SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 49
Download to read offline
EMRgency Medicine – Are You Ready?




            December 10th, 2009
Agenda
Opening Remarks                  Dr. Michael Fossel

Understanding the HITECH Act     Dr. Kennedy Ganti
and the EMR Mandate

Lessons Learned: A European      Jean-Michel Van
Perspective on EMR’s effect on
savings costs, lives & time

Increasing Your Chances for      Paul Roemer
Success: What are the Critical
Success Factors for EHR/EMR

Break

Thought Leadership               Panelists
Discussion

Open Q&A

Networking & Dessert
                                                | 2
Dr. Michael Fossel | Cerner Corporation
OPENING REMARKS




                                          | 3
Sometimes,
your EMR can be a

―PICNIC‖

                    | 4
Reality:
not always a

PICNIC


               | 5
People will never laugh at
anything that is not based on
truth.
                           - Will Rogers



I feel like I’m working for the
computer, rather than it working
for me.
                   MD, Iowa, 2007

                                           | 6
| 7
Sound like your EMR?




                       | 8
Extormity and ARRA’s meaningful use
"Our legal team is expending incalculable billable hours to develop a
carefully worded statement that will depict in illustrative terms our
commitment to helping customers and prospects move toward the
eventual demonstration of meaningful use," explained Extormity chief
financial officer Samantha James in a carefully worded statement.



"It is common knowledge that meaningful use criteria are not fully
defined, so Extormity is taking great care not to issue an ironclad, no
exceptions guarantee," added James. "However, we plan to provide
the market with a vague impression of intent designed to inspire a
tinge of confidence and an indication of some degree of willingness to
comply at some future point, all without creating a legal obligation or
definitive pledge to deliver an actionable event."


                                                                          | 9
Who said…




            | 10
Nothing new under the sun...

Who and when?
 Florence Nightingale
 1863
 ―Notes on Hospitals‖




                               Source: London: Longman, et al.

                                                             | 11
Potential Benefits

  Reduce errors
  More ―intelligent‖ care
  Real-time data
  Better communication & documentation
  Secure (and HIPAA compliant) data
  Reduced labor costs
  Reduced litigation
  Automated workflows




                                         | 12
Costs of doing nothing…

• 33 cents/dollar spent is non-clinical

Consider:
  >90% of ~30 billion transactions/year by phone, fax, or mail
  Physicians spend an estimated:
      20-30% searching for information
      38% documenting (nurses 50%)
  Records misplaced in 30% of visits
  Patients average 13 pieces of paper/visit
  Offices average $10/visit on paper records
  Patient records average 3.3 kg

                                                                 | 13
Deadlines are nearing, penalties are looming


Why hesitate?
   Ill-defined requirements

   Unanswered questions




                         The opportunity to learn from others
                              Successes in the EU and US
                              How do we achieve success?

                                                                | 14
THANK
THANK
 YOU
 YOU




        | 15
Dr. Kennedy Ganti | NJ Health IT Commission Chair
UNDERSTANDING THE HITECH ACT AND THE
EMR MANDATE




                                                    | 16
Stimulus, Software and Sense

 Understanding the Fundamentals of Electronic
 Health Data Use and Exchange:




                                                | 17
The Case for Health IT Adoption

 Computerized health data: nothing new
    Since the 1970s
    At centers like Boston, Indianapolis and Salt Lake City
    Electronic medical records such as VA Vista were created
    Central data repositories


 Enter the Electronic Medical Record
    Collection of related pieces of health data on a person's health and
    disease
    Electronic version of the standard medical charge
    Data can be structured
    Data can be shared




                                                                           | 18 1
The Case for Health IT Adoption

 Making better decisions- clinical decision support
    Drug-drug interactions
    clinical reminders for preventative services

    'red flags' on structured lab data

 ePrescribing- tracking meds better
    Know if patient actually filled a script

    Track prescribers tendencies

 Connecting the dots




                                                      | 19 1
HITECH: Adding fuel to the fire

  Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical
  Health Act
  Makes federal funding and planning resources to build an
  interconnected, interoperable national health data exchange
  network

