SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 14
Descargar para leer sin conexión
“Very useful.”                                       “Wonderful.”
  —Murat Ozbaydar, Portfolio Manager,               —Tom Gayner, Chief Investment Officer,
          Soros Fund Management                               Markel Corporation



                       “The best institutional-quality equity research.“
             —Pavel Savor, Assistant Professor of Finance, The Wharton School

                                “An extremely valuable resource.”
                     —Guy Spier, CEO, Aquamarine Capital Management




                                Value-oriented Equity
                                 Investment Ideas for
                                Sophisticated Investors



“There is nothing else like it on the market.”     “Tremendous effort and well put together.”
     —Jake Rosser, Managing Partner,               —Mohnish Pabrai, Founder and Managing
         Coho Capital Management                       Partner, Pabrai Investment Funds


“I highly recommend MOI — the thoroughness of the product coupled with the quality of the
                content makes it an invaluable tool for the serious investor.”
                —Tim Davis, Managing Director, Bluestem Asset Management


                                 “We do similar work ourselves.”
                     —Glenn Greenberg, Founder, Brave Warrior Capital
The
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Good ideas are the lifeblood of
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                the investment business and the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                exclusive focus of The Manual of




Manual
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Ideas. Authored by investment
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                professionals, who have grown up on
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                the teachings of Graham, Buffett and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Greenblatt, and have studied under




of Ideas
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                or worked with luminaries such
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                as Yale Chief Investment Officer
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                David Swensen and Economics
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Nobel Laureate James Tobin, The
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Manual of Ideas delivers timely,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                differentiated investment ideas.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                In a market flooded with data and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                opinion, we deliver clarity.




