SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 49
The Wind Industry: Past, Present, Future  Randall Swisher Power Test   Conference February 15, 2010
The Past: A Brief History of the Wind Industry
Growing a New Industry ,[object Object]
In the Beginning:  A Vision
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],In the Beginning:  A Vision
Late 70’s Policy Provided a Foundation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
In the 1980s, the U.S. led the World in Wind Technology ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
But Turning Vision to Reality was Tough ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
We Turned our Backs on the Opportunity ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Europe Took the Lead in the 1990s ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Today, the Global Industry has Three Key Markets ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The U.S. Wind Industry in 2010
U.S. is World Leader in Wind Power ,[object Object],[object Object]
2009 Highlights ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
U.S. Wind Industry: 2009 Wind MW Installed Total Installation in 4Q 2009: 4,041 MW Total Installation in 2009: 9,922 MW Total U.S. Installation through 4Q 2009: 35,159 MW Source: American Wind Energy Association
Top Ten States in 2009 Source: American Wind Energy Association
State by State Installations (MW) Source: American Wind Energy Association
Market Players: Turbine Manufacturers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Manufacturers’ Share of Installed Capacity Share of 2008 2008 Installations by WTG Mfgr
U.S. Wind Manufacturing  Source: AWEA, updated through 4Q 2009 Major facilities online prior to 2008 All new online in 2008 - 2009 Announced facilities
300,000 MW of Proposed Wind in Interconnection Queues
Wind Power in Queues (MW) Iowa 14,569 Minnesota 20,011 New Mexico 14,136 North  Dakota 11,493 Penn. 3,391 South  Dakota 30,112 Oklahoma 14,677 Illinois 16,284 Ohio 3,683 Kansas 13,191 Wisconsin 908 Michigan 2,518 WV 1,045 New York 8,000 VT 155 Total 311,155 MW MA 492 Montana 2327 NJ 1416 Under 1000 MW  1,000 MW-8,000 MW Over 8,000 MW Missouri 2,050 Indiana 8,426 Maine 1,398 NH 396 RI 347 DE 450 MD 810 VA 820 Arkansas 210 Texas 63,504 Arizona 7,268 California 18,629 Colorado 16,602 Idaho 446 Nebraska 3,726 Nevada 3,913 Oregon 9,361 Utah 1,052 Washington 5,831 Wyoming 7,870
Note: AWEA does not make industry forecasts or endorse any external forecasts Other Analysts’ Projected Wind Growth Nationwide
[object Object]
20% Wind Energy by 2030 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The 20% Technical Report ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The 20% Wind Energy Scenario ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
20% Wind Energy by 2030 Installed Capacity at year end 2009 is greater than 35 GW;  3 years ahead of schedule 305 GW
20% Wind:  Electricity Sector Costs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Savings from Reduced Natural Gas Price Pressure   The benefits from reduced pressure on natural gas prices across all gas users would be $150 billion (NPV), by itself exceeding the incremental cost of investing in the 20% Wind Scenario. *NPV  Source: Hand et al., 2008 Billions of Dollars* 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Incremental C ost  Natural Gas  Savings
20% Wind Impact on Generation Mix in 2030 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],U.S. electrical energy mix Source *: Hand et al., 2008
Challenges to Achieving Wind’s Potential
Key Barriers to Achieving 20% Wind ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The Longer Term Policy Challenge ,[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Long-term Policy Options
A Federal RPS Means Stable Policy ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Barrier 3:  Transmission Infrastructure ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
20% Wind:  Transmission Challenges ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Getting our Huge Wind Resource to Market ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Transmission  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
AEP’s Conceptual Transmission Plan to  Accommodate 400 GW of Wind Energy
Managing Wind’s Variability
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Wind Integration
Lessons Learned about Wind Integration ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Wind Power & Energy Storage
Xcel Study Regarding Wind Integration Costs ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Summary and Conclusion
The Way Forward ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Further Information ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systems
Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systemsEmergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systems
Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systemsSwarnim Srivastava
 
Power Sector Developments in India
Power Sector Developments in IndiaPower Sector Developments in India
Power Sector Developments in IndiaIndian Energy Sector
 
Power sector in India
Power sector in IndiaPower sector in India
Power sector in IndiaDaya Kherwar
 
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...alex regado
 
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in IndiaOpportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India Devesh Gautam
 
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero Energy
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero EnergyPrecincts to Support the Delivery of Zero Energy
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero EnergyTurlough Guerin GAICD FGIA
 
Power sector in india
Power sector in indiaPower sector in india
Power sector in indiaHarshit Garg
 
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case Study
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case StudyA Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case Study
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case StudyCatherineRizos
 
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010Eliot Norman
 
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentation
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentationIEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentation
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentationEnergy for One World
 
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?Bounce Energy
 
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013RCREEE
 
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity Market
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity MarketThe New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity Market
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity MarketCSCJournals
 
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally here
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally hereWinds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally here
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally herehardhathub
 
Transmission Summit West 2013
Transmission Summit West 2013Transmission Summit West 2013
Transmission Summit West 2013ScottMadden, Inc.
 
