SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 23
Money is Not Territory

“Religious” Dimensions of Iroquois
             Wampum
On the “Freedom Trail”
Tourist Highlights
What Freedom?
Pilgrims on Cape Cod
First Theft
What is Religion?
• Exchange
• Indigenous traditions challenge conventional
  (i.e., Constitutional) understandings of
  religion
• Not strictly ideological--material
• Status of researcher as a participant in
  cultural critique and creation
Wampum
   • Worked shell bead
     from the quahoag shell
Contemporary Wampum artistry
Wampum’s Value
       • Purple (black) and
         white
          – Cosmological attributes
            of Earth/Sky,
            Night/Day, Creator
            Twins
       • Purity of intention
          – Living force of words
            spoken into wampum
            and from wampum into
            speaker
Hiawantha Belt of the
    Haudenosaunee Confederacy
• Story of the
  Peacemaker and
  Hiawantha
• Condolence
  – Grief as a sudden
    disjunction between
    humans and creation
  – Wampum restores
    relations
Tsha’hon’nonyen’dakhwa’
“Where they play games”
Wampum Belts




• “Two-Row Wampum”--Guswentha
  – Treaty between Haudenosaunee and Dutch 1613
  – Residence and exchange as equals
      • Non-interference agreement
  – Dutch version discovered in 1968
      • Emphasis on exclusivity of trade relationship
NOON campaign for 2013




• http://www.honorthetworow.org
European Wampum

• Wampum as Money
   – Tied to the Development of Colonial America
• Access to Beaver pelts
   – Basis of trans-Atlantic commerce
   – Creation of NYC (JJ Astor), Erie Canal
• Long Island factories
   – Last “wampum mint” closed in 1899
   – Reorganized worlds of Native and Europeans
• Exchange rate: 3 white/1 black to British penny
Wampum and Money: Expor-ations of
      Religion as Exchange
• For Haudenosaunee            • For Europeans wampum
  wampum is an                   was the basis for trans-
  expression of the              Atlantic trade
  cosmos                          – Extending colonial
  – Extending the                   empires through
    Confederacy through             commerce
    Condolence                    – Wampum as money
  – Wampum as being                  • Immigrant phenomenon
     • Indigenous phenomenon
Money and Native Americans
             • Monetary exchange
               network (Global
               economy) has been the
               most detrimental to
               Native communities
               – Not religion, per se
               – Modern notion of
                 money derived from
                 Christian worldview
Theodor de Bry, Las Casas, the Black
        Legend and GOLD
Money as Religion
• “Total fact” of modern existence
  – Everything is evaluated with respect to monetary
    value
• Symbolic, mythic, “faith based,”
• Materiality of our current existence
• Wampum clarifies religious nature of money
  – No joke
Theology of Money
• Sacred reality is removed
  from material life
   – Anthrocentric emphasis
       • Everything is here for
         human beings
• God or Creator is “otiosus”
   – Sign of God in money
   – Removed from Creation
• Creates a dangerous world
Basic Call to Consciousness

  What has befallen Native American people
  will befall us all
• Environmental degradation
  – Expressed in weather and sickness
• Loss of cultural identity
• Not apocalyptic; no sense of optimism
  – Self-fulfilling prophecy of Religions which
    emphasize the end
Native Nations and the UN
• World Stage that respects cultural differences
• Since 1978 there has developed a Indigenous
  peoples consultation
  – Lead by Oren Lyons of Onondaga
  – Haudenosaunee passports
• Quote page 90
  – World at a critical point
UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous
              Issues
• http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/unpfii/index.h
  tml
• Meeting at UN NYC every spring
• Discussions of the Doctrine of Discovery as a
  critical aspect of Indigenous survival

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

The muslim empires
The muslim empiresThe muslim empires
The muslim empireselager
 
Tourism and Culture
Tourism and CultureTourism and Culture
Tourism and CultureUnica Hija
 
Chapter 2 notes
Chapter 2 notesChapter 2 notes
Chapter 2 notesmstraile
 
Chapter 1 notes
Chapter 1 notesChapter 1 notes
Chapter 1 notesmstraile
 
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural Tourism
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural TourismSample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural Tourism
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural TourismAmelia Jones
 
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture Supplement
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture SupplementAP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture Supplement
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture SupplementLunmara
 

La actualidad más candente (9)

