SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 88
Descargar para leer sin conexión
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND LOYALTY IN
LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD


                            A PROJECT REPORT
  Submitted in Partial fulfillment of the degree of requirement for the award of



                MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMISTRATION
                        (Marketing & HR)


                                 Submitted by
                             GAURAB DUTTA
                          Registration No: P07BA126



                            Under the guidance of
                                Dr. S. Lalitha
                        Prof. in Management Studies




                      BHARATH UNIVERSITY
                 SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES
                         Chennai 600073
                             India
                            May 2009
School of Management Studies
                        173, Agaram Road, Selaiyur, CHENNAI 600 073
                                              Ph: 044-22290125, 22290742;
                                                 Telefax: 044-22293886
  Web: www.bharathuniv.com; Mobile 09380408052




                               CERTIFICATE


       This is    to Certify    that the Project      report   on   “CUSTOMER
SATISFACTION AND LOYALTY IN LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL
EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD” is a bonafide work and submitted by Mr. Gaurab
Dutta in partial fulfillment of the degree of Master of Business Administration,
School of Management Studies, Bharath University, during 2007–2009.


This certificate is issued based on the declaration by the candidate.




Dr. S. Lalitha                                                   Prof. N. M. Jaffer
(Project Guide)                                                         (HOD)




           Project Report evaluated & Viva Voice held on …………….
INTERNAL EXAMINER                                     EXTERNAL EXAMINER


                 DECLARATION BY CANDIDATE



       I declare that this project work on “CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND
LOYALTY IN LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD” is a
bonafide work done and submitted by me and the research work was carried out
under the guidance of Mr. Rajkumar Krishnan, Clearance Supervisor, DHL
Express (I) Pvt. Ltd. and under overall supervision of Dr. S. Lalitha, Professor,
School of Management Studies, Bharath University.




       I further declare that this Project Report does not form of any other
project reports or dissertations on the basis of which a degree was awarded or
conferred on an earlier occasion on me or any other candidate.




Place: Chennai
Date:                                                             Gaurab Dutta
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT


       I express my deep sense of gratitude to our beloved chairman Dr. S.
Jagathrakshagan for giving me a wonderful opportunity for doing Master of
Business Administration in this esteemed institution


       I wish to place my deep sense of gratitude to Mr. Rajkumar Krishnan,
Clearance Supervisor, DHL Express (I) Pvt. Ltd. For his valuable guidance
throughout the project.


       Foremost, I would like to thank Dr. N. M. Jaffer, HOD, School Of
Management Studies, Bharath University, for his intensity and focus on technical
aspects and for taking all efforts to make my journey smooth on the information
technology super highway. It is a privilege to have him as our faculty.


       I consider it a great privilege to be under the guidance of Dr. S. Lalitha,
Professor, School of Management Studies, Bharath University. The contribution
and significant role played by her help me in preparation and submission of
project report in time.


       I gratefully acknowledge the team of staff members in M.B.A department
for helping me in all aspects and giving their valuable ideas for making my
project efficient and effective. Last but not the least I would like to thank my
parents and friends for their valuable support and encouragement through out
the course of the project.




                                                                    Gaurab Dutta
CONTENTS




                   Chapters           Page No.

1. Introduction                          1

2. Company Profile                      15

3. Review of Literature                 19

4. Research Methodology                 29

5. Data Analysis and Interpretation     35

6. Findings                             55

7. Suggestions                          57

8. Conclusions                          59

9. Annexure                              I

10. Bibliography                         II
 customer-satisfaction
INTRODUCTION

Research Motivation



       A multitude of companies today has already identified the need to create a

loyal customer base and acknowledges that maintaining existing customers and

extending business with them is significantly less expensive than acquiring new

customers. Empirical proof of the proliferation of such customer loyalty efforts in the

business world is e.g. provided in the form of loyalty programs, which many

companies have installed during the past years. By engaging in efforts aimed at

creating customer loyalty, which in turn fosters financial success in monetary terms

firms react to increasing competitive challenges.



       Within research, the investigation of customer loyalty gained importance when

the classic marketing paradigm with its instrumental and transactional orientation

proved unsuitable in the context of longer-term business relationships. Instead, the

relationship marketing approach, which is specifically concerned with the study of

relational ex-changes, gained importance within research, serving as a conceptual

foundation for the majority of customer loyalty researchers.



       The question of how loyalty develops has been subject to an abundance of

research, leading to an expansive body of literature on loyalty determinants. The

extant literature exploring different factors and their constituent effects on loyalty,

however, reveals a strong focus on consumer goods and industrial equipment settings,
while industrial services have received relatively little attention so far. In addition, the

majority of articles incorporates merely a few potential determinants and thus fails to

draw a comprehensive picture of the mechanisms of customer loyalty formation.

Place: Chennai

       Just like other businesses, logistics service providers (LSPs) are faced with

increasing competitive pressure that urges them to concentrate not only on operational

business processes, but also on an efficient and effective customer management. In

the US alone, LSPs’ revenues grew from US-$ 31 billion in 1995 to US-$ 85 billion

in 2004 and logistics outsourcing expenditures as a fraction of total logistics

expenditures are at over 40% and expected to rise even further. One way to meet this

challenge of rapid growth and expansion, according to Langley et al. is to focus on

establishing, maintaining, and developing relationships with customers.




An often proposed driver of logistics outsourcing is the need to develop and maintain

competitive advantage, which customers of LSPs intend to achieve through

concentrating on core competencies and re-engineering. Another important driver is

the ongoing globalization, which several authors regard as the most important

challenge that companies are facing. In this context, LSPs can play an important role

as facilitators of global trade. Along with globalization, however, companies that

outsource logistics activities increasingly try to consolidate the number of LSPs they

use globally. Therefore, LSPs do not only have to devise sustain-able growth

strategies, but also have to develop intercultural management competencies, a

challenge hardly ad-dressed in LSP management literature.
While intercultural management deals with the influence of culture on

management styles in different countries, it is also arguable whether a one best way

management paradigm is applicable even within national confines. LSPs’ customers

are extremely diverse and similarly, relationships between LSPs and their customers

can be expected to exhibit momentous differences. As such, it is a crucial

management issue for LSPs to de-sign their customer loyalty efforts in a manner that

accounts for both cultural context and different relationship characteristics.

Research goals



       As outlined in the preceding section, LSPs are confronted with diverse

management challenges that result from continuous growth, globalization, and

customer diversity. The aim of the present study therefore is to identify determinants

of customer loyalty in relationships between LSPs and their customers by explicitly

considering different characteristics and cultural contexts of such relationships. In this

sense, the present research is positioned at the interface of marketing and logistics and

is intended to contribute not only to logistics research, but also to research in

marketing, customer loyalty, and cultural studies.




       In order to address the concept of customer loyalty, it is important to

understand the mechanisms underlying loyalty in the logistics outsourcing context.

For this reason, the starting point of the present research will be the study of

Wallenburg, who studied customer loyalty within relationships between LSPs and
their customers. On this basis, factors that can be surmised to determine customer

loyalty in such relationships will be proposed and interdependencies between these

factors will be identified. The resulting comprehensive explanatory model of customer

loyalty will not only provide insights into the constitution of customer loyalty, but

will also serve as the basis for subsequent analyses.



       As stated previously, a globalizing marketplace and the need of LSPs to render

logistics services on an international scale requires intercultural management

competencies. Before being able to apply such management techniques, though, a

thorough understanding of cultural differences between different countries is

necessary. The present study will therefore provide a starting point for such analyses

by investigating cultural differences between two important markets for logistics

outsourcing, the USA and Germany. Particular differences between Germany and the

USA will be identified and applied to the previously devised customer loyalty model.

As a result, differences between the two countries with respect to the formation of

customer loyalty can be inferred.



       Finally, this study will investigate in how far different relationship conditions

influence the development of customer loyalty. For this purpose, important

relationship characteristics will be identified and their moderating influences on the

customer loyalty model will be examined. This will provide information on the

robustness of the customer loyalty model versus relational contingencies and will

suggest if it is necessary to differentiate customer loyalty efforts accordingly.
Customer Satisfaction



        The term logistics is often misinterpreted to mean transportation. In fact, the

scope of logistics goes well beyond transportation. Logistics forms the system that

ensures the delivery of the product in the entire supply pipeline. This includes

transportation, packaging, storage and handling methods, and information flow. The

impact of logistics in the ability of a company to satisfy its customers cannot be

overstated. All other efforts at modernization within a company would not bear fruit

until the logistics system is carefully designed to facilitate the smooth and efficient

flow of goods in the system.




        The topic of logistics is relatively new in India. There have been some

companies that have done work in this area, but a large number of companies are only

now beginning to realize the benefits of designing and managing the entire supply

chain. With India joining the global marketplace, the role of logistics assumes greater

importance.

        The industrial policies in India have prompted manufacturers to build plants in

remote, backward areas due to inexpensive land and tax benefits. This poses some

serious logistical problems. Apart from a poor road and transportation network, the

existing communications system in India leaves a lot to be desired by any

international standard. It is in this context that logistics has to be considered in India.




Customer Satisfaction in 7 Steps
1. Encourage Face-to-Face Dealings



       This is the most daunting and downright scary part of interacting with a

customer. If you're not used to this sort of thing it can be a pretty nerve-wracking

experience. Rest assured, though, it does get easier over time. It's important to meet

your customers face to face at least once or even twice during the course of a project.




2. Respond to Messages Promptly & Keep Your Clients Informed



       This goes without saying really. We all know how annoying it is to wait days

for a response to an email or phone call. It might not always be practical to deal with

all customers' queries within the space of a few hours, but at least email or call them

back and let them know you've received their message and you'll contact them about it

as soon as possible. Even if you're not able to solve a problem right away, let the

customer know you're working on it.




3. Be Friendly and Approachable



       A fellow Site Pointer once told me that you can hear a smile through the

phone. This is very true. It's very important to be friendly, courteous and to make your

clients feel like you're their friend and you're there to help them out. There will be
times when you want to beat your clients over the head repeatedly with a blunt object

- it happens to all of us. It's vital that you keep a clear head, respond to your clients'

wishes as best you can, and at all times remain polite and courteous.




4. Have a Clearly-Defined Customer Service Policy



          This may not be too important when you're just starting out, but a clearly

defined customer service policy is going to save you a lot of time and effort in the

long run. If a customer has a problem, what should they do? If the first option doesn't

work, then what? Should they contact different people for billing and technical

enquiries? If they're not satisfied with any aspect of your customer service, who

should they tell? There's nothing more annoying for a client than being passed from

person to person, or not knowing who to turn to. Making sure they know exactly what

to do at each stage of their enquiry should be of utmost importance. So make sure

your customer service policy is present on your site -- and anywhere else it may be

useful.

5. Attention to Detail (also known as 'The Little Niceties')



          Have you ever received a Happy Birthday email or card from a company you

were a client of? Have you ever had a personalized sign-up confirmation email for a

service that you could tell was typed from scratch? These little niceties can be time

consuming and aren't always cost effective, but remember to do them.
Even if it's as small as sending a Happy Holidays email to all your customers,

it's something. It shows you care; it shows there are real people on the other end of

that screen or telephone; and most importantly, it makes the customer feel welcomed,

wanted and valued.




6. Anticipate Your Client's Needs & Go Out Of Your Way to Help Them Out



       Sometimes this is easier said than done! However, achieving this supreme

level of understanding with your clients will do wonders for your working

relationship.




7. Honour Your Promises



       It's possible this is the most important point in this article. The simple

message: when you promise something, deliver. Clients don't like to be disappointed.

Sometimes, something may not get done, or you might miss a deadline through no

fault of your own. Projects can be late, technology can fail and sub-contractors don't

always deliver on time. In this case a quick apology and assurance it'll be ready ASAP

wouldn't go a miss.




Customer Loyalty
Obtaining a thorough understanding of customer loyalty is a prerequisite for

the execution of the research at hand. For that, the development of customer loyalty

research within the framework of relationship marketing will be presented first, before

different customer loyalty concepts will be introduced. From these concepts, a

definition of customer loyalty for use in this study will be derived, before both

consequences and antecedents of customer loyalty will be portrayed.




       Since the beginning of the 1990s, customer loyalty has gained importance both

in relationship marketing research and in business. In business, this can be attributed

to changing market- and competition-environments. Due to a shift from a sellers’ to a

buyers’ market and because of an increasing degree of globalization, most industries

find themselves confronted with new challenges. In a first phase, firms tried to face

these challenges by focusing on their internal processes and organizational structures,

trying to achieve cost reductions by concentrating on internal improvements. A

second phase of external focus followed, where firms directed attention to their

customers, trying to retain existing ones and to win over new ones (churning). Since

“acquiring new customers is much more expensive than keeping them”. And “loyal

customers are the bedrock of any business”. A loyal customer base represents a

barrier to entry, a basis for a price premium, time to respond to competitor

innovations, and a bulwark against deleterious price competition. Loyalty is critical to

brand volume, is highly correlated to market share, and can be used as the basis of

predicting future market share; consequently, understanding loyalty appears critical to

any meaningful analysis of marketing strategy.
In marketing research, two trends mark the development of customer loyalty.

While individual transactions initially were in the center of marketing research, the

focus shifted towards analyzing relationships states that the ‘traditional’ marketing

concept of the marketing mix with its ‘4 Ps’, developed in the middle of the last

century, had been the established approach until the 1990s. This approach, how-ever,

focuses solely on transactions, a deficit tackled by the relationship marketing

approach. At the core of it is the study of relationships between buyers and sellers of

goods or services, in contrast to merely examining transactions. An often cited and

comprehensive definition of relationship marketing is provided “Relationship

marketing refers to all marketing activities directed toward establishing, developing,

and maintaining successful relational exchanges.” Therefore, the relationship

marketing approach pro-vides a suitable environment in which customer loyalty

research can be nested.




       While the development of relationship marketing began in the early 1970s, it

was not until the late 1980s that works from the ‘Nordic School of Services’. Initiated

a paradigm shift that geared marketing towards the creation, conservation, and

extension of buyer-seller relationships. Although relationship marketing today is

widely accepted among marketing researchers, its promoters do not postulate the

replacement of the transactional approach, but rather juxtapose the two approaches.

For example, delineates a strategy continuum, in which different goods require

different degrees of transaction- and relationship-based marketing strategies. As a
result of the focus on relationships in marketing research, customer loyalty gained

importance within research.




