD UHOHYkQFLD HFR Q{PLFD VRFLDO H MXUtGLFD R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH QmR PHUHFHX VHTXHU XPD UHIHUrQFLD QR &yGLJR GH 3RU TXH LVVR" -i VH UHVVDOWRX TXH R 3URMHWR GR &yGLJR GH IRL HODERUDGR SRU &OyYLV %HYLOiTXD QD ~OWLPD GpFDGD GH HP TXDQGR R WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR HUD DLQGD LQFLSLHQWH VHTXHU H[LVWHQWH $ KLVWyULD GR WUDQVSRUWH FROHWLYR FRPHoRX OLWHUDOPHQWH QR WHPSR GD 0DULD )XPD 3DOHVWUD SURIHULGD QR 6HPLQiULR UHDOL]DGR HP
  • 2. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 207 QRX VH QHFHVViULR DSOLFDU SRU DQDORJLD D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR DRV GHPDLV PHLRV GH WUDQVSRUWH j PHGLGD HP TXH IRUDP VXUJLQGR ERQGH {QLEXV HWF 'HV VD IRUPD HVVD OHL TXH UHSXWR XPD GDV PDLV DQWLJDV DLQGD HP YLJRU FRQVHJXLX VREUHYLYHU SRU TXDVH XP VpFXOR $ GRX WULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQFLD IL]HUDP FRP D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR DTXLOR TXH %RXUODQJHU GHQRPLQDYD GH ´SRGHU GH UHMXYHQHFLPHQWR GD OHLµ SRGHU TXH FRQ VLVWH HP ID]r ODV YLYHU VHJXQGR RX DWHQ GHQGR jV H[LJrQFLDV GR WHPSR SUHVHQWH 1D UHDOLGDGH VH TXLVHUPRV WHU XPD LGpLD GR SRGHU FULDWLYR GD GRXWULQD H GD MXULV SUXGrQFLD EDVWD HVWXGDU R GHVHQYROYL PHQWR GD LQWHUSUHWDomR H GD DSOLFDomR TXH IRL GDGD j /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR (QWUDQGR HP YLJRU R QRYR &yGLJR &L YLO SHOR PHQRV GRLV HIHLWRV FXULRVRV LUi SURGX]LU HP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQV SRUWH (P SULPHLUR OXJDU LUi UHYRJDU XPD GDV PDLV DQWLJDV OHLV HP YLJRU TXH p D OHL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 7DO OHL VREUHYLYHX j &RQVWLWXLomR GH H DR SUySULR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPL GRU GDGR R DYDQoR GD GLVFLSOLQD TXH HOD HVWDEHOHFHX (P VHJXQGR OXJDU R &yGL JR LUi GLVFLSOLQDU H LQFOXLU QR VHX WH[WR XP FRQWUDWR TXH QmR p QRYR DR FRQWUi ULR p PDLV DQWLJR GR TXH R SUySULR &yGL JR TXH LUi UHYRJDU 3RU LVVR QD UHDOLGD GH QmR HQFRQWUDUHPRV LQRYDo}HV QD GLV FLSOLQD GR QRYR &yGLJR FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH 2 &yGLJR HVWi WmR VRPHQWH SRVLWLYDQGR HVWDEHOHFHQ GR QD OHL DTXLOR TXH IRL VHQGR FULDGR GHVHQYROYLGR H FULVWDOL]DGR SHOD GRXWUL QD H MXULVSUXGrQFLD DR ORQJR GH TXDVH XP VpFXOR 2 QRYR &yGLJR HVWi HP SHU IHLWD VLQWRQLD FRP D GRXWULQD H D MXULV SUXGrQFLD TXH QHVVH SHUtRGR VH ILUPD UDP 'HVWDFDULD LQLFLDOPHQWH R DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO TXH DR GLVFLSOL QDU R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH UHVVDOWRX XP GRV VHXV HOHPHQWRV TXH VHULD DWp GHVQHFHVViULR PDV TXH SDVVRX D WHU UH OHYkQFLD SRU DTXLOR TXH YDPRV HQIDWL]DU ´3HOR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DOJXpP VH REULJD PHGLDQWH UHWULEXLomR D WUDQVSRU WDU GH XP OXJDU SDUD R RXWUR SHVVRDV RX FRLVDVµ 7RGRV VDEHP TXH R FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH DOpP GH ELODWHUDO p RQHUR VR RX VHMD H[LJH XPD FRQWUDSUHVWDomR &RQWXGR VXUJLX DR ORQJR GHVVH SHUtRGR D GLVFXVVmR DFHUFD GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GR FKDPDGR FRQWUDWR JUDFLRVR RX WUDQVSRUWH JUDWXL WR )RL XPD ORQJD GLVFXVVmR TXH DFDERX JHUDQGR MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7UL EXQDO GH -XVWLoD FRQVDJUDGD QD 6~PXOD 3RLV DJRUD R HQWHQGLPHQWR FULVWDOL ]DGR QD GRXWULQD H QD MXULVSUXGrQFLD SDVVRX D VHU GLVSRVLomR H[SUHVVD GR DU WLJR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR FRQWUDWR JUD WXLWR ´1mR VH VXERUGLQD jV QRUPDV GR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH R IHLWR JUDWXLWD PHQWH SRU DPL]DGH RX FRUWHVLDµ )RL QH FHVViULR UHSHWLU LVVR DTXL SRUTXH KRXYH XP WHPSR HP TXH VH TXHULD HQTXDGUDU DTXHOH TXH WUDQVSRUWDYD JUDWXLWDPHQWH QDV PHVPDV UHJUDV GH UHVSRQVDELOLGD GH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU TXH WHP FRPR HOH PHQWR GR FRQWUDWR R UHFHELPHQWR GD FRQWUDSUHVWDomR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR QDGD PDLV ID] GR TXH UHSHWLU D GLVWLQomR TXH D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQFLD Mi HV WDEHOHFHUDP HQWUH R FRQWUDWR SXUDPHQ WH JUDWXLWR H R DSDUHQWHPHQWH JUDWXLWR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GLVS}H ´QmR VH FRQVL GHUD JUDWXLWR R WUDQVSRUWH TXDQGR HP ERUD IHLWR VHP UHPXQHUDomR R WUDQVSRU WDGRU DXIHULU YDQWDJHP LQGLUHWDµ %DV WDUi TXDOTXHU WLSR GH YDQWDJHP FRPR SRU H[HPSOR QR FDVR GH R HPSUHJDGRU TXH WUDQVSRUWD R HPSUHJDGR R LGRVR RX R HVWXGDQWH TXH WrP SDVVH JUDWXLWR 1HV VDV KLSyWHVHV DOJXpP HVWi SDJDQGR D FRQWD QmR VHQGR HVVH FRQWUDWR HVVHQFL DOPHQWH JUDWXLWR Vy SRGHQGR VHU DVVLP FRQVLGHUDGR DTXHOH TXH VHJXQGR R &y GLJR p IHLWR SRU DPL]DGH RX FRUWHVLD 8P SRQWR TXH PH SDUHFHX LPSRU WDQWH p R DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO 4XDQGR HQWURX HP YLJRU R &yGLJR GR &RQ VXPLGRU VXUJLX XPD TXHVWmR EDVWDQWH LQWHUHVVDQWH 2 &'& HVWDEHOHFH LQGH QL]DomR LOLPLWDGD &RQWXGR R &yGLJR %UD VLOHLUR GD $HURQiXWLFD H D &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD HVWDEHOHFHP LQGHQL]DomR WDULIDGD OLPLWDGD SDUD R WUDQVSRUWH Dp UHR $ TXHVWmR TXH VH FRORFRX IRL HVWD R
  • 3. 208 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” WUDQVSRUWDGRU DpUHR VHP G~YLGD p XP SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoRV H QR FDVR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH HVWDULD HOH VXMHLWR D SD JDU XPD LQGHQL]DomR LOLPLWDGD FRPR SUH YLVWR QR &'& RX XPD LQGHQL]DomR OLPL WDGD FRPR SUHYLVWR QD &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD H QR &yGLJR %UDVLOHLUR GD $HUR QiXWLFD" 'HVGH R SULPHLUR PRPHQWR VXVWHQWHL FRP EDVH QR HQWHQGLPHQWR GR 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDO )HGHUDO TXH RV WUD WDGRV H FRQYHQo}HV QR QRVVR SDtV QmR VmR VXSUDOHLV QmR VmR OHLV FRQVWLWXFLRQDLV QmR HVWmR DFLPD GDV OHLV RUGLQiULDV PDV QR PHVPR SODQR GHODV (VVD IRL XPD TXHV WmR ORQJDPHQWH GHEDWLGD QR 67) TXH DFD ERX HQWHQGHQGR GHVVD PDQHLUD KDYHQ GR KRMH GLVSRVLomR H[SUHVVD QD &RQVWL WXLomR DUW ,,, D 4XDQGR TXDOTXHU GHFLVmR FRQWUDULDU WUDWDGR RX FRQYHQomR LQWHUQDFLRQDO R UHFXUVR FDEtYHO QmR p R H[WUDRUGLQiULR PDV VLP R HVSHFLDO 6H WUD WDGR IRVVH OHL FRQVWLWXFLRQDO R UHFXUVR GHYHULD VHU R H[WUDRUGLQiULR H QmR R HV SHFLDO +RMH SRUWDQWR SRU H[SUHVVD GLVSR VLomR FRQVWLWXFLRQDO QmR Ki G~YLGDV GH TXH R WUDWDGR HVWi QR PHVPR SODQR GD OHL RUGLQiULD 6HQGR DVVLP HYLGHQWHPHQWH GHYHULD SUHYDOHFHU R &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU SRU VHU D OHL PDLV QRYD (VVD TXHVWmR IRL PXLWR GLVFXWLGD QR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD TXH