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations IEEE-USA
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations   IEEE-USA2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations   IEEE-USA
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations IEEE-USAJohn Ragan
 
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to Local
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to LocalEnergy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to Local
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to LocalOrkestra
 

What's hot (20)

Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systems
Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systemsEmergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systems
Emergence-of-hybrid renewable energy systems
 
Power Sector Developments in India
Power Sector Developments in IndiaPower Sector Developments in India
Power Sector Developments in India
 
Power sector in India
Power sector in IndiaPower sector in India
Power sector in India
 
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...
Energy generation report. final 10 oct 14pptx...Philippine Energy Plan 2012 -...
 
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in IndiaOpportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India
Opportunities & Challenges in Developing Wind Energy in India
 
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero Energy
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero EnergyPrecincts to Support the Delivery of Zero Energy
Precincts to Support the Delivery of Zero Energy
 
Power sector in india
Power sector in indiaPower sector in india
Power sector in india
 
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case Study
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case StudyA Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case Study
A Grid Dominated by Wind and Solar is Possible: South Australia Case Study
 
Awea Annual Wind Report 2009
Awea Annual Wind Report 2009Awea Annual Wind Report 2009
Awea Annual Wind Report 2009
 
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010
Usa Energy Market Ppt June 30, 2010
 
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentation
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentationIEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentation
IEA World Energy Outlook 2020 launch-presentation
 
Power Ppt
Power PptPower Ppt
Power Ppt
 
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?
Why is Texas the Model for Energy Deregulation?
 
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013
RCREEE-enerMENA_sudan renewable energy projects-21.08.2013
 
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity Market
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity MarketThe New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity Market
The New Role of Renewable Energy Systems In Developing GCC Electricity Market
 
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally here
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally hereWinds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally here
Winds of change: Offshore U.S. farms finally here
 
Transmission Summit West 2013
Transmission Summit West 2013Transmission Summit West 2013
Transmission Summit West 2013
 
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations IEEE-USA
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations   IEEE-USA2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations   IEEE-USA
2011 National Energy Policy Recommendations IEEE-USA
 
9-Energy
9-Energy9-Energy
9-Energy
 
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to Local
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to LocalEnergy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to Local
Energy: Current Situation and Trends. From Global to Local
 

Similar to Power Test Conference

Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptx
Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptxWind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptx
Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptxAnandKahar4
 
National Clean Energy Summit PPt
National Clean Energy Summit PPtNational Clean Energy Summit PPt
National Clean Energy Summit PPtguest3fd329
 
IBM Wind Power Point of View
IBM Wind Power Point of ViewIBM Wind Power Point of View
IBM Wind Power Point of Viewbenhanley77
 
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson Publishers
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson PublishersWind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson Publishers
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson PublishersCrimsonpublishersPRSP
 
FERC & DOE Incentives for Renewables
FERC & DOE Incentives for RenewablesFERC & DOE Incentives for Renewables
FERC & DOE Incentives for Renewableselwalsh
 
Wind Energy
Wind EnergyWind Energy
Wind Energymohkab1
 
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, Turkey
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, TurkeyRabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, Turkey
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, TurkeyVeronika Rabl
 
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energy
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energyChapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energy
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energyStart Loving
 
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentation
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentationCal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentation
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentationFingerPointer
 
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017Peter Kelley
 
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric GridIntegrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric GridPower System Operation
 
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case Study
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case StudyWind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case Study
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case StudyGovindarajan Chittaranjan
 
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks A Case Study
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks   A Case StudyWind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks   A Case Study
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks A Case Studychittaranjang
 
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solution
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a SolutionAging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solution
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solutionpacificcresttrans
 

Similar to Power Test Conference (20)

Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptx
Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptxWind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptx
Wind_Turbine_L1-L2_Revised.pptx
 
National Clean Energy Summit PPt
National Clean Energy Summit PPtNational Clean Energy Summit PPt
National Clean Energy Summit PPt
 
Wind power3
Wind power3Wind power3
Wind power3
 
IBM Wind Power Point of View
IBM Wind Power Point of ViewIBM Wind Power Point of View
IBM Wind Power Point of View
 