Argentina
ArgentinaArgentina
Argentina
 
The muslim empires
The muslim empiresThe muslim empires
The muslim empires
 
Tourism and Culture
Tourism and CultureTourism and Culture
Tourism and Culture
 
Intangible Cultural Heritage Tourism
 Intangible Cultural Heritage Tourism Intangible Cultural Heritage Tourism
Intangible Cultural Heritage Tourism
 
Heritage tourism by g 2
Heritage tourism by g 2Heritage tourism by g 2
Heritage tourism by g 2
 
Chapter 2 notes
Chapter 2 notesChapter 2 notes
Chapter 2 notes
 
Chapter 1 notes
Chapter 1 notesChapter 1 notes
Chapter 1 notes
 
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural Tourism
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural TourismSample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural Tourism
Sample Report on Importance of Museum, Heritage and Cultural Tourism
 
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture Supplement
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture SupplementAP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture Supplement
AP Human Geo Chapter 4 - Folk culture Supplement
 

Destacado

EH201.2MythVSLegend
EH201.2MythVSLegendEH201.2MythVSLegend
EH201.2MythVSLegendsadean
 
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were Created
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were CreatedMythology: How the World and Mankind were Created
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were Createdmarina13171
 
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Time
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own TimeWorkplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Time
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Timeshrmi
 
Creation myths
Creation mythsCreation myths
Creation mythsLark47
 
Myths And Legends
Myths And LegendsMyths And Legends
Myths And Legendsjengrisch
 
Greek creation mythology
Greek creation mythologyGreek creation mythology
Greek creation mythologykarrinem
 
2 greek creation powerpoint
2 greek creation powerpoint2 greek creation powerpoint
2 greek creation powerpointThalia Longoria
 

Destacado (10)

Legends myths
Legends mythsLegends myths
Legends myths
 
EH201.2MythVSLegend
EH201.2MythVSLegendEH201.2MythVSLegend
EH201.2MythVSLegend
 
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were Created
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were CreatedMythology: How the World and Mankind were Created
Mythology: How the World and Mankind were Created
 
In The Beginning
In The BeginningIn The Beginning
In The Beginning
 
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Time
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own TimeWorkplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Time
Workplace Flexibility:Creating a Legend in Its Own Time
 
The Palace of the Lost City
The Palace of the Lost CityThe Palace of the Lost City
The Palace of the Lost City
 
Creation myths
Creation mythsCreation myths
Creation myths
 
Myths And Legends
Myths And LegendsMyths And Legends
Myths And Legends
 
Greek creation mythology
Greek creation mythologyGreek creation mythology
Greek creation mythology
 
2 greek creation powerpoint
2 greek creation powerpoint2 greek creation powerpoint
2 greek creation powerpoint
 

Similar a 11 12-12-rel142

9 10-12-rel142
9 10-12-rel1429 10-12-rel142
9 10-12-rel142pparnold
 
The World of the 15th Century Part 1
The World of the 15th Century Part 1The World of the 15th Century Part 1
The World of the 15th Century Part 1Colleen Skadl
 
Fertile Crescent Vocabulary
Fertile Crescent VocabularyFertile Crescent Vocabulary
Fertile Crescent Vocabularycmiles2
 
Chapter 1 - New World Beginnings
Chapter 1  - New World BeginningsChapter 1  - New World Beginnings
Chapter 1 - New World Beginningsjjyr10
 
AP US History Chapter 1
AP US History Chapter 1AP US History Chapter 1
AP US History Chapter 1bwellington
 
Big history jennifer simon
Big history   jennifer simonBig history   jennifer simon
Big history jennifer simonJensim0n1
 
Renaissance, zheng he ming 2015
Renaissance, zheng he  ming 2015Renaissance, zheng he  ming 2015
Renaissance, zheng he ming 2015Janet Pareja
 
History 17 a online lecture 1
History 17 a online lecture 1History 17 a online lecture 1
History 17 a online lecture 1jgardner194
 
New Encounters
New EncountersNew Encounters
New Encounterselager
 
African Civilizations & Bantu Migration
African Civilizations & Bantu MigrationAfrican Civilizations & Bantu Migration
African Civilizations & Bantu MigrationCassidy Baker
 
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdf
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdfCULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdf
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdfssuserc8e60e
 

Similar a 11 12-12-rel142 (20)

