Enviar búsqueda
Cargar
Alternatives to Nonprofit
•
1 recomendación
•
436 vistas
M
msdiamond
Seguir
Denunciar
Compartir
Denunciar
Compartir
1 de 4
Descargar ahora
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Recomendados
Co-op 101 for Athens Free School 2016
Co-op 101 for Athens Free School 2016
Matthew Epperson
iWave applications
iWave applications
JasonBarrett007
Forprofit AND Nonprofit, A new type of hybrid- Bronberger - Stanford SIR
Forprofit AND Nonprofit, A new type of hybrid- Bronberger - Stanford SIR
Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
Gn
Gn
T.I.M.E. (Triumphant Institute of Management Education)
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Stephen Bainbridge
DiversityPlus/Apr2009
DiversityPlus/Apr2009
Ji Hyun Lee
2009 Canada to UK Study Tour: Slide Deck Presentation
2009 Canada to UK Study Tour: Slide Deck Presentation
Joanna Reynolds
KNOW THE LEDGE EMPOWERMENT
KNOW THE LEDGE EMPOWERMENT
Phillip Moreland El
Recomendados
Co-op 101 for Athens Free School 2016
Co-op 101 for Athens Free School 2016
Matthew Epperson
iWave applications
iWave applications
JasonBarrett007
Forprofit AND Nonprofit, A new type of hybrid- Bronberger - Stanford SIR
Forprofit AND Nonprofit, A new type of hybrid- Bronberger - Stanford SIR
Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
Gn
Gn
T.I.M.E. (Triumphant Institute of Management Education)
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Revitalizing Rule 14a-8's ordinary business exclusion for shareholder proposals
Stephen Bainbridge
DiversityPlus/Apr2009
DiversityPlus/Apr2009
Ji Hyun Lee
2009 Canada to UK Study Tour: Slide Deck Presentation
2009 Canada to UK Study Tour: Slide Deck Presentation
Joanna Reynolds
KNOW THE LEDGE EMPOWERMENT
KNOW THE LEDGE EMPOWERMENT
Phillip Moreland El
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
babak danyal
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Михаил Самохин
Stanford University Summit Program
Stanford University Summit Program
msdiamond
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
msdiamond
Proyecto power final
Proyecto power final
elviapresentaciones
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Idealist Job Search Book
Idealist Job Search Book
msdiamond
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
ux singapore
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Stanford GSB Corporate Governance Research Initiative
Why You Should Care
Why You Should Care
Nonprofit Finance Fund_SIB Learning Hub
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
Linda Alexander
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
Linda Alexander
Capital One
Capital One
Paper Writing Help Howard University
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
jeremylockett77
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
pooleavelina
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
Faisal Hoque
Boundaryless Organisation
Boundaryless Organisation
Lindsey Jones
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
"Allison "Ali"" Walker
Más contenido relacionado
Destacado
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
babak danyal
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Михаил Самохин
Stanford University Summit Program
Stanford University Summit Program
msdiamond
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
msdiamond
Proyecto power final
Proyecto power final
elviapresentaciones
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
GIOVANNI LARICCIA
Idealist Job Search Book
Idealist Job Search Book
msdiamond
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
ux singapore
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Stanford GSB Corporate Governance Research Initiative
Destacado
(13)
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
Beit 381 se lec 13 - 11 - 12 mar20 - project management
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Лояльность и блогосфера. Горизонтальный мир
Stanford University Summit Program
Stanford University Summit Program
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
SoBe Rincon Hill Neighborhood Guide
Proyecto power final
Proyecto power final
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
Barbara Reale, presentazione Arte Spirituale San Biagio
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
Guida 1a [2012 2013]
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
Spirale.quadrata.tricolore
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
Spirale.esagonale.ricol3
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
2015-12-07 Matematica felice a 4-5 anni
Idealist Job Search Book
Idealist Job Search Book
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
Lightning Talk #9: How UX and Data Storytelling Can Shape Policy by Mika Aldaba
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Succession “Losers”: What Happens to Executives Passed Over for the CEO Job?