                             January 2010: Best Ideas for 2010                                                                                                                     February 2010: The Superinvestor Issue                                                                                                                           March 2010: The Brand Value Issue
BUSINESS OVERVIEW                                                                SELECTED OPERATING DATA 1
                                                                                                                                                           YTD
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Selected Brand Value Rankings
BreitBurn owns oil and natural gas reserves in the U.S.
                                                                                      FYE December 31                      2006         2007    2008    9/30/09
BreitBurn was formed as a master limited partnership (MLP)                            � revenue 2                            n/m       -44%    970%       -54%                                                           Exclusive Interview with Aaron Edelheit                                                             Top 100 by Interbrand                                                                                   explanation of brand valuation methodology: http://bit.ly/99Jm6c
and went public in 2006. The majority of current reserves                             � production                           n/m        84%    126%        -5%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Interbrand           Brand Finance          Brand                Ticker                 Country              Sector                   Interbrand       Brand Finance
were acquired from Quicksilver Resources (KWK) in 2007.                               � realized price 3                     n/m         1%      7%       -13%
                                                                                                                             n/m       351%    -25%         n/a                                                                                                                                                                Current Year           Current Year                                                       of Origin                                    Brand Value        Brand Value
                                                                                      � proved developed reserves
                                                                                      � proved reserves                      n/m       363%    -27%         n/a                                                          We recently had the pleasure of interviewing Aaron                                                     Rank      Ago          Rank     Ago                                                                                                  ($bn) y-y �        ($bn)    y-y �
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS
                                                                                      Proved developed reserves (period-end):                                                                                            Edelheit of Sabre Value Asset Management, a value-                                                          1       1              3     2          Coca-Cola            KO                     United States        Beverages                 69      3%         35      6%
        �      Onshore U.S.-based oil and natural gas producer                        Natural gas (Bcf)                          4       457      434       n/a                                                                                                                                                                      2       2              4     3          IBM                  IBM                    United States        Computer Services         60      2%         34      7%
               with a total of 102 million boe * of proved reserves                   Oil/liquids (Mbbls)                27,786       52,103   23,346       n/a                                                          oriented investment firm founded in 1998. The firm
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3       3              5     4          Microsoft            MSFT                   United States        Computer Software         57     -4%         34      9%
               at year-end 2008. ** Natural gas represents 75% of                       Total (Mboe)`                    28,484      128,344   95,643       n/a                                                          manages the Sabre Value Fund and two distressed real
                                                                                      After-tax NPV @ 10% ($mn) 4            312       1,912      592       n/a                                                                                                                                                                      4       4              6     6          GE                   GE                     United States        Diversified               48 -10%            32     20%
               proved reserves, which are mainly located in                                                                                                                                                              estate funds. Edelheit graduated with a B.B.A. in
                                                                                      Selected average production data:                                                                                                                                                                                                              5       5             21    13          Nokia                NOK                    Finland              Consumer Electronics      35     -3%         20     -2%
               Michigan’s Antrim Shale (70% of proved reserves).                      Natural gas (MMcf)                     273       4,134   22,384   15,826                                                           finance from the University of Georgia in 1996. He is a                                                     6       8             18    12          McDonald's           MCD                    United States        Restaurants               32      4%         20      1%
        �      15+ years of reserve life based on proved reserves                     Oil/liquids (Mboe)                  1,595        2,330    3,078    2,247                                                           philanthropist and serves on the board of directors of                                                      7      10              2     5          Google               GOOG                   United States        Internet Services         32     25%         36     24%
               at yearend 2008 and 2008 production level. 92% of                        Total (Mboe)                      1,640        3,019    6,809    4,885
                                                                                      Realized average sales prices ($ per ...): 3                                                                                       the Moishe House Foundation. Edelheit maintains an                                                          8       6             10    10          Toyota               TM                     Japan                Automotive                31     -8%         27     24%
               reserves are developed, meaning reserves can be                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       9       7             28    25          Intel                INTC                   United States        Computer Hardware         31     -2%         17     19%
                                                                                      Natural gas (…Mcf)                    4.90        7.36     8.24     7.45                                                           online blog at aaronedelheit.com, which we have found      Aaron Edelheit
               recovered from existing wells with minor capex.                        Oil/liquids (…boe)                  55.98        58.93    71.51    65.08                                                                                                                      Sabre Value                                     10       9             19    18          Disney               DIS                    United States        Media                     28     -3%         20     20%
        �      Hedges provide cash flow visibility through 2013.                        Total (...boe)                    55.24        55.69    59.49    53.96                                                           educational and thought-provoking. Since June 1998,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    11      12              9     9          HP                   HPQ                    United States        Computer Hardware         24      2%         27     15%
               89% and 85% of expected oil and gas production in                      Selected expenses ($ per boe):                                                                                                     Edelheit has reported a compounded annual net return in excess of 12%.
                                                                                      Lease operating 5                   17.66        19.60    20.55    20.16                                                                                                                                                                      12      11             39    52          Mercedes-Benz        DAI                    Germany              Automotive                24     -7%         14     41%
               2010 is hedged at average prices of $81/bbl and                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      13      14           117     94          Gillette             PG                     United States        Personal Care             23      4%          7      4%
                                                                                      DD&A                                  5.19        9.75    26.42    16.66
               $8/Mcf, respectively. Similar prices are hedged on                     Revenue ($mn) 2                        133          75     802      167                                                                                                                                                                       14      17             60    42          Cisco                CSCO                   United States        Computer Services         22      3%         11      6%
               volumes representing roughly 75%, 65% and 50%                          Selected items as % of revenue:                                                                                                    The Manual of Ideas: Value investors come in many different stripes. How                                   15      13             29    26          BMW                  Frankfurt: BMW         Germany              Automotive                22     -7%         17     22%
               of production in 2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively.                    EBIT                                  38%        -74%      54%      -29%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         does your approach differ from some other value-oriented strategies?
                                                                                      Net income                              1%       -80%      47%      -41%                                                                                                                                                                      16      16           270    210          Louis Vuitton        LVMUY                  France               Luxury                    21     -2%          3      5%
        �      ~ 20% FCF yield on equity based on $168 million                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      17      18           149    128          Marlboro             PM                     United States        Tobacco                   19 -11%             6      7%
                                                                                      DD&A                                  10%         39%      22%       49%
               of net cash from operations (annualized from 3Q09)                     Capex                                 29%         31%      16%       11%                                                           Aaron Edelheit: I focus on small to medium sized companies that most                                       18      20             46    35          Honda                HMC                    Japan                Automotive                18     -7%         13     14%
               and $32 million of maintenance capex. Given                            Net cash from operations ($mn)           46         60      227       184     “I’m looking for spin-offs,                          investors have never heard of. My goal is to find companies that are very                                  19      21             23    28          Samsung              London: SMSN           Republic of Korea    Consumer Electronics      18     -1%         19     40%
               existing hedges, relative stability of cash generation                 Tangible equity / assets (avg)        77%         73%      66%       59%       companies restructuring,                            attractive, but aren’t being followed closely due to their size, lack of analyst                           20      24             20    27          Apple                AAPL                   United States        Computer Hardware         15     12%         20     45%
               appears reasonable assumption for next four years.                     ���hares out (avg)                     n/m        48%      82%      -16%
                                                                                 1
                                                                                   Where stated, 2006 data refers to owned assets at BreitBurn’s formation.          turnarounds and special                             coverage or neglect. I look for change inside of those companies that investors                            21      22             94   146          H&M                  Stockholm: H&M B       Sweden               Apparel                   15     11%          8     81%
               Management has started hedging into 2014 as well.
                                                                                                                                                                  situations, such as a company                                                                                                                                     22
                                                                                 2
                                                                                   Includes realized and unrealized gains/losses on derivative instruments.                                                              are not seeing and that will make the company much more valuable.                                                  15             50    50          American Express     AXP                    United States        Financial Services        15 -32%            13     28%
        �      Reinstatement of MLP distributions likely with                    3
                                                                                   Includes realized gains/losses on derivative instruments.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    23      26             31    21          Pepsi                PEP                    United States        Beverages                 14      3%         16      6%
               continued FCF generation and reducing debt level.
                                                                                 4
                                                                                   Based on SEC guidelines (from production of proved reserves with period-end     with two divisions, in which                          Specifically, I’m looking for spin-offs, companies restructuring, turnarounds and
                                                                                 prices held constant), and not accounting for hedges. 5 Excludes SG&A.                                                                                                                                                                             24      23             49    39          Oracle               ORCL                   United States        Computer Software         14     -1%         13     15%
               BreitBurn has reduced net debt by $160+ million                                                                                                     the poor division is masking                          special situations, such as a company with two divisions, in which the poor
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    25      28           198     63          Nescafé              NSRGY                  Switzerland          Beverages                 13      2%          4    -52%
               since yearend 2008 to $574 million at 10/31/09, or                                                                                                 the other division that is very                        division is masking the other division that is very attractive. And I take very
                                                                                          �     Borrowing base at discretion of lenders, based on                                                                                                                                                                                   26      29             33    22          Nike                 NKE                    United States        Sporting Goods            13      4%         16      8%
