SlideShare una empresa de Scribd logo
1 de 27
Descargar para leer sin conexión
Directors’ Assembly
                                                      March 9, 2010




Between Rocks and Whirlpools: Bank Strategy 2010
Required Disclosures
The following information is for informational purposes only and was prepared from sources
 believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy and is not a complete summary
or statement of all available data. The views or opinions expressed in this material are solely
 those of the speaker/author and do not necessarily represent those of Janney Montgomery
                                           Scott LLC.


   Janney Montgomery Scott LLC is a broker-dealer registered with the US Securities and
              Exchange Commission and member NYSE, FINRA, and SIPC.




                                                                                              2
Speaker Credentials: Roger G. Powell
                                   Native of Fayetteville                                      Experience
                                   Former Scoutmaster,
                                   Troop 17, Christ          Investment Banking                   Janney Montgomery Scott (2008 - )
                                   Church, Charlotte          Banks / Thrifts                    Alex. Brown & Sons1 (1990-1999)
                                   Interests: family,         Mortgage Companies
                                   American history,
                                   antique maps,              Credit Card
                                   conservation and            Issuers
                                   outdoor activities
                                                               Processors
                                                              Commercial Finance

                        Academic                             Investment Research                  Alex. Brown & Sons (1983-1990)
                                                              Banks / Thrifts                    The Powell Group (1972-1976)
                                                              Mortgage Cos
B.A. Economics 1971      Davidson College, Davidson, NC
                                                              Credit Card Cos
                                                              Asset Managers
Certificate, Advanced    North Carolina School of Banking,   Corporate Development /              Deutsche Bank AG2 (2000-2007)
Management Program                                           Strategic Planning                   United Carolina Bancshares (1976 – 1982)
                         Chapel Hill, NC
1978



                                                              1 Andsuccessors: BT Alex. Brown and Deutsche Bank Securities d/b/a Deutsche Bank
                                                               Alex. Brown
                                                              2 Global
                                                                     Private Client Group and Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown, a business unit of Deutsche
                                                               Bank Securities Inc.

                                                                                                                                                       3
Rocks and whirlpools: the sailor’s fear…
                         Adm. Shovel’s fleet on the Rocks of Scilly, 1707




             National Maritime Museum Picture Library, Greewich, England




                                                                            4
Rocks and whirlpools…
                                Adm. Shovel’s fleet on the Rocks of Scilly, 1707

   Admiral Cloudsley Shovel – a 26 year veteran of the most advanced and powerful naval power of the time – lost his
    flagship, his life and ~2,000 sailors and marines along with a large part of his fleet on the Scilly Isles in 1707.
   He knew the islands were there – they are well known to English, Irish and Cornish sailors – off of Cornwall at the
    entry of the Irish sea.
   He did not know where he was and an storm drove the fleet upon the rocks.
   This disaster, the greatest in the history of the British fleet, incited the Lords of the Admiralty to offer a prize for the
    maker of an accurate chronograph in order that navigators could accurately compute their longitude.


   As a banker you know the rocks in your course – the known risks of the business. You must always know where
    you are relative to those risks by using the best techniques of navigation. Do not let a storm throw you upon t he
    rocks.




                                                                                                                                   5
Rocks and whirlpools…
                                                  Maelstrom of Lofoten, Norway




      New-York Magazine; or, Literary Repository Of the celebrated WHIRLPOOL called the MAELSTROM on the Coast of Norway, Vol. II No. XII Dec 1791




                                                                                                                                                     6
Rocks and whirlpools…
                                          Maelstrom of Lofoten, Norway
   Whirlpools rise from action of tide and wind, generally in narrow channels.
   The most famous is off the coast of Norway and was named ‘Maelstrom’ by Dutch sailors.
   A small vessel can be destroyed by its action.
   To avoid a whirlpool requires adquate flotation and power to avoid its force.
   The tide of regulatory vigor has set with full force; the wind of the economy has blown Force 5.
   Capital is a bank’s flotation; earnings is its power. It takes both to avoid the vortex of the Maelstrom.




                                                                                                                7
Goal: avoid the known risks; be able to survive the unknown.
   Rocks
     You know where they are.
         Where are you?
         Can you be blown upon them?


   Whirlpools
     Arise with winds of regulation and economic tides; you will not see them until you are upon
      them.
         Are you large enough to survive?
         Do you have enough flotation, i.e. capital?
         Can you power, i.e. earn, through them?