LQLFLDOPHQWH VH LQFOLQRX SHOD SUHYDOrQFLD GD &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD H GR &yGLJR %UDVLOHLUR GD $H URQiXWLFD (QWUHWDQWR R 67- PXGRX R VHX HQWHQGLPHQWR H QDV XOWLPDV GHFLV}HV GH DOJXQV DQRV SDUD Fi WHP GHFLGLGR TXH R &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU SUHYDOHFH HP UHOD omR j &RQYHQomR GH 9DUVyYLD (VVH HQWHQGLPHQWR HVWDUi FRQVD JUDGR QR DUWLJR DUW GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO ´$RV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH HP JHUDO VmR DSOLFiYHLV TXDQGR FRXEHU GHVGH TXH QmR FRQWUDULHP DV GLVSRVLo}HV GHVWH &yGLJR RV SUHFHLWRV FRQVWDQWHV GD OHJLVODomR HVSHFLDO H GH WUDWDGRV H FRQ YHQo}HV LQWHUQDFLRQDLVµ /HQGR HVVH GLV SRVLWLYR QD RUGHP GLUHWD WHUtDPRV DRV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH HP JHUDO VmR DSOLFiYHLV TXDQGR FRXEHUHP RV WUDWD GRV H FRQYHQo}HV LQWHUQDFLRQDLV GHVGH TXH QmR FRQWUDULHP HVVH &yGLJR (TXLYDOH GL]HU TXH VH KRXYHU DOJXPD FRQWUDULH GDGH HQWUH DV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR H TXDOTXHU GLVSRVLomR GH WUDWDGRV RX FRQ YHQomR LQWHUQDFLRQDO GHYHUmR SUHYDOHFHU DV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR &LYLO R TXH PH SDUHFH HVWDU HP SHUIHLWD KDUPRQLD FRP D QRVVD &RQVWLWXLomR H FRP R HQWHQGL PHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO QmR Vy GR 67) FRPR WDPEpP GR 67- 'H VRUWH TXH FRQ IRUPH DV QRYDV GLVSRVLo}HV GR &yGLJR &L YLO HVVD TXHVWmR HVWDUi QR PHX HQWHQ GHU VXSHUDGD 2 DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO WUDWD GR WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR RX VHMD DTXHOH HP TXH PDLV GH XP WUDQVSRUWD GRU VH HQFDUUHJD GH ID]HU R WUDQVSRUWH HP SHUFXUVRV GLIHUHQWHV 3RU H[HPSOR XP WUDQVSRUWD DWp 3RUWXJDO H RXWUR SHOR UHVWDQWH GD (XURSD 1HVVHV FRQWUDWRV FXPXODWLYRV R &yGLJR HVWDEHOHFHX XPD UHJUD HP UHODomR j UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FL YLO TXH QmR p D GD VROLGDULHGDGH 'L] TXH ´QRV FRQWUDWRV GH WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWL YR FDGD WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH REULJD D FXP SULU R FRQWUDWR UHODWLYDPHQWH DR UHVSHF WLYR SHUFXUVR UHVSRQGHQGR SHORV GDQRV QHOH FDXVDGRV D SHVVRDV H FRLVDV &RQ VHTHQWHPHQWH QmR KDYHUi UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH VROLGiULD 1R HQWDQWR H Dt QmR HQWHQGL EHP R SRUTXr QR DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO TXDQGR WUDWRX GR WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH PHUFDGRULDV R OHJLVODGRU HVWDEHOHFHX D UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH VROLGiULD 1R FDVR GH WUDQVSRUWH FX PXODWLYR WRGRV RV WUDQVSRUWDGRUHV UHV SRQGHP VROLGDULDPHQWH $ GLIHUHQoD GH GLVFLSOLQD WDOYH] WHQKD SRU FDXVD QmR VHU SRVVtYHO GHWHUPLQDU VH FRP SUHFLVmR HP TXH SHUFXUVR RFRUUHX R GDQR R TXH QmR VH YHULILFD QR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV &HUWR p TXH R OHJLVODGRU IH] HVVD GLVWLQ omR HQWUH R WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH PHUFDGRULD H WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH SHVVRDV DWULEXLQGR D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH VROLGiULD jTXHOD PRGDOLGDGH H QmR D DWULEXLQGR TXDQGR VH WUDWDU GH WUDQVSRUWH FXPXODWLYR GH SHVVRDV 2 DUWLJR GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO GLVFLSOLQD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU (VVD PDWpULD SDVVRX SRU YiULDV IDVHV $ /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HU UR HVWDEHOHFLD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO RE MHWLYD SDUD R WUDQVSRUWDGRU HP UHODomR
  • 4. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 209 DR SDVVDJHLUR (P UHODomR DR SHGHVWUH jTXHOH TXH QmR HUD SDVVDJHLUR D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH HUD VXEMHWLYD DUW GR && &RP D &RQVWLWXLomR GH TXH HVWDEHOHFHX UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD WDPEpP SDUD R SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoR S~ EOLFR R WUDQVSRUWDGRU SDVVRX D WHU UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD WDPEpP HP UHOD omR D WHUFHLUR 9HLR R &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU H HVWDEHOHFHX UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH REMHWLYD SDUD R SUHVWDGRU GH VHU YLoR TXHU FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWDGR TXHU FRP UHODomR DR FRQVXPLGRU GLUHWR FRPR HP UHODomR DR FRQVXPLGRU LQGLUH WR 6y Dt SDVVDPRV D WHU XPD UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH XQLILFDGD GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU FRP UHODomR QmR Vy DR SDVVDJHLUR FRPR WDP EpP HP UHODomR DR WHUFHLUR 2 QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO QR VHX DUWLJR SUDWLFDPHQWH FRQVROLGRX HVVH HQ WHQGLPHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO HVWDEHOH FHQGR D VHJXLQWH UHJUD ´2 WUDQVSRUWD GRU UHVSRQGH SHORV GDQRV FDXVDGRV jV SHVVRDV WUDQVSRUWDGDV HYLGHQWHPHQWH VRPHQWH HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR H VXDV EDJDJHQV VDOYR PRWLYR GH IRUoD PDLRU VHQGR QXOD TXDOTXHU FOiXVXOD H[FOXGHQWH GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGHµ 1HVVH GLVSRVLWLYR WHPRV YiULDV TXHVW}HV LPSRUWDQWHV (P SULPHLUR OX JDU WUDWD VH LQTXHVWLRQDYHOPHQWH GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH REMHWLYD HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR H DTXL HVWi D FOiXVXOD GH LQFROXPLGDGH HQTXDGUDGD SHORV MXULVWDV IUDQFHVHV TXDQGR SURFXUDUDP FRQVWUXLU XPD QRYD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH SDUD R WUDQV SRUWDGRU 1R PHX HQWHQGHU R TXH WH PRV DTXL p D FOiXVXOD GH VHJXUDQoD H[ SUHVVD QR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVX PLGRU 4XHP VH GLVS}H D SUHVWDU VHUYL oRV TXH FDXVDP ULVFRV DR SDVVDJHLUR RX D WHUFHLURV ILFD REULJDGR D SUHVWi OR FRP VHJXUDQoD WHQGR TXH JDUDQWLU D LQFROXPLGDGH GH TXHP TXHU TXH VHMD 2 &yGLJR FRQVDJURX R TXH Mi HVWDYD HVWD EHOHFLGR GHVGH D /HL GDV (VWUDGDV GH )HUUR 'HVWDFDPRV HP VHJXQGR OXJDU TXH R GLVSRVLWLYR HP H[DPH HVWDEHOHFH FOD UDPHQWH D QXOLGDGH GH TXDOTXHU FOiX VXOD H[FOXGHQWH GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH ,VVR IRL XPD FULDomR GD GRXWULQD GHSRLV GD MXULVSUXGrQFLD H ILQDOPHQWH HVVD YHGDomR HVWi H[SUHVVD QR &yGLJR GH 'H IHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU 4XDOTXHU FOiXVXOD TXH UHGX]D D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH p SOHQD PHQWH QXOD (VVD GLVSRVLomR HVWDUi DJR UD QR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO 7HPRV WDPEpP DTXL R SULQFtSLR GD LQGHQL]DomR LOLPLWDGD TXH HPERUD QmR HVFULWR QR