               3.1x the midpoint of 2009 adj. EBITDA guidance.                                  their valuation of reserves and internal criteria. A                       attractive.”                                  concentrated positions, am patient and do not use leverage.                                                27      31           104    102          SAP                  SAP                    Germany              Computer Software         12     -1%          8     24%
        �      Borrowing base confirmed at $732 million in                                      decline in oil prices may reduce borrowing capacity.                                                                                                                                                                                28      35              -      -         IKEA                 Privately held         Sweden               Home Furnishings          12     10%          -         -
               October 2009, with next evaluation in April.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         29      25             52    34          Sony                 SNE                    Japan                Consumer Electronics      12 -12%            13      9%
               BreitBurn’s credit facility, which expires in                     MAJOR HOLDERS                                                                                                                           MOI: You have at times put in writing your thesis on your favorite ideas, both                             30      33             16    19          Budweiser            BUD                    United States        Alcohol                   12      3%         21     27%
               November 2011, is provided by 18 banks.                           Insiders 1% | Quicksilver Resources 40% | Baupost 16%                                                                                                                                                                                              31      30             44    32          UPS                  UPS                    United States        Transportation            12     -8%         13     11%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         long and short. Let’s take a look at some of what you’ve written and extract
        �      $13 EV to boe of proved reserves. This compares                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      32      27              8     7          HSBC                 HBC                    United Kingdom       Financial Services        11 -20%            28     12%
               to an average realized sales price of $54 per boe and                                                                                                                                                     lessons that may help us become better investors. In April 2009, when Sprott
                                                                                 RATINGS                                                                                                                                 Resource (Toronto: SCP), an investment firm controlled by respected
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    33      36           126    110          Canon                CAJ                    Japan                Computer Hardware         10     -4%          6      8%
               estimated all-in cash costs of $26 per boe in 3Q09.               VALUE Intrinsic value materially higher than market value? �����                                                                                                                                                                                   34      39             98    71          Kellogg's            K                      United States        Food                      10      7%          8      2%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Canadian investor Eric Sprott, traded at C$2.65 per share, you wrote, “What if I                           35      32             75    67          Dell                 DELL                   United States        Computer Hardware         10 -12%            10     19%
                                                                                 MANAGEMENT Capable and properly incentivized?               ���
INVESTMENT RISKS & CONCERNS                                                      FINANCIAL STRENGTH Solid balance sheet?                      ���                                                                        told you there was a company out there that was predominantly sitting in cash,                             36      19             36    54          Citi                 C                      United States        Financial Services        10 -49%            14     46%
        �      Lawsuit by 40% shareholder Quicksilver claims                     MOAT Able to sustain high returns on invested capital?      ����                                                                        gold and silver bullion with no debt, whose tangible book value is                                         37      37             57    69          JP Morgan            JPM                    United States        Financial Services        10 -11%            12     45%
               BreitBurn “made false and misleading statements to                EARNINGS MOMENTUM Fundamentals improving?                   ����                                                                        approximately C$3.50 per share, with little expenses, that was selling for C$2.65                          38      38             38    89          Goldman Sachs        GS                     United States        Financial Services          9 -10%           14 106%
               induce Quicksilver to acquire units” in their 2007                MACRO Poised to benefit from economic and secular trends?   ���                                                                         per share? Better yet, what if I told you that it is run by one of the best resource                       39      40           120     55          Nintendo             NTDOY                  Japan                Consumer Electronics        9     5%          7    -32%
               deal. Quicksilver recently dropped claims against                 EXPLOSIVENESS 5%+ probability of 5x upside in one year?      ���                                                                                                                                                                                   40      44           315    277          Thomson Reuters      TRI                    Canada               Media                       8     1%          3     16%
               individual BreitBurn directors but not the MLP.                                                                                                                                                           investors around, who has a proven record for making investors money and has
                                                                                 **
                                                                                  Reserve total reflects sale of Permian assets. Reserves may be about 140                                                                                                                                                                          41      45              -      -         Gucci                GUCG                   Italy                Luxury                      8    -1%          -         -
*
    Barrels per oil equivalent (six thousand cubic feet to one barrel of oil).   million boe at yearend 2009 based on new SEC average price rules.�                                                                      increased book value from $1.50 to over $3.50 in two years?” Many investors
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    42      43             93   117          Philips              PHG                    Netherlands          Diversified                 8    -2%          8     49%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         reading your argument might have said, “Yes, I see that SCP is undervalued on a                            43      58             42    79          Amazon.com           AMZN                   United States        Internet Services           8    22%         13     79%
THE BOTTOM LINE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         sum-of-the-parts basis, but what is the catalyst to unlocking value? Can’t the
             July 2010: The Downside Protection Issue                                                                                                                                 August 2010: The Superinvestor Issue                                                                                                         September 2010: The European Value Issue
What differentiates BreitBurn from other oil and gas producers is better visibility into future cash generation as a result of the                                                                                                                                                                                                  44      51             32    37          L'Oréal              Paris: OR              France               Personal Care               8     3%         16     41%
company’s commodity price hedging program. As the hedges are struck at attractive prices, BreitBurn should be able to                                                                                                    discount persist indefinitely?” Eight months later, SCP traded at more than C$4                            45      47           154    135          Accenture            ACN                    United States        Computer Services           8    -3%          6     11%
generate about $135 million of annual FCF through 2013/14. That amounts to close to 100% of market value over five years.                                                                                                per share, with additional upside looking likely due to value creation in the                              46      46           166    171          eBay                 EBAY                   United States        Internet Services           7    -8%          5     28%
At a minimum, the capacity to quickly de-lever significantly removes downside risk, while increasing the likelihood of a                                                                                                 interim. When dealing with investment vehicles such as SCP, how do you                                     47      48             35    66          Siemens              SI                     Germany              Diversified                 7    -8%         15     79%
reinstatement of distributions, which traditionally represent one of the core benefits of the tax-efficient MLP structure. It                                                                                            decide what discount to net asset value is sufficiently compelling, and how do                             48      56              -      -         Heinz                HNZ                    United States        Food                        7     9%          -         -
appears unlikely that litigation will lead to any materialitvalue transfer fromour Top 5 investment to 40% shareholder several
                                                          We found difficult to select smaller shareholders ideas this month, as                                                                                         you avoid the entitiesTop investorsat wide discounts to NAV for a long time?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                that do trade included in this section:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Top 5 European Investment Ideas
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    49      49             51    53          Ford                 F                      United States        Automotive                  7 -11%           13     29%
                                                     other companies in this report offer very interesting risk-reward tradeoffs. We have
Quicksilver. In fact, all shareholders may benefit from closer scrutiny of management to ensure intrinsic value is realized.                                        50+ Portfolios With Signal Value™                                                                                                                               50      62
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Lavendon (London: LVD)        212       -         Zara                 Madrid: ITX            Spain                Apparel                     7    14%          4         -
                                                     slotted those companies into our “Next 5 ideas with strong downside protection.”                               Revealing the Top Ideas of Top Investors                                       �     Bill Ackman, Pershing Square
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Rental Equipment                                                                         Leicestershire, UK, 44-1455558874                        www.lavendongroup.com
                                                     They are EchoStar (SATS; $19.50; MV $1.7 billion), Gravity (GRVY; $1.55; MV                                                                                                                   �     Lee Ainsle, Maverick                                                © 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved.                       www.manualofideas.com                                               March 25, 2010 – Page 84 of 116
© 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved.                www.manualofideas.com                              January 21, 2010 – Page 9 of 124           © 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved.           www.manualofideas.com
                                                     $43 million), Harvest Natural Resources (HNR; $8.45; MV $280 million), Penn                                                                                                                   �     Chuck Akre, Akre Capital February 18, 2010 – Page 28 of 144                     Trading Data                                               Consensus EPS Estimates                                                Valuation
                                                                                                                                                                    “Signal value” as opposed to “noise.” We present the                           �     Zeke Ashton, Centaur Capital                                          Price: £0.52 (as of 9/24/10)                                                                   Month           # of         P/E FYE 12/31/09                   n/a
                                                     Millers (PMIC; $12.10; MV $57 million), and Seahawk Drilling (HAWK; $10; MV
                                                     $118 million). Set-top box and satellite company EchoStar trades at a material                                 holdings of some of the world’s top investors. We look for                     �     Brian Bares, Bares Capital                                            52-week range: £0.43 - £1.86                                                     Latest         Ago            Ests         P/E FYE 12/31/10                   n/a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Bruce Berkowitz, Fairholme                                            Market value: £86.7 million                           This quarter                  n/a          n/a           n/a          P/E FYE 12/31/11                   n/a
                                                     discount to tangible book value, with well over one-half of market value in net cash                           investors who have amassed impressive track records over                                                                                                   Enterprise value: £254.4 billion                      Next quarter                  n/a          n/a           n/a          P/E FYE 12/31/12                   n/a
                                                     and investments; it has improving business performance and is run by one of the                                                                                                               �     Richard Breeden, Breeden Capital
                                                                                                                                                                    long periods of time. We choose these investors carefully                                                                                                  Shares out: 164.4 million                             FYE 12/31/10                  n/a          n/a           n/a          EV/ LTM revenue                    1.2x
                                                     most accomplished entrepreneurs in the industry, Charlie Ergen, who owns one-half                                                                                                             �     Tom Brown, Second Curve
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Ownership Data                              FYE 12/31/11                  n/a           n/a           n/a         EV/ LTM EBIT                        21x
                                                     of the equity. Korean Internet gaming company Gravity trades for less than net cash,                           to avoid the noise inherent in most 13F-HR filings.                            �     Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Insider ownership: <1%                                FYE 12/30/12                  n/a           n/a           n/a         P / tangible book                  1.0x
                                                     is profitable and cash generative and should release a long-awaited new game within                                                                                                           �     Francis Chou, Chou Associates
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Insider buys (last six months): >1                    LT growth                     n/a           n/a           n/a                   Greenblatt Criteria