  Provisions:
     $18 billion for CMS to promote "meaningful use" of EMR systems
     $2 billion for ONC for infrastructural upgrades in HHS, education of health IT professionals,
     promotion of interoperable clinical data repositories
     $1 billion to Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC) for renovation and acquisition of
     health IT systems
     $550 million for Health IT and other uses for Indian Health Services
     $300 million to support regional and sub-national efforts for HIEs
     $40 million to be used by Social Security Admin to use EMRs to submit disability claims


                                                                                                     | 20 2
Meaningful Use

 Policies, standards and metrics that guide clinical usefulness of
 EMRs
 Specifies goals by policy, patient setting and time (every two years
 starting in 2011)
 Guide for CMS for promoting incentive payments and eventually
 non-use penalties
 Has harmonized goals between ambulatory and inpatient care
 Pro- grounded in sound clinical and health policy principle
 Con- Not very helpful in other care settings (Long term care,
 physical therapy, etc)




                                                                        | 21 2
Jean-Michel Van | Cegedim Healthcare Software (CHS)
LESSONS LEARNED: A EUROPEAN
PERSPECTIVE ON EMR’S EFFECT ON SAVING
COSTS, LIVES AND TIME



                                                      | 22
Group’s Expertise

 Cegedim Group
    2008 : €849 million with 8,200 employees (80 countries)


 Cegedim Healthcare Software (CHS)
    29% of group’s activity


 Main market in western Europe
  a) Healthcare provider
  b) #1 in France, #2 in the UK, #1 in Italy, #1 in Spain, #2 in Belgium


  Definition of EHR:
     Data exchange, e-prescribing, CPOE, e-claim



                                                                           | 23
Adoption Rate Across Top Countries

1. Early starters

  Fig 1- Use of EHR Systems in Hospitals      Fig 2 - Use of EHR Systems by Primary Care Physicians
            Percentage of Hospitals Using                       Percent of Primary Care Physicians
  Country            EHR Systems                  Country               Using EHR systems
DENMARK                  65                   DENMARK                           95
FINLAND                  100                  FINLAND                           95
SWEDEN                   88                   GERMANY                           42
France                   40                   France                            70
SPAIN                    70                   NETHERLANDS                       98
US                        8                   SWEDEN                           100
                                              UK                                89
                                              US                                28
Sources: Castro, D. ITIF, Sept 2009



     a)        European initiatives earlier than US (Northern Europe): early 1980’ 90’
               with e-claims submission, e-referral, e-clinical record


                                                                                               | 24
US and EU: Similar Barriers

1. Privacy issues
    a)      Danish Web portal Sundhed.dk= privacy functions! Thru Digital Signature, access tracking (40%
            healthcare related Internet traffic)
    b)      Sweden: Good Policy - government-run database (4 to 5 % opt out)
    c)      Netherlands: stored in healthcare providers. Privacy control (2% opt-out)


2. Data ownership
    a)      Patients do not manage their data but own them and decide who can view/modify them


3. Cost of IT adoption


 Fig 3 – Cost of IT Adoption and % of total cost
 Denmark                          Small subsidies (30%)
 Netherlands                      Tax deductible and incentive payments for every patient (50%)
 UK                               Financial incentives (75%)
 France                           Subsidies (75%)
 Spain                            Financial incentives (90%)
Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France                         | 25
Benefits of e-Health
(France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic )



1. ROI ?  Yes
2. Benefits for Patient Safety (2005-2008)
         15% reduction in prescription errors/year = Electronic Transfer of
         Prescription
         France: 200,000 reduction of prescription errors
         Czech Republic: 75,000 reduction of prescription errors
         Netherlands: 26,000 medication errors through CPOE and CDS
         Six States: potential reductions of 5 million outpatient prescription
         errors across the studied states




                                       Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France

                                                                                                                       | 26
Benefits of e-Health
(France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic )



3. Benefits for Quality of Care
         UK: over 250,000 surplus laboratory tests were avoided since 2005
         France : 11,000 readmissions to hospital for CHF were avoided
         through EMR (an additional 26,000  savings of over €110 million,
         if full elec.)

