End-Use Energy Efficiency: National Plan for Regional Energy Challenge 26 - 27 July, 2010

1. Euro-Mediterranean
Energy Market Integration Project
Germany
France
Lebanon End Use Energy Efficiency:
National Plans for Regional Energy Challenges
Belgium
Presentation of Budget Allocation Charts - Lebanon
Germany Tunis, 26th – 27th, July, 2010
Ahmad Houri
BAC Expert – Lebanon
“The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of the author
and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union”.
This project is funded
by the European Union 1

2.  Lebanon Energy Overview
 Lebanon Potential EE and RE Technologies
 Budget Allocation Chart (BAC) Objective
 Methodology for the BAC
 Methodology for the BAC RE/EE
 BAC Output
 Next Steps
This project is funded
by the European Union

3.  Capacity way below demand
 Outages of 3 hours in the capital (daily) and up
to 12 hours in the rural areas
 Approximately 400 MW of private generation
capacity
 Hydropower contribution decreasing due to
higher demand on water and decreasing
rainfall.
 Monopolized electricity generation
 This project is funded
by the European Union
3

4.  35% losses on the grid
 25% due to non-technical losses
 17 cents/KWh
 Imports from Syria and Egypt
 Low efficiency of old plants
 Expected 7% growth in demand
 Private generation is not regulated and only
estimates are available
This project is funded
by the European Union
4

5.  Stakeholders contacted
 Response rate / length of questionnaire
 Selection of technologies
This project is funded
by the European Union
5

6. Tech 1. Energy-efficient lighting (CFLs, efficient Tech 11. Hydropower
linear fluorescents with electronic ballasts,
LEDs?)
Tech 2. Energy-efficient lighting (e.g., electronic Tech 12. CSP
ballasts, daylight and occupancy controls)
Tech 3. Thermal insulation of existing buildings Tech 13. Energy-efficient compressed air
(roof, façade, windows) against heat and
cold
Tech 4. Solar Water heating Tech 14. Energy management, good
housekeeping
Tech 5. Energy-efficient public lighting (e.g., high Tech 15. Solar Space Heating
pressure sodium, LEDs?)
Tech 6. Energy-efficient new buildings Tech 16. PV roofs
Tech 7. Cogeneration of heat or cold and power Tech 17. Municipal land fill gas
Tech 8. PV street lighting Tech 18. Mini Grids and home systems for
remote areas
Tech 9. Wind Energy Tech 19. Solar Swimming pool heating
Tech 10. Low-energy building Tech 20. Cement processes (klinker
production, grinding, substitutes
for klinker)
This project is funded
by the European Union
6

7.  The overall objective of this study is to develop and
disseminate the “budget allocation efficiency charts for
public and private sector spending in EE and RE” for
Lebanon.
 The aim of this report is to present to decision makers
the results of the national budget allocation efficiency
charts that identify the most cost effective EE and RE
measures to implement for achieving energy supply
diversification, energy sustainability and energy
security.
This project is funded
by the European Union
7

8.  Business as usual SSM scenario: kWh cost is based on
World Bank levelized electricity cost.
 Technology/Measure cost: based on international prices. It
is assumed that the proposed technologies and measures
will be implemented through national programs that
ensure market efficiency.
 Technology/Measure benefits: kWh saving/generation is
country specific, depending on technology/measure
investigated.
 Detailed simple methodologies developed by WI institute
were used to calculate the country potential for each
investigated technology/measure.
This project is funded
by the European Union
8

9.  Main data sources:
 Policy paper by the Minister of Energy
 EDL data
 Producers and retailers of technology
 LCEC
 Other stake holders
This project is funded
by the European Union
9

10. Ranking Name
1 Lighting___Energy‐efficient lighting CFLs
2 Heating & Cooling___Thermal insulation of existing buildings
3 Heating & Cooling___Good housekeeping (Programmable Thermostat for A/C)
4 Solar water heaters SWH, commercial sector___Tertiary
5 Lighting___Energy‐efficient lighting Electronic Ballast
6 Municipal landfill gas, utilities / services___Utilities / Services
7 PV facades, commercial/public___Utilities / Services
8 PV street lighting, utilities / services___Utilities / Services
9 Public lighting___Efficient Public Lighting (LED)
10 Compressed Air___Energy-efficient compressed air
11 Building___Low Energy Building
12 Geothermal, power sector___Power Sector
13 PV water pumps, agriculture___Agriculture
14 Municipal solid waste incineration, utilities / services___Utilities / Services
biogas or other residual biomass power and heat/cost co-generation, power
15 sector___Power Sector
16 Building___Energy-efficient new building
17 Cement Industry___Cement processes (Grinding - Efficient Ball Mill)
18 Hydropower, large, power sector___Power Sector
19 Concentrated solar power, power sector___Power Sector
This project is funded
20
by the European Union Heat Recovery___Cogeneration (Generators)
10

11. EE1.13 Lighting
Budget Allocation Charts
EE1.3 Heating & Cooling
EE2.14 Heating & Cooling
35.0000 0.0000
RE3.1 Solar water heaters SWH, commercial sector
30.0000 -0.5000
Accumulated Net Costs Electricity Savings [Mrd. Euro/a]
EE3.8 Lighting
Net Costs per kWh electricity saved [Euro/kWh]
-1.0000
25.0000 RE2.1 Municipal landfill gas, utilities / services
-1.5000
RE3.7 PV facades, commercial/public
20.0000
-2.0000 RE2.6 PV street lighting, utilities / services
15.0000
EE3.10 Public lighting
-2.5000
10.0000 EE2.9 Compressed Air
-3.0000
EE1.1 Building
5.0000
-3.5000
RE4.6 Geothermal, power sector
0.0000 -4.0000
RE6.4 PV water pumps, agriculture
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
-5.0000 -4.5000 RE2.2 Municipal solid waste incineration, utilities / services
Electricity Savings [TWh/a]
This project is funded
by the European Union
11

12.  Detailed review of the calculations and data
generated
 Dissemination of the BAC’s in Lebanon
 Prioritization of the technologies to be used
 Insuring compatibility with the Minister’s plan.
This project is funded
by the European Union
12

13. Thank you
This project is funded
by the European Union
13