Keynote of Ronald Damhof on the Data Vault automation conference at october 6, 2011

1. To Push or To Pull, That is the question
Ronald Damhof
woensdag 21 september 11 1
!"#$%&
!"#$%&
Taken from ‘Out of the Crisis’, Dr. W.Edwards Deming
'!&()*+%',)-
!"#$%!&'(%)*+!,+(-#./('!,+(.*$$
woensdag 21 september 11 2

2. woensdag 21 september 11 3
woensdag 21 september 11 4

3. woensdag 21 september 11 5
woensdag 21 september 11 6

4. Push characteristics
! Mass production
! Known specifications, operational definitions, standards
! Repeatable, predictable, & even better; uniform process
! Part of the system that needs statistical control
! Inventory allowed/necessary
! Supply driven
! Reliability over flexibility
Pull characteristics
! Just in time
! Demand driven
! Build to order
! Preferably no inventory
! Flexibility over Reliability
woensdag 21 september 11 7
@&%4-4&*/
56'7&*&$)/&'8*1"$()+"*-$"9#%/2
0'1(+2&/('!3*456*+7!,+(.*$$
<*9A#2&$'BC"%)>D
.)/)'0'1#*%+"*'2&$34%&
5 5 5 5 5
;6'<*$4%=')*9'%>&)*2&'9)/)
; ; ; ; ;
?6'@&,42/&$'0'!/)*9)$94F&
? ? ? ? ?
:6'7&/'/=&'$)E'B#*%#/D'9)/) : : : : :
8*'*+5.!90!,+(.*$!:;*'%+&4<
.)/)'2"#$%&2
0'1(+2&/('!3*456*+7!=+(.*$
woensdag 21 september 11 8

5. E5*BF!;(2,('*'%!65*B
: ? ; 5
;(2,&'7!AAA!-&%&!B&+*)(#$*!C!9#$5'*$$!0'%*445D*'.*!!3(2&5'
5
;
H8')--2
?*,(+%$
?
!"#$%&'2/"$&
:PJ'?P
H#24*&22'O4&EJ'
!"#$%&2
.)/)'1&&92
:
H8'I--2
>'&47$5$
<*/&$-$42&'
.)/)'G)$&="#2&
H8'I--2
>-@)(.
.)/)J'KG=)/L M#*%+"*J'KN"EL KG=&$&LJ'KG="(L
<Q/&$*)>
'2"#$%&2
woensdag 21 september 11 9
!"#$%&'/"' !"#$%&2/"$&' !"#$%&2/"$&'
<.G'B.OD
-$"9#%/ /"'-$"9#%/ /"'HO
>-&,%&H4*
G#$%&5'&H4*
;(2,45&'%
3*.(#,4*-
JK*./6*
G%&'-&+-5I*-
;*'%+&45I*-
woensdag 21 september 11 10

6. E5*BF!;(2,('*'%!65*B
: ? ; 5
;(2,&'7!AAA!-&%&!B&+*)(#$*!C!9#$5'*$$!0'%*445D*'.*!!3(2&5'
5
;
H8')--2
?*,(+%$
?
!"#$%&'2/"$&
:PJ'?P
H#24*&22'O4&EJ'
!"#$%&2
.)/)'1&&92
:
H8'I--2
>'&47$5$
<*/&$-$42&'
.)/)'G)$&="#2&
H8'I--2
>-@)(.
.)/)J'KG=)/L M#*%+"*J'KN"EL KG=&$&LJ'KG="(L
<Q/&$*)>
'2"#$%&2
woensdag 21 september 11 11
I9(4*42/$)+3&'-$"%&22 8*1"$()+"*'.&>43&$S'R$"%&22 .&%424"*A'0'%"*/$">
8*'*+&%*C! .)/)'0'8*1"$()+"*'$&%4-4&*/2
35$%+5H#%*
J'+5.)
?*D5$%*+!C!
G%&'-&+-5I*
>L&5'
R$"%&2
R.UI
U"(->4)*%&'$&-"$+*,
8*1"$()+"*'
!"#$ -$"9#%/2
@42V'W)*),&(&*/
!"#$
!S2/&(2 .O'T)2&9 !"%%
B4*/&$*)>'0 .)/)' R&$1"$()*%&'
&Q/&$*)>D G)$&="#2& W)*),&(&*/
H#24*&22 !#-->S'%=)4*'
!/),4*, $#>&2 "-+(4F)+"*
.)/)'-$"9#%/2
M$)#9'9&/&%+"*
W)$V&/'T)2V&/'
)*)>S242
U"*/$">'X'W&/)9)/)
woensdag 21 september 11 12