FDSXW R GHSUHHQGHPRV GR SD UiJUDIR ~QLFR TXH GL] ´e OtFLWR DR WUDQV SRUWDGRU H[LJLU D GHFODUDomR GR YDORU GD EDJDJHP D ILP GH IL[DU R OLPLWH GD LQGH QL]DomRµ &RPR VH Yr R &yGLJR VRPHQWH DGPLWLX IL[DU OLPLWH GD LQGHQL]DomR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR j EDJDJHP $ FRQWUDULR VHQVX QmR Ki OLPLWH LQGHQL]DWyULR HP UHODomR DR SDVVDJHLUR &RPR QmR SRGH ULD GHL[DU GH VHU KDYHUi KDUPRQLD HQ WUH R QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO H R GR &RQVXPL GRU 6HULD PXLWR UXLP VH R &yGLJR &LYLO SHUPLWLVVH XPD OLPLWDomR WHQGR R &yGL JR GR &RQVXPLGRU HVWDEHOHFLGR FRPR SULQFtSLR FRPR GLUHLWR IXQGDPHQWDO GR FRQVXPLGRU D SOHQD LQGHQL]DomR RX D UHSRVLomR LOLPLWDGD 0HVPR HP VH WUD WDQGR GH EDJDJHP D OLPLWDomR WHUi TXH VHU IHLWD FRP EDVH QXPD GHFODUDomR GR YDORU GD SUySULD EDJDJHP 2 DUWLJR DR SULPHLUR H[DPH SHUPLWH FRQFOXLU TXH D UHVSRQVDELOLGD GH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VRPHQWH VHULD H[ FOXtGD SHOD IRUoD PDLRU $OJXQV GLDV DWUiV FRQYHUVDQGR FRP XPD LOXVWUH FLYLOLVWD HOD PH GLVVH TXH R &yGLJR &LYLO HVWDULD j IUHQWH GR &yGLJR GH 'HIHVD GR &RQVXPLGRU SRUTXH VRPHQWH H[FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GH IRUoD PDLRU e R TXH HVWi GLV SRVWR QR DUWLJR GR &yGLJR &LYLO 7R GDYLD R &yGLJR GLVFLSOLQRX D UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU HP PDLV GH XP DUWLJR H QmR DSHQDV HP XP ~QLFR GLVSR VLWLYR $ VHJXLU WHPRV R DUWLJR TXH WUD WD GR IDWR GH WHUFHLUR ( DTXL R &yGLJR QDGD PDLV IH] TXH SRVLWLYDU D DQWLJXtVVLPD V~PXOD GR 67) ´$ UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FRQWUDWXDO GR WUDQVSRUWD GRU SHOR DFLGHQWH FRP SDVVDJHLUR QmR p HOLGLGD SRU FXOSD GH WHUFHLUR FRQWUD R TXDO WHP DomR UHJUHVVLYD µ ,VWR QmR p QRYLGDGH UHSHWLPRV SRUTXH D 6~PXOD
  • 5. 210 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” Mi GLVSXQKD DVVLP 7RGDYLD R FyGL JR IDOD HP FXOSD GH WHUFHLURV )DWR FXOSRVR GH WHUFHLUR QmR H[FOXL 0DV D TXHVWmR p H R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR" 1mR SRGHPRV HYLGHQWHPHQWH HTXLSDUDU GROR H FXOSD 2 IDWR FXOSRVR GH WHUFHLUR SRGH VHU SHUIHLWDPHQWH LQFOXtGR QDTXL OR TXH PXLWRV DXWRUHV FKDPDP GH IRU WXLWR LQWHUQR )D] SDUWH GR ULVFR GR QHJy FLR GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU 0DV TXDQWR DR IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR FRPR SRU H[HPSOR R DVVDOWR H DJRUD YHUGDGHLURV DWDTXHV D {QLEXV TXH VmR IHLWRV TXDQGR D SROtFLD PDWD DOJXpP QR PRUUR H RV EDQGLGRV GHV FHP SDUD TXHLPDU RV {QLEXV SRGH VH LPSXWDU DR WUDQVSRUWDGRU R GHYHU GH LQ GHQL]DU VH DOJXpP ILFDU IHULGR HP XPD PDQLIHVWDomR GHVVD QDWXUH]D" (QWmR Dt WHPRV R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR 3DUHFH PH TXH FRQWLQXDUHPRV FRP D PHVPD GRX WULQD FRP D PHVPD MXULVSUXGrQFLD H FRP D PHVPD FRQWURYpUVLD TXH DWp DTXL VH WUD YRX +i DTXHOHV TXH HQWHQGHP FRPR HX TXH R IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR H[FOXL D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU SRUTXH HOH QmR p TXHVWmR GH LPSUHYLVLELOLGDGH PDV VLP GH LQHYLWDELOLGDGH ( Ki RXWURV TXH HQ WHQGHP TXH QmR H[FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH 2 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD Mi WHP GHFLGLGR GRV GRLV PRGRV HPERUD HV WHMD VH LQFOLQDQGR QDV ~OWLPDV GHFLV}HV SHOD QmR H[RQHUDomR GD UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU QR FDVR GH IDWR GRORVR GH WHUFHLUR FRPR R DVVDOWR D {QLEXV 7HPRV D VHJXLU D TXHVWmR GR IDWR H[FOXVLYR GD YtWLPD RX GD FXOSD H[FOXVL YD GD YtWLPD TXH p QRUPDOPHQWH RX WUD FDXVD GH H[FOXVmR GH UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH $ FXOSD H[FOXVLYD GD YtWLPD H[ FOXLULD D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRU WDGRU" 2 FyGLJR WUDWRX GHVVD TXHVWmR QR DUWLJR (VVH DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ SHV VRD WUDQVSRUWDGD GHYH VXMHLWDU VH jV QRUPDV HVWDEHOHFLGDV SHOR WUDQVSRUWD GRU FRQVWDQWHV QR ELOKHWH RX DIL[DGDV j YLVWD GRV XVXiULRV µ (P RXWUDV SD ODYUDV HVWi GL]HQGR TXH R SDVVDJHLUR GHYD WHU XP FRPSRUWDPHQWR DGHTXDGR GH DFRUGR FRP DV UHJUDV 'LVS}H R SDUi JUDIR ~QLFR TXH QRV LQWHUHVVD ´6H R SUH MXt]R VRIULGR SHOD SHVVRD WUDQVSRUWDGD IRU DWULEXtYHO j WUDQVJUHVVmR GH QRUPDV H LQVWUXo}HV UHJXODPHQWDUHV R MXL] UHGX ]LUi HTLWDWLYDPHQWH D LQGHQL]DomR QD PHGLGD HP TXH D YtWLPD KRXYHU FRQFRU ULGR SDUD D RFRUUrQFLD GR GDQR µ (LV DTXL D FXOSD FRQFRUUHQWH ( Dt HQWmR D PLQKD FRQFOXVmR 2UD VH R FyGLJR SHUPLWH UH GX]LU D UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWD GRU HP UD]mR GD FXOSD FRQFRUUHQWH GR SDVVDJHLUR SRU PDLV IRUWH UD]mR WHUHPRV TXH DGPLWLU D H[FOXVmR GD UHVSRQVDELOL GDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH R GDQR GHFRU UHU GD H[FOXVLYD DWXDomR GD SUySULD YtWL PD (QWmR PDLV XPD YH] RV VXUILVWDV URGRYLiULRV QR PHX HQWHQGHU FRQWLQX DUmR VHP D FREHUWXUD GD LQGHQL]DomR GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU VH R GDQR GHFRUUHU GH IDWR H[FOXVLYR GD SUySULD YtWLPD 2 DUWLJR WDPEpP p FRQVDJUD omR GH HQWHQGLPHQWR GRXWULQiULR H MXULVSUXGHQFLDO (OH WUDWD GR LQWHUURP SLPHQWR GD YLDJHP 7RGRV QyV MXt]HV Mi GHFLGLPRV KLSyWHVHV GH LQWHUUXSomR GH YLDJHP FRPR RYHUERRNLQJ RX PHOKRU DLQGD FDVRV HP TXH R DYLmR RX HQWmR {QLEXV VRIUH DOJXPD SDQH H WHP TXH SD UDU HP DOJXP OXJDU 1HVVH FDVR WHPRV PDQGDGR SDJDU DV GHVSHVDV GH KRVSH GDJHP DOLPHQWDomR HWF H DUUXPDU ORJR XP PHLR GH WUDQVSRUWH SDUD OHYDU R SDV VDJHLUR VmR H VDOYR DR VHX GHVWLQR e LVVR TXH HVWi QR DUWLJR ´,QWHUURPSHQGR VH D YLDJHP SRU TXDOTXHU PRWLYR DOKHLR j YRQ WDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU DLQGD TXH HP FRQVH TrQFLD GH HYHQWR LPSUHYLVtYHO HLV DTXL R IRUWXLWR LQWHUQR TXH QmR H[FOXL D UHVSRQ VDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU ILFD HOH REUL JDGR D FRQFOXLU R WUDQVSRUWH FRQWUDWDGR HP RXWUR YHtFXOR GD PHVPD FDWHJRULD µ ( DLQGD WHPRV XP DUWLJR LPSRUWDQ WH TXH QmR H[LVWLD HP QHQKXP GLVSRVL WLYR OHJDO FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH R DUWLJR e R GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR TXH IRL DJRUD RXWRUJDGR OHJDOPHQWH DR WUDQV SRUWDGRU ´2 WUDQVSRUWDGRU XPD YH] H[H FXWDGR R WUDQVSRUWH WHP GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR VREUH D EDJDJHP GR SDVVDJHLUR H RXWURV RE MHWRV SHVVRDLV GHVWH SDUD JDUDQWLU VH GR SD JDPHQWR GR YDORU GD SDVVDJHP TXH QmR WLYHU VLGR IHLWR QR LQtFLR RX GXUDQWH R SHUFXUVRµ (VVH GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR TXH Mi HVWDYD SUHYLVWR QR &yGLJR GH SDUD RV FD VRV GH GHSyVLWR H KRVSHGDJHP H DJRUD