       Before determining which stream the present study can be associated with,
however, it is important to create a clear understanding of different customer loyalty
concepts prevalent in research. This will be accomplished in the following section.




Customer Loyalty Concepts

       Reviewing research, it becomes obvious that the notion of customer loyalty is

blurred. At its core, customer loyalty deals with relationships between suppliers and

their customers and can be distinguished from other loyalty aspects, such as brand

loyalty, which refer to a more abstract attachment, such as that towards a brand.

Within German customer loyalty literature, the notion of customer loyalty is even

more faceted, encompasses both ‘customer loyalty’ and ‘customer retention’

distinguishes an active, supplier-focused component and a passive, customer focused

component of customer loyalty.




       In the supplier-focused perspective, customer loyalty is seen as a bundle of

measures that aim at improving relationships with customers. The supplier is in the

center of attention and the customer is only regarded as the factor at which success of

customer loyalty becomes manifest. Here it becomes clear that this approach contains

a conceptual deficit. It is the customer who eventually decides on whether customer

loyalty management is successful or not, because all activities undertaken by a
supplier can only be geared at influencing customers to be loyal. A customer-focused

perspective therefore has to be added to evaluate the success of customer loyalty

management.




       Within the customer-focused perspective, customer loyalty is conceptualized

taking into account customers’ complex characteristics. These can either be

approached as customers’ directly observable actions and/or take into account their

attitudes and intentions. Since customers’ actions are directly influenced by their

attitudes and intentions, it is obvious that these have to be scrutinized to understand

and manage loyalty. A third perspective is a synthesis of the former two approaches.

The relationship-focused perspective directly examines the relationship between

suppliers and customers. Accordingly, the objects of study in this perspective usually

are buying behavior in retail contexts and long-term relationships marked by frequent

interaction between suppliers and buyers in industrial contexts.




       It is clear that the supplier-focused perspective with its instrumental approach

is significantly different from the other two approaches. Distinguishing the customer-

and the relationship-focused perspective, however, is difficult, because both focus on

the customer.



                 Behaviorist customer loyalty concepts


       Behaviorist concepts of customer loyalty have been at the core of early

marketing research and focus on customers’ observable behavior, as e.g. in
purchasing behavior. Accordingly, customer loyalty is established, when customers

demonstrate consistency in their choice of supplier or brand. “Hard-core” loyalty,

when one product alternative is exclusively repurchased and of “reinforcing” loyalty,

when customers switch among brands but repeat-purchase one or more alternatives to

a significant extent. Similarly, customer loyalty as “the proportion of times a

purchaser chooses the same product or service in a specific category compared to the

total number of purchases made by the purchaser in that category“. Pegging customer

loyalty to purchasing behavior, however, is very critical, there can be a multitude of

factors affecting purchasing behavior, such as product availability or special deals,

which are not grasped by looking at purchases alone. A main deficit of the

behavioristic approach thus is that it does not look at the drivers’ behind purchasing

behavior.



       Another disadvantage of behavioristic customer loyalty concepts is their ex-

post approach. When loyalty is only expressed through purchases, information on

customers’ actual loyalty status in between purchases is not available. Consequently,

decreasing loyalty is only recognized after it manifests itself through changed

purchasing behavior. Only in relationships with frequent interaction can a supplier

integrate further aspects, such as complaints, into customer loyalty management. The

reason, why behavioristic concepts may still be valuable, is because the measurement

of customer loyalty in this approach does not necessitate involvement by the

customer. The assessment of attitudes and intentions would always imply customers’

cooperation through participation in surveys. By simply recording purchases, e.g.

through delivery records in the industrial context or customer cards in a consumer
context; the assessment of customer loyalty poses little difficulty. Particularly in

areas, where most purchases can be easily ascribed to individual customers, as is the

case with mail-ordering or book-stores on the internet, the behavioristic approach is

useful for identifying different customer groups and their characteristics. Such firms,

however, can only assess purchases of their own products, while purchases of

competing products go unnoticed. Firms can therefore neither draw conclusions about

relative changes of purchasing behaviors, nor evaluate their comparative market

position.



                Neo-behaviorist customer loyalty concepts


       These narrow technical definitions do not adequately capture the richness and

depth of the loyalty construct implicit in a relational framework.” Consequently, neo-

behavioristic customer loyalty concepts start at the shortcomings of the behavioristic

approach by examining the causes of loyalty. As early as 1969, Day concluded that

“loyalty should be evaluated with both attitudinal and behavioral criteria” otherwise

accidental repeat-purchases, merely resulting from situational exigencies, would be

regarded as indicators of loyalty. There is no agreement, however, on the question,

whether attitudes are part of customer loyalty or merely an antecedent of it. Some

authors propose that only positive attitude can lead to ‘true’ customer loyalty. If

attitude then is a necessary prerequisite of customer loyalty, some drivers of loyalty

cannot be explained. Transaction cost theory, for instance, provides the concept of

asset specificity. Relationship-specific investments create economic switching barriers

and therefore increase customer loyalty. However, the mere repeat purchase of goods

or services for reasons of economic constraints would not qualify as loyalty, as
positive attitudes are not involved. In order to avoid the outlined problem, it is useful

to abstain from defining positive attitude to be a necessary antecedent of loyalty.

Instead, researchers usually consider intentions and observable behavior to be the

constituting elements of customer loyalty.




Determinants of Customer Loyalty


       In order to be able to gear marketing activities towards the creation of

customer loyalty, its determinants and their precise effects have to be known.

Accordingly, many researchers have investigated this topic. In order to gain an

overview of the determinants identified in these works, they can be structured in three

dimensions:



 (1)    Company-related determinants refer to the supplier itself or to the goods or

       services offered. It is a prerequisite for the existence of customer loyalty that

       the offered goods or services create utility for the customer and that they are

       available. In this respect, an assessment is usually performed by examining

       quality. In order to evaluate the price-performance ratio, customers will pay

       attention to prices. Customer loyalty will also be influenced by the reputation

       a company has and ultimately by customer loyalty programs offered.



 (2)   Relationship-related determinants play a significant role in long-term

       relationships. Factors regarding the interaction between supplier and
customer, such as relationship quality, previous experiences, and trust are

      important. Commitment, which provides evidence of emotional closeness and

      moral or normative feelings of obligation, takes a central role in relationships.

      Specificity and dependence can lead to economic, psychological and social

      switching barriers.



(3)   Customer-related determinants are mainly influenced by customers’

      characteristics. In this respect, affect and involvement, and consequently also

      the importance of the good or service to the customer, are important. In

      addition to the above delineated areas, the effects of the market environment

      and competition are researched, as is the link between satisfaction and loyalty,

      which plays an important role in the research of customer loyalty and is often

      placed in one of the three dimensions. However, as most other determinants

      influence satisfaction, it cannot be clearly separated and should therefore be

      listed as a distinct category.
 customer-satisfaction
COMPANY PROFILE

Overview

          Logistics market is all set to experience a period of explosive organic growth,

judging by independent market analyst Datamonitor's latest research. The

Datamonitor report, "India Logistics Outlook 2007," predicts high double-digit

growth rates for both outsourced and contract logistics in India.



          With India's gross domestic profit (GDP) growing at over 9% per year and the

manufacturing sector enjoying double digit growth rates, the Indian logistics industry

is at an inflection point, and is expected to reach a market size of over $125 billion in

year 2010.



          Strong growth enablers exist in India today in the form of over $300 billion

worth of infrastructure investments, phased introduction of value-added-tax (VAT),

and development of organized retail and agri-processing industries. In addition, strong

foreign direct investment inflows (FDI) in automotive, capital goods, electronics,

retail, and telecom will lead to increased market opportunities for providers of 3PL in

India."



          However, as a result of the under-developed trade and logistics infrastructure,

the logistics cost of the Indian economy is over 13% of GDP, compared to less than

10% of GDP in almost the entire Western Europe and North America.
As leading manufacturers realign their global portfolios of manufacturing

locations, India will have to work on such systemic inefficiencies, in order to attract

and retain long-term real investments.



       3PL/outsourced logistics is the outsourcing of a company's logistics operations

to a specialized firm, which provides multiple tactical logistics services for use by

customers as opposed to the respective company having a business unit in-house to

oversee its supply chain and transportation of goods.



Some Facts:


   •   Market Size US $ 1.5 Billion
   •   Growth rate between 15 to 20% per annum


   •   International gateways:
           o Mumbai
           o Delhi,
           o Chennai
   •   Domestic gateways
           o Mumbai,
           o Delhi,
           o Kolkata,
           o Chennai,
           o Bangalore,
           o Hyderabad,
           o Pune,
           o Salem,
           o Ambala,
o Gauwhati,
          o Ahmedabad,
          o Nagpur.


  •   Employs over 1.2 Million people


  •   Air express witnessed maximum growth in the air cargo market
  •   In 2007 over 1.70 Billion shipments handled


  •   Air traffic grows faster than anywhere in the world


  •   Total cargo traffic increased by 21.5 % in 2006-07


  •   126 airport


  •   14 int‘l airport account for 96 % of total freight traffic


  •   Estimated market size US$ 1.5 Billion


  •   High growth rate


  •   Express market expected to grow more than 20 %


  •   India‘s Express industry bigger than tea and entertainment industry


  •   2nd fastest growing major economy




About DHL
DHL is a Deutsche Post World Net company of Germany that provides
international Mail, Express, Logistics and Finance. The company was founded in
1969 by Adrian Dalsey, Larry Hillblom, and Robert Lynn.

        The trio initially provided a courier service between the Continental United
States and Hawaii then expanded the business from there. In 1998, Deutsche Post
World Net began to acquire shares in DHL, finally reached majority ownership in
2001, and completed the purchase in 2002.

        DHL's global headquarters are located in Bonn and London (its Exel
subsidiary). Headquarters for the Americas are located in Plantation, Florida, while its
Asia Pacific & EEMEA headquarters are located respectively in Singapore &
Bahrain/Brussels.

        DHL owns its own cargo airlines, European Air Transport, originally based in
Brussels, and DHL Air, based at the East Midlands Airport in the United Kingdom.
EAT moved from Brussels Airport in Belgium to Leipzig/Halle Airport in Germany
in Spring 2008 with its fleet of Boeing 757SF freighters and Airbus A300 B4
freighters. Leipzig is now DHL major European Airline hub with dedicated brand
new facilities.

        Major competitors of DHL include:


            • FedEx.
            • UPS.
            • TNT.
            • United States Postal Service and,
            • Royal Mail.

As on 2006 DHL employees around 2,85,000 people across the various locations.
 customer-satisfaction
REVIEW OF LITERATURE

Logistics


        After having presented the necessary fundamentals of customer loyalty in the

preceding section, this section will elaborate on the reference point of the research

project, i.e. logistics. For that, the first section will present different views on logistics

and lay the notional basis for the understanding of logistics embraced in this study. As

relationships between logistics service providers and their customers are to be

analyzed, the logistics outsourcing phenomenon will be detailed, before taxonomy of

logistics service providers is provided.




Nature of Logistics


        Logistics is an established discipline both in theory and in practice, yet there is

no agreement on a universal definition of logistics. One widely accepted view stems

from the Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals (CSCMP). In their

latest definition (CSCMP 2005), logistics management is seen as “that part of Supply

Chain Management that plans, implements, and controls the efficient, effective

forward and reverses flow and storage of goods, services and related information

between the point of origin and the point of consumption in order to meet customers'

requirements.”This view is clearly marked by the economic objectives of

effectiveness and efficiency and regards logistics as part of supply chain management.
Other definitions e.g. that of Weber and Kummer are broader and refer to

logistics as a flow-oriented design of all value-creation processes. At the base of their

understanding is the empirically backed assumption that there are different stages of

maturity in logistics. While there are several researchers that also argue for stage

models of logistics development, there is no unity as to how many stages such a

model has. The model that will be briefly examined in this section stems from Weber,

who identifies four maturity stages. These stages are determined by the level of

logistics knowledge present in a firm and require path-dependent development from

the lowest to the highest level of logistics knowledge:




       In the first maturity stage, logistics is a specialized service function that

provides transportation, handling, and storage services that are necessary for an

efficient flow of materials and goods. Weber states that this stage of logistics maturity

was first observable in the 1950s, when markets changed from suppliers’ to buyers’

markets, requiring improved materials flows to succeed in the changed market

environment. This is in line with Bowersox and Daugherty, who confirm that

advanced logistical organizations barely existed at that time. Effects of this paradigm-

change were two-fold. On the one hand, logistics optimization was achieved through

process improvements and advances in forecasting and planning techniques. On the

other hand, organizational changes took place, as many companies institutionalized

their logistics functions in dedicated departments and therefore created a specialized

service function that was separated from other functions such as procurement or

manufacturing.
The second stage of logistics maturity was initiated by contextual changes in

the economic environment. In addition, advances in technology facilitated

communication and networks between different departments in companies’ state. As a

result, firms realized that efficiency could be increased by improving the coordination

of materials flows from inbound streams in procurement through the value creation

process in manufacturing to outbound streams in distribution. Through this focus on

the integration of different functions, cost and performance benefits were achieved.

Weber provides coordination of lot-sizes and just-in-time supply and production as

examples of these benefits.

        The following third stage of logistics maturity was necessitated by further

changes of the market environment. Simon points out that the intensity of competition

increased, an effect attributable to over-capacities, and a world-wide convergence of

product quality, shortened product-life-cycles, and a strengthened focus on customer

demands. The required simultaneous focus on differentiation and cost leadership was

not feasible under the prevalent functional structures and rigid organizational systems.

Instead, a process-oriented intra-company value chain that reduces complexity was

needed to succeed in the changing market environment. Hence, logistics evolved from

a mere functional concept to a management concept or, as from operational to

strategic orientation.




        The fourth and, for the time being, last maturity stage of logistics development

is again driven by market pressures. When companies realized that optimization

potentials within the organization had been largely exploited, the focus of attention
was furthered to include upstream and downstream partners in the supply chain. In

this sense, the view of logistics as a management concept from the third maturity

stage is ex-tended over company boundaries and can be labeled supply chain

management (SCM).




        This underlines the outstanding importance of logistics for companies, which

can realize significant economic benefits by allocating management capacities to the

improvement of logistics and the creation of flow-oriented organizations. A way, in

which many companies presently try to accomplish this, is by outsourcing parts or all

of their logistics activities to third parties.




