SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 55
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Devising a Risk Index for Priority
Substances Emissions from
WWTP
Fiona Regan
Overview
Work Package
•  Interpreting PS monitoring data from DCU
(Lisa Jones) and CIT: Metals, PAHs,
Pesticides, VOCs
•  Identifying major sources and risk factors for
PS occurrence in WW
•  Assessing risk of PS occurrence in
catchments, over time
•  Understanding sources, prioritising monitoring
Priority Substance Monitoring
•  EU WFD: Waters must be of “Good” ecological and
chemical status by 2015
•  WFD: 33 PS groups, including 20 PHS, plus 11
potential PS
•  PS emissions reduced to background concentrations
•  PHS emissions eliminated within 20 years
•  2008 EQS Directive: Average annual and maximum
acceptable concentrations specified
EQSDirective
Potential Priority Substances
Priority Hazardous Substances
Alachlor Anthracene AMPA
Atrazine Brominated diphenylether Bentazon
Benzene Cadmium and its compounds Bisphenol-A
Chloroalkanes, C10-13 Dicofol
Endosulfan EDTA
Chlorfenvinpos Hexachlorobenzene Free cyanide
Chlorpyrifos (Chlorpyrifos-theyl) Hexachlorobutadiene Glyphosate
1,2-dichloroethane Hexachlorocyclohexane Mercoprop (MCPP)
Dichloromethane Mercury and its compounds Musk xylene
Di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) Nonylphenol
Diuron (4-nonylphenol)
Fluoranthene Pentachlorobenzene
Isoproturon Polyaromatic hydrocarbons
Lead and its compounds (Benzo(a)pyrene) Dioxins
Napthalene (Benzo(b)fluoranthene) PCB
Nickel and its compounds (Benzo(g,h,i)perylene)
Octylphenol (Benzo(k)fluoranthene)
(Ideno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene)
Tributyltin compounds
Pentachlorophenol (Tributyltin-cation)
Simazine
Trichlorobenzenes
Trichloromethane (chloroform)
Trifluralin
(4-(1,1',3,3'-tetramethylbutyl)-phenol)
Priority Substances
Perflurooctane sulphonic acid
(PFOS)
Quinoxyfen (5,7-dichloro-4(p-
fluorophenoxy)quinoline)
Pentabromodiphenylether (cogener
numbers 28, 47, 99, 100, 153 and
154)
Ireland Monitoring
•  SERBD PS screening programmes
•  Expert Working Group identified 202 (WFD + 161)
candidate substances
•  Produced preliminary screening list of 41 PS
•  TNO: 47 of the 51 analysed PS found in water
•  18 PS in 10% samples, 3 in >50% of the samples –
naphthalene, fluoranthene, nickel
–  Median concentrations ranged from 0.009 µg L-1 for
fluoranthene to 1.4 µg L-1 for Nickel
•  Long-term compliance monitoring required
Priority Substances in
Wastewater
•  Waste water major point-source input to surface
waters
•  Responsible for localised EQS exceedance?
•  Often upstream of drinking water abstraction!
•  Can be controlled
•  Combined sewer discharges and “high-risk” runoff
•  Few data on waste water PS discharges
•  Will complement storm water studies, and inform
targeted PS monitoring (both WW and SW)
WWTP
Removal
(to sludge /air)
Diffuse sources
WasteWater Drainage
Storm
overflow
River
Direct sources
Final Effluent
Surfacewater
1. Source magnitude /
type
2. Diffuse loss risk /
conditions
3. Surface water -
sewer connectivity
5.WWTP removal
efficiency
4. Sewer mixing and
overflow
Potential High Risk Source Sites
(SWRBD)
•  Oil and gasworks sites (IPPC, LA)
•  (Hazardous) waste disposal/handling
sites (EPA, LA)
•  Mining sites (IPPC)
•  Chemical plants (IPPC, LA)
•  Airports, railway depots, dockyards,
petroleum import terminals (LA)
•  Timber treatment (IPPC, LA)
•  Filling stations (LA)
•  Building sites (LA)
• Past industrial sites
• Roads
• Industrial estates
• Combined drainage
areas
Connectivity to sewers?
Pesticides: High Risk Landuse
•  Sports grounds (Incl golf courses)
•  Parks and open urban areas
•  Intensive animal rearing (IPPC)
•  Intensive tillage (potatoes) (CORINE)
•  Forestry (Coillte spray data)
•  Intensive grassland (CORINE)
Source intensity
Connectivity
Households
Commercial
Industry
Roads-traffic
Contaminatedsites
Point sources, continuous input, baseline
loading and concentrations
Diffuse sources,
periodic input, peak
loading and
concentrations
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Study Approach
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Industry dominated, no final treatment: possible to ID industry input
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periodsMonthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters
Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R
Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R
Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine
Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R
Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R
Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine
Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal
Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine
Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine
Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periodsMonthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods
Study Approach cont…
Ten catchments, range of sizes, physical
characteristics, industrial contributions, treatment
levels
1.  Collate data on potential sources (e.g. industry) and risk
factors (e.g. combined drainage) for each catchment