  • 6. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 211 HVWHQGLGR SHOR QRYR &yGLJR WDPEpP DR WUDQVSRUWDGRU 0XLWRV HQWHQGHP TXH HVVH GLUHLWR GH UHWHQomR VHULD DUELWUi ULR DOJR FRQWUiULR j OLEHUGDGH HWF GH VRUWH TXH D FRQWURYpUVLD SURVVHJXLUi PRUPHQWH HP IDFH GR &yGLJR GR &RQVX PLGRU 2EVHUYR XPD RPLVVmR QR FyGLJR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SDVVD JHLUR 2PLVVmR HVWD TXH SRGHULD WHU VLGR VXSULGD SRUTXH R FyGLJR WHYH R FXLGDGR GH QmR FRPHWHU HVVD RPLVVmR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH FRLVDV +i XPD TXHVWmR TXH PXLWDV YH]HV FKHJD DR 7UL EXQDO H TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR PRPHQWR HP TXH FRPHoD H HP TXH WHUPLQD D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU (VVD p XPD TXHVWmR LPSRUWDQWH SRUTXH XPD FRLVD p D FHOHEUDomR GR FRQWUDWR H RXWUD p D VXD H[HFXomR 1HP VHPSUH D UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU FRPHoD QR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH FHOHEUD R FRQ WUDWR &RPSUR XPD SDVVDJHP GH DYLmR SRU H[HPSOR PDV Vy YRX YLDMDU GDTXL D XP PrV 6H DOJXpP TXH YDL YLDMDU GH DYLmR VRIUHU XP DFLGHQWH TXDQGR HVWi VH GLULJLQGR SDUD R DHURSRUWR D FRPSD QKLD DpUHD QmR WHP QDGD D YHU FRP LVVR 0HVPR TXH D SHVVRD DUJXPHQWH TXH Mi KDYLD FRPSUDGR D SDVVDJHP TXH LD YLD MDU H TXH R FRQWUDWR HVWDYD IHFKDGR QmR LPSRUWD SRLV DLQGD QmR VH KDYLD LQLFLD GR D H[HFXomR GR FRQWUDWR 8PD FRLVD p R FRQWUDWR H RXWUD FRLVD p D VXD H[HFX omR 6HQGR DVVLP VHULD PXLWR LPSRU WDQWH TXH R FyGLJR HVWDEHOHFHVVH R PR PHQWR GR LQtFLR GD H[HFXomR GR FRQWUD WR GH WUDQVSRUWH H R PRPHQWR HP TXH WHUPLQD HVVD REULJDomR $ MXULVSUXGrQ FLD YHP ID]HQGR LVWR FRP EDVWDQWH FXL GDGR 1R DUWLJR R FyGLJR WUDWRX GD TXHVWmR FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH PHUFDGRULD PDV VH HVTXHFHX RX QmR TXLV WUDWDU GLVVR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ UHVSRQVD ELOLGDGH GR WUDQVSRUWDGRU H DTXL Mi HVWi QD SDUWH TXH WUDWD GR WUDQVSRUWH GH FRL VDV TXH FRPHoD QR DUWLJR OLPLWD GD DR YDORU FRQVWDQWH GH FRQKHFLPHQWR FR PHoD QR PRPHQWR HP TXH HOH RX VHXV SUHSRVWRV UHFHEHP D FRLVD WHUPLQD TXDQ GR p HQWUHJXH DR GHVWLQDWiULR RX GHSRVLWD GD HP MXt]R VH DTXHOH QmR IRU HQFRQWUDGRµ 4XHU GL]HU HVWDEHOHFHX VH TXDQGR FR PHoD H TXDQGR WHUPLQD R WUDQVSRUWH GH FRLVDV PDV QDGD WUDWRX FRP UHODomR DR WUDQVSRUWH GH SHVVRDV +i RXWUDV TXHVW}HV UHOHYDQWHV FRP UHODomR DR FRQWUDWR GH WUDQVSRUWH PDV FRPR SURPHWL QmR XOWUDSDVVDU R WHPSR YDPRV WUDWDU GH &RQWUDWR GH 6HJXUR (VVH FRQWUDWR p WDPEpP H[WUDRUGLQiULR QR TXH GL] UHVSHLWR j VXD UHOHYkQFLD MX UtGLFD HFRQ{PLFD H SROtWLFD *UDQGHV HPSUHHQGLPHQWRV VH WRUQDULDP LQYLiYHLV VH QmR IRVVH D VHJXUDQoD GR VHJXUR ( p SRU LVVR TXH R VHJXUR REWHYH XP GHVHQ YROYLPHQWR IDQWiVWLFR QDV ~OWLPDV GpFD GDV (OH FLUFXOD ELOK}HV GH GyODUHV DQX DOPHQWH ,PDJLQHP R TXH VHULD GD 3HWUREUiV VH QmR IRVVH R VHJXUR TXDQ GR XPD GH VXDV PDLRUHV SODWDIRUPDV SH JRX IRJR H DIXQGRX 8P FXVWR GH ELOK}HV GH GyODUHV R TXH DEDODULD D HFRQRPLD DWp PHVPR GH XPD JUDQGH HPSUHVD ,PDJL QHP R TXH VHULD VH QmR KRXYHVVH XPD UHGH GH VHJXURV H UHVVHJXURV PXQGLDO 1R FDVR GD GHVWUXLomR GDV GXDV WRUUHV JrPHDV HP 1RYD <RUN QmR IRVVH R VHJXUR HVVH IXQHV WR DFRQWHFLPHQWR DEDODULD D HFRQRPLD DWp GH PXLWRV SDtVHV e HVWD D LPSRUWkQFLD TXH WHP R VHJXUR 1R %UDVLO GH DFRUGR FRP DV HVWDWtVWLFDV VRPRV PDLV GH VHVVHQWD PL OK}HV GH VHJXUDGRV QRV YiULRV VHJXURV 4XDOTXHU SHVVRD GH FODVVH PpGLD WHUi SHOR PHQRV XP WLSR GH VHJXUR SRU H[HPSOR GH DXWRPyYHO GH VD~GH HWF (QWmR R TXH YHP D VHU VHJXUR" 3RU TXH HOH WHP HVWD LPSRUWkQFLD HVWD HQRU PH UHOHYkQFLD" &RVWXPR FRQWDU XP IDWR UHDO TXH QRV DMXGDUi D FRPSUHHQGHU 1D GpFDGD GH WULQWD TXDQGR HVWDYDP FRQV WUXLQGR D JUDQGH SRQWH VREUH D %DtD GH 6mR )UDQFLVFR QRV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV RV FRQVWUXWRUHV VH YLUDP HQYROYLGRV FRP XP JUDYH SUREOHPD D VHJXUDQoD GRV WUDED OKDGRUHV 4XHP DLQGD KRMH VREH DR FLPR GH XPD GDV WRUUHV GDTXHOD SRQWH FRP FHUFD GH GX]HQWRV H YLQWH PHWURV GH DO WXUD H ROKD Oi GH FLPD DV iJXDV GD %DtD D FHQWHQDV GH PHWURV DEDL[R QmR GHL[D GH WHU XP DUUHSLR QD HVSLQKD &RPR VH
  • 7. 212 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” ULD SRVVtYHO WUDEDOKDU QDTXHODV DOWXUDV VHP R SDYRU GH VH SUHFLSLWDU QR DELVPR D TXDOTXHU PRPHQWR" $ SRQWH HVWDYD RU oDGD HP WULQWD H FLQFR PLOK}HV GH GyOD UHV H RV RSHUiULRV VDELDP TXH SDUD FDGD PLOKmR D VHU JDVWR KDYLD D SHUVSHFWLYD GH TXH XP GHOHV SRGHULD SHUGHU D VXD YLGD ,PSRUWDYD HQWmR HP GL]HU TXH DWp D FRQFOXVmR GD SRQWH FHUFD GH WULQWD H FLQFR WUDEDOKDGRUHV SRGHULDP PRUUHU ( LVWR D WRGD HYLGrQFLD JHURX SkQLFR 7R GRV WUDEDOKDYDP FRP D LGpLD IL[D GH TXH D TXDOTXHU PRPHQWR SRGHULD VH WUDQVIRU PDU HP XPD GDTXHODV WULQWD H FLQFR YtWL PDV 3RU LVVR D REUD FDPLQKDYD OHQWDPHQ WH FDXVDQGR HQRUPHV SUHMXt]RV DWp TXH DOJXpP WHYH D LGpLD GH HVWHQGHU VREUH WRGD H[WHQVmR GD SRQWH XPD JLJDQWHVFD UHGH GH FRUGDV 'H VRUWH TXH VH DOJXP RSHUiULR FDtVVH KDYHULD GH VHU DSDQKDGR SHOD UHGH $ UHGH FXVWRX RLWHQWD PLO GyOD UHV PDV UHYHORX VH GHVGH ORJR XP H[ FHOHQWH LQYHVWLPHQWR 7mR ORJR HOD IRL HV WHQGLGD RV RSHUiULRV UHDGTXLULUDP D FRQ ILDQoD YROWDUDP D WUDEDOKDU QRYDPHQWH D REUD UHDGTXLULX R DQGDPHQWR GHVHMDGR D SRQWH IRL FRQFOXtGD QR SUD]R SUHYLVWR H PHOKRU GR TXH WXGR VHP R VDFULItFLR GH XPD YLGD VHTXHU e TXH DJRUD RV RSHUiUL RV WLQKDP XPD UHVSRVWD WUDQTLOL]DGRUD SDUD DTXHOD LQTXLHWDQWH LQGDJDomR H VH HX FDLU GD SRQWH" 3DUHFH PH TXH HVVH IDWR UHYHOD TXH VHJXUDQoD H SURWHomR VmR QHFHVVLGDGHV EiVLFDV GR VHU KXPDQR SULQFLSDOPHQWH D SDUWLU GH XPD GHWHUPLQDGD FODVVH VR FLDO $ WRGR LQVWDQWH HVWDPRV QRV LQGD JDQGR ´H VH HX FDLU GD SRQWH" H VH HX PRU UHU" H VH HX ILFDU GRHQWH" H VH PLQKD FDVD SHJDU IRJR" H VH URXEDUHP R PHX DXWRPy YHO"µ ( p H[DWDPHQWH Dt TXH HQWUD D LGpLD GR VHJXUR (P XPD OLQJXDJHP ILJXUDGD SRGHUtDPRV GL]HU TXH R VHJXUR p XPD HVSpFLH GH UHGH MXUtGLFR HFRQ{PLFD TXH QRV SURWHJH FRQWUD RV ULVFRV DRV TXDLV WRGRV QyV HVWDPRV H[SRVWRV QD YLGD HP VRFLHGDGH 7RGRV QyV VDEHPRV TXH R VH JXUR p IXQGDGR p DOLFHUoDGR HP WUrV HOH PHQWRV HVVHQFLDLV R ULVFR D PXWXDOLGDGH H D ERD Ip &RVWXPR GL]HU TXH HVVHV WUrV HOHPHQWRV VmR R WULSp GR VHJXUR XPD HVSpFLH GH VDQWtVVLPD WULQGDGH XPD WULORJLD GR VHJXUR 1mR KDYHUi VHJXUR RQGH QmR KRXYHU ULVFR RQGH QmR KRXYHU PXWXDOLGDGH H RQGH QmR KRXYHU ERD Ip 2 ULVFR p R HOHPHQWR EiVLFR R HOH PHQWR PDWHULDO GR VHJXUR $V SHVVRDV Vy ID]HP VHJXUR SRUTXH HVWmR H[SRVWDV D ULVFR 6H YRFr QmR VHQWLU ULVFR GH QDGD QmR YDL ID]HU VHJXUR ( ULVFR p H[DWD PHQWH SHULJR p SUREDELOLGDGH GH GDQR 1yV ID]HPRV VHJXUR TXDQGR VHQWLPRV SUREDELOLGDGH GH GDQR TXDOTXHU TXH