Similar a Alternatives to Nonprofit
Why You Should Care
Why You Should Care
Nonprofit Finance Fund_SIB Learning Hub
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
Linda Alexander
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
Linda Alexander
Capital One
Capital One
Paper Writing Help Howard University
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
jeremylockett77
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
pooleavelina
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
Faisal Hoque
Boundaryless Organisation
Boundaryless Organisation
Lindsey Jones
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
"Allison "Ali"" Walker
Professional and Ethical, Issues and Responsibilities
Professional and Ethical, Issues and Responsibilities
Upekha Vandebona
Persuasive Speech Central Idea Examples - Nestqust
Persuasive Speech Central Idea Examples - Nestqust
Erika Nelson
For love or lucre - Jim Fruchterman - Stanford SIR
For love or lucre - Jim Fruchterman - Stanford SIR
Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
Conflict of interest
Conflict of interest
Chiranjibi Banjade
Non-profit vs For-profit final
Non-profit vs For-profit final
Prista Corporation
Professional Ethics Paper Scenario 4
Professional Ethics Paper Scenario 4
llknaack
Companization - Business as usual is over!
Companization - Business as usual is over!
Plantagon
Great Expectations Lateral Attorney Nylj
Great Expectations Lateral Attorney Nylj
ellenostrow
ESG engagement inisghts (v 1.1)
ESG engagement inisghts (v 1.1)
Nawar Alsaadi
Hire More Staff or Contract Out?
Hire More Staff or Contract Out?
Social Media Today
Angle Capital How To Rise Early Stage Private Equity Financing (2)
Angle Capital How To Rise Early Stage Private Equity Financing (2)
Vishweshwar
Similar a Alternatives to Nonprofit
(20)
Why You Should Care
Why You Should Care
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
NonprofitPage_Final_June23
Capital One
Capital One
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
1 of 19 Winning Grants Power PackJumpstart your grant .docx
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
Here are two discussion post responses from classmates that need r.docx
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
What Every Entrepreneur Should Know Before Taking Any Outside Investment
Boundaryless Organisation
Boundaryless Organisation
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
Hedge Fund Succession AWalker Final
Professional and Ethical, Issues and Responsibilities
Professional and Ethical, Issues and Responsibilities
Persuasive Speech Central Idea Examples - Nestqust
Persuasive Speech Central Idea Examples - Nestqust
For love or lucre - Jim Fruchterman - Stanford SIR
For love or lucre - Jim Fruchterman - Stanford SIR
Conflict of interest
Conflict of interest
Non-profit vs For-profit final
Non-profit vs For-profit final
Professional Ethics Paper Scenario 4
Professional Ethics Paper Scenario 4
Companization - Business as usual is over!
Companization - Business as usual is over!
Great Expectations Lateral Attorney Nylj
Great Expectations Lateral Attorney Nylj
ESG engagement inisghts (v 1.1)
ESG engagement inisghts (v 1.1)
Hire More Staff or Contract Out?
Hire More Staff or Contract Out?
Angle Capital How To Rise Early Stage Private Equity Financing (2)
Angle Capital How To Rise Early Stage Private Equity Financing (2)
Alternatives to Nonprofit
1.