2.  Compile literature data on source magnitudes and WWTP
removal efficiencies
3.  Look for associations between meterological or physico-
chem parameters and PS concs / loads
4.  Devise risk index for high PS in effluent (across
catchments, over time): compare with mon data
Case-study Ringsend
SWORDS
WWTP
Licensed industry
License n Risk
IPPC-Chemicals 27 Ms, PAH, VOC
IPPC- Food & Drink 4
IPPC- Metals 4 Ms, PAH, VOC
IPPC-Minerals, Fibre, Glass 3 PAH, VOC
IPPC-Power Stations 5 PAH, VOC
IPPC-Surface Coatings 17 PAH, VOC
IPPC-Wood Paper Textiles 6 PAH, VOC
EPA-Hazardous Waste 13 Ms, VOC, PAH
EPA-Integrated Waste Management 4 Ms, VOC, PAH
EPA-Landfill 2 Ms, VOC, PAH
EPA-Materials Recovery Facility 4 Ms, VOC, PAH
EPA-Waste Transfer Facility 15 Ms, VOC, PAH
License n Risk
LA-Airport 2 PAH, VOC
LA-Chemical 13 Ms, PAH, VOC
LA-College 9 VOC
LA-Construction 28 Ms, PAH
LA-Dentist 1 Ms
LA-Electronics 1 Ms, VOC
LA-Filling Station 67 M, PAH, VOC
LA Food & Drink 63
LA-Garage 33 PAH, VOC
LA-Gym 7
LA-Haulage Depot 51 M, PAH, VOC
LA-Hotel 3
LA-Hospital 19 VOC
LA-Hairdresser 1 VOC
LA-Laundry 5 M, PAH, VOC
LA-Metal 10 Ms, PAH, VOC
LA-Oil Distribution 1 PAH, VOC
LA-Office 6
LA-Printers 16 VOC
LA-Retail 25
LA-Sport 6 Pest
LA-Washing (Outdoors)4 Ms, PAH
LA-Waste 6 Ms, PAH, VOC
Other 10
Separate direct vs diffuse
inputs?
Data from EPA, DCC, SDCC,
FCC. Awaiting DLRCC…
Other risk factors
•  Traffic volume or road area
•  Intensive agriculture and forestry in / near catchment
•  Local authority pesticide application
•  Extent of combined drainage
•  Temporal
–  meteorological (heavy rainfall after dry period)
–  traffic volume patterns (stats)
Data from Met Eireann and NRA require update and
processing. Awaiting CC pest app data…
Ringsend effluent
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 1400000 1600000
Flow (m3 day-1)
PercentageinfluentTSSremoved
Routine operating variability (random?)
Process failure: Non predictable risk factor
Capacity excedence?
Risk Factor?
On average, less efficient at
higher flows: Risk factor
Stats…
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0
Rainfall (mm day-1)
Flow(m3day-1)
High non-meteo variability
Above 800,000 m3 = rain
R2
= 0.55
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0
Rainfall (mm day-1)
Flow(m3day-1)
High non-meteo variability
Above 600,000 m3 = rain
Rain, next-day flow
More data and analysis required. New
parameter (e.g. daily-flow increase vs
rainfall?)
Same-day rain and flow
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0
Rainfall (mm day-1)
TSSload(tonnesday-1)
Rain, next day TSS total load
Rainfall threshold for TSS
and PAH loss risk? More
data and analysis required…
Owenahincha agglomeration
PAH Loading Risk Index
1.  Discharge from licensed high-risk industry
2.  Frequency of contaminated sites
3.  Traffic volume
4.  Combined drains x (2 + 3) (+ urban, - rural ?)
5.  Normalised according to popn
Effluent PAH conc Risk Index
1.  Loading Index x:
i.  Meteorological conditions
ii.  WWTP removal efficiency
2.  Normalised acc to flow per popn
Work Plan
•  Complete industrial point source database
–  Distinguish IPPC direct from diffuse inputs?
•  Literature search for magnitude of PS emissions from
various sources
•  Find data on past industrial sites?
•  Collate NRA traffic volume data for each catchment
•  Obtain and collate pesticide use data from CCs
•  Obtain Met Eireann data to Nov and compare with
Ringsend / Swords effluent PS concs
•  Obtain flow and physico-chem data from Swords and Cork
WWTPs
•  Literature search for WWTP PS removal efficiencies
Work Overview….
•  A review was used to identify the major
factors leading to Priority Pollutant (PP)
loading from WWTPs, integrated and
conceptualised in a basic conceptual
model.
•  Available data sources were identified for
the major PP loading risk factors. Then,
through a combination of quantitative
data collation (e.g. number of discharge
licences issued to different types of
operations) and qualitative risk
assessment (risk ranking), risk
databases were compiled for major
sources.
….Work Overview
•  Databases were compiled for Local
Authority and EPA licensed
discharges, and agglomeration traffic.
Results from these databases were
integrated into a simple risk model for
agglomeration PP loading, combined
with basic WWTP (e.g. capacity and
treatment level) and agglomeration
(e.g. population and area) data, and
finally expressed as elevated risk in a
national context following
normalisation procedures.
Work Overview
•  Collate available literature and statistical data that could
be used to inform targeted PP monitoring strategies.
•  Focus on readily-available data relevant to major PP risk
factors identified by conceptual modelling, and develop
appropriate indicators.
•  Indicators are applied to ten WWTP agglomerations
currently being monitored to predict the relative risk of
elevated PP loading to receiving waters across
agglomerations and over time.
List of WWTP
•  Cork
–  Ballincollig
–  Bandon
–  Charleville
–  Clonakilty
–  Fermoy
–  Mallow
–  Ringaskiddy
–  Rosscarbery
•  Dublin
–  Ringsend
–  Swords
Collated Data
•  Basic information on WWTPs and
the agglomerations they serve in