4. Increasing Physician Availability
         UK: Over 90,000 appointments covered through “Did Not Attends”
         option enabled by Electronic Appointment Booking (600,000)
         Czech Republic: Almost 560,000 bed-days were become available
         every year through Telemedicine, direct saving of €32 million
         Sweden: Over 92,500 GP appointments/year were made available
         alone through the use of web-portal


                                      Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France

                                                                                                                      | 27
Mid + Long-term Costs & Benefits
(France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic)


1. Benefits on Annual basis
         Average HPOs : annual benefits = annual costs  year 3

          Fig 4 - Annual Costs And Benefits Of E-Health 60 Sites From 1994 To 2008, In € Mill




                                 Present value of annual costs          Present value of annual benefits

                                                                                                           | 28
             Source: European Commission « Economic Impact of eHealth Report » 2008
Mid + Long-term Costs & Benefits
(France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic)



2. Benefits on Cumulative basis
            Average HPOs: annual benefits > annual costs  year 5
            Cumulative benefit by 2008: € 330 million
            Cumulative investment costs (incl. operating expenditure): €155 million

       Fig 5 - Cumulative Costs And Benefits Of E-Health 60 Sites From 1994 To 2008, In € Mill



              2500




              1500




              500




                              Present value of cumulative costs      Present value of cumulative benefits
                                                                                                            | 29
 Source: European Commission « Economic Impact of eHealth Report » 2008
Future of the US e-Health

  Each country is different
     There is no one best practice!



  Same strong signals as in Europe
  a) National leadership groups, CCHIT

  b) Set of Standards, HL7, SNOMED

  c) Incentives

  d) Top-down communication



                                         | 30
Thank You for Your Attention




       « Yes, you can!!! »

                               | 31
Paul Roemer | Managing Principal, Healthcare IT Strategy
INCREASING YOUR CHANCES FOR SUCCESS:
WHAT ARE THE CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS
FOR EHR/EMR



                                                           | 32
EMR—What Should I Know?

What is the elephant in the room?

  What does this mean—EMRs must be interoperable
  & interconnected?
     Know before you buy—what connects to what?
     If EMRs aren’t connected, doctors will still need electronic and
     paper files




                                                                        | 33
EMR—Where Does that leave you?

Focus on yourself, on what you control
  Don’t let Washington drive your decision
     ARRA
     Certification
     Meaningful Use
  Decide why EMR is right for you
  Figure out what your team should include

  Define your requirements
  Set a budget




                                             | 34
EMR—Fail Safe Points

What are the EMR Fail Safe Points (FSPs)?

  EMR is healthcare’s Y2K time bomb.
  There a is concurrent national rollout of EMR; standards not
  available until 2010.
  The costs are very high, so are the penalties

  1/3rd to 2/3rd of EMRs implemented have failed
  There may not be time to earn the incentives




                                                                 | 35
EMR—Ambulatory Practices

A good argument can be made for waiting. Within 12-18
months they will likely have the opportunity to acquire a
plug-and-play EMR in-house or SaaS, including:
  Project management
  Selection
  Implementation
  Adapting workflows
  Training
  Support




                                                            | 36
EMR is Wide Open

New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) received
responses from 63.1% of hospitals surveyed:

  Only 1.5% of U.S. hospitals have a comprehensive electronic-
  records system present in all clinical units.
  7.6% have a basic system present in at least one clinical unit.
  Computerized provider-order entry for medications has been
  implemented in only 17% of hospitals.
  Respondents cited capital and maintenance
  costs as the primary barriers to implementation




                                                                    | 37
EMR
if it doesn’t connect…

  Just because EMR’s have been implemented,
  doesn’t mean they’re of much value.
     “I've witnessed more serious errors with the EMR than in my
     previous 25 years as a physician.”
     Christine A. Sinsky, MD

     "...our system for delivering medical care is clearly in crisis...At
     the heart of the problem is the fragmented nature of the way
     health information is created and collected,"
     Bill Gates

  Most EMRs don’t operate beyond the walls of the
  building in which they were implemented


                                                                            | 38
EMR
Are you ready?