Alternatives to Forming
a Charitable Nonprofit A Start-Up May Not Be in Your Client’s Best Interests By Gene Takagi and Emily Chan L awyers retained to assist in the for- may present little challenge for a law- Before a decision is made to form a mation of a charitable nonprofit yer or a sophisticated client. Howev- nonprofit, lawyers should ensure that should consider whether forming er, funding, compliance with myriad the founders understand the funda- a nonprofit is in the client’s best inter- requirements, and operating a viable mentals of operating as an organiza- ests. Absent sufficient research by the nonprofit can be exceptionally difficult, tion exempt under section 501(c)(3) of client and a good plan for continued even with the best of intentions and ini- the Internal Revenue Code (the Code), viability, the lawyer may best serve tial seed capital. Typically, when the including the prohibitions against pri- the client by introducing alternatives economy is not strong, the competition vate inurement and private benefit. Too to forming a nonprofit, which may for funds and other resources can be many founders believe that they are enti- include (1) an alliance with an existing fierce due to an increasing pool of non- tled to control the nonprofits they create nonprofit, (2) fiscal sponsorship, or (3) profits, the growing need for services, and can leverage such control to their a donor-advised fund. and diminishing resources. If a nonprof- personal advantage with little restriction. Prior to forming a nonprofit, lawyers it is insufficiently prepared to compete Under the private inurement doc- and their clients should consider the and operate in such an environment, trine, a nonprofit may not permit any extremely competitive landscape—the the end product may be gross inefficien- part of its net earnings to inure to the vast majority of new nonprofits will cies, frustrated founders, disillusioned benefit of a person having a personal fail, become dormant, or operate in donors, and fewer resources ultimately and private interest in the organiza- financial distress. Stan Madden, direc- reaching its intended beneficiaries. tion’s activities (i.e., an insider such as tor of the Center for Nonprofit Studies a director, officer, or key employee). at the Hankamer School of Business at Sufficient Research An organization that engages in an Baylor University, estimated that only Individuals considering forming a inurement transaction may face revo- one-third of nonprofits survive beyond charitable nonprofit should research cation of its exempt status. Under the five years. Ron Mattocks, author of not only how to start a nonprofit but similar, but broader, private benefit Zone of Insolvency: How Nonprofits Avoid also whether a new nonprofit would be doctrine, a nonprofit may not confer Hidden Liabilities and Build Financial the best vehicle to further their chari- nonincidental benefits on individu- Strength, asserts that as many as one- table objectives from the public’s per- als for the benefit of private interests. third of the nation’s 1.4 million regis- spective. Researching and writing a Accordingly, any benefit conferred tered nonprofits operate in the zone of business plan is a prudent early step. upon an individual must be incidental, insolvency. The plan should define the nonprofit’s quantitatively and qualitatively, to the The mechanics of forming a non- mission and identify its core activi- furthering of the organization’s exempt profit and obtaining tax-exempt status ties, potential supporters, and targeted purposes. Where an excess benefit is beneficiaries. It also should contain an conferred upon a person who is in a Takagi is principal of the law office of assessment of the nonprofit’s environ- position to exercise substantial influ- Gene Takagi in San Francisco and editor ment, including its potential allies and ence over the affairs of the organization of the Nonprofit Law Blog. Chan is a competitors, and a projected multiyear (e.g., a director, officer, or other dis- member of the Class of 2010, University budget. The exercise of preparing a qualified person), the transaction may of California, Hastings College of the plan will likely require market research be subject to excise taxes under section Law. Their respective e-mails are gene@ and help determine whether or not 4958 of the Code. attorneyfornonprofits.com and there are already one or more nonprof- Founders also should be cogni- emilynicolechan@gmail.com. its with similar goals. zant of the ongoing obligations of a Published in Business Law Today, Volume 18, Number 6, July/August 2009. © 2009 by the American Bar Association. Reproduced with permission. All rights reserved. 1 This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.
2.