Ireland is provided in
documentation submitted to the
EPA in application for Urban
Wastewater Discharge Licences
(http://www.epa.ie).
From EPA Urban Waste Water
Report
•  Removal factors applied to
WWTPs in dry- and wet- weather
flow conditions, based on
removal efficiencies derived from
Seriki et al. (2008) and load
factors (agglomeration PE
divided by WWTP PE capacity).
Seriki K., Gasperi J., Castillo L., Scholes L., Eriksson E., Revitt M., Meinhold J., Atanasova N. (2008)
Priority pollutants behaviour in end of pipe wastewater treatment plants. In Source Control Options for
Reducing Emissions of Priority Pollutants (ScorePP)
•  WWTP load factors were
calculated as a ratio of
agglomeration PE loading to
WWTP PE capacity.
•  WWTP risk factor = 1-removal fraction (e.g. 80% PAH removal for standard secondary treatment in Dry
Weather Flow = 0.2)
•  For CY, because secondary treatment capacity limited to approx half average agglomeration PE, DWF risk
factor based on average of Primary and Secondary treatment
•  For Wet Weather Flow, risk factors assume primary treatment removal efficiencies
•  For WWTPs working in excess
of or close to capacity, WWF
removal factors were based on
the assumption that overall
removal efficiencies under high
loading conditions were
equivalent to primary treatment
removal efficiencies. Removal
factors were inversed into
Effluent Factors (EF) for direct
multiplication with loading
factors.
•  Industrial installations performing
listed activities above specified
thresholds are licensed under the
EU Integrated Pollution
Prevention and Control (IPPC)
Directive. Licence conditions and
annual reports on emissions from
these installations are made
publicly available by the Irish
Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA)
•  The level of information provided
on PP emissions varies across
installations, and for the initial
purposes of our risk-based model
we define risk factors for each
installation according to activity
class, refined based on some
installation-specific information
provided in licences (whether or not
discharge to sewers, and surface
water management).
Risk Scale
•  ‘Typical’ loading risk factors for
each major PP group, applied to
installations in each IPPC and
Waste activity class.
•  Loading risk factors applied to
individual installations may vary
within activity groups, depending
on licence information regarding
processes, sewer discharge, and
surface water management.
Licensed Risk
Licensed Risk
•  Traffic-induced loading to
WWTP (PAH, VOCs, HMs)
should be largely proportional to
traffic volume within
agglomeration combined
drainage areas, as measured by
Vehicle km Travelled (VKT).
•  Relevant available statistics
are traffic flow on national
roads in the vicinty of study
agglomerations (NRA, 2009),
total VKT for different vehicle
types (CSO, 2009) and
national VKT for six major
road types (National Primary,
National Secondary,
Regional, Local Primary,
Local Secondary, Local
Tertiary)
Road type
National VKT
(M km a-1
)a
Agglomeration VKM
calculation
Length
restriction
Sewer input
Nat. Prim. (10,665) NA
Nat. Sec. (3,865) NA
Regional 9,051 0.10 x (Popag / Popnat)
Loc. Prim 4,621 0.25 x (Popag / Popnat)
Loc. Sec 2,187 0.75 x (Popag / Popnat)
Loc. Ter 784 1.00 x (Popag / Popnat)
National road VKM travelled not used in calculations
a Cars only. NRA data for 2002 (NRA, 2001) extrapolated to 2009 based on CSO national VKM in 2009 (presentation ref)
LocaltrafficThrough
traffic
2008 NRA traffic flow x
road length in
agglomeration
Peripheral or
central road?
Sum local <
2 x
agglomerat
ion length
Estimated
percentage area
under combined
foul-storm
drainage
Ballincollig
•  DWF
•  Heavy rainfall
•  PE/development
Ringaskiddy
Bandon
Charleville
•  Designed for a PE of up to
15,000
•  The PE and DWF are based on
measured foul flows from 1973
•  Incoming flow can be divided
evenly between two oxidation
ditches
–  Only one oxidation ditch in use
–  PE ~ 7,000
Clonakilty
•  Designed for a PE of 5,333
•  Increased loading during
summer of up to 15,000 PE
•  At present two oxidation
ditches
•  Application for increased
storage capacity not yet
implemented
•  Hydraulic load of 6 DWF
Mallow
•  Two treatment systems; 50
– 50 split between new and
old plant
•  Contract out for private
operation and maintenance
contract
–  Could be in place before the
end of the year
Rosscarberry/Owenahincha
•  Proposed works may
now not take place
•  Discharge from chemical
toilets and mobile
homes?
Fermoy
•  Designed for a PE of
20,000
•  System was upgraded,
licence states that 40 % of
flow meant to go to old
plant
Ringsend
Swords
Further Work
•  Meteorological data will need to be used to derive a
temporal component to this risk factor.
Acknowledgements
This project is funded by the EPA as part of the Science,
Technology, Research and Innovation for the Environment
(STRIVE) Programme 2007–2013. This programme is
financed by the Irish Government under the National
Development Plan 2007–2013. It is administered on behalf of
the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local
Government by the Environmental Protection Agency, which
has the statutory function of co-ordinating and promoting
environmental research.