Logistics Service Providers


        If a company employs an outside provider to perform some or all of its

logistics activities, this outside provider is termed a logistics service provider. These

LSPs were originally only offering a very narrow spectrum of services, mainly

consisting of transportation or warehousing services. In order to react to changing

demands from their customers, as pointed out in the preceding sections, LSPs have

started to offer integrated service portfolios that include a multitude of different

services. According to, five types of LSPs can currently be distinguished: carriers,

couriers & express & parcel/postal (CEP), freight forwarders, third-party LSPs

(3PLs), and fourth-party LSPs (4PLs), which will be briefly described below.
Carriers are firms that own assets for transportation purposes. These as-sets

are usually confined to road, sea, air, or rail transportation. In some cases, however,

carriers own several of the aforementioned transportation assets. management of

capacity and load-factor optimization are at the core of the carrier business. CEP

providers are also transportation providers. As opposed to carriers, CEP providers

send parcels or mail though their networks, employing different transportation

vehicles and incorporating handling at hubs. In this way, they can virtually supply

door-to-door services anywhere in the world, without having to rely on any third

parties. Core competencies of CEP providers are the operation and management of

highly complex distribution networks.




       Freight forwarders are intermediaries between suppliers and buyers of

transportation services. In most cases, brokers carry out additional ser-vices, such as

transportation planning and management, including the associated provision of

information systems. In some cases, brokers also dispose of their own transportation

assets. Bundling and coordination of demand for transportation services are the core

competencies of brokers.




       In contrast to the aforementioned LSPs, 3PLs or contract LSPs offer their

customers logistics solutions that often include management capacities. These

solutions most commonly include several services, such as warehousing and
pick/pack operations that are carried out on a longer-term contractual basis.

Sometimes, customers’ value chains, such as fleet management, order handling,

complaints management, call centers, or assembly services. A recent addition to the

list of types of LSPs comes in the form of 4PLs. While there is no universal

agreement on the definition of the 4PL, the cur-rent state of the debate establishes

4PLs as suppliers of complete logistics systems, without carrying out the services

themselves. Instead, 4PLs sub-contract all operations from other LSPs and confine

themselves to the management of logistics systems. Thus, they do not dispose of any

logistical assets and are a neutral intermediary between businesses and asset-based

LSPs.




        As 3PLs form the point of reference for logistics outsourcing as dealt with in

this study, the existing notional ambiguities in research have to be examined. Author

to identify different types of 3PLs. To him, there are four distinct classes of 3PLs:




        (1) asset-based 3PLs use their own assets (e.g. trucks and warehouses) to offer

              dedicated logistics services;



        (2)     management-based       3PLs    supply   logistics   management   through

information           systems or consulting;



        (3) Integrated 3PLs use their own assets to provide logistics services, but also

              subcontract from other vendors if necessary; and
(4) administration-based 3PLs mainly offer administrative management (e.g.

           Freight payment).




THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK


Social Exchange Theory


       Social exchange theory deals with “the relational interdependence, or

relational contract, that develops over time through the interactions of the ex-change

partners.” While this concept has only entered marketing theory in the 1980s, the

discussion goes as far back as to the Greek philosopher Aristotle, who distinguished

social exchange from economic exchange in his Nicomachean Ethics. Later,

sociologists such as Blau and Emerson, as well as social psychologists such as

Thibaut and Kelley worked on the concept of social exchange.




       On the basis of a thorough investigation of social exchange literature, Lambe,

Wittmann, and Spekman summarize the following four foundational premises of

social exchange theory, which will be detailed below:



   •   Exchange interactions result in economic and/or social outcomes,

   •   These outcomes are compared over time to other exchange alternatives to

       determine dependence on the exchange relationship

   •   Positive outcomes over times increase firms’ trust of their trading partner(s)

       and their commitment to the exchange relationship, and
•   Positive exchange interactions over time produce relational exchange norms

       that govern the exchange relationship.



       In contrast to pure economic theories, social exchange theory thus incorporates

both economic and social outcomes, highlighting the fact that social as well as

economic considerations are made when evaluating the value of relationships. This

value results from an assessment of both utilities and costs of a relationship, and

parties will choose to uphold a relationship as long as the cost-utility-ratio is

satisfactory. The exact composition of utilities and costs varies from individual to

individual, and more emphasis may be put on either social or economic aspects.




       When appraising the value of a relationship, parties will not only consider

current and past costs and utilities, but also potential future benefits, and may forego

present benefits for benefits in the future. Therefore, an important factor in social

exchange theory is trust, which results from multiple and beneficial interactions over

time. Only if the trading partner is trusted, will one be willing to reciprocate the

abdication of cur-rent benefits for future benefits. Another important aspect of social

exchange theory is commitment, which is fostered by trust. This causal relationship

between trust and commitment is based on the principle of generalized reciprocity,

because commitment entails vulnerability and parties will seek only trustworthy

partners.
Social exchange theory’s foundational premises indicate that relation-ships are

not only governed by contracts, but also by norms, which develop as a consequence of

repeated interaction and “increase the efficiency of relationships because by agreeing

to the manner in which interactions take place, the degree of uncertainty may be

reduced.” As with trust, norms are adhered to because rewards are expected.



       While social exchange theory can be very useful conceptually, it is mainly

criticized for its lack of empirical foundation. Factors such as commitment and trust

should be able to substitute (at least in part) contractual governance structures, but this

cannot be confirmed empirically. Presumably, this is attributable to social exchange

theory’s neglect of opportunism.




Equity Theory


       Equity theory represents an extension of social exchange theory by adding the

aspect of fairness. While the concept dates back to Homans, equity theory was

primarily coined by Adams. At that time referred to as “theory of inequity”, it was

introduced to explain wage inequities. The basic assumption underlying equity theory

is that each party in a relationship compares its input-output-ratio to that of the other

party. Analogous to social exchange theory, social as well as economic considerations

are incorporated in the evaluation of fairness.




       In case the ratio is balanced, the perception of being fairly treated is conveyed.

Otherwise, one feels unfairly treated, arousing distress for both the over-benefited and
the under-benefited parties, which may lead to emotional and behavioral

consequences. In order to re-create fairness, parties can change their inputs, adjust

their expectations, influence the other party, or terminate the relationship.




       As in social exchange theory, the input-output-ratios of the involved parties do

not have to be in balance at any given time. Instead, parties must trust that outcomes

be split equitably in the long-run




Commitment Trust Theory


       Morgan and Hunt in 1994 first introduced commitment trust theory in their

article on successful relationship marketing. According to them, commitment and

trust function as key mediating variables between five antecedents (relationship

termination costs, relationship benefits, shared values, and opportunistic behavior)

and five outcomes (acquiescence, propensity to leave, cooperation, functional conflict,

and decision-making uncertainty). By highlighting commitment and trust, Morgan

and Hunt’s theory is based on the fundamental ideas of social exchange theory. At the

same time, one of the major deficits of social exchange theory is addressed by

allowing for opportunistic behavior.




       Considerations by Morgan and Hunt were spurred by a shift in marketing

research and practice away from a mere transactional focus towards the relationship

marketing approach, according to which all marketing activities are supposed to
establish, develop, and maintain successful relational exchanges. While Morgan and

Hunt ac-knowledge that many contextual factors determine the success or failure of

relationship marketing efforts, commitment and trust are seen as key, be-cause they

can establish relational governance norms. As such, commitment and trust can

encourage cooperative behavior aimed at preserving relationship investments,

mitigate the risk of choosing attractive short-term alternatives despite of expected

long-term benefits with existing exchange partners, and can make high-risk actions

appear more attractive, because exchange partners are not feared to act

opportunistically. “Therefore, when both commitment and trust – not just one or the

other – are present, they produce outcomes that promote efficiency, productivity, and

effectiveness.”




The six key factors that influence customer loyalty




       According to Peter Clark, co-editor of The Wise Marketer and co-author

of The Loyalty Guide report series, there are six major factors that play key

roles in influencing the loyalty and commitment of customers:
Figure 1: Factors that influence customer loyalty
 customer-satisfaction
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY


Objective of the study




     A study on customer level of satisfaction in towards DHL Express (I)

         Pvt Ltd



     To identify the loyalty of customer towards DHL Express (I) Pvt.

         Ltd.



     To measure the specific reasons for satisfaction and dissatisfaction in

         with DHL Express.



     To identify the recommendations of DHL Express to others by

         existing loyal customers.
Scope of the study




     Scope of the study mainly to know the current level of customer

         satisfaction.



     Scope of the study mainly to know the loyalty of the customer

         towards the company.



     To give suggestion regarding improvement of performance standard

         of the Company



     To inform the management about current level.
Limitations of the study




     Time limit restricts detailed survey work for this particular topic of

         research



     The survey is restricted to the customers of DHL Express I Pvt ltd

         who are involved in imports.



     Some customers have lack of time, so they may not communicate

         properly.
Research design

       The objective of the study has been achieved by using both Primary and
Secondary Data’s. The data’s obtained for the study was primarily from field
investigation carried out among the customers of DHL.


Sampling


       Sample design is a definite plan for obtaining a sample from a given
population. It refers to the technique or the procedure the researcher would adopt in
selecting items for samples.


       Samples are studied for the population who are the customers of DHL Express
I Pvt. Ltd. Research design is needed because it facilitates the smooth railing of the
various research operations thereby making research as effective as possible yielding
maximal information with minimal expenditure of effort, time and money.


Sample Size


       The Customers, to whom DHL provides service is taken into consideration.
The sample size is 85.


Primary Data


       Primary data was collected through Online Survey



          http://dhl-customerloyalty.surveyconsole.com/

       Survey Research:
Survey research as name suggests, is distinguished by the facts that the data
are collected from the people who are thought to have the desired information,
through questionnaire.


       Questionnaire was posted over the internet and sent to the respective
customers in order to collect information related to the topic. The questionnaires so
designed for this purpose were structured.




Secondary Data


       Secondary data was collected through company websites and records. And
analysis on various aspects has been done using different statistical techniques.


The methods followed for the analysis and interpretation of data are:

   •   Uni variate Percentage Analysis
   •   Weighted average method



       •      Univariate Percentage Analysis:



       Percentage refers to a special kind of ratio. It is used to make comparison
between two or more series of data. They can be used to compare the relative items,
the distribution of two or more series of data, since the percentages reduces every
thing to a common base and there by allow meaningful comparisons to be made. Here
only one factor is considered.


                          NO OF RESPONDENTS
PERCENTAGE          =                                  x 100
                         TOTAL RESPONDENTS
•   Weighted Average Method:


         This method is a used when the relative importance of the different items is
not the same. The term weighted stands for the relative importance of the different
items. It is assumed that inventory costs should be assigned on the basis of average
costs of identical units. An average cost unit is determined by dividing the total costs
of the units by the number of units.


The weighted average method is logical when assigning costs to units that become
mixed together, there by making separate identification difficult or impossible.
The formula is:


__               ∑ WX
X        =
                 ∑W


Where;


X        = Weighted Arithmetic mean


X        = Frequency or no of response dents


W        = Weighted allotted to each factor
 customer-satisfaction
DATA ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION

Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL
representative through Telephone.




       Options                       Respondents          Percentage
       Excellent                         16                   20 %

       Very Good                         16                   20 %

       Good                              32                   40 %

       Fair                              16                   20 %

       Poor                               0                    0%

       Total                             80                  100 %

                                         Table - 1




    Interpretation:


                20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to


accessibility and responses through Telephone is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very


good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so


they said that the service is fair
Poor
                    Fair       0%            Excellent
                    20%                        20%



                                                                     Excellent
                                                                     Very Good
                                                                     Good
                                                                     Fair
                                                    Very Good
                                                                     Poor
                                                       20%



                   Good
                   40%




                                      Figure - 2




(Chart showing Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of
                 DHL representative through Telephone)
Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL
representative through E-mail.




       Options                       Respondents         Percentage
       Excellent                         16                  20 %

       Very Good                         16                  20 %

       Good                              32                  40 %

       Fair                              16                  20 %

       Poor                               0                  0%

       Total                             80                 100 %



                                         Table - 2




    Interpretation:


                20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to


accessibility and responses through E-mail is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very


good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so


they said that the service is fair
Poor
                 Fair      0%            Excellent
                 20%                       20%



                                                                 Excellent
                                                                 Very Good
                                                                 Good
                                                                 Fair
                                                Very Good
                                                                 Poor
                                                   20%



                Good
                40%




                                  Figure - 3




(Chart showing Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses
                of DHL representative through E-mail)
Clearance representative ability to help customer issue/need




       Options                       Respondents            Percentage
       Excellent                            15                   19 %
       Very Good                            17                   21 %
       Good                                 22                   28 %
       Fair                                 19                   24 %
       Poor                                  7                   9%
       Total                                80                  100 %

                                            Table - 3



Interpretation:



        `       19 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to ability


to help resolve issue or need is Excellent. Next 21 % says it is very good. Good being


awarded by 28 % of the customer. 24 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the


service is fair. 9 % is not satisfied with the service.
Poor
                     9%                Excellent
                                         19%



          Fair
                                                                 Excellent
          24%
                                                                 Very Good
                                                                 Good
                                                                 Fair
                                               Very Good
                                                  21%            Poor




                      Good
                      27%




                                 Figure - 4




(Chart showing Clearance representative ability to help customer issue/need)
Customers Overall experience with DHL Clearance Department




       Options                       Respondents          Percentage
       Excellent                            17               21%
       Very Good                            15               19%
       Good                                 14               18%
       Fair                                 30               38%
       Poor                                  4               5%
       Total                                80              100 %

                                            Table - 4



Interpretation:



                21 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with


DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 19 % says it is very good. Good being


awarded by 18 % of the customer. 38% is somewhat satisfied so they said that the


service is fair. 5 % is not satisfied with the service.
Poor
                    5%
                                     Excellent
                                       21%




                                                           Excellent
      Fair                                                 Very Good
      37%                                                  Good
                                                           Fair
                                           Very Good       Poor
                                             19%




                           Good
                           18%




                            Figure - 5




(Chart showing Customers Overall experience with DHL Clearance
                           Department)
Customers Overall experience with DHL Shipment Delivery at doorstep




       Options                       Respondents          Percentage
       Excellent                             9               11%
       Very Good                            25               31%
       Good                                 40               50%
       Fair                                  4               5%
       Poor                                  2               3%
       Total                                80              100 %

                                            Table - 5



Interpretation:



                11 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with


DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 31 % says it is very good. Good being


awarded by 50 % of the customer. 5 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the


service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service.
Fair Poor        Excellent
                       5% 3%              11%




                                                                Excellent
                                                                Very Good
                                                                Good
                                                    Very Good
                                                      31%       Fair
                                                                Poor
             Good
             50%




                                   Figure - 6




(Chart showing Customers Overall experience with DHL Shipment Delivery at
                                   doorstep)
Customer Satisfaction level with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd




      Options                      Respondents             Percentage
      Extremely Satisfied                15                     19%
      Satisfied                          20                     25%
      Neutral                            22                     28%
      Dissatisfied                       18                     23%
      Extremely Dissatisfied              5                      6%
      Total                              80                    100 %

                                        Table - 6



Interpretation:



                19 % of the customers responded they are Extremely Satisfied with the


service. Next 25 % they are satisfied. Neutral is 22 % of the customer. 23 % is


somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the


service.
Extremely
                 Dissatisfied
                     6%         Extremely Satisfied
                                      19%
      Dissatisfied
         23%                                           Extremely Satisfied
                                                       Satisfied
                                                       Neutral
                                                       Dissatisfied
                                    Satisfied
                                      25%              Extremely Dissatisfied

                Neutral
                 27%




                                Figure - 7




(Chart showing Customer Satisfaction level with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd)
Customer Responses or Reasons for satisfaction with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd




   •   Less transit time



   •   Clear tracking



   •   Advance furnishing of documents



   •   Keeping customer fully informed



   •   Timely clearance



   •   Good Shipment delivery at doorstep




Interpretation:




       Various reasons are given by customers for satisfaction like less transit time,


Clear tracking, Advance furnishing of documents, keeping customer fully informed,


Timely clearance, Good Shipment delivery at doorstep etc.
Customer Responses or Reasons for Dissatisfaction with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd




   •   Original Bill of Entry getting only after 3 days after our follow up, this should

       come along with delivery



   •   Freight Bill received 30 days after delivery this should deliver within 24 hrs,

       so that your payment will not be delayed



   •   The currency some times wrongly mention in the B/E before filing with

       Customs, check the invoice or check with the customer - this will help

       avoiding mistake.



