SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
Relevance of the Turkish
Democratization in the Arab World :
         Turkish Model



                 Aswini K. Mohapatra
– The SubjecT headingS:
1. Evolution of the Turkish Polity
2. Transition to Liberal Democracy

3. Democracy in the Arab World
4. Relevance of the Turkish Model in the
   Arab World
evoluTion of The
 Turk ı Sh poliTy
evoluTion of TurkiSh
  republic
• In 23rd of April,1923, Turkish
  Republic is established
• The Republican People’s Party
  (RPP)
• Small group of Westernized
  elites
• ’’Bureaucratic ruling tradition’’
  from the Ottoman times
• Bureaucracy was the part of the
  political centre
• Supported by military
• Paternal state : Devlet Baba
evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy
   6 fundaMenTal principleS of aTaTurk (6
   arroWS)

• Republicanism:
• Kemalism believes that it is only the republican regime which can best represent
  the wishes of the people.
• Populism:
• This was a revolution led by an elite with an orientation towards people in
  general. Women received the right to vote in 1934. 
• Secularism:
• Kemalist secularism did not merely mean separation of state and religion, but also
  the separation of religion from educational and legal affairs.
• Reformism:
  Turkey made reforms and that the country replaced traditional institutions with
  modern institutions.
  Nationalism:
• Kemalist nationalism believes in the principle that the Turkish state is an indivisible
  whole comprising its territory and people.
• Statism:
• The state was to regulate the country's general economic activity and the state
  was to engage in areas where private enterprise was not willing to do so, or where
  private enterprise had proved to be inadequate, or if national interest required it.
evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy
• Turkey had signed UN Charter in 1945
• Competitive Party System-after World War II.
• The Democrat Party is established (DP) in 1945
• Intense Conflict between RPP and DP
• The Military Coup in 1960
• The Government of Prime Minister Adnan Menderes was
  overthrown
• The 1961 Constitution framed
• Justice Party (The Successor of the DP) formed the
  government
• The Semi Military Coup in 1971
• Deep Political and Ideological Polarization between JP and
  RPP
evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy
• The Economic Package announced by Süleyman Demirel
• Displeasure among Other Parties
• The encounters the Kurdish Separatists and the Ultra-
  Nationalists
• Party leaders warned by the Military
• The Turkish Military made an official declaration in 1980 “
  It had a duty to step in.”
• The Main Reason: The Massive meeting organized by
  Necmettin Erbakan, the leader of The National Salvation
  Party (NSP)
• Kenan Evren, the general of the coup elected as President
• Motherland Party (ANAP) by Turgut Özal
• 3 Party Coalition among – RP , DSP and RPP
TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy
    probleMaTic SideS of Turkey’S deMocracy


• The Absence of Democratic Political Culture
• High Level of Human Rights Abuse
• Denial of Cultural Liberties to the Minority Kurds
• Kurdish Separatism
• Islamic Extremism
• Intense Polarization as Left wing and Right wing
• Primacy of The Military
TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy
• After Justice and Development Party (AKP) :
• Supporting for Turkish Integration into global
  economy
• Supporting Membership in the European Union
• Overall alignment with the West
• Electing AKP was a YES to :
• Democratic Reforms
• Market Economy and Open Society
• The EU Membership Process
• Opening up to the World
TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy
• With AKP, The Proposed Reforms:
• Complete Freedom of Expression
• Assosiation to Removel of Legal Provisions on
  the usage of mothertongue
• Protection of Minority and Human Rigts
• Democratic Control of Armed Forces
• Decentralization of Power
The Leader of AKP, Recep Tayyip ERDOGAN
deMocraTiZaTion in The arab World :
relevance of The TurkiSh Model
• It contradicts correlation between levels of socio-
  economic development and propensity for democratic
  rule
• The success of electoral democracy in Turkey
• It had debunked the claim that Islam is incompatible
  with democracy
• Turkish- Islamic Synthesis
• Turkey’s historical and institutional linkages with the
  West and its resolve to maintain these linkages have
  made the military sensitive to external pressures
relevance of The TurkiSh Model
• Turkey’s democracy can’t be a model ;
• The absence of Turkey’s historical and structural conditions
  in the Arab World
• Inherrited strong state-traditions from Ottoman Empire
  such as:
   Statecraft and respect for state
• Absence of a strong landed class in Anatolia
• Powerful upper landed class in Arab States
• Consolidation of State Authority
• Escaped from colonialism and mandate
relevance of The TurkiSh Model