Más contenido relacionado

Similar a Priority pollutants

Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...
Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...
Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...Cairn India Limited
 
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill Webinar
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill WebinarTip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill Webinar
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill WebinarOhio Environmental Council
 
Ipsw presentation mestech
Ipsw presentation   mestechIpsw presentation   mestech
Ipsw presentation mestechreganf
 
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing Australia
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing AustraliaDesalination Sustainably Drought Proofing Australia
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing AustraliaEngineers Australia
 
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017Sustainable Severn
 
Dow Wetlands Restoration Project
Dow Wetlands Restoration ProjectDow Wetlands Restoration Project
Dow Wetlands Restoration ProjectWilliam Mavrode
 
Future of Wastewater
Future of WastewaterFuture of Wastewater
Future of Wastewaterbwenzlau
 
Taw River Improvement Project - Science Day
Taw River Improvement Project - Science DayTaw River Improvement Project - Science Day
Taw River Improvement Project - Science DayWestcountry Rivers Trust
 
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board Adoption
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board AdoptionCrooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board Adoption
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board AdoptionCoon Creek Watershed District
 
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...No to mining in Palawan
 
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wells
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wellsStudy: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wells
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wellsMarcellus Drilling News
 
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...Environmental Protection Agency, Ireland
 
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe Harrington
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe HarringtonSediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe Harrington
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe HarringtonEnvironmental Protection Agency, Ireland
 
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industries
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industriesEffluent treatment schematics for Dairy industries
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industriesManikandan R
 
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regnHydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regnEVAnetDenmark
 
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...IRJET Journal
 
Stormwater pond ppt (1)
Stormwater pond ppt (1)Stormwater pond ppt (1)
Stormwater pond ppt (1)jojotaguinod
 
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks TayyabaIrfan2
 

Similar a Priority pollutants (20)

Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...
Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...
Water Usage Optimization & Management for Hydraulic Fracturing | Dr. Chris Fr...
 
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill Webinar
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill WebinarTip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill Webinar
Tip & Glow Radioactive Waste Amendment in the State Budget Bill Webinar
 
Ipsw presentation mestech
Ipsw presentation   mestechIpsw presentation   mestech
Ipsw presentation mestech
 
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing Australia
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing AustraliaDesalination Sustainably Drought Proofing Australia
Desalination Sustainably Drought Proofing Australia
 
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017
Roger Falconer and Chris Binnie - Sustainable Severn Forum 2017
 
Arctic change 2017
Arctic change 2017Arctic change 2017
Arctic change 2017
 
Dow Wetlands Restoration Project
Dow Wetlands Restoration ProjectDow Wetlands Restoration Project
Dow Wetlands Restoration Project
 
Future of Wastewater
Future of WastewaterFuture of Wastewater
Future of Wastewater
 
Taw River Improvement Project - Science Day
Taw River Improvement Project - Science DayTaw River Improvement Project - Science Day
Taw River Improvement Project - Science Day
 
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board Adoption
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board AdoptionCrooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board Adoption
Crooked Lake Comp Plan Summary For CCWD Board Adoption
 
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...
Impacts of Lafayette Mining In The Island of Rapu-Rapu Albay Resulting From C...
 
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wells
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wellsStudy: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wells
Study: Organic compounds in produced waters from shale gas wells
 
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...
Siltflux workshop 1: Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue - Dr...
 
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe Harrington
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe HarringtonSediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe Harrington
Sediment Research on the Rivers Bandon and Owenabue, Ireland - Joe Harrington
 
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industries
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industriesEffluent treatment schematics for Dairy industries
Effluent treatment schematics for Dairy industries
 
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regnHydrauliske kapacitet under regn
Hydrauliske kapacitet under regn
 
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...
Investigation of Ground Water Quality for Drinking and Domestic Purpose in Na...
 
Stormwater pond ppt (1)
Stormwater pond ppt (1)Stormwater pond ppt (1)
Stormwater pond ppt (1)
 
Leachability of Elements From Hydraulic Fracturing Residuals by Dr. Gregory B...
Leachability of Elements From Hydraulic Fracturing Residuals by Dr. Gregory B...Leachability of Elements From Hydraulic Fracturing Residuals by Dr. Gregory B...
Leachability of Elements From Hydraulic Fracturing Residuals by Dr. Gregory B...
 