an organization with
substantially 10 Questions Your Clients Should Answer Before Forming a Nonprofit similar goals to the one contemplated 1. What will be the nonprofit’s charitable purposes? already exists. Working or collabo- rating with an existing nonprofit can 2. What will be its core activities? leverage significant advantages while 3. Who are its intended beneficiaries? mitigating many of the risks that can 4. Are there existing nonprofits with a similar mission, and, if so, have you be a fatal blow to the survival of a new discussed your ideas with them? nonprofit. Working with an existing nonprofit 5. Can your mission be furthered more effectively and efficiently by an as an employee or volunteer may be existing nonprofit? especially valuable to an individual 6. Can you attract sufficient resources to start and operate a new who lacks experience, nonprofit busi- nonprofit? ness sophistication, and/or resources. When appropriate, lawyers should 7. Have you drafted a business plan (including a three-year projected make their clients aware of the follow- budget)? ing benefits of working with an exist- 8. Are you familiar with what it takes to start and run a nonprofit in ing nonprofit: compliance with the laws and best practices? • Avoidance of start-up costs and administrative burdens of a new 9. Have you considered alternatives to forming a new nonprofit, such as nonprofit. fiscal sponsorship and donor advised funds? • Increased efficiency in further- 10. Whose help will you need to form the nonprofit and get it running? ing the charitable mission by using an established infrastructure. nonprofit, including periodic filings governing body, marketing strategies, • Opportunity to gain experience with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and targets for ongoing support and and expertise in running a nonprofit. and various state authorities. Those some long-range ideas. • Development of connections in who will serve on the board of a non- While it may not be the lawyer’s the nonprofit community. profit corporation should know the role to judge the relative viability of Collaborating with an existing non- basics of nonprofit corporate gover- a contemplated nonprofit, it is usu- profit is an alternative that may be nance. In addition, if there are to be ally clear when a client is relying on considered even where the contem- employees, the nonprofit must be pre- an unrealistic expectation that donors plated charitable idea is not currently pared to meet the obligations of a new and funders will find and support the being implemented by an existing employer. new nonprofit with little effort or plan- nonprofit. A nonprofit with a com- Well-prepared founders increase ning. Generally, in such case, the law- patible mission may be receptive to their chances of creating a sustainable yer should recommend that the client implementing and operating a new nonprofit organization. Lawyers advis- either postpone forming a nonprofit program, particularly if a volunteer is ing ill-prepared, would-be founders or consider one of the alternatives out- willing to bring resources to the table. may do a great service to their clients lined below. Alternatively, the nonprofit may have and to the broader public by educat- institutional knowledge relating to ing them and sending them back to Use of an Existing Nonprofit the charitable idea and its implemen- do their homework before they decide According to the National Center tation. Moreover, the nonprofit may whether to proceed with the formation for Charitable Statistics, the number of open doors and leverage assets that of a nonprofit. 501(c)(3) organizations has increased might not be otherwise readily avail- by over 70 percent between 1996 and able, such as Plan for Viability 2006. In the one-year period from • Existing resources, including A great plan for providing services October 1, 2006, through September staff, volunteers, infrastructure, and to members of a charitable class is rea- 30, 2007, the IRS received over 85,000 systems. son for excitement, but in and of itself, applications for recognition of exemp- • In-house experience and exper- it is not a sufficient reason to form a tion under section 501(c)(3). tise, which may allow the contem- nonprofit. There also needs to be an A critical mistake made by many plated program to be launched and achievable plan for acquiring resources founders of charitable nonprofits is operated efficiently and in compliance (human, financial, and other) required their failure to communicate with, with the law. to provide those services and operate and examine, the existing nonprofits • Donor and business relationships, the nonprofit over a period of time. in their space. With roughly 1.8 mil- including with institutional funders, Such plan should include sources of lion domestic nonprofits (IRS 2008 nonprofit leaders, allied organizations, adequate start-up capital, an initial Annual Report), chances are high that and the media. Published in Business Law Today, Volume 18, Number 6, July/August 2009. © 2009 by the American Bar Association. Reproduced with permission. All rights reserved. 2 This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.
3.