                                                     the next six to twelve months. Oil and gas firm Harvest trades at a lowly price based                                 MOI Signal Rank answers the question, “What are                         �     Chase Coleman, Tiger Global
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Insider sales (last six months): 0                    EPS Surprise             Actual                 Estimate              LTM EBIT yield                      5%
                                                                                                    on proved reserves in Venezuela, a                                                                                                             �     James Crichton, Scout
                                                                                                                                                                    this investor’s top ten ideas right now?” Rather than                                                                                                      Institutional ownership: n/a                               n/a                  n/a                     n/a                 LTM pre-tax ROC                     4%
                                                                                                    country that strikes fear into investors                                                                                                       �     Ian Cumming and Joe Steinberg, Leucadia
                                                                                                                                                                    simply presenting each investor’s largest holdings as of the                   �     Boykin Curry, Eagle                                                                                                             Operating Performance and Financial Position
                                                                                                    but appears unlikely to stand in the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     David Einhorn, Greenlight                                          (£ millions, except                                                  Fiscal Years Ended                                              LTME             6ME               6ME
                                                                                                    way of value creation for Harvest                               recently filed quarter end, the MOI’s proprietary                                                                                                       per share data)                        12/31/04          12/31/05     12/31/06     12/31/07         12/31/08        12/31/09        6/30/10        6/30/09           6/30/10
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Phil Falcone, Harbinger
                                                                                                    shareholders. Penn Millers is a leader                          methodology ranks the companies in each investor’s                                                                                                      Revenue                                     108               100           125         186              260             227           219             114               106
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Alan Fournier, Pennant
                                                                                                    in the attractive agribusiness insurance                                                                                                                                                                                Gross profit                                 36                41            55          87              110              87             80             43                36
                                                                                                                                                                    portfolio based on the investor’s current level of conviction                  �     Glenn Fuhrman and John Phelan, MSD Capital
                                                                                                    niche, yet trades at a material discount                                                                                                                                                                                Operating income                             (9)                7            13          26               39            (25)             12           (31)                  6
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Jeffrey Gates, Gates Capital
                                                                                                    to tangible book value, owing to an                             in each holding, as judged by the MOI.                                                                                                                  Net income                                 (13)                 1              7         15               17            (43)             (7)          (37)                (0)
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Tom Gayner, Markel Gayner                                          Diluted EPS                                 n/m              0.02          0.18        0.42             0.35             n/m           n/m             n/m               n/m
                                                                                                    ownership change quirk typical in                                                                                                              �     Kian Ghazi, Hawkshaw
                                                                                                    demutualizations. Gulf of Mexico                                       Our proprietary methodology takes into account a                                                                                                 Shares out (avg)                             37                37            38          42               46              56           105              47               164
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Ed Gilhuly and Scott Stuart, Sageview                              Cash from ops                                24                25            30          49               54              56             49             20                13
                                                                                                    jackup driller Seahawk has seen                                 number of variables, including the size of a position in an                    �     Glenn Greenberg, Brave Warrior                                     Capex                                          2                8            36          50               59              13             16              5                  8
                                                                                                    demand for its drilling platforms                                                                                                              �     John Griffin, Blue Ridge
                                                                                                                                                                    investor’s portfolio, the size of a position relative to the                                                                                            Free cash flow                               22                17            (6)         (1)              (5)             43             33             15                  5
                                                                                                    decline along with natural gas prices,                                                                                                         �     Howard Guberman, Gruss                                             Cash & investments                             8                8            10          17               15              76               6            10                  6
                                                                                                    but the shares have slumped to a level                          market value of the corresponding company, the most recent                     �     Andreas Halvorsen, Viking Global                                   Total current assets                         34                32            44          69               80             135             68             72                68
                                                                                                    that might be below the price                                   quarterly change in the number of shares owned, and the                        �     Mason Hawkins, Southeastern                                        Intangible assets                              1                1              3         10               15               7               6             9                  6
                                                                                                    shareholders could realize in a                                                                                                                �     Lance Helfert and Paul Orfalea, West Coast                         Total assets                                202               177           268         426              571             514           414             466               414
                                                                                                    liquidation that would see the rigs sold                        change in the stock price of a position since the most recent                  �     Chris Hohn, Children’s Investment Fund                             Short-term debt                              16                14            25          41               55              44             46             52                46
                                                                                                    for scrap steel.                                                quarterly filing date.                                                         �     Carl Icahn, Icahn                                                  Current liabilities                          33                32            67         119              116              98             89             99                89
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Long-term debt                               81                56            84         161              265             214           127             231               127
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Rehan Jaffer, H Partners
                                                                                                           Finally, we are happy to bring                                  For example, an investor might have the most                                                                                                     Total liabilities                           127                99           174         306              423             340           244             360               244
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Seth Klarman, Baupost
                                                                                                      you an exclusive interview with top-                                                                                                                                                                                  Common equity                                75                78            94         119              148             174           170             105               170
                                                                                                                                                                    conviction in a position that is only the tenth-largest                        �     John Kleinheinz, Kleinheinz Capital
                                                                                                      performing small cap value fund                                                                                                              �     Eddie Lampert, ESL Investments                                                                                     Ten-Year Stock Price Performance and Trading Volume Dynamics
                                                                                                      manager Scott Barbee of the Aegis                             position in such investor’s portfolio. This might be the                       �     Dan Loeb, Third Point                                                 800p
                                                                                                      Value Fund (AVALX), a mutual fund                                                                                                            �     Steve Mandel, Lone Pine
                                                                                                                                                                    case if an investor invests in a small company, resulting in
                                                                                                      that has handily outperformed the                                                                                                            �     Sandy Nairn, Edinburgh Partners                                       700p
                                                         Russell 2000 Value Index since the fund’s inception in 1998. Scott has been through                        a holding that is simply too small to rank highly based on
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Mohnish Pabrai, Pabrai Funds
                                                         two very tough periods for value investors while at the helm of Aegis — the tech                           size alone. On the other hand, such a holding might                            �     John Paulson, Paulson & Co.                                           600p
                                                         stock “melt-up” in 1998-2000 and the market collapse of late 2008 and early 2009.                                                                                                         �     Boone Pickens, BP Capital
                                                                                                                                                                    represent 19.9% of the shares outstanding of the subject                                                                                                   500p
                                                         His insights into surviving and thriving as a Graham-and-Dodd-style investor are                                                                                                          �     Mark Rachesky, MHR
                                                         perhaps not so much unique as they are a reminder that investors do better when they                       company, suggesting a high level of conviction. Our                            �     Lisa Rapuano, Lane Five
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               400p
                                                         refuse to be swayed by the prevailing market psychology and instead follow their                           estimate of the conviction level would rise further if the                     �     Larry Robbins, Glenview
                                                         own path with discipline and conviction.                                                                                                                                                  �     Bob Rodriguez and Steven Romick, First Pacific                        300p
                                                                                                                                                                    subject company has a 20% poison-pill threshold, thereby                       �     Wilbur Ross, WL Ross
                                                                                                          Sincerely,
                                                                                                                                                                    suggesting that the investor has bought as much of the                         �     Chris Shumway, Shumway Capital                                        200p
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     David Tepper, Appaloosa
                                                                                                                                                                    subject company as is practically feasible.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     Peter Thiel, Clarium                                                  100p
                                                                                                          John Mihaljevic, CFA                                                                                                                     �     Prem Watsa, Fairfax
                                                                                                          and The Manual of Ideas research team                                                                                                    �     Wally Weitz, Weitz Funds                                                 0p
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   �     David Winters, Wintergreen                                                                                                   Sep 03        Sep 04         Sep 05         Sep 06         Sep 07       Sep 08         Sep 09          Sep 10
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas
Overview - The Manual of Ideas