                                     Enterprise
                                     Readiness
                                    Assessment


                 Federal funding
EMR                Incentives,                       Implementation
                     grants                             Playbook
Readiness         And penalties

Methodology
has a 6 phase
scorecard.
                 Implementation                          Risk
                  Management                          Assessment



                                        Cost
                                   Benefit/Funding
                                      Analysis



                                                                      | 39
Enterprise Readiness Assessment

The Enterprise Readiness Assessment identifies gaps in:

  Change Management Readiness

  Technology Readiness

  Risk Management

  Standards Readiness




                                                      | 40
EMR Implementation Playbook

The Implementation Playbook defines a program or set
of projects the enterprise needs to execute in order to
implement EMR. Potential projects may include:
  Requirements

  SW selection

  Change Management

  Integration

  Policy, Procedure or Process

  Training


                                                          | 41
Enterprise Risk Assessment

The Enterprise Risk Assessment should help you
identify potentially fatal EMR implementation risks:

  Staffing
  Program management
  Readiness




                                                       | 42
EMR Cost Benefit/Funding Analysis

The Cost Benefit Analysis identifies:

  The cost of implementation and the level of funding
  necessary to successfully implement EMR
  Funding sources such as grants or federal government
  loans
  The short term costs and the long term benefits

  ROI development and monitoring




                                                         | 43
EMR Implementation Management

Implementation Management oversees projects to
successfully implement each EMR project managing:



  Project task management
  Budget, Schedule, & ROI
  Issues tracking and resolution

  Staffing and skill requirements
  Project accountability and visibility




                                                    | 44
In Summary




             | 45
THOUGHT LEADERSHIP PANEL DISCUSSION




                                      | 46
Overview

 Panel:
   What is an EMR?      Dr. Naomi Grobstein
   Meaningful use       Dr. Kennedy Ganti
   Implementation       Dr. Ganti/Dr. Fossel
   Interoperability     Paul Roemer
   Which vendor?        Dr. Spencer Kroll
   Are EMR’s good?      Jean-Michel Van
   Getting reimbursed   Dr. Kennedy Ganti
   Who owns the data?   Dr. David Memel
 Q&A




                                               | 47
QUESTIONS & ANSWERS




                      | 48
NETWORKING & DESSERT




                       | 49

More Related Content

Similar to EMRgency Medicine – Critical Success Factors for EHR Adoption

Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016
Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016
Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 20163GDR
 
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdf
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdfICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdf
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdfAbhimaniSadeesha
 
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in Europe
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in EuropeMarket Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in Europe
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in EuropeCGI
 
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...OECD Governance
 
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECD
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECDAdvanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECD
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECDOECD Governance
 
Chapter 13 national health information system
Chapter 13 national health information systemChapter 13 national health information system
Chapter 13 national health information systemnaranbatn
 
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simons
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simonsEuroBioForum2014_speaker_simons
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simonsEuroBioForum
 
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian Perspective
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian PerspectiveProcess Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian Perspective
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian PerspectiveDenis Gagné
 
Healthcare in Nepal
Healthcare in NepalHealthcare in Nepal
Healthcare in NepalRabiKC6
 
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.43GDR
 
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslop
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan HyslopNHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslop
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslophealthcareisi
 
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformation
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare TransformationRole Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformation
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformationdalesanders
 
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and DiagnosticsTelehealth Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and DiagnosticsAmmar
 
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging Countries
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging CountriesA Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging Countries
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging CountriesSaatviga Sudhahar
 
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie Endicott
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie EndicottmHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie Endicott
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie EndicottLevi Shapiro
 
Health-tech forum, February 2017, London
Health-tech forum, February 2017, LondonHealth-tech forum, February 2017, London
Health-tech forum, February 2017, LondonBrowne Jacobson LLP
 

Similar to EMRgency Medicine – Critical Success Factors for EHR Adoption (20)

Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016
Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016
Digital Health & Wellness Summit @ Mobile World Congress 2016
 
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdf
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdfICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdf
ICT in HealthCare Sector (Health Information & Communication Technology).pdf
 
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in Europe
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in EuropeMarket Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in Europe
Market Study of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Systems in Europe
 
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...
Advanced health technologies and their budgetary implications - Valérie Paris...
 