Chapter 2.2 2.4
Chapter 2.2 2.4Chapter 2.2 2.4
Chapter 2.2 2.4
 
9 10-12-rel142
9 10-12-rel1429 10-12-rel142
9 10-12-rel142
 
iksfhk
iksfhkiksfhk
iksfhk
 
The World of the 15th Century Part 1
The World of the 15th Century Part 1The World of the 15th Century Part 1
The World of the 15th Century Part 1
 
Fertile Crescent Vocabulary
Fertile Crescent VocabularyFertile Crescent Vocabulary
Fertile Crescent Vocabulary
 
Chapter 1 - New World Beginnings
Chapter 1  - New World BeginningsChapter 1  - New World Beginnings
Chapter 1 - New World Beginnings
 
AP US History Chapter 1
AP US History Chapter 1AP US History Chapter 1
AP US History Chapter 1
 
Big history jennifer simon
Big history   jennifer simonBig history   jennifer simon
Big history jennifer simon
 
Renaissance, zheng he ming 2015
Renaissance, zheng he  ming 2015Renaissance, zheng he  ming 2015
Renaissance, zheng he ming 2015
 
History 17 a online lecture 1
History 17 a online lecture 1History 17 a online lecture 1
History 17 a online lecture 1
 
Whiich3
Whiich3Whiich3
Whiich3
 
New Encounters
New EncountersNew Encounters
New Encounters
 
Olaudah Equiano
Olaudah EquianoOlaudah Equiano
Olaudah Equiano
 
Ccri text
Ccri textCcri text
Ccri text
 
Ccri text
Ccri textCcri text
Ccri text
 
Ccri text
Ccri textCcri text
Ccri text
 
Ccri text
Ccri textCcri text
Ccri text
 
Ccri text
Ccri textCcri text
Ccri text
 
African Civilizations & Bantu Migration
African Civilizations & Bantu MigrationAfrican Civilizations & Bantu Migration
African Civilizations & Bantu Migration
 
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdf
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdfCULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdf
CULTURAL AND BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION.pdf
 

Más de pparnold

11 5-12-rel142
11 5-12-rel14211 5-12-rel142
11 5-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 29-12-rel142
10 29-12-rel14210 29-12-rel142
10 29-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 24-12-rel142
10 24-12-rel14210 24-12-rel142
10 24-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 22-12-rel142
10 22-12-rel14210 22-12-rel142
10 22-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 17-12-rel142
10 17-12-rel14210 17-12-rel142
10 17-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 15-12-rel142
10 15-12-rel14210 15-12-rel142
10 15-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 10-12-rel142
10 10-12-rel14210 10-12-rel142
10 10-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 8-12-rel142
10 8-12-rel14210 8-12-rel142
10 8-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 3-12-rel142
10 3-12-rel14210 3-12-rel142
10 3-12-rel142pparnold
 
10 1-12-rel142
10 1-12-rel14210 1-12-rel142
10 1-12-rel142pparnold
 
9 24-12-rel142
9 24-12-rel1429 24-12-rel142
9 24-12-rel142pparnold
 
Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1pparnold
 
Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1pparnold
 
9 19-12-rel142
9 19-12-rel1429 19-12-rel142
9 19-12-rel142pparnold
 
9 17-12-rel142
9 17-12-rel1429 17-12-rel142
9 17-12-rel142pparnold
 
Cas101 phots-f12
Cas101 phots-f12Cas101 phots-f12
Cas101 phots-f12pparnold
 
Rel142 9-12-12
Rel142 9-12-12Rel142 9-12-12
Rel142 9-12-12pparnold
 
9 5-12-r348-exchange
9 5-12-r348-exchange9 5-12-r348-exchange
9 5-12-r348-exchangepparnold
 
8 29-12-r348-religion?
8 29-12-r348-religion?8 29-12-r348-religion?
8 29-12-r348-religion?pparnold
 

Más de pparnold (19)

11 5-12-rel142
11 5-12-rel14211 5-12-rel142
11 5-12-rel142
 
10 29-12-rel142
10 29-12-rel14210 29-12-rel142
10 29-12-rel142
 
10 24-12-rel142
10 24-12-rel14210 24-12-rel142
10 24-12-rel142
 
10 22-12-rel142
10 22-12-rel14210 22-12-rel142
10 22-12-rel142
 
10 17-12-rel142
10 17-12-rel14210 17-12-rel142
10 17-12-rel142
 
10 15-12-rel142
10 15-12-rel14210 15-12-rel142
10 15-12-rel142
 
10 10-12-rel142
10 10-12-rel14210 10-12-rel142
10 10-12-rel142
 
10 8-12-rel142
10 8-12-rel14210 8-12-rel142
10 8-12-rel142
 
10 3-12-rel142
10 3-12-rel14210 3-12-rel142
10 3-12-rel142
 
10 1-12-rel142
10 1-12-rel14210 1-12-rel142
10 1-12-rel142
 
9 24-12-rel142
9 24-12-rel1429 24-12-rel142
9 24-12-rel142
 
Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1
 
Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1Rel142 paper#1
Rel142 paper#1
 