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Dificil convivencia
Dificil convivenciaDificil convivencia
Dificil convivenciaFer Nanda
 
关于职业发展的一点思考
关于职业发展的一点思考关于职业发展的一点思考
关于职业发展的一点思考kevin_ke
 
Overview of the HR Consulting Industry
Overview of the HR Consulting IndustryOverview of the HR Consulting Industry
Overview of the HR Consulting Industryjennyray
 
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 ready
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 readyจงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 ready
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 readypannily
 
Rich poor
Rich poorRich poor
Rich poorsubbu p
 
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slot
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slotScse seating arrangement_d1_slot
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slotSathyaraj Ragupathi
 
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post Blackness
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post BlacknessPreview: Who's Afraid of Post Blackness
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post BlacknessMedia Center
 
Sabe pq vc existe
Sabe pq vc existeSabe pq vc existe
Sabe pq vc existeFer Nanda
 
Aprender a fracassar
Aprender a fracassarAprender a fracassar
Aprender a fracassarFer Nanda
 
Persistencia
PersistenciaPersistencia
PersistenciaFer Nanda
 
A melhor saida
A melhor saidaA melhor saida
A melhor saidaFer Nanda
 
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...Fabrice Leclerc
 
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social media
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social mediaOuderavond mediawijsheid en social media
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social media21stcenturyskillsNL
 

Destacado (17)

Aprendi
AprendiAprendi
Aprendi
 
Quem sou eu
Quem sou euQuem sou eu
Quem sou eu
 
Dificil convivencia
Dificil convivenciaDificil convivencia
Dificil convivencia
 
关于职业发展的一点思考
关于职业发展的一点思考关于职业发展的一点思考
关于职业发展的一点思考
 
Overview of the HR Consulting Industry
Overview of the HR Consulting IndustryOverview of the HR Consulting Industry
Overview of the HR Consulting Industry
 
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 ready
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 readyจงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 ready
จงขอบคุณพระเจ้าตลอดเวลา 11.7.10 ready
 
Rich poor
Rich poorRich poor
Rich poor
 
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slot
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slotScse seating arrangement_d1_slot
Scse seating arrangement_d1_slot
 
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post Blackness
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post BlacknessPreview: Who's Afraid of Post Blackness
Preview: Who's Afraid of Post Blackness
 
Sabe pq vc existe
Sabe pq vc existeSabe pq vc existe
Sabe pq vc existe
 
Aprender a fracassar
Aprender a fracassarAprender a fracassar
Aprender a fracassar
 
Persistencia
PersistenciaPersistencia
Persistencia
 
A melhor saida
A melhor saidaA melhor saida
A melhor saida
 
SCSE_A1_slot_display_19-08-2012
SCSE_A1_slot_display_19-08-2012SCSE_A1_slot_display_19-08-2012
SCSE_A1_slot_display_19-08-2012
 
C2 scse 03-apr-13
C2 scse 03-apr-13C2 scse 03-apr-13
C2 scse 03-apr-13
 
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...
Computational Enzymology of Ribozymes (from metal-ion to nucleobase catalysis...
 
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social media
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social mediaOuderavond mediawijsheid en social media
Ouderavond mediawijsheid en social media
 