• Goodwill, which
may provide the must weigh such benefits against a lack Donor-Advised Funds program with name recognition and of autonomy; their limited control over A donor-advised fund, first defined built-in public trust. the Project, which remains under the in the Internal Revenue Code as a ultimate control of the Sponsor; and result of the Pension Protection Act of Fiscal Sponsorship the sponsorship fees. 2006, is a fund or account (1) that is Fiscal sponsorship is the term used It is likely that a great majority of separately identified by reference to to describe the relationship between an individuals and groups interested in the contributions of a donor or donors; individual or group of individuals who forming a nonprofit have never con- (2) that is owned and controlled by a have initiated a charitable project (the sidered, nor even heard of, fiscal spon- sponsoring organization; and (3) with Project) and an existing tax-exempt sorship. Yet, fiscal sponsorship may be respect to which the donor or person organization that has agreed to support a very attractive alternative to forma- appointed or designated by the donor the Project (the Sponsor). Typically, tion of a nonprofit, particularly where has, or reasonably expects to have, the Sponsor confers upon the Project the sustainability of a separate entity advisory privileges with respect to dis- the benefit of the Sponsor’s tax-exempt is highly questionable or the charita- tributions or investments. Individuals status and certain administrative servic- ble endeavor has a relatively short life contemplating forming a grant-making es. However, the precise nature of the span. Sponsors often serve as incuba- private foundation may find a donor- relationship, the support provided by tors of Projects that later spin off upon advised fund to be a better alternative. the Sponsor, and the rights of the Proj- a determination by their respective Founders of private foundations will ect’s initiators (the Project Initiators) Project Initiators that they can govern face slightly different challenges from may vary widely depending on the agreement between the parties. A well- drafted fiscal sponsorship agreement is Additional Resources therefore imperative. Fiscal Sponsorship Perhaps the most common model of • www.fiscalsponsorship.com (San Francisco Study Center) fiscal sponsorship is one in which the • http://foundationcenter.org/getstarted/tutorials/fiscal (Guide to Fiscal Project is housed within the Sponsor, Sponsorship) has no separate legal existence, and is operated by the Sponsor’s employees and/or volunteers. Greg Colvin, author Donor-Advised Funds of Fiscal Sponsorship: 6 Ways to Do It • www.guidestar.org/DisplayArticle.do?articleId=1092 (New Rules Affecting Right, describes this model as the Direct Donor-Advised Funds) Project Model. Contributors to the • www.bostonfoundation.org/Giving/GivingDetail.aspx?id=194 (Donor- Project make their gifts directly to the Advised Fund/Private Foundation Comparison) Sponsor. The Sponsor usually retains a portion of the gifts as a fee (5–10 percent is common) and allocates the and operate sustainable independent founders of public charities. Funding rest to the Project. The Project Initia- organizations. Lawyers providing coun- may not be a critical issue, but direc- tors may serve as employees or volun- sel to would-be founders of nonprof- tors, trustees, and managers must deal teers of the Sponsor delegated with the its who appear inadequately prepared with additional laws and limitations responsibility of operating the Project. to set up a sustainable organization associated with private foundations. They also may retain the right to move should inform their clients of the fiscal For example, private foundations must the Project to another Sponsor or to sponsorship alternative. (1) pay a 2 percent tax on their net a new exempt organization created to Project Initiators that are consider- investment income; (2) refrain from permanently house the Project. Any ing fiscal sponsorship should be very acts of self-dealing; (3) meet minimum such rights should be precisely spelled selective in choosing a Sponsor. Spon- distribution requirements (generally out in the fiscal sponsorship agreement. sors differ widely with respect to 5 percent of their investment assets); Fiscal sponsorship may provide a charitable mission, services, manage- (4) abstain from excess business with- Project with immediate tax-exempt sta- ment oversight, fees, experience, legal holdings; (5) abstain from jeopardiz- tus, advantageous treatment as a pub- sophistication, and their own viabili- ing investments; and (6) refrain from lic charity (i.e., nonprivate foundation) ty. Nonprofit support centers, commu- certain types of expenditures, such as without independently passing a public nity foundations, and the online Fiscal those paid or incurred to lobby, make support test, some degree of adminis- Sponsor Directory produced by the grants to individuals that do not sat- trative support, and a governing body San Francisco Study Center (www. isfy certain criteria, or make grants to that has a duty to ensure that the Proj- fiscalsponsordirectory.org) may be help- nonpublic charities other than oper- ect is operating in compliance with ful resources for finding a qualified ating foundations without exercising applicable laws. The Project Initiators Sponsor. expenditure responsibility. Moreover, Published in Business Law Today, Volume 18, Number 6, July/August 2009. © 2009 by the American Bar Association. Reproduced with permission. All rights reserved. 3 This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.