                                                                                                    8
For 2010 Strategy cycle: focus on critical themes

   Position
       versus changing competition
       relative to your balance sheet risks



   Capital
       to survive
       to thrive
       to earn


   Control
       of operations and risk position
       of message and information
       of future

                                                    9
Position: versus competitors
   Secular
     Banks lose share to capital markets
     Consolidation creates highly competitive markets
     Capital markets pricing and structure degrade overall bank pricing
     Portfolio mix responds to disintermediation of cards, cars and mortgages


   Cyclical
     Risk cycle takes away momentum
         risk realization exceeds trend after a decade below-trend
         Asset quality and capital issues distract management
     Competitive banks have opportunity
     Regulators as referees




                                                                                 10
Position: versus competitors
 Banks lose share to capital markets
                                                Shifting Shares of Major Non-Bank Players in Credit Provision
                                                    [Ex cludes Credit Market Assets Held by Federal Reserv e]
      100%
             Percent of Total Credit Market                                                Other Credit Providers
                Assets Held by Financial
                         Sector                                                                                        Money Market
       80%          Credit Providers                                                                                   Mutual Funds
                                                                            Insurance Cos.



                                                                                                                         "Private Label" MBS Issuers,
                                                                                                Pension Funds
       60%                                                                                                                    and Consumer Credit &
                                                                                                                                 Business Credit
                                                                                                                                   ABS Issuers

       40%                                                                                                                Government Sponsored

                                                                         Banks                                                    Enterprises
                                                            (Commercial Banks, Bank Holding
                                                               Cos., Thrifts, Credit Unions)
       20%

                Source: Figure A1. in Susan Hickok and Daniel E. Nolle, "The U.S. Financial System in 2011: How Will Sufficient Credit Be Provided?"
                Economics Working Paper 2009-6, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (Nov. 2009).

        0%
         1970    1972   1974      1976   1978    1980   1982    1984    1986    1988     1990    1992   1994    1996   1998     2000   2002     2004   2006   2008




                                                                                                                                                                     11
Position: “A Banking Battleground”




  Source: New York Times, March 6, 2010 “A Banking Battleground”




                                                                   12
Position: versus competitors
   Capital markets pricing and structure degrade spreads




                                                            13
Position: versus competitors
 Portfolio mix responds to
                                                                     Loan Portfolio Composition
                         December 31, 2002                                                                        December 31, 2009
                                                         Commercial Real                                                        Commercial Real
                                                                                                    Residential
                                                            Estate                                                                    Estate
                                                                                                       25%                            15%
   Residential                                                 12%
     30%                                                                    Credit Cards
                                                                                6%
                                                                                                                                                  Credit Cards
                                                                                                                                                      6%

                                                                                Other Consumer
                                                                                     10%                                                          Other Consumer
                                                                                                                                                         9%
                                                                                   Agriculture *
                                                                                                                                                    Agriculture *
                                                                                       1%
                                                                                                                                                        1%
                                                                                  Leases                                                           Leases
                                                                                   3%              Commercial &                                     2%
Commercial &                                                                                         Industrial                                     Construction
                                                                                    Construction
  Industrial                                                  All Other Loans                          17%
                                                                                       5%                                       All Other Loans          6%
    19%                                                            14%                                                               19%




   * OTS – Supervised Savings Associations do no identify agriculture loans.
   Source: FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile 4Q:02 and 4Q:09




                                                                                                                                                               14
Position: versus balance sheet
 Below-trend risk realization ends
 3.00                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             3.00




 2.50                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2.50




 2.00                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             2.00




 1.50                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1.50



                                                                                                           Average ’84-’09 = 0.84%
 1.00                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             1.00




 0.50                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             0.50




 0.00                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             0.00
        Mar-84

                 Mar-85

                          Mar-86

                                   Mar-87

                                            Mar-88

                                                     Mar-89

                                                              Mar-90

                                                                       Mar-91

                                                                                Mar-92

                                                                                         Mar-93

                                                                                                  Mar-94

                                                                                                           Mar-95

                                                                                                                    Mar-96

                                                                                                                             Mar-97

                                                                                                                                      Mar-98

                                                                                                                                               Mar-99

                                                                                                                                                        Mar-00

                                                                                                                                                                 Mar-01

                                                                                                                                                                          Mar-02

                                                                                                                                                                                   Mar-03

                                                                                                                                                                                            Mar-04

                                                                                                                                                                                                     Mar-05

                                                                                                                                                                                                              Mar-06

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Mar-07

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Mar-08

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Mar-09
        Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     15
Position: versus competitors
 Asset quality and capital issues distract management
                            Banks Headquartered in NC with NPAs / Assets > 4% at 12/31/09
               30




               25                                                                  24




               20




               15




               10



                                                              6

                5



                                     1

                0
                                  > $10 bn              $1 bn - $10 bn           < $1 bn
   Source: SNL Financial.