Overview - The Manual of Ideas

  • 1. “Very useful.” “Wonderful.” —Murat Ozbaydar, Portfolio Manager, —Tom Gayner, Chief Investment Officer, Soros Fund Management Markel Corporation “The best institutional-quality equity research.“ —Pavel Savor, Assistant Professor of Finance, The Wharton School “An extremely valuable resource.” —Guy Spier, CEO, Aquamarine Capital Management Value-oriented Equity Investment Ideas for Sophisticated Investors “There is nothing else like it on the market.” “Tremendous effort and well put together.” —Jake Rosser, Managing Partner, —Mohnish Pabrai, Founder and Managing Coho Capital Management Partner, Pabrai Investment Funds “I highly recommend MOI — the thoroughness of the product coupled with the quality of the content makes it an invaluable tool for the serious investor.” —Tim Davis, Managing Director, Bluestem Asset Management “We do similar work ourselves.” —Glenn Greenberg, Founder, Brave Warrior Capital
  • 2. The Good ideas are the lifeblood of the investment business and the exclusive focus of The Manual of Manual Ideas. Authored by investment professionals, who have grown up on the teachings of Graham, Buffett and Greenblatt, and have studied under of Ideas or worked with luminaries such as Yale Chief Investment Officer David Swensen and Economics Nobel Laureate James Tobin, The Manual of Ideas delivers timely, differentiated investment ideas. In a market flooded with data and opinion, we deliver clarity. January 2010: Best Ideas for 2010 February 2010: The Superinvestor Issue March 2010: The Brand Value Issue BUSINESS OVERVIEW SELECTED OPERATING DATA 1 YTD Selected Brand Value Rankings BreitBurn owns oil and natural gas reserves in the U.S. FYE December 31 2006 2007 2008 9/30/09 BreitBurn was formed as a master limited partnership (MLP) � revenue 2 n/m -44% 970% -54% Exclusive Interview with Aaron Edelheit Top 100 by Interbrand explanation of brand valuation methodology: http://bit.ly/99Jm6c and went public in 2006. The majority of current reserves � production n/m 84% 126% -5% Interbrand Brand Finance Brand Ticker Country Sector Interbrand Brand Finance were acquired from Quicksilver Resources (KWK) in 2007. � realized price 3 n/m 1% 7% -13% n/m 351% -25% n/a Current Year Current Year of Origin Brand Value Brand Value � proved developed reserves � proved reserves n/m 363% -27% n/a We recently had the pleasure of interviewing Aaron Rank Ago Rank Ago ($bn) y-y � ($bn) y-y � INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Proved developed reserves (period-end): Edelheit of Sabre Value Asset Management, a value- 1 1 3 2 Coca-Cola KO United States Beverages 69 3% 35 6% � Onshore U.S.-based oil and natural gas producer Natural gas (Bcf) 4 457 434 n/a 2 2 4 3 IBM IBM United States Computer Services 60 2% 34 7% with a total of 102 million boe * of proved reserves Oil/liquids (Mbbls) 27,786 52,103 23,346 n/a oriented investment firm founded in 1998. The firm 3 3 5 4 Microsoft MSFT United States Computer Software 57 -4% 34 9% at year-end 2008. ** Natural gas represents 75% of Total (Mboe)` 28,484 128,344 95,643 n/a manages the Sabre Value Fund and two distressed real After-tax NPV @ 10% ($mn) 4 312 1,912 592 n/a 4 4 6 6 GE GE United States Diversified 48 -10% 32 20% proved reserves, which are mainly located in estate funds. Edelheit graduated with a B.B.A. in Selected average production data: 5 5 21 13 Nokia NOK Finland Consumer Electronics 35 -3% 20 -2% Michigan’s Antrim Shale (70% of proved reserves). Natural gas (MMcf) 273 4,134 22,384 15,826 finance from the University of Georgia in 1996. He is a 6 8 18 12 McDonald's MCD United States Restaurants 32 4% 20 1% � 15+ years of reserve life based on proved reserves Oil/liquids (Mboe) 1,595 2,330 3,078 2,247 philanthropist and serves on the board of directors of 7 10 2 5 Google GOOG United States Internet Services 32 25% 36 24% at yearend 2008 and 2008 production level. 92% of Total (Mboe) 1,640 3,019 6,809 4,885 Realized average sales prices ($ per ...): 3 the Moishe House Foundation. Edelheit maintains an 8 6 10 10 Toyota TM Japan Automotive 31 -8% 27 24% reserves are developed, meaning reserves can be 9 7 28 25 Intel INTC United States Computer Hardware 31 -2% 17 19% Natural gas (…Mcf) 4.90 7.36 8.24 7.45 online blog at aaronedelheit.com, which we have found Aaron Edelheit recovered from existing wells with minor capex. Oil/liquids (…boe) 55.98 58.93 71.51 65.08 Sabre Value 10 9 19 18 Disney DIS United States Media 28 -3% 20 20% � Hedges provide cash flow visibility through 2013. Total (...boe) 55.24 55.69 59.49 53.96 educational and thought-provoking. Since June 1998, 11 12 9 9 HP HPQ United States Computer Hardware 24 2% 27 15% 89% and 85% of expected oil and gas production in Selected expenses ($ per boe): Edelheit has reported a compounded annual net return in excess of 12%. Lease operating 5 17.66 19.60 20.55 20.16 12 11 39 52 Mercedes-Benz DAI Germany Automotive 24 -7% 14 41% 2010 is hedged at average prices of $81/bbl and 13 14 117 94 Gillette PG United States Personal Care 23 4% 7 4% DD&A 5.19 9.75 26.42 16.66 $8/Mcf, respectively. Similar prices are hedged on Revenue ($mn) 2 133 75 802 167 14 17 60 42 Cisco CSCO United States Computer Services 22 3% 11 6% volumes representing roughly 75%, 65% and 50% Selected items as % of revenue: The Manual of Ideas: Value investors come in many different stripes. How 15 13 29 26 BMW Frankfurt: BMW Germany Automotive 22 -7% 17 22% of production in 2011, 2012 and 2013, respectively. EBIT 38% -74% 54% -29% does your approach differ from some other value-oriented strategies? Net income 1% -80% 47% -41% 16 16 270 210 Louis Vuitton LVMUY France Luxury 21 -2% 3 5% � ~ 20% FCF yield on equity based on $168 million 17 18 149 128 Marlboro PM United States Tobacco 19 -11% 6 7% DD&A 10% 39% 22% 49% of net cash from operations (annualized from 3Q09) Capex 29% 31% 16% 11% Aaron Edelheit: I focus on small to medium sized companies that most 18 20 46 35 Honda HMC Japan Automotive 18 -7% 13 14% and $32 million of maintenance capex. Given Net cash from operations ($mn) 46 60 227 184 “I’m looking for spin-offs, investors have never heard of. My goal is to find companies that are very 19 21 23 28 Samsung London: SMSN Republic of Korea Consumer Electronics 18 -1% 19 40% existing hedges, relative stability of cash generation Tangible equity / assets (avg) 77% 73% 66% 59% companies restructuring, attractive, but aren’t being followed closely due to their size, lack of analyst 20 24 20 27 Apple AAPL United States Computer Hardware 15 12% 20 45% appears reasonable assumption for next four years. ���hares out (avg) n/m 48% 82% -16% 1 Where stated, 2006 data refers to owned assets at BreitBurn’s formation. turnarounds and special coverage or neglect. I look for change inside of those companies that investors 21 22 94 146 H&M Stockholm: H&M B Sweden Apparel 15 11% 8 81% Management has started hedging into 2014 as well. situations, such as a company 22 2 Includes realized and unrealized gains/losses on derivative instruments. are not seeing and that will make the company much more valuable. 15 50 50 American Express AXP United States Financial Services 15 -32% 13 28% � Reinstatement of MLP distributions likely with 3 Includes realized gains/losses on derivative instruments. 