9 19-12-rel142
9 19-12-rel1429 19-12-rel142
9 19-12-rel142
 
9 17-12-rel142
9 17-12-rel1429 17-12-rel142
9 17-12-rel142
 
Cas101 phots-f12
Cas101 phots-f12Cas101 phots-f12
Cas101 phots-f12
 
Rel142 9-12-12
Rel142 9-12-12Rel142 9-12-12
Rel142 9-12-12
 
9 5-12-r348-exchange
9 5-12-r348-exchange9 5-12-r348-exchange
9 5-12-r348-exchange
 
8 29-12-r348-religion?
8 29-12-r348-religion?8 29-12-r348-religion?
8 29-12-r348-religion?
 

11 12-12-rel142

  • 1. Money is Not Territory “Religious” Dimensions of Iroquois Wampum
  • 2. On the “Freedom Trail”
  • 7. What is Religion? • Exchange • Indigenous traditions challenge conventional (i.e., Constitutional) understandings of religion • Not strictly ideological--material • Status of researcher as a participant in cultural critique and creation
  • 8. Wampum • Worked shell bead from the quahoag shell
  • 10. Wampum’s Value • Purple (black) and white – Cosmological attributes of Earth/Sky, Night/Day, Creator Twins • Purity of intention – Living force of words spoken into wampum and from wampum into speaker
  • 11. Hiawantha Belt of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy • Story of the Peacemaker and Hiawantha • Condolence – Grief as a sudden disjunction between humans and creation – Wampum restores relations
  • 13. Wampum Belts • “Two-Row Wampum”--Guswentha – Treaty between Haudenosaunee and Dutch 1613 – Residence and exchange as equals • Non-interference agreement – Dutch version discovered in 1968 • Emphasis on exclusivity of trade relationship
  • 14. NOON campaign for 2013 • http://www.honorthetworow.org
  • 15. European Wampum • Wampum as Money – Tied to the Development of Colonial America • Access to Beaver pelts – Basis of trans-Atlantic commerce – Creation of NYC (JJ Astor), Erie Canal • Long Island factories – Last “wampum mint” closed in 1899 – Reorganized worlds of Native and Europeans • Exchange rate: 3 white/1 black to British penny
  • 16. Wampum and Money: Expor-ations of Religion as Exchange • For Haudenosaunee • For Europeans wampum wampum is an was the basis for trans- expression of the Atlantic trade cosmos – Extending colonial – Extending the empires through Confederacy through commerce Condolence – Wampum as money – Wampum as being • Immigrant phenomenon • Indigenous phenomenon
  • 17. Money and Native Americans • Monetary exchange network (Global economy) has been the most detrimental to Native communities – Not religion, per se – Modern notion of money derived from Christian worldview
  • 18. Theodor de Bry, Las Casas, the Black Legend and GOLD
  • 19. Money as Religion • “Total fact” of modern existence – Everything is evaluated with respect to monetary value • Symbolic, mythic, “faith based,” • Materiality of our current existence • Wampum clarifies religious nature of money – No joke
  • 20. Theology of Money • Sacred reality is removed from material life – Anthrocentric emphasis • Everything is here for human beings • God or Creator is “otiosus” – Sign of God in money – Removed from Creation • Creates a dangerous world
  • 21. Basic Call to Consciousness What has befallen Native American people will befall us all • Environmental degradation – Expressed in weather and sickness • Loss of cultural identity • Not apocalyptic; no sense of optimism – Self-fulfilling prophecy of Religions which emphasize the end
  • 22. Native Nations and the UN • World Stage that respects cultural differences • Since 1978 there has developed a Indigenous peoples consultation – Lead by Oren Lyons of Onondaga – Haudenosaunee passports • Quote page 90 – World at a critical point
  • 23. UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues • http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/unpfii/index.h tml • Meeting at UN NYC every spring • Discussions of the Doctrine of Discovery as a critical aspect of Indigenous survival