                                                                                            16
Position: cyclical opportunity
   Opportunity for active banks to take share by becoming a strategic partner


     Historical advantage of commercial banks: information advantage
         View of cash flows
         Intimate business analysis
         Collateral ties


   Regulators are the referee


     Regulatory vigor animates the board room
     Banks become the ‘whipping boy’ of the economy
         The savings & loans are no longer the instrument of housing and economic policy
     Winners / Losers



                                                                                            17
Capital
   Secular Trend
     Reversal of trend to lower tangible equity levels
         Basel II was height of trust in risk models and infinite liquidity
         “The new 10% is 12%” and etc.
     What ROE translates to premium share price?
     Portfolio mix responds to disintermediation of cards, cars and mortgages


   Cyclical Factors
     Access degraded, especially for ‘micro-cap’ and smaller
         Trust preferred reverts to single-issuer – no longer ‘just-in-time’ for all
     Internal capital growth depends upon earnings retention




                                                                                        18
Capital: seek higher levels
 Reversal of trend to lower Tier 1 Risk Based Capital levels
  18.00



  16.00



  14.00



  12.00



  10.00



   8.00



   6.00



   4.00



   2.00



   0.00
          1990     1991      1992   1993   1994   1995   1996   1997   1998   1999   2000   2001   2002   2003   2004   2005   2006   2007   2008   2009

    Source: SNL Financial.


                                                                                                                                                           19
Capital: what is good performance?
   What ROE translates to premium share price?


     Investor attention turns to ‘pre-provision normalized earning rate’
         If asset quality is seen to be stable or improving, THEN bank earnings matter
         SPDR S&P 500 Index ETF: 21.2% trailing ROE a/o 2/28/2010 (β~1.08)
         SPDR KBW Bank ETF: 0.14% trailing ROE (β~2.35)


     Investors have abandoned ‘micro-’ and ‘nano-cap’ stocks
         Large-cap = $8 billion common equity value and larger
         Mid-cap = $1 < $8 billion common equity value
         Small-cap = $250 million < $ 1 billion common equity value
         Micro-cap = $50 million < $250 million common equity value
         Nano-cap = less than $50 million common equity value



                                                                                          20
Capital: equity market access degraded
       Market access degraded, especially for ‘micro-cap’ and smaller
                                                    Capital Raising in 2009 By Institution Asset Size ($MM)

                               Senior Debt


                         Subordinated Debt


                                       TRUPS


                           TARP Preferred


                                  Preferred


                                  Common




                                               $0      $20,000         $40,000          $60,000         $80,000                $100,000              $120,000

                                                            Common       Preferred   TARP Preferred   TRUPS       Subordinated Debt       Senior Debt
                              <$1.0B                             554       126           1,491          16               35                  176
                              $1.0B - $25.0B                 11,045       1,412          3,752         405               297                 404
                              $25.0B - $100.0B               6,330        1,800            -           935              1,500                960
                              >$100.0B                       94,331       64,137         30,000       32,984             710                24,775
Source: SNL Financial.



                                                                                                                                                                21
Capital: growth relies on internal equity retention
     Internal capital growth depends upon earnings retention


                          Rate of Growth Supported by Equity Retention at 6% Constant Equity/Assets
                                                             Dividend Payout Ratio (%)
                        11.67%         10.0%    20.0%    30.0%    40.0%    50.0%    60.0%   70.0%   80.0%   90.0%
                         0.25%         3.75%    3.33%    2.92%    2.50%    2.08%    1.67%   1.25%   0.83%   0.42%
                         0.50%         7.50%    6.67%    5.83%    5.00%    4.17%    3.33%   2.50%   1.67%   0.83%
          ROA (%)




                         0.75%        11.25%   10.00%    8.75%    7.50%    6.25%    5.00%   3.75%   2.50%   1.25%
                         1.00%        15.00%   13.33%   11.67%   10.00%    8.33%    6.67%   5.00%   3.33%   1.67%
                         1.25%        18.75%   16.67%   14.58%   12.50%   10.42%    8.33%   6.25%   4.17%   2.08%
                         1.50%        22.50%   20.00%   17.50%   15.00%   12.50%   10.00%   7.50%   5.00%   2.50%
                         1.75%        26.25%   23.33%   20.42%   17.50%   14.58%   11.67%   8.75%   5.83%   2.92%