• Authoritarian state structure emerged in the Arab
  World, was consolidated by 3 factors;
• Conflict with Israil
• Entanglement of the region in superpower rivalry
  during the Cold War period
• The Oil Economy of the 1970s –Huge Oil Reserves
  and Geo-Strategic Utility
relevance of The TurkiSh Model
“The winds of democratic change have swept all parts
 of the world except our region, because America
 wants us to have dictators and monarchical
 presidents to ensure that we remain weak and
 vanquished. The geo-strategic imperatives such as a
 reliable oil supply, necessity to find new markets,
 protection of the Jewish state of Israel and
 containment of political Islam have all played a
 decisive role in exempting the Arab world from
 Western pressures to democratize.”
                         The Editor of Al-Quds al-Arabi
concluSion:
• As a conclusion, even though Turkish Model of
  democracy does provide an example for Arab liberal
  reformers, currently campaigning for democracy and
  political pluralism in the region, Turkish experience is
  sui generis and cannot be replicated by any other
  state in the region.
Thank you for your
attention...


                     Ay ş e
Betül Kılıç

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
Zarmeen Durrani
 
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
Paulina Méndez
 
TURKEY
TURKEYTURKEY
TURKEY
Farhan Ahmad
 
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-IntroductionTheories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Keshab Giri
 
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and PresentThe Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
Przegląd Politologiczny
 
Civil and military bureacracy.
Civil and military bureacracy.Civil and military bureacracy.
Civil and military bureacracy.
DRMOMINASAJJAD
 
Introduction to Comparative Politics
Introduction to Comparative PoliticsIntroduction to Comparative Politics
Introduction to Comparative Politics
Amogh Kanjilal
 
Local government of pakistan
Local government of pakistanLocal government of pakistan
Local government of pakistan
Adnan Aslam
 
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk
Mustafa Kemal AtaturkMustafa Kemal Ataturk
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk
Tayyaba ijaz
 
Ataturk
AtaturkAtaturk
Ataturk
ahmetemina
 
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISMPOLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
George Dumitrache
 
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
Muntaha Ahmad
 
Robert Cox-Critical Theory
Robert Cox-Critical TheoryRobert Cox-Critical Theory
Robert Cox-Critical Theory
Venkata Krishnan Sankaranarayanan
 
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good GovernanceImportance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
Bilal yousaf
 
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracyRole of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
Keshav Prasad Bhattarai
 
Decline of the Ottoman Empire
Decline of the Ottoman EmpireDecline of the Ottoman Empire
Decline of the Ottoman Empire
ssclasstorremar
 
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation TurkeyMustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
Comenius Projects in Paderewski
 
Liberalism
LiberalismLiberalism
Liberalism
Eman Ali
 
Neorealism in International Relations
Neorealism in International RelationsNeorealism in International Relations
Neorealism in International Relations
Adnan Munir
 
Feminism
FeminismFeminism
Feminism
Hina Zaidi
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
POLITICAL PARTIES, INTEREST GROUPS, PUBLIC OPINION, ELECTORAL PROCESS
 
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
Foucault. Right of death and power over life.
 
TURKEY
TURKEYTURKEY
TURKEY
 
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-IntroductionTheories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
 
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and PresentThe Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
The Political System of the Republic of Turkey, Past and Present
 
Civil and military bureacracy.
Civil and military bureacracy.Civil and military bureacracy.
Civil and military bureacracy.
 
Introduction to Comparative Politics
Introduction to Comparative PoliticsIntroduction to Comparative Politics
Introduction to Comparative Politics
 
Local government of pakistan
Local government of pakistanLocal government of pakistan
Local government of pakistan
 
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk
Mustafa Kemal AtaturkMustafa Kemal Ataturk
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk
 
Ataturk
AtaturkAtaturk
Ataturk
 
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISMPOLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - LENINISM
 
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
18th amendment federal and provincial responsibilities in education
 
Robert Cox-Critical Theory
Robert Cox-Critical TheoryRobert Cox-Critical Theory
Robert Cox-Critical Theory
 
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good GovernanceImportance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
Importance of Local Government in Democracy and Good Governance
 
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracyRole of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
Role of civil society in promotion and protection of democracy
 
Decline of the Ottoman Empire
Decline of the Ottoman EmpireDecline of the Ottoman Empire
Decline of the Ottoman Empire
 
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation TurkeyMustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk Presentation Turkey
 
Liberalism
LiberalismLiberalism
Liberalism
 
Neorealism in International Relations
Neorealism in International RelationsNeorealism in International Relations
Neorealism in International Relations
 