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks
Aquatic pollution in port qasim creeks
 

Más de reganf

Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchments
Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchmentsOccurrences of priority substances in selected catchments
Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchmentsreganf
 
Sensorcomm3 t sullivan
Sensorcomm3 t sullivanSensorcomm3 t sullivan
Sensorcomm3 t sullivanreganf
 
Smart sensors for BTEX
Smart sensors for BTEXSmart sensors for BTEX
Smart sensors for BTEXreganf
 
Novel materials for development of optical sensors
Novel materials for development of optical sensorsNovel materials for development of optical sensors
Novel materials for development of optical sensorsreganf
 
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona regan
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona reganSwig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona regan
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona reganreganf
 
Mestech spring bulletin
Mestech spring bulletinMestech spring bulletin
Mestech spring bulletinreganf
 
Mestech autumn bulletin
Mestech autumn bulletinMestech autumn bulletin
Mestech autumn bulletinreganf
 
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014 Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014 reganf
 
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014reganf
 

Más de reganf (9)

Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchments
Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchmentsOccurrences of priority substances in selected catchments
Occurrences of priority substances in selected catchments
 
Sensorcomm3 t sullivan
Sensorcomm3 t sullivanSensorcomm3 t sullivan
Sensorcomm3 t sullivan
 
Smart sensors for BTEX
Smart sensors for BTEXSmart sensors for BTEX
Smart sensors for BTEX
 
Novel materials for development of optical sensors
Novel materials for development of optical sensorsNovel materials for development of optical sensors
Novel materials for development of optical sensors
 
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona regan
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona reganSwig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona regan
Swig water sensors sept 26th 2013 fiona regan
 
Mestech spring bulletin
Mestech spring bulletinMestech spring bulletin
Mestech spring bulletin
 
Mestech autumn bulletin
Mestech autumn bulletinMestech autumn bulletin
Mestech autumn bulletin
 
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014 Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014
Steering meeting presentation april 15 2014
 
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014
Fiona regan oceanology march 11 2014
 

Último

BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptx
BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptxBIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptx
BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptxROLANARIBATO3
 
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girls
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call GirlsAl Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girls
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girlstiril72860
 
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsHi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girlsssuser7cb4ff
 
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"s
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"sAlong the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"s
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"syalehistoricalreview
 
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptx
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptxEMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptx
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptxSarmad Naeem
 
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170simranguptaxx69
 
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesGwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Servicesnajka9823
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一z xss
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...Delhi Escorts
 
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling Difference
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling DifferenceMaking a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling Difference
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling DifferenceSwag Cycle
 
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptx
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptxLimnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptx
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptxTesfahunTesema
 
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdf
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdfGroup 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdf
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdfs2015004
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Nightssuser7cb4ff
 
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCR
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCRCall In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCR
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCRjennyeacort
 
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...Aqsa Yasmin
 
Water Conservation.pptxfgggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
Water Conservation.pptxfggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggWater Conservation.pptxfgggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
Water Conservation.pptxfggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggkhulekanimkhize2
 
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作f3774p8b
 

Último (20)

BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptx
BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptxBIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptx
BIODIVERSITY QUIZ ELIMINATION ROUND.pptx
 
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girls
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call GirlsAl Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girls
Al Jaddaf Housewife Call Girls +971509530047 Al Jaddaf Call Girls
 
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call GirlsHi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
Hi FI Call Girl Ahmedabad 7397865700 Independent Call Girls
 
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"s
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"sAlong the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"s
Along the Lakefront, "Menacing Unknown"s
 
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptx
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptxEMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptx
EMP (Environment Management Plan . .pptx
 
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
Call Girls Sarovar Portico Naraina Hotel, New Delhi 9873777170
 
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi NcrCall Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
Call Girls In R.K. Puram 9953056974 Escorts ServiCe In Delhi Ncr
 
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best ServicesGwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
Gwalior Call Girls 7001305949 WhatsApp Number 24x7 Best Services
 
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(Victoria毕业证书)维多利亚大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...9873940964 High Profile  Call Girls  Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
9873940964 High Profile Call Girls Delhi |Defence Colony ( MAYA CHOPRA ) DE...
 
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling Difference
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling DifferenceMaking a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling Difference
Making a Difference: Understanding the Upcycling and Recycling Difference
 
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptx
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptxLimnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptx
Limnology and Wetland Management 2023 NaRM.pptx
 
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdf
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdfGroup 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdf
Group 4The Species of the Atlantic Forest.pdf
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Ahmedabad 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
 
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCR
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCRCall In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCR
Call In girls Connaught Place (DELHI)⇛9711147426🔝Delhi NCR
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In  kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974FULL ENJOY Call Girls In  kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In kashmiri gate (Delhi) Call Us 9953056974
 
Call Girls In { Delhi } South Extension Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pl...
Call Girls In { Delhi } South Extension Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pl...Call Girls In { Delhi } South Extension Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pl...
Call Girls In { Delhi } South Extension Whatsup 9873940964 Enjoy Unlimited Pl...
 
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...
EARTH DAY Slide show EARTHDAY.ORG is unwavering in our commitment to end plas...
 
Water Conservation.pptxfgggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
Water Conservation.pptxfggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggWater Conservation.pptxfgggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
Water Conservation.pptxfgggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
 
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作
Düsseldorf U学位证,杜塞尔多夫大学毕业证书1:1制作
 