Source: Janney Montgomery Scott LLC



                                                                                                                    22
Control
   Secular Trend
     Tolerances are small in low growth environment
     Margins remain under pressure
     Fee sources under attack
     Internal controls must tighten in response to demanding operating conditions
     ‘Big Bank’ risk management systems become ‘best practices’


   Cyclical Factors
     Regulatory pendulum swings to full vigor
     Governance issues take higher profile (SarbOx and fiduciary law developments)
     Public relations demand high resolution




                                                                                      23
Control: secular factor response
   Tolerances are small in low growth environment
       You must manage the details all day every day
   Margins remain under pressure
       Pricing degradation is permanent – find a niche where you can
   Fee sources under attack
       Populism and consumerism go hand-in-hand and marry in post-recession scenarios
   Internal controls must tighten in response to demanding operating conditions
       While you must retain marketing momentum
   ‘Big Bank’ risk management systems become ‘best practices’
       How can you efficiently implement enterprise risk management?




                                                                                         24
Control: cyclical factor response
   Regulatory pendulum swings to full vigor
       Position statements from Washington may not jibe with examination outcomes


   Governance issues take higher profile (SarbOx and fiduciary law developments)
       Financial statement certification is serious
       Prudential management is serious


   Public relations demand high resolution
       Say only what you mean to say
       Be able to defend everything that you say

    “Never write if you can speak; never speak if you can nod; never nod if you can wink”.
        -attributed to Martin Michael Lomasney (December 3, 1859 -August 12, 1933), Boston politician
     “never put it in email”
        - attributed to Eliot Laurence Spitzer (born June 10, 1959), New York politician




                                                                                                        25
Rocks and whirlpools…

                      ‘Old Sow’ – the largest whirlpool in the western hemisphere

  Between Deer Island, N.B. and Eastport, Me




    Watch out, you sport kayakers!



                                                                                    26
Janney Montgomery Scott Contact Information
JMS Contact                         Telephone                     Email                Location
Cliff Booth, Head of FIG Practice   410-583-5992                  cbooth@janney.com    Baltimore / Philadelphia

Ed Losty, Head of Bank Practice     757-564-9737 / 215-665-4491   elosty@janney.com    Virginia / Philadelphia

Roger Powell, Managing Director     410-583-5993 / 215-665-6687   rpowell@janney.com   Baltimore / Philadelphia

Jay Junior, Managing Director       215-665-4497                  jjunior@janney.com   Philadelphia




                                                                                                             27

Más contenido relacionado

Destacado

Monavie Dr Schauss
Monavie Dr SchaussMonavie Dr Schauss
Monavie Dr Schausswayneulery
 
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social business
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social businessiCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social business
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social businessiCrossing
 
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346Kees Romkes
 
jQuery From the Ground Up
jQuery From the Ground UpjQuery From the Ground Up
jQuery From the Ground UpKevin Griffin
 
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MD
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MDClean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MD
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MDOhio Environmental Council
 
workshop: de visieversneller
workshop: de visieversnellerworkshop: de visieversneller
workshop: de visieversnellerannaTita
 
מצגת מטה מאבק גז
מצגת מטה מאבק גזמצגת מטה מאבק גז
מצגת מטה מאבק גזmoshava
 
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...rivetlogic
 
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nl
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nlBloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nl
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nlKees Romkes
 
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water Conference
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water ConferenceProtecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water Conference
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water ConferenceOhio Environmental Council
 
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferay
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with LiferayBuilding and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferay
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferayrivetlogic
 

Destacado (20)

Monavie Dr Schauss
Monavie Dr SchaussMonavie Dr Schauss
Monavie Dr Schauss
 
Quant03
Quant03Quant03
Quant03
 
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social business
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social businessiCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social business
iCrossing UK Client Summit 2011 - Social media to social business
 
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346
Nederland Leert - Presentatie bij #s2m346
 
Metadata 101
Metadata 101Metadata 101
Metadata 101
 
jQuery From the Ground Up
jQuery From the Ground UpjQuery From the Ground Up
jQuery From the Ground Up
 
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MD
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MDClean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MD
Clean Air & Your Health (Part 1) - David Stukus, MD
 
workshop: de visieversneller
workshop: de visieversnellerworkshop: de visieversneller
workshop: de visieversneller
 
מצגת מטה מאבק גז
מצגת מטה מאבק גזמצגת מטה מאבק גז
מצגת מטה מאבק גז
 
Unpacking the Final State Budget Bill
Unpacking the Final State Budget BillUnpacking the Final State Budget Bill
Unpacking the Final State Budget Bill
 
Year 9 major unit
Year 9 major unitYear 9 major unit
Year 9 major unit
 
Engagement Introduction
Engagement IntroductionEngagement Introduction
Engagement Introduction
 
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...
Increase Your Marketing Productivity With the Marketing Asset Center for Alfr...
 