Feminism
FeminismFeminism
Feminism
 

Destacado

Strategic Instruments and Regional Policies
Strategic Instruments and Regional PoliciesStrategic Instruments and Regional Policies
Strategic Instruments and Regional Policies
Zarina Abzalilova
 
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIABENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
Margarita Goroshkevich
 
Foreign Policy of Turkey
Foreign Policy of Turkey Foreign Policy of Turkey
Foreign Policy of Turkey
Temirlan Atyrov
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
mat_umba
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
Ayman Refaat
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
Afifah Nabilah
 
What is Islamophobia
What is IslamophobiaWhat is Islamophobia
What is Islamophobia
Malory Nye
 
Turkey presentation
Turkey presentationTurkey presentation
Turkey presentation
Semanur Duran
 
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey PolicyFrom Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
M. Kıvanç Önder
 
Pakistan us relationship
Pakistan us relationshipPakistan us relationship
Pakistan us relationship
Haider Sabir
 
Lesson plan Turkish Literature
Lesson plan Turkish LiteratureLesson plan Turkish Literature
Lesson plan Turkish Literature
Comenius Projects in Paderewski
 
Islamophobia (Text Outline)
Islamophobia (Text Outline)Islamophobia (Text Outline)
Islamophobia (Text Outline)
Afifah Nabilah
 
Turkish literature
Turkish literatureTurkish literature
Turkish literature
Jose Jr. Lopez
 
Sample essay on islamophobia
Sample essay on islamophobiaSample essay on islamophobia
Sample essay on islamophobia
Academic Research Paper Writing Services
 
Ottoman report
Ottoman reportOttoman report
Ottoman report
Jose Jr. Lopez
 
Fdi brazil
Fdi  brazilFdi  brazil
Fdi brazil
Semanur Duran
 
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
Hameel Khan
 
The history of anti - semitism
The history of anti - semitismThe history of anti - semitism
The history of anti - semitism
Jurgen Marechal
 
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid ZafarStereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
Abid Zafar
 
Arab spring
Arab springArab spring
Arab spring
rufushp
 

Destacado (20)

Strategic Instruments and Regional Policies
Strategic Instruments and Regional PoliciesStrategic Instruments and Regional Policies
Strategic Instruments and Regional Policies
 
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIABENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
BENEATH THE VEIL: A CLOSER LOOK AT ISLAMOPHOBIA
 
Foreign Policy of Turkey
Foreign Policy of Turkey Foreign Policy of Turkey
Foreign Policy of Turkey
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
 
Islamophobia
IslamophobiaIslamophobia
Islamophobia
 
What is Islamophobia
What is IslamophobiaWhat is Islamophobia
What is Islamophobia
 
Turkey presentation
Turkey presentationTurkey presentation
Turkey presentation
 
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey PolicyFrom Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
From Rhetoric to Reality: Reframing U.S.-Turkey Policy
 
Pakistan us relationship
Pakistan us relationshipPakistan us relationship
Pakistan us relationship
 
Lesson plan Turkish Literature
Lesson plan Turkish LiteratureLesson plan Turkish Literature
Lesson plan Turkish Literature
 
Islamophobia (Text Outline)
Islamophobia (Text Outline)Islamophobia (Text Outline)
Islamophobia (Text Outline)
 
Turkish literature
Turkish literatureTurkish literature
Turkish literature
 
Sample essay on islamophobia
Sample essay on islamophobiaSample essay on islamophobia
Sample essay on islamophobia
 
Ottoman report
Ottoman reportOttoman report
Ottoman report
 
Fdi brazil
Fdi  brazilFdi  brazil
Fdi brazil
 
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
Research paper ISLAMOPHOBIA AND MEDIA STUDIES SINCE 9/11
 
The history of anti - semitism
The history of anti - semitismThe history of anti - semitism
The history of anti - semitism
 
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid ZafarStereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
Stereotyping, Muslim Stereotyping & Islamophobia by Abid Zafar
 
Arab spring
Arab springArab spring
Arab spring
 

Similar a Relevance of the Turkish Democratization

turkey_politics_pptx.pptx
turkey_politics_pptx.pptxturkey_politics_pptx.pptx
turkey_politics_pptx.pptx
SatriaHibatalAzizy
 
IRI Modern Turkey.pptx
IRI Modern Turkey.pptxIRI Modern Turkey.pptx
IRI Modern Turkey.pptx
SAJJADALI591691
 
Class 9 civics
Class 9 civicsClass 9 civics
Class 9 civics
pratik8897
 
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
Shivam Parmar
 
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava RevolutionStrengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
philrag2
 