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECD
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECDAdvanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECD
Advanced health technologies and budgetary implications -- Valerie Paris, OECD
 
Chapter 13 national health information system
Chapter 13 national health information systemChapter 13 national health information system
Chapter 13 national health information system
 
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simons
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simonsEuroBioForum2014_speaker_simons
EuroBioForum2014_speaker_simons
 
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian Perspective
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian PerspectiveProcess Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian Perspective
Process Automation in Telemedicine - The Italian Perspective
 
Healthcare in Nepal
Healthcare in NepalHealthcare in Nepal
Healthcare in Nepal
 
THE E-HEALTH PANORAMA by Christian FOURY
THE E-HEALTH PANORAMA by Christian FOURYTHE E-HEALTH PANORAMA by Christian FOURY
THE E-HEALTH PANORAMA by Christian FOURY
 
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4
Irish HSE EHR strategic business case master briefing deck v1.4
 
eHealth in the Netherlands: The Polder Model
eHealth in the Netherlands: The Polder ModeleHealth in the Netherlands: The Polder Model
eHealth in the Netherlands: The Polder Model
 
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslop
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan HyslopNHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslop
NHS Scotland Ehealth Strategy - Alan Hyslop
 
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformation
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare TransformationRole Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformation
Role Of The EMR In Healthcare Transformation
 
David Appleby, Marsoftware Ltd
David Appleby, Marsoftware LtdDavid Appleby, Marsoftware Ltd
David Appleby, Marsoftware Ltd
 
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and DiagnosticsTelehealth Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics
Telehealth Remote Monitoring and Diagnostics
 
Developing World Class Health IT
Developing World Class Health ITDeveloping World Class Health IT
Developing World Class Health IT
 
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging Countries
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging CountriesA Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging Countries
A Mobile eHealth Solution for Emerging Countries
 
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie Endicott
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie EndicottmHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie Endicott
mHealth israel_Medical Coding Bootcamp_Melanie Endicott
 
Health-tech forum, February 2017, London
Health-tech forum, February 2017, LondonHealth-tech forum, February 2017, London
Health-tech forum, February 2017, London
 

More from Dr. Susan Dorfman

State of the US healthcare industry - a compilation of infographics 2014
State of the US healthcare industry  -  a compilation of infographics 2014State of the US healthcare industry  -  a compilation of infographics 2014
State of the US healthcare industry - a compilation of infographics 2014Dr. Susan Dorfman
 
Healthcare changes a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...
Healthcare changes    a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...Healthcare changes    a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...
Healthcare changes a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...Dr. Susan Dorfman
 
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement Dr. Susan Dorfman
 
Internet and Its Impact On Health
Internet and Its Impact On HealthInternet and Its Impact On Health
Internet and Its Impact On HealthDr. Susan Dorfman
 
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of InnovationDr. Susan Dorfman
 
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT Companies
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT CompaniesUS Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT Companies
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT CompaniesDr. Susan Dorfman
 
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a Correlation
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a CorrelationMedication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a Correlation
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a CorrelationDr. Susan Dorfman
 
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health?
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health? Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health?
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health? Dr. Susan Dorfman
 

More from Dr. Susan Dorfman (8)

State of the US healthcare industry - a compilation of infographics 2014
State of the US healthcare industry  -  a compilation of infographics 2014State of the US healthcare industry  -  a compilation of infographics 2014
State of the US healthcare industry - a compilation of infographics 2014
 
Healthcare changes a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...
Healthcare changes    a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...Healthcare changes    a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...
Healthcare changes a compilation of infographics to tell a story of what's...
 
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement
Media Utilization and Preferences of Physicians: Trends in Engagement
 
Internet and Its Impact On Health
Internet and Its Impact On HealthInternet and Its Impact On Health
Internet and Its Impact On Health
 
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation
"Influence Marketing:" The Diffusion of Innovation
 
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT Companies
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT CompaniesUS Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT Companies
US Healthcare Reform and Impact On Pharma and Healthcare IT Companies
 
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a Correlation
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a CorrelationMedication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a Correlation
Medication Compliance and Diabetes Outcomes: Is There a Correlation
 
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health?
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health? Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health?
Will eHealth Help or Harm to Our Health?
 