   •   In some of the instances your response is not proper



   •   Since express service is preferred only when there are some urgency, though

       the cargo reaches at airport. clearance team takes minimum 7-25days takes for

       customs clearance



   •   Commitment not met in several cases



Interpretation:



       Various reasons are given by customers for dissatisfaction. The company need


more focused approach for satisfying the customers
Recommend DHL Express to others




      Options                     Respondents           Percentage
      Yes                               51                  64%
      No                                29                  36%
      Total                             80                 100 %

                                       Table - 7




Interpretation:



          64 % of the customer responded in favour of recommending DHL Express to


others. On the other hand 36 % of the people say No to recommend DHL Express to


others.
No
        36%

                                                       Yes
                                                       No

                                  Yes
                                  64%




                     Figure - 8




(Chart showing Recommendation DHL Express to others)
Over the past years loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger




      Options                    Respondents             Percentage
      Yes                               55                    69%
      No                                25                    31%
      Total                             80                   100 %

                                       Table - 8




Interpretation:



       69 % of the customer responded in favour that loyalty towards DHL Express


has grown stronger. On the other hand 31 % of the people say No that loyalty towards


DHL Express has not grown stronger.
No
                  31%


                                                                      Yes
                                                                      No


                                            Yes
                                            69%




                               Figure - 9




(Chart showing status of loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger)
DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals




      Options                    Respondents             Percentage
      Yes                               41                    51%
      No                                39                    49%
      Total                             80                   100 %



                                       Table - 9




Interpretation:




       51 % of the customer responded in favour that DHL Express Values people &


Relationships ahead of Short-term goals. On the other hand 49 % of the people say No


that DHL Express do not Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals.
No                                                 Yes
                                             Yes
                 49%                         51%                     No




                              Figure – 10




(Chart showing DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-
                              term goals)
 customer-satisfaction
FINDINGS


•   20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility


    and responses through Telephone is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good.


    Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so


    they said that the service is fair



•   20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility


    and responses through E-mail is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good.


    Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so


    they said that the service is fair



•   19 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to ability to help


    resolve issue or need is Excellent. Next 21 % says it is very good. Good being


    awarded by 28 % of the customer. 24 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that


    the service is fair. 9 % is not satisfied with the service.



•   21 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL


    clearance department is Excellent. Next 19 % says it is very good. Good being
awarded by 18 % of the customer. 38% is somewhat satisfied so they said that


    the service is fair. 5 % is not satisfied with the service.




•   11 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL


    clearance department is Excellent. Next 31 % says it is very good. Good being


    awarded by 50 % of the customer. 5 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that


    the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service.




•   19 % of the customers responded they are Extremely Satisfied with the


    service. Next 25 % they are satisfied. Neutral is 22 % of the customer. 23 % is


    somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with


    the service.



•   64 % of the customer responded in favour of recommending DHL Express to


    others. On the other hand 36 % of the people say No to recommend DHL


    Express to others.
•   69 % of the customer responded in favour that loyalty towards DHL Express


    has grown stronger. On the other hand 31 % of the people say No that loyalty


    towards DHL Express has not grown stronger.




•   51 % of the customer responded in favour that DHL Express Values people &


    Relationships ahead of Short-term goals. On the other hand 49 % of the people


    say No that DHL Express do not Values people & Relationships ahead of


    Short-term goals.
 customer-satisfaction
SUGGESTIONS

•   Communicate. Whether it is an email newsletter, monthly flier, a reminder

    card for a tune up, or a holiday greeting card, reach out to your steady

    customers.



•   Customer Service. Go the extra distance and meet customer needs. Train the

    staff to do the same. Customers remember being treated well.




•   Employee Loyalty. Loyalty works from the top down. If you are loyal to your

    employees, they will feel positively about their jobs and pass that loyalty

    along to your customers.




•   Employee Training. Train employees in the manner that you want them to

    interact with customers. Empower employees to make decisions that benefit

    the customer.




•   Customer Incentives. Give customers a reason to return to your business. For

    instance, because children outgrow shoes quickly, the owner of a children’s

    shoe store might offer a card that makes the tenth pair of shoes half price.

    Likewise, a dentist may give a free cleaning to anyone who has seen him

    regularly for five years.
•   Product Awareness. Know what your steady patrons purchase and keep these

    items in stock. Add other products and/or services that accompany or

    compliment the products that your regular customers buy regularly. And make

    sure that your staff understands everything they can about your products.




•   Reliability. If you say a purchase will arrive on Wednesday, deliver it on

    Wednesday. Be reliable. If something goes wrong, let customers know

    immediately and compensate them for their inconvenience.




•   Be Flexible. Try to solve customer problems or complaints to the best of your

    ability. Excuses — such as "That's our policy" — will lose more customers

    then setting the store on fire..

•   People over Technology. The harder it is for a customer to speak to a human

    being when he or she has a problem, the less likely it is that you will see that

    customer again.



•   Know Their Names. Remember the theme song to the television show Cheers?

    Get to know the names of regular customers or at least recognize their faces.
 customer-satisfaction
CONCLUSIONS



       In addition to suggestions and findings, this study also provides several scopes
for further research, which will be addressed in the following paragraphs:


 (1)   While the customer loyalty model validated in this study possesses good
       power for explaining repurchase intentions and referral behavior, only partial
       explanation of the construct of additional purchase intentions is achieved. As
       stated before, factors not contained in the model such as strategic outsourcing
       considerations can be assumed to affect the intention of customers to
       outsource additional logistics activities to the currently most important LSP.
       For this reason, future studies should explore additional determinants of this
       loyalty dimension.


 (2)   Measurement model assessment revealed that the operationalization of
       fairness in this study does not achieve sufficient discriminance from other
       constructs, especially from trust and relational satisfaction. As there is a strong
       theoretical indication that fairness is important in customer loyalty
       considerations, further studies should modify fair-ness’ measurement model,
       e.g. by more strongly recurring to the concept of inequity.



 (3)   Within this study, four relational characteristics were examined. In addition,
       analyses were conducted for a multitude of other contingency factors that are
       not included in the present study. Overall, however, no conclusive
       moderations were identified. Nevertheless, it may be assumed that customer
       diversity still has moderating effects on the formation of customer loyalty. The
       determinants contained in this study, however, capture rather general
       evaluations of relationships between LSPs and their customers, which may be
       too broad to be subject to moderating effects. For this reason it would be
       sensible to examine antecedents of the employed determinants, as moderating
       effects could surface when this level of detail is added to the analyses.
 customer-satisfaction
 customer-satisfaction
 customer-satisfaction
DHL Customer Satisfaction & Loyalty Survey




•    How would you rate your overall experience to accessablity and responses
     (of DHL representative) through phone and e-mail :



    Excellent
    Very Good
    Good
    Fair

    Poor



•    How you rate the representative ability to help you resolve your
     issue/need?



    Excellent
    Very Good
    Good

    Fair
    Poor


•    How you rate the representative on being Courteous & helpfulness?



    Excellent
    Very Good

    Good
    Fair
    Poor
•    Think specifically about the CLEARANCE Department, How would you rate
     your overall experience:



    Excellent
    Very Good

    Good
    Fair
    Poor




•    Think specifically about the SHIPMENT DELIVERY at your doorstep, How
     would you rate your overall experience:



    Excellent

    Very Good
    Good
    Fair
    Poor




•    In scale of 1 to 5, where 1 represents ‘Extremely Dissatisfied’ and 5
     represents ‘Extremely Satisfied’. How would you rate your level of
     satisfaction with DHL Express.



     1

     2
     3
     4
     5
What specifically are you SATISFIED with DHL Express, Chennai. Enter your
response below: { E.g., - Safety & security, Excellent tracking, Less transit time }




What specifically are you DISSATISFIED with DHL Express, Chennai. Enter your
response below: {E.g, - Commitment not met. etc.}




   •    How likely are you to recommend DHL Express to others? The chances are:



       Excellent
       Very Good
       Good
       Fair

       Poor




   •    In total, how long you have been a customer of DHL Express:



       More then 10 years
       7 to 10 years
       5 to 7 years

       3 to 5 years
       Less then 3 years
Please list top 3 reasons, initially becoming a member of DHL Express in order of
importance:




Please rate your level of agreement with the following statements. In scale of 1 to
5, where 1 represents ‘Completely Disagree’ , 3 represents ‘Neutral’ and 5 being
‘Completely Agree’



    I believe the company, DHL Express deserves my loyalty:



        1                2              3               4               5




    Over the past years, my loyalty to the company, DHL Express has grown
stronger:



        1                2              3               4               5




    DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals:




       1                 2              3               4               5




*
••• Suggestions ••• ( if any)
Thanks for your valuable feedback.
 customer-satisfaction
 customer-satisfaction
BIBLIOGRAPHY

Books:
   •     Research Methodology – Kothari
   •     The Loyalty Guide report series - Peter Clark
   •     Marketing Management 12 e – Philip Kotler



Websites:

   •     www.google.com
   •     www.wikipedia.com
   •     www.dhl.com
   •     www.scribd.com

Más contenido relacionado

La actualidad más candente

Summer training project_report
Summer training project_reportSummer training project_report
Summer training project_reportlavyans
 
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.amidlonelybond11
 
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds Bharath Nair
 
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-ac
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-acRole of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-ac
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-acHeisenberg26
 
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics Shivansh Dwivedi
 
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...RishikeshMishra34
 
indicom project report of tara saini
indicom project report of tara sainiindicom project report of tara saini
indicom project report of tara sainiTara Saini
 
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...Avinash Labade
 
summer training Certificate
summer training Certificatesummer training Certificate
summer training CertificateAjay Kumar
 
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotech
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotechMBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotech
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotechDinesh Jogdand
 
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee Bangalore
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee BangaloreSummer Internship Project Report at Arokee Bangalore
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee BangaloreSiddharth Bhatnagar
 
HR policies in HCL by monika ndim
HR policies in HCL by monika ndimHR policies in HCL by monika ndim
HR policies in HCL by monika ndimMonika S
 
MBA Internship report - Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...
MBA Internship report -  Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...MBA Internship report -  Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...
MBA Internship report - Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...Santanu Das
 
MBA Dissertation1ai
MBA Dissertation1aiMBA Dissertation1ai
MBA Dissertation1aiAnil Mehta
 
Summer Internship Project report- Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...
Summer Internship Project report-  Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...Summer Internship Project report-  Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...
Summer Internship Project report- Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...Shubham Dasgupta
 

La actualidad más candente (20)

MBA project
MBA projectMBA project
MBA project
 
Summer training project_report
Summer training project_reportSummer training project_report
Summer training project_report
 
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.
Amit mishra live project report on hcl infinet ltd.
 
MBA PROJECT
MBA PROJECTMBA PROJECT
MBA PROJECT
 
dissertation project
dissertation projectdissertation project
dissertation project
 
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds
Employee perception towards training at kerala feeds
 
HR policy report
HR policy reportHR policy report
HR policy report
 
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-ac
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-acRole of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-ac
Role of indian_logistics_industry_in_international_trade-dissertation-ac
 
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics
Impact on sales by Advertising & marketing Strategies in Mahindra logistics
 
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...
A Study on Employee Relationship Management at Ray Technology and Business So...
 
indicom project report of tara saini
indicom project report of tara sainiindicom project report of tara saini
indicom project report of tara saini
 
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...
A Study of business analysis oil & Natural Gas Corporation RJ Capital Oversea...
 
Front pages
Front pagesFront pages
Front pages
 
summer training Certificate
summer training Certificatesummer training Certificate
summer training Certificate
 
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotech
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotechMBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotech
MBA (IT) SIP Report on RIInfotech
 
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee Bangalore
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee BangaloreSummer Internship Project Report at Arokee Bangalore
Summer Internship Project Report at Arokee Bangalore
 
HR policies in HCL by monika ndim
HR policies in HCL by monika ndimHR policies in HCL by monika ndim
HR policies in HCL by monika ndim
 
MBA Internship report - Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...
MBA Internship report -  Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...MBA Internship report -  Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...
MBA Internship report - Customer Awareness and Market potential of geographi...
 
MBA Dissertation1ai
MBA Dissertation1aiMBA Dissertation1ai
MBA Dissertation1ai
 
Summer Internship Project report- Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...
Summer Internship Project report-  Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...Summer Internship Project report-  Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...
Summer Internship Project report- Customer Satisfaction Analysis: Reliance S...
 