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson Publishers
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson PublishersWind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson Publishers
Wind Energy: Analysis and Application-Crimson Publishers
 
FERC & DOE Incentives for Renewables
FERC & DOE Incentives for RenewablesFERC & DOE Incentives for Renewables
FERC & DOE Incentives for Renewables
 
Wind Energy
Wind EnergyWind Energy
Wind Energy
 
Resch - Solar Vision Forum
Resch - Solar Vision ForumResch - Solar Vision Forum
Resch - Solar Vision Forum
 
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, Turkey
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, TurkeyRabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, Turkey
Rabl Presentation - NATO, Antalya, Turkey
 
Wind Power
Wind PowerWind Power
Wind Power
 
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energy
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energyChapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energy
Chapter 12 sprinting toward renewable energy
 
Harnessing The Wind
Harnessing The WindHarnessing The Wind
Harnessing The Wind
 
Harnessing the Wind
Harnessing the WindHarnessing the Wind
Harnessing the Wind
 
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentation
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentationCal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentation
Cal Marine Power & Water "straw" scam presentation
 
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017
Top slides on U.S. wind power - AWEA August 2017
 
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric GridIntegrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid
Integrating Wind Power Into the Electric Grid
 
Solar Revolution
Solar  RevolutionSolar  Revolution
Solar Revolution
 
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case Study
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case StudyWind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case Study
Wind-Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation for Theme Parks - A Case Study
 
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks A Case Study
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks   A Case StudyWind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks   A Case Study
Wind Solar Hybrid Power Project Investigation For Theme Parks A Case Study
 
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solution
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a SolutionAging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solution
Aging Power Infrastucture in the US: Towards a Solution
 

Power Test Conference

  • 1. The Wind Industry: Past, Present, Future Randall Swisher Power Test Conference February 15, 2010
  • 2. The Past: A Brief History of the Wind Industry
  • 3.
  • 4. In the Beginning: A Vision
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12. The U.S. Wind Industry in 2010
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. U.S. Wind Industry: 2009 Wind MW Installed Total Installation in 4Q 2009: 4,041 MW Total Installation in 2009: 9,922 MW Total U.S. Installation through 4Q 2009: 35,159 MW Source: American Wind Energy Association
  • 16. Top Ten States in 2009 Source: American Wind Energy Association
  • 17. State by State Installations (MW) Source: American Wind Energy Association
  • 18.
  • 19. Manufacturers’ Share of Installed Capacity Share of 2008 2008 Installations by WTG Mfgr
  • 20. U.S. Wind Manufacturing Source: AWEA, updated through 4Q 2009 Major facilities online prior to 2008 All new online in 2008 - 2009 Announced facilities
  • 21. 300,000 MW of Proposed Wind in Interconnection Queues
  • 22. Wind Power in Queues (MW) Iowa 14,569 Minnesota 20,011 New Mexico 14,136 North Dakota 11,493 Penn. 3,391 South Dakota 30,112 Oklahoma 14,677 Illinois 16,284 Ohio 3,683 Kansas 13,191 Wisconsin 908 Michigan 2,518 WV 1,045 New York 8,000 VT 155 Total 311,155 MW MA 492 Montana 2327 NJ 1416 Under 1000 MW 1,000 MW-8,000 MW Over 8,000 MW Missouri 2,050 Indiana 8,426 Maine 1,398 NH 396 RI 347 DE 450 MD 810 VA 820 Arkansas 210 Texas 63,504 Arizona 7,268 California 18,629 Colorado 16,602 Idaho 446 Nebraska 3,726 Nevada 3,913 Oregon 9,361 Utah 1,052 Washington 5,831 Wyoming 7,870
  • 23. Note: AWEA does not make industry forecasts or endorse any external forecasts Other Analysts’ Projected Wind Growth Nationwide
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28. 20% Wind Energy by 2030 Installed Capacity at year end 2009 is greater than 35 GW; 3 years ahead of schedule 305 GW
  • 29.
  • 30. Savings from Reduced Natural Gas Price Pressure The benefits from reduced pressure on natural gas prices across all gas users would be $150 billion (NPV), by itself exceeding the incremental cost of investing in the 20% Wind Scenario. *NPV Source: Hand et al., 2008 Billions of Dollars* 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Incremental C ost Natural Gas Savings
  • 31.
  • 32. Challenges to Achieving Wind’s Potential
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
  • 38.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41. AEP’s Conceptual Transmission Plan to Accommodate 400 GW of Wind Energy
  • 43.
  • 44.
  • 45.
  • 46.
  • 48.
  • 49.

Editor's Notes

  1. This conference is a living symbol of the emergence of the wind industry at a new level. I expect wind’s market share of new generating capacity will continue to be significant for years to come. And we are well-positioned strategically. We are One of the most significant single options available for dealing with climate change; A very exciting new source of manufacturing and other jobs in this country; An effective hedge against the scary volatility we are seeing in fossil fuel prices. Aside from those advantages, when you look at the positions of coal, natural gas and nuclear, each is constrained in some very significant ways, leaving wind with an open field for years to come.
  2. Figure 12 shows that GE Energy continues to dominate the market, with 43% of the newly installed capacity in 2008 and over 48% of the over 5,000 turbines installed in 2008. The turbine market is still fairly concentrated, with the top eight companies accounting for over 98% of the new capacity added. Vestas and Siemens retained the second and third place spots in terms of installed capacity. New companies are entering the U.S. market each year, however. 2008 saw turbines installed in the U.S. by newcomers to the U.S. market Acciona WP, REPower, Fuhrlander, DeWind, and AWE.
  3. Only the 13 largest queues are included here – other utilities may have smaller queues that are not included Source: AWEA analysis of publicly available queue data
  4. From data for five largest queues as of March 2009, data for next 8 queues as of end of 2008, data for smaller utilities as of September 2009 Queues for smaller utilities excluded
  5. AWEA does not make industry forecasts or endorse any external forecasts
  6. 20% Wind Scenario: Wind Energy Provides 20% of U.S. Electricity Needs by 2030 Key Issues to Examine: Does the nation have sufficient wind energy resources? What are the wind technology requirements? Does sufficient manufacturing capability exist? What are some of the key impacts? Can the electric network accommodate 20% wind? What are the environmental impacts? Is the scenario feasible? Assessment Participants: U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE), Office of Electricity Delivery and Energy Reliability (OE), and Power Marketing Administrations (PMAs) National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab) Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) Black & Veatch engineering and consulting firm American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) Leading wind manufacturers and suppliers Developers and electric utilities Others in the wind industry
  7. Considerations in the 20% Wind Scenario Wind resources of varying quality exist across the United States and offshore. Although land-based resources are less expensive to capture, they are sometimes far from demand centers. Typically, wind power must be integrated into the electric grid with other generation sources. Technology and power market innovations would make it easier to handle a variable energy resource such as wind. New transmission lines would be required to connect new wind power sources to demand centers. Transmission costs add to the cost of delivered wind energy costs, but today’s U.S. grid requires significant upgrading and expansion under almost any scenario. Wind installations will require significant amounts of land, although actual tower footprints are relatively small. Domestic manufacturing capacity might not be sufficient to accommodate near-term rapid growth in U.S. wind generation capacity; the gap may be filled by other countries.
  8. The gas savings estimate is based on a mid-range estimate of gas price elasticity.  For low to high elasticities, the estimated savings range from $86 billion to $214 billion.
  9. The 20% Wind Scenario would require delivery of nearly 1.16 billion MWh of wind energy in 2030, altering U.S. electricity generation. In this scenario, wind would supply enough energy to displace about 50% of electric utility natural gas consumption and 18% of coal consumption by 2030. This amounts to an 11% reduction in natural gas across all industries. (Gas-fired generation would probably be displaced first, because it typically has a higher operating cost.) Talking Point : Even at 20%, wind still part of an overall portfolio
  10. The 20% Wind Scenario assumes that transmission planning and grid operations occur on several levels—planning at the national level, reserve margin constraint planning at the NERC level, and load growth planning and operations at the balancing area (BA) level. For visual clarity, these figures display wind capacity only at the balancing area level. The balancing areas, shaded in purple, depict the amount of locally installed wind, which is assumed to meet local load levels. Generally, the first wind system installed either uses the existing grid or is accompanied by a short transmission line built to supply local loads. In later years, as the existing grid capacity is filled, additional transmission lines are built. New transmission lines built to support load in a balancing area with wind resources within that same area are not pictured in this figure; only transmission lines that cross balancing area boundaries are illustrated. The blue arrows represent wind energy transported on existing transmission lines between balancing areas. The red arrows represent new transmission lines constructed to transport wind energy between balancing areas. The arrows originate and terminate at the centroid of a balancing area and do not represent the physical location of demand centers or wind resources. The location and relative number of red or blue arrows depend on the relative cost of using existing transmission lines or building new lines. Existing Transmission Lines: 71 GW New Capacity Lines within a WinDS region: 67 GW Over 12,000 miles of new transmission will be needed to support the 20% Wind Scenario.
  11. The fact that wind power installations can provide cost stability to a utility’s resource portfolio and bring income and tax benefits to rural communities is an obvious advantage of the technology. In addition, electricity produced with wind power does not emit harmful pollutants, generate waste or ash, or burn resources.