VHMD D VXD QDWXUH]D 0XWXDOLGDGH p R HOHPHQWR HFRQ{ PLFR GR VHJXUR e XPD RSHUDomR FROHWL YD GH SRXSDQoD TXH p IHLWD SRU WRGDV DTXHODV SHVVRDV TXH LQWHJUDP XP PHV PR JUXSR GH ULVFR 6DEHQGR TXH SRVVR VRIUHU XP VLQLVWUR VRIUHU XP GDQR HP UD]mR GR ULVFR D TXH HVWRX H[SRVWR SUR FXUR PH SUHFDYHU HVWDEHOHFHQGR DOJR TXH PH SRVVD UHSDUDU R GDQR VH HYHQWXDO PHQWH HOH RFRUUHU ( DVVLP FRP PXLWDV SHVVRDV IRUPD VH XP IXQGR FDSD] GH EDQFDU RV GDQRV GHFRUUHQWHV GRV ULVFRV D TXH SHVVRDV HVWmR H[SRVWDV ( D WRGD HYLGrQFLD WHUi TXH KDYHU Dt HVWi XP SRQWR LPSRUWDQWH R HTXLOtEULR HQWUH ULV FR H SUrPLR 3UrPLR QmR p DTXLOR TXH UHFHER GH LQGHQL]DomR PDV DTXLOR TXH SDJR FRPR VHJXUDGR 7HUi TXH KDYHU XP HTXLOtEULR XPD QHFHVViULD SURSRUFLRQD OLGDGH HQWUH R SUrPLR SDJR H RV ULVFRV D TXH HVWRX H[SRVWR SDUD IRUPDU R SDWUL P{QLR DGHTXDGR H QHFHVViULR SDUD EDQ FDU HVVHV ULVFRV ( LVWR p FDOFXODGR DWUD YpV GH GDGRV HVWDWtVWLFRV FiOFXORV DWX DULDLV D OHL GRV JUDQGHV Q~PHURV H FRP EDVWDQWH SUHFLVmR e GHVVD PDQHLUD TXH R VHJXUR VH HVWUXWXUD 8PD ERD GHILQLomR GH VHJXUR FDOFD GD QR SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH IRL DTXH OD TXH QRV GHL[RX D 5DLQKD (OL]DEHWK , GD ,QJODWHUUD Ki PDLV GH WUrV VpFXORV ´FRP R VHJXUR R GDQR p XP IDUGR TXH SHVD OH YHPHQWH VREUH XP JUDQGH Q~PHUR GH SHV VRDV HP YH] GH LQVXSRUWDYHOPHQWH VREUH XP SHTXHQR Q~PHURµ 0XWXDOLGDGH p LVVR p GLYLVmR GRV ULVFRV GH WDO PDQHLUD TXH VH WRUQH VXSRUWiYHO SRU PXLWRV DTXLOR TXH VHULD LQVXSRUWiYHO SRU SRXFRV $JRUD YHP R WHUFHLUR HOHPHQWR D ERD Ip $ ERD Ip p R HOHPHQWR MXUtGLFR GR
  • 8. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 213 VHJXUR %RD Ip p R HOHPHQWR TXH OLJD PXWXDOLGDGH H ULVFR 0XWXDOLGDGH H ULV FR MDPDLV DQGDUmR MXQWRV VH QmR KRXYHU ERD Ip e D ERD Ip TXH SHUPLWH HQWUH R VHJXUDGR H R VHJXUDGRU XPD FRQYLYrQ FLD WDO TXH XP FRQWULEXD SDUD IRUPDU XP IXQGR H R RXWUR SRU VXD YH] WHQKD FRQGLo}HV GH UHSDUDU R GDQR R SUHMXt]R VH HYHQWXDOPHQWH R ULVFR D TXH HVWi H[SRVWR R VHJXUDGR YLHU D VH PDWHULDOL ]DU QR VLQLVWUR e SRU LVVR TXH RV DXWR UHV FRVWXPDP GL]HU TXH D ERD Ip p D DOPD p D UD]mR GH VHU GR VHJXUR 2QGH QmR KRXYHU D ERD Ip KDYHUi IUDXGH Pi Ip 3RU HVVD UD]mR VH FRVWXPD GL]HU TXH D IUDXGH p D PDLRU LQLPLJD GR VHJXUR SRUTXH HOD GHVHVWUXWXUD R HTXLOtEULR TXH WHP TXH KDYHU HQWUH PXWXDOLGDGH H R SUrPLR TXH GHYH VHU SDJR 2 &yGLJR DQWHULRU SUDWLFDPHQWH Vy IDODYD QD ERD Ip QR VHJXUR &RVWXPDYD VH GL]HU TXH D ERD Ip HUD XP HOHPHQWR GR VHJXUR SRUTXH Vy QR FRQWUDWR GH VH JXUR HOD HUD H[SUHVVDPHQWH PHQFLRQD GD $TXL QR VHJXUR QmR Vy WHPRV D ERD Ip VXEMHWLYD D ERD LQWHQomR GDV SDUWHV PDV WDPEpP D ERD Ip REMHWLYD SRUTXH PDLV GR TXH HP TXDOTXHU RXWUR FRQWUD WR HVWD p LQGLVSHQViYHO QR VHJXUR TXH p VHPSUH XP FRQWUDWR GH WUDWR VXFHVVL YR )D]HPRV VHJXUR SRU XP SHUtRGR XP DQR SRU H[HPSOR (QWmR R FRQWUDWR YDL VH SURORQJDU H HPERUD DV SDUWHV SRV VDP WHU ERDV LQWHQo}HV QR PRPHQWR GD FHOHEUDomR GR FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR VH QR FXUVR GR FRQWUDWR XPD GHODV SDVVDU D WHU Pi Ip SURFXUDU DXPHQWDU RV ULVFRV SRU H[HPSOR RX SURFXUDU FULDU REVWiFX ORV SDUD D H[HFXomR GR VHJXUR HOH VH WRUQD LQYLiYHO (QWmR WXGR DTXLOR TXH IRL GLWR FRP UHODomR j ERD Ip H TXH KRMH HVWi VHQGR FDQWDGD H GHFDQWDGD SRLV SDVVDUi D VHU XP SULQFtSLR JHUDO GR QRYR &yGLJR Mi HUD XP GRV HOHPHQWRV GR FRQ WUDWR HP JHUDO )HLWDV HVVDV REVHUYDo}HV GLULD DSHQDV TXH R QRYR &yGLJR YDL GDU DR FRQ WUDWR GH VHJXUR XPD GLVFLSOLQD PDLV HQ[XWD PDLV UDFLRQDO +i QR &yGLJR GH PXLWDV GLVSRVLo}HV UHSHWLWLYDV H TXH FRP R GHFRUUHU GR WHPSR VH PRVWUD UDP LQyFXDV GHVQHFHVViULDV 2 QRYR &y GLJR IH] XPD OLPSH]D GHL[DQGR DSHQDV DV FOiXVXODV H UHJUDV TXH VmR UHDOPHQWH UH OHYDQWHV H LPSRUWDQWHV ( FRPR QmR SR GHULD GHL[DU GH VHU RV WUrV HOHPHQWRV ULVFR PXWXDOLGDGH H ERD Ip QmR Vy SHUVLV WHP PDV IRUDP DLQGD PDLV SUHVWLJLDGRV H GHVWDFDGRV SRUTXH VH HVVHV HOHPHQWRV QmR IRUHP SUHVWLJLDGRV R VHJXUR SDVVDUi D VHU DEVROXWDPHQWH LQYLiYHO (QWUHWDQWR R TXH PH SDUHFH PH UHFHU GHVWDTXH p R QRYR FRQFHLWR TXH R &yGLJR GHX DR VHJXUR 2 FRQFHLWR DQWH ULRU HQVHMDYD FDGD GHILQLomR TXH GDWD YHQLD HUD GH FKRUDU &RVWXPDYD VH GL ]HU TXH R VHJXUR WUDQVIHUH R ULVFR GR VH JXUDGR SDUD R VHJXUDGRU ,VVR p XP DE VXUGR GR SRQWR GH YLVWD MXUtGLFR H IiWLFR &RP RX VHP VHJXUR TXHP FRQWLQXD HP ULVFR p R DVVHJXUDGR p R VHX FDUUR p R RSHUiULR TXH HVWi SHQGXUDGR HP DOJXP OXJDU 2 VHJXUR QmR WUDQVIHUH R ULVFR 7DPEpP QmR p DEVROXWDPHQWH FRUUHWR GL]HU TXH R FDUUR IRL VHJXUDGR TXH D SHV VRD IRL VHJXUDGD p XPD PDQHLUD GH VH GL]HU PDV QmR p LVWR TXH IRL VHJXUDGR (QWmR TXDO p UHDOPHQWH R REMHWR GR VH JXUR" 2 TXH p R VHJXUDGRU" 7HPRV QR QRYR &yGLJR XPD GHIL QLomR TXH PH SDUHFH PXLWR EHP FRORFD GD HVWi QR DUWLJR TXH GLVS}H ´3HOR FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR R VHJXUDGRU VH REULJD PHGLDQWH R SDJDPHQWR GR SUrPLR D JDUDQWLU LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR GR VHJXUDGR UHODWLYR D SHVVRD RX D FRLVD FRQWUD ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPL QDGRVµ $TXL ILFR UHDOPHQWH HP G~YLGD SRLV TXHP LUi SDJDU R SUrPLR" 4XHP SDJD R SUrPLR p R VHJXUDGR SRU LVVR HX FRORFDULD ´PHGLDQWH R UHFHELPHQWR GR SUr PLRµ PDV FRPR DVVLP HVWi GLVSRVWR YDPRV HQWHQGHU TXH RQGH VH GL] SDJD PHQWR OHLD VH UHFHELPHQWR TXHP SDJD p R VHJXUDGR H TXHP UHFHEH p R VHJXUD GRU 'HSRLV GL] ´JDUDQWLU LQWHUHVVH OHJtWL PR GR VHJXUDGR UHODWLYR D SHVVRD FRQ WUD ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPLQDGRVµ 3ULPHLUR SRQWR TXH R FRQFHLWR GHVWDFD p R VHJX UDGRU p XP JDUDQWH SRU LVVR GLJR TXH HOH p XP SUHVWDGRU GH VHUYLoR 2V VHQKRUHV YHMDP TXH VDELDPHQ WH R &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU VDEHQGR TXH KDYHULD PXLWD UHDomR FRORFRX H[SUHV VDPHQWH QR FRQFHLWR GH VHUYLoR D DWLYL