Destacado

Megafoni
MegafoniMegafoni
Megafonicendoo1
 
Album komiksowy Chopinium.pl
Album komiksowy Chopinium.plAlbum komiksowy Chopinium.pl
Album komiksowy Chopinium.plcendoo1
 
Presspad
PresspadPresspad
Presspadcendoo1
 
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarska
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra SitarskaStart-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarska
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarskacendoo1
 
Polakpotrafi
PolakpotrafiPolakpotrafi
Polakpotraficendoo1
 
Miasteczko Multimedialne
Miasteczko MultimedialneMiasteczko Multimedialne
Miasteczko Multimedialnecendoo1
 
Pawel Fornalski
Pawel FornalskiPawel Fornalski
Pawel Fornalskicendoo1
 
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.pl
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.plAlbum vlepkowy Chopinium.pl
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.plcendoo1
 
Presskiosk
PresskioskPresskiosk
Presskioskcendoo1
 
Rafal Brzoska
Rafal BrzoskaRafal Brzoska
Rafal Brzoskacendoo1
 
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...cendoo1
 
Audioteka
AudiotekaAudioteka
Audiotekacendoo1
 
MOD Reforms Office presentation
MOD Reforms Office presentation MOD Reforms Office presentation
MOD Reforms Office presentation Lala Zinkevich
 
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010retailtherapy90
 

Destacado (18)

Vocals
VocalsVocals
Vocals
 
Megafoni
MegafoniMegafoni
Megafoni
 
SaveUp
SaveUpSaveUp
SaveUp
 
Album komiksowy Chopinium.pl
Album komiksowy Chopinium.plAlbum komiksowy Chopinium.pl
Album komiksowy Chopinium.pl
 
Presspad
PresspadPresspad
Presspad
 
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarska
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra SitarskaStart-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarska
Start-up - Animili.pl - Przepis na serwis dla dzieci, Aleksandra Sitarska
 
Polakpotrafi
PolakpotrafiPolakpotrafi
Polakpotrafi
 
Miasteczko Multimedialne
Miasteczko MultimedialneMiasteczko Multimedialne
Miasteczko Multimedialne
 
Tomek
TomekTomek
Tomek
 
Pawel Fornalski
Pawel FornalskiPawel Fornalski
Pawel Fornalski
 
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.pl
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.plAlbum vlepkowy Chopinium.pl
Album vlepkowy Chopinium.pl
 
Presskiosk
PresskioskPresskiosk
Presskiosk
 
Pozycz
PozyczPozycz
Pozycz
 
Rafal Brzoska
Rafal BrzoskaRafal Brzoska
Rafal Brzoska
 
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...
Czym zabłysnę gdy przyjdzie konkurencja, i jak trzymać wydatki na obsługę Kli...
 
Audioteka
AudiotekaAudioteka
Audioteka
 
MOD Reforms Office presentation
MOD Reforms Office presentation MOD Reforms Office presentation
MOD Reforms Office presentation
 
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010
Group C - Demo 22 Oct 2010
 

Similar a customer-satisfaction

Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And Cargo
Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And CargoCustomer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And Cargo
Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And CargoPrachiChauhan10
 
Oil & gas bpcl
Oil & gas bpclOil & gas bpcl
Oil & gas bpclCyrus Cool
 
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection process
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection processProject report on evaluation of recruitment and selection process
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection processElina Pari
 
Training and development in axis bank
Training and development in axis bankTraining and development in axis bank
Training and development in axis bankAmmy Chohan
 
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdf
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdfROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdf
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdfPrinceVerma938105
 
A study on the Employee Satisfaction
A study on the Employee SatisfactionA study on the Employee Satisfaction
A study on the Employee SatisfactionAtul K. Shukla
 
Mba hr & finance project may 2014
Mba hr & finance project  may 2014Mba hr & finance project  may 2014
Mba hr & finance project may 2014City Union Bank Ltd
 
Employee engagement
Employee engagementEmployee engagement
Employee engagementGuna MBA
 
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]basudeb das.
 
Employee retention 1
Employee retention 1Employee retention 1
Employee retention 1manisa1992
 
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdfKamal Deep
 
Analysis of recruitment and selection process
Analysis of recruitment and selection processAnalysis of recruitment and selection process
Analysis of recruitment and selection processNeethu yadav
 
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup company
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup companyA study on branding strategies via social media for a statup company
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup companyRachana Patil
 
trainning and development sip report of ism patna
trainning and development sip report of ism patnatrainning and development sip report of ism patna
trainning and development sip report of ism patnaANIKET SINHA
 
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)Pooja MBA (2015-2017)
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)Pooja Singh
 
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptx
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptxBhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptx
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptxShivaniVindhane
 
MBA Summer Training Project Report
MBA Summer Training Project Report MBA Summer Training Project Report
MBA Summer Training Project Report Aparna Sharma
 

Similar a customer-satisfaction (20)

FINAL PROJECT
FINAL PROJECTFINAL PROJECT
FINAL PROJECT
 
04 project report .pdf
04 project report .pdf04 project report .pdf
04 project report .pdf
 
Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And Cargo
Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And CargoCustomer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And Cargo
Customer Satisfaction Towards Professional Courier And Cargo
 
Oil & gas bpcl
Oil & gas bpclOil & gas bpcl
Oil & gas bpcl
 
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection process
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection processProject report on evaluation of recruitment and selection process
Project report on evaluation of recruitment and selection process
 
Training and development in axis bank
Training and development in axis bankTraining and development in axis bank
Training and development in axis bank
 
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdf
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdfROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdf
ROSHNI KUMARI PANDEY new file.pdf
 
A study on the Employee Satisfaction
A study on the Employee SatisfactionA study on the Employee Satisfaction
A study on the Employee Satisfaction
 
Mba hr & finance project may 2014
Mba hr & finance project  may 2014Mba hr & finance project  may 2014
Mba hr & finance project may 2014
 
Employee engagement
Employee engagementEmployee engagement
Employee engagement
 
Project2[1]
Project2[1]Project2[1]
Project2[1]
 
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]
A project report_on_distribution_and_channel_management_in_cachar_paper_mill[1]
 
Employee retention 1
Employee retention 1Employee retention 1
Employee retention 1
 
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf
“EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT.pdf
 
Analysis of recruitment and selection process
Analysis of recruitment and selection processAnalysis of recruitment and selection process
Analysis of recruitment and selection process
 
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup company
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup companyA study on branding strategies via social media for a statup company
A study on branding strategies via social media for a statup company
 
trainning and development sip report of ism patna
trainning and development sip report of ism patnatrainning and development sip report of ism patna
trainning and development sip report of ism patna
 
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)Pooja MBA (2015-2017)
Pooja MBA (2015-2017)
 
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptx
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptxBhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptx
Bhagyashri Patil SIP Presentation.pptx
 
MBA Summer Training Project Report
MBA Summer Training Project Report MBA Summer Training Project Report
MBA Summer Training Project Report
 

Último

Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfSourav Sikder
 
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessQ2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessAPCO
 
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor PresentationMoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentationbaron83
 
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursDeveloping Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursKaiNexus
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHelene Heckrotte
 
Intellectual Property Licensing Examples
Intellectual Property Licensing ExamplesIntellectual Property Licensing Examples
Intellectual Property Licensing Examplesamberjiles31
 
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003believeminhh
 
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBBPMedia1
 
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView
 
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyAnyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyHanna Klim
 
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfPDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfHajeJanKamps
 
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating Performance
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating PerformanceSix Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating Performance
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating PerformanceOperational Excellence Consulting
 
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfCompany Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfRobertPhillips265023
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsIntellect Design Arena Ltd
 

Último (20)

Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global Panel book-unlock 2024
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
 
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessQ2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
 
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV IndustriesInvestment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
 
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor PresentationMoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
 
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursDeveloping Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
 
WAM Corporate Presentation Mar 25 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation Mar 25 2024.pdfWAM Corporate Presentation Mar 25 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation Mar 25 2024.pdf
 
Intellectual Property Licensing Examples
Intellectual Property Licensing ExamplesIntellectual Property Licensing Examples
Intellectual Property Licensing Examples
 
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
 
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
 
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
 
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyAnyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
 
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfPDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
 
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating Performance
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating PerformanceSix Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating Performance
Six Sigma Improvement Process: Transforming Processes, Elevating Performance
 
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfCompany Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
 
Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDFSixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
 