Democracy in the contemporary world ppt
Democracy in the contemporary world pptDemocracy in the contemporary world ppt
Democracy in the contemporary world ppt
Tibetan Homes School
 
Class 9 cvics chap 1
Class 9 cvics chap 1Class 9 cvics chap 1
Class 9 cvics chap 1
Bhanu Kalra
 
The nuclear age and cold war
The nuclear age and cold warThe nuclear age and cold war
The nuclear age and cold war
francoisenslin
 
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTANREASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
abdullahkhalid50
 
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
John Paul Tabakian
 
ataturk's life
ataturk's lifeataturk's life
ataturk's life
guest696325
 
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet UnionGorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
58033000
 
The Kemalist One Party State
The Kemalist One Party StateThe Kemalist One Party State
The Kemalist One Party State
Arno Lordkronos
 
What is government
What is governmentWhat is government
What is government
PRIYANKA ABRAHAM
 
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International StudentsIIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
sabazulfqar1996
 
Military dictatorship
Military dictatorshipMilitary dictatorship
Military dictatorship
Hridoy Sarkar
 
The origin of democratic rule
The origin of democratic ruleThe origin of democratic rule
The origin of democratic rule
Aniksaha36
 
Stages of the french revolution
Stages  of the  french revolutionStages  of the  french revolution
Stages of the french revolution
Gines García
 
Part-IV of Twilight in Delhi
Part-IV of Twilight in DelhiPart-IV of Twilight in Delhi
Part-IV of Twilight in Delhi
Bibi Halima
 
Constitutional design
Constitutional designConstitutional design
Constitutional design
Nazima Hussain
 

Similar a Relevance of the Turkish Democratization (20)

turkey_politics_pptx.pptx
turkey_politics_pptx.pptxturkey_politics_pptx.pptx
turkey_politics_pptx.pptx
 
IRI Modern Turkey.pptx
IRI Modern Turkey.pptxIRI Modern Turkey.pptx
IRI Modern Turkey.pptx
 
Class 9 civics
Class 9 civicsClass 9 civics
Class 9 civics
 
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
Chapter - 1, Democracy in Contemporary World, Democratic Politics/Civics, Soc...
 
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava RevolutionStrengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
Strengths And Challenges For The Rojava Revolution
 
Democracy in the contemporary world ppt
Democracy in the contemporary world pptDemocracy in the contemporary world ppt
Democracy in the contemporary world ppt
 
Class 9 cvics chap 1
Class 9 cvics chap 1Class 9 cvics chap 1
Class 9 cvics chap 1
 
The nuclear age and cold war
The nuclear age and cold warThe nuclear age and cold war
The nuclear age and cold war
 
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTANREASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
REASONS OF UNSTABLE DEMOCRATIC SETUP IN PAKISTAN
 
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
Political Science 2 – Comparative Politics - Power Point #10
 
ataturk's life
ataturk's lifeataturk's life
ataturk's life
 
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet UnionGorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
Gorbachev Moves Towards Democracy and Collapse of the Soviet Union
 
The Kemalist One Party State
The Kemalist One Party StateThe Kemalist One Party State
The Kemalist One Party State
 
What is government
What is governmentWhat is government
What is government
 
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International StudentsIIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
IIRI Study in Modern Turkey for International Students
 
Military dictatorship
Military dictatorshipMilitary dictatorship
Military dictatorship
 
The origin of democratic rule
The origin of democratic ruleThe origin of democratic rule
The origin of democratic rule
 
Stages of the french revolution
Stages  of the  french revolutionStages  of the  french revolution
Stages of the french revolution
 
Part-IV of Twilight in Delhi
Part-IV of Twilight in DelhiPart-IV of Twilight in Delhi
Part-IV of Twilight in Delhi
 
Constitutional design
Constitutional designConstitutional design
Constitutional design
 