23 26 31 21 Pepsi PEP United States Beverages 14 3% 16 6% continued FCF generation and reducing debt level. 4 Based on SEC guidelines (from production of proved reserves with period-end with two divisions, in which Specifically, I’m looking for spin-offs, companies restructuring, turnarounds and prices held constant), and not accounting for hedges. 5 Excludes SG&A. 24 23 49 39 Oracle ORCL United States Computer Software 14 -1% 13 15% BreitBurn has reduced net debt by $160+ million the poor division is masking special situations, such as a company with two divisions, in which the poor 25 28 198 63 Nescafé NSRGY Switzerland Beverages 13 2% 4 -52% since yearend 2008 to $574 million at 10/31/09, or the other division that is very division is masking the other division that is very attractive. And I take very � Borrowing base at discretion of lenders, based on 26 29 33 22 Nike NKE United States Sporting Goods 13 4% 16 8% 3.1x the midpoint of 2009 adj. EBITDA guidance. their valuation of reserves and internal criteria. A attractive.” concentrated positions, am patient and do not use leverage. 27 31 104 102 SAP SAP Germany Computer Software 12 -1% 8 24% � Borrowing base confirmed at $732 million in decline in oil prices may reduce borrowing capacity. 28 35 - - IKEA Privately held Sweden Home Furnishings 12 10% - - October 2009, with next evaluation in April. 29 25 52 34 Sony SNE Japan Consumer Electronics 12 -12% 13 9% BreitBurn’s credit facility, which expires in MAJOR HOLDERS MOI: You have at times put in writing your thesis on your favorite ideas, both 30 33 16 19 Budweiser BUD United States Alcohol 12 3% 21 27% November 2011, is provided by 18 banks. Insiders 1% | Quicksilver Resources 40% | Baupost 16% 31 30 44 32 UPS UPS United States Transportation 12 -8% 13 11% long and short. Let’s take a look at some of what you’ve written and extract � $13 EV to boe of proved reserves. This compares 32 27 8 7 HSBC HBC United Kingdom Financial Services 11 -20% 28 12% to an average realized sales price of $54 per boe and lessons that may help us become better investors. In April 2009, when Sprott RATINGS Resource (Toronto: SCP), an investment firm controlled by respected 33 36 126 110 Canon CAJ Japan Computer Hardware 10 -4% 6 8% estimated all-in cash costs of $26 per boe in 3Q09. VALUE Intrinsic value materially higher than market value? ����� 34 39 98 71 Kellogg's K United States Food 10 7% 8 2% Canadian investor Eric Sprott, traded at C$2.65 per share, you wrote, “What if I 35 32 75 67 Dell DELL United States Computer Hardware 10 -12% 10 19% MANAGEMENT Capable and properly incentivized? ��� INVESTMENT RISKS & CONCERNS FINANCIAL STRENGTH Solid balance sheet? ��� told you there was a company out there that was predominantly sitting in cash, 36 19 36 54 Citi C United States Financial Services 10 -49% 14 46% � Lawsuit by 40% shareholder Quicksilver claims MOAT Able to sustain high returns on invested capital? ���� gold and silver bullion with no debt, whose tangible book value is 37 37 57 69 JP Morgan JPM United States Financial Services 10 -11% 12 45% BreitBurn “made false and misleading statements to EARNINGS MOMENTUM Fundamentals improving? ���� approximately C$3.50 per share, with little expenses, that was selling for C$2.65 38 38 38 89 Goldman Sachs GS United States Financial Services 9 -10% 14 106% induce Quicksilver to acquire units” in their 2007 MACRO Poised to benefit from economic and secular trends? ��� per share? Better yet, what if I told you that it is run by one of the best resource 39 40 120 55 Nintendo NTDOY Japan Consumer Electronics 9 5% 7 -32% deal. Quicksilver recently dropped claims against EXPLOSIVENESS 5%+ probability of 5x upside in one year? ��� 40 44 315 277 Thomson Reuters TRI Canada Media 8 1% 3 16% individual BreitBurn directors but not the MLP. investors around, who has a proven record for making investors money and has ** Reserve total reflects sale of Permian assets. Reserves may be about 140 41 45 - - Gucci GUCG Italy Luxury 8 -1% - - * Barrels per oil equivalent (six thousand cubic feet to one barrel of oil). million boe at yearend 2009 based on new SEC average price rules.� increased book value from $1.50 to over $3.50 in two years?” Many investors 42 43 93 117 Philips PHG Netherlands Diversified 8 -2% 8 49% reading your argument might have said, “Yes, I see that SCP is undervalued on a 43 58 42 79 Amazon.com AMZN United States Internet Services 8 22% 13 79% THE BOTTOM LINE sum-of-the-parts basis, but what is the catalyst to unlocking value? Can’t the July 2010: The Downside Protection Issue August 2010: The Superinvestor Issue September 2010: The European Value Issue What differentiates BreitBurn from other oil and gas producers is better visibility into future cash generation as a result of the 44 51 32 37 L'Oréal Paris: OR France Personal Care 8 3% 16 41% company’s commodity price hedging program. As the hedges are struck at attractive prices, BreitBurn should be able to discount persist indefinitely?” Eight months later, SCP traded at more than C$4 45 47 154 135 Accenture ACN United States Computer Services 8 -3% 6 11% generate about $135 million of annual FCF through 2013/14. That amounts to close to 100% of market value over five years. per share, with additional upside looking likely due to value creation in the 46 46 166 171 eBay EBAY United States Internet Services 7 -8% 5 28% At a minimum, the capacity to quickly de-lever significantly removes downside risk, while increasing the likelihood of a interim. When dealing with investment vehicles such as SCP, how do you 47 48 35 66 Siemens SI Germany Diversified 7 -8% 15 79% reinstatement of distributions, which traditionally represent one of the core benefits of the tax-efficient MLP structure. It decide what discount to net asset value is sufficiently compelling, and how do 48 56 - - Heinz HNZ United States Food 7 9% - - appears unlikely that litigation will lead to any materialitvalue transfer fromour Top 5 investment to 40% shareholder several We found difficult to select smaller shareholders ideas this month, as you avoid the entitiesTop investorsat wide discounts to NAV for a long time? that do trade included in this section: Top 5 European Investment Ideas 49 49 51 53 Ford F United States Automotive 7 -11% 13 29% other companies in this report offer very interesting risk-reward tradeoffs. We have Quicksilver. In fact, all shareholders may benefit from closer scrutiny of management to ensure intrinsic value is realized. 