  • 9. 214 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” GDGH EDQFiULD VHFXULWiULD HWF ,QLFLDO PHQWH RV VHJXUDGRUHV TXLVHUDP VXV WHQWDU TXH QmR HUDP SUHVWDGRUHV GH VHU YLoR SRUTXH DILQDO GH FRQWDV QmR SUHVWD YDP VHUYLoR DOJXP 0DV QD UHDOLGDGH HOHV SUHVWDP VHUYLoR HOHV VmR JDUDQWHV 0DV R VHJXUDGRU JDUDQWH R TXr" (OH QmR JDUDQWH D YLGD GR VHJXUDGR SRLV FRP RX VHP VHJXUR R VHJXUDGR SRGH IDOHFHU HOH QmR JDUDQWH TXH R FDUUR HVWDUi VHPSUH FRP R VHJXUDGR 2 TXH HOH JDUDQWH p R LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR TXH R VHJXUDGR WHP HP UHODomR D FRLVDV H HP UHODomR D SHVVRDV 1RUPDOPHQWH VHUi XP LQWHUHVVH SDWULPRQLDO 2 TXH HX TXHUR TXDQGR IDoR XP VHJXUR" 4XHUR VH R PHX FDUUR IRU URXEDGR WHU R SDWULP{QLR QHFHVViULR SDUD FRPSUDU RXWUR SDUD UHSRU R PHX SUHMXt]R e XP LQWHUHVVH HFRQ{PLFR $ PHVPD FRL VD RFRUUH FRP R VHJXUR GH YLGD 2 TXH VH TXHU TXDQGR VH FHOHEUD XP VHJXUR GH YLGD" $ SHVVRD QmR TXHU PRUUHU HOD TXHU YLYHU R Pi[LPR SRVVtYHO PDV FRP D JD UDQWLD D FHUWH]D GH TXH VH PRUUHU DTXH OHV TXH GHSHQGHP GHOD QmR ILFDUmR DR DEDQGRQR p XP LQWHUHVVH HFRQ{PLFR 4XDQGR D SHVVRD ID] XP VHJXUR GH VD~ GH QmR SUHWHQGH SDVVDU GLDV LQWHUQDGR QD 87, QLQJXpP TXHU LVVR QLQJXpP HVWi LQWHUHVVDGR HP REWHU D LQGHQL]DomR GR VHJXUR SHOR FRQWUiULR R TXH VH TXHU p JDUDQWLD VHJXUDQoD WUDQTLOLGDGH e LVVR TXH GHYHPRV HQWHQGHU SRU LQWHUHVVH OH JtWLPR $JRUD HQWmR R &yGLJR HVWDEHOHFH TXH R TXH p VHJXUDGR R TXH p JDUDQWLGR p R LQWHUHVVH PDV Ki TXH VHU XP LQWH UHVVH OHJtWLPR /RJR TXDOTXHU LQWHUHV VH LOtFLWR LOHJtWLPR DLQGD TXH FHOHEUD GR FRP R VHJXUR FRQWUDULD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip FRQWUDULD D SUySULD UD]mR GH VHU GR VHJXUR (VVH FRQFHLWR HVWi SHU IHLWR QR PHX HQWHQGHU ( PDLV DLQGD GHVWDFD DTXL TXH R LQWHUHVVH OHJtWLPR p JDUDQWLGR FRQWUD RV ULVFRV SUHGHWHUPL QDGRV +i XPD WHQGrQFLD QRVVD LQFOX VLYH GRV PDJLVWUDGRV GH ID]HU GR VHJX UR R VHJXUDGRU XQLYHUVDO ² ´+i VHJXUR HQWmR SDJD WXGR FREUH WXGRµ ,VVR YLROD R SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH 2 FRQWUDWR IRL FHOHEUDGR WHQGR HP YLVWD GHWHUPLQD GRV ULVFRV R SUrPLR FDOFXODGR p VREUH HVVHV ULVFRV HVSHFtILFRV $TXL HVWi R HTXLOtEULR $ SDUWLU GR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH FRPHoD D LQFOXLU QR RXWUR ODGR ULV FRV TXH QmR IRUDP OHYDGRV HP FRQVLGH UDomR QR PRPHQWR GD FHOHEUDomR GR FRQ WUDWR VH HVWi TXHEUDQGR R SULQFtSLR GD PXWXDOLGDGH 3RLV DJRUD R &yGLJR DSH VDU GH Mi R ID]HU R DQWHULRU GL] TXH RV ULVFRV GHYHP VHU SUHGHWHUPLQDGRV TXH VmR DTXHOHV TXH IRUDP SUHYLVWRV QR FRQWUD WR QD DSyOLFH (VVD PHVPD UHJUD p HQIDWL]DGD QR DUWLJR TXH GLVS}H ´$ DSyOLFH RX R ELOKHWH GH VHJXUR VHUmR QRPLQDWLYRV j RUGHP RX DR SRUWDGRU H PHQFLRQDUmR RV ULVFRV DVVXPLGRV R LQtFLR H R ILP GH VXD YDOLGDGH R OLPLWH GD JD UDQWLD H R SUrPLR GHYLGR H TXDQGR IRU R FDVR R QRPH GR VHJXUDGR H R GR EHQHILFLiULRµ 0HQFLRQDU RV ULVFRV DVVX PLGRV p YLWDO SDUD VH PDQWHU D PXWXDOLGDGH R HTXLOtEULR 4XDQWR DR LQt FLR H R ILP GH VXD YDOLGDGH Ki XPD GLV FXVVmR PXLWR JUDQGH HP FHUWRV VHJX URV VREUH HP TXH PRPHQWR FRPHoD RX QmR D REULJDomR GR VHJXUDGRU VH p QR PRPHQWR HP TXH FHOHEURX D DSyOLFH VH p QR PRPHQWR HP TXH VH IH] R SULPHLUR SDJDPHQWR RX VH p GHSRLV (VVD p XPD TXHVWmR EDVWDQWH FRQWURYHUWLGD H TXH QRV WUD] PXLWD GLILFXOGDGH QD YLGD SUiWLFD TXDVH VHPSUH QRV LQFOLQDPRV HP IDYRU GR VHJXUDGR VHJXQGR XPD WHQGrQFLD QD WXUDO 2 QRYR &yGLJR GL] H[SUHVVDPHQWH TXH YDL YDOHU DTXLOR TXH HVWi HVFULWR QD DSyOLFH e FODUR TXH VH DTXLOR TXH HVWi HVFULWR YLRODU R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip VH IRU XPD FOiXVXOD DEXVLYD YDPRV HQWHQ GHU TXH LVVR QmR YDOH QDGD p FRPR VH QmR H[LVWLVVH 0DV VH IRU XPD FOiXVXOD UD]RiYHO FRPR SRU H[HPSOR TXH R VH JXUR YDL YDOHU D SDUWLU GH KRUDV RX DSyV R SULPHLUR SDJDPHQWR FRLVDV GHV VH WLSR QyV MXt]HV H SURILVVLRQDLV GH GL UHLWR GHYHPRV UHVSHLWDU SRUTXH p LVVR TXH HVWi HVFULWR DTXL QD OHL 6H QmR KRX YHU FROLGrQFLD FRP XP SULQFtSLR PDLRU FRPR D ERD Ip GHYH SUHYDOHFHU DTXLOR TXH IRL HVWDEHOHFLGR QD DSyOLFH SDUD R LQtFLR H ILP GD YDOLGDGH GR FRQWUDWR 7HPRV QR DUWLJR XPD FOiXVX OD TXH FROLGH GH IUHQWH FRP D MXULVSUX
  • 10. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 215 GrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD $LQGD QmR p XPD MXULVSUXGrQFLD SDFtIL FD PDV SHOR PHQRV XP DFyUGmR Mi YL TXH PH GHL[RX DWp EDVWDQWH SUHRFXSD GR 2 FDVR GL]LD UHVSHLWR D XP VHJXUDGR TXH HVWDYD HP PRUD DWp LQDGLPSOHQWH SRUTXH HVWDYD VHP SDJDU R SUrPLR Ki YiULRV PHVHV H SUHFLVRX GR VHJXUR 2 VHJXUDGRU QHJRX VH D SDJDU D LQGHQL]D omR OHYDQGR R VHJXUDGR D LQJUHVVDU QD -XVWLoD QD TXDO WHYH JDQKR GH FDXVD 2 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD HQWHQGHX TXH PHVPR HVWDQGR R VHJXUDGR DWUDVD GR VH SDJRX R SUrPLR WHUi GLUHLWR j LQ GHQL]DomR e LVVR TXH SUHRFXSD SRLV RQGH ILFD D ERD Ip" (QWmR IDoR XP VH JXUR GH DXWRPyYHO H HVSHUR VH URXED UHP R PHX DXWRPyYHO YRX Oi H SDJR R TXH GHYR DSHVDU GH Mi WHU RFRUULGR R VL QLVWUR" ,VVR YLROD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip LVVR p Pi Ip SXUD 1mR YHMR QHQKXP EUL OKDQWLVPR QHVVH HQWHQGLPHQWR FRQWUD ULD D HVWUXWXUD GR VHJXUR 2 DUWLJR DJRUD KDEHPXV OHJLV H[SUHVVD GLVS}H R VHJXLQWH ´1mR WHUi GLUHLWR D LQGHQL]DomR R VHJXUDGR TXH HVWLYHU HP PRUD QR SDJDPHQWR GR SUr PLR VH RFRUUHU R VLQLVWUR DQWHV GH VXD SXUJDomRµ 6H HVVD QRUPD QmR YLROD XP SULQFtSLR GH ERD Ip XP SULQFtSLR PDLRU FUHLR TXH HOD GHYHUi VHU UHVSHLWDGD H QR PHX HQWHQGHU p XPD QRUPD DWp PRUDOL]DGRUD SRUTXH LPSHGLUi HP PXL WRV FDVRV H[DWDPHQWH HVWD SRVLomR GR LQGLYtGXR DJXDUGDU VH H TXDQGR RFRUUHU R VLQLVWUR SDUD Vy HQWmR ID]HU R SDJD PHQWR GR SUrPLR $t HOH QmR TXHU HYL GHQWHPHQWH XP VHJXUR SRLV R FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR p DOHDWyULR HOH TXHU XPD LQ GHQL]DomR PHGLDQWH XP SDJDPHQWR LQ VLJQLILFDQWH SRUTXH D LQGHQL]DomR p PXL WR PDLRU GR TXH DTXLOR TXH HOH SDJRX 2 DUWLJR p D UHSHWLomR GDTXLOR TXH HVWi QR &yGLJR DWXDO ´2 VHJXUDGR H R VHJXUDGRU VmR REULJDGRV D JXDUGDU QD FRQFOXVmR H QD H[HFXomR GR FRQWUDWR D PDLV HVWULWD ERD Ip H YHUDFLGDGH WDQWR D UHVSHLWR GR REMHWR FRPR GDV FLUFXQVWkQFL DV H GHFODUDo}HV D HOH FRQFHUQHQWHVµ -i QRV UHIHULPRV D LVVR TXDQGR GLVVHPRV TXH D ERD Ip p DOPD GR VHJXUR R VHX HOHPHQ WR MXUtGLFR PDV p WDPEpP XPD YLD GH PmR GXSOD SRUTXH WDQWR WHP TXH KDYHU ERD Ip GR VHJXUDGRU FRPR GR VHJXUDGR 2 SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR p TXH PH SUHRFXSD SRUTXH D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD p WUDQTLOD QR VHQWLGR GH TXH R VH JXUDGR Vy SHUGHUi R GLUHLWR j LQGHQL]D omR VH GH Pi Ip LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH IL ]HU DILUPDo}HV TXH QmR FRUUHVSRQGHP j UHDOLGDGH RPLWLU LQIRUPDo}HV TXH GHYH ULDP VHU SUHVWDGDV LQIRUPDo}HV TXH WH ULDP UHOHYkQFLD QD IRUPDomR GR FRQWUD WR 9DPRV DR H[HPSOR GR VHJXUR GH VD~ GH IDoR XP VHJXUR GH YLGD RX GH VD~GH H QmR LQIRUPR TXH VRIUR GH XPD GHWHU PLQDGD GRHQoD RX VHMD XPD GRHQoD SUHH[LVWHQWH (QWmR WHP VH HQWHQGLGR TXH LVVR p XPD DILUPDomR IDOVD IUDXGX OHQWD H FRQVHTHQWHPHQWH YLRODULD R SULQFtSLR GD ERD Ip 0DV VH HX QmR VRX EHU TXH WHQKR XPD GRHQoD VH HX QmR VRXEHU TXH WHQKR XP SUREOHPD DQWH ULRU" $t QHVVH FDVR QmR HVWDULD GH Pi Ip H SRU LVVR D MXULVSUXGrQFLD FRQVD JURX R HQWHQGLPHQWR GH TXH D DILUPD omR TXH QmR FRUUHVSRQGH j YHUGDGH Vy WLUD R GLUHLWR j LQGHQL]DomR VH HOD IRU IHLWD GH Pi Ip RX VHMD VH R VHJXUDGR FRQKHFHQGR R SUREOHPD GH VD~GH FRQKH FHQGR D GRHQoD QmR D LQIRUPD (QWmR D ERD Ip p SUHVXPLGD H FDEHUi j VHJXUD GRUD SURYDU D Pi Ip GR VHJXUDGR SDUD Vy DVVLP QmR SDJDU LQGHQL]DomR $JRUD R SD UiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR GLVS}H ´6H D LQH[DWLGmR RX RPLVVmR QDV GHFODUDo}HV QmR UHVXOWDU GH Pi Ip GR VHJXUDGR SRLV VH UHVXOWDU GH Pi Ip HOH QmR WHUi GLUHL WR D QDGD R VHJXUDGRU WHUi R GLUHLWR GH UHVROYHU R FRQWUDWR RX D FREUDU PHVPR DSyV R VLQLVWUR D GLIHUHQoD GR SUrPLRµ $TXL HP RXWUD SDODYUDV HVWi GL]HQGR TXH VH R VHJXUDGR HVWDYD GH Pi Ip SHU GHUi WXGR VH HVWLYHU GH ERD Ip PDV IL ]HU XPD DILUPDomR SRU H[HPSOR TXH HVWDYD VDGLR H GHSRLV FRQVWDWRX VH TXH HOH WLQKD XPD GRHQoD R VHJXUDGRU SRGH GL]HU TXH QmR TXHU PDLV R FRQWUDWR TXH HVWH HVWi URPSLGR TXH QmR SDJDUi D LQGH QL]DomR H DLQGD LUi FREUDU GR VHJXUDGR R SUrPLR TXH HVWH GHYLD 4XHU GL]HU WUDWD VH GH XPD FOiXVXOD IHUR] YLROHQWD FRQWUD R VHJXUDGR -i GHYHPRV LU SHQVDQGR QD LQWHUSUHWDomR TXH OKH YDPRV GDU