Blogovi1
Blogovi1Blogovi1
Blogovi1
 
Vernal Pools & Plants
Vernal Pools & PlantsVernal Pools & Plants
Vernal Pools & Plants
 
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nl
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nlBloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nl
Bloggen, niet alleen omdat het leuk is - Ikki.nl
 
Junk Science vs. Solid Science
Junk Science vs. Solid ScienceJunk Science vs. Solid Science
Junk Science vs. Solid Science
 
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water Conference
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water ConferenceProtecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water Conference
Protecting Groundwater Resources - OH Clean Water Conference
 
Deep-Shale Gas Drilling, aka Fracking
Deep-Shale Gas Drilling, aka FrackingDeep-Shale Gas Drilling, aka Fracking
Deep-Shale Gas Drilling, aka Fracking
 
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferay
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with LiferayBuilding and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferay
Building and Deploying a Global Intranet with Liferay
 

Similar a Between Rocks and Whirlpools: Bank Strategy 2010

title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraud
title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraudtitle Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraud
title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraudMaria32232
 
Zahm covered bonds bna article
Zahm covered bonds bna articleZahm covered bonds bna article
Zahm covered bonds bna articleRichard Zahm
 
BNA Covered Bonds
BNA Covered BondsBNA Covered Bonds
BNA Covered Bondsrzahm
 
Zahm bna june 10 covered bonds
Zahm bna june 10 covered bondsZahm bna june 10 covered bonds
Zahm bna june 10 covered bondsRichard Zahm
 
Asset allocation inflation_july09
Asset allocation inflation_july09Asset allocation inflation_july09
Asset allocation inflation_july09norhafizam
 
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institute
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment InstituteU.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institute
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institutedtresemer
 
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North AmericaGRESB
 
The henley group outlook march
The henley group outlook   marchThe henley group outlook   march
The henley group outlook marchJason King
 
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 edition
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 editionThe Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 edition
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 editionTania Scott
 
The Henley Group Outlook: March
The Henley Group Outlook: MarchThe Henley Group Outlook: March
The Henley Group Outlook: MarchNicola Arnold
 
Henley outlook march
Henley outlook marchHenley outlook march
Henley outlook marchGary Lansdown
 
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012Western Areas Ltd
 
Collateral Debt Obligation – A Perspective
Collateral Debt Obligation – A PerspectiveCollateral Debt Obligation – A Perspective
Collateral Debt Obligation – A PerspectiveAjay Rathi
 

Similar a Between Rocks and Whirlpools: Bank Strategy 2010 (20)

title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraud
title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraudtitle Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraud
title Inside Job.pptx its global crises or fraud
 
Zahm covered bonds bna article
Zahm covered bonds bna articleZahm covered bonds bna article
Zahm covered bonds bna article
 
Bna covered bonds
Bna covered bondsBna covered bonds
Bna covered bonds
 
BNA Covered Bonds
BNA Covered BondsBNA Covered Bonds
BNA Covered Bonds
 
Zahm bna june 10 covered bonds
Zahm bna june 10 covered bondsZahm bna june 10 covered bonds
Zahm bna june 10 covered bonds
 
Asset allocation inflation_july09
Asset allocation inflation_july09Asset allocation inflation_july09
Asset allocation inflation_july09
 
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institute
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment InstituteU.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institute
U.S. Election Cliffhangers - BlackRock Investment Institute
 
DDOz16 brochure 4Mar
DDOz16 brochure 4MarDDOz16 brochure 4Mar
DDOz16 brochure 4Mar
 
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America
2016 GRESB Real Estate & Debt Results Release - North America
 
Nap investor presentation_feb2011
Nap investor presentation_feb2011Nap investor presentation_feb2011
Nap investor presentation_feb2011
 
Nap investor presentation_2010dec
Nap investor presentation_2010decNap investor presentation_2010dec
Nap investor presentation_2010dec
 
The henley group outlook march
The henley group outlook   marchThe henley group outlook   march
The henley group outlook march
 
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 edition
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 editionThe Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 edition
The Henley Group' Outlook - March 2013 edition
 
The Henley Group Outlook: March
The Henley Group Outlook: MarchThe Henley Group Outlook: March
The Henley Group Outlook: March
 
Henley outlook march
Henley outlook marchHenley outlook march
Henley outlook march
 
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012
Western Areas Corporate Presentation June 2012
 