customer-satisfaction

  • 1. CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND LOYALTY IN LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD A PROJECT REPORT Submitted in Partial fulfillment of the degree of requirement for the award of MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMISTRATION (Marketing & HR) Submitted by GAURAB DUTTA Registration No: P07BA126 Under the guidance of Dr. S. Lalitha Prof. in Management Studies BHARATH UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES Chennai 600073 India May 2009
  • 2. School of Management Studies 173, Agaram Road, Selaiyur, CHENNAI 600 073 Ph: 044-22290125, 22290742; Telefax: 044-22293886 Web: www.bharathuniv.com; Mobile 09380408052 CERTIFICATE This is to Certify that the Project report on “CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND LOYALTY IN LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD” is a bonafide work and submitted by Mr. Gaurab Dutta in partial fulfillment of the degree of Master of Business Administration, School of Management Studies, Bharath University, during 2007–2009. This certificate is issued based on the declaration by the candidate. Dr. S. Lalitha Prof. N. M. Jaffer (Project Guide) (HOD) Project Report evaluated & Viva Voice held on …………….
  • 3. INTERNAL EXAMINER EXTERNAL EXAMINER DECLARATION BY CANDIDATE I declare that this project work on “CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND LOYALTY IN LOGISTICS SERVICES @ DHL EXPRESS (I) PVT LTD” is a bonafide work done and submitted by me and the research work was carried out under the guidance of Mr. Rajkumar Krishnan, Clearance Supervisor, DHL Express (I) Pvt. Ltd. and under overall supervision of Dr. S. Lalitha, Professor, School of Management Studies, Bharath University. I further declare that this Project Report does not form of any other project reports or dissertations on the basis of which a degree was awarded or conferred on an earlier occasion on me or any other candidate. Place: Chennai Date: Gaurab Dutta
  • 4. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I express my deep sense of gratitude to our beloved chairman Dr. S. Jagathrakshagan for giving me a wonderful opportunity for doing Master of Business Administration in this esteemed institution I wish to place my deep sense of gratitude to Mr. Rajkumar Krishnan, Clearance Supervisor, DHL Express (I) Pvt. Ltd. For his valuable guidance throughout the project. Foremost, I would like to thank Dr. N. M. Jaffer, HOD, School Of Management Studies, Bharath University, for his intensity and focus on technical aspects and for taking all efforts to make my journey smooth on the information technology super highway. It is a privilege to have him as our faculty. I consider it a great privilege to be under the guidance of Dr. S. Lalitha, Professor, School of Management Studies, Bharath University. The contribution and significant role played by her help me in preparation and submission of project report in time. I gratefully acknowledge the team of staff members in M.B.A department for helping me in all aspects and giving their valuable ideas for making my project efficient and effective. Last but not the least I would like to thank my parents and friends for their valuable support and encouragement through out the course of the project. Gaurab Dutta
  • 5. CONTENTS Chapters Page No. 1. Introduction 1 2. Company Profile 15 3. Review of Literature 19 4. Research Methodology 29 5. Data Analysis and Interpretation 35 6. Findings 55 7. Suggestions 57 8. Conclusions 59 9. Annexure I 10. Bibliography II
  • 7. INTRODUCTION Research Motivation A multitude of companies today has already identified the need to create a loyal customer base and acknowledges that maintaining existing customers and extending business with them is significantly less expensive than acquiring new customers. Empirical proof of the proliferation of such customer loyalty efforts in the business world is e.g. provided in the form of loyalty programs, which many companies have installed during the past years. By engaging in efforts aimed at creating customer loyalty, which in turn fosters financial success in monetary terms firms react to increasing competitive challenges. Within research, the investigation of customer loyalty gained importance when the classic marketing paradigm with its instrumental and transactional orientation proved unsuitable in the context of longer-term business relationships. Instead, the relationship marketing approach, which is specifically concerned with the study of relational ex-changes, gained importance within research, serving as a conceptual foundation for the majority of customer loyalty researchers. The question of how loyalty develops has been subject to an abundance of research, leading to an expansive body of literature on loyalty determinants. The extant literature exploring different factors and their constituent effects on loyalty, however, reveals a strong focus on consumer goods and industrial equipment settings,
  • 8. while industrial services have received relatively little attention so far. In addition, the majority of articles incorporates merely a few potential determinants and thus fails to draw a comprehensive picture of the mechanisms of customer loyalty formation. Place: Chennai Just like other businesses, logistics service providers (LSPs) are faced with increasing competitive pressure that urges them to concentrate not only on operational business processes, but also on an efficient and effective customer management. In the US alone, LSPs’ revenues grew from US-$ 31 billion in 1995 to US-$ 85 billion in 2004 and logistics outsourcing expenditures as a fraction of total logistics expenditures are at over 40% and expected to rise even further. One way to meet this challenge of rapid growth and expansion, according to Langley et al. is to focus on establishing, maintaining, and developing relationships with customers. An often proposed driver of logistics outsourcing is the need to develop and maintain competitive advantage, which customers of LSPs intend to achieve through concentrating on core competencies and re-engineering. Another important driver is the ongoing globalization, which several authors regard as the most important challenge that companies are facing. In this context, LSPs can play an important role as facilitators of global trade. Along with globalization, however, companies that outsource logistics activities increasingly try to consolidate the number of LSPs they use globally. Therefore, LSPs do not only have to devise sustain-able growth strategies, but also have to develop intercultural management competencies, a challenge hardly ad-dressed in LSP management literature.
  • 9. While intercultural management deals with the influence of culture on management styles in different countries, it is also arguable whether a one best way management paradigm is applicable even within national confines. LSPs’ customers are extremely diverse and similarly, relationships between LSPs and their customers can be expected to exhibit momentous differences. As such, it is a crucial management issue for LSPs to de-sign their customer loyalty efforts in a manner that accounts for both cultural context and different relationship characteristics. Research goals As outlined in the preceding section, LSPs are confronted with diverse management challenges that result from continuous growth, globalization, and customer diversity. The aim of the present study therefore is to identify determinants of customer loyalty in relationships between LSPs and their customers by explicitly considering different characteristics and cultural contexts of such relationships. In this sense, the present research is positioned at the interface of marketing and logistics and is intended to contribute not only to logistics research, but also to research in marketing, customer loyalty, and cultural studies. In order to address the concept of customer loyalty, it is important to understand the mechanisms underlying loyalty in the logistics outsourcing context. For this reason, the starting point of the present research will be the study of Wallenburg, who studied customer loyalty within relationships between LSPs and
  • 10. their customers. On this basis, factors that can be surmised to determine customer loyalty in such relationships will be proposed and interdependencies between these factors will be identified. The resulting comprehensive explanatory model of customer loyalty will not only provide insights into the constitution of customer loyalty, but will also serve as the basis for subsequent analyses. As stated previously, a globalizing marketplace and the need of LSPs to render logistics services on an international scale requires intercultural management competencies. Before being able to apply such management techniques, though, a thorough understanding of cultural differences between different countries is necessary. The present study will therefore provide a starting point for such analyses by investigating cultural differences between two important markets for logistics outsourcing, the USA and Germany. Particular differences between Germany and the USA will be identified and applied to the previously devised customer loyalty model. As a result, differences between the two countries with respect to the formation of customer loyalty can be inferred. Finally, this study will investigate in how far different relationship conditions influence the development of customer loyalty. For this purpose, important relationship characteristics will be identified and their moderating influences on the customer loyalty model will be examined. This will provide information on the robustness of the customer loyalty model versus relational contingencies and will suggest if it is necessary to differentiate customer loyalty efforts accordingly.
  • 11. Customer Satisfaction The term logistics is often misinterpreted to mean transportation. In fact, the scope of logistics goes well beyond transportation. Logistics forms the system that ensures the delivery of the product in the entire supply pipeline. This includes transportation, packaging, storage and handling methods, and information flow. The impact of logistics in the ability of a company to satisfy its customers cannot be overstated. All other efforts at modernization within a company would not bear fruit until the logistics system is carefully designed to facilitate the smooth and efficient flow of goods in the system. The topic of logistics is relatively new in India. There have been some companies that have done work in this area, but a large number of companies are only now beginning to realize the benefits of designing and managing the entire supply chain. With India joining the global marketplace, the role of logistics assumes greater importance. The industrial policies in India have prompted manufacturers to build plants in remote, backward areas due to inexpensive land and tax benefits. This poses some serious logistical problems. Apart from a poor road and transportation network, the existing communications system in India leaves a lot to be desired by any international standard. It is in this context that logistics has to be considered in India. Customer Satisfaction in 7 Steps
  • 12. 1. Encourage Face-to-Face Dealings This is the most daunting and downright scary part of interacting with a customer. If you're not used to this sort of thing it can be a pretty nerve-wracking experience. Rest assured, though, it does get easier over time. It's important to meet your customers face to face at least once or even twice during the course of a project. 2. Respond to Messages Promptly & Keep Your Clients Informed This goes without saying really. We all know how annoying it is to wait days for a response to an email or phone call. It might not always be practical to deal with all customers' queries within the space of a few hours, but at least email or call them back and let them know you've received their message and you'll contact them about it as soon as possible. Even if you're not able to solve a problem right away, let the customer know you're working on it. 3. Be Friendly and Approachable A fellow Site Pointer once told me that you can hear a smile through the phone. This is very true. It's very important to be friendly, courteous and to make your clients feel like you're their friend and you're there to help them out. There will be
  • 13. times when you want to beat your clients over the head repeatedly with a blunt object - it happens to all of us. It's vital that you keep a clear head, respond to your clients' wishes as best you can, and at all times remain polite and courteous. 4. Have a Clearly-Defined Customer Service Policy This may not be too important when you're just starting out, but a clearly defined customer service policy is going to save you a lot of time and effort in the long run. If a customer has a problem, what should they do? If the first option doesn't work, then what? Should they contact different people for billing and technical enquiries? If they're not satisfied with any aspect of your customer service, who should they tell? There's nothing more annoying for a client than being passed from person to person, or not knowing who to turn to. Making sure they know exactly what to do at each stage of their enquiry should be of utmost importance. So make sure your customer service policy is present on your site -- and anywhere else it may be useful. 5. Attention to Detail (also known as 'The Little Niceties') Have you ever received a Happy Birthday email or card from a company you were a client of? Have you ever had a personalized sign-up confirmation email for a service that you could tell was typed from scratch? These little niceties can be time consuming and aren't always cost effective, but remember to do them.
  • 14. Even if it's as small as sending a Happy Holidays email to all your customers, it's something. It shows you care; it shows there are real people on the other end of that screen or telephone; and most importantly, it makes the customer feel welcomed, wanted and valued. 6. Anticipate Your Client's Needs & Go Out Of Your Way to Help Them Out Sometimes this is easier said than done! However, achieving this supreme level of understanding with your clients will do wonders for your working relationship. 7. Honour Your Promises It's possible this is the most important point in this article. The simple message: when you promise something, deliver. Clients don't like to be disappointed. Sometimes, something may not get done, or you might miss a deadline through no fault of your own. Projects can be late, technology can fail and sub-contractors don't always deliver on time. In this case a quick apology and assurance it'll be ready ASAP wouldn't go a miss. Customer Loyalty
  • 15. Obtaining a thorough understanding of customer loyalty is a prerequisite for the execution of the research at hand. For that, the development of customer loyalty research within the framework of relationship marketing will be presented first, before different customer loyalty concepts will be introduced. From these concepts, a definition of customer loyalty for use in this study will be derived, before both consequences and antecedents of customer loyalty will be portrayed. Since the beginning of the 1990s, customer loyalty has gained importance both in relationship marketing research and in business. In business, this can be attributed to changing market- and competition-environments. Due to a shift from a sellers’ to a buyers’ market and because of an increasing degree of globalization, most industries find themselves confronted with new challenges. In a first phase, firms tried to face these challenges by focusing on their internal processes and organizational structures, trying to achieve cost reductions by concentrating on internal improvements. A second phase of external focus followed, where firms directed attention to their customers, trying to retain existing ones and to win over new ones (churning). Since “acquiring new customers is much more expensive than keeping them”. And “loyal customers are the bedrock of any business”. A loyal customer base represents a barrier to entry, a basis for a price premium, time to respond to competitor innovations, and a bulwark against deleterious price competition. Loyalty is critical to brand volume, is highly correlated to market share, and can be used as the basis of predicting future market share; consequently, understanding loyalty appears critical to any meaningful analysis of marketing strategy.
  • 16. In marketing research, two trends mark the development of customer loyalty. While individual transactions initially were in the center of marketing research, the focus shifted towards analyzing relationships states that the ‘traditional’ marketing concept of the marketing mix with its ‘4 Ps’, developed in the middle of the last century, had been the established approach until the 1990s. This approach, how-ever, focuses solely on transactions, a deficit tackled by the relationship marketing approach. At the core of it is the study of relationships between buyers and sellers of goods or services, in contrast to merely examining transactions. An often cited and comprehensive definition of relationship marketing is provided “Relationship marketing refers to all marketing activities directed toward establishing, developing, and maintaining successful relational exchanges.” Therefore, the relationship marketing approach pro-vides a suitable environment in which customer loyalty research can be nested. While the development of relationship marketing began in the early 1970s, it was not until the late 1980s that works from the ‘Nordic School of Services’. Initiated a paradigm shift that geared marketing towards the creation, conservation, and extension of buyer-seller relationships. Although relationship marketing today is widely accepted among marketing researchers, its promoters do not postulate the replacement of the transactional approach, but rather juxtapose the two approaches. For example, delineates a strategy continuum, in which different goods require different degrees of transaction- and relationship-based marketing strategies. As a
  • 17. result of the focus on relationships in marketing research, customer loyalty gained importance within research. Before determining which stream the present study can be associated with, however, it is important to create a clear understanding of different customer loyalty concepts prevalent in research. This will be accomplished in the following section. Customer Loyalty Concepts Reviewing research, it becomes obvious that the notion of customer loyalty is blurred. At its core, customer loyalty deals with relationships between suppliers and their customers and can be distinguished from other loyalty aspects, such as brand loyalty, which refer to a more abstract attachment, such as that towards a brand. Within German customer loyalty literature, the notion of customer loyalty is even more faceted, encompasses both ‘customer loyalty’ and ‘customer retention’ distinguishes an active, supplier-focused component and a passive, customer focused component of customer loyalty. In the supplier-focused perspective, customer loyalty is seen as a bundle of measures that aim at improving relationships with customers. The supplier is in the center of attention and the customer is only regarded as the factor at which success of customer loyalty becomes manifest. Here it becomes clear that this approach contains a conceptual deficit. It is the customer who eventually decides on whether customer loyalty management is successful or not, because all activities undertaken by a
  • 18. supplier can only be geared at influencing customers to be loyal. A customer-focused perspective therefore has to be added to evaluate the success of customer loyalty management. Within the customer-focused perspective, customer loyalty is conceptualized taking into account customers’ complex characteristics. These can either be approached as customers’ directly observable actions and/or take into account their attitudes and intentions. Since customers’ actions are directly influenced by their attitudes and intentions, it is obvious that these have to be scrutinized to understand and manage loyalty. A third perspective is a synthesis of the former two approaches. The relationship-focused perspective directly examines the relationship between suppliers and customers. Accordingly, the objects of study in this perspective usually are buying behavior in retail contexts and long-term relationships marked by frequent interaction between suppliers and buyers in industrial contexts. It is clear that the supplier-focused perspective with its instrumental approach is significantly different from the other two approaches. Distinguishing the customer- and the relationship-focused perspective, however, is difficult, because both focus on the customer.  Behaviorist customer loyalty concepts Behaviorist concepts of customer loyalty have been at the core of early marketing research and focus on customers’ observable behavior, as e.g. in