  • 11. 216 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” $TXL PH SDUHFH KRXYH XP UHWUR FHVVR PDV D GRXWULQD H D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD VDEHUmR GDU R WUDWR DGHTXDGR j TXHV WmR D ILP GH TXH QmR KDMD PDLRUHV SUH MXt]RV HP PDWpULD GH WDO LPSRUWkQFLD 2 &yGLJR GLVFLSOLQRX PHOKRU D TXHVWmR GR DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR (VVH p RXWUR SRQWR LPSRUWDQWH VH TXDQGR FHOHEUD PRV R FRQWUDWR GH VHJXUR HVWDEHOHFH PRV XP HTXLOtEULR HQWUH ULVFR H SUrPLR LVVR p PXWXDOLGDGH H HVWH FRQWUDWR GH WUDWR VXFHVVLYR LUi SHUGXUDU VHUi QH FHVViULR TXH DV SDUWHV QD PHGLGD GR SRVVtYHO PDQWHQKDP R VWDWXV TXR 2 VHJXUDGR QmR GHYH DJUDYDU RV VHXV ULV FRV QmR GHYH DXPHQWi ORV VRE SHQD GH HYHQWXDOPHQWH FDXVDU XP GHVHTXLOtEULR QR FRQWUDWR 2 &yGLJR GH IDOD QR DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR H D GRXWULQD H MX ULVSUXGrQFLD FRQVDJUDUDP R HQWHQGL PHQWR GH TXH HVVH DJUDYDPHQWR Vy H[ FOXL D LQGHQL]DomR GR VHJXUDGR VH IRU GH Pi Ip LQWHQFLRQDO 3RU H[HPSOR PRUR HP XPD FLGDGH SDFDWD GR LQWHULRU H WHQKD R PHX FDUUR VHJXUDGR Oi 'H UH SHQWH PXGHL PH SDUD R 5LR GH -DQHLUR RQGH R URXER H IXUWR GH DXWRPyYHLV VmR PXLWR JUDQGHV $XPHQWHL R ULVFR PDV SRU TXDOTXHU UD]mR HVTXHFL PH H QmR FRPXQLTXHL j 6HJXUDGRUD H GH UHSHQ WH R PHX FDUUR p URXEDGR $ 6HJXUDGR UD YDL DOHJDU TXH VH PH PXGHL SDUD R 5LR GH -DQHLUR H QmR FRPXQLTXHL HVWH IDWR SHUGL R GLUHLWR SRU WHU DJUDYDGR R ULVFR +i HQWHQGLPHQWR MXULVSUXGHQFLDO QR VHQWLGR GH Vy DGPLWLU D SHUGD GD LQ GHQL]DomR TXDQGR R DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULV FR IRU LQWHQFLRQDO 2 FHUWR VHUi LPHGLD WDPHQWH FRPXQLFDU R DJUDYDPHQWR GR ULVFR PDV HVWH Vy H[FOXLUi D LQGHQL]D omR VH KRXYHU LQWHQFLRQDOLGDGH $JRUD R DUWLJR p FODUR ´2 VHJXUDGR SHUGHUi R GLUHLWR j JDUDQWLD VH DJUDYDU LQWHQFLRQDOPHQWH R ULVFR REMHWR GR FRQWUDWRµ 1mR KDYHQGR DJUDYDPHQ WR LQWHQFLRQDO HYLGHQWHPHQWH QmR KD YHUi TXH VH IDODU HP SHUGD GD LQGH QL]DomR 8PD RXWUD QRUPD LPSRUWDQWH H TXH GH FHUWD PDQHLUD EDWH GH IUHQWH FRP D MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 6XSHULRU 7UL EXQDO GH -XVWLoD p D GR DUWLJR 2V VHQKRUHV VH OHPEUDP GD TXHVWmR FRQ WURYHUWLGD FRP UHODomR D VHJXUR GH DXWR PyYHO VH D LQGHQL]DomR GHYHULD VHU SHOR SUHoR GH PHUFDGR RX VH SHOR YDORU GD DSy OLFH (VVD TXHVWmR IRL PXLWR GLVFXWLGD H Ki UD]}HV SDUD RV GRLV ODGRV $ DOHJDomR SULQFLSDO p HVWD D LQGHQL]DomR QmR SRGH VHU PDLRU GR TXH R YDORU GD FRLVD 4XDQ GR IRL IHLWR R VHJXUR GR DXWRPyYHO R VHX YDORU HUD FLQTHQWD PLO ² HVVH p R YDORU GD DSyOLFH ² PDV TXDQGR RFRUUHX R VLQLV WUR Vy YDOLD TXDUHQWD PLO 4XDO GHYH VHU R YDORU GD LQGHQL]DomR" &LQTHQWD RX TXDUHQWD PLO" 3DUD D VHJXUDGRUD TXDUHQ WD SRUTXH HVWH p R YDORU DWXDO GR EHP 0DV R VHJXUDGR SDJRX R SUrPLR VREUH FLQ THQWD ,VVR FKHJRX DR 6XSHULRU 7ULEX QDO GH -XVWLoD TXH LQLFLDOPHQWH HQWHQ GHX TXH HUD R YDORU GR PHUFDGR H GHSRLV GHX XPD JXLQDGD HP HPEDUJRV GH GLYHU JrQFLD HP XP DFyUGmR HP TXH KDYLD HV WDEHOHFLGR R YDORU GR PHUFDGR 2 UHODWRU IRL R QRVVR HVWLPDGR 0LQLVWUR :DOGHPDU =YHLWHU $ SDUWLU GHVVH PRPHQWR R 6XSH ULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XVWLoD SDVVRX D HQWHQ GHU TXH GHYHUi VHU R YDORU GD DSyOLFH $JRUD WHPRV DTXL R DUWLJR TXH PH SDUHFH VHU XP REVWiFXOR D HVVH HQ WHQGLPHQWR 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H ´$ LQGH QL]DomR QmR SRGH XOWUDSDVVDU R YDORU GR LQWH UHVVH VHJXUDGR QR PRPHQWR GR VLQLVWUR H HP KLSyWHVH DOJXPD R OLPLWH Pi[LPR GD JD UDQWLD IL[DGR QD DSyOLFH VDOYR HP FDVR GH PRUD GR VHJXUDGRUµ (P FDVR GH PRUD GR VHJXUDGRU PDQGD VH SDJDU MXURV H FRU UHomR PRQHWiULD $R TXH WXGR LQGLFD D GLVFXVVmR VHUi UHLQLFLDGD QR VHQWLGR GH VDEHU VH HVVD SRVLomR GR 6XSHULRU D SDU WLU GR &yGLJR QRYR HVWi HP YLJRU RX QmR 7HPRV RXWUD QRUPD LPSRUWDQWH QR DUWLJR H TXH WDPEpP FRQVDJURX R HQWHQGLPHQWR SUHGRPLQDQWH $ WHP R VHX DXWRPyYHO VHJXUDGR YHQGH R SDUD % WUDQVIHULQGR OKH R VHJXUR 'HSRLV TXH R DXWRPyYHO Mi HVWi HP SRGHU GH % p URX EDGR RX IXUWDGR $t R % YHP SHGLU R VHJX UR PDV D VHJXUDGRUD DOHJD TXH WLQKD VH JXUR FRP $ H TXH HVWH DR WUDQVIHULU R DXWRPyYHO VHP QDGD DYLVDU DJUDYRX R ULV FR UD]mR SHOD TXDO QmR SDJDUi D LQGHQL ]DomR +i QR &yGLJR GH XPD FHUWD G~YLGD VH HUD RX QmR SRVVtYHO HVVD WUDQV IHUrQFLD GR VHJXUR +RMH R DUWLJR FRQ VDJUD R HQWHQGLPHQWR TXH SUHYDOHFHX QD
  • 12. Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” - 217 GRXWULQD H MXULVSUXGrQFLD ´VDOYR GLVSRVL omR HP FRQWUiULR DGPLWH VH D WUDQVIHUrQ FLD GR FRQWUDWR D WHUFHLUR FRP D DOLHQD omR RX FHVVmR GR LQWHUHVVH VHJXUDGRµ 2XWUD TXHVWmR TXH IRL FRQVWUXomR GD GRXWULQD H GD MXULVSUXGrQFLD HVWi FRQVDJUDGD QR DUWLJR D VXE URJD omR 4XDQGR LQJUHVVHL QD PDJLVWUDWX UD XPD GDV TXHVW}HV WRUPHQWRVDV HUD VH R VHJXUDGRU WLQKD RX QmR R GLUHLWR GH VXE URJDU VH QRV GLUHLWRV GR VHJXUDGR GHSRLV GH SDJDU D LQGHQL]DomR +DYLD WHVHV SDUD WRGRV RV ODGRV )LQDOPHQWH D MXULVSUXGrQFLD GR 67) FULVWDOL]DGD QD 6~PXOD Qž FRQVDJURX R HQWHQGLPHQ WR GH TXH R VHJXUDGRU VXE URJD VH QR GLUHLWR GR VHJXUDGR (VVD V~PXOD HVWi KRMH SRVLWLYDGD QR DUWLJR TXH GLV S}H ´3DJD D LQGHQL]DomR R VHJXUDGRU VXE URJD VH QRV OLPLWHV GR YDORU UHVSHF WLYR QRV GLUHLWRV H Do}HV TXH FRPSHWL UHP DR VHJXUDGR FRQWUD R DXWRU GR GDQRµ 2 SDUiJUDIR SULPHLUR WHP XPD FHUWD H[ FHomR TXH QmR QRV LQWHUHVVD QR PRPHQ WR 2V DUWLJRV H WUDWDUDP GH GXDV TXHVW}HV WRUPHQWRVDV QR VHJXUR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO Ki XPD FRUUHQWH TXH Ki PXLWR WHPSR YLQKD GHIHQGHQGR D DG PLVVLELOLGDGH GD DomR GLUHWD GR WHUFHLUR FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU 8PD SHVVRD WHP