7. Remember the Push characteristics
! Mass production Data Vault
! Known specifications, operational definitions, standards Data Vault
! Repeatable, predictable, & even better; uniform process Data Vault
! Part of the system that needs statistical control Data Vault
! Inventory allowed/necessary Data Vault
! Mainly supply driven Data Vault
! Reliability over flexibility Data Vault
Automation of a Data Vault production system is just common sense
woensdag 21 september 11 13
WS'R"O'
IT"#/'B.)/)'O)#>/D')#/"()+"*'Y"">4*,
! 7&*&$)+"*'42')*')49J'*"/')',")>'4*'4/2&>1
– '."'*"/')%%"("9)/&'/=&'-$4*%4->&2'/"'Z/'/=&'/"">6666
– 'C""V'1"$'9&%"#->4*,
! Y$#>S'#*9&$2/)*9'/=&'(&%=)*4%2'A'=)*9%$)['4/'Z$2/
– '8*3&2/'4*'-$"-&$'&9#%)+"*')*9'>&)$*4*,
– '8*3&2/'4*'K,&]*,'$&)9SL'+(&
– '8*3">3&'S"#$'K%#2/"(&$2L'1$"('/=&'2/)$/
! R"UJ'R"UJ'R"U
! .&>43&$J'.&>43&$J'.&>43&$
woensdag 21 september 11 14

8. YS-&':'A'U>)224%'.)/)'O)#>/
H#24*&22'
Y$)*2)%+"*'
!S2/&('
!/),4*,'
.)/)'O)#>/ .)/)2&/2
b#/
H#24*&22'
Y$)*2)%+"*' 8*'*+5.!9#$5'*$$!?#4*$
!S2/&('
@#>&'O)#>/
!/$#%/#$&'/$)*21"$()+"* H#24*&22'$#>&'&Q&%#+"*
N#T'^'T#24*&22'V&S2 !/$#%/#$&')*9'3)>#&'/$)*21"$()+"*
I9)-/)T>& !#2/)4*)T>& U"(->4)*/ .&%"#->&9 <_&%+3&*&22 !/)*9)$94F&9 U&*/$)>4F&9
` `
woensdag 21 september 11 15
YS-&'?'A'!"#$%&'.)/)'O)#>/
H#24*&22'
Y$)*2)%+"*' !/),4*,'O)#>/
!S2/&('
H#24*&22' .)/)'W)$/2
.)/)'O)#>/
H#24*&22'
Y$)*2)%+"*' !/),4*,'O)#>/
!S2/&('
!/$#%/#$&'/$)*21"$()+"* H#24*&22'$#>&'&Q&%#+"* !/$#%/#$&'/$)*21"$()+"*
a"'4*/&,$)+"*J'N#T^2#$$",)/&'V&S2 8*/&,$)+"*
R&$242+*,'2/),4*,'4*'.O'1"$()/ .O'("9&>>&9'
I9)-/)T>& !#2/)4*)T>& U"(->4)*/ .&%"#->&9 <_&%+3&*&22 !/)*9)$94F&9 U&*/$)>4F&9
` ` `
woensdag 21 september 11 16