4.
A Fourth Alternative?
exempt purposes and in compliance with the law. Sponsoring organizations Lawyers may determine for certain clients that the laws applicable to non- that regularly disregard their donors’ profits and tax-exempt entities are not compatible with the client’s plans. wishes will soon lose goodwill in their For example, the client may be seeking to secure investment capital or communities and may no longer be earned income from substantial unrelated business activities. Or the cli- competitive as sponsors of donor- ent may want rights and control more consistent with that of an owner advised funds. of a for-profit corporation than a director or officer of a nonprofit. In such Lawyers asked to form private foun- cases, a for-profit corporation or limited liability company may be a more dations should generally ensure that appropriate vehicle for the client. If the client desires to form an entity their clients are aware of, and educated that pursues social goals over maximization of its owners’ return on their about, the donor-advised fund alter- investments, the new low-profit limited liability company (L3C) may be a native, particularly where the initial viable alternative. funding is modest. One rule of thumb states that private foundations should the charitable deduction limits for con- with a financial institution like Fidel- not be formed without funding of at tributions to a private foundation are ity, Vanguard, or Schwab. Community least $2 million. However, this recom- lower than those for comparable con- foundations offer valuable philanthrop- mendation presumes that such amount tributions to a public charity (e.g., the ic guidance to donors and opportuni- will be a one-time contribution to an charitable deduction for a contribu- ties to participate in community lead- endowment. It does not recognize the tion of money to a private foundation ership initiatives and events. Financial plan of some clients to make regular is generally limited to 30 percent of the institutions may offer lower administra- contributions to the foundation or to donor’s adjusted gross income versus tive fees and costs. give the foundation a limited life span. 50 percent for a contribution of money Perhaps the most important limi- The better rule of thumb is that a pri- to a public charity). tation of a donor-advised fund is the vate foundation should not be formed The many benefits for the donor of a donor’s lack of legal control after mak- without a strong likelihood that it will donor-advised fund include ing the contribution. Because the con- distribute at least $25,000 in annual • No formation costs. tribution is considered a completed gift grants. Anything less may result in • Possibility of making immediate at the time of contribution, the donor inefficient grant-making in light of the deductible contributions. may be able to take a charitable deduc- costs associated with operating the • More generous deduction limits tion in the year that the gift is made. foundation. (because the sponsoring organization is However, the trade-off is that the donor a public charity). may only provide recommendations Conclusion • No administrative, investment, or or advice to the sponsoring organiza- Well-intentioned individuals form governance responsibilities (and associ- tion about potential recipients of grants too many unsustainable and ineffi- ated risks). from the donor-advised fund. While cient nonprofit organizations because • No need to provide oversight over the donor may not have legal control of insufficient research or planning. grants. over the fund, it is easy to understand Before routinely facilitating the for- Additional benefits of a donor- why sponsoring organizations gener- mation of a nonprofit, in many cases, advised fund may depend on the ally make a strong attempt to adhere lawyers may best serve their clients by nature of the sponsoring organization, to their donors’ recommendations so advising them of possible alternatives. which is typically either a community long as such grants would be consis- foundation or a public charity affiliated tent with the sponsoring organization’s Published in Business Law Today, Volume 18, Number 6, July/August 2009. © 2009 by the American Bar Association. Reproduced with permission. All rights reserved. 4 This information or any portion thereof may not be copied or disseminated in any form or by any means or stored in an electronic database or retrieval system without the express written consent of the American Bar Association.
Descargar ahora