  • 19. purchasing behavior. Accordingly, customer loyalty is established, when customers demonstrate consistency in their choice of supplier or brand. “Hard-core” loyalty, when one product alternative is exclusively repurchased and of “reinforcing” loyalty, when customers switch among brands but repeat-purchase one or more alternatives to a significant extent. Similarly, customer loyalty as “the proportion of times a purchaser chooses the same product or service in a specific category compared to the total number of purchases made by the purchaser in that category“. Pegging customer loyalty to purchasing behavior, however, is very critical, there can be a multitude of factors affecting purchasing behavior, such as product availability or special deals, which are not grasped by looking at purchases alone. A main deficit of the behavioristic approach thus is that it does not look at the drivers’ behind purchasing behavior. Another disadvantage of behavioristic customer loyalty concepts is their ex- post approach. When loyalty is only expressed through purchases, information on customers’ actual loyalty status in between purchases is not available. Consequently, decreasing loyalty is only recognized after it manifests itself through changed purchasing behavior. Only in relationships with frequent interaction can a supplier integrate further aspects, such as complaints, into customer loyalty management. The reason, why behavioristic concepts may still be valuable, is because the measurement of customer loyalty in this approach does not necessitate involvement by the customer. The assessment of attitudes and intentions would always imply customers’ cooperation through participation in surveys. By simply recording purchases, e.g. through delivery records in the industrial context or customer cards in a consumer
  • 20. context; the assessment of customer loyalty poses little difficulty. Particularly in areas, where most purchases can be easily ascribed to individual customers, as is the case with mail-ordering or book-stores on the internet, the behavioristic approach is useful for identifying different customer groups and their characteristics. Such firms, however, can only assess purchases of their own products, while purchases of competing products go unnoticed. Firms can therefore neither draw conclusions about relative changes of purchasing behaviors, nor evaluate their comparative market position.  Neo-behaviorist customer loyalty concepts These narrow technical definitions do not adequately capture the richness and depth of the loyalty construct implicit in a relational framework.” Consequently, neo- behavioristic customer loyalty concepts start at the shortcomings of the behavioristic approach by examining the causes of loyalty. As early as 1969, Day concluded that “loyalty should be evaluated with both attitudinal and behavioral criteria” otherwise accidental repeat-purchases, merely resulting from situational exigencies, would be regarded as indicators of loyalty. There is no agreement, however, on the question, whether attitudes are part of customer loyalty or merely an antecedent of it. Some authors propose that only positive attitude can lead to ‘true’ customer loyalty. If attitude then is a necessary prerequisite of customer loyalty, some drivers of loyalty cannot be explained. Transaction cost theory, for instance, provides the concept of asset specificity. Relationship-specific investments create economic switching barriers and therefore increase customer loyalty. However, the mere repeat purchase of goods or services for reasons of economic constraints would not qualify as loyalty, as
  • 21. positive attitudes are not involved. In order to avoid the outlined problem, it is useful to abstain from defining positive attitude to be a necessary antecedent of loyalty. Instead, researchers usually consider intentions and observable behavior to be the constituting elements of customer loyalty. Determinants of Customer Loyalty In order to be able to gear marketing activities towards the creation of customer loyalty, its determinants and their precise effects have to be known. Accordingly, many researchers have investigated this topic. In order to gain an overview of the determinants identified in these works, they can be structured in three dimensions: (1) Company-related determinants refer to the supplier itself or to the goods or services offered. It is a prerequisite for the existence of customer loyalty that the offered goods or services create utility for the customer and that they are available. In this respect, an assessment is usually performed by examining quality. In order to evaluate the price-performance ratio, customers will pay attention to prices. Customer loyalty will also be influenced by the reputation a company has and ultimately by customer loyalty programs offered. (2) Relationship-related determinants play a significant role in long-term relationships. Factors regarding the interaction between supplier and
  • 22. customer, such as relationship quality, previous experiences, and trust are important. Commitment, which provides evidence of emotional closeness and moral or normative feelings of obligation, takes a central role in relationships. Specificity and dependence can lead to economic, psychological and social switching barriers. (3) Customer-related determinants are mainly influenced by customers’ characteristics. In this respect, affect and involvement, and consequently also the importance of the good or service to the customer, are important. In addition to the above delineated areas, the effects of the market environment and competition are researched, as is the link between satisfaction and loyalty, which plays an important role in the research of customer loyalty and is often placed in one of the three dimensions. However, as most other determinants influence satisfaction, it cannot be clearly separated and should therefore be listed as a distinct category.
  • 24. COMPANY PROFILE Overview Logistics market is all set to experience a period of explosive organic growth, judging by independent market analyst Datamonitor's latest research. The Datamonitor report, "India Logistics Outlook 2007," predicts high double-digit growth rates for both outsourced and contract logistics in India. With India's gross domestic profit (GDP) growing at over 9% per year and the manufacturing sector enjoying double digit growth rates, the Indian logistics industry is at an inflection point, and is expected to reach a market size of over $125 billion in year 2010. Strong growth enablers exist in India today in the form of over $300 billion worth of infrastructure investments, phased introduction of value-added-tax (VAT), and development of organized retail and agri-processing industries. In addition, strong foreign direct investment inflows (FDI) in automotive, capital goods, electronics, retail, and telecom will lead to increased market opportunities for providers of 3PL in India." However, as a result of the under-developed trade and logistics infrastructure, the logistics cost of the Indian economy is over 13% of GDP, compared to less than 10% of GDP in almost the entire Western Europe and North America.
  • 25. As leading manufacturers realign their global portfolios of manufacturing locations, India will have to work on such systemic inefficiencies, in order to attract and retain long-term real investments. 3PL/outsourced logistics is the outsourcing of a company's logistics operations to a specialized firm, which provides multiple tactical logistics services for use by customers as opposed to the respective company having a business unit in-house to oversee its supply chain and transportation of goods. Some Facts: • Market Size US $ 1.5 Billion • Growth rate between 15 to 20% per annum • International gateways: o Mumbai o Delhi, o Chennai • Domestic gateways o Mumbai, o Delhi, o Kolkata, o Chennai, o Bangalore, o Hyderabad, o Pune, o Salem, o Ambala,
  • 26. o Gauwhati, o Ahmedabad, o Nagpur. • Employs over 1.2 Million people • Air express witnessed maximum growth in the air cargo market • In 2007 over 1.70 Billion shipments handled • Air traffic grows faster than anywhere in the world • Total cargo traffic increased by 21.5 % in 2006-07 • 126 airport • 14 int‘l airport account for 96 % of total freight traffic • Estimated market size US$ 1.5 Billion • High growth rate • Express market expected to grow more than 20 % • India‘s Express industry bigger than tea and entertainment industry • 2nd fastest growing major economy About DHL
  • 27. DHL is a Deutsche Post World Net company of Germany that provides international Mail, Express, Logistics and Finance. The company was founded in 1969 by Adrian Dalsey, Larry Hillblom, and Robert Lynn. The trio initially provided a courier service between the Continental United States and Hawaii then expanded the business from there. In 1998, Deutsche Post World Net began to acquire shares in DHL, finally reached majority ownership in 2001, and completed the purchase in 2002. DHL's global headquarters are located in Bonn and London (its Exel subsidiary). Headquarters for the Americas are located in Plantation, Florida, while its Asia Pacific & EEMEA headquarters are located respectively in Singapore & Bahrain/Brussels. DHL owns its own cargo airlines, European Air Transport, originally based in Brussels, and DHL Air, based at the East Midlands Airport in the United Kingdom. EAT moved from Brussels Airport in Belgium to Leipzig/Halle Airport in Germany in Spring 2008 with its fleet of Boeing 757SF freighters and Airbus A300 B4 freighters. Leipzig is now DHL major European Airline hub with dedicated brand new facilities. Major competitors of DHL include: • FedEx. • UPS. • TNT. • United States Postal Service and, • Royal Mail. As on 2006 DHL employees around 2,85,000 people across the various locations.
  • 29. REVIEW OF LITERATURE Logistics After having presented the necessary fundamentals of customer loyalty in the preceding section, this section will elaborate on the reference point of the research project, i.e. logistics. For that, the first section will present different views on logistics and lay the notional basis for the understanding of logistics embraced in this study. As relationships between logistics service providers and their customers are to be analyzed, the logistics outsourcing phenomenon will be detailed, before taxonomy of logistics service providers is provided. Nature of Logistics Logistics is an established discipline both in theory and in practice, yet there is no agreement on a universal definition of logistics. One widely accepted view stems from the Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals (CSCMP). In their latest definition (CSCMP 2005), logistics management is seen as “that part of Supply Chain Management that plans, implements, and controls the efficient, effective forward and reverses flow and storage of goods, services and related information between the point of origin and the point of consumption in order to meet customers' requirements.”This view is clearly marked by the economic objectives of effectiveness and efficiency and regards logistics as part of supply chain management.
  • 30. Other definitions e.g. that of Weber and Kummer are broader and refer to logistics as a flow-oriented design of all value-creation processes. At the base of their understanding is the empirically backed assumption that there are different stages of maturity in logistics. While there are several researchers that also argue for stage models of logistics development, there is no unity as to how many stages such a model has. The model that will be briefly examined in this section stems from Weber, who identifies four maturity stages. These stages are determined by the level of logistics knowledge present in a firm and require path-dependent development from the lowest to the highest level of logistics knowledge: In the first maturity stage, logistics is a specialized service function that provides transportation, handling, and storage services that are necessary for an efficient flow of materials and goods. Weber states that this stage of logistics maturity was first observable in the 1950s, when markets changed from suppliers’ to buyers’ markets, requiring improved materials flows to succeed in the changed market environment. This is in line with Bowersox and Daugherty, who confirm that advanced logistical organizations barely existed at that time. Effects of this paradigm- change were two-fold. On the one hand, logistics optimization was achieved through process improvements and advances in forecasting and planning techniques. On the other hand, organizational changes took place, as many companies institutionalized their logistics functions in dedicated departments and therefore created a specialized service function that was separated from other functions such as procurement or manufacturing.
  • 31. The second stage of logistics maturity was initiated by contextual changes in the economic environment. In addition, advances in technology facilitated communication and networks between different departments in companies’ state. As a result, firms realized that efficiency could be increased by improving the coordination of materials flows from inbound streams in procurement through the value creation process in manufacturing to outbound streams in distribution. Through this focus on the integration of different functions, cost and performance benefits were achieved. Weber provides coordination of lot-sizes and just-in-time supply and production as examples of these benefits. The following third stage of logistics maturity was necessitated by further changes of the market environment. Simon points out that the intensity of competition increased, an effect attributable to over-capacities, and a world-wide convergence of product quality, shortened product-life-cycles, and a strengthened focus on customer demands. The required simultaneous focus on differentiation and cost leadership was not feasible under the prevalent functional structures and rigid organizational systems. Instead, a process-oriented intra-company value chain that reduces complexity was needed to succeed in the changing market environment. Hence, logistics evolved from a mere functional concept to a management concept or, as from operational to strategic orientation. The fourth and, for the time being, last maturity stage of logistics development is again driven by market pressures. When companies realized that optimization potentials within the organization had been largely exploited, the focus of attention
  • 32. was furthered to include upstream and downstream partners in the supply chain. In this sense, the view of logistics as a management concept from the third maturity stage is ex-tended over company boundaries and can be labeled supply chain management (SCM). This underlines the outstanding importance of logistics for companies, which can realize significant economic benefits by allocating management capacities to the improvement of logistics and the creation of flow-oriented organizations. A way, in which many companies presently try to accomplish this, is by outsourcing parts or all of their logistics activities to third parties. Logistics Service Providers If a company employs an outside provider to perform some or all of its logistics activities, this outside provider is termed a logistics service provider. These LSPs were originally only offering a very narrow spectrum of services, mainly consisting of transportation or warehousing services. In order to react to changing demands from their customers, as pointed out in the preceding sections, LSPs have started to offer integrated service portfolios that include a multitude of different services. According to, five types of LSPs can currently be distinguished: carriers, couriers & express & parcel/postal (CEP), freight forwarders, third-party LSPs (3PLs), and fourth-party LSPs (4PLs), which will be briefly described below.
  • 33. Carriers are firms that own assets for transportation purposes. These as-sets are usually confined to road, sea, air, or rail transportation. In some cases, however, carriers own several of the aforementioned transportation assets. management of capacity and load-factor optimization are at the core of the carrier business. CEP providers are also transportation providers. As opposed to carriers, CEP providers send parcels or mail though their networks, employing different transportation vehicles and incorporating handling at hubs. In this way, they can virtually supply door-to-door services anywhere in the world, without having to rely on any third parties. Core competencies of CEP providers are the operation and management of highly complex distribution networks. Freight forwarders are intermediaries between suppliers and buyers of transportation services. In most cases, brokers carry out additional ser-vices, such as transportation planning and management, including the associated provision of information systems. In some cases, brokers also dispose of their own transportation assets. Bundling and coordination of demand for transportation services are the core competencies of brokers. In contrast to the aforementioned LSPs, 3PLs or contract LSPs offer their customers logistics solutions that often include management capacities. These solutions most commonly include several services, such as warehousing and
  • 34. pick/pack operations that are carried out on a longer-term contractual basis. Sometimes, customers’ value chains, such as fleet management, order handling, complaints management, call centers, or assembly services. A recent addition to the list of types of LSPs comes in the form of 4PLs. While there is no universal agreement on the definition of the 4PL, the cur-rent state of the debate establishes 4PLs as suppliers of complete logistics systems, without carrying out the services themselves. Instead, 4PLs sub-contract all operations from other LSPs and confine themselves to the management of logistics systems. Thus, they do not dispose of any logistical assets and are a neutral intermediary between businesses and asset-based LSPs. As 3PLs form the point of reference for logistics outsourcing as dealt with in this study, the existing notional ambiguities in research have to be examined. Author to identify different types of 3PLs. To him, there are four distinct classes of 3PLs: (1) asset-based 3PLs use their own assets (e.g. trucks and warehouses) to offer dedicated logistics services; (2) management-based 3PLs supply logistics management through information systems or consulting; (3) Integrated 3PLs use their own assets to provide logistics services, but also subcontract from other vendors if necessary; and
  • 35. (4) administration-based 3PLs mainly offer administrative management (e.g. Freight payment). THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK Social Exchange Theory Social exchange theory deals with “the relational interdependence, or relational contract, that develops over time through the interactions of the ex-change partners.” While this concept has only entered marketing theory in the 1980s, the discussion goes as far back as to the Greek philosopher Aristotle, who distinguished social exchange from economic exchange in his Nicomachean Ethics. Later, sociologists such as Blau and Emerson, as well as social psychologists such as Thibaut and Kelley worked on the concept of social exchange. On the basis of a thorough investigation of social exchange literature, Lambe, Wittmann, and Spekman summarize the following four foundational premises of social exchange theory, which will be detailed below: • Exchange interactions result in economic and/or social outcomes, • These outcomes are compared over time to other exchange alternatives to determine dependence on the exchange relationship • Positive outcomes over times increase firms’ trust of their trading partner(s) and their commitment to the exchange relationship, and
  • 36. Positive exchange interactions over time produce relational exchange norms that govern the exchange relationship. In contrast to pure economic theories, social exchange theory thus incorporates both economic and social outcomes, highlighting the fact that social as well as economic considerations are made when evaluating the value of relationships. This value results from an assessment of both utilities and costs of a relationship, and parties will choose to uphold a relationship as long as the cost-utility-ratio is satisfactory. The exact composition of utilities and costs varies from individual to individual, and more emphasis may be put on either social or economic aspects. When appraising the value of a relationship, parties will not only consider current and past costs and utilities, but also potential future benefits, and may forego present benefits for benefits in the future. Therefore, an important factor in social exchange theory is trust, which results from multiple and beneficial interactions over time. Only if the trading partner is trusted, will one be willing to reciprocate the abdication of cur-rent benefits for future benefits. Another important aspect of social exchange theory is commitment, which is fostered by trust. This causal relationship between trust and commitment is based on the principle of generalized reciprocity, because commitment entails vulnerability and parties will seek only trustworthy partners.
  • 37. Social exchange theory’s foundational premises indicate that relation-ships are not only governed by contracts, but also by norms, which develop as a consequence of repeated interaction and “increase the efficiency of relationships because by agreeing to the manner in which interactions take place, the degree of uncertainty may be reduced.” As with trust, norms are adhered to because rewards are expected. While social exchange theory can be very useful conceptually, it is mainly criticized for its lack of empirical foundation. Factors such as commitment and trust should be able to substitute (at least in part) contractual governance structures, but this cannot be confirmed empirically. Presumably, this is attributable to social exchange theory’s neglect of opportunism. Equity Theory Equity theory represents an extension of social exchange theory by adding the aspect of fairness. While the concept dates back to Homans, equity theory was primarily coined by Adams. At that time referred to as “theory of inequity”, it was introduced to explain wage inequities. The basic assumption underlying equity theory is that each party in a relationship compares its input-output-ratio to that of the other party. Analogous to social exchange theory, social as well as economic considerations are incorporated in the evaluation of fairness. In case the ratio is balanced, the perception of being fairly treated is conveyed. Otherwise, one feels unfairly treated, arousing distress for both the over-benefited and