Nap investor presentationmarch2011
Nap investor presentationmarch2011Nap investor presentationmarch2011
Nap investor presentationmarch2011
 
Collateral Debt Obligation – A Perspective
Collateral Debt Obligation – A PerspectiveCollateral Debt Obligation – A Perspective
Collateral Debt Obligation – A Perspective
 
Pam Icecap Oct Nov2012
Pam Icecap Oct Nov2012Pam Icecap Oct Nov2012
Pam Icecap Oct Nov2012
 
Drconferencefinal
DrconferencefinalDrconferencefinal
Drconferencefinal
 

Between Rocks and Whirlpools: Bank Strategy 2010

  • 1. Directors’ Assembly March 9, 2010 Between Rocks and Whirlpools: Bank Strategy 2010
  • 2. Required Disclosures The following information is for informational purposes only and was prepared from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy and is not a complete summary or statement of all available data. The views or opinions expressed in this material are solely those of the speaker/author and do not necessarily represent those of Janney Montgomery Scott LLC. Janney Montgomery Scott LLC is a broker-dealer registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission and member NYSE, FINRA, and SIPC. 2
  • 3. Speaker Credentials: Roger G. Powell Native of Fayetteville Experience Former Scoutmaster, Troop 17, Christ Investment Banking Janney Montgomery Scott (2008 - ) Church, Charlotte  Banks / Thrifts Alex. Brown & Sons1 (1990-1999) Interests: family,  Mortgage Companies American history, antique maps,  Credit Card conservation and  Issuers outdoor activities  Processors  Commercial Finance Academic Investment Research Alex. Brown & Sons (1983-1990)  Banks / Thrifts The Powell Group (1972-1976)  Mortgage Cos B.A. Economics 1971 Davidson College, Davidson, NC  Credit Card Cos  Asset Managers Certificate, Advanced North Carolina School of Banking, Corporate Development / Deutsche Bank AG2 (2000-2007) Management Program Strategic Planning United Carolina Bancshares (1976 – 1982) Chapel Hill, NC 1978 1 Andsuccessors: BT Alex. Brown and Deutsche Bank Securities d/b/a Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown 2 Global Private Client Group and Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown, a business unit of Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. 3
  • 4. Rocks and whirlpools: the sailor’s fear… Adm. Shovel’s fleet on the Rocks of Scilly, 1707 National Maritime Museum Picture Library, Greewich, England 4
  • 5. Rocks and whirlpools… Adm. Shovel’s fleet on the Rocks of Scilly, 1707  Admiral Cloudsley Shovel – a 26 year veteran of the most advanced and powerful naval power of the time – lost his flagship, his life and ~2,000 sailors and marines along with a large part of his fleet on the Scilly Isles in 1707.  He knew the islands were there – they are well known to English, Irish and Cornish sailors – off of Cornwall at the entry of the Irish sea.  He did not know where he was and an storm drove the fleet upon the rocks.  This disaster, the greatest in the history of the British fleet, incited the Lords of the Admiralty to offer a prize for the maker of an accurate chronograph in order that navigators could accurately compute their longitude.  As a banker you know the rocks in your course – the known risks of the business. You must always know where you are relative to those risks by using the best techniques of navigation. Do not let a storm throw you upon t he rocks. 5
  • 6. Rocks and whirlpools… Maelstrom of Lofoten, Norway New-York Magazine; or, Literary Repository Of the celebrated WHIRLPOOL called the MAELSTROM on the Coast of Norway, Vol. II No. XII Dec 1791 6
  • 7. Rocks and whirlpools… Maelstrom of Lofoten, Norway  Whirlpools rise from action of tide and wind, generally in narrow channels.  The most famous is off the coast of Norway and was named ‘Maelstrom’ by Dutch sailors.  A small vessel can be destroyed by its action.  To avoid a whirlpool requires adquate flotation and power to avoid its force.  The tide of regulatory vigor has set with full force; the wind of the economy has blown Force 5.  Capital is a bank’s flotation; earnings is its power. It takes both to avoid the vortex of the Maelstrom. 7
  • 8. Goal: avoid the known risks; be able to survive the unknown.  Rocks  You know where they are.  Where are you?  Can you be blown upon them?  Whirlpools  Arise with winds of regulation and economic tides; you will not see them until you are upon them.  Are you large enough to survive?  Do you have enough flotation, i.e. capital?  Can you power, i.e. earn, through them? 8