50+ Portfolios With Signal Value™ 50 62 Lavendon (London: LVD) 212 - Zara Madrid: ITX Spain Apparel 7 14% 4 - slotted those companies into our “Next 5 ideas with strong downside protection.” Revealing the Top Ideas of Top Investors � Bill Ackman, Pershing Square Rental Equipment Leicestershire, UK, 44-1455558874 www.lavendongroup.com They are EchoStar (SATS; $19.50; MV $1.7 billion), Gravity (GRVY; $1.55; MV � Lee Ainsle, Maverick © 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved. www.manualofideas.com March 25, 2010 – Page 84 of 116 © 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved. www.manualofideas.com January 21, 2010 – Page 9 of 124 © 2009-2010 by BeyondProxy LLC. All rights reserved. www.manualofideas.com $43 million), Harvest Natural Resources (HNR; $8.45; MV $280 million), Penn � Chuck Akre, Akre Capital February 18, 2010 – Page 28 of 144 Trading Data Consensus EPS Estimates Valuation “Signal value” as opposed to “noise.” We present the � Zeke Ashton, Centaur Capital Price: £0.52 (as of 9/24/10) Month # of P/E FYE 12/31/09 n/a Millers (PMIC; $12.10; MV $57 million), and Seahawk Drilling (HAWK; $10; MV $118 million). Set-top box and satellite company EchoStar trades at a material holdings of some of the world’s top investors. We look for � Brian Bares, Bares Capital 52-week range: £0.43 - £1.86 Latest Ago Ests P/E FYE 12/31/10 n/a � Bruce Berkowitz, Fairholme Market value: £86.7 million This quarter n/a n/a n/a P/E FYE 12/31/11 n/a discount to tangible book value, with well over one-half of market value in net cash investors who have amassed impressive track records over Enterprise value: £254.4 billion Next quarter n/a n/a n/a P/E FYE 12/31/12 n/a and investments; it has improving business performance and is run by one of the � Richard Breeden, Breeden Capital long periods of time. We choose these investors carefully Shares out: 164.4 million FYE 12/31/10 n/a n/a n/a EV/ LTM revenue 1.2x most accomplished entrepreneurs in the industry, Charlie Ergen, who owns one-half � Tom Brown, Second Curve Ownership Data FYE 12/31/11 n/a n/a n/a EV/ LTM EBIT 21x of the equity. Korean Internet gaming company Gravity trades for less than net cash, to avoid the noise inherent in most 13F-HR filings. � Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway Insider ownership: <1% FYE 12/30/12 n/a n/a n/a P / tangible book 1.0x is profitable and cash generative and should release a long-awaited new game within � Francis Chou, Chou Associates Insider buys (last six months): >1 LT growth n/a n/a n/a Greenblatt Criteria the next six to twelve months. Oil and gas firm Harvest trades at a lowly price based MOI Signal Rank answers the question, “What are � Chase Coleman, Tiger Global Insider sales (last six months): 0 EPS Surprise Actual Estimate LTM EBIT yield 5% on proved reserves in Venezuela, a � James Crichton, Scout this investor’s top ten ideas right now?” Rather than Institutional ownership: n/a n/a n/a n/a LTM pre-tax ROC 4% country that strikes fear into investors � Ian Cumming and Joe Steinberg, Leucadia simply presenting each investor’s largest holdings as of the � Boykin Curry, Eagle Operating Performance and Financial Position but appears unlikely to stand in the � David Einhorn, Greenlight (£ millions, except Fiscal Years Ended LTME 6ME 6ME way of value creation for Harvest recently filed quarter end, the MOI’s proprietary per share data) 12/31/04 12/31/05 12/31/06 12/31/07 12/31/08 12/31/09 6/30/10 6/30/09 6/30/10 � Phil Falcone, Harbinger shareholders. Penn Millers is a leader methodology ranks the companies in each investor’s Revenue 108 100 125 186 260 227 219 114 106 � Alan Fournier, Pennant in the attractive agribusiness insurance Gross profit 36 41 55 87 110 87 80 43 36 portfolio based on the investor’s current level of conviction � Glenn Fuhrman and John Phelan, MSD Capital niche, yet trades at a material discount Operating income (9) 7 13 26 39 (25) 12 (31) 6 � Jeffrey Gates, Gates Capital to tangible book value, owing to an in each holding, as judged by the MOI. Net income (13) 1 7 15 17 (43) (7) (37) (0) � Tom Gayner, Markel Gayner Diluted EPS n/m 0.02 0.18 0.42 0.35 n/m n/m n/m n/m ownership change quirk typical in � Kian Ghazi, Hawkshaw demutualizations. Gulf of Mexico Our proprietary methodology takes into account a Shares out (avg) 37 37 38 42 46 56 105 47 164 � Ed Gilhuly and Scott Stuart, Sageview Cash from ops 24 25 30 49 54 56 49 20 13 jackup driller Seahawk has seen number of variables, including the size of a position in an � Glenn Greenberg, Brave Warrior Capex 2 8 36 50 59 13 16 5 8 demand for its drilling platforms � John Griffin, Blue Ridge investor’s portfolio, the size of a position relative to the Free cash flow 22 17 (6) (1) (5) 43 33 15 5 decline along with natural gas prices, � Howard Guberman, Gruss Cash & investments 8 8 10 17 15 76 6 10 6 but the shares have slumped to a level market value of the corresponding company, the most recent � Andreas Halvorsen, Viking Global Total current assets 34 32 44 69 80 135 68 72 68 that might be below the price quarterly change in the number of shares owned, and the � Mason Hawkins, Southeastern Intangible assets 1 1 3 10 15 7 6 9 6 shareholders could realize in a � Lance Helfert and Paul Orfalea, West Coast Total assets 202 177 268 426 571 514 414 466 414 liquidation that would see the rigs sold change in the stock price of a position since the most recent � Chris Hohn, Children’s Investment Fund Short-term debt 16 14 25 41 55 44 46 52 46 for scrap steel. quarterly filing date. � Carl Icahn, Icahn Current liabilities 33 32 67 119 116 98 89 99 89 Long-term debt 81 56 84 161 265 214 127 231 127 � Rehan Jaffer, H Partners Finally, we are happy to bring For example, an investor might have the most Total liabilities 127 99 174 306 423 340 244 360 244 � Seth Klarman, Baupost you an exclusive interview with top- Common equity 75 78 94 119 148 174 170 105 170 conviction in a position that is only the tenth-largest � John Kleinheinz, Kleinheinz Capital performing small cap value fund � Eddie Lampert, ESL Investments Ten-Year Stock Price Performance and Trading Volume Dynamics manager Scott Barbee of the Aegis position in such investor’s portfolio. This might be the � Dan Loeb, Third Point 800p Value Fund (AVALX), a mutual fund � Steve Mandel, Lone Pine case if an investor invests in a small company, resulting in that has handily outperformed the � Sandy Nairn, Edinburgh Partners 700p Russell 2000 Value Index since the fund’s inception in 1998. Scott has been through a holding that is simply too small to rank highly based on � Mohnish Pabrai, Pabrai Funds two very tough periods for value investors while at the helm of Aegis — the tech size alone. On the other hand, such a holding might � John Paulson, Paulson & Co. 600p stock “melt-up” in 1998-2000 and the market collapse of late 2008 and early 2009. � Boone Pickens, BP Capital represent 19.9% of the shares outstanding of the subject 500p His insights into surviving and thriving as a Graham-and-Dodd-style investor are � Mark Rachesky, MHR perhaps not so much unique as they are a reminder that investors do better when they company, suggesting a high level of conviction. Our � Lisa Rapuano, Lane Five 400p refuse to be swayed by the prevailing market psychology and instead follow their estimate of the conviction level would rise further if the � Larry Robbins, Glenview own path with discipline and conviction. � Bob Rodriguez and Steven Romick, First Pacific 300p subject company has a 20% poison-pill threshold, thereby � Wilbur Ross, WL Ross Sincerely, suggesting that the investor has bought as much of the � Chris Shumway, Shumway Capital 200p � David Tepper, Appaloosa subject company as is practically feasible. � Peter Thiel, Clarium 100p John Mihaljevic, CFA � Prem Watsa, Fairfax and The Manual of Ideas research team � Wally Weitz, Weitz Funds 0p � David Winters, Wintergreen Sep 03 Sep 04 Sep 05 Sep 06 Sep 07 Sep 08 Sep 09 Sep 10