Priority pollutants

  • 1. Devising a Risk Index for Priority Substances Emissions from WWTP Fiona Regan
  • 3. Work Package •  Interpreting PS monitoring data from DCU (Lisa Jones) and CIT: Metals, PAHs, Pesticides, VOCs •  Identifying major sources and risk factors for PS occurrence in WW •  Assessing risk of PS occurrence in catchments, over time •  Understanding sources, prioritising monitoring
  • 4. Priority Substance Monitoring •  EU WFD: Waters must be of “Good” ecological and chemical status by 2015 •  WFD: 33 PS groups, including 20 PHS, plus 11 potential PS •  PS emissions reduced to background concentrations •  PHS emissions eliminated within 20 years •  2008 EQS Directive: Average annual and maximum acceptable concentrations specified
  • 5. EQSDirective Potential Priority Substances Priority Hazardous Substances Alachlor Anthracene AMPA Atrazine Brominated diphenylether Bentazon Benzene Cadmium and its compounds Bisphenol-A Chloroalkanes, C10-13 Dicofol Endosulfan EDTA Chlorfenvinpos Hexachlorobenzene Free cyanide Chlorpyrifos (Chlorpyrifos-theyl) Hexachlorobutadiene Glyphosate 1,2-dichloroethane Hexachlorocyclohexane Mercoprop (MCPP) Dichloromethane Mercury and its compounds Musk xylene Di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) Nonylphenol Diuron (4-nonylphenol) Fluoranthene Pentachlorobenzene Isoproturon Polyaromatic hydrocarbons Lead and its compounds (Benzo(a)pyrene) Dioxins Napthalene (Benzo(b)fluoranthene) PCB Nickel and its compounds (Benzo(g,h,i)perylene) Octylphenol (Benzo(k)fluoranthene) (Ideno(1,2,3-cd)pyrene) Tributyltin compounds Pentachlorophenol (Tributyltin-cation) Simazine Trichlorobenzenes Trichloromethane (chloroform) Trifluralin (4-(1,1',3,3'-tetramethylbutyl)-phenol) Priority Substances Perflurooctane sulphonic acid (PFOS) Quinoxyfen (5,7-dichloro-4(p- fluorophenoxy)quinoline) Pentabromodiphenylether (cogener numbers 28, 47, 99, 100, 153 and 154)
  • 6. Ireland Monitoring •  SERBD PS screening programmes •  Expert Working Group identified 202 (WFD + 161) candidate substances •  Produced preliminary screening list of 41 PS •  TNO: 47 of the 51 analysed PS found in water •  18 PS in 10% samples, 3 in >50% of the samples – naphthalene, fluoranthene, nickel –  Median concentrations ranged from 0.009 µg L-1 for fluoranthene to 1.4 µg L-1 for Nickel •  Long-term compliance monitoring required
  • 7. Priority Substances in Wastewater •  Waste water major point-source input to surface waters •  Responsible for localised EQS exceedance? •  Often upstream of drinking water abstraction! •  Can be controlled •  Combined sewer discharges and “high-risk” runoff •  Few data on waste water PS discharges •  Will complement storm water studies, and inform targeted PS monitoring (both WW and SW)
  • 8. WWTP Removal (to sludge /air) Diffuse sources WasteWater Drainage Storm overflow River Direct sources Final Effluent Surfacewater 1. Source magnitude / type 2. Diffuse loss risk / conditions 3. Surface water - sewer connectivity 5.WWTP removal efficiency 4. Sewer mixing and overflow
  • 9. Potential High Risk Source Sites (SWRBD) •  Oil and gasworks sites (IPPC, LA) •  (Hazardous) waste disposal/handling sites (EPA, LA) •  Mining sites (IPPC) •  Chemical plants (IPPC, LA) •  Airports, railway depots, dockyards, petroleum import terminals (LA) •  Timber treatment (IPPC, LA) •  Filling stations (LA) •  Building sites (LA) • Past industrial sites • Roads • Industrial estates • Combined drainage areas Connectivity to sewers?
  • 10. Pesticides: High Risk Landuse •  Sports grounds (Incl golf courses) •  Parks and open urban areas •  Intensive animal rearing (IPPC) •  Intensive tillage (potatoes) (CORINE) •  Forestry (Coillte spray data) •  Intensive grassland (CORINE)
  • 11. Source intensity Connectivity Households Commercial Industry Roads-traffic Contaminatedsites Point sources, continuous input, baseline loading and concentrations Diffuse sources, periodic input, peak loading and concentrations
  • 12.
  • 13. WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Study Approach WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Industry dominated, no final treatment: possible to ID industry input WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periodsMonthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine WWTP Treatment Agglom. PE Plant PE 2007 compliance Receiving waters Ballincollig, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Freshwater-R Bandon, Cork Secondary 6,200 8,000 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Charleville, Cork Secondary 7,500 6,415 F (sample no.s) Freshwater-R Clonakilty, Cork Secondary 15,000 15,000 F (TSS) Estuarine Fermoy, Cork Secondary, NR 12,960 12,960 P Freshwater-R Mallow, Cork Secondary, NR 12,000 12,000 P Freshwater-R Ringaskiddy, Cork None 12,000 97,556 F (no 2nd treatment) Estuarine Rosscarbery, Cork Primary 2,500 2,500 NA Coastal Ringsend, Dublin Secondary 2,870,000 1,640,000 F (BOD, COD, TSS) Estuarine Swords, Dublin Secondary, NR 50,000 60,000 F (BOD, TSS) Estuarine Monthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periodsMonthly sampling, plus intensive summer + winter sampling periods