  • 38. the under-benefited parties, which may lead to emotional and behavioral consequences. In order to re-create fairness, parties can change their inputs, adjust their expectations, influence the other party, or terminate the relationship. As in social exchange theory, the input-output-ratios of the involved parties do not have to be in balance at any given time. Instead, parties must trust that outcomes be split equitably in the long-run Commitment Trust Theory Morgan and Hunt in 1994 first introduced commitment trust theory in their article on successful relationship marketing. According to them, commitment and trust function as key mediating variables between five antecedents (relationship termination costs, relationship benefits, shared values, and opportunistic behavior) and five outcomes (acquiescence, propensity to leave, cooperation, functional conflict, and decision-making uncertainty). By highlighting commitment and trust, Morgan and Hunt’s theory is based on the fundamental ideas of social exchange theory. At the same time, one of the major deficits of social exchange theory is addressed by allowing for opportunistic behavior. Considerations by Morgan and Hunt were spurred by a shift in marketing research and practice away from a mere transactional focus towards the relationship marketing approach, according to which all marketing activities are supposed to
  • 39. establish, develop, and maintain successful relational exchanges. While Morgan and Hunt ac-knowledge that many contextual factors determine the success or failure of relationship marketing efforts, commitment and trust are seen as key, be-cause they can establish relational governance norms. As such, commitment and trust can encourage cooperative behavior aimed at preserving relationship investments, mitigate the risk of choosing attractive short-term alternatives despite of expected long-term benefits with existing exchange partners, and can make high-risk actions appear more attractive, because exchange partners are not feared to act opportunistically. “Therefore, when both commitment and trust – not just one or the other – are present, they produce outcomes that promote efficiency, productivity, and effectiveness.” The six key factors that influence customer loyalty According to Peter Clark, co-editor of The Wise Marketer and co-author of The Loyalty Guide report series, there are six major factors that play key roles in influencing the loyalty and commitment of customers:
  • 40. Figure 1: Factors that influence customer loyalty
  • 42. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Objective of the study  A study on customer level of satisfaction in towards DHL Express (I) Pvt Ltd  To identify the loyalty of customer towards DHL Express (I) Pvt. Ltd.  To measure the specific reasons for satisfaction and dissatisfaction in with DHL Express.  To identify the recommendations of DHL Express to others by existing loyal customers.
  • 43. Scope of the study  Scope of the study mainly to know the current level of customer satisfaction.  Scope of the study mainly to know the loyalty of the customer towards the company.  To give suggestion regarding improvement of performance standard of the Company  To inform the management about current level.
  • 44. Limitations of the study  Time limit restricts detailed survey work for this particular topic of research  The survey is restricted to the customers of DHL Express I Pvt ltd who are involved in imports.  Some customers have lack of time, so they may not communicate properly.
  • 45. Research design The objective of the study has been achieved by using both Primary and Secondary Data’s. The data’s obtained for the study was primarily from field investigation carried out among the customers of DHL. Sampling Sample design is a definite plan for obtaining a sample from a given population. It refers to the technique or the procedure the researcher would adopt in selecting items for samples. Samples are studied for the population who are the customers of DHL Express I Pvt. Ltd. Research design is needed because it facilitates the smooth railing of the various research operations thereby making research as effective as possible yielding maximal information with minimal expenditure of effort, time and money. Sample Size The Customers, to whom DHL provides service is taken into consideration. The sample size is 85. Primary Data Primary data was collected through Online Survey http://dhl-customerloyalty.surveyconsole.com/ Survey Research:
  • 46. Survey research as name suggests, is distinguished by the facts that the data are collected from the people who are thought to have the desired information, through questionnaire. Questionnaire was posted over the internet and sent to the respective customers in order to collect information related to the topic. The questionnaires so designed for this purpose were structured. Secondary Data Secondary data was collected through company websites and records. And analysis on various aspects has been done using different statistical techniques. The methods followed for the analysis and interpretation of data are: • Uni variate Percentage Analysis • Weighted average method • Univariate Percentage Analysis: Percentage refers to a special kind of ratio. It is used to make comparison between two or more series of data. They can be used to compare the relative items, the distribution of two or more series of data, since the percentages reduces every thing to a common base and there by allow meaningful comparisons to be made. Here only one factor is considered. NO OF RESPONDENTS PERCENTAGE = x 100 TOTAL RESPONDENTS
  • 47. Weighted Average Method: This method is a used when the relative importance of the different items is not the same. The term weighted stands for the relative importance of the different items. It is assumed that inventory costs should be assigned on the basis of average costs of identical units. An average cost unit is determined by dividing the total costs of the units by the number of units. The weighted average method is logical when assigning costs to units that become mixed together, there by making separate identification difficult or impossible. The formula is: __ ∑ WX X = ∑W Where; X = Weighted Arithmetic mean X = Frequency or no of response dents W = Weighted allotted to each factor
  • 49. DATA ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL representative through Telephone. Options Respondents Percentage Excellent 16 20 % Very Good 16 20 % Good 32 40 % Fair 16 20 % Poor 0 0% Total 80 100 % Table - 1 Interpretation: 20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility and responses through Telephone is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so they said that the service is fair
  • 50. Poor Fair 0% Excellent 20% 20% Excellent Very Good Good Fair Very Good Poor 20% Good 40% Figure - 2 (Chart showing Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL representative through Telephone)
  • 51. Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL representative through E-mail. Options Respondents Percentage Excellent 16 20 % Very Good 16 20 % Good 32 40 % Fair 16 20 % Poor 0 0% Total 80 100 % Table - 2 Interpretation: 20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility and responses through E-mail is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so they said that the service is fair
  • 52. Poor Fair 0% Excellent 20% 20% Excellent Very Good Good Fair Very Good Poor 20% Good 40% Figure - 3 (Chart showing Customers overall experience to accessibility and responses of DHL representative through E-mail)
  • 53. Clearance representative ability to help customer issue/need Options Respondents Percentage Excellent 15 19 % Very Good 17 21 % Good 22 28 % Fair 19 24 % Poor 7 9% Total 80 100 % Table - 3 Interpretation: ` 19 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to ability to help resolve issue or need is Excellent. Next 21 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 28 % of the customer. 24 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 9 % is not satisfied with the service.
  • 54. Poor 9% Excellent 19% Fair Excellent 24% Very Good Good Fair Very Good 21% Poor Good 27% Figure - 4 (Chart showing Clearance representative ability to help customer issue/need)
  • 55. Customers Overall experience with DHL Clearance Department Options Respondents Percentage Excellent 17 21% Very Good 15 19% Good 14 18% Fair 30 38% Poor 4 5% Total 80 100 % Table - 4 Interpretation: 21 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 19 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 18 % of the customer. 38% is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 5 % is not satisfied with the service.
  • 56. Poor 5% Excellent 21% Excellent Fair Very Good 37% Good Fair Very Good Poor 19% Good 18% Figure - 5 (Chart showing Customers Overall experience with DHL Clearance Department)
  • 57. Customers Overall experience with DHL Shipment Delivery at doorstep Options Respondents Percentage Excellent 9 11% Very Good 25 31% Good 40 50% Fair 4 5% Poor 2 3% Total 80 100 % Table - 5 Interpretation: 11 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 31 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 50 % of the customer. 5 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service.
  • 58. Fair Poor Excellent 5% 3% 11% Excellent Very Good Good Very Good 31% Fair Poor Good 50% Figure - 6 (Chart showing Customers Overall experience with DHL Shipment Delivery at doorstep)
  • 59. Customer Satisfaction level with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd Options Respondents Percentage Extremely Satisfied 15 19% Satisfied 20 25% Neutral 22 28% Dissatisfied 18 23% Extremely Dissatisfied 5 6% Total 80 100 % Table - 6 Interpretation: 19 % of the customers responded they are Extremely Satisfied with the service. Next 25 % they are satisfied. Neutral is 22 % of the customer. 23 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service.
  • 60. Extremely Dissatisfied 6% Extremely Satisfied 19% Dissatisfied 23% Extremely Satisfied Satisfied Neutral Dissatisfied Satisfied 25% Extremely Dissatisfied Neutral 27% Figure - 7 (Chart showing Customer Satisfaction level with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd)
  • 61. Customer Responses or Reasons for satisfaction with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd • Less transit time • Clear tracking • Advance furnishing of documents • Keeping customer fully informed • Timely clearance • Good Shipment delivery at doorstep Interpretation: Various reasons are given by customers for satisfaction like less transit time, Clear tracking, Advance furnishing of documents, keeping customer fully informed, Timely clearance, Good Shipment delivery at doorstep etc.
  • 62. Customer Responses or Reasons for Dissatisfaction with DHL Express I Pvt Ltd • Original Bill of Entry getting only after 3 days after our follow up, this should come along with delivery • Freight Bill received 30 days after delivery this should deliver within 24 hrs, so that your payment will not be delayed • The currency some times wrongly mention in the B/E before filing with Customs, check the invoice or check with the customer - this will help avoiding mistake. • In some of the instances your response is not proper • Since express service is preferred only when there are some urgency, though the cargo reaches at airport. clearance team takes minimum 7-25days takes for customs clearance • Commitment not met in several cases Interpretation: Various reasons are given by customers for dissatisfaction. The company need more focused approach for satisfying the customers
  • 63. Recommend DHL Express to others Options Respondents Percentage Yes 51 64% No 29 36% Total 80 100 % Table - 7 Interpretation: 64 % of the customer responded in favour of recommending DHL Express to others. On the other hand 36 % of the people say No to recommend DHL Express to others.
  • 64. No 36% Yes No Yes 64% Figure - 8 (Chart showing Recommendation DHL Express to others)
  • 65. Over the past years loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger Options Respondents Percentage Yes 55 69% No 25 31% Total 80 100 % Table - 8 Interpretation: 69 % of the customer responded in favour that loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger. On the other hand 31 % of the people say No that loyalty towards DHL Express has not grown stronger.
  • 66. No 31% Yes No Yes 69% Figure - 9 (Chart showing status of loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger)
  • 67. DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals Options Respondents Percentage Yes 41 51% No 39 49% Total 80 100 % Table - 9 Interpretation: 51 % of the customer responded in favour that DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals. On the other hand 49 % of the people say No that DHL Express do not Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals.
  • 68. No Yes Yes 49% 51% No Figure – 10 (Chart showing DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short- term goals)
  • 70. FINDINGS • 20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility and responses through Telephone is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so they said that the service is fair • 20 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to accessibility and responses through E-mail is Excellent. Next 20 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 40 % of the customer. Final 20 % is not so satisfied so they said that the service is fair • 19 % of the customers responded that their overall experience to ability to help resolve issue or need is Excellent. Next 21 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 28 % of the customer. 24 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 9 % is not satisfied with the service. • 21 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 19 % says it is very good. Good being
  • 71. awarded by 18 % of the customer. 38% is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 5 % is not satisfied with the service. • 11 % of the customers responded that their overall experience with DHL clearance department is Excellent. Next 31 % says it is very good. Good being awarded by 50 % of the customer. 5 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service. • 19 % of the customers responded they are Extremely Satisfied with the service. Next 25 % they are satisfied. Neutral is 22 % of the customer. 23 % is somewhat satisfied so they said that the service is fair. 3 % is not satisfied with the service. • 64 % of the customer responded in favour of recommending DHL Express to others. On the other hand 36 % of the people say No to recommend DHL Express to others.
  • 72. 69 % of the customer responded in favour that loyalty towards DHL Express has grown stronger. On the other hand 31 % of the people say No that loyalty towards DHL Express has not grown stronger. • 51 % of the customer responded in favour that DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals. On the other hand 49 % of the people say No that DHL Express do not Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals.
  • 74. SUGGESTIONS • Communicate. Whether it is an email newsletter, monthly flier, a reminder card for a tune up, or a holiday greeting card, reach out to your steady customers. • Customer Service. Go the extra distance and meet customer needs. Train the staff to do the same. Customers remember being treated well. • Employee Loyalty. Loyalty works from the top down. If you are loyal to your employees, they will feel positively about their jobs and pass that loyalty along to your customers. • Employee Training. Train employees in the manner that you want them to interact with customers. Empower employees to make decisions that benefit the customer. • Customer Incentives. Give customers a reason to return to your business. For instance, because children outgrow shoes quickly, the owner of a children’s shoe store might offer a card that makes the tenth pair of shoes half price. Likewise, a dentist may give a free cleaning to anyone who has seen him regularly for five years.
  • 75. Product Awareness. Know what your steady patrons purchase and keep these items in stock. Add other products and/or services that accompany or compliment the products that your regular customers buy regularly. And make sure that your staff understands everything they can about your products. • Reliability. If you say a purchase will arrive on Wednesday, deliver it on Wednesday. Be reliable. If something goes wrong, let customers know immediately and compensate them for their inconvenience. • Be Flexible. Try to solve customer problems or complaints to the best of your ability. Excuses — such as "That's our policy" — will lose more customers then setting the store on fire.. • People over Technology. The harder it is for a customer to speak to a human being when he or she has a problem, the less likely it is that you will see that customer again. • Know Their Names. Remember the theme song to the television show Cheers? Get to know the names of regular customers or at least recognize their faces.
  • 77. CONCLUSIONS In addition to suggestions and findings, this study also provides several scopes for further research, which will be addressed in the following paragraphs: (1) While the customer loyalty model validated in this study possesses good power for explaining repurchase intentions and referral behavior, only partial explanation of the construct of additional purchase intentions is achieved. As stated before, factors not contained in the model such as strategic outsourcing considerations can be assumed to affect the intention of customers to outsource additional logistics activities to the currently most important LSP. For this reason, future studies should explore additional determinants of this loyalty dimension. (2) Measurement model assessment revealed that the operationalization of fairness in this study does not achieve sufficient discriminance from other constructs, especially from trust and relational satisfaction. As there is a strong theoretical indication that fairness is important in customer loyalty considerations, further studies should modify fair-ness’ measurement model, e.g. by more strongly recurring to the concept of inequity. (3) Within this study, four relational characteristics were examined. In addition, analyses were conducted for a multitude of other contingency factors that are not included in the present study. Overall, however, no conclusive moderations were identified. Nevertheless, it may be assumed that customer diversity still has moderating effects on the formation of customer loyalty. The determinants contained in this study, however, capture rather general evaluations of relationships between LSPs and their customers, which may be too broad to be subject to moderating effects. For this reason it would be sensible to examine antecedents of the employed determinants, as moderating effects could surface when this level of detail is added to the analyses.
  • 81. DHL Customer Satisfaction & Loyalty Survey • How would you rate your overall experience to accessablity and responses (of DHL representative) through phone and e-mail : Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor • How you rate the representative ability to help you resolve your issue/need? Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor • How you rate the representative on being Courteous & helpfulness? Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor
  • 82. Think specifically about the CLEARANCE Department, How would you rate your overall experience: Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor • Think specifically about the SHIPMENT DELIVERY at your doorstep, How would you rate your overall experience: Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor • In scale of 1 to 5, where 1 represents ‘Extremely Dissatisfied’ and 5 represents ‘Extremely Satisfied’. How would you rate your level of satisfaction with DHL Express. 1 2 3 4 5
  • 83. What specifically are you SATISFIED with DHL Express, Chennai. Enter your response below: { E.g., - Safety & security, Excellent tracking, Less transit time } What specifically are you DISSATISFIED with DHL Express, Chennai. Enter your response below: {E.g, - Commitment not met. etc.} • How likely are you to recommend DHL Express to others? The chances are: Excellent Very Good Good Fair Poor • In total, how long you have been a customer of DHL Express: More then 10 years 7 to 10 years 5 to 7 years 3 to 5 years Less then 3 years
  • 84. Please list top 3 reasons, initially becoming a member of DHL Express in order of importance: Please rate your level of agreement with the following statements. In scale of 1 to 5, where 1 represents ‘Completely Disagree’ , 3 represents ‘Neutral’ and 5 being ‘Completely Agree’  I believe the company, DHL Express deserves my loyalty: 1 2 3 4 5  Over the past years, my loyalty to the company, DHL Express has grown stronger: 1 2 3 4 5  DHL Express Values people & Relationships ahead of Short-term goals: 1 2 3 4 5 * ••• Suggestions ••• ( if any)
  • 85. Thanks for your valuable feedback.
  • 88. BIBLIOGRAPHY Books: • Research Methodology – Kothari • The Loyalty Guide report series - Peter Clark • Marketing Management 12 e – Philip Kotler Websites: • www.google.com • www.wikipedia.com • www.dhl.com • www.scribd.com