VHJXUR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO FRP UHODomR DR VHX DXWRPyYHO EDWH HP DO JXpP H GH UHSHQWH HVVH TXH FDXVRX R DFLGHQWH QmR WHP FRQGLo}HV GH UHSDUDU R GDQR PDV R VHJXUDGRU WHP (QWmR D TXHVWmR p HVVD VH D YtWLPD VH R WHUFHL UR TXH VRIUHX R SUHMXt]R SRGHULD PRYHU DomR LQGHQL]DWyULD GLUHWDPHQWH FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU +i PXLWR WHPSR TXH HVVD LGpLD YHP VHQGR WUDEDOKDGD QR VHQWLGR GH TXH SRGH 2 &yGLJR GR &RQVXPLGRU GHX XP SDVVR DYDQoDGR HPERUD QmR SHUPLWD D GHQXQFLDomR GD OLGH DR VHJX UDGRU SRUTXH VHQmR HOH YHP SDUD FRP SOLFDU R SURFHVVR SHUPLWH WRGDYLD R FKDPDPHQWR DR SURFHVVR ( VH HOH p FKDPDGR D H[HFXomR SRGH VHU IHLWD GL UHWDPHQWH FRQWUD R VHJXUDGRU (UD D RSRUWXQLGDGH GH VH GDU XP SDVVR H GH VH HVWDEHOHFHU D DomR GLUHWD FRQWUD R VH JXUDGRU QR FDVR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FL YLO 2 DUWLJR QmR R IH] GLVSRQGR R VHJXLQWH ´1R VHJXUR GH UHVSRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO R VHJXUDGRU JDUDQWH R SDJDPHQWR GH SHUGDV H GDQRV GHYLGRV SHOR VHJXUDGR D WHUFHLURµ 1RV SDUiJUDIRV ž ž ž H ž HVWDEHOHFH XPD VpULH GH H[LJrQFLDV SDUD TXH R VHJXUDGR QmR SHUFD HVVH GLUHLWR 1R DUWLJR HQWUHWDQWR DGPLWLX D DomR GLUHWD QR FDVR GH VHJXUR REULJD WyULR PDV QmR QR FDVR GR VHJXUR GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH FLYLO ´1RV VHJXURV GH UHV SRQVDELOLGDGH OHJDOPHQWH REULJDWyULRV D LQGHQL]DomR SRU VLQLVWURV VHUi SDJD SHOR VHJXUDGRU GLUHWDPHQWH DR WHUFHLUR SUH MXGLFDGRµ ( HVVD p D QRUPD TXH PH SD UHFH GHYHULD HVWDU Oi QR DUWLJR WDP EpP 6HULD XP DYDQoR HOLPLQDULD XPD FDUUDGD GH Do}HV TXH DLQGD KRMH DFRQ WHFHP R TXH GH FHUWD PDQHLUD QD SUi WLFD PXLWDV VHJXUDGRUDV Mi ID]HP 4XDQGR RFRUUH R DFLGHQWH R YHtFXOR p HQFDPLQKDGR SDUD XPD RILFLQD DXWRUL ]DGD H DOL FRQVHUWDGR GLUHWDPHQWH &RP UHODomR DR VHJXUR GH SHVVRDV JRVWDULD GH GHVWDFDU DSHQDV GRLV GLVSR VLWLYRV R SULPHLUR GHOHV p R DUWLJR TXH WDPEpP p XPD FRQVDJUDomR QD OHL GDTXLOR TXH IRL FRQVWUXtGR SHOD MXULVSUX GrQFLD 4XDQGR HQWUHL QD PDJLVWUDWX UD VH DOJXpP IL]HVVH XP VHJXUR GH YLGD SDUD D VXD FRQFXELQD TXH HUD XP SDOD YUmR QmR WHULD YDOLGDGH &RQVWUXLX VH GHEDWHX VH GLVFXWLX VH H D MXULVSUXGrQ FLD SUDWLFDPHQWH Vy QmR DGPLWH FRPR EHQHILFLiULD GR VHJXUR D DPDQWH 0DV QR FDVR GH FRPSDQKHLUD GH FRQYLYrQ FLD DGPLWH VH WUDQTLODPHQWH R VHJXUR HP VHX IDYRU 2 DUWLJR DJRUD FRQVD JUD HVVD UHJUD ´e YiOLGD D LQVWLWXLomR GR FRPSDQKHLUR FRPR EHQHILFLiULR VH DR WHPSR GR FRQWUDWR R VHJXUDGR HUD VHSD UDGR MXGLFLDOPHQWH RX Mi VH HQFRQWUDYD VHSDUDGR GH IDWRµ 1mR SUHFLVD QHP VHU D XQLmR HVWiYHO 6H KRXYHU VHSDUDomR GH IDWR VHUi YiOLGD D LQVWLWXLomR YDL GHVD SDUHFHU GR QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO SRUWDQWR R DUWLJR GR &yGLJR GH TXH GLV S}H ´QmR VH SRGH LQVWLWXLU EHQHILFLiULR SHVVRD TXH IRU OHJDOPHQWH LQLELGD H UH FHEHU D GRDomR GR VHJXUDGRµ 3RU ~OWLPR JRVWDULD GH GHVWDFDU R DUWLJR PXLWR FXULRVR SRLV DJRUD YD
  • 13. 218 - Anais do “EMERJ Debate o Novo Código Civil” PRV WHU VXLFtGLR FRP SUD]R GH FDUrQFLD 2V VHQKRUHV VDEHP TXH FRP UHODomR DR VXLFtGLR D MXULVSUXGrQFLD WDQWR GR 6X SUHPR FRPR GR 6XSHULRU 7ULEXQDO GH -XV WLoD HQWHQGHX TXH Vy QmR p GHYLGD D LQ GHQL]DomR VH VH WUDWDU GH VXLFtGLR SUH PHGLWDGR e UDUtVVLPR R FDVR GH VXLFtGLR SUHPHGLWDGR 4XDVH VHPSUH p IUXWR GH GHSUHVVmR H SRU LVVR D LQGHQL]DomR p VHPSUH GHYLGD DWp SRUTXH SURYDU D SUH PHGLWDomR QmR p IiFLO (VVD SURYD FDEH ULD DR VHJXUDGRU 2 DUWLJR GLVS}H R VHJXLQWH ´2 EHQHILFLiULR QmR WHP GLUHL WR DR FDSLWDO HVWLSXODGR TXDQGR R VHJX UDGR VH VXLFLGD QRV SULPHLURV GRLV DQRV GH YLJrQFLD LQLFLDO GR FRQWUDWR RX GD VXD UHFRQGXomR GHSRLV GH VXVSHQVR REVHU YDGR R GLVSRVWR QR SDUiJUDIR ~QLFR GR DUWLJR DQWHFHGHQWHµ 6H D ILQDOLGDGH DTXL HUD DIDVWDU D SUHPHGLWDomR DFDERX VH HVWDEHOHFHQGR DSHQDV XP SUD]R PDLRU GH SUHPHGLWDomR $JRUD VHUi SUHFLVR SOD QHMDU XP VXLFtGLR FRP QR PtQLPR GRLV DQRV GH DQWHFHGrQFLD 6H p FXULRVR RX QmR p R TXH HVWi HVFULWR DTXL 2 OHJLVOD GRU HQWHQGHX TXH QLQJXpP YDL SUHPH GLWDU XP VXLFtGLR FRP GRLV DQRV GH DQ WHFHGrQFLD GH VRUWH TXH VH R VXLFtGLR RFRUUHU GRLV DQRV DSyV R VHJXUR SUHVX PH VH TXH QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR 0DV VH RFRUUHU DQWHV DLQGD TXH VHMD XP LQIH OL] FRP SURIXQGD GHSUHVVmR HP XP HV WDGR GH DOXFLQDomR HWF PHVPR DVVLP VH DSOLFDUPRV D OHL FRPR HVWi HVFULWR QmR KDYHUi LQGHQL]DomR e FODUR TXH DTXL WDPEpP YDPRV WHU TXH ID]HU GLVWLQomR FDGD FDVR p XP FDVR 6H HYLGHQFLDGR TXH R VXLFtGLR GHFRUUHX GH XPD VLWXDomR GH DQJ~VWLD GH DIOLomR GH SHUWXUEDomR GH GHSUHVVmR GHYLGD VHUi D LQGHQL]DomR 7DOYH] VHUi FDVR GH VH LQYHUWHU R {QXV GD SURYD 'XUDQWH HVVHV GRLV DQRV WHUi TXH VH SURYDU TXH R VXLFtGLR QmR IRL SUH PHGLWDGR 'HSRLV GH GRLV DQRV KDYHUi XPD SUHVXQomR DEVROXWD GH TXH R VXLFt GLR QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR $ LQWHUSUHWDomR TXH IDoR GHVGH DJRUD p TXH QHVVH SHUt RGR GH GRLV DQRV VHUi SUHFLVR SURYDU TXH R VXLFtGLR QmR IRL SUHPHGLWDGR 'HSRLV GRV GRLV DQRV KDYHUi SUHVXQomR DEVROX WD GH TXH QmR KRXYH SUHPHGLWDomR (QFHUUR UHODWDQGR D KLVWyULD GH XP PHQLQR TXH PRUDYD QR LQWHULRU GH 0L QDV *HUDLV H TXH XP GLD YHLR SDVVHDU QR 5LR GH -DQHLUR FRP D VXD PmH RQGH WHYH D RSRUWXQLGDGH GH FRQKHFHU R PDU )RL XP GHVOXPEUDPHQWR %ULQFRX QD SUDLD FDWRX FRQFKLQKDV SXORX RQGDV H TXDQGR UHWRUQRX D VXD FLGDGH]LQKD QD WDO UHODWRX HPSROJDGR DR VHX DY{ D VXD QRYD DYHQWXUD ( WHUPLQRX R VHX UHODWR ID]HQGR XPD SHUJXQWD YRY{ YRFr WDP EpP FRQKHFH R PDU" (OH TXH HUD XP YH OKR PDUXMR FRP PDLV GH WULQWD DQRV GH QDYHJDomR DR VH UHOHPEUDU HP XP LQV WDQWH GDV VXDV SURIXQGDV H[SHULrQFLDV FRP R RFHDQR UHVSRQGHX FRP FHUWD LQ VHJXUDQoD TXH WDPEpP FRQKHFLD R PDU 8P QRYR &yGLJR &LYLO p XP RFHDQR SRLV DTXL HVWi WRGD D HVWUXWXUD GD RUGHP MXUtGLFD EUDVLOHLUD (VWRX TXHUHQGR GL]HU TXH HVVH RFHDQR TXH HVWi DTXL GLDQWH GH WRGRV QyV SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR GH GXDV PDQHLUDV SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR FRPR SRU DTXHOH PHQLQR TXH EULQFRX QD SUDLD H LPDJLQRX TXH FRQKHFLD R PDU H SRGH VHU FRQKHFLGR FRPR SRU DTXHOH PDUXMR TXH QDYHJRX WULQWD DQRV QR RFHDQR HQIUHQ WRX WRGR WLSR GH WHPSHVWDGH H DLQGD WL QKD FHUWD LQVHJXUDQoD DR GL]HU TXH FR QKHFLD R PDU 7RGRV QyV WHUHPRV TXH QDYHJDU QHVVH QRYR RFHDQR H LVVR FRPH oDUi QR GLD TXH HVVH &yGLJR HQWUDU HP YLJRU 3RGHUHPRV ILFDU QD SUDLD EULQFDQ GR RX SRGHUHPRV LQLFLDU XPD YLDJHP IDQ WiVWLFD H TXH QmR WHUi ILP 2 REMHWLYR GD (0(5- p HVWLPXODU D WRGRV D TXH FRQKH oDPRV SURIXQGDPHQWH HVVH &yGLJR H SRV VDPRV DVVLP GDU D HOH D DSOLFDomR TXH HOH PHUHFH 2EULJDGR SHOD DWHQomR