  • 14. Study Approach cont… Ten catchments, range of sizes, physical characteristics, industrial contributions, treatment levels 1.  Collate data on potential sources (e.g. industry) and risk factors (e.g. combined drainage) for each catchment 2.  Compile literature data on source magnitudes and WWTP removal efficiencies 3.  Look for associations between meterological or physico- chem parameters and PS concs / loads 4.  Devise risk index for high PS in effluent (across catchments, over time): compare with mon data
  • 16. Licensed industry License n Risk IPPC-Chemicals 27 Ms, PAH, VOC IPPC- Food & Drink 4 IPPC- Metals 4 Ms, PAH, VOC IPPC-Minerals, Fibre, Glass 3 PAH, VOC IPPC-Power Stations 5 PAH, VOC IPPC-Surface Coatings 17 PAH, VOC IPPC-Wood Paper Textiles 6 PAH, VOC EPA-Hazardous Waste 13 Ms, VOC, PAH EPA-Integrated Waste Management 4 Ms, VOC, PAH EPA-Landfill 2 Ms, VOC, PAH EPA-Materials Recovery Facility 4 Ms, VOC, PAH EPA-Waste Transfer Facility 15 Ms, VOC, PAH License n Risk LA-Airport 2 PAH, VOC LA-Chemical 13 Ms, PAH, VOC LA-College 9 VOC LA-Construction 28 Ms, PAH LA-Dentist 1 Ms LA-Electronics 1 Ms, VOC LA-Filling Station 67 M, PAH, VOC LA Food & Drink 63 LA-Garage 33 PAH, VOC LA-Gym 7 LA-Haulage Depot 51 M, PAH, VOC LA-Hotel 3 LA-Hospital 19 VOC LA-Hairdresser 1 VOC LA-Laundry 5 M, PAH, VOC LA-Metal 10 Ms, PAH, VOC LA-Oil Distribution 1 PAH, VOC LA-Office 6 LA-Printers 16 VOC LA-Retail 25 LA-Sport 6 Pest LA-Washing (Outdoors)4 Ms, PAH LA-Waste 6 Ms, PAH, VOC Other 10 Separate direct vs diffuse inputs? Data from EPA, DCC, SDCC, FCC. Awaiting DLRCC…
  • 17. Other risk factors •  Traffic volume or road area •  Intensive agriculture and forestry in / near catchment •  Local authority pesticide application •  Extent of combined drainage •  Temporal –  meteorological (heavy rainfall after dry period) –  traffic volume patterns (stats) Data from Met Eireann and NRA require update and processing. Awaiting CC pest app data…
  • 18. Ringsend effluent 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 1400000 1600000 Flow (m3 day-1) PercentageinfluentTSSremoved Routine operating variability (random?) Process failure: Non predictable risk factor Capacity excedence? Risk Factor? On average, less efficient at higher flows: Risk factor Stats…
  • 19. 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 1400000 1600000 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0 Rainfall (mm day-1) Flow(m3day-1) High non-meteo variability Above 800,000 m3 = rain R2 = 0.55 0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000 1200000 1400000 1600000 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0 Rainfall (mm day-1) Flow(m3day-1) High non-meteo variability Above 600,000 m3 = rain Rain, next-day flow More data and analysis required. New parameter (e.g. daily-flow increase vs rainfall?) Same-day rain and flow
  • 20. 0 20,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 100,000 120,000 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 35.0 40.0 Rainfall (mm day-1) TSSload(tonnesday-1) Rain, next day TSS total load Rainfall threshold for TSS and PAH loss risk? More data and analysis required…
  • 22. PAH Loading Risk Index 1.  Discharge from licensed high-risk industry 2.  Frequency of contaminated sites 3.  Traffic volume 4.  Combined drains x (2 + 3) (+ urban, - rural ?) 5.  Normalised according to popn Effluent PAH conc Risk Index 1.  Loading Index x: i.  Meteorological conditions ii.  WWTP removal efficiency 2.  Normalised acc to flow per popn
  • 23. Work Plan •  Complete industrial point source database –  Distinguish IPPC direct from diffuse inputs? •  Literature search for magnitude of PS emissions from various sources •  Find data on past industrial sites? •  Collate NRA traffic volume data for each catchment •  Obtain and collate pesticide use data from CCs •  Obtain Met Eireann data to Nov and compare with Ringsend / Swords effluent PS concs •  Obtain flow and physico-chem data from Swords and Cork WWTPs •  Literature search for WWTP PS removal efficiencies
  • 24. Work Overview…. •  A review was used to identify the major factors leading to Priority Pollutant (PP) loading from WWTPs, integrated and conceptualised in a basic conceptual model. •  Available data sources were identified for the major PP loading risk factors. Then, through a combination of quantitative data collation (e.g. number of discharge licences issued to different types of operations) and qualitative risk assessment (risk ranking), risk databases were compiled for major sources.
  • 25. ….Work Overview •  Databases were compiled for Local Authority and EPA licensed discharges, and agglomeration traffic. Results from these databases were integrated into a simple risk model for agglomeration PP loading, combined with basic WWTP (e.g. capacity and treatment level) and agglomeration (e.g. population and area) data, and finally expressed as elevated risk in a national context following normalisation procedures.
  • 26. Work Overview •  Collate available literature and statistical data that could be used to inform targeted PP monitoring strategies. •  Focus on readily-available data relevant to major PP risk factors identified by conceptual modelling, and develop appropriate indicators. •  Indicators are applied to ten WWTP agglomerations currently being monitored to predict the relative risk of elevated PP loading to receiving waters across agglomerations and over time.
  • 27. List of WWTP •  Cork –  Ballincollig –  Bandon –  Charleville –  Clonakilty –  Fermoy –  Mallow –  Ringaskiddy –  Rosscarbery •  Dublin –  Ringsend –  Swords