  • 9. For 2010 Strategy cycle: focus on critical themes  Position  versus changing competition  relative to your balance sheet risks  Capital  to survive  to thrive  to earn  Control  of operations and risk position  of message and information  of future 9
  • 10. Position: versus competitors  Secular  Banks lose share to capital markets  Consolidation creates highly competitive markets  Capital markets pricing and structure degrade overall bank pricing  Portfolio mix responds to disintermediation of cards, cars and mortgages  Cyclical  Risk cycle takes away momentum  risk realization exceeds trend after a decade below-trend  Asset quality and capital issues distract management  Competitive banks have opportunity  Regulators as referees 10
  • 11. Position: versus competitors  Banks lose share to capital markets Shifting Shares of Major Non-Bank Players in Credit Provision [Ex cludes Credit Market Assets Held by Federal Reserv e] 100% Percent of Total Credit Market Other Credit Providers Assets Held by Financial Sector Money Market 80% Credit Providers Mutual Funds Insurance Cos. "Private Label" MBS Issuers, Pension Funds 60% and Consumer Credit & Business Credit ABS Issuers 40% Government Sponsored Banks Enterprises (Commercial Banks, Bank Holding Cos., Thrifts, Credit Unions) 20% Source: Figure A1. in Susan Hickok and Daniel E. Nolle, "The U.S. Financial System in 2011: How Will Sufficient Credit Be Provided?" Economics Working Paper 2009-6, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (Nov. 2009). 0% 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 11
  • 12. Position: “A Banking Battleground” Source: New York Times, March 6, 2010 “A Banking Battleground” 12
  • 13. Position: versus competitors  Capital markets pricing and structure degrade spreads 13
  • 14. Position: versus competitors  Portfolio mix responds to Loan Portfolio Composition December 31, 2002 December 31, 2009 Commercial Real Commercial Real Residential Estate Estate 25% 15% Residential 12% 30% Credit Cards 6% Credit Cards 6% Other Consumer 10% Other Consumer 9% Agriculture * Agriculture * 1% 1% Leases Leases 3% Commercial & 2% Commercial & Industrial Construction Construction Industrial All Other Loans 17% 5% All Other Loans 6% 19% 14% 19% * OTS – Supervised Savings Associations do no identify agriculture loans. Source: FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile 4Q:02 and 4Q:09 14
  • 15. Position: versus balance sheet  Below-trend risk realization ends 3.00 3.00 2.50 2.50 2.00 2.00 1.50 1.50 Average ’84-’09 = 0.84% 1.00 1.00 0.50 0.50 0.00 0.00 Mar-84 Mar-85 Mar-86 Mar-87 Mar-88 Mar-89 Mar-90 Mar-91 Mar-92 Mar-93 Mar-94 Mar-95 Mar-96 Mar-97 Mar-98 Mar-99 Mar-00 Mar-01 Mar-02 Mar-03 Mar-04 Mar-05 Mar-06 Mar-07 Mar-08 Mar-09 Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 15
  • 16. Position: versus competitors  Asset quality and capital issues distract management Banks Headquartered in NC with NPAs / Assets > 4% at 12/31/09 30 25 24 20 15 10 6 5 1 0 > $10 bn $1 bn - $10 bn < $1 bn Source: SNL Financial. 16
  • 17. Position: cyclical opportunity  Opportunity for active banks to take share by becoming a strategic partner  Historical advantage of commercial banks: information advantage  View of cash flows  Intimate business analysis  Collateral ties  Regulators are the referee  Regulatory vigor animates the board room  Banks become the ‘whipping boy’ of the economy  The savings & loans are no longer the instrument of housing and economic policy  Winners / Losers 17
  • 18. Capital  Secular Trend  Reversal of trend to lower tangible equity levels  Basel II was height of trust in risk models and infinite liquidity  “The new 10% is 12%” and etc.  What ROE translates to premium share price?  Portfolio mix responds to disintermediation of cards, cars and mortgages  Cyclical Factors  Access degraded, especially for ‘micro-cap’ and smaller  Trust preferred reverts to single-issuer – no longer ‘just-in-time’ for all  Internal capital growth depends upon earnings retention 18
  • 19. Capital: seek higher levels  Reversal of trend to lower Tier 1 Risk Based Capital levels 18.00 16.00 14.00 12.00 10.00 8.00 6.00 4.00 2.00 0.00 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Source: SNL Financial. 19