Relevance of the Turkish Democratization

  • 1. Relevance of the Turkish Democratization in the Arab World : Turkish Model Aswini K. Mohapatra
  • 2. – The SubjecT headingS: 1. Evolution of the Turkish Polity 2. Transition to Liberal Democracy 3. Democracy in the Arab World 4. Relevance of the Turkish Model in the Arab World
  • 3. evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy evoluTion of TurkiSh republic • In 23rd of April,1923, Turkish Republic is established • The Republican People’s Party (RPP) • Small group of Westernized elites • ’’Bureaucratic ruling tradition’’ from the Ottoman times • Bureaucracy was the part of the political centre • Supported by military • Paternal state : Devlet Baba
  • 4. evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy 6 fundaMenTal principleS of aTaTurk (6 arroWS) • Republicanism: • Kemalism believes that it is only the republican regime which can best represent the wishes of the people. • Populism: • This was a revolution led by an elite with an orientation towards people in general. Women received the right to vote in 1934.  • Secularism: • Kemalist secularism did not merely mean separation of state and religion, but also the separation of religion from educational and legal affairs. • Reformism: Turkey made reforms and that the country replaced traditional institutions with modern institutions. Nationalism: • Kemalist nationalism believes in the principle that the Turkish state is an indivisible whole comprising its territory and people. • Statism: • The state was to regulate the country's general economic activity and the state was to engage in areas where private enterprise was not willing to do so, or where private enterprise had proved to be inadequate, or if national interest required it.
  • 5. evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy • Turkey had signed UN Charter in 1945 • Competitive Party System-after World War II. • The Democrat Party is established (DP) in 1945 • Intense Conflict between RPP and DP • The Military Coup in 1960 • The Government of Prime Minister Adnan Menderes was overthrown • The 1961 Constitution framed • Justice Party (The Successor of the DP) formed the government • The Semi Military Coup in 1971 • Deep Political and Ideological Polarization between JP and RPP
  • 6. evoluTion of The Turk ı Sh poliTy • The Economic Package announced by Süleyman Demirel • Displeasure among Other Parties • The encounters the Kurdish Separatists and the Ultra- Nationalists • Party leaders warned by the Military • The Turkish Military made an official declaration in 1980 “ It had a duty to step in.” • The Main Reason: The Massive meeting organized by Necmettin Erbakan, the leader of The National Salvation Party (NSP) • Kenan Evren, the general of the coup elected as President • Motherland Party (ANAP) by Turgut Özal • 3 Party Coalition among – RP , DSP and RPP
  • 7.
  • 8. TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy probleMaTic SideS of Turkey’S deMocracy • The Absence of Democratic Political Culture • High Level of Human Rights Abuse • Denial of Cultural Liberties to the Minority Kurds • Kurdish Separatism • Islamic Extremism • Intense Polarization as Left wing and Right wing • Primacy of The Military
  • 9. TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy • After Justice and Development Party (AKP) : • Supporting for Turkish Integration into global economy • Supporting Membership in the European Union • Overall alignment with the West • Electing AKP was a YES to : • Democratic Reforms • Market Economy and Open Society • The EU Membership Process • Opening up to the World
  • 10. TranSiTion To liberal deMocracy • With AKP, The Proposed Reforms: • Complete Freedom of Expression • Assosiation to Removel of Legal Provisions on the usage of mothertongue • Protection of Minority and Human Rigts • Democratic Control of Armed Forces • Decentralization of Power
  • 11. The Leader of AKP, Recep Tayyip ERDOGAN
  • 12. deMocraTiZaTion in The arab World :
  • 13. relevance of The TurkiSh Model • It contradicts correlation between levels of socio- economic development and propensity for democratic rule • The success of electoral democracy in Turkey • It had debunked the claim that Islam is incompatible with democracy • Turkish- Islamic Synthesis • Turkey’s historical and institutional linkages with the West and its resolve to maintain these linkages have made the military sensitive to external pressures
  • 14. relevance of The TurkiSh Model • Turkey’s democracy can’t be a model ; • The absence of Turkey’s historical and structural conditions in the Arab World • Inherrited strong state-traditions from Ottoman Empire such as: Statecraft and respect for state • Absence of a strong landed class in Anatolia • Powerful upper landed class in Arab States • Consolidation of State Authority • Escaped from colonialism and mandate
  • 15. relevance of The TurkiSh Model • Authoritarian state structure emerged in the Arab World, was consolidated by 3 factors; • Conflict with Israil • Entanglement of the region in superpower rivalry during the Cold War period • The Oil Economy of the 1970s –Huge Oil Reserves and Geo-Strategic Utility
  • 16. relevance of The TurkiSh Model “The winds of democratic change have swept all parts of the world except our region, because America wants us to have dictators and monarchical presidents to ensure that we remain weak and vanquished. The geo-strategic imperatives such as a reliable oil supply, necessity to find new markets, protection of the Jewish state of Israel and containment of political Islam have all played a decisive role in exempting the Arab world from Western pressures to democratize.” The Editor of Al-Quds al-Arabi
  • 17.
  • 18. concluSion: • As a conclusion, even though Turkish Model of democracy does provide an example for Arab liberal reformers, currently campaigning for democracy and political pluralism in the region, Turkish experience is sui generis and cannot be replicated by any other state in the region.
  • 19. Thank you for your attention... Ay ş e Betül Kılıç