  • 28. Collated Data •  Basic information on WWTPs and the agglomerations they serve in Ireland is provided in documentation submitted to the EPA in application for Urban Wastewater Discharge Licences (http://www.epa.ie).
  • 29. From EPA Urban Waste Water Report
  • 30. •  Removal factors applied to WWTPs in dry- and wet- weather flow conditions, based on removal efficiencies derived from Seriki et al. (2008) and load factors (agglomeration PE divided by WWTP PE capacity). Seriki K., Gasperi J., Castillo L., Scholes L., Eriksson E., Revitt M., Meinhold J., Atanasova N. (2008) Priority pollutants behaviour in end of pipe wastewater treatment plants. In Source Control Options for Reducing Emissions of Priority Pollutants (ScorePP)
  • 31. •  WWTP load factors were calculated as a ratio of agglomeration PE loading to WWTP PE capacity.
  • 32. •  WWTP risk factor = 1-removal fraction (e.g. 80% PAH removal for standard secondary treatment in Dry Weather Flow = 0.2) •  For CY, because secondary treatment capacity limited to approx half average agglomeration PE, DWF risk factor based on average of Primary and Secondary treatment •  For Wet Weather Flow, risk factors assume primary treatment removal efficiencies
  • 33. •  For WWTPs working in excess of or close to capacity, WWF removal factors were based on the assumption that overall removal efficiencies under high loading conditions were equivalent to primary treatment removal efficiencies. Removal factors were inversed into Effluent Factors (EF) for direct multiplication with loading factors.
  • 34. •  Industrial installations performing listed activities above specified thresholds are licensed under the EU Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (IPPC) Directive. Licence conditions and annual reports on emissions from these installations are made publicly available by the Irish Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
  • 35. •  The level of information provided on PP emissions varies across installations, and for the initial purposes of our risk-based model we define risk factors for each installation according to activity class, refined based on some installation-specific information provided in licences (whether or not discharge to sewers, and surface water management).
  • 37. •  ‘Typical’ loading risk factors for each major PP group, applied to installations in each IPPC and Waste activity class. •  Loading risk factors applied to individual installations may vary within activity groups, depending on licence information regarding processes, sewer discharge, and surface water management.
  • 40. •  Traffic-induced loading to WWTP (PAH, VOCs, HMs) should be largely proportional to traffic volume within agglomeration combined drainage areas, as measured by Vehicle km Travelled (VKT).
  • 41. •  Relevant available statistics are traffic flow on national roads in the vicinty of study agglomerations (NRA, 2009), total VKT for different vehicle types (CSO, 2009) and national VKT for six major road types (National Primary, National Secondary, Regional, Local Primary, Local Secondary, Local Tertiary)
  • 42. Road type National VKT (M km a-1 )a Agglomeration VKM calculation Length restriction Sewer input Nat. Prim. (10,665) NA Nat. Sec. (3,865) NA Regional 9,051 0.10 x (Popag / Popnat) Loc. Prim 4,621 0.25 x (Popag / Popnat) Loc. Sec 2,187 0.75 x (Popag / Popnat) Loc. Ter 784 1.00 x (Popag / Popnat) National road VKM travelled not used in calculations a Cars only. NRA data for 2002 (NRA, 2001) extrapolated to 2009 based on CSO national VKM in 2009 (presentation ref) LocaltrafficThrough traffic 2008 NRA traffic flow x road length in agglomeration Peripheral or central road? Sum local < 2 x agglomerat ion length Estimated percentage area under combined foul-storm drainage
  • 43. Ballincollig •  DWF •  Heavy rainfall •  PE/development
  • 46. Charleville •  Designed for a PE of up to 15,000 •  The PE and DWF are based on measured foul flows from 1973 •  Incoming flow can be divided evenly between two oxidation ditches –  Only one oxidation ditch in use –  PE ~ 7,000
  • 47. Clonakilty •  Designed for a PE of 5,333 •  Increased loading during summer of up to 15,000 PE •  At present two oxidation ditches •  Application for increased storage capacity not yet implemented •  Hydraulic load of 6 DWF
  • 48. Mallow •  Two treatment systems; 50 – 50 split between new and old plant •  Contract out for private operation and maintenance contract –  Could be in place before the end of the year
  • 49.
  • 50. Rosscarberry/Owenahincha •  Proposed works may now not take place •  Discharge from chemical toilets and mobile homes?
  • 51. Fermoy •  Designed for a PE of 20,000 •  System was upgraded, licence states that 40 % of flow meant to go to old plant
  • 54. Further Work •  Meteorological data will need to be used to derive a temporal component to this risk factor.
  • 55. Acknowledgements This project is funded by the EPA as part of the Science, Technology, Research and Innovation for the Environment (STRIVE) Programme 2007–2013. This programme is financed by the Irish Government under the National Development Plan 2007–2013. It is administered on behalf of the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government by the Environmental Protection Agency, which has the statutory function of co-ordinating and promoting environmental research.