9. !"#$%&
!"#$%&
':ccd'!&()*+%',)-
!"#$%& !/),4*,'.O
H#24*&22'.O
!"#$%& !/),4*,'.O
:ccd'!&()*+%',)-
!+>>'/=&'2"#$%&
8*/&,$)+"*J'%>&)*24*,J'%"*2">49)+"*
H#24*&22'$#>&'&Q&%#+"*'#-2/$&)('``
.O'("9&>>&9'
woensdag 21 september 11 17
!"#$%&
!"#$%&
':ccd'!&()*+%',)-
!"#$%& !"#$%& !/),4*,'.O
H#24*&
.)/)'
G)$&="#2&
!"#$%& !"#$%& !/),4*,'.O 22'.O
:ccd'!&()*+%',)-
!+>>'/=&'2"#$%&
8*/&,$)+"*J'%>&)*24*,J'%"*2">49)+"*
H#24*&22'$#>&'&Q&%#+"*'#-2/$&)('``
.O'("9&>>&9'
woensdag 21 september 11 18

10. W&/)("9&>'9$43&*')#/"()+"*
A W"9&>2'B-$"%&22J'$#>&2')*9'9)/)D'9&/&$(4*&'/=&'(&/)9)/)J'/=&'(&/)9)/)'9&/&$(4*&2'/=&')#/"()+"*')$+1)%/2
A I4('42'/"'T&':ccd'9&%>)$)+3&
A 8/'%)*'*"/'T&',&*&$)/&9')>>J'2-&%4Z%'/)4>"$&9'(&/)9)/)'E4>>'$&()4*'*&%&22)$S
W&/)9)/)'9$43&*')#/"()+"*
A'8*-#/2e'!"#$%&'("9&>B2DJ'/)$,&/'("9&>J'Y&(->)/&'.&24,*J'a)(4*,'%"*3&*+"*2
A'I93)*%&9'4*-#/2e'a"$()>4F)+"*'-$&1&$&*%&2J'b*/">",4&2
Y)V&*'1$"('.)*'C4*2/&9/L2'T>",'-"2/e'=f-eXX9)*>4*2/&9/6%"(X9)/)3)#>/%)/X%"9&A,&*&$)+"*A1"$A9)/)A3)#>/A*"/A)2A&)2SA)2AS"#A/=4*VX
.)/)'O)#>/'
4(->&(&*/)+"*2 Y&(->)/&'9$43&*')#/"()+"*
A 8*'/=&'("2/'T)24%'1"$(2g'9"%#(&*/)+"*''A'9&2%$4T4*,')'-)f&$*
A W"$&')93)*%&9g',&*&$)+*,'hWC'%"9&'1"$'?*9',&*6'<YC'/"">4*,
A OT'A'=f-eXXEEE6,$#*92)/F>4%=A4/6*>XT4A/"">2A/&(->)/"$6=/(>
woensdag 21 september 11 19
I#/"()+"*'/S-">",S
• Y="2&'/=)/'2#--"$/'2-&%4&2'i:'BT#4>94*,')'!"#$%&'O)#>/D
– Y&(->)/&'9$43&*'"$'W&/)9)/)'9$43&*
– b[&*',&*&$)/&2'/=&'("9&>')*9'/=&'>",42+%2
• Y="2&'/=)/'2#--"$/'2-&%4&2'i?'BT#4>94*,')'U>)224%'O)#>/D
– Y&(->)/&'9$43&*'"$'W&/)9)/)'9$43&*
– 7&*&$)/&'B(&/)9)/)'"1D'/=&'>",42+%2
– W"9&>4*,'$&()4*2')'%$)['j'8.<aY8Mk'YN<'Hl!8a<!!'m<k!
• Y="2&'/=)/',"'T&S"*9'
– W&/)("9&>'9$43&*
– H)2&9'"*'/=&'T#24*&22'-$"%&22J'/=&'$#>&2')*9'/=&'9)/)
– Y=&'9)/)("9&>'B.OJ'IWJ'66D'42')'%"*2&n#&*%&'"1'/=&'-$"%&22
– !#--"$/'1"$'ICW'%=)$)%/&$42+%2
woensdag 21 september 11 20