EMRgency Medicine – Critical Success Factors for EHR Adoption

  • 1. EMRgency Medicine – Are You Ready? December 10th, 2009
  • 2. Agenda Opening Remarks Dr. Michael Fossel Understanding the HITECH Act Dr. Kennedy Ganti and the EMR Mandate Lessons Learned: A European Jean-Michel Van Perspective on EMR’s effect on savings costs, lives & time Increasing Your Chances for Paul Roemer Success: What are the Critical Success Factors for EHR/EMR Break Thought Leadership Panelists Discussion Open Q&A Networking & Dessert | 2
  • 3. Dr. Michael Fossel | Cerner Corporation OPENING REMARKS | 3
  • 4. Sometimes, your EMR can be a ―PICNIC‖ | 4
  • 6. People will never laugh at anything that is not based on truth. - Will Rogers I feel like I’m working for the computer, rather than it working for me.  MD, Iowa, 2007 | 6
  • 7. | 7
  • 8. Sound like your EMR? | 8
  • 9. Extormity and ARRA’s meaningful use "Our legal team is expending incalculable billable hours to develop a carefully worded statement that will depict in illustrative terms our commitment to helping customers and prospects move toward the eventual demonstration of meaningful use," explained Extormity chief financial officer Samantha James in a carefully worded statement. "It is common knowledge that meaningful use criteria are not fully defined, so Extormity is taking great care not to issue an ironclad, no exceptions guarantee," added James. "However, we plan to provide the market with a vague impression of intent designed to inspire a tinge of confidence and an indication of some degree of willingness to comply at some future point, all without creating a legal obligation or definitive pledge to deliver an actionable event." | 9
  • 10. Who said… | 10
  • 11. Nothing new under the sun... Who and when? Florence Nightingale 1863 ―Notes on Hospitals‖ Source: London: Longman, et al. | 11
  • 12. Potential Benefits Reduce errors More ―intelligent‖ care Real-time data Better communication & documentation Secure (and HIPAA compliant) data Reduced labor costs Reduced litigation Automated workflows | 12
  • 13. Costs of doing nothing… • 33 cents/dollar spent is non-clinical Consider: >90% of ~30 billion transactions/year by phone, fax, or mail Physicians spend an estimated: 20-30% searching for information 38% documenting (nurses 50%) Records misplaced in 30% of visits Patients average 13 pieces of paper/visit Offices average $10/visit on paper records Patient records average 3.3 kg | 13
  • 14. Deadlines are nearing, penalties are looming Why hesitate? Ill-defined requirements Unanswered questions The opportunity to learn from others Successes in the EU and US How do we achieve success? | 14
  • 16. Dr. Kennedy Ganti | NJ Health IT Commission Chair UNDERSTANDING THE HITECH ACT AND THE EMR MANDATE | 16
  • 17. Stimulus, Software and Sense Understanding the Fundamentals of Electronic Health Data Use and Exchange: | 17
  • 18. The Case for Health IT Adoption Computerized health data: nothing new Since the 1970s At centers like Boston, Indianapolis and Salt Lake City Electronic medical records such as VA Vista were created Central data repositories Enter the Electronic Medical Record Collection of related pieces of health data on a person's health and disease Electronic version of the standard medical charge Data can be structured Data can be shared | 18 1
  • 19. The Case for Health IT Adoption Making better decisions- clinical decision support Drug-drug interactions clinical reminders for preventative services 'red flags' on structured lab data ePrescribing- tracking meds better Know if patient actually filled a script Track prescribers tendencies Connecting the dots | 19 1
  • 20. HITECH: Adding fuel to the fire Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act Makes federal funding and planning resources to build an interconnected, interoperable national health data exchange network Provisions: $18 billion for CMS to promote "meaningful use" of EMR systems $2 billion for ONC for infrastructural upgrades in HHS, education of health IT professionals, promotion of interoperable clinical data repositories $1 billion to Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC) for renovation and acquisition of health IT systems $550 million for Health IT and other uses for Indian Health Services $300 million to support regional and sub-national efforts for HIEs $40 million to be used by Social Security Admin to use EMRs to submit disability claims | 20 2