  • 20. Capital: what is good performance?  What ROE translates to premium share price?  Investor attention turns to ‘pre-provision normalized earning rate’  If asset quality is seen to be stable or improving, THEN bank earnings matter  SPDR S&P 500 Index ETF: 21.2% trailing ROE a/o 2/28/2010 (β~1.08)  SPDR KBW Bank ETF: 0.14% trailing ROE (β~2.35)  Investors have abandoned ‘micro-’ and ‘nano-cap’ stocks  Large-cap = $8 billion common equity value and larger  Mid-cap = $1 < $8 billion common equity value  Small-cap = $250 million < $ 1 billion common equity value  Micro-cap = $50 million < $250 million common equity value  Nano-cap = less than $50 million common equity value 20
  • 21. Capital: equity market access degraded  Market access degraded, especially for ‘micro-cap’ and smaller Capital Raising in 2009 By Institution Asset Size ($MM) Senior Debt Subordinated Debt TRUPS TARP Preferred Preferred Common $0 $20,000 $40,000 $60,000 $80,000 $100,000 $120,000 Common Preferred TARP Preferred TRUPS Subordinated Debt Senior Debt <$1.0B 554 126 1,491 16 35 176 $1.0B - $25.0B 11,045 1,412 3,752 405 297 404 $25.0B - $100.0B 6,330 1,800 - 935 1,500 960 >$100.0B 94,331 64,137 30,000 32,984 710 24,775 Source: SNL Financial. 21
  • 22. Capital: growth relies on internal equity retention  Internal capital growth depends upon earnings retention Rate of Growth Supported by Equity Retention at 6% Constant Equity/Assets Dividend Payout Ratio (%) 11.67% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% 90.0% 0.25% 3.75% 3.33% 2.92% 2.50% 2.08% 1.67% 1.25% 0.83% 0.42% 0.50% 7.50% 6.67% 5.83% 5.00% 4.17% 3.33% 2.50% 1.67% 0.83% ROA (%) 0.75% 11.25% 10.00% 8.75% 7.50% 6.25% 5.00% 3.75% 2.50% 1.25% 1.00% 15.00% 13.33% 11.67% 10.00% 8.33% 6.67% 5.00% 3.33% 1.67% 1.25% 18.75% 16.67% 14.58% 12.50% 10.42% 8.33% 6.25% 4.17% 2.08% 1.50% 22.50% 20.00% 17.50% 15.00% 12.50% 10.00% 7.50% 5.00% 2.50% 1.75% 26.25% 23.33% 20.42% 17.50% 14.58% 11.67% 8.75% 5.83% 2.92% Source: Janney Montgomery Scott LLC 22
  • 23. Control  Secular Trend  Tolerances are small in low growth environment  Margins remain under pressure  Fee sources under attack  Internal controls must tighten in response to demanding operating conditions  ‘Big Bank’ risk management systems become ‘best practices’  Cyclical Factors  Regulatory pendulum swings to full vigor  Governance issues take higher profile (SarbOx and fiduciary law developments)  Public relations demand high resolution 23
  • 24. Control: secular factor response  Tolerances are small in low growth environment  You must manage the details all day every day  Margins remain under pressure  Pricing degradation is permanent – find a niche where you can  Fee sources under attack  Populism and consumerism go hand-in-hand and marry in post-recession scenarios  Internal controls must tighten in response to demanding operating conditions  While you must retain marketing momentum  ‘Big Bank’ risk management systems become ‘best practices’  How can you efficiently implement enterprise risk management? 24
  • 25. Control: cyclical factor response  Regulatory pendulum swings to full vigor  Position statements from Washington may not jibe with examination outcomes  Governance issues take higher profile (SarbOx and fiduciary law developments)  Financial statement certification is serious  Prudential management is serious  Public relations demand high resolution  Say only what you mean to say  Be able to defend everything that you say “Never write if you can speak; never speak if you can nod; never nod if you can wink”. -attributed to Martin Michael Lomasney (December 3, 1859 -August 12, 1933), Boston politician “never put it in email” - attributed to Eliot Laurence Spitzer (born June 10, 1959), New York politician 25
  • 26. Rocks and whirlpools… ‘Old Sow’ – the largest whirlpool in the western hemisphere  Between Deer Island, N.B. and Eastport, Me Watch out, you sport kayakers! 26
  • 27. Janney Montgomery Scott Contact Information JMS Contact Telephone Email Location Cliff Booth, Head of FIG Practice 410-583-5992 cbooth@janney.com Baltimore / Philadelphia Ed Losty, Head of Bank Practice 757-564-9737 / 215-665-4491 elosty@janney.com Virginia / Philadelphia Roger Powell, Managing Director 410-583-5993 / 215-665-6687 rpowell@janney.com Baltimore / Philadelphia Jay Junior, Managing Director 215-665-4497 jjunior@janney.com Philadelphia 27