11. Y=)*V'k"#
&'#()*+,-%.)&()&-/$+0
H>", =f-eXX-$#9&*F)6/S-&-)96%"(X
=f-eXXEEE6TA&S&A*&/E"$V6%"(XT>",2X9)(="1X'
C4*V&94* =f-eXX*>6>4*V&94*6%"(X4*X$"*)>99)(="1
<()4> $"*)>969)(="1o-$#9&*F)6*>
YE4f&$ @"*)>9.)(="1
!VS-& @"*)>96.)(="1
W"T4>& p;:BcDq'?qr'qs':t5
b/=&$2 8*1"$()+"*'u#)>4/S'U&$+Z&9'R$"1&224"*)>'B8uURD
.)/)'O)#>/'U&$+Z&9'7$)*9'W)2/&$
U&$+Z&9'!%$#('W)2/&$
W&(T&$'"1'/=&'H"#>9&$'H8'H$)4*'Y$#2/'BiHHHYD
*+,-%.)&-/$+0)42')*'4*9&-&*9&*/'-$)%++"*&$'4*'/=&'Z&>9'"1'9)/)'()*),&(&*/')*9'9&%424"*'2#--"$/6'7$)9#)/&9'4*':rrv'4*'
/=&'2/#9S'"1'<%"*"(4%26'!4*%&':rrv'=&'E"$V&9')2')'-$)%++"*&$'4*/"'/=&'Z&>9'"1'8*1"$()+"*'W)*),&(&*/'E4/=')'1"%#2'"*'
9&%424"*'2#--"$/')*9'9)/)'()*),&(&*/J'/$S4*,'=)$9'/"'&*=)*%&'/=&'$4,"$')*9'$&>&3)*%&'4*'/=&2&'Z&>92'TS'%"(T4*4*,'2%4&*+Z%'
$&2&)$%='E4/='/=&'&3&$S9)S'%=)>>&*,&2'"1'/=&'-$)%++"*&$6'@"*)>9'42'()4*>S'=4$&9'TS'%#2/"(&$2'4*'/=&'$">&'"1'T#24*&22X8Y'
)$%=4/&%/J')#94/"$J'%")%='0'/$)4*&$6'N&'T>",2'"*'HA<S&Aa&/E"$V6%"(')2'E&>>')2'=42'"E*'T>",J'42')'(&(T&$'"1'/=&'-$&2+,4"#2'
HHHYJ'E$"/&'2&3&$)>')$+%>&2'$&,)$94*,'9&%424"*'2#--"$/')$%=4/&%/#$&2')*9'42')'$&2&)$%=&$'4*'/=&'Z&>9'"1'8*1"$()+"*'
W)*),&(&*/6'
I>/="#,='@"*)>9'>4V&2'/"'E"$V'E4/='/=&"$&+%)>',$"#*9&9'$&2&)$%=')*9'-$"3&*'-$)%+%&2J'@"*)>9'42'*"/')'wE=4/&'-)-&$w'
)$%=4/&%/g'-#/'S"#$'("*&S'E=&$&'S"#$'("#/='42J'42'=42'("f"6'N&'>4V&2'/"'2&&')$%=4/&%/#$&2'w>43&w'4*'&*/&$-$42&2J'*"/'x#2/'E$4/&'
)T"#/'4/6'8*'("2/'"$,)*4F)+"*2'=42'$">&'&Q/&*92')$%=4/&%/#$&'"[&*6'8*'/$#&>S'),4>&'2-4$4/'/=&'$">&2'=&'->)S2'9&-&*9'"*'/=&'
%"*/&Q/'"1'/=&'%>4&*/g'=&'%)*'T&')'(4224"*)$S'B2&>>4*,'/=&'3)>#&DJ')'-$"x&%/'()*),&$'B,&]*,'4/'9"*&DJ')'2%$#('()2/&$'B$&("34*,'
4(-&94(&*/2DJ'2-&%4)>42/'B&9#%)+*,'=)$9E)$&'-&&-2J'9)/)')$%=4/&%/2J'9)/)'>",42+%2'&/%6D'"$')'>&)9&$6
woensdag 21 september 11 21