  • 21. Meaningful Use Policies, standards and metrics that guide clinical usefulness of EMRs Specifies goals by policy, patient setting and time (every two years starting in 2011) Guide for CMS for promoting incentive payments and eventually non-use penalties Has harmonized goals between ambulatory and inpatient care Pro- grounded in sound clinical and health policy principle Con- Not very helpful in other care settings (Long term care, physical therapy, etc) | 21 2
  • 22. Jean-Michel Van | Cegedim Healthcare Software (CHS) LESSONS LEARNED: A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE ON EMR’S EFFECT ON SAVING COSTS, LIVES AND TIME | 22
  • 23. Group’s Expertise Cegedim Group 2008 : €849 million with 8,200 employees (80 countries) Cegedim Healthcare Software (CHS) 29% of group’s activity Main market in western Europe a) Healthcare provider b) #1 in France, #2 in the UK, #1 in Italy, #1 in Spain, #2 in Belgium Definition of EHR: Data exchange, e-prescribing, CPOE, e-claim | 23
  • 24. Adoption Rate Across Top Countries 1. Early starters Fig 1- Use of EHR Systems in Hospitals Fig 2 - Use of EHR Systems by Primary Care Physicians Percentage of Hospitals Using Percent of Primary Care Physicians Country EHR Systems Country Using EHR systems DENMARK 65 DENMARK 95 FINLAND 100 FINLAND 95 SWEDEN 88 GERMANY 42 France 40 France 70 SPAIN 70 NETHERLANDS 98 US 8 SWEDEN 100 UK 89 US 28 Sources: Castro, D. ITIF, Sept 2009 a) European initiatives earlier than US (Northern Europe): early 1980’ 90’ with e-claims submission, e-referral, e-clinical record | 24
  • 25. US and EU: Similar Barriers 1. Privacy issues a) Danish Web portal Sundhed.dk= privacy functions! Thru Digital Signature, access tracking (40% healthcare related Internet traffic) b) Sweden: Good Policy - government-run database (4 to 5 % opt out) c) Netherlands: stored in healthcare providers. Privacy control (2% opt-out) 2. Data ownership a) Patients do not manage their data but own them and decide who can view/modify them 3. Cost of IT adoption Fig 3 – Cost of IT Adoption and % of total cost Denmark Small subsidies (30%) Netherlands Tax deductible and incentive payments for every patient (50%) UK Financial incentives (75%) France Subsidies (75%) Spain Financial incentives (90%) Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France | 25
  • 26. Benefits of e-Health (France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic ) 1. ROI ?  Yes 2. Benefits for Patient Safety (2005-2008) 15% reduction in prescription errors/year = Electronic Transfer of Prescription France: 200,000 reduction of prescription errors Czech Republic: 75,000 reduction of prescription errors Netherlands: 26,000 medication errors through CPOE and CDS Six States: potential reductions of 5 million outpatient prescription errors across the studied states Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France | 26
  • 27. Benefits of e-Health (France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic ) 3. Benefits for Quality of Care UK: over 250,000 surplus laboratory tests were avoided since 2005 France : 11,000 readmissions to hospital for CHF were avoided through EMR (an additional 26,000  savings of over €110 million, if full elec.) 4. Increasing Physician Availability UK: Over 90,000 appointments covered through “Did Not Attends” option enabled by Electronic Appointment Booking (600,000) Czech Republic: Almost 560,000 bed-days were become available every year through Telemedicine, direct saving of €32 million Sweden: Over 92,500 GP appointments/year were made available alone through the use of web-portal Source: Gartner, Ministry of Health Sweden and Sécurité Sociale Report France | 27
  • 28. Mid + Long-term Costs & Benefits (France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic) 1. Benefits on Annual basis Average HPOs : annual benefits = annual costs  year 3 Fig 4 - Annual Costs And Benefits Of E-Health 60 Sites From 1994 To 2008, In € Mill Present value of annual costs Present value of annual benefits | 28 Source: European Commission « Economic Impact of eHealth Report » 2008
  • 29. Mid + Long-term Costs & Benefits (France, Spain, Holland, UK, Denmark, Czech Republic) 2. Benefits on Cumulative basis Average HPOs: annual benefits > annual costs  year 5 Cumulative benefit by 2008: € 330 million Cumulative investment costs (incl. operating expenditure): €155 million Fig 5 - Cumulative Costs And Benefits Of E-Health 60 Sites From 1994 To 2008, In € Mill 2500 1500 500 Present value of cumulative costs Present value of cumulative benefits | 29 Source: European Commission « Economic Impact of eHealth Report » 2008
  • 30. Future of the US e-Health Each country is different There is no one best practice! Same strong signals as in Europe a) National leadership groups, CCHIT b) Set of Standards, HL7, SNOMED c) Incentives d) Top-down communication | 30
  • 31. Thank You for Your Attention « Yes, you can!!! » | 31
  • 32. Paul Roemer | Managing Principal, Healthcare IT Strategy INCREASING YOUR CHANCES FOR SUCCESS: WHAT ARE THE CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS FOR EHR/EMR | 32
  • 33. EMR—What Should I Know? What is the elephant in the room? What does this mean—EMRs must be interoperable & interconnected? Know before you buy—what connects to what? If EMRs aren’t connected, doctors will still need electronic and paper files | 33
  • 34. EMR—Where Does that leave you? Focus on yourself, on what you control Don’t let Washington drive your decision ARRA Certification Meaningful Use Decide why EMR is right for you Figure out what your team should include Define your requirements Set a budget | 34
  • 35. EMR—Fail Safe Points What are the EMR Fail Safe Points (FSPs)? EMR is healthcare’s Y2K time bomb. There a is concurrent national rollout of EMR; standards not available until 2010. The costs are very high, so are the penalties 1/3rd to 2/3rd of EMRs implemented have failed There may not be time to earn the incentives | 35
  • 36. EMR—Ambulatory Practices A good argument can be made for waiting. Within 12-18 months they will likely have the opportunity to acquire a plug-and-play EMR in-house or SaaS, including: Project management Selection Implementation Adapting workflows Training Support | 36
  • 37. EMR is Wide Open New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) received responses from 63.1% of hospitals surveyed: Only 1.5% of U.S. hospitals have a comprehensive electronic- records system present in all clinical units. 7.6% have a basic system present in at least one clinical unit. Computerized provider-order entry for medications has been implemented in only 17% of hospitals. Respondents cited capital and maintenance costs as the primary barriers to implementation | 37
  • 38. EMR if it doesn’t connect… Just because EMR’s have been implemented, doesn’t mean they’re of much value. “I've witnessed more serious errors with the EMR than in my previous 25 years as a physician.” Christine A. Sinsky, MD "...our system for delivering medical care is clearly in crisis...At the heart of the problem is the fragmented nature of the way health information is created and collected," Bill Gates Most EMRs don’t operate beyond the walls of the building in which they were implemented | 38
  • 39. EMR Are you ready? Enterprise Readiness Assessment Federal funding EMR Incentives, Implementation grants Playbook Readiness And penalties Methodology has a 6 phase scorecard. Implementation Risk Management Assessment Cost Benefit/Funding Analysis | 39
  • 40. Enterprise Readiness Assessment The Enterprise Readiness Assessment identifies gaps in: Change Management Readiness Technology Readiness Risk Management Standards Readiness | 40
  • 41. EMR Implementation Playbook The Implementation Playbook defines a program or set of projects the enterprise needs to execute in order to implement EMR. Potential projects may include: Requirements SW selection Change Management Integration Policy, Procedure or Process Training | 41
  • 42. Enterprise Risk Assessment The Enterprise Risk Assessment should help you identify potentially fatal EMR implementation risks: Staffing Program management Readiness | 42
  • 43. EMR Cost Benefit/Funding Analysis The Cost Benefit Analysis identifies: The cost of implementation and the level of funding necessary to successfully implement EMR Funding sources such as grants or federal government loans The short term costs and the long term benefits ROI development and monitoring | 43
  • 44. EMR Implementation Management Implementation Management oversees projects to successfully implement each EMR project managing: Project task management Budget, Schedule, & ROI Issues tracking and resolution Staffing and skill requirements Project accountability and visibility | 44
  • 45. In Summary | 45
  • 46. THOUGHT LEADERSHIP PANEL DISCUSSION | 46
  • 47. Overview Panel: What is an EMR? Dr. Naomi Grobstein Meaningful use Dr. Kennedy Ganti Implementation Dr. Ganti/Dr. Fossel Interoperability Paul Roemer Which vendor? Dr. Spencer Kroll Are EMR’s good? Jean-Michel Van Getting reimbursed Dr. Kennedy Ganti Who owns the data